Click on this link to Amainhobbies and anything you purchase there for the next 30 days will help the RC Review channel deliver more content. bit.ly/2PGrJav
I know this is an old video but just thought I'd mention that several times you're saying 'this one' but the video is showing b-roll of other things and we don't know which one 'this' one is :)
Excellent review. Covered all of the important details, gave careful consideration each time, conducted real-world tests when appropriate, very thorough and detailed, and thankfully no annoying music (which ruins so many videos). Well done sir! Well done indeed.
Absolutely superb video. I am just about to buy my first crawler kit, and this video has everything I wanted to know in one place. Traxxas it is then. Thanks for the effort in doing this. it's people like you that make youtube brilliant. Not the corporate crap. I hope they are good to you!
Same here I've been following the Scale RC game for a while and I'm ready to buy my first crawler without breaking the bank lol I narrowed it down to these 2 and this video broke it down really good, I'm goin with the TRX 4 sport
Redcat got me into rock crawling...back when the only real options were the $300 axial ax10, I bought the redcat RS10. It wasn't a scale truck, but had a simple frame, very trick 4 wheel steering and MOA axles. It could out-crawl any $300+ scale truck, especially after a few free mods. The RS10xt is still under $200 today and is a good option for anyone wanted to rock crawl on a budget.
@The Sacrosanct I spent months looking at everything rtr and trx4 was better in everything turning ratio no flex in chassis best rtr shocks in the business decent tires bullet proof gears and drivetrain parts available everywhere
Thanks for the comparison review for a returning beginner. I was considering both of these for a hardbody trail truck project that will probably make both pretty heavy. The Traxxas is the better climber but the Redcat is close. I consider the Scout body and mounting a bonus. Redcat for my project.
Awesome video. I was in the market for my first scaler recently and it was between these two. Ultimately the silver bits on the gen 8 started to bug me and that was the MAIN reason I leaned towards the TRX4. Silly reason but it is what is. Glad to see I picked the more capable rig out of the box.
ChraftShaft I managed to get the pack on sale b4 Christmas and overall I have around 260$ in my gen8 plus all the piece mail electronics. Haven’t put it together yet but I have a 35t motor I’m gonna throw in it. The stock 17t motor is too fast for my taste. Plus I got to choose my own body which is always nice.
Redcat has really stepped up their game these past few years, I used to be a Traxxas guy but now all I run is Redcat RC's , Repair costs on Redcat is so much lower
@Wubu Mini Farm The few rc friends i had owned redcats. They no longer rc because it was non stop breakage and upgrades were just not there. The gen 8 broke input gears non stop,Trans gears,ESC cooked in 6 inches of water and they probably sent him 20 replacement parts before the warranty ran out.I kind of wish they would have went with traxxas or axial then i wouldn't be rc'ing solo
@@Fiaudiodude I don't know what your friends were doing with their Gen 8s. Ive have mine since it came out , and in over a year with heavy use, Ive only had to replace 3 things. One of the 3 things were totally my fault btw. In addition , Ive done many opitional upgrades and love it! my Gen 8 has been good to me. Ive talked to a coupe other gen 8 owner and they both love it. maybe your friends were bashng the crap out of it. Who knows.
I have two Redcat Gen 8s a TRX4 Bronco a TRX6, and my most recent purchase for myself was the TRX4 Sport. My Traxxas trucks break far less parts, have a higher build quality, larger after market for parts, and outperform my Redcats. Started with a Gen 8 Axe edition and have had a lot of downtime with it. Some things like having to Dremel out cross-threaded drive shaft grub screws, poor steering geometry, and clattery drivetrain and vulnerable servo steering arm and servo made me look elsewhere. The less stuff they break the more time we get to spend on the trail together. And that's what I value most at the end of the day.
I have to tell ya I have a gen 8 scout 2 I run all factory and I have a way smaller turning radius then your video shows my throttle is a lot smoother then you described and I personally would put mine against a traxxas 4 sport any day. That is the reason. I did not get a traxxas I have friends who run them and personally drove them etc. Now mine is also brand new so I suppose there is a possibility that redcat changed a lot since the video was made but
Coming from someone who has owned a Gen 7 and a Gen 8 PACK and now a TRX4. The TRX4 is hands down the best. It's does everything very well not perfect at anything and not horrible at anything. It's a very neutral yet solid truck for the price.
😃👍Nice comparison. I have both and been running the gen 8 in the same spots as I do my TRX4 and I found the only thing better on the gen 8 is the body looks better and the servo is a bit more powerful and that's it everything else about the trx4 is better. no faults about the trx4 it's made right and goes anyplace better than the gen 8, the gen 8 is a cool rig though but not in the same category as the trx4. A trx4 is a Swiss watch and the gen 8 is just a normal watch.
I thing the Gen 8 is more aimed at entry level beginners. It also is aimed some what more to the "scale" detail oriented guys at a bargin price. With the divorced transfer case and front mount motor you can easily get a full scale interior in to the truck without amputating your driver figures. Also the scale exterior details really are top notch. On the steering angle issue it is improved with a better servo. My buddies TRX4 Denfender and my new Gen 8 both using the same 20kg all metal servo (both upgraded $18 USD on Amazon) with aluminum horn have nearly identical turning radius. Both trucks benefited from the better servo, but I have not measured the actual Gen 8 steering angle degree but my guess is still not a full 47*. The memory foam is great in spring/summer/fall Phoenix AZ (Home office of Redcat) but I always switch to 2 stage foams. To protect my front steering horn on the Gen 8 I added an aftermarket TRX4 front skid (looks good too!). The Gen 8 receiver is water proof so the box does not need to be. Bottom line for competition or all performance the TRX4 is the way to go. For details, looks, bargin, and performance better than anything you could get 3 or more years ago (RTR) the Gen 8 is what the doctor ordered. In these types of reviews I don't think people remember just how far scale crawlers have come in the time from when the first Axial SCX10 came out. The Gen 7 is close relative to the SCX10 (design wise) and is blast to drive, and these 2 newer trucks are miles ahead design wise over the Gen 7. It really is a great time to be in RC crawling and I think it will still get a lot better in the next 5 years.
I am both trucks and one thing I do disagree with is the tires. The stock Gen 8 tires Are much better in my opinion. They work better in dirt they work better on rocks most importantly they look better and they are bead locks. While Traxxas has a glue on wheel which is not very impressive. And the memory foam works well just got a break it in.
@@RCReviewChannel Great suggestion, I always love vintage looking truck! This is why I suddenly interested in Gen8, but the center underneath bump... (facepalm)... TRX-4 Sport with changed body way to go!
Great video, very interesting, though I think a more fair comparison would be against other budget brand entry level crawlers. The trx4 sport is only down to near-budget price because of its throwaway body, stripped features and zero extras. The gen 8 is basically a 200 dollar rtr with a 100 dollar body. The tr4 is a 300+ dollar rtr with a cheap body.
nice review. I still feel that redcat just isn't on that level yet. Traxxas or Axial for me but no redcat. but that's just my opinion and what i feel comfortable with when spending my cash
I agree to a point. Traxxas bashers all day. Axial crawlers all day. Traxxas crawlers not as solid as axial to me and scale. Redcat is in the right direction if they keep the price down . if redcat brings a 400$ crawler after this gen 8 I'm gonna lose my mind .
