I Watched Netflix *SOCIETY OF THE SNOW* For The FIRST Time Left Me Abhorrently HORRIFIED!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 кві 2024
  • Become a member of the channel by supporting here: / @billybinges
    Dont forget to like and subscribe if you havent already...
    Reckless Three Podcast: / @reckless3podcast
    Discord: / discord
    Instagram: @BillyBinges
    Twitter: @BillyBinges
    Twitch: / billybinges
    Snapchat: @ItsDDubble
    My other youtube channel:
    / @billyyousocrazy
  • Фільми й анімація

КОМЕНТАРІ • 406

  • @judkim8132
    @judkim8132 Місяць тому +174

    Seriously, one of the best reactions of this movie. I didn't care that you watched it in English because it made you understand more easily what was happening to them. You showed a lot of empathy and you also put yourself in their shoes.

  • @kellifranklin4432
    @kellifranklin4432 Місяць тому +467

    The reason why he wouldn't leave that piece of luggage is because he had collected keepsakes from every person that died and he was taking them to their families. It was important. I read he eventually made it to every victim's families and brought them a keepsake.

  • @ashdrizzy
    @ashdrizzy Місяць тому +154

    “she’s resting”
    “… in peace?” 😭😭

  • @rumbledumpthumpershaker6735
    @rumbledumpthumpershaker6735 Місяць тому +321

    The Spanish version has more emotion and really shows off the acting. They all did a great job even though some of them had never acted before.

    • @shinigamik2
      @shinigamik2 Місяць тому +16

      eh pero bastante bien el doblaje en inglés igual. Una lástima que no lo haya visto con subs pero bue, al menos la vio ♥♥♥✨✨

    • @judkim8132
      @judkim8132 Місяць тому +8

      Puede que perdiera un poco viéndola en inglés, pero también ganó. Fue capaz de entender mucho más (a veces unos aparta la vista de la pantalla porque se está mostrando algo fuerte o porque quieren hacer un comentario mirando a cámara) que otros que sí han respetado el idioma y luego preguntan porque los "personajes" no hicieron esto o aquello, cuando ya se explicó anteriormente en la película. Para nosotros es más sencillo escoger en qué idioma vemos algo porque manejamos ambos. Porfa no bombardeen al chico de esta forma o en un futuro ni se interesará en ver películas españolas.

  • @eslunita
    @eslunita Місяць тому +203

    Fun fact: Some of the survivors were part of this movie. The Real Nando Parrado was the man in the airport who opens the door for the actor playing Nando and his family. The man reading back the names twice is the real Carlitos Páez, playing the role of his own father. And when the actor playing Roberto is walking into the hospital, the real Roberto Canessa is the doctor walking behind him, smiling.
    Thank you for your reaction Billy!!

  • @jonathansmith8672
    @jonathansmith8672 Місяць тому +119

    Honestly, the original spanish verison (With English captions) is way better than the English voiceover. But either way, such a great and powerful movie.

  • @ceebee2
    @ceebee2 Місяць тому +49

    Billy: a $45 flight?? I’m there!
    Me: you’re about to see exactly what kind of flight you get for $45

    • @manuellunaurquizo8663
      @manuellunaurquizo8663 Місяць тому +2

      Hahahahaha you are a so .n of ... XD i am about pee of laughing😂😂

  • @lapreviaasinomas
    @lapreviaasinomas Місяць тому +43

    Part of what you said coincides with what the real Roberto Canessa says when he is interviewed, about valuing what we have.
    He says that when he wants to complain about something in life he thinks that he was sleeping on the cold metal of a plane that crashed in the mountains, and that one day he was complaining about that and when the avalanche came and they lost friends and their only refuge he understood who complained without valuing what he had, and so he stops complaining.
    At the same time, upon returning to Uruguay, he finished his medical studies and became a pediatric cardiologist. At the same time, he is such an important professional that the most difficult cases are brought to him, where other doctors no longer see hope. And he says that he approaches each case as if it were that mountain he had to climb, and thus he has saved many children's lives throughout his professional career.
    He always says that we all have our "own mountains" to climb, and that you can fall, and you are allowed to cry, but that you have to keep walking, just like they did.

    • @okoala62
      @okoala62 Місяць тому +1

      So powerful

  • @23marian
    @23marian Місяць тому +105

    This movie is beautiful and extremely sad. The survivors said this is one of the closest to the actual events. There are cameos of the real survivor too. Amazing movie. And yes, you should've watched in Spanish

  • @justclaudiabusiness
    @justclaudiabusiness Місяць тому +82

    Did not expect you to react to this. So glad you did! It's a wonderful and moving film 💖😢

  • @user-qx6ri2bf4o
    @user-qx6ri2bf4o Місяць тому +577

    NOOO YOU SHOULD'VE WATCHED IT IN SPANISH :(

    • @AdonisTimone
      @AdonisTimone Місяць тому +160

      Billy did 2 years of Spanish and can’t form a sentence. Pls give him a break for the Dub 😂 Have you seen his spelling bees!? He ain’t finna read a movie

    • @DamiahSpencer-om4zc
      @DamiahSpencer-om4zc Місяць тому +13

      @@AdonisTimone Oop-

    • @BillyBinges
      @BillyBinges  Місяць тому +212

      This violation was uncalled. Adonis Tim(e)OUT is about to be your new name when I send you to the shadow realm 😂

    • @DamiahSpencer-om4zc
      @DamiahSpencer-om4zc Місяць тому +9

      @@BillyBinges LMAAAAOOOO😭

    • @matt2522
      @matt2522 Місяць тому +29

      Why does this bother so many people? Some people prefer to keep their eyes on the characters’ faces during dialogue. Different strokes for different folks. There are pros and cons to both dubs and captions. I guarantee 99 percent of people complaining about the English dub watch anime in english, which is objectively sillier, considering there’s much less visual detail to miss, compared to live action.

