Under a community post, a commenter pointed out that the verse focuses too much on the guilt and regret of the believer, and not on the harm they would've caused to their victim. I think that's a brilliant point but I had already recorded the video before I saw that comment! It may be because the author puts more weight on the believer's feelings, or it may be because he is used to preaching using guilt. It's impossible to know.
@@alonzoharris9049Ah it's the moron who thinks god is necessarily omnipotent (without understanding omnipotence). Anyway, I don't think Aladdin is doing that at all. Nor do I think Alonzo Harris is your name. More like Julio Abdulio
@@alonzoharris9049yes, the whole justice system focuses on that. Making people feel guilt helps and help tremendously because people are selfish by nature. Only a few get their stuff correct from intellectual discourse. I see this as a divine mark instead of what you said.
I love how you deconstruct verses like this. As Muslims, we approached the Qur'an with reverence and read it as an act of devotion. If we did ask questions, it was only to seek justifications to confirm our biases. It is almost impossible for a believer to step outside that mindset. But when one is able to do that, one cannot fail to see how flawed and imperfect the Qur'an really is. Inextricably tied to its time, context and fallible human author.
You don’t even believe in perfection. Both of you are incoherent. You don’t even believe that god exists. You are arguing in bad faith. That’s why this Zorro tries to appeal to emotions. He even thinks it’s absurd for the state to use force on people who don’t pay taxes. He calls your western government the mafia for collecting taxes by law.🥴🤣
@@moizkayani8790 then that means he is lacking in many ways.. I don't see how special then u find him to be.. Even if it were the case it doesn't make excuse any of his action or character, it makes it just as a worse
@@hirwacorso2079 Well God made this world imperfect. Nothing is perfect except for him. So he is dealing according to this world. Their are many verses that are not to follow now but are present in Quran. Allah has given us the commands of world and it is us who caused the mishap here. So One verse if says stay in peace doesn't mean that we can't defend ourselves. And also Islam doesn't allow a person inner self end. Because we have believe in philosophy of self. A man should learn independently and he is free to interpret things in his own ways. That is what our Sufi Mystics follow. He is just telling personal views of how should it be. But someone else may find it perfect. But the main thing is message which is clear..... Also if God made one thing that even he can't perfect anymore will mean that he does not have infinite wisdom which is our believe
In the Quran , It is essential to differentiate between the earlier "Medina verses " ( when Mohammed was aspiring to get acceptance for his new religion ) and the latter "Makkah verses" ( when Mohammed had already consolidated his,absolute authority) . The "Medina verses ", therefore, are more conciliatory and tolerant towards " disbelievers " and the ",Makkah verses " absolutely intolerant and aggressive. It is the earlier " Medina verses " that Islamic, apologists often quote as " evidence " of Islam's," peaceful " and "tolerant " nature .
In order to justify the truth about Islam that the scholars hide, you can have no empathy for human beings. I tried to get rid of my empathy to stay Muslim but the cognitive dissonance was killing me. I felt like a hypocrite. So to me it was better to leave and make it known then to stay in because if Islam is true the punishment for a munafiq is even worse than a non believer. That’s a different pascals wager.😂😂😂
@@user-bq8mw7rr6j Do they already know, that Tel Aviv University in Israel and basically all archaeologists of today already agree, that Moses and Abraham were invented? If they want to be safe, they need to add Zeus again, because the evidence for him would still be better now than for Moses and the Iliad has never been corrupted. 😂
I'm sick of the translations, they translated Fasiq (wicked) as "disobedient". They've done that to make it less scary to non-Arabic-speaking people. Thank you for the video. Subscribed. BTW, you pronounce Arabic so well, is it your native language? Asking because, I've seen so many people telling me to go learn Arabic if I really want to understand Quran even though I can read it and most of the words from the Quran found place in my own language. But having someone who speaks Arabic debunk it is cool.
Yes, Arabic is his first language, by the way most Muslims don't speak Arabic, like the majority of people, if your book and religion is dependant on understanding a language, then that isn't a religion worth your time.
The Classical Arabic dictionaries all support disobedient. You are not the criteria of the Classical Arabic dictionary. You are a dishonest person. Even non Muslim translators refute you. I guess everyone is in involved in your conspiracy of hiding meanings.🥴🤣 The language of the Quran from the seventh century doesn’t have to confirm to modern meanings of words in daily use. Stop being dishonest and accusing people. You have no shame?
They also straight up forced a semantic change on a word xD Dharra (mosquito, ant, iota) today translates as atom and also means atom (very recent dictionary change, like 19th century) to make it seem like the Quran talks about subatomic particles
From Umdat as-Salik re "fasiq" o24.3 (A:) Meaning of a corrupt person (fasiq) (N: hadiths of both types being obligatory for a Muslim to believe in, though someone who denies them is merely considered corrupt (fasiq), not an unbeliever (kafir)) (A: A legally corrupt or immoral person (fasiq) is someone guilty of (1) or (2) above.) "It is not permissible to seek out dispensations [A: meaning it is unlawful, and the person who does is corrupt (fasiq)], and Allah knows best"
Best channel on UA-cam, brave man you are. It’s very hard for me knowing I am safe in the US, yet seeing comments from people in Libya and other places knowing the danger they are in, for something I take for granted.