@@stinky3shoes491 lol.. I mentioned the $400 in another channel. Think that will be right there stepping on Vanquish's toes. btw, for my group.. maybe driving style or the areas we go, the Axial's need upgrades to keep up with the TRX's in the durability department. Sometimes that flexy Axial plastic don't cut it when in a bind and just flex flex flex without progression. Don't get me wrong, after spending $2k on my Wraith.. none of my group can keep up with it. But you can't win if you can't cross the finish line, which the Wraith has failed to do twice out of about 12 runs.
@@stinky3shoes491 lol.. didn't run the bill till I was done. Never would have thought you could spend that much into a rig.. check the video description for the parts. ua-cam.com/video/l7L5_K0Ivwk/v-deo.html
Like your comparison, spot on. I trust your judgement because you crawl with the guys and gals in the Bay Area😉. Both have their strong points but I like the challengers style. Don't sleep on the Underdog👊
I know its not scale but i have owned my redcat everest 10. And have not replaced or broken a thing. I crawl it everyday too. I do know alot of people replace parts with the scx10 for a more scale crawler. Great review!
Am I the only one who likes the trx4 sport body? Don’t know why it’s hated on so much.. reminds me of a compact truck, maybe Nissan+Toyota mix with a dash of Jeep commanche truck. I’m a little done with all the suv bodies, nice to have a truck
and it looks better with the expedition rack on it. A new body is coming too, same truck but with a topper. Only thing that kept me from running straight to the Sport is I have to have inner fenders, I know they have plans for them, just taking too long to get them out. I did get a Sport, having inner fenders from Traxxas won't fit well with the body I chose for it, so will just have to be using crafting foam.
I fixed the steering radius issue and the jerky throttle modulation of the Gen 8!!! I have a video to be released later. Anybody know what it is? The great news is the Gen 8 is capable of very tight radius turns. Also, it can throttle modulate very well with that motor and esc stock.
Hope it wasn't the trims, don't know how many times that has bitten us in my group. But I could guess maybe a longer servo horn to get more throw and for the throttle, maybe pinion spur mesh.
@@TerraQuestRC Nope, but related. Out of the box, the steering exponential adjust was absolutely maxed out and that was a clue. Putting a longer servo horn would have put that steering arm even farther away with a steeper angle.
Thanks for this comparison video. i would also like to thank you for not being bias during the testing. I could not tell if you liked one over the other. Great job. TRX-4 is very hard to beat. 👍🏻👍🏻
That is our point. There too many reviewers around that just love one brand or love everything. Or say everything is personal preference. Objective knowledge and testing first, then preference kicks in at the end to decide. :)
The Scout II in my opinion is way far better.... The reason why I say that is because it is 😂 so cool looking..... So legit .....looks like the real thing...
I love your videos. Very thought out and technical. Exactly the kind of RC channel I have been looking for. Amazing work, keep it up. I just subscribed.
Why don't you compare the AXE Edition to the trx4 range? Or maybe upgrade the gen8 basic to be similar price to the trx4 and then compare? Don't spend 200 less on something and expect it to perform the same on the same level.
Thought for the day? I do wonder how many people knocking the redcat have driven both? Or even seen the redcat gen 8 in the flesh? I'll give it a fair test before modifying it, my trial run around the yard in the wet? Tires seemed to slip a lot more than I'd like, but that's an easy change. One thing to note about climbing performance, the redcat has a 17T motor and the Traxxas a 21T motor so the Traxxas will have more torque. I've a spare axial 35T motor on the side? Should I put that in guys? With better tires and motor I can see the redcats weight distribution coming in to play.
I am still waiting for my Redcat Gen8 to be delivered. But I have 2 Traxxas TRX-4s and upgraded those to a Holmes Hobbies Trailmaster Sport 27T motor. That sure helped with the performance. I think if you change the motor of the Redcat Gen8 for a 550 motor, something like 21T or 27T that will be a very good upgrade. And get it engine and specs wise to the same level as the TRX-4.
Seems a fair comparison supported with real world runs. On the one hand the Redcat Gen8 does look so much more especially for the money but the Traxxas has had a substantial headstart that Redcat will have to put the time in to prove it's worth. All in all a win for us the consumers!
The Gen8 is not a bad crawler. The problem with it is that is not a Traxxas, axial, vanquish . Because of that you find them dirt cheap used. If the Gen 8 was a top brand they would be more expensive.
The Redcat is completely waterproof including the receiver. The electronics are the same as the Gen 7 and we float em down the creek all the time. The box is probably a dust/mud kind of thing, but I'd pull it or put a drain hole or two in the bottom. Nice job on the review! ;)
Good to know. This receiver will probably upgraded though since this radio is holding back steering and making throttle response hard to modulate Would have been good to get a sealed box
Huh, It's the Flysky GT2B with EPAs and trim adjustments. While not great as far as radios go, one of the better RTR setups out there and more than adequate for a 2 channel crawler and much better than the TQi in the experience of most.
SOO HAPPY I WENT WITH THE (TRAXXAS TRX4 SPORT!) INSTED OF GETTING ****ANOUTHER* AXIAL SCX10,,,,,, BUT IM SOOO HAPPY WITH THE TRX4,,,,(CRAWLS LIKE IT ALREADY HAS UPGRADES,,,THE PARTS ARE VERY DECENT QUALITY,,,,,I LOVE IT!!!!! JUST NEED THE LIFTKIT;) AND ILL BE GOOD;)
Went with the Gen 8 because of the body. Modded to the gills now.... very happy with it! Next truck will be a TRX4 Bronco or Blazer to bash a bit with the 2 speeds.
I know my previous comments about the Redcat Scout II may make it seem like I believe its the better between the TRX-4 (pick your version) and that I don't like the TRX-4. But I will point out that I have 5 TRX-4's, and don't consider myself a Traxxas fanboy. Just give me a rig that can perform nearly or better for less money, without having to do a bunch of upgrades and aesthetic add ons, then count me in. I don't have a single rig out of my 21, and the Scout will make 22, that I haven't had to modify to make it stronger (durability), faster or better performing. Thus far, it is the Axial Wraith, Yeti, and SCX10 II that have cost me the most to get to the performance and looks that I am happy with. I am sure my wallet is going to open for the Redcat Scout II as well. I found your current comparison to be fair and of no surprise. There is a small flaw to your turning test, very small, but the Scout II does have a slightly longer wheelbase, so even if the steering angles were identical with the same tires and foams, the Scout will still have the larger turning radius. As for recommending one over the other it is still going to come down to what it will be used for (terrain and speed), what is the degree of modification your willing to do with current and future parts. So far I can't say that you can go wrong with a Scout II for beginning in the hobby or just letting your own creativity rule in making it a top performer and looking good in the process.
Very good insight as I thought the same thing. So the TRX4 Sport is 12.3" and the Gen 8 is 12.5" wheelbase. Wheelbase matters a little bit with these differences but not that much. Maybe an inch or two in diameter? I have a TRX4 Defender which is 12.8", fully locked diffs. The steering radius is quite a bit smaller than the Gen 8 as well.
