E.F.S.F Megellan Class Battleship [Origin Ver]

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 сер 2023

КОМЕНТАРІ • 104

  • @krossbow789
    @krossbow789 4 місяці тому +170

    I find it hilarious how mobile suits can withstand several hits from mobile suit weapons, but a giant battleship, who's armor should be absurdly more dense, crumples from even the tiniest of hits.

    • @NACLGames
      @NACLGames 4 місяці тому +30

      MS don't withstand several hits. They can't even take one hit from these weapons. MS use much smaller caliber weapons against each other. These are 280mm bazookas with AP ammo. You can even see the heat hawk (the axe) is only used to cut battleship armor after it's been compromised by other hits.
      Unless you are talking about Gundams and other advanced and expensive mobile suits. They are framed and plated in Luna Titanium. The near-invulnerability of the material is a major plot point (and plot armor) of the series. Ships and other MS aren't equipped with it. If you're going to "logic" a criticism, then it would help not to omit such info.

    • @williamalfonso1373
      @williamalfonso1373 4 місяці тому +29

      @@NACLGames I think He means in the sense of "oh no my bridge is hit and now my ship explodes"

    • @NonsenseFabricator
      @NonsenseFabricator 4 місяці тому +17

      @@NACLGamesMobile suits survive hits from mobile suit weapons all the time.
      Imagine a giant mobile armor where the entire surface is covered in MS shields, layered multiple deep, and with guns of all kinds facing every direction. There's no good reason warships aren't like that.

    • @mattwoodard2535
      @mattwoodard2535 4 місяці тому +5

      Even better how G forces don't seem to matter much either. sm

    • @mattwoodard2535
      @mattwoodard2535 4 місяці тому +1

      @@NACLGames280mm is equal to just over 11 inches. (There were real world warships that have used this caliber BTW). The problem is that bazooka's are recoilless rifles and by nature are low velocity weapons, more like a missile than a shell fired from a piece of navel artillery. Such a round wouldn't have nearly the velocity to penetrate armor of any reasonable thickness. Recoilless Rifles do damage because they use a HEAT round (Shaped Charge), not by penetratingly armor and exploding. While a big HEAT round going might punch through a warship's armor (assuming they don't have modern armor like is on tanks these days), ships are so big and have so much redundancy built into them unless you get a Golden BB you will need to hit with a LOT of rounds to take out even a single larger ship. sm

  • @m.s.cheung8471
    @m.s.cheung8471 10 місяців тому +80

    I really love the fleet battles of origin. Hope we will get model kits for the origin ver magellan and salamis soon.

  • @ilhamshobri461
    @ilhamshobri461 10 місяців тому +55

    i love how powerful federation ship actually are in gundam origins, they surely can destroy zeon armada in very good formation. and only fell because zeon exploit the weakness of EFF sensor that actually not design to combat minovsky jaming yet. making zeon victory mos justifyable like they actually smart villain that explot enemy weakness, not a giant dumb villain that using brute force to stomp weaker defender like in child show.

    • @taliawtf6944
      @taliawtf6944 4 місяці тому +5

      At this point neither side could deal with minovsky jamming and that tech never really got going as using minovsky particles for that was banned after the war as it made dead zones on both Earth and in space where radar was useless as well as long range comms. Zeon was no slouch in military terms as they were always good at taking the fedies by surprise, they just never had the real numbers to keep up the momentum nor the smart leadership to fully exploit any gains made save for Char who had other objectives other than just taking out the federation. Good antagonists either way though I agree!

    • @mostdefinitelynotadurian1043
      @mostdefinitelynotadurian1043 4 місяці тому

      the only exception to them actually being smart. Is the whole colony drop shenanigan they pulled off. As all it does is just piss off the feds and it's citizens even more. effectively making them lose any credibility that they should be allowed to be fully independent.

    • @solaireofastora5999
      @solaireofastora5999 3 місяці тому

      ​@@taliawtf6944but Minovsky particles is used in all of their engines. Which means even if they don't dabble into Minovsky jamming, the particles left by the engines would still leave a trail of Minovsky particles which would all build up slowly depending on the amount of ships and MS that would pass by a area

    • @taliawtf6944
      @taliawtf6944 3 місяці тому

      @@solaireofastora5999 The levels that anti grav engines and beam weapons put out are well within the levels that will naturally decay. The levels you need for jamming radar and communications are on entire orders of magnitude more than what even the most beef mega particle cannon will put out in it's entire service life. The engines used to get around space are nuclear or propellant engines while the anti grav engines like the white base do produce Minovsky particles but again not enough to really mess up an area for long or at all really.