  • @Divine_Athena
    @Divine_Athena Місяць тому +51

    Ugh I’m so sad you didn’t watch it in Spanish 😭 it’s so good- you can feel the emotions more but loved that you still reacted to this, by far a top movie for me

  • @bluemilkxo
    @bluemilkxo Місяць тому +13

    so happy you reacted to this Billy! As a Uruguayan myself, it made me cry like a bitch, made me feel like i was watching family of mine go through this. Rest in peace to those who never made it home. 😪

    • @okoala62
      @okoala62 Місяць тому

      Such a powerful movie

  • @xel1673
    @xel1673 Місяць тому +20

    The turbulence wasn't what crashed the plane. If you remember the diagram at the beginning that the mechanic drew, he explained their path couldn't be a straight line from point A to point B over the mountains. They had to go South first to cross the Andes at a low point in the mountains (where the peaks aren't as high) and then, once clear of the mountain range, were to turn North again to get to their destination in Chile. Unfortunately, with the poor weather and cloud cover obscuring their visuals at the altitude they needed to safely fly above the mountains, the pilots had to calculate when they thought they had fully cleared the Andes. Because that was the way it was done back then. And they calculated very wrong. For whatever reason known only to the now dead pilots, they turned North waaay too soon. Around 10 minutes too early in a 20-some minute traverse. They unknowingly flew North right in the middle of the Andes mountains. Then they also started to descend, thinking the dangerous mountain peaks were well behind them and it was now safe to fly below the clouds. The weather and thin air got far worse the further they went into the mountain range, which caused the turbulence and made them drop very quickly. When the pilots had descended low enough to see again, they realized they were flying right at a mountain. In the poor conditions, the plane struggled to regain altitude. It was a miracle the plane's nose was able to clear the top of mountain and avoid a head-on collision that would have killed everyone.
    The miracles only continued when the plane's wings struck the mountain. With that much violence and with a part of the plane experiencing such a sudden stop, somehow it didn't jerk the plane and cause the fuselage to spin out wildly. Or the tail striking didn't cause the whole plane to spin or flip. Or, as it slid down the mountain, it didn't skip or bounce, avoiding any rocks, which could have flipped the plane over and caused a somersault effect or something like that. The fact everything sheared away cleanly and the plane continued soaring forward, just to land at the right angle to basically slide down the mountain like a toboggan is, honestly, 1 in a million in and of itself. There were numerous ways they could have died beyond the initial strike.
    Also, the guy (Zerbino) in the movie who states the dead person the group eventually find still strapped to his seat being someone who had been in the row right behind him before it was sucked out. Here at 22:30 And you said "That could have been him". Very true. But Zerbino's row of seats WAS sucked out of the plane. It wasn't shown in the movie, but, as told by the real Zerbino, he started to feel the row of seats getting loose. Not really understanding it and just acting on instinct, he unbuckled himself and grabbed onto the seats in front of him and the overhead luggage compartment. Just as he did so, his seat and the guy who had been sitting beside him, who was still buckled in, got sucked out. Zerbino then rode the rest of the way down basically holding onto the plane for dear life. In the movie it does briefly show Zerbino's actor standing and clinging to the plane (no row of seats behind him @ about 7:40 ) just before the plane crashes into the snow and everyone is thrown forward. Real life Zerbino was thrown forward, but, miraculously, walked away with just some minor scratches and bruises.

  • @isaintrovert
    @isaintrovert Місяць тому +9

    Guys leave him alone about the language switch. I watched it in both versions (English first because I didn’t know it was a Spanish film. Netflix defaulted the movie to English) & I cried like a baby during both version. Yes Spanish is obviously the better version but lay off him, guys. He gave a great reaction 👏

  • @rdsanantonio
    @rdsanantonio Місяць тому +13

    I was tense the entire movie. I didn't know anything about this story at all when I watched it, but I knew it was a survival movie, so I was prepared to be STRESSED. Nothing could have prepared me for how stressed I was going to be the ENTIRE TIME though 😭

  • @sophiacarvalhoguterres3452
    @sophiacarvalhoguterres3452 Місяць тому +36

    This film carries a lot of emotional weight, especially when you stop to think about what the survivors went through on the mountain, I was distressed throughout the entire film and cried horribly at the end

  • @Zozette27
    @Zozette27 Місяць тому +10

    The reason for the crash was that the pilot turned north too soon and thereby flew into the middle of the mountains. I was 14 when this happened and remember the news reports about it. I was 17 when I read the book ‘Alive’. Since then I have read 9 books about Flight 571 including 5 written by a survivor Ie those books written by Nando, Roberto, Carlitos, Pedro and Eduardo. I own Coche’s book but have not read it yet.
    The youngest survivor was Carlitos who turned 19 while on the mountain. One of the boys who died, Carlos Valeta, was about three months younger than Carlitos.

  • @kamisartor5998
    @kamisartor5998 Місяць тому +5

    As an argentinian, I'm sad that you missed the beautiful accents from our country and Uruguay (we have a very similar one).

  • @xel1673
    @xel1673 Місяць тому +35

    My heart really breaks for all of them, but especially Nando. He lost a lot. He not only lost his mom and sister, who he had encouraged to come on the trip to Chile and carries that guilt, but his two closest friends also died. Guido Magri was one of the guys in the tail section of the plane and was found dead later up on the mountain. Nando's other best friend was Francisco "Panchito" Abal. He was the guy who died here 10:06 Abal and Nando were sitting together and both were thrown from their seats to the front of the plane. They both suffered serious head injuries, like a cracked skull. Unfortunately, Abal didn't survive. Nando should have also died, but a bunch of lucky accidents happened to keep him alive and he was eventually able to walk out of the Andes on his own two feet. Only to go home to an empty void where his mother and sister had been, his father (thinking he lost his entire family and was alone) had sought comfort and companionship with a new woman, and all of Nando's belongings had been sold or given away since the dad assumed he'd died. Nando moved out, lived alone, and was lost for years. Thankfully things eventually improved and he found happiness and contentment with life.

    • @rlk3490
      @rlk3490 Місяць тому

      And its really sad to think that, according to some accounts of the story, Abal was found dead trying to shield Susana from the cold.