Terra Quest RC bro I do go out very regularly for crawling and all of us are always so engrossed in crawling that. I one bothers to make the video. The only video I have up on my so called channel is just a random day when one of the guy broke his car before we even started so he decided to film us and then I edited 😂 thanks a lot for your support. I’m really looking forward to making videos and getting stuff on UA-cam. Thank you for your support 🙏🏻👍🏻
Just after a month of use, my trx4 broke the front diff locking servo, then the rear one, a few days later the damn esc was fried so i sell the car and purchased the sport version. Guess what? two weeks and the esc died... Purchasde a gen 8 several months ago: Not a single failure since then and i'm not gentle with it. Bad luck? Maybe but i will not have any other traxxas crawler,never again. Thanks for those vids, sir, i love them.
I noticed the TRX4 has better low gearing for rock crawling and locking diff for extra assistance. It's also way quieter. Sharper steering as well. The body choices are all my choices. Land Rover Defender, Classic Ford Bronco. That generic looking pickup is nothing I would even look at.
I felt the review was very honest given that Traxxas TRX4 Sport has been around much longer along wit the loads of aftermarket upgrades, it’s a much more reliable rig but with that Said I love the Gen 8 platform, it can be a really cool project for the avid hobbyist to find solutions to the downsides you’ve pointed out. It could be a trail truck as is or it can serve as a rock machine with some minor improvements one suggestion is to maybe equip it with a stinger style bumper, add a front skid plate to kinda help with climbing steep inclines and probably put some 2.2’s on it to give it a little more ground clearance but I’m not sure if it can accept bigger tires due to the fixed wheel wells or maybe trying some longer shocks to help raise the chassis but all and all it can work out if you just give it a little TLC. If outfitted properly it can be a cool trail truck or maybe a camper with roof rack LED light bar and whatever the avid hobbyist chooses to do with it. I’d love to see one dressed up and out on the trail. Thanks for the vid and in-depth analyst for both trucks as always good job man.
Right on, you get exactly what we are saying. These are two of the best vehicles now. Great for project cars too. Did you see our fabulous Topless Gen 8? ua-cam.com/video/Bt4THQEnpfI/v-deo.html
I definitely consider the TRX4 as a trail rig. The Gen 7 was straight away a rock crawler. The battery location directly over the front axle keeping weight low and up front made climbing steep walls and rocks amazing! No belly bump either!
I built a all metal Gen8 10.5 lbs 2.2/ 57 Dual mud slinger tires in rear single wheels in front can turn in 2.5ft radius nune of the noise of my stock gen8, I will take any traxxs😋bring it !!! Moses
really nice truck😍, I hope you send me one of them even the used one no problem✌😀, you are generous and I deserve😉 I really like your channel and the way you review things, and of course your personality🙂, very well review & info that you give us solves a lot of questions that came or not yet in mind, useful things that helps with the rc hobby👍
Redcat gets the best bang for your buck nod because of a better body?? Trx beats it in every category but the body. Seems like upgrading a body would be more cost effective than fixing all the issues with the redcat. jmo
Your review is clearly biased and you are obviously paid by or at least favor the Traxxas brand. You have 16 links for Traxxas items and 2 for Redcat. As far as you stating the Traxxas lunges forward when you first pull the throttle is not accurate. If you use a little finesse and throttle management it takes off as slowly as any other crawler I have. Also the reason the Traxxas has a tighter turning radius is because it has a much shorter wheelbase. Lastly I was able to get mine to have the full 47 degree turning angle by maxing out the steering rate on the transmitter. The TRX4 body looks like a toy you would by at Walmart and the truck is $50 more.
Hey sorry you feel that way. That's our honest analysis and we've spent many many hours on our three Gen 8's. We've produced 26 videos on the Gen 8 and have lots of links on them. It is great at many things but now all. ua-cam.com/video/QlwVbqFE4Mk/v-deo.html
Maybe Redcat didn't waterproof the receiver box, because Traxxas would sue them if they did. Yes, somehow Traxxas patented a waterproof receiver box... Anyway, great video!
so what if Traxxas did patent "their receiver box".. its amazing how many never checked out the full details of what the lawsuit was about. I say go ahead and patent your design, it doesn't hurt the community. It forces other companies to come up with better designs in the end.
@@TerraQuestRC I actually don't have much of a problem with Traxxas. (I own 2 TRX-4s) The patent office on the other hand... (mostly a software rant in this case...)
My kids old hpi wheely king has a waterproof hpi receiver box. It's actually better design than many traxxas boxes. You can see if the gasket is correctly placed. I sometimes find sand grains in my traxxas boxes. Not in the hpi one. Cable intake is on the underside on the hpi box. I use traxxas reciver box on rustler, slash and scx10.
Watched all your videos and bought a Gen 8. You are clearly a traxxas fan. Traxxas cheap body, flimsy bumpers after a few free mods of the Gen 8 it's still cheaper with better construction. I live in Wisconsin the foam in the tires gets better after use on the Gen 8 and a skid plate helps the front. The Gen 8 doesn't have a waterproof compartment but the electronics are well coated. I like the Traxxas but the wheel wells does tremendously to keep an inside compartment clean on the gen 8. I enjoy all your videos immensely but when you have it out for a vehicle I think you tend to be hypercritical of it. Just my opinion. Looking forward to more videos.
Appreciate the comment. We produced 24 video on the Redcat Gen8 and most are very complementary. ua-cam.com/video/YG3m3LbDupg/v-deo.html Nice kit. We just want to see a lot more updates, upgrades and development from Redcat on this platform.
I'll tell ya boys..the sport kit, with modified canyon trails...it's doing things you wouldn't believe, with minimal upgrades. Check out my latest video, or any of my TRXellence series to see how this thing can perform! ua-cam.com/video/SDJtIzW3rpo/v-deo.html latest, vol 6, includes some crashes that I thought would break any 9-10lb truck..but wrong again. This thing is a beast.
Not even close, TRX4 hands down. I personally don't care about body pins and bling. TRX4 is well worth the extra $40. I actually prefer the look of the TRX4 and it is far more capable, no brainer here.
taking into consideration the redcat comes out the box with a battery and charger and the Traxxas does not, do you think the choice would be best for my 1st crawler? Also, witch one goes faster on flat terrain?
The Redcat Gen 7 comes with battery and charger and is no a good purchase. The TRX4 is a little faster on flat terrain and is the best purchase. Make sure you get an 11.1 volt lipo battery for the best speed.
I watched this video a couple of times, along with many others, prior to making my choice and eventually went with the Redcat Gen 8. The primary reason being the scale looks of the Scout II. The issues with the Redcat are fairly negligible compared to the toyish/plastic look of the TRX4 Sport - plus the body posts - yuck! I would have to have invested another $100 to get to the level of aesthetics of the Gen 8, I wanted something that is fun to watch crawl around because it looks scale. I also like the metal parts of the Redcat, they look nice, are functional enough for my needs, and thus far have proven to be reliable. Thank you for the outstanding videos man - fun stuff.