    • @benlex5672
      @benlex5672 Місяць тому

      @@taliawtf6944 Not really. Minovsky communication existed by the end of the OYW but it works a lot like telegraph IRL where it sends the signal to everyone within receiving distance. Laser Comm is also the mainstay of military communication by the Gryps conflict in order to prevent Minovsky particles from Jamming comms.

  • @strikezero01
    @strikezero01 10 місяців тому +88

    Armor-piercing with explosive fragmentation projectile , that was sick

    • @ilhamshobri461
      @ilhamshobri461 10 місяців тому +16

      and that thing actually exist. in ww2, armor piercing has explosive filler in it. its precisely design to destroy vurnurable parts or kill the crew after its successfully pierce armor. how its works are simple. its has a fuze that activate after hit something, and its explode quickly after it. assuming if the ammo already inside ship or tank

    • @taliawtf6944
      @taliawtf6944 4 місяці тому +1

      @@ilhamshobri461 That sort of ammo is still used today though with the composite armor that tanks have it's not as effective but some bunker busters use the same concept of post penetration explosion. Insane weapons in any time period though and disturbingly effective in their hay days.

    • @williamalfonso1373
      @williamalfonso1373 4 місяці тому

      @@taliawtf6944 I remember watching in some Military channel that modern anti-tank weapons make the tank armor be the demise of its crew. Like Pieces of the armor itself become projectiles.

    • @Boomkokogamez
      @Boomkokogamez 4 місяці тому +2

      @@williamalfonso1373 Yeah, that called spalling. As APFSDS penetrate, piece of the enemy armor will breakoff due to the kinetic energy and act as shrapnel.

    • @xxnightdriverxx9576
      @xxnightdriverxx9576 4 місяці тому +2

      ​​@@williamalfonso1373what you are describing is true, but it is a side effect, not the intended goal of ammunition design. Today's armor simply has become so good that you need very specific ammunition designs to be able to penetrate it at all, and those ammunition designs can not carry any explosive filler inside them at all.
      The ammunition is called APFSDS, Armor Piercing Fin Stabilized Discarding Sabot, and it is shaped like a medieval arrow: very long but very thin, made from very heavy materials, with fins at the back for mid-flight stabilization. This design is the only way to penetrate a tanks armor. More damage after a penetration is of no use if you can't penetrate the armor in the first place.

  • @Chondrichyes
    @Chondrichyes 10 місяців тому +29

    [マゼラン級戦艦(オリジン版)]
    オリジンの世界でのマゼラン級戦艦。色と外観など細かいところ以外はTV版とほぼ同じ。
    やられ役なのも同じ。

  • @trooperjay12
    @trooperjay12 5 місяців тому +27

    I like how the bridge and ship implodes after explosion

    • @samuraijackson241
      @samuraijackson241 4 місяці тому +3

      Which I don't think make sense since the inside is probably in a higher pressure than outer space.

    • @Renorick1
      @Renorick1 4 місяці тому +1

      ​​@@samuraijackson241
      Yes. Internal pressure being constantly exerted onto the inside of the hull. What happens when that force is suddenly, and completely, released? Like if the bridge tower was suddenly swiss-cheesed by a fragmentation round?

    • @NonsenseFabricator
      @NonsenseFabricator 4 місяці тому

      Actually, I think they crumple because there's a giant robot in an anime so nothing matters and everything is just pure magic

  • @dy1228000013
    @dy1228000013 4 місяці тому +4

    ミノフスキー粒子というレーダーや誘導兵器を無効化するものが出来たおかげで目視による攻撃でしか出来なくなり、モビルスーツのような近接戦闘の兵器が有効になった。

  • @eight-cloudspurple5871
    @eight-cloudspurple5871 5 місяців тому +15

    You know, as much as people harp on Strike Freedom, even that got whipped by the Gouf.
    Meanwhile I dont recall a single instance of Zeon MS even got as much as a scratch in live combat in Origin.

    • @samuraijackson241
      @samuraijackson241 4 місяці тому

      Just goes to show that their soldiers train very hard, and their mobile suits are more defined and better engineered.

    • @ruleofwtf
      @ruleofwtf 4 місяці тому +1

      Nah that's just the anime trope of using the flawless victory to make Zeon look more formidable as an enemy

  • @starpilot101
    @starpilot101 3 місяці тому +3

    The design of the ships and the way the battle went really reminds me of WW2 pacific theatre. Small attackers taking out battleships while avoiding their firepower? Battle off Samar (taffy 3 vs center force), Midway, hunt for Yamato come to mind. The shitty Federation combat air patrol, lack of screening is really like the IJN while their firepower, aesthetics and characters feel very american.