    • @sodamnsexy16
      @sodamnsexy16 Місяць тому +1

      His dad moved on after 2 months???😅

    • @rlk3490
      @rlk3490 Місяць тому +2

      @@sodamnsexy16 yes, but no hard feelings between Nando, his father and his remaining sister. He was left alone, as his elder daughter lived in Chile and was married with a little boy, and he thought his son, younger daughter and wife had died in the mountains. Was shocked when Nando appeared. It was tragic, I think we cant judge him ... after all, as Nando says, he was a great father that always cared for his family in both affective and material ways.

    • @Linsey009
      @Linsey009 Місяць тому +1

      i'm on the waiting list on the libby app for nando's book and i'm just so so so looking forward to reading it.

    • @Linsey009
      @Linsey009 Місяць тому +2

      @@rlk3490 in the society of the snow book they said he was so distraught that he would wander around their village often and their neighbors would have to walk him back home because he'd get lost. i can't imagine what he went through.

  • @user-qx6ri2bf4o
    @user-qx6ri2bf4o Місяць тому +72

    The film is a cinematic masterpiece, not only because of the aesthetics, art, photography, make-up or script, but because they managed to tell the story as real and truthful as possible, to the point that the survivors actively participated in it and say that when they see it they relive in their minds everything that happened. It is wonderful the way in which Bayona manages to show the harshness of what happened with an artistic touch and a strong emotional charge and for the first time not only highlighting the figure of the survivors as heroes but also those who died and did not make it out of the mountain, which is why Numa's voice as narrator is so important. Each of the actors met the real person they were playing and most of them managed to create a bond with them, moving from interpretation to reality and giving the importance it deserves to what each survivor felt, because as they have already said, each one remembers the mountain in a unique way. THANKS FOR REACTING!

  • @valenrosas1747
    @valenrosas1747 Місяць тому +6

    Something that I always like to clarify when I see reactions to this movie is that in Uruguay we don't have snow! We are not used to such extreme cold (that and surviving a plane crash obviously)

  • @martindrudi
    @martindrudi Місяць тому +6

    Some facts about the movie:
    Three of the survivors made cameos in the movie:
    - Fernando "Nando" Parrado: opens the airport door to his character at the beginning of the movie.
    - Roberto Canessa: Plays a doctor when they are received at the hospital because he is a doctor in the real life.
    - Carlos Paez Rodríguez: Represents his own father (Carlos Paez Vilaró) when he reads the list of survivors reading the name of his own son (“Carlitos Miguel Paez, my son”).
    - The house where Numa arrives is the real Numa's house and the walker is a Numa's nephew.
    - The suitcase that Gustavo Zerbino didn't want to leave in the Andes was full of belongings of the deceased that he took to their respective families.
    - The actors underwent a diet under strict medical supervision so that their bodies would more realistically reflect the effects of what the survivors went through.
    - The survivors and the families of those who passed away say that this movie is much more faithful to the real events, unlike the film 'Alive!' which was more of a spectacle than a tribute. In addition to changing the names of the characters, they altered almost the entire story.
    - All the survivors (except for 2 who died in 2015 and 2023) are still alive. You can search for their accounts on Instagram.
    - The location of the accident (Valle de las Lágrimas [Valley of Tears]) can still be visited today, starting from Argentina (as it is a substantially shorter journey): it takes several days on horseback and hiking through the mountains. It requires several days of planning and good physical condition.
    - They were there for 72 days. On the first day of rescue, they took some of them and a group of rescuers stayed who set up a tent a little away because of the smell. The next day they rescued the others.
    See more info in: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uruguayan_Air_Force_Flight_571
    Hugs from Argentina. 🤗

    • @ailem2707
      @ailem2707 Місяць тому

      There’s even more cameos:
      - Daniel Fernández is sitting in the front row of the church
      - Coche Inciarte is reading a newspaper at the bar
      - Moncho Sabella is an extra in the airport (Tintín too, but his appearance got cut, same as Gustavo Zerbino as a rugby coach).

    • @rociosegura6091
      @rociosegura6091 Місяць тому

      Es tremendo, los amo que están en la peli. Coche Inciarte llegó a ver la peli antes de fallecer, él estaba tan contento, le decía a Simón que era su actor favorito mi vida no lo habría visto actuar nunca jajaja

  • @michelleelliott4402
    @michelleelliott4402 Місяць тому +35

    Lmaooo Billy you should have watched it Spanish, but I truly love your reaction 😂. And it’s so heart breaking finding out this what they all went through and how it happened, I remember watching the is on UA-cam like 6 years ago and checking out all their interviews.

  • @sallyj632
    @sallyj632 Місяць тому +18

    Would I eat the bodies in a desperate situation like this? Yes. As repulsive as it is, you either eat or you die. Also, when you're starving ... I mean literally starving to death, you will eat whatever you possibly can around you.

  • @vivianamora7505
    @vivianamora7505 Місяць тому +12

    When I cried the most was the very end when they were all in one hospital room together. It’s because that’s all they knew for so long They decided to leave each other hospital rooms so that They can be bonded together at night. They didn’t know any other way to sleep.😢❤

  • @Zozette27
    @Zozette27 Місяць тому +5

    The reason that they had so many cigarettes is that there was a shortage in Chile. Javier Methol and Panchito Abal were cousins and their family owned a cigarette company. They were taking cigarettes to Chile to sell. Abal was the young man who died during the first night. I read somewhere that some of the other boys were taking cigarettes to give to their Chilean hosts (or maybe they were going to also going sell them).