Great decision man. I think that is exactly why we would recommend the Gen8. It just looks better and folks who value that will have a greater experience. Both are two of the market leaders right now.
@@RCReviewChannel Thanks man, I really enjoyed your videos on upgrades and setting up the Gen 8 with an interior/scale features - those were the videos that put me over the fence and into a Redcat. I appreciate your work.
No dude. I was listening to u until you said tie on servo. Traxxas servo is shit, the whole world knows it. Im currently running a redcat servo from a rs10 rockslide in the traxxas because in the 2nd run the traxxas servo died
Hi,, is it possible to just add some of those weights sold at tire shops to the chassis. Isn't this will lower the whole chassis which is not good for crawling? it would be cool if you make a video about easy ways of adding weights to the chassis or wheels without removing the tires.
Absolutely. Those are the best bang for the buck. Put them on as low and as forward as possible. We like putting those inside the tires a wheel, taped to the inside of the wheel.
I also like the gen 8 better, it dwarfs the trx-4, and the turning radius is better on the trx-4 because the gen 8 has a longer wheel base, much better platform, trx-4 looks like a fisher price toy compared to the gen 8. Other pros have also said the gen 8 is better🙂👍
Let's not get carried away here. The gen 8 seems like a good design and great value, but the trx4 is clearly the stronger platform. Extremely beefy design and the drivetrain is super strong, no upgrades needed. Even the trx4 sport stock body looks surprisingly good in person. Let's not forget that the trx4 platform wasn't designed by some nobody, but a fellow veteran crawler friend of *the* John Holmes. Traxxas knew what they were doing when they needed to hire someone to design the platform. All that said, I'm tempted to try out a gen 8 too, though I can tell it's gonna need some upgrades down the line.
I wrote my previous comment before watching the video, after watching the trx4 clearly wipes the floor with the gen 8. But from the beginning I've felt it is an unfair comparison, the gen 8 isn't a trx4-killer, but rather a better alternative to most of the budget brand entry level crawlers on the market. It'd be more interesting to see a side to side comparison with those.
Darn! I was sooo rooting for the Scout for the win. I LOVE the looks but yeah looks don't get ya home. BUT, there's always upgrades and McGivering to be done! lol I love McGivering!! Love your channel btw. great info and a joy to watch.
Thanks for helping me confirn my deccision! Trx4 it is . I have the redcat everest 10 its very capable . Im just looking for a more scale car . Traxxas seems to be better out of the box
Thanks for breaking it down for us man. It's so freaking annoying that they have Zero foresight and put that HUGE hump in the skid... and a guys gotta spend 30-40 more bucks on the Bowhouse skid just to be on par with Any other Manufacturer.... Shame on Redcat for fibbing on the Specs too - Steering Degrees dont count if it it cant move maxed out... All the extras don't make up for inadequacy. Gotta Love that Body though!
Check out Brazin Scale's new ALL TIME LOW chassis for the TRX-4. I pre-ordered mine this morning and bought the skid and cross members.Yea its an expensive upgrade at $200 for all the parts but its the only LCG chassis for the already great crawling TRX-4 so imo it'll be untouchable. Checkout their website and their FB page for pics and info.
Click on this link to Amainhobbies and anything you purchase there for the next 30 days will help the RC Review channel deliver more content. bit.ly/2PGrJav
Why would you compare the Traxxas sport to a gen 8 should have got compared Bronco or Blazer trx4
I know this is an old video but just thought I'd mention that several times you're saying 'this one' but the video is showing b-roll of other things and we don't know which one 'this' one is :)
@@tobydyes Because of price... clearly... and he discusses this exact thing at the start of the video 🤣
Excellent review. Covered all of the important details, gave careful consideration each time, conducted real-world tests when appropriate, very thorough and detailed, and thankfully no annoying music (which ruins so many videos). Well done sir! Well done indeed.
Really really appreciate that comment. We will try harder each time.
Almost 10,000 views in the first two days. This is a record for us. Share it, like it, subscribe. Thanks for all the support all!!!
"The winner is..." (points to the winner) "well, let me tell you about the factors."
Absolutely superb video. I am just about to buy my first crawler kit, and this video has everything I wanted to know in one place. Traxxas it is then. Thanks for the effort in doing this. it's people like you that make youtube brilliant. Not the corporate crap. I hope they are good to you!
Same here I've been following the Scale RC game for a while and I'm ready to buy my first crawler without breaking the bank lol I narrowed it down to these 2 and this video broke it down really good, I'm goin with the TRX 4 sport
Redcat is cheaper but Traxxas has more parts/mods
Gen8 have the scale look,Traxxas Sport the climbing performance.
Redcat got me into rock crawling...back when the only real options were the $300 axial ax10, I bought the redcat RS10. It wasn't a scale truck, but had a simple frame, very trick 4 wheel steering and MOA axles. It could out-crawl any $300+ scale truck, especially after a few free mods. The RS10xt is still under $200 today and is a good option for anyone wanted to rock crawl on a budget.
Just bought a trx4 sport so many choices 100 to 600 dollars to get started. Was losing my mind trying to decide what to buy ..glad I got what I did
@The Sacrosanct I spent months looking at everything rtr and trx4 was better in everything turning ratio no flex in chassis best rtr shocks in the business decent tires bullet proof gears and drivetrain parts available everywhere
Thanks for making these videos, I find them informative. I especially like your presentation style.
Thank you. This one was tough. We wanted it shorter but maybe on the next one where all variables are equalize. Tires, body, et.
I thought the length was fine! Really enjoyed watching it!
Thanks for the comparison review for a returning beginner. I was considering both of these for a hardbody trail truck project that will probably make both pretty heavy. The Traxxas is the better climber but the Redcat is close. I consider the Scout body and mounting a bonus. Redcat for my project.
I can’t help but love this guy. Keep following ur dream
Do what you love and love what you do. And always share the fun and the addiction.
I've always loved his reviews.. Not everything glitter is gold, he shows us real gold from fool's gold!
Yeah, we like to bring out the good and the bad. What's best and what's best for certain styles
So fit the gen 8 shell to a TRX 4 sport, job done.
Really in-depth review. The steering! Man I’m going to share this on our group page
We don't want to steer you wrong
Hi, what group page do you have?
Awesome video. I was in the market for my first scaler recently and it was between these two. Ultimately the silver bits on the gen 8 started to bug me and that was the MAIN reason I leaned towards the TRX4. Silly reason but it is what is. Glad to see I picked the more capable rig out of the box.
I just bought the Redcat Gen 8 for $259 free shipping on Amazon. Great bang for my buck! I like being the underdog, especially when I save $$$. Haha.
@panzer Ken and if you spend some on upgrades you may have the winner.
ChraftShaft I managed to get the pack on sale b4 Christmas and overall I have around 260$ in my gen8 plus all the piece mail electronics. Haven’t put it together yet but I have a 35t motor I’m gonna throw in it. The stock 17t motor is too fast for my taste. Plus I got to choose my own body which is always nice.