@@optimus-prime703take courage you are extremely courageous! We love you! My the lord help you out that place I will pray tonight deeply for you and others people who are in the same situation
I love this so much! This video is perfection. Once you think critically and understand the meaning of the hypnotic rhyming sounds, they are quite repetitive and disjointed in theme, and far from perfection. I can’t wait for your next video!
Thank you! Looking forward to publishing it I love how someone immediately pointed out my spelling mistake at 0:48, ironically proving that even this video is imperfect 😂
I suggest you pick up the quran and read for yourself and understand, instead of listening and following some ignorant person on the internet who don't even understand basic Arabic.
"Truth is in the details" - yes. This applies to so many areas of our lives as well. We naturally prefer simple, generalized, black-and-white concepts, but they rarely can convey the whole truth of the matter. I like your thorough, investigative approach. Personally, I think that posting less often isn't a bad thing if it means you have more time to prepare, and don't forget to take some time for yourself as well!
I suggest you pick up the quran and read for yourself and understand, instead of listening and following some ignorant person on the internet who don't even understand basic Arabic.
I suggest you pick up the quran and read for yourself and understand, instead of listening and following some ignorant person on the internet who don't even understand basic Arabic.
@@muhammadkijera76 What about the millions of people that don't speak arabic? allah chooses them not to understand the quran? This alone is laughable : allah's scientific miracle MISTAKE AND IT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH LANGUAGE! allah thinks milk is made in a cow's Belly (stomach) Q16:66 - And there is certainly a lesson for you in cattle: We give you to drink of what is in their bellies, from between digested food and blood: pure milk, pleasant to drink. MILK IS 100% NOT MADE IN THE BELLY/STOMACH OF THE COW, NOR IS MILK IN THE BELLY/STOMACH OF A COW.. allah is 100% FALSE, quran is 100% FALSE, mahamed is 100% FALSE
I suggest you pick up the quran and read for yourself and understand, instead of listening and following some ignorant person on the internet who don't even understand basic Arabic.
@@muhammadkijera76 how can Apostate Aladdin not even know Basic Arabic when he himself is an Arab? Also the Information he tells us is a direct reference from the Noble Quran & the Sahih Hadith of the Prophet (police be upon him) but either way, You're right. They should've picked the Quran up & later on confirm that Apostate Aladdin's words are the truth.🏴☝️💥
I love the content you put out on your channel. Your videos are highly weighted and it is clear you put in a lot of time and effort to putting the information together. I would really like to see a conversation about Islam and god between yourself and Mufti Abu layth. Thanks again for another brilliant video.
There are over 300 references in the Koran to Allah and fear, there are only 49 references to love. Of these love references, 39 are negative such as the 14 negative references to love of money, power, other gods and status. Three verses command humanity to love Allah and only 2 verses are about how Allah loves a believer. There are 25 verses about how Allah does not love kafirs (unbelievers; the worst of all creature). This leaves only 5 verses about love in the entire book. Of these 5, 3 are about loving kin or a ‘Muslim brother’ (ignored on a daily basis). One verse commands a Muslim to give for the love of Allah. This leaves only one quasi-universal verse about love: give what you love to charity and even this is contaminated by dualism since the requisite Muslim charity only goes to other Muslims. So, love your fellow man = NONE! Nearly 500 verses (one out of every twelve) in the entire Qur'an speak of hell and over 400 speak negatively and encourage hatred or dislike of Jews, Christians, Idolaters and non muslims in general. One line in every five lines in the Quran is incomprehensible, even to Islamic scholars! What a god, what a prophet, what a book!
@@MrBjoern91 I and my 60 years research are the source. But this might help you. Ref: Bill Warner - LOVE VERSUS FEAR IN THE KORAN: A STATISTICAL ANALYSIS AND REFORM ACCORDING TO GOLDEN RULE
@@venenareligioest410 thanks. I can't really find that book though. Only vague references to it are available online it seems. Do you have any idea where to find more info on it? Sorry to bother you, it just seemed so interesting what you commented
I know you are ignorant about the Quran, I can see what you are doing is copy and patsting. Anyways, Quran has 114 Chapters, and each chapter start with, "In the name of Allah the most gracious the most merciful" It cant get any better than that. you are soo much obsessed with Love, but is this not the reason why the western world is falling apart, in the name of "LOVE"?