  • @Xingmey
    @Xingmey 4 місяці тому +5

    just imagine sitting in your chair in one of those battleships... in nothing more than a uniform of normal fabric...
    in space... when all that is seperating you from death is a few inch thick piece of armor...
    no way sir.
    i'd sit there in a space suit bare minimum.
    and not just coz we watched the expanse and saw them do it...
    it's just the smart thing to do in case you have to GET OUT real quick.
    on earth you can just step outside... and maybe jump in the ocean... if in battle of the coral sea or something like that.

    • @ytadventurer9170
      @ytadventurer9170 3 місяці тому

      Imagine sweating your ass off, potentially impacting your concentration while controlling a massive battleship, all for the fraction of a percent of a chance that you'd be able to live a few minutes longer, depending on how your ship was breached. Chances are, even if you weren't killed by whatever breached your ship, you certainly will be by all the debris around you inevitably moving and thousands of miles an hour or more. And even if you aren't killed by debris, the chances of you being rescued from the void (mid-battle, no less) are so infinitesimal as to not be worth mentioning.
      May as well enjoy what comfort you can, while you can. Give me the uniform of normal fabric, thanks. If I'm most likely going to die either way, I'd really rather not do so while wearing a diaper, like you have to if you're wearing a space suit.

  • @user-uc7qi4xg2e
    @user-uc7qi4xg2e 4 місяці тому +8

    イグルーでもそうだったが、艦艇が密集しすぎではないか?
    あの状態だと回避行動取ったら隣の艦にぶつかると思うのだが。

    • @khjyt2
      @khjyt2 4 місяці тому +1

      海上艦なら航行速度が遅いから
      ある程度密集していても良いと思うが
      宇宙戦艦だと航行速度は第1宇宙速度8km/sはあるはず
      ちょっと回避行動をとったら衝突すると思う。

  • @FLJBeliever1776
    @FLJBeliever1776 4 місяці тому +6

    If the Federation Space Fleet was so powerful, why do Zeon ships rip them to pieces so frequently?

  • @mikssityar3363
    @mikssityar3363 4 місяці тому +2

    Being hulking beast that they are, you think space battleships would be more heavily armored. But playing space engineers on a weapon focused modded pvp server for a year, one will be forced to quickly learn that the most efficient and cost effective way to to protect the bridge, aka the command and control center of the whole ship, is to have it at the center of the ship

    • @mattwoodard2535
      @mattwoodard2535 4 місяці тому

      Just following real life examples. While modern warships do have an exposed bridge, the real command and control (CIC) is buried deep in the ship. Something that they don't seem to do much in anime. sm

  • @xinguan2681
    @xinguan2681 4 місяці тому +8

    0:39 Is it possible to do a video on the Lepanto Missile frigate? The one that’s light grey and fired lots of missiles

    • @FederationMS787
      @FederationMS787  4 місяці тому +1

      Tell me the what series it it and which episode and time is it and I might do it

    • @xinguan2681
      @xinguan2681 4 місяці тому

      @@FederationMS787 It looks to be a Origin exclusive ship. It may have appeared in every episode, but I don’t know. I did found a episode on UA-cam (here: ua-cam.com/video/ewUrYvBLHvs/v-deo.htmlsi=aZr2jhbZPLY6UNW4 ) with shots of the Lepanto class, which I made a comment showing when. This may help.

    • @ahnafahmed5928
      @ahnafahmed5928 4 місяці тому +1

      It's extinct lorewise. Minovsky effect made most guided weapons useless. I honestly like the EFSF fleet designs.

  • @taliawtf6944
    @taliawtf6944 4 місяці тому +3

    I love this as a Zeon fangirl but that's not how decompression works in space. It is the reverse of what a submarine would have, the air in the ship would blow out of the hole in hull sucking people and stuff out of the hole. Which would be awful in the hole was not that big but a person gets forced through the hole... a spray of people paste would be seen. You know what I'd rather not see that but this is gundam and in F91 they showed a woman getting fried by a beam saber and then there is the scene of the mother getting her skull cracked from the spent shell from a fedie MS... Could fit actually. lol