My dad got his for 199 sucks to be you sorry dude
@@GrimReaper-sl9zo give us a link as to where or I'm calling bullshit
@@GrimReaper-sl9zo lol youre full of BS 😂
Redcat has really stepped up their game these past few years, I used to be a Traxxas guy but now all I run is Redcat RC's , Repair costs on Redcat is so much lower
I run Traxxas and Redcat, but I like how Redcats are newer and not everyone has one.....yet lol.
@Wubu Mini Farm The few rc friends i had owned redcats. They no longer rc because it was non stop breakage and upgrades were just not there. The gen 8 broke input gears non stop,Trans gears,ESC cooked in 6 inches of water and they probably sent him 20 replacement parts before the warranty ran out.I kind of wish they would have went with traxxas or axial then i wouldn't be rc'ing solo
Yeah but redcat sucks ass it break faster and are pure garbage
@@Fiaudiodude I don't know what your friends were doing with their Gen 8s. Ive have mine since it came out , and in over a year with heavy use, Ive only had to replace 3 things. One of the 3 things were totally my fault btw. In addition , Ive done many opitional upgrades and love it! my Gen 8 has been good to me. Ive talked to a coupe other gen 8 owner and they both love it. maybe your friends were bashng the crap out of it. Who knows.
I have two Redcat Gen 8s a TRX4 Bronco a TRX6, and my most recent purchase for myself was the TRX4 Sport.
My Traxxas trucks break far less parts, have a higher build quality, larger after market for parts, and outperform my Redcats.
Started with a Gen 8 Axe edition and have had a lot of downtime with it.
Some things like having to Dremel out cross-threaded drive shaft grub screws, poor steering geometry, and clattery drivetrain and vulnerable servo steering arm and servo made me look elsewhere.
The less stuff they break the more time we get to spend on the trail together. And that's what I value most at the end of the day.
I have a red cat gen 8 it is really good
Same
I have to tell ya I have a gen 8 scout 2 I run all factory and I have a way smaller turning radius then your video shows my throttle is a lot smoother then you described and I personally would put mine against a traxxas 4 sport any day. That is the reason. I did not get a traxxas I have friends who run them and personally drove them etc. Now mine is also brand new so I suppose there is a possibility that redcat changed a lot since the video was made but
Really like the way this review was put together, top notch. Thank you!
Coming from someone who has owned a Gen 7 and a Gen 8 PACK and now a TRX4. The TRX4 is hands down the best. It's does everything very well not perfect at anything and not horrible at anything. It's a very neutral yet solid truck for the price.
😃👍Nice comparison. I have both and been running the gen 8 in the same spots as I do my TRX4 and I found the only thing better on the gen 8 is the body looks better and the servo is a bit more powerful and that's it everything else about the trx4 is better. no faults about the trx4 it's made right and goes anyplace better than the gen 8, the gen 8 is a cool rig though but not in the same category as the trx4. A trx4 is a Swiss watch and the gen 8 is just a normal watch.
absoluely agreed.
Hey Shen, both watches do the same thing....they keep time.
I thing the Gen 8 is more aimed at entry level beginners. It also is aimed some what more to the "scale" detail oriented guys at a bargin price. With the divorced transfer case and front mount motor you can easily get a full scale interior in to the truck without amputating your driver figures. Also the scale exterior details really are top notch. On the steering angle issue it is improved with a better servo. My buddies TRX4 Denfender and my new Gen 8 both using the same 20kg all metal servo (both upgraded $18 USD on Amazon) with aluminum horn have nearly identical turning radius. Both trucks benefited from the better servo, but I have not measured the actual Gen 8 steering angle degree but my guess is still not a full 47*. The memory foam is great in spring/summer/fall Phoenix AZ (Home office of Redcat) but I always switch to 2 stage foams. To protect my front steering horn on the Gen 8 I added an aftermarket TRX4 front skid (looks good too!). The Gen 8 receiver is water proof so the box does not need to be. Bottom line for competition or all performance the TRX4 is the way to go. For details, looks, bargin, and performance better than anything you could get 3 or more years ago (RTR) the Gen 8 is what the doctor ordered. In these types of reviews I don't think people remember just how far scale crawlers have come in the time from when the first Axial SCX10 came out. The Gen 7 is close relative to the SCX10 (design wise) and is blast to drive, and these 2 newer trucks are miles ahead design wise over the Gen 7. It really is a great time to be in RC crawling and I think it will still get a lot better in the next 5 years.
What should I get trx4 Bronco or the sport
I think the Gen8 is better for the price ,, pluss I can 3D print parts free from Redcat
I am both trucks and one thing I do disagree with is the tires. The stock Gen 8 tires Are much better in my opinion. They work better in dirt they work better on rocks most importantly they look better and they are bead locks. While Traxxas has a glue on wheel which is not very impressive. And the memory foam works well just got a break it in.
Ok, after watched this comparison, I think I'll stick with my original plan, TRX-4 Sport
Just change that body and you're golden! Proline Power Wagon!
Get both is the correct answer.
@@RCReviewChannel Great suggestion, I always love vintage looking truck! This is why I suddenly interested in Gen8, but the center underneath bump... (facepalm)... TRX-4 Sport with changed body way to go!
Great video, very interesting, though I think a more fair comparison would be against other budget brand entry level crawlers. The trx4 sport is only down to near-budget price because of its throwaway body, stripped features and zero extras. The gen 8 is basically a 200 dollar rtr with a 100 dollar body. The tr4 is a 300+ dollar rtr with a cheap body.
How I see it - the TRX4 sport is the benchmark and that's obviously who redcat is going after.
nice review. I still feel that redcat just isn't on that level yet. Traxxas or Axial for me but no redcat. but that's just my opinion and what i feel comfortable with when spending my cash
I agree to a point. Traxxas bashers all day. Axial crawlers all day. Traxxas crawlers not as solid as axial to me and scale. Redcat is in the right direction if they keep the price down . if redcat brings a 400$ crawler after this gen 8 I'm gonna lose my mind .
@@stinky3shoes491 lol.. I mentioned the $400 in another channel. Think that will be right there stepping on Vanquish's toes.
btw, for my group.. maybe driving style or the areas we go, the Axial's need upgrades to keep up with the TRX's in the durability department. Sometimes that flexy Axial plastic don't cut it when in a bind and just flex flex flex without progression. Don't get me wrong, after spending $2k on my Wraith.. none of my group can keep up with it. But you can't win if you can't cross the finish line, which the Wraith has failed to do twice out of about 12 runs.
@@TerraQuestRC I have a G6 that I've spent about 600$ on upgrades . its a boss . 2k$ in insane lol geeezzzz
@@stinky3shoes491 lol.. didn't run the bill till I was done. Never would have thought you could spend that much into a rig.. check the video description for the parts. ua-cam.com/video/l7L5_K0Ivwk/v-deo.html
@@TerraQuestRC freaking sick build bro!! Now I see where the $$$ went. Very cool. I'm a bit jealous lol
Thanks for the video! I changed my mind from getting a Gen8 and just purchased a lightly used TRX-4 Sport.
You will not be disappointed.