@@muhammadkijera76 If you don't know that the quran shows hate, rage, threats and violence then you are the one that is truly ignorant. Especially, the hatred toward women. It's just terrible what this religion shows and the examples of mahamed (POLICE BE UPON HIM) were the worst in history in my opinion. Just gross. It's so easy to see.
one thing I would love to see you make a video on is how muslims are knowingly harming their child by raising them muslim. the line of no compulsion in religion only applies if the person isn’t muslim already. so if parents raise their kids muslim, they must either stay muslim by force, or get executed by the state or fake their muslim status till death. when a parent chooses to raise their kid muslim there is no way out ever. at least if the parents raise their kids as non muslim they won’t be forced with the muslim identity. this also applies in other countries where people have christian laws applied to them and can change to the islamic law but if someone is born into islamic law they can’t change that
That's the point though. Raising your kids Muslim and making sure they stay that way after they grow up (beatings are prescribed). Making sure they marry a Muslim spouse and give birth to more Muslims (arranged marriage culture, interfaith marriages are borderline impossible or discouraged). There is no element of choice in Islam. This is something Christians and Westerners will never realize.
If a holy book from the 7th century had a checksum after each line to prevent corruption, I might believe it. It's not superhuman, not supernatural, it's something we can easily do today and just about possible even back then but it would have been impressive for that period in history.
The advice in the Qur'an is indeed a gem of wisdom - verify your sources for truth. That obviously includes the moral character and capacity of the person conveying the information. That's good advice for anybody anywhere and a safeguard against bad judgement of a situation. Sensible people do this everyday! The fact that you question this shows your own bias and desperate need for self-justification.
If the point of the verse was "verify all sources for truth" then the Quran could have simply said those exact words - it doesn't. It wouldn't contain the word Fasiq. Alladin also clearly explains that this verse doesn't talk about verifying information from sources that you trust implicitly and it's a reach to say that it does. It does not "obviously" mean too assess the moral character and capacity, because the verse defines the moral character for us, ie wicked or disobedient. Further, Alladin isn't questioning the wisdom of verifying your sources for truth, he is questioning how the message is conveyed in the Quran, so you are just using a straw man. The ultimate point of the video is to show how the Quran could be improved. It could be improved by simply stating 'when any person comes to you with information, verify it to avoid harm', but again, it doesn't. This is a common theme among all religious scriptures.
@@hoz1711_ This verse warns the believers against trusting information from a "fasiq" (deceitful, duplicitous, untrustworthy person). Checking the source is the first principle of verification. It's the perfect advice which cannot be improved. That's why no one should trust someone who hides behind a mask and uses a name like "Alladin".
@@AnalyseThat you’ve just moved the goalposts from what your originally said. You initially state the verse includes the “obvious” directions to assess moral character, now you’re actually agreeing with Alladin in saying the verse only applies to a Fasiq! Which still doesn’t address any of the arguments made in the video - does the verse or any other verse, tell us what to do when a believer or trustworthy person spreads harmful misinformation by accident? If it did, the verse would be clearer and speak to a wider variety of situations, and thus improved. Good advice does not necessarily equal complete advice. The verse provides partially good advice, at best. Ps, You call people out for having a bias, when your arguments are either 1) a strawman or 2) different from the first argument you made 3) calling out a persons youtube handle or for wearing a mask.
@@hoz1711_ Perhaps it's worth pointing out that the guidance of the Qur'an is only for the believers; unbelievers, on the other hand, are expected to be misguided by the same because they are among the "fasiq". It's like a mental person trying to diagnose their own issues - it can't be done.
So strange that so many quran verses sound like Muhammad talking. (49:4) Surely most of those who call out to you, (O Prophet), from behind the apartments, are devoid of understanding. (49:5) If they were patient until you went out to them, that would have been better for them. Allah is super clever and smart yardiyarda.
@@ApostateAladdinby the way Bible is the ordained word of God. Every scripture is written through inspiration received from the Spirit of God. Your discovery of fake Muhammad and Allah does not mean that God of Christians is also fake. There is a Creator and you well know it. And there is only ONE WAY HE ordained to get to HIM.
@@Al-Muzil both of them have the same name, but the quran means it literally as if he got confused bc the sister of moses and the mother of Jesus have the name. Sister in faith is a reach, considering she's supposed to follow David has the zabur until Jesus gets his gospel and starts his "prophetic mission". She can't be moses sister in faith, Jews would rather say they are his followers, not companions like the muhammed sees his first followers.
6:32 “the benefit of the doubt” & “cutting him some slack” my ass, you brought that point home brotha! 😂😂😂 I just LOVE THIS .. taking a verse .. a story or a Hadith and bashing it down!! .. keep it up!! ✨✨
Thank you for all your efforts. I just had a thought, what if moham could use social media today? What would those tweets look like and tiktok posts ?? Dude
"Life gets busy, and there's a lot to know." I love that. Sometimes I feel a pressure, entirely self-imposed, to get on the level of this or that historian or science communicator in whichever video I'm watching. Which is absurd. No one is even halfway decent on every subject. It's okay to not know something. All any of us can do is learn. Point being, I find that quote reassuring.