  • @lennnpg
    @lennnpg Місяць тому +11

    I've been watching you for a while now and I am so happy that u watched this movie!! It's a masterpiece, and I am so proud to be Uruguayan because of this story and these people.
    Fun fact: Roberto Canessa, one of the survivors, is a cardiologist here and he treated me a few years ago! the most lovely and humble man ever. And it's crazy to think about what they went through, its impossible to comprehend when you have them in front of you.
    Love from Uruguay :)

  • @ohbooyourselves
    @ohbooyourselves Місяць тому +43

    "Y'all not ready for the word" Billy stay preaching 😂

  • @allaboutthecookies9642
    @allaboutthecookies9642 Місяць тому +52

    I’m a 1979 baby… yup, feeling old 😂 I do remember going to the gate to see people off at the airport… feeling even older 🤣

    • @BillyBinges
      @BillyBinges  Місяць тому +9

      Kinda jealous I will never experience that!

  • @katsukirenka1629
    @katsukirenka1629 Місяць тому +3

    I can't believe this didn't win any of the oscars it was nominated for, I really can't. And now for the info dump -
    Like others have said, some of the survivors are in the movie and had a part in it's creation. The real Nando holds the door for actor Nando in the airport, the real Roberto is the doctor behind actor Roberto as they walk into the hospital, and Carlitos' father saying the names over the radio is the real Carlitos playing his father.
    I believe it was also the survivors who suggested that Numa be the narrator, or they agreed with the choice of it. Numa wasn't part of the Old Christians rugby team, he was just friends with one or two players and was invited along. He became almost the spirit of the survivors - I'm reading Nando's book 'Miracle in the Andes' and Numa is very much described as a saint-like figure. Nando writes that Numa seems to be able to handle things better than others, whether that be comforting the injured or pushing to help with anything else. Through the whole book, it's clear that these boys loved and cared for each other and truly worked as a team when it would have been easy to splinter apart under stress.
    In the real rescue, not everybody was taken at once. Half of the survivors had to stay another night in the plane, but some rescuers stayed with them. The rescuers were shown the boneyard (for lack of a better term) and told who was was. The rescuers said that the survivors didn't need to show or tell them anything, and the survivors (one or two in particular I think but I can't quite remember) said that they did and their dead were just as important as the living. One thing that breaks my heart is that the survivors agreed not to tell anyone/the press about their forced cannibalism until they had spoken to their families and the families of the dead, wanting to have those conversations personally before publicly saying anything, but reporters broke the story first. Reporters went to the crash site and saw the boneyard and made assumptions - saying that survivors killed each other for food. The public started turning against the survivors and they were forced to make a statement to the press about the real circumstances before talking to the families. The public thankfully came back to their side, but that false rhetoric still exists, I'm embarrassed to say that I thought that had been the case from brief mentions in pop culture before doing my own research. There is no shame in what the survivors did to survive, and nobody is in a place to judge them. We don't know what we're capable of until we are put in these kinds of situations. Anyone can say that they would never resort to cannibalism, but you don't know that until you're put into a life or death situation. Though even without knowing for certain, I'm pretty sure I wouldn't survive what they did. They truly are heroes, even if they don't feel like them.
    Also, while promises and offers were given, not all the bodies were used for food. None of the women were touched, including Nando's mother and sister, or the bodies of anyone who died of infection. This included Numa and Arturo.
    Only two of the survivors have passed away since the rescue, and several have gone on to live incredible lives. Roberto is a renown cardiologist who also put forward help with the COVID-19 pandemic for example.

  • @rumbledumpthumpershaker6735
    @rumbledumpthumpershaker6735 Місяць тому +16

    Yes true story with some of the survivors involved. So this version is supposed to be pretty accurate. The survivors didn't like the American version Alive 1993. They did change some things. They flew north and made an unscheduled overnight stop due to the weather. The pilot lived until the next day begging for his bang in his bag to end it. Numa's foot was hurt when someone stepped on it in the dark plane, not as shown. By the way the man that found them was very poor but he gave them all his food. The survivors took care of him for the rest of his life and continue to take care of his children.

  • @xChaseTheWind
    @xChaseTheWind Місяць тому +2

    The moment you squirmed so bad at the way someone ripped A BANDAID at the very beginning I KNEW this movie was gonna hurt you

  • @rebeccagibbs4128
    @rebeccagibbs4128 Місяць тому +8

    5:15 hey billy! i was born in 1984 and i clearly remember as a wee kid going ONTO the plane to see the cockpit and say bye to my dad on trips. we live in NZ and back then our lil city's airport was a shed with a tarmac and because the big planes never came in everyone flew out and in to the smaller regions on "flying pencils" aka fairchild metroliners that had one seat per row and a curtain separating the cockpit from the passengers which usually wasn't closed lol
    This story has fascinated me since i was 11 and read the book by one of the survivors. This movie does downplay how important their catholic faith became throughout but other than that, this adaptation is spot on. I remember seeing the photo of them posing with the wreckage and there was a human ribcage in the background and how intense that was for a kid to think about. The survivors had very difficult lives as they were judged pretty harshly when the cannibalism came to light, as well as dealing with survivors guilt and recovering physically and mentally from that ordeal. L
    oved the reaction as always, would love to see you react to Hunt for the Wilderpeople made in my country by Taika Waititi :)

    • @pablomassardi
      @pablomassardi Місяць тому

      Roberto Canessa is a cardiologist and an excellent person. He is my primary doctor and helps many children who suffer from heart disease and cannot be operated on here in Uruguay. He makes all the contacts so that the operation can be performed in more advanced countries.
      Of the 16 survivors, 14 remain. Recently, 2 died and of all those who returned, none of them, until today, had to consult a psychologist or psychiatrist regarding anthropophagy here in Uruguay. The survivors held a press conference to talk about this issue and no one told them. I judge, the audience present stood up to applaud them, in other countries they did question them a lot but not here in Uruguay, the "good" thing about this movie is that they put the names of the people who died in the mountain and in the movie they do much emphasis on those who could not return.
      Greetings from Uruguay

  • @Zozette27
    @Zozette27 Місяць тому +2

    Only one of those who died was buried in Uruguay. Rafael Echavarren’s father went up to the mountain to retrieve his son’s body because he had been told Rafael’s body was untouched. 13 of the bodies were untouched. This included all those that relatives on among the survivors (Susana and Eugenia Parrado, Panchito Abal, Liliana Methol and Daniel Shaw), 5 of those who went out of the back of the plane, and the three who died last which included Rafael. The rest of the bodies, and what remained of those who were eaten were gathered and buried on the mountain.