Like your comparison, spot on. I trust your judgement because you crawl with the guys and gals in the Bay Area😉. Both have their strong points but I like the challengers style. Don't sleep on the Underdog👊
I know its not scale but i have owned my redcat everest 10. And have not replaced or broken a thing. I crawl it everyday too. I do know alot of people replace parts with the scx10 for a more scale crawler. Great review!
Am I the only one who likes the trx4 sport body? Don’t know why it’s hated on so much.. reminds me of a compact truck, maybe Nissan+Toyota mix with a dash of Jeep commanche truck. I’m a little done with all the suv bodies, nice to have a truck
and it looks better with the expedition rack on it. A new body is coming too, same truck but with a topper. Only thing that kept me from running straight to the Sport is I have to have inner fenders, I know they have plans for them, just taking too long to get them out. I did get a Sport, having inner fenders from Traxxas won't fit well with the body I chose for it, so will just have to be using crafting foam.
I fixed the steering radius issue and the jerky throttle modulation of the Gen 8!!! I have a video to be released later. Anybody know what it is? The great news is the Gen 8 is capable of very tight radius turns. Also, it can throttle modulate very well with that motor and esc stock.
Hope it wasn't the trims, don't know how many times that has bitten us in my group. But I could guess maybe a longer servo horn to get more throw and for the throttle, maybe pinion spur mesh.
@@TerraQuestRC Nope, but related. Out of the box, the steering exponential adjust was absolutely maxed out and that was a clue. Putting a longer servo horn would have put that steering arm even farther away with a steeper angle.
@@RCReviewChannel good that it wasn't a servo horn swap, figured that would not have been preferential.
Thanks for this comparison video. i would also like to thank you for not being bias during the testing. I could not tell if you liked one over the other. Great job. TRX-4 is very hard to beat. 👍🏻👍🏻
That is our point. There too many reviewers around that just love one brand or love everything. Or say everything is personal preference. Objective knowledge and testing first, then preference kicks in at the end to decide. :)
The Scout II in my opinion is way far better.... The reason why I say that is because it is 😂 so cool looking..... So legit .....looks like the real thing...
I love your videos. Very thought out and technical. Exactly the kind of RC channel I have been looking for. Amazing work, keep it up. I just subscribed.
Much appreciated!! So many toys, so little time.
Don’t forget, your review was a winner! Thanks! 👍
Fantastic video, really honest review.
YOU ARE SO GREAT!!!!!!!!! YOU HAVE SAVED ME SO MUCH TIME AND MONEY. PLEASE,KEEP IT UP!!!!!!!!!
THANKS, STEVE
No, you're awesome. Cause you love RC. That's what it's all about. Research, buy, crawl... repeat.
Why don't you compare the AXE Edition to the trx4 range?
Or maybe upgrade the gen8 basic to be similar price to the trx4 and then compare?
Don't spend 200 less on something and expect it to perform the same on the same level.
200 less? They're 40 bux apart.
Thought for the day? I do wonder how many people knocking the redcat have driven both? Or even seen the redcat gen 8 in the flesh? I'll give it a fair test before modifying it, my trial run around the yard in the wet? Tires seemed to slip a lot more than I'd like, but that's an easy change. One thing to note about climbing performance, the redcat has a 17T motor and the Traxxas a 21T motor so the Traxxas will have more torque. I've a spare axial 35T motor on the side? Should I put that in guys? With better tires and motor I can see the redcats weight distribution coming in to play.
@@williamperri3437 you still haven't contacted me over the 12k subs prize you won!!!!
I am still waiting for my Redcat Gen8 to be delivered. But I have 2 Traxxas TRX-4s and upgraded those to a Holmes Hobbies Trailmaster Sport 27T motor. That sure helped with the performance. I think if you change the motor of the Redcat Gen8 for a 550 motor, something like 21T or 27T that will be a very good upgrade. And get it engine and specs wise to the same level as the TRX-4.
Seems a fair comparison supported with real world runs. On the one hand the Redcat Gen8 does look so much more especially for the money but the Traxxas has had a substantial headstart that Redcat will have to put the time in to prove it's worth. All in all a win for us the consumers!
Exactly our takeaway. We now have a contender that is a noticeably better value. Good for us consumers and will change the category for the better.
Have you reviewed any 1/18th scale crawlers?
Would love to see some of those comparisons as they're not as popular.
I have both of these and they are both awesome at crawling.
The Gen8 is not a bad crawler. The problem with it is that is not a Traxxas, axial, vanquish . Because of that you find them dirt cheap used. If the Gen 8 was a top brand they would be more expensive.
The Redcat is completely waterproof including the receiver. The electronics are the same as the Gen 7 and we float em down the creek all the time. The box is probably a dust/mud kind of thing, but I'd pull it or put a drain hole or two in the bottom. Nice job on the review! ;)
Good to know. This receiver will probably upgraded though since this radio is holding back steering and making throttle response hard to modulate
Good to know. This receiver will probably upgraded though since this radio is holding back steering and making throttle response hard to modulate
Would have been good to get a sealed box
Huh, It's the Flysky GT2B with EPAs and trim adjustments. While not great as far as radios go, one of the better RTR setups out there and more than adequate for a 2 channel crawler and much better than the TQi in the experience of most.
SOO HAPPY I WENT WITH THE (TRAXXAS TRX4 SPORT!) INSTED OF GETTING ****ANOUTHER* AXIAL SCX10,,,,,, BUT IM SOOO HAPPY WITH THE TRX4,,,,(CRAWLS LIKE IT ALREADY HAS UPGRADES,,,THE PARTS ARE VERY DECENT QUALITY,,,,,I LOVE IT!!!!! JUST NEED THE LIFTKIT;) AND ILL BE GOOD;)
Im about to grab the Bronco or Blazer
Went with the Gen 8 because of the body. Modded to the gills now.... very happy with it! Next truck will be a TRX4 Bronco or Blazer to bash a bit with the 2 speeds.
I know my previous comments about the Redcat Scout II may make it seem like I believe its the better between the TRX-4 (pick your version) and that I don't like the TRX-4. But I will point out that I have 5 TRX-4's, and don't consider myself a Traxxas fanboy. Just give me a rig that can perform nearly or better for less money, without having to do a bunch of upgrades and aesthetic add ons, then count me in. I don't have a single rig out of my 21, and the Scout will make 22, that I haven't had to modify to make it stronger (durability), faster or better performing. Thus far, it is the Axial Wraith, Yeti, and SCX10 II that have cost me the most to get to the performance and looks that I am happy with. I am sure my wallet is going to open for the Redcat Scout II as well.
I found your current comparison to be fair and of no surprise. There is a small flaw to your turning test, very small, but the Scout II does have a slightly longer wheelbase, so even if the steering angles were identical with the same tires and foams, the Scout will still have the larger turning radius.
As for recommending one over the other it is still going to come down to what it will be used for (terrain and speed), what is the degree of modification your willing to do with current and future parts. So far I can't say that you can go wrong with a Scout II for beginning in the hobby or just letting your own creativity rule in making it a top performer and looking good in the process.
Right on. The Gen 8 Scout II gets our seal of approval for price, performance and oh so attractive!!
Terra Quest RC subscribed to you for your smart brain!!
Very good insight as I thought the same thing.