You videos are absolutely top notch. Haven't seen such analysis of Islam in a long time. This channel deserves more subscribers. By the way i have a topic that is worth of making a video. 'Parallels Between the Qur'an and Late Antique Judeo-Christian Literature' There's a fantastic article from wiki Islam on this topic but i think it should be put on video format. Do consider
A perfect guidebook (ethics from god; objective morality) presupposes a perfect understanding (god). How does a perfect idea be translated into language and interpreted by human minds? There are so many people, with many perspectives, and complex changes in culture over time, how can these complex subjective experiences be united by the perfect idea? God’s perfect idea for imperfect humans. This ideology is circular in logic (why is the idea perfect? Because it comes from the perfect god who creates perfect ideas). How do we define and measure imperfection and perfection, and to what degree are humans able to comprehend god? Is perfection a human construct? A claim of perfection is paralyzing or stagnating. To prove perfection we need to comprehend perfection (how to prove something unknown?). So, how to live without a perfect guide? Use the imperfect knowable guide that is our current understanding of things.
wow these stories of muhammad almost attacking a tribe over a misunderstanding should really be emphasized when some muslims try to make excuses for him actually attacking other tribes, claiming they all including children were evil and somehow betrayed him and deserved death or slavery... who knows how it actually was
You claim that the Quran is eternal and uncreated and unchanged, so how could it be uncreated if abrogation is part of the doctrine ??? Wouldn’t the great allah have brought an ( finished ) Quran without abrogation?? The Quran was revealed to Muhammad and some verses were abrogated during his life time! Did the great Allah changed his toughts within and in few years?? If so, then clearly the eternal Quran doesn’t exist! God is perfect and all knowledgeable he wouldn’t change his mind like unsure , insecure human beings!!! Impossible!
@venenareligioest that book “Quran” cannot be eternal, unchanging and unchangable. The Muslims scholars just CREATED a verse in this Quran that gives Allah @ Jibril @ Muhammad and NOW Muslim Scholars the right to abrogate the verses in the Quran. I wonder who is hearing from Jibril now that Muhammad is dead. With the death of Muhammad, Jibril is also dead. And Muslims scholars are taking over the throne.
@@alonzoharris9049 you Muslims are the least qualified to talk about logic. When it comes to religion where one seek to live right before God, do you follow a man who is clearly corrupted? Unsound mind? Depressed and Suicidal? Before you go any further to speak to others or condemn them, answer this question truthfully.
@@alonzoharris9049 Why NOT because the quran actually shows that it has changed right in Scripture. It's been bastardized to death and the scriptures even can prove that. Did allah reveal his TORAH or was it written??
Thanks for the interesting and well researched videos Aladdin. Could you do a video on the ‘scientific miracles’ soon as someone who is studying science Im very tired of the misinformation.
@@substance-1 Not really, both detail supremacist ideologies. The only difference is that one is somehow more socially acceptable than the other due to the sheer number of people who are brainwashed into it.
It’s so disturbing to here these stories about Mohammed while all along growing up I was taught the opposite, in the same breath why would the imams discuss these topics. And one last thing a language arabic that 99.99999 do not understand who I grew up with.
Perhaps lost in translation, so please if someone in the chat knows respond. The passage to me (english speaking, North American, ex-christian) sounded more like "Investigate even IF you think they are wicked, because they might still be right. " Or entertain the words of even the least trustworthy as you don't want to regret your own biases later. Obviously not the accepted take on this so I may have lost something.
How did you miss this? [17:36] You shall not accept any information, unless you verify it for yourself. I have given you the hearing, the eyesight, and the brain, and you are responsible for using them.
The many wildly different explanations for this verse and many others in the exegesis almost make me feel like the people who wrote the exegesis had no clue what the verses were really talking about and instead they just winged it and made up the explanations as they went!
So good to see you post again, Aladdin Hope you're doing well :3 I saw today that Jubilee is planning one of their middle ground episodes between Muslims and exmuslims It's supposed to take place on the 16th or 18th of August and I thought I'd let you know You're definitely one of the exmuslims that I'd be happy to have represent us and if you won't be able to partake in it, I hope you'll be able to let other exmuslim content creators know about this Stay safe and have a great day
5:00 "if there comes to you information double check it" LOL how in your mind do you imagine this improves the verse? so any information including from people you trust your going to double check? thats called being paranoid . the Quran is right you should double check information that come from enemies not information that comes from people you trust. this is also used by historians who also mistrust negative information given by enemies of a group
No. It's necessary fight this evil ideology of Muhammad which teaches death penalty for those who leave Islam. Reference: SAHIH BUKHARI 6922 Narrated `Ikrima: Some Zanadiqa (atheists) were brought to `Ali and he burnt them. The news of this event, reached Ibn `Abbas who said, "If I had been in his place, I would not have burnt them, as Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) forbade it, saying, 'Do not punish anybody with Allah's punishment (fire).' I would have killed them according to the statement of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ), 'Whoever changed his Islamic religion, then kill him.'"