    • @NACLGames
      @NACLGames 4 місяці тому

      Both you and the show are wrong. I assume you are referring to the ship crumpling...and that certainly should not happen. There's not enough loss of pressure to buckle the hull unless it was built like a drink can. Though in the show's defense, it actually does show, extremely briefly, air being rapidly blown out of the individual holes made by the weapons. It is much harder to see in this lousy compressed clip, it's much clearer on legit streaming or bluray.
      Where you're also wrong is the idea that people get sucked out like paste through holes. 14~15 PSI, which is earth standard atmosphere pressure and also the same on modern spacecraft, is not that much pressure. It doesn't matter how much air there is in a ship, what matters is how much pressure there is. And it's just 14 PSI. The force of being pulled into a hole at that pressure might be lethal from the blunt trauma, but it is highly unlikely your body would be ripped in half or something, much less turned into paste. You were probably thinking that the smaller the hole, the more likely you'd get 'people paste', when in fact the smaller the hole, the more likely you'd survive getting sucked into it. Pressure exerts more force the larger the area it acts on, that's why the unit is called PSI (Pounds per Square Inch). One square inch hole? You'd only experience 14 pounds of force when you reach the hole. The average punch of a person measures around 150 PSI in contrast.
      Your comparison to a submarine doesn't work. Modern military submarines experience probably around 400 PSI at crush depth. The Titan submersible that was recently lost experienced almost 6000 PSI.

    • @taliawtf6944
      @taliawtf6944 4 місяці тому +1

      @@NACLGames I was not wrong I didn't include the exact pressure needed to blow your bits out into space. Typical atmo pressure we enjoy is not that strong to do much as we see in planes whose windows bust out. You just went way beyond the scope of the comment for reasons known only to you but at least you feel included right?

  • @mrhironAB
    @mrhironAB 4 місяці тому +2

    Ох уж эти читерские технологии во вселенной, где в целом логично проходили бои)

  • @TheZorch
    @TheZorch 4 місяці тому +4

    Which Gundam series was this?

  • @xanderortega4359
    @xanderortega4359 4 місяці тому +5

    Arent ships useless in battle, they were basically pummeled by mobile suits, they mostly serve as carriers

    • @samuraijackson241
      @samuraijackson241 4 місяці тому +4

      I had the same thought. Why not just get rid of the big guns to have bigger mobile suit carrying capacity, and have more anti air turrets as more effective defense against enemy mobile suits? And then, have smaller ships that are either equipped with a lot AA guns (AA gun boat) and ones with just big turrets (battleships) in a fleet in case there are multiple enemy ships.

    • @xanderortega4359
      @xanderortega4359 4 місяці тому +2

      @@samuraijackson241 agree, ships would be better of with more armor, I think thats why the Gundam Seed Archangel survive and endured thos mobile suit battles, vause it basically serves as carrier with more armor.
      I mean if mobile suits are the main players, its better to make them have longer flight time so ships can stay far out

    • @trollinoakenshield9822
      @trollinoakenshield9822 4 місяці тому +4

      To be fair, this scene is the first introduction of mobile suits.
      Feds underestimated the capability of MS n doesn't even bother producing their MS until late in the war.

    • @remliqa
      @remliqa 3 місяці тому

      Did they do that with the Trafalgar Class?

  • @zeo-pe5sg
    @zeo-pe5sg 2 місяці тому

    This is funny because in grihnes greed this ship with a saberfish wall can maul those men biled suits, i basically liberate earth orbit in 9 turns after game start. My favourite thing i to use this ship and fighter to blast char away.

  • @legostar00
    @legostar00 3 місяці тому

    "Char go to the Yamato show your resolve"

  • @user-gm1td9ff9z
    @user-gm1td9ff9z Місяць тому

    宇宙世紀の終わりまで使われたサラミスと比べてマゼランは不遇のイメージが強い

  • @williamalfonso1373
    @williamalfonso1373 3 місяці тому

    I wonder why ship captains never wear space suits in the bridge but the rest of the crew do.

    • @Cyborg_J
      @Cyborg_J 3 місяці тому

      Maybe morale reasons? Like it's a bad sign if the captain wears one cause it implies they think the ship might get sunk. Impractical sure but I can see that being a reason

  • @honestdude8497
    @honestdude8497 3 місяці тому

    That was so hilarious, 1 big fokin space ship got arse whoped by 1 tiny robot..

  • @kakakakamilllo6333
    @kakakakamilllo6333 4 місяці тому

    i w tedy przyszedł tu sk i tak zadłużył wszystko że kosmiczne statki nigdy nie powstały

  • @user-tq1yn3vp3x
    @user-tq1yn3vp3x 4 місяці тому

    よく見たら味方の弾幕ミサイルが他の艦に当たってるのね

  • @sardaukerlegion
    @sardaukerlegion 4 місяці тому

    Seg Zeon!