  • @ursularowe3353
    @ursularowe3353 Місяць тому +23

    Yes, a million other people will probably tell you but this really did happen.

    • @Natra9
      @Natra9 Місяць тому +4

      Have you watched Ask a Mortician on UA-cam??? She explained it beautifully and with respect

  • @MusicxxRose
    @MusicxxRose Місяць тому +6

    I watched it in English the first time too, my mistake. People might have already said but one of the survivors said this movie was 90% accurate, super spot on details wise how it happened.

  • @jacquelinea.7575
    @jacquelinea.7575 Місяць тому +3

    The book was written based on the true story. Some of them stayed in the mountain for 72 days because they were really rescued in 2 days.
    If u ever visit Uruguay in Montevideo they have a museum with everything about the accident.

  • @dioanacortes982
    @dioanacortes982 Місяць тому +10

    If you have the opportunity and want to see it again, you can do it in Spanish and with subtitles, because seriously, the essence of the accent and the feeling that the actors give with the dialogue is very different.
    Pd: Saludos from Colombia!

  • @efmar138
    @efmar138 Місяць тому +4

    Soy Uruguaya y tenía 11 años cuando ocurrió. De los 16 sobrevivientes, al día de hoy, viven 14. Ojalá pudieras ver sus entrevistas, son una enseñanza de vida!! Es increíble lo que hicieron estos muchachos, acá en Uruguay no tenemos nieve, por tanto no conocían nada y el cerro más alto que tenemos es de 513 metros! Ellos dicen que si les hubieran dicho lo que iban a tener que hacer, no lo hubieran logrado. Es una historia de amor hacia el otro, ellos debían cuidar al otro más que a si mismos, sin el otro, que te ayudara, que te masajeara los pies durante la noche, que estuviera contigo... No lo habrían logrado.
    Cayeron en un lugar donde todavía no había estado ningún ser humano.
    Es una historia que muestra de lo que somos capaces los seres humanos. De la fuerza que tenemos, aunque no lo sabemos. Como dicen ellos, todos los seres humanos tenemos nuestras "propias montañas" para pasar, pero el mensaje es que sí se puede, siempre se puede,!!
    Me encantó tu reacción! Un abrazo desde Uruguay? 🇺🇾🇺🇾🇺🇾

  • @tjohns25
    @tjohns25 Місяць тому +3

    "That couldve been his row that flew out "
    It actually was.. Gustavo's seat flew out, but just prior to that happening, he jumped up and held onto the overhead bin area. They actually filmed this, but it was cut from the final edit.
    The boy who was sitting next to him flew out.

  • @angelasangronis9104
    @angelasangronis9104 Місяць тому +8

    The way Billy said “The way the dub over voice sounds it’s like he’s still on the mountain” and I went “um… about that..”

  • @kamccomb16
    @kamccomb16 Місяць тому +8

    Leaving Billy speechless, love that. I caught this in theaters, the sound and airplane crash alone made the movie visceral

  • @briannapinkney4966
    @briannapinkney4966 Місяць тому +2

    The film, while horrific, was done so beautifully… You can really see the intersection of nature, spirituality, and humankind. Humans are small, but it’s incredible what we, as a species, have survived and created.

  • @moramorandobianchi7093
    @moramorandobianchi7093 Місяць тому +4

    Billy! I'm so happy you watched this movie, I hope more channels do too. Some of the actors are from my country and I wished you watched in the original language so you could also hear the accent and typical rioplatense expressions, but if watching in English is what it takes for you to watch then I'll deal. I've recently been to the museum in Montevideo where a lot of the real stuff from the plane is kept (like the mementos from the ones that died) and it's harrowing

  • @ronnieswrld
    @ronnieswrld Місяць тому +3

    i’m late to watching this so i’m not sure if you’ll see this comment but it wasn’t just turbulence that brought the plane down. somehow the pilot misjudged the timing of the flight and thought they were already in chile so he turned way too early and as a result ended up turning into a mountain. they were never in chile. they were still in argentina and if they went the opposite direction when they started walking they would’ve found civilization much sooner. it’s a heartbreaking story all around.

    • @BillyBinges
      @BillyBinges  Місяць тому

      Ohh wow 🤯. That is insane.

  • @loheirlyjean4568
    @loheirlyjean4568 Місяць тому +15

    If you want to watch another True story survival movie I would recommend
    #Bingers
    The 33 - Chilean mine rescue
    Or
    13 Lives - Thai Cave rescue of 13 school children and their Soccer Coach
    Love your energy by the way, currently in the Army National Guard myself so you motivate me to do and be better 👌🏾👏🏾

  • @MelissaK.
    @MelissaK. Місяць тому +4

    I remember learning about this story when I watched an earlier movie inspired by the crash, Alive (1993) as a young teenager. (I’m part of that smaller demographic you mentioned, born in 1978.) This film hits harder in so many ways. I can’t imagine the struggles these men went through in deciding to consume the body parts. If you haven’t already, look for some of the photos taken by the men. There’s a rather famous one showing 1+ backbone(s) next several grinning young men. The juxtaposition is jarring.

  • @areeeka8916
    @areeeka8916 Місяць тому +20

    Also, there are a few of the actual survivors in the movie! It's the closest, most accurate depiction of this very real tragedy. Carlos, one of the survivors, played his dad, the one who says "Carlos, my son" on the phone!

  • @janeqa9227
    @janeqa9227 Місяць тому +11

    I was eagerly awaiting your reaction to this movie.
    The man at 42:48 is one of the survivors of the plane crash. He was portraying his own father.

  • @macymurray12
    @macymurray12 Місяць тому +4

    I learned about this unfortunate accident in elementary school. Pulls on my brain and emotions every time

  • @AguedaG
    @AguedaG Місяць тому +4

    "Based on a book" it's not the same thing that "based on a novel". It is a real story.