I'm binge-watching your videos and I only have one question that will refute everything you're trying to prove!!!!!! Why is your cat always sleeping in the background ? hhh he's so cute sleeping there peacefully while you're actively mercilessly destroying people's beliefs. I love your videos, and I love them even more because of that little fluff ball
The Quran was not the focus of the universe, like believers claim. Many people simply didn't care to get involved in "debunking" it. And many have but either faced backlash or weren't recorded by Muslim scholars
I’d argue that, from the islamic perspective, your improvement upon the verse might not apply. First of all, let’s suppose the news/نبأ being referenced was that of disobediance to Allah, which, from the islamic perspective, is incorrect and reprehensible. The point of this verse could be “when there is a possibility of someone being disobedient, make sure first that the disobedience occurred.” Most people, however, have difficulty ascertaining whether or not a situation is certain, and jump to certainty and blame prematurely. The use of the word فاسق then could more closely mirror the person’s conception of the situation and help the verse come to mind more immediately, giving it greater applicability.
I wish i could watch more of these videos..they are truly brilliant and well worth watching your videos. Do you think you ttne quran would be as memorizable if the author made thr changes you suggest
Quran : The example of those who disbelieve is like that of one who shouts at what hears nothing but calls and cries cattle or sheep - deaf, dumb and blind, so they do not understand. CH: 2/171 (21:42) Tell them, (O Muhammad): "Who protects you, during the night or the day from the Most Compassionate Lord?"43 And yet they turn away from the Admonition of their Lord. (21:43) - Quran always get it right :)
peepeepoopoo Quran is nothing but Mohammed ranting to himself and reassuring himself. There is not a single verse dedicated to compassion for your fellow man, nothing to comfort a man in pain, nothing spiritual. Just ramblings of Mohammed about his domestic issues.
Thank you Aladdin, as always the video was insightful, thought provoking and made me view the verse from a few different angles. And no need to apologise for doing a video every couple of weeks, quality is always more important than quantity with this sort of content
I once asked a Muslim friend of mine about missing contexts and explanations in the Qur'an, becuause to me they invalidate the "perfection"-claim. He said that we should not expect perfect contextualizations and explanations of the verses in the Qur'an, because "life is a trial", and it would not be a trial if everything was served on a silver tray. What do you make of this? Because frankly I do not know how to answer or counter that directly, the only way out beeing to adress the claim that life is a trial.
Your definition of perfection is illogical. Your position is that a human being can only be perfect if there was no free will. That’s basically what you are trying to say.
@@alonzoharris9049 like @marcocapelli7929 already said, you and logic are on two opposite sides. First off, you're putting words in ops "mouth?" He never said anything about free will. If god is unchanging and his words are not perfect then that should be clear that he's not perfect. If I have insight into the future and I'm a god, I should be able to get everything right in the first try. I don't need to test you if I already know what you're going to do, that's stupid.
@@alonzoharris9049 Thank you for your response. I can see why you might think that is the case. However, even if the Qur'an was perfectly explained, humans could still theoretically refuse to believe, so free will is not impaired.
Hello from New Zealand, AA 👋. Though I’m a staunch Christian I want to study the Quran to better understand Islam. Which version do you recommend I start with? Thanks so much for the info you’ve shared so far 🙏
What an interesting way for a non-muslim to learn about this religion. I will not bother to share my one and only and very, brief experience with the Quran myself. Warmest Wishes. Out For Now.
I keep getting ads to donate to a mosque in Sam Antonio on your vids. Fucking annoying! Hoping the algorithm starts learning the difference between Moose and Ex-Muslim content.
Aladdin, you're missing (or forgetting) some essentials about the Quran. Consider the audience of the Quran, and if you're not sure who it is, reread the first and second chapter, especially the first one, really carefully. As a hint, who are the "maghdoobi 3alayhim," and what is their relationship with the "fasiqeen"? Also consider the audience of this verse, those who are already believers. To a believer, it is a clear that a fasiq is a nonbeliever, and furthermore, one who is known to be a causer of harm. When in times of tension and anxiety and uncertainty (as the Muslims were in Medina), it is typical (from an emotional standpoint) to be more receptive to information which promotes distrust of another people. By mentioning the word fasiq, the verse reminds the believers who these people who create distrust really are-disbelieving people who do not operate by the same standards expected of a believer, so extra scrutiny is necessary. This may seem obvious, but many ideas in isolation may seem obvious, whereas the collection of a consistent set of these "obvious" ideas (Quran as a whole) is much less trivial. Additionally, the Quran is a book in which every grammatically viable interpretation of any one verse is sound and accepted. An alternative understanding is that the "qawm" are a people which are with the disbelievers, so Allah swt asks the Muslims to be careful of hurting even the disbelievers if the source very well may be hearsay-yes not all wars/attacks taken were defensive, but the understanding is that offensive wars are to be avoided except for sound reasoning. In your comment, you mention that the emphasis of the verse is to alleviate guilt from the believer rather than harm to others. Of course, the goal of a Muslim is to attain heaven, and this is something each Muslim is individually accountable for. It may sound harsh, but in a way, doing any favor for others is doing a favor for yourself-the ultimate goal is inherently selfish. Even if helping another just makes you happy or content, that's still a positive feeling that you seek for yourself. So at the end of the day, yes, the implications of your actions to yourself are what is most important, there is no mistake there.