  • @kukri1014
    @kukri1014 4 місяці тому

    爆炎で覆い隠す前に、壊れるところをもうちょっと詳しく見せてほしいかな。

  • @miltin6156
    @miltin6156 3 місяці тому

    「赤いモビルスーツ」ってセリフがあるけど、この時点で連邦は「モビルスーツ」をどの程度知ってたんだべか

    • @scarlet_squadron
      @scarlet_squadron 2 місяці тому

      オリジン時空は戦前からMSの存在は知ってたし、連邦も一応ガンキャノン作ってたからね。

  • @yusufxanderortega5944
    @yusufxanderortega5944 4 місяці тому

    if battles are like his id rather turn those ships into fast moving carrier and away from the battle, and let the mobile suits do the rest

    • @KingOfYamimakai
      @KingOfYamimakai 4 місяці тому +3

      This is technically before the Feds start focusing on Mobile Suits as their first mobile suits the Guncannons did jack shit to Zaku I so they only continue to make Mobile Armor.

    • @yusufxanderortega5944
      @yusufxanderortega5944 3 місяці тому

      @@KingOfYamimakai I mean at least after 1 engagement feds should have already learn

  • @user-qw9ve6gy5s
    @user-qw9ve6gy5s 3 місяці тому

    せめて航空戦力さえあれば…

  • @user-by4uz2vw3p
    @user-by4uz2vw3p 4 місяці тому +1

    これだと5隻以上楽チンでしょってな動き
    これは異常

    • @user-cw3ys2tj3h
      @user-cw3ys2tj3h 4 місяці тому +1

      流石は赤い彗星w

    • @Kei-zh9fh
      @Kei-zh9fh 4 місяці тому

      こんな勢いで破壊しててたったの5隻ってことはないよねw

    • @user-uo9nu3zj5e
      @user-uo9nu3zj5e 3 місяці тому

      @@Kei-zh9fh 撃破判定がめちゃくちゃ多いのかも

  • @user-xw8hd2wy8u
    @user-xw8hd2wy8u 4 місяці тому

    이쪽이 야마토보다 엑션이 좋네요

  • @remliqa
    @remliqa 3 місяці тому

    Which Gundam series is this from ?

  • @hikakin_mania440
    @hikakin_mania440 2 місяці тому

    こう見るとヤマトに見える

  • @user-tr4ly4bn1f
    @user-tr4ly4bn1f 4 місяці тому +4

    弾幕薄いよ。何やってるの?

  • @MrReded69
    @MrReded69 3 місяці тому

    ITS LIKE THE GUNDAM FRANCHISE SHOWED THE YAMATO FRANCHISE WHO'S THE BOSS!

    • @Austin-vg2by
      @Austin-vg2by 2 місяці тому

      Uncf navy is more stronger than earth federation fleet cause the wave motion gun spam which will destroy the federation fleet and Yamato have plot armor

  • @JeanLucCaptain
    @JeanLucCaptain 3 місяці тому

    ALSO those Fighters are totally useless and entire Zeon fleet is NINJA lol.

  • @xxxyxxxy7483
    @xxxyxxxy7483 4 місяці тому

    Нафига нужны корабли если они сраный картонки

  • @Azathoth2980
    @Azathoth2980 3 місяці тому

    Without Gundam the UC is another Starwars another Dune another 40k. But with Gundam it becomes anime

    • @remliqa
      @remliqa 3 місяці тому

      Star Wars , Dune , Warhammer 40k. None of those franchise are even remotely similar to each other. Furthermore they have giants mech in WH40K , The Tau Empire used them all the time, that is why WH40K fan nicknamed the Tau as weeaboos.

    • @remliqa
      @remliqa 3 місяці тому

      I also forgot to add that even without mobiles suits, The gundam universe would not be resembles Star Wars , Dune or Warhammer 40k. The closest Western franchise would be closer to The Expanse, except less realistic.

  • @user-hx7ug4pe8l
    @user-hx7ug4pe8l 6 місяців тому +3

    最初のムサイとかとの砲戦いる?

    • @marinFan08
      @marinFan08 6 місяців тому +11

      モビルスーツが敵艦に近づくための陽動作戦じゃないんですかね~?ものすごい犠牲ですけど、、、陽動作戦で甚大な被害はヤマトの先例がありますし、、、

    • @yyyyy1622
      @yyyyy1622 6 місяців тому +7

      肉を切らせて骨をたつ
      身を捨ててこそ浮かぶ背もあれ

    • @user-hx7ug4pe8l
      @user-hx7ug4pe8l 6 місяців тому +3

      @@yyyyy1622 浮かばないんだよなぁ

  • @user-wg3el5py2x
    @user-wg3el5py2x 4 місяці тому

    マゼラン級を確実に狙ってる辺りがマジで気色悪い😅

  • @deltazeta5506
    @deltazeta5506 4 місяці тому

    this is why i don't like gundam