  • @Uruguay23
    @Uruguay23 21 день тому +2

    Soy de URUGUAY.
    La "Tragedia de los Andes"... (así llamamos a este terrible accidente aéreo de 1972) fue muy doloroso y angustiante para todo mi país.
    Yo era estudiante Secundario y estando en clases de noche, nuestro profesor nos contó llorando que un sobrino suyo había caído ese día en el avión de la Fuerza Aérea Uruguaya que trasladaba a los rugbiers uruguayos del "Old Christians" a jugar a Chile!
    Fue el accidente aéreo más doloroso para los uruguayos!
    Todos los muertos mencionados en la película, y hasta lo que Debieron "COMER"... fue tal como ocurrió!.
    Y hasta ese señor a caballo, frente al río ( es un arriero chileno) fue REAL como sucedió esta tristísima historia!
    Greetings from URUGUAY!

  • @cristianstark9411
    @cristianstark9411 Місяць тому +9

    I really enjoyed your reaction, and also I realised that the English dub is totally on point transmitting the feelings, making it more relatable for English speakers 👌🏻👌🏻. Greetings from Chile!
    Knowing The Andes, (it's not just a mountain, is a mountain range 😅 hundreds of volcanoes, simply insane haha) I would survive a day maybe, if I'm lucky and without the plane crash 🤷🏻

  • @anthonyrivera6319
    @anthonyrivera6319 Місяць тому +1

    Billy I just got home from work and I didn't expect this video, but I am excited to watch this one. I've been waiting for a reaction! Keep it up man, love the videos

  • @manusilveira6218
    @manusilveira6218 Місяць тому +1

    An interesting information about this movie is the fact that they brought back some of the real survivors to make a cameo, like, the man who is saying all the survivors names, and pronnunced "Carlitos Miguel Paez, my son" is actually the real Carlito Miguel Paez. The real Nando Parrado showed up on the airport scene with his younger self version, as a family member. The doctor who received Roberto Canessa on the hospital, guiding him after they got rescued is the real Roberto Canessa, who became a doctor in real life. This was such a touching thing for the producers to make and to think about it. Such a shame that they didn't won the Oscar for Best Foreign film.

  • @avi9205
    @avi9205 Місяць тому +32

    Oooh u was hoping you'll watch it in spanish and use the subtitles ❤😢 anyway, great reaction

    • @BillyBinges
      @BillyBinges  Місяць тому +7

      Netflix automatically gave me this version. I didnt know until I started watching it was dubbed

  • @najhiahhall7080
    @najhiahhall7080 Місяць тому +4

    This is a devastating true story.i cried when i first watched it and even today it still gets me

  • @paulap.q.9843
    @paulap.q.9843 Місяць тому +4

    I'm so glad that you watched it, it's without a dobut my favourite film, i've watched it like 20 times. It is a powerful real story and yours it is the best reaction

  • @TT-Rex
    @TT-Rex Місяць тому +2

    Fun fact, the director actually hired Uruguayan actors, and consulted some of the survivors to ensure the film is accurate to the true story.

    • @ailem2707
      @ailem2707 Місяць тому +1

      He didn’t only consult the survivors, he got in contact with the victims families, so that every actor would know how the person they were playing was when they were alive (no matter how little screen time they ended up having)

  • @allthewayornowayy
    @allthewayornowayy Місяць тому +10

    omg billy i was hoping but never thought you would react to this! wish you watched in the original language but glad you reacted either way

  • @vivianamora7505
    @vivianamora7505 Місяць тому +4

    The most incredible movie I’ve watched this year. It should’ve won all the awards. Netflix also has a making of it, please react to that as well 😊

  • @y.u.n.gg_tellyy
    @y.u.n.gg_tellyy Місяць тому +16

    Super excited for this one!

  • @angelajaime5155
    @angelajaime5155 Місяць тому +6

    NNNOOOOOOOOOOOOO english dub :C
    I was so exited for you to watch it x''D
    But I'm glad you enjoyed it

  • @esmeflores1618
    @esmeflores1618 Місяць тому +2

    sooooo happy to see that people are reacting and watching this movie. When I watched it , it instantly became one of my favorite films of all time. This had me hooked from start to finish and I still think about it all the time.

  • @meryjey1507
    @meryjey1507 Місяць тому +5

    Just one thing please, watch any video that explains all details of the movie that director wanted to show and ypu missed, director did a great job telling the story as closest as possibl. There tooooooooo many lilttle thing that you would be amazed and then watch the movie on your own again. This movie made me feel so much different way. This movie is a masterpiece that will always be in me hearth

  • @briannapinkney4966
    @briannapinkney4966 Місяць тому +2

    No film has ever affected me as much as this one has. And a totally different experience watching it in Spanish

  • @nayelis8947
    @nayelis8947 Місяць тому +1

    I was scrolling on TikTok when my sister played this. I tried soooo hard not to look at the screen due to the fact that it was "based on true story". But I literally could not look away. Every scene after that crash had me glued to the screen and crying. As someone who always travels, I literally cannot get on plane without praying and thank God that the way I travel the turbulence is minimal and there's no icy mountains. This movie is a gem in itself and I wish those who survive have not died yet. Its truly amazing the story and how well portrayed it was

    • @ailem2707
      @ailem2707 Місяць тому +1

      About the survivors: all of them remained close, and get together at least once a year.
      Two of the survivors have passed away: Javier Methol (the eldest, whose wife Liliana died in the avalanche) in 2015, and José Luis “Coche” Inciarte (the one who started crying at the discussion about eating) in 2023.
      We know that at least the eldest and the youngest daughters of the Methols were involved in the film. The youngest said that it helped her build the image of the mother she never got to have, and they all cried when they saw the actress at the airport, because it really looked like her in her last pictures.
      And Coche was also heavily involved, had a cameo in the bar scene, got really close to the actor who plays him (Simón Hempe), and watched the movie twice, before the official release. There’s videos of him praising it and thanking the crew. His widow, Soledad González, says that being part of the movie kept him motivated during his last years.