*One who is known to be a causer of harm.* I am curious. Who are they, these known to be a causer of harm? For example, suicide bombers do not consider themselves to be evil. They believe that the Qur'an is the literal word of God, and prophet Muhammad is the last prophet. In my opinion, Islam (much like other religion) teaches some (not all) terrible morals. These vague words like "wicked" or "know to be causer of harm" are used to justify horrible morality. Are Apostates "causer of harm?" What about gays? What about slave owners? What qualifies someone as a causer of harm?
The Muslims scholars CREATED a verse in this Quran that gives Allah @ Jibril @ Muhammad and NOW Muslim Scholars the right to abrogate the verses in the Quran. I wonder who is hearing from Jibril now that Muhammad is dead. But with the death of Muhammad, it is assumed Jibril is also dead. And Muslims scholars are taking over the throne.
@@markorbit4752 If you believe that Vishnu is the one who created you. God says He created man in His likeness an image. Now, do you look like a woman and have 4 hands as Vishnu? God bless you with wisdom!
@@huios974 Well, if god created me in his/its image, then what an awful god he/it must be. I have serious back pain, my beard grows into my skin and causes all these inflamed bumps every week, My left hand craps all the time and i can´t use it. If i look like god, what a miserable, grumpy creature he must be.
The verse calls attention to credibility as a hallmark of good sources for taking information ,specifically and to confirm the accuracy of information generally.
you said there are proofs that the quran is changed by the prophets followers if you want to say stuff like this in ur intro kindly give a backup statement and to ur pinned comment i think the quran won then?
Allah seems to be able to deliver miracles at the drop of hat but in the critical matter of his eternal book why did he refrain from sending his perfect book complete - written on exquisite parchment and made by a pen dipped in liquid gold , gradually descending to earth in a blaze of glory to an expectant multitude? Instead we have an incredibly flawed and confusing process - bits written on palm leaves and bones, sections memorized and with many variants and parts lost and we have to have a murderous autocrat in the person of caliph Uthman to create a final recension and then all the evidence of past variants burnt? I'm well aware that the Koran itself tries to answer this objection but it would try to do that wouldn't it?
She was certainly in it, but in Islam she had to wear so much thick clothing that no one would recognize her anymore as a woman and people mistook her for a jinn. That's also why the quran talks so much nonsense about jinns.
someone who tells or shares misinformation is himself the wicked person. as simple as that. and if you can, try making a verse of your own. see if it even comes close with the verses of quran and plz don't copy.
During an interview with Angelika Neuwirth, the distinguished Professor of Qur’anic studies, she argued that the Qur’an has never been successfully challenged by anyone, past or present: "No one has succeeded, this is right… I really think that the Qur’an has even brought Western researchers embarrassment, who were not able to clarify how suddenly in an environment where there were not any appreciable written text, appeared the Qur’an with its richness of ideas and its magnificent wordings."
LOL! Neuwirth doesn't teach that the Quran was divine or revealed by a god, but that it originated from christian and jewish debates in late antiquity.
Under a community post, a commenter pointed out that the verse focuses too much on the guilt and regret of the believer, and not on the harm they would've caused to their victim. I think that's a brilliant point but I had already recorded the video before I saw that comment!
It may be because the author puts more weight on the believer's feelings, or it may be because he is used to preaching using guilt. It's impossible to know.
That’s such an intellectual argument.
Trying to appeal to emotions are such good arguments.🥴🤣
@@alonzoharris9049Ah it's the moron who thinks god is necessarily omnipotent (without understanding omnipotence).
Anyway, I don't think Aladdin is doing that at all.
Nor do I think Alonzo Harris is your name. More like Julio Abdulio
@@alonzoharris9049yes, the whole justice system focuses on that. Making people feel guilt helps and help tremendously because people are selfish by nature. Only a few get their stuff correct from intellectual discourse.
I see this as a divine mark instead of what you said.
@@alonzoharris9049 i think we all have a choice of doing right and wrong? where doest that come from?
@@nhdnhd6710
I was being sarcastic. His arguments are all fallacies.
He tries to present himself as a rational person lol.
