Great in the original violins of Vivaldi, Just as good or even better (more powerful) in the Bach rewrite for harpsichord, and absolutely stunning in the piano version, in which one has more definition of the pianos than of the harpsichords. I could listen to any and each of the versions hundreds of times, each with its own strengths and corresponding losses. The music is of such a level that surely one can be amazed by any one of the versions.
Enjoyed this version. I thought the strings were intrusive at times, a distraction. Someone commented on the pianists all playing this from memory, i agee. The interaction and empathy between the soloists was fantastic. Such intimate knowledge of the piece and the artists.. Thank you.
C'est exacte il s'agit au départ d'un concerto pour quatre violons de Vivaldi qui a été adapté pour quatre claviers par J.S Bach. Cette interprétation est une des plus équilibrée et jolie que j'ai déjà entendue.
Este concieirto lo toque en el aula Magna de la facultad de Derecho en Buenos Aires Aires Argentina , ermoa 4 compañeras recien graduadas , tengo fotos de ello esto es genial maravilloso , los picados son geniales , la armonia igual , claro estamos hablando o escribiendo del lamado PADRE DE LA MUSICA Johan Sebastian BAch , bravooooooo
You mean INCOMPARAVEL VIVALDI ! This Music is UNICAMENTE musica de El Vivaldi . Bach simplemente trascribi' por uno otro instrumento ; no es una Impreza mas grande 😊😊😊
Oh my God, how can you be `pretty sure´ when you're so wrong? This is Bach BWV 1065, a famous and beautiful piece, originally composed for four harpsichords and even better when played on four pianos.
Rudi Ratlos Sorry but your are really wrong. This is a concert from Vivaldi’s op. 3 “L’estro armonico “,RV580,. Bach beloved this italian composer,and all we do ☺️😏😏
die aufnahme ist recht gut,ich hab im hinterkopf,aufnahme:h.schmidt,justus frantz,c,eschenbach,f.oppitz,es gibt immer sachen,die hat man in einer aufnahma im kopf!alle anderen haben es schwer.
Großartig. Man hört jede Stimme. Und man vermißt kein Orchester. Vergleich sicher nicht mit Franz und Schmidt, wohl aber mit Argerich, Kissin, Levine,Pletnev.
I know that I am going to be like the blackbird, but I think that Bach accepted that as an order, but I find that the four keyboards at re too heavy for this light muisc, which is so well suited to soli violins!
I love this and feel wonderful for their collective collaboration. I wonder if 1 of them were allowed to venture off of the collective collaboration during the performance if it would be accepted. I know the answer of course. I am just asking questions to stimulate the reason we are here in the first place. What is good?
+juanky dutari Yea I know. This is Concerto in B minor, RV 580 by Vivaldi just transcribed for piano. My point is that the person who uploaded this video titled it as if this music were from Bach.
Da sollten Sie die Aufnahme von "Multipiano-Ensemble" hören: insgesamt Aufführungsdauer 6 Minuten kürzer. Ich bin sonst eher skeptisch bei der neuen "Schnelligkeit", - aber die Virtuosität der beiden Ecksätze kommt einfach begeisternd zum Tragen/Hören ...
Nice rendition, VERY good Players ! 😮😮😮 Though .. it's absolutely creepy uneducated erroneous to credit BACH, who merely copied/transcribed VIVALDI c.580 : if anyone translates Hamlet , it still remains Shakespeare , agreed ?? 😮😮😮 PLEASE STOP THE CHEATING 😮😮😮
La practica de los tres factores de la revolución de la conciencia nos libera del karma del error. Gnosticismo cristiano primitivo mistico científico youtube.
Whichever idiot decided to hit metal with a hammer sounds like .... pulling a string ... of a harpsihord was for a mentall hospitall. And this concert, originally for 4 harpsihords proves it completely. You hear constantly a multitude of hammers knocking through the performance of violins. While if it was one only wouldn't be sensed that much what of a fail it is, but here the instrument reveals itself at its best !