  • @janelle6017
    @janelle6017 Місяць тому +8

    OMGGGG I’M actually shook, I don’t even know what to say 🤦🏾‍♀️

  • @Linsey009
    @Linsey009 Місяць тому +2

    love seeing more and more reactors watch this movie, definitely my favorite release of the last couple of years. i was familiar with this true story because i'd heard it on a true crime podcast so when i saw the previews for this movie i had to watch it and i'm so glad i did. immediately checked out the book and read it as well and it was incredible, can't wait to buy the hardback in english when it's released in june!
    i remember watching this for the first time and seeing day 30 something and i was like HOW LONG WERE THEY ON THAT MOUNTAIN, DAMN! i always love seeing at which point people ask that question. i think my mom asked on day 6 and i was like phew....just wait.
    i hate saying it like this but i appreciate that the "cannibalism" aspect was done, well....tastefully? like i feel like if it was american made they would have had blood splatter in that shot of the cousins cutting up the bodies but they were frozen so it's not necessary. i like that they shield the audience from it just like the cousins shielded their fellow friends from it and the meat that we see isn't very easily identifiable. idk just a lot of thought and care went into this movie to the most minute detail and i really appreciate it. a lot of this story is remembered as "the rugby players whose plane crashed and they ate their friends" and i hate that it's boiled down to that because it's just so much more than just that part of it and i think the movie does a good job at being honest about that part but not being weird about it, if that makes sense.

  • @BelenPeralta1
    @BelenPeralta1 Місяць тому +6

    Billy you should’ve watched it in Spanish and used subtitles it’s so much better 😭. I’ve never heard it in English, I also speak Spanish so there’s no reason to, but it’s just better. Movies are almost always better in their original languages

  • @areeeka8916
    @areeeka8916 Місяць тому +3

    def one of the best movies i've watched in a long time. im so glad you reacted to it!

  • @tedda14
    @tedda14 28 днів тому +1

    I remember as a kid picking up and dropping off my grandparents at the airport when they'd visit and walking right up to the gate. I was born in 1994, so I was very young when 9/11 happened but I have vivid memories from airports before and vivid memories of the day itself even tho I was just 6.
    I also remember reading a book about this crash when I was probably wayyyyy too young. like who was letting me read this shit at like 8? wowww
    ***Editing this comment to say I fasted (didn't eat) for 7 days when I was about 10-11. my family was very religious and fucked and my dad wanted me to lose weight and often starved or put me on diets so as a "cleanse" and religious experience and to please him I chose not to eat for a week. only water and herbal tea wt no sweeteners. it was awful I had no energy and all I thought about was food. starvation is one of the worst things.

  • @leslieoneal4464
    @leslieoneal4464 Місяць тому +1

    Being incapacitated in the hospital, I didn't eat anything by mouth for 2 months... BUT I had IV water/glucose so that's a bit different. I was at least staying hydrated and receiving nutrients.
    It's still VERY weird not taking in anything by mouth - not even ice chips or flavored swabs like they have now, and you DO get hungry regardless of the IV. Definitely wouldn't want to do that again!

  • @cristianv.6749
    @cristianv.6749 Місяць тому +1

    Born 1969! Although when I'm asked for my ID, people freak out cuz they think I am way younger. And yes I remember sitting at the gate with family and watching the planes take off. Loved it!

  • @agatone20
    @agatone20 Місяць тому +1

    Thanks for your great reaction brother. I grew up knowing about this story and has always been great inspiration to continue in the hard times.

  • @sarahwalton2662
    @sarahwalton2662 Місяць тому +1

    Billy, if you want to dive deeper into this amazing survival story there are some fantastic books. As well as Society of the Snow, there's Alive, and my absolute favourite written by Nando Parrado - Miracle in the Andes.
    In the Audiobook Nando reads sone of chapters. He tells a little about what each of the survivors ( who all meet up once a year) went on to do with their lives.
    All the survivors are amazing people - but for mw Nando is one of my living heroes. You can keep Marvel and DC... this is the type of real person who helps me to keep pushing forward when life gets tough.
    Much love to the Old Christians.

  • @belenbarrera2582
    @belenbarrera2582 Місяць тому +1

    One of the best reactions yet, idk if you whatched in english this is one of the most genuine reactions so far ❤

  • @aprilstrickland6950
    @aprilstrickland6950 Місяць тому +2

    "They smoking on the plane too. The 70s was wild.' 😂Right wtf!😅 There was no brace for impact from captain. #Bars "Just cuz you are wounded does Not mean you are useless." They used ice /snow as water for hydration. Yes based on a True Story!

  • @rowanjoy419
    @rowanjoy419 24 дні тому +3

    Wow, I usually watch your reactions because you are funny, so I was not expecting this reaction from you, you really put yourself in their shoes, I thank you for that, because I had seem some other reactions (am not going to say names) where people seem like for them this is just "another emotional movie".

  • @tiffanyphillips6086
    @tiffanyphillips6086 Місяць тому +2

    Well, I'm glad you watched it. I've been encouraging all my UA-cam's that I watch to watch it? Cause it's just an amazing film and it just touches you.

  • @degrios3768
    @degrios3768 Місяць тому +2

    This movie was phenomenal and heart breaking. I cried like a baby with the deaths but Numas especially.
    Not sure if you are or familiar with Catholic religion but Catholic faiths really only believe in burial services; body intact, not cremation, and is almost considered a sacrament. Which is why Numa, who was said to be a devote Catholic, would not eat the dead and was very against it. So he believed if he/they did eat the bodies the souls would not rest in peace. It was a very good argument on both sides. Robertos line, "and i dont have the right to do whatever it takes to survive!?" That sealed it for me.
    Great reaction as always!

  • @missgigglebox748
    @missgigglebox748 Місяць тому +1

    This was such a good movie and so heartbreaking. It was a long movie but when you sit down and watch it, it doesn't seem like it. Now Billy, I was born in 1974 and it was a fantastic time to grow up. Yes, I was a kid when you could actually walk your family and hang out with them at the airport and actually see their plane taxi down the runway. It was such a different time and Gen X are so happy to have been able to grow up when we did.