So the TRX4 Sport is 12.3" and the Gen 8 is 12.5" wheelbase.
Wheelbase matters a little bit with these differences but not that much. Maybe an inch or two in diameter?
I have a TRX4 Defender which is 12.8", fully locked diffs. The steering radius is quite a bit smaller than the Gen 8 as well.
@@adnanbaigmirza thanks, and back to you.. now quit watching everyone else and go make an adventure, been awhile since you posted a vid.
Terra Quest RC bro I do go out very regularly for crawling and all of us are always so engrossed in crawling that. I one bothers to make the video. The only video I have up on my so called channel is just a random day when one of the guy broke his car before we even started so he decided to film us and then I edited 😂 thanks a lot for your support. I’m really looking forward to making videos and getting stuff on UA-cam. Thank you for your support 🙏🏻👍🏻
Very awesome comprehensive review! Great job!
This was a hard one. So much we wanted to say and hard to package it. Glad it turned out ok
Just after a month of use, my trx4 broke the front diff locking servo, then the rear one, a few days later the damn esc was fried so i sell the car and purchased the sport version. Guess what? two weeks and the esc died... Purchasde a gen 8 several months ago: Not a single failure since then and i'm not gentle with it. Bad luck? Maybe but i will not have any other traxxas crawler,never again. Thanks for those vids, sir, i love them.
Great video! I love this channel and I love this guys presentations!
I noticed the TRX4 has better low gearing for rock crawling and locking diff for extra assistance. It's also way quieter. Sharper steering as well. The body choices are all my choices. Land Rover Defender, Classic Ford Bronco. That generic looking pickup is nothing I would even look at.
The TRX4’s light pickup body and simplified engineering is the secret sauce over the Bronco, Blazer and Defender. Gives up looks for performance.
I felt the review was very honest given that Traxxas TRX4 Sport has been around much longer along wit the loads of aftermarket upgrades, it’s a much more reliable rig but with that Said I love the Gen 8 platform, it can be a really cool project for the avid hobbyist to find solutions to the downsides you’ve pointed out. It could be a trail truck as is or it can serve as a rock machine with some minor improvements one suggestion is to maybe equip it with a stinger style bumper, add a front skid plate to kinda help with climbing steep inclines and probably put some 2.2’s on it to give it a little more ground clearance but I’m not sure if it can accept bigger tires due to the fixed wheel wells or maybe trying some longer shocks to help raise the chassis but all and all it can work out if you just give it a little TLC. If outfitted properly it can be a cool trail truck or maybe a camper with roof rack LED light bar and whatever the avid hobbyist chooses to do with it. I’d love to see one dressed up and out on the trail. Thanks for the vid and in-depth analyst for both trucks as always good job man.
Right on, you get exactly what we are saying. These are two of the best vehicles now. Great for project cars too. Did you see our fabulous Topless Gen 8? ua-cam.com/video/Bt4THQEnpfI/v-deo.html
I definitely consider the TRX4 as a trail rig. The Gen 7 was straight away a rock crawler. The battery location directly over the front axle keeping weight low and up front made climbing steep walls and rocks amazing! No belly bump either!
Do you recommend redcat Gen8？
I built a all metal Gen8 10.5 lbs 2.2/ 57
Dual mud slinger tires in rear single wheels in front can turn in 2.5ft radius nune of the noise of my stock gen8, I will take any traxxs😋bring it !!! Moses
really nice truck😍, I hope you send me one of them even the used one no problem✌😀, you are generous and I deserve😉 I really like your channel and the way you review things, and of course your personality🙂, very well review & info that you give us solves a lot of questions that came or not yet in mind, useful things that helps with the rc hobby👍
What happened to your MTBR background? MTBR!!
Yea. , coming from a mtb.background also ,I loved that backdrop.keep up your great work!
Redcat gets the best bang for your buck nod because of a better body?? Trx beats it in every category but the body. Seems like upgrading a body would be more cost effective than fixing all the issues with the redcat. jmo
My Redcat Racing Gen 8 came with grease in all the gears I checked to portals gears and the diff gears they looked good to me
Your review is clearly biased and you are obviously paid by or at least favor the Traxxas brand. You have 16 links for Traxxas items and 2 for Redcat. As far as you stating the Traxxas lunges forward when you first pull the throttle is not accurate. If you use a little finesse and throttle management it takes off as slowly as any other crawler I have. Also the reason the Traxxas has a tighter turning radius is because it has a much shorter wheelbase. Lastly I was able to get mine to have the full 47 degree turning angle by maxing out the steering rate on the transmitter. The TRX4 body looks like a toy you would by at Walmart and the truck is $50 more.
Hey sorry you feel that way. That's our honest analysis and we've spent many many hours on our three Gen 8's. We've produced 26 videos on the Gen 8 and have lots of links on them. It is great at many things but now all. ua-cam.com/video/QlwVbqFE4Mk/v-deo.html
Awesome vid. Big like from me!
Did you say 40 dollars difference??.
In Denmark the TRX4 cost 50 % more than the GEN 8.
Great vid bro, love my sport, getting ready to scale her out. Your content is great, good work,take care ,out 😎😁👍
really appreciate it.
Change out the servo and transmitter the gen 2 will turn a lot better, for some reason the supplied transmitter doesn't give the full lock.
Exactly our observation on the Redcat Gen 8
Maybe Redcat didn't waterproof the receiver box, because Traxxas would sue them if they did. Yes, somehow Traxxas patented a waterproof receiver box... Anyway, great video!
so what if Traxxas did patent "their receiver box".. its amazing how many never checked out the full details of what the lawsuit was about.
I say go ahead and patent your design, it doesn't hurt the community. It forces other companies to come up with better designs in the end.
@@TerraQuestRC I actually don't have much of a problem with Traxxas. (I own 2 TRX-4s) The patent office on the other hand... (mostly a software rant in this case...)
It’s funny how they have a patent on waterproof servos and didn’t put one in.
donald ellis ahh yes traxxas did out one in it mostly All their rcs are waterproof .
My kids old hpi wheely king has a waterproof hpi receiver box. It's actually better design than many traxxas boxes. You can see if the gasket is correctly placed. I sometimes find sand grains in my traxxas boxes. Not in the hpi one. Cable intake is on the underside on the hpi box. I use traxxas reciver box on rustler, slash and scx10.
Loved the honest and thorough review so much, I subscribed. Thanks for the unbiased review..😊
Watched all your videos and bought a Gen 8. You are clearly a traxxas fan. Traxxas cheap body, flimsy bumpers after a few free mods of the Gen 8 it's still cheaper with better construction. I live in Wisconsin the foam in the tires gets better after use on the Gen 8 and a skid plate helps the front. The Gen 8 doesn't have a waterproof compartment but the electronics are well coated. I like the Traxxas but the wheel wells does tremendously to keep an inside compartment clean on the gen 8. I enjoy all your videos immensely but when you have it out for a vehicle I think you tend to be hypercritical of it. Just my opinion. Looking forward to more videos.
Appreciate the comment. We produced 24 video on the Redcat Gen8 and most are very complementary. ua-cam.com/video/YG3m3LbDupg/v-deo.html Nice kit. We just want to see a lot more updates, upgrades and development from Redcat on this platform.