@Christina Nowotny das Original ist zwar von Vivaldi, alledings ist die gespielte Version hier die Version, die Bach für 4 Cembali geschrieben hat. Hier zu hören: ua-cam.com/video/L7VXRKwMCuQ/v-deo.html
It is true that four pianos do seem to overwhelm the other instruments, although, of course, having greater dynamic range than a harpsichord. The music is still stunning.
Phänomenal alle 4 Pianisten spielen zusammen auswendig
I thought I already found the best version of this masterpiece on youtube - then I found this - this is über alles - thank you for sharing!@
Man sieht (oder besser hört), wie diese famose Musik ohne Orchester und viel Tam Tam überzeugt.
Einfach Bach!
Bach es el padre de la música, sus obras sublimes llegan al alma, saludos desde Chile, 🎼🎶❤
Great in the original violins of Vivaldi, Just as good or even better (more powerful) in the Bach rewrite for harpsichord, and absolutely stunning in the piano version, in which one has more definition of the pianos than of the harpsichords. I could listen to any and each of the versions hundreds of times, each with its own strengths and corresponding losses. The music is of such a level that surely one can be amazed by any one of the versions.
👍👍👍👌✨️
Delightful, thank you.👏👏👏👍👍👍
Wunderschön. Vielen herzlichen Dank 🤗 👍 🌻
Das kann nur gut sein!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
視频姐姐/多謝妳/辛苦你了！为我们找到那么好聽/非常精采的四鋼琴八手联弹音樂！❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤非常滿意！
Enjoyed this version. I thought the strings were intrusive at times, a distraction. Someone commented on the pianists all playing this from memory, i agee. The interaction and empathy between the soloists was fantastic. Such intimate knowledge of the piece and the artists..
Thank you.
C'est exacte il s'agit au départ d'un concerto pour quatre violons de Vivaldi qui a été adapté pour quatre claviers par J.S Bach. Cette interprétation est une des plus équilibrée et jolie que j'ai déjà entendue.
Einfach ein Traum!
Este concieirto lo toque en el aula Magna de la facultad de Derecho en Buenos Aires Aires Argentina , ermoa 4 compañeras recien graduadas , tengo fotos de ello esto es genial maravilloso , los picados son geniales , la armonia igual , claro estamos hablando o escribiendo del lamado PADRE DE LA MUSICA Johan Sebastian BAch , bravooooooo
Incomparável Johann Sebastian Bach.
You mean INCOMPARAVEL VIVALDI ! This Music is UNICAMENTE musica de El Vivaldi . Bach simplemente trascribi' por uno otro instrumento ; no es una Impreza mas grande 😊😊😊
wunderschön
Wunderbar 😍😍
VivaVivaldi! Bach for sure indeed! 👍👍👍
großartig, ein Genuss
This is just magnificent! Thank you 🙏 💕 music 🎼 🎶 🎹 🎻 💕
... la música expresiones múltiples, de empezar y no terminar. Sorpresas no da la vida, y ésta es sorprendente ! ... 💜🍁💚 ...
LA MUSICA CLASICA ES MELODIA UNIVERSAL, RELAJA, ARMONIZA.
Oh my God, how can you be `pretty sure´ when you're so wrong? This is Bach BWV 1065, a famous and beautiful piece, originally composed for four harpsichords and even better when played on four pianos.
Rudi Ratlos Sorry but your are really wrong. This is a concert from Vivaldi’s op. 3 “L’estro armonico “,RV580,. Bach beloved this italian composer,and all we do ☺️😏😏
ANY Musician and every Music Lover should know , tantamount if you like it so much :D
A pure wonder ....*** Une pure merveille ***
die aufnahme ist recht gut,ich hab im hinterkopf,aufnahme:h.schmidt,justus frantz,c,eschenbach,f.oppitz,es gibt immer sachen,die hat man in einer aufnahma im kopf!alle anderen haben es schwer.