  • @lynnhettrick7588
    @lynnhettrick7588 Місяць тому +1

    5:07 Yep, before 9/11, we all could meet people at their gate, or wait with them until they got on the plane. 5:38 Smoking on a plane was a thing. I mostly remember that they had the smokers in the back of the plane and nonsmokers in the front of the plane, but with the air system, it really didn't matter. We were all getting second-hand smoke the whole flight. Same with restaurants. I remember when there were smoking and non-smoking sections. But often, you had to walk through the smoking section to get to the non-smoking section. Or my dad would tell the hostess to seat us in whichever section had a table first because he was so impatient to wait for non-smoking. But I'm allergic to tobacco/tobacco smoke. Cigar smoke made (make) me throw up. Cigarettes made (make) me cough nonstop and feel sick to my stomach.

  • @maggiojeda8311
    @maggiojeda8311 Місяць тому +1

    Such an amazing story! I'm still thinking about it! Great reaction!!👏👏👏

  • @yomarysanchez6263
    @yomarysanchez6263 Місяць тому +2

    Their voices in Spanish give the movie more of an authentic feel of the real story. The 1993 version was all American actors and obviously didn’t act as how Uruguayans ppl speak and mannerism .

  • @evakrupickova8937
    @evakrupickova8937 Місяць тому +5

    I think you don't know exactly what to do anyway. Until you are in the same situation….

  • @manuellunaurquizo8663
    @manuellunaurquizo8663 Місяць тому +2

    it not easy to try to leave ANDES in FRIST 3 hours. They live in no more than 100 meter over sea level. So cant walk overt snow (More than 3500 over sea level ) easily also the snow blinds you and try to sleep out site with no equipment its suicide.

  • @princesadelaos
    @princesadelaos Місяць тому +2

    there's always turbulence while going through the andes, it's scary. this was a smaller plane that couldnt fly too high that's why they had too find lower pass but the pilot turned north too early

    • @ailem2707
      @ailem2707 Місяць тому +1

      The plane was originally meant to fly over the Andes, in the route feom Mendonza to Santiago (as it had done the year before), the reason why they went through that pass was because of the bad weather.

  • @stacycalvo
    @stacycalvo Місяць тому +12

    #Bingers: Saw 6, Cruella and Zoolander and Zoolander 2, Party Central, Sharpay Fabulous Adventure and Legally Blondes 2 and An Extremely Goofy Movie and Brother Bear 2 and Beetlejuice and Edward Scissorshands, Cars Trilogy and Kung Fu Panda Trilogy and The Simpsons Movie, The Great Mouse Detective and The Addams Family, The Addams Family Values

    • @_katsuki.bakugo_
      @_katsuki.bakugo_ Місяць тому +2

      I think he said he was finishing the saw series for a while

    • @stacycalvo
      @stacycalvo Місяць тому +2

      @_katsuki.bakugo_ I didn't know that and thank you for the head up

    • @jebVlogs556
      @jebVlogs556 Місяць тому +2

      only ten i am watching cause ive seen all these listed: the fog, evil clown, krampus, crooked man, winnie the pooh blood and bone, shehulk,cookies fortune, driving mrs daisy, and than there were none.😅

    • @_katsuki.bakugo_
      @_katsuki.bakugo_ Місяць тому +1

      @@stacycalvo yw 😊

    • @_katsuki.bakugo_
      @_katsuki.bakugo_ Місяць тому +1

      @@stacycalvo I think he said later in October of something

  • @silvanamezzano7496
    @silvanamezzano7496 Місяць тому +7

    NOOOOOOO IT HAD TO BE IN SPANISH BILLY TF

  • @luciaarnaotorrego6852
    @luciaarnaotorrego6852 Місяць тому +3

    If you have the chance you should rewatch it in spanish, the acting was extraordinary

  • @jenm393
    @jenm393 Місяць тому +1

    I could only get through half the movie when I initially wanted to watch. I was FLOORED by the cinematography and extremes these characters (and after I searched up the true stories) and human beings went through. It was so brutal and hauntingly beautifully well done in a film aspect.

  • @yessysroses
    @yessysroses Місяць тому +1

    What a awesome surprise to see you react to this! Thank you sm!

  • @Akkaylyn
    @Akkaylyn Місяць тому +1

    I’m so glad you enjoyed this movie, it’s an absolutely insane story and I think this movie told it so well

  • @aprilstrickland6950
    @aprilstrickland6950 Місяць тому +1

    They always was lighting a cigarette like I'm needed that to cook my meat. 15 survivers out of 43 -47 for over 3 months. They banned together for their needs and well of the well being of others. The resourcefulness outstanding to survive.

  • @mickeymay_mua3998
    @mickeymay_mua3998 Місяць тому +3

    Such a heart breaking movie! You should watch the show Yellowjackets , it’s based off this event but with a girls soccer team

  • @bubblegumbaby8
    @bubblegumbaby8 Місяць тому +2

    In all honesty I wouldn’t have been able to survive for 3 days bcz of the fact I’m epileptic so I take medicine everyday and i can’t go 2 days without it or ima have a seizure and it just makes me think I’m so glad none of them had a disability that I know of because that would’ve been so much harder to deal with while in this situation as hard as it is already. Unless my medicine would miraculously still be there I’m toast 😂

  • @KellyKels23
    @KellyKels23 Місяць тому +1

    I'm not that much older than you (37) & I remember being able to walk straight up to the gate with family members and wait with them until they board THEN say our goodbyes. Definitely a different time.
    This movie isn't my cup of tea, but I'm usually more interested in the documentaries of true events than the movies. Either way, much respect to everyone who lost their lives & fought to make it out of there. Im confident after a few days, i just wouldve given up.

  • @AJ-qi6zc
    @AJ-qi6zc Місяць тому +2

    About your question : I'm anorexic so once or twice in the past I've lasted about a week without food. It's horrible, 0/10 do not recommend.