I love how you deconstruct verses like this. As Muslims, we approached the Qur'an with reverence and read it as an act of devotion. If we did ask questions, it was only to seek justifications to confirm our biases. It is almost impossible for a believer to step outside that mindset. But when one is able to do that, one cannot fail to see how flawed and imperfect the Qur'an really is. Inextricably tied to its time, context and fallible human author.
You don’t even believe in perfection.
Both of you are incoherent.
You don’t even believe that god exists.
You are arguing in bad faith.
That’s why this Zorro tries to appeal to emotions.
He even thinks it’s absurd for the state to use force on people who don’t pay taxes. He calls your western government the mafia for collecting taxes by law.🥴🤣
I wish you would make videos again!
Spot on, written with clarity and eloquence and highly relatable to those who have left Islam
I have read your article about this verse like a month ago and it was great... as always
Make videos again please!!!!!!!❤
"If there is room for improvement then it's imperfect hence not from god ".. On point 👌
I like how it's not even his criteria, but the very one muslims use. "The Quran is complete". Kekw
God is not bounded to a level of perfection, so he can always improve.
@@moizkayani8790 then that means he is lacking in many ways.. I don't see how special then u find him to be.. Even if it were the case it doesn't make excuse any of his action or character, it makes it just as a worse
@@hirwacorso2079 Well God made this world imperfect. Nothing is perfect except for him. So he is dealing according to this world.
Their are many verses that are not to follow now but are present in Quran.
Allah has given us the commands of world and it is us who caused the mishap here.
So One verse if says stay in peace doesn't mean that we can't defend ourselves.
And also Islam doesn't allow a person inner self end. Because we have believe in philosophy of self.
A man should learn independently and he is free to interpret things in his own ways. That is what our Sufi Mystics follow.
He is just telling personal views of how should it be.
But someone else may find it perfect. But the main thing is message which is clear.....
Also if God made one thing that even he can't perfect anymore will mean that he does not have infinite wisdom which is our believe
@@moizkayani8790 so he is not omniscient?
In the Quran , It is essential to differentiate between the earlier "Medina verses " ( when Mohammed was aspiring to get acceptance for his new religion ) and the latter "Makkah verses" ( when Mohammed had already consolidated his,absolute authority) . The "Medina verses ", therefore, are more conciliatory and tolerant towards " disbelievers " and the ",Makkah verses " absolutely intolerant and aggressive. It is the earlier " Medina verses " that Islamic, apologists often quote as " evidence " of Islam's," peaceful " and "tolerant " nature .
@substance-1the fact of there even being the concept of abrogation SHOWS that this book is not divine.
Other way around dude
@@pandawandas You are right ! That was a lapse on my part !
Dumb comment Quran was always peaceful.
In Malaysia, it’s near to impossible to ask questions.
Hello bro, Selamat Pagi. Bro, can I intro to you Council of ExMuslims of Singapore (CEMS)?
Google it. There are many Malays.
Impossible*
In order to justify the truth about Islam that the scholars hide, you can have no empathy for human beings. I tried to get rid of my empathy to stay Muslim but the cognitive dissonance was killing me. I felt like a hypocrite. So to me it was better to leave and make it known then to stay in because if Islam is true the punishment for a munafiq is even worse than a non believer. That’s a different pascals wager.😂😂😂
I felt the same way❤❤❤
@@user-bq8mw7rr6j Do they already know, that Tel Aviv University in Israel and basically all archaeologists of today already agree, that Moses and Abraham were invented?
If they want to be safe, they need to add Zeus again, because the evidence for him would still be better now than for Moses and the Iliad has never been corrupted. 😂
lol that made me feel better. even if i find an evil god like Allah after my death. punishment would be less than dying as a munafiq 😂
I'm sick of the translations, they translated Fasiq (wicked) as "disobedient". They've done that to make it less scary to non-Arabic-speaking people. Thank you for the video. Subscribed. BTW, you pronounce Arabic so well, is it your native language? Asking because, I've seen so many people telling me to go learn Arabic if I really want to understand Quran even though I can read it and most of the words from the Quran found place in my own language. But having someone who speaks Arabic debunk it is cool.
Yes, Arabic is his first language, by the way most Muslims don't speak Arabic, like the majority of people, if your book and religion is dependant on understanding a language, then that isn't a religion worth your time.
The Classical Arabic dictionaries all support disobedient.
You are not the criteria of the Classical Arabic dictionary.
You are a dishonest person. Even non Muslim translators refute you.
I guess everyone is in involved in your conspiracy of hiding meanings.🥴🤣
The language of the Quran from the seventh century doesn’t have to confirm to modern meanings of words in daily use.
Stop being dishonest and accusing people. You have no shame?