Really should be on harpsichords. These massive and beautiful pianos rather overwhelm. Like Chopin on a clavichord.
Großartig. Man hört jede Stimme. Und man vermißt kein Orchester. Vergleich sicher nicht mit Franz und Schmidt, wohl aber mit Argerich, Kissin, Levine,Pletnev.
All from the piano, no sheet music.👏👏👏👏
pure genius
The harpsichord version is the best, I am not too sure about pianos playing it🤨
I know that I am going to be like the blackbird, but I think that Bach accepted that as an order, but I find that the four keyboards at re too heavy for this light muisc, which is so well suited to soli violins!
❤ léger et chantant
I love this and feel wonderful for their collective collaboration.
I wonder if 1 of them were allowed to venture off of the collective collaboration during the performance if it would be accepted.
I know the answer of course.
I am just asking questions to stimulate the reason we are here in the first place.
What is good?
strings are a bit thin. mike problem?
Kein Kontrabass!!
Bei der Besetzung muss ein Kontrabass dabei sein.
VIVALDI
Thems is some funny look'n harpsichords, they sound mighty funny too.
I'm pretty sure this is Vivaldi not Bach.
powninnoobs10 the original is for 4 violins in b minor from Vivaldi
+juanky dutari Yea I know. This is Concerto in B minor, RV 580 by Vivaldi just transcribed for piano. My point is that the person who uploaded this video titled it as if this music were from Bach.
got your point. totally right on target
Bach transcribed it for four keyboards.
+Irrrakli You're right. I stand corrected.
Why so big and heavy pianos for a such light concerto? Isn't it ridiculous? A little bit more ad for Steinway...
insòlit Bach !
Das Tempo scheint mir ziemlich rasant zu sein ...
Da sollten Sie die Aufnahme von "Multipiano-Ensemble" hören: insgesamt Aufführungsdauer 6 Minuten kürzer. Ich bin sonst eher skeptisch bei der neuen "Schnelligkeit", - aber die Virtuosität der beiden Ecksätze kommt einfach begeisternd zum Tragen/Hören ...
The strings are very confused.
Nice rendition, VERY good Players ! 😮😮😮 Though .. it's absolutely creepy uneducated erroneous to credit BACH, who merely copied/transcribed VIVALDI c.580 : if anyone translates Hamlet , it still remains Shakespeare , agreed ?? 😮😮😮 PLEASE STOP THE CHEATING 😮😮😮
La practica de los tres factores de la revolución de la conciencia nos libera del karma del error.
Gnosticismo cristiano primitivo mistico científico youtube.
No es Bach, es Vivaldi !!
Whichever idiot decided to hit metal with a hammer sounds like .... pulling a string ... of a harpsihord was for a mentall hospitall. And this concert, originally for 4 harpsihords proves it completely. You hear constantly a multitude of hammers knocking through the performance of violins. While if it was one only wouldn't be sensed that much what of a fail it is, but here the instrument reveals itself at its best !
@Christina Nowotny das Original ist zwar von Vivaldi, alledings ist die gespielte Version hier die Version, die Bach für 4 Cembali geschrieben hat. Hier zu hören: ua-cam.com/video/L7VXRKwMCuQ/v-deo.html
Pianofortes playing harpsichord music? Disgusting.
No. Should be on harpsichords. It's like Chopin on a clavichord!
I have no doubt that Bach would love these Steinway D Grands.
It is true that four pianos do seem to overwhelm the other instruments, although, of course, having greater dynamic range than a harpsichord. The music is still stunning.
boring
Laut den Deutschen ist alle klassische Musik Bach, Einstein ist Deutscher, Nobel ist Deutscher und Stalin ist auch Deutscher - nur aus Georgien ...🤣
Zu blöd!!!
Половина русских тоже любит немцев.35 % лексики тождественен по глубиной этимологии.