Really appreciate your videos. Great job!
Best review content yet
Great video!
Very interesting and truly informative, keep the good work!
Very good information. Why is the speech audio in your videos so quiet??
Two RC's enta....One RC leaves. TWO RC's ENTA.....ONE RC LEAVES!
I'll tell ya boys..the sport kit, with modified canyon trails...it's doing things you wouldn't believe, with minimal upgrades. Check out my latest video, or any of my TRXellence series to see how this thing can perform! ua-cam.com/video/SDJtIzW3rpo/v-deo.html latest, vol 6, includes some crashes that I thought would break any 9-10lb truck..but wrong again. This thing is a beast.
Thank you. That's what wer're running too. Overdrive and brass portals and every other car bows down.
I saw your review well.It helped me a lot. Thank you
i didnt know the guy from squid games was into rc crawlers...nice
hello i wanna ask this redcat gen8 is good crawler for rocks and for snow and mud ?
Not even close, TRX4 hands down. I personally don't care about body pins and bling. TRX4 is well worth the extra $40. I actually prefer the look of the TRX4 and it is far more capable, no brainer here.
Trx4 defender chasis would have tore that redcat up. I have both
The sport...maybe. The Trx-4 , the original one,nope. Can't be detroned yet.
Love my TRX4 thing is a beast
Nice comparison review. Gonna have to check out that Kelly Moore paints store, do they mind if people are crawling in the front? 😅
A little bit. It's best done after hours and be discrete.
You in San Jose? Where do you crawl?
They should pay you for the free advertising!
I’ve been watching a lot of your trx4 videos! I enjoy all the details you throw in! Your funny too! Thank You! Building a sport right now!
Really appreciate it.
I'm just now getting notified on this video wtf UA-cam
Make sure you hit that 'notify' button on our channel. Otherwise, they do their random logic. We did change the thumbnail of this video today.
Chad Kunka damn bro
taking into consideration the redcat comes out the box with a battery and charger and the Traxxas does not, do you think the choice would be best for my 1st crawler?
Also, witch one goes faster on flat terrain?
The Redcat Gen 7 comes with battery and charger and is no a good purchase.
The TRX4 is a little faster on flat terrain and is the best purchase. Make sure you get an 11.1 volt lipo battery for the best speed.
RC Review oh! I was sure the gen 8 also came with a battery!
Thanks for the info!!
I watched this video a couple of times, along with many others, prior to making my choice and eventually went with the Redcat Gen 8. The primary reason being the scale looks of the Scout II. The issues with the Redcat are fairly negligible compared to the toyish/plastic look of the TRX4 Sport - plus the body posts - yuck! I would have to have invested another $100 to get to the level of aesthetics of the Gen 8, I wanted something that is fun to watch crawl around because it looks scale. I also like the metal parts of the Redcat, they look nice, are functional enough for my needs, and thus far have proven to be reliable. Thank you for the outstanding videos man - fun stuff.
Great decision man. I think that is exactly why we would recommend the Gen8. It just looks better and folks who value that will have a greater experience.
Both are two of the market leaders right now.
@@RCReviewChannel Thanks man, I really enjoyed your videos on upgrades and setting up the Gen 8 with an interior/scale features - those were the videos that put me over the fence and into a Redcat. I appreciate your work.
One of the best reviews i've ever seen 👍👍
Thank you!,,
No dude. I was listening to u until you said tie on servo. Traxxas servo is shit, the whole world knows it. Im currently running a redcat servo from a rs10 rockslide in the traxxas because in the 2nd run the traxxas servo died
They're both below average. The Traxxas servo is not too bad here since the Sport is light. They would both love the 20kg servo!!
Disagree. Redcat wins servo comparison even if it is slower. It works and keeps working
Hi,, is it possible to just add some of those weights sold at tire shops to the chassis. Isn't this will lower the whole chassis which is not good for crawling?
it would be cool if you make a video about easy ways of adding weights to the chassis or wheels without removing the tires.
Absolutely. Those are the best bang for the buck. Put them on as low and as forward as possible. We like putting those inside the tires a wheel, taped to the inside of the wheel.
RC Review Thanks alot.
I'll stick with my Redcat RS10, yeah it's not a "scale" but at least it will go over everything!
Its scale,1/10th scale....so its scale bud.
RC Review for president 2024 !!!
Where is this parking lot that you crawl at located?
Very well done video! New sub!
Why thank you. Spread the word!!
Look at the size difference aswell...you get more from redcat....redcat the winner for me
It does well for its girth. On the next test, we run both wit no body to take that out of the equation.
RCReview make sure you waterproof the rx , does have holes on the bottom of the box and might short out.
I’ve seen where others use spray or balloons
I also like the gen 8 better, it dwarfs the trx-4, and the turning radius is better on the trx-4 because the gen 8 has a longer wheel base, much better platform, trx-4 looks like a fisher price toy compared to the gen 8. Other pros have also said the gen 8 is better🙂👍
Let's not get carried away here. The gen 8 seems like a good design and great value, but the trx4 is clearly the stronger platform. Extremely beefy design and the drivetrain is super strong, no upgrades needed. Even the trx4 sport stock body looks surprisingly good in person. Let's not forget that the trx4 platform wasn't designed by some nobody, but a fellow veteran crawler friend of *the* John Holmes. Traxxas knew what they were doing when they needed to hire someone to design the platform. All that said, I'm tempted to try out a gen 8 too, though I can tell it's gonna need some upgrades down the line.
I wrote my previous comment before watching the video, after watching the trx4 clearly wipes the floor with the gen 8. But from the beginning I've felt it is an unfair comparison, the gen 8 isn't a trx4-killer, but rather a better alternative to most of the budget brand entry level crawlers on the market. It'd be more interesting to see a side to side comparison with those.
Traxxas is the best when it comes to rock crawling
Darn! I was sooo rooting for the Scout for the win. I LOVE the looks but yeah looks don't get ya home. BUT, there's always upgrades and McGivering to be done! lol I love McGivering!!
Love your channel btw. great info and a joy to watch.
Thanks!
Thanks for helping me confirn my deccision! Trx4 it is . I have the redcat everest 10 its very capable . Im just looking for a more scale car . Traxxas seems to be better out of the box
Thanks for breaking it down for us man. It's so freaking annoying that they have Zero foresight and put that HUGE hump in the skid... and a guys gotta spend 30-40 more bucks on the Bowhouse skid just to be on par with Any other Manufacturer.... Shame on Redcat for fibbing on the Specs too - Steering Degrees dont count if it it cant move maxed out... All the extras don't make up for inadequacy. Gotta Love that Body though!
Check out Brazin Scale's new ALL TIME LOW chassis for the TRX-4. I pre-ordered mine this morning and bought the skid and cross members.Yea its an expensive upgrade at $200 for all the parts but its the only LCG chassis for the already great crawling TRX-4 so imo it'll be untouchable. Checkout their website and their FB page for pics and info.
Makes me feel so much better about my purchase
The new trx 4 is better and it’s traxxas and not traxxa
Cool comparison