They also straight up forced a semantic change on a word xD
Dharra (mosquito, ant, iota) today translates as atom and also means atom (very recent dictionary change, like 19th century) to make it seem like the Quran talks about subatomic particles
From Umdat as-Salik re "fasiq"
o24.3 (A:) Meaning of a corrupt person (fasiq)
(N: hadiths of both types being obligatory for a Muslim to believe in, though someone who denies them is merely considered corrupt (fasiq), not an unbeliever (kafir))
(A: A legally corrupt or immoral person (fasiq) is someone guilty of (1) or (2) above.)
"It is not permissible to seek out dispensations [A: meaning it is unlawful, and the person who does is corrupt (fasiq)], and Allah knows best"
@@Tar-Elenion
That’s not in English but In Arabic.🫠
Best channel on UA-cam, brave man you are. It’s very hard for me knowing I am safe in the US, yet seeing comments from people in Libya and other places knowing the danger they are in, for something I take for granted.
How could you say that is he is Brave..
he is NOTHING BUT coward
@@HarrySharesSuper brave, that's what he is. Knowledgeable, kind, empathetic, kind-heartedly, articulate. All those things you're not!
@@HarrySharesshut up harry
I am following you from libya.
A country that kill apostates 😢😢😢
I love your work
I hope that changes someday..
@ApostateAladdin
Thanks. I also hope that.
People like you who have the ability and freedom to speak can change
@@optimus-prime703take courage you are extremely courageous!
We love you!
My the lord help you out that place I will pray tonight deeply for you and others people who are in the same situation
@@cocoalfaridah5831❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ Thank you for saying that
plz stay safe and leave the country.Don't let them trace you
I love this so much! This video is perfection. Once you think critically and understand the meaning of the hypnotic rhyming sounds, they are quite repetitive and disjointed in theme, and far from perfection. I can’t wait for your next video!
Thank you! Looking forward to publishing it
I love how someone immediately pointed out my spelling mistake at 0:48, ironically proving that even this video is imperfect 😂
@@ApostateAladdin you are brilliant and I love your videos! I like this new super polished format very much!
@@momo19991
You don’t even believe in perfection.
Nothing is perfect for you in the first place.
It shows how dishonest people like you are.
I suggest you pick up the quran and read for yourself and understand, instead of listening and following some ignorant person on the internet who don't even understand basic Arabic.
@@muhammadkijera76 Do you even know your own scriptures? Did allah reveal the Torah or was it written??
Hasan Radwan wrote an article on this a month ago and it was really good.
"Truth is in the details" - yes. This applies to so many areas of our lives as well. We naturally prefer simple, generalized, black-and-white concepts, but they rarely can convey the whole truth of the matter. I like your thorough, investigative approach. Personally, I think that posting less often isn't a bad thing if it means you have more time to prepare, and don't forget to take some time for yourself as well!
Every two weeks is absolutely grand. Keep them coming, I love these deep dives. ❤
I suggest you pick up the quran and read for yourself and understand, instead of listening and following some ignorant person on the internet who don't even understand basic Arabic.
I suggest you pick up the quran and read for yourself and understand, instead of listening and following some ignorant person on the internet who don't even understand basic Arabic.
@@muhammadkijera76 What about the millions of people that don't speak arabic? allah chooses them not to understand the quran?
This alone is laughable :
allah's scientific miracle MISTAKE AND IT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH LANGUAGE!
allah thinks milk is made in a cow's Belly (stomach) Q16:66 - And there is certainly a lesson for you in cattle: We give you to drink of what is in their bellies, from between digested food and blood: pure milk, pleasant to drink.
MILK IS 100% NOT MADE IN THE BELLY/STOMACH OF THE COW, NOR IS MILK IN THE BELLY/STOMACH OF A COW.. allah is 100% FALSE, quran is 100% FALSE, mahamed is 100% FALSE
@@muhammadkijera76 Why? What did he misunderstand? Please explain.
@@muhammadkijera76 AA is a native Arabic speaker, and as said by others, he's also right on point.
The nearest Islam gets to the truth is “There is no god…..” 😃
We love you Alladin! Thanks for being patient with us as we grow surely yet steadily.
I suggest you pick up the quran and read for yourself and understand, instead of listening and following some ignorant person on the internet who don't even understand basic Arabic.
@@muhammadkijera76 allah was 3 gods. She is shown to be 3 gods in the quran and hadiths. It's all in there.
@@muhammadkijera76 how can Apostate Aladdin not even know Basic Arabic when he himself is an Arab? Also the Information he tells us is a direct reference from the Noble Quran & the Sahih Hadith of the Prophet (police be upon him) but either way, You're right. They should've picked the Quran up & later on confirm that Apostate Aladdin's words are the truth.🏴☝️💥
I love the content you put out on your channel. Your videos are highly weighted and it is clear you put in a lot of time and effort to putting the information together. I would really like to see a conversation about Islam and god between yourself and Mufti Abu layth. Thanks again for another brilliant video.
There are over 300 references in the Koran to Allah and fear, there are only 49 references to love. Of these love references, 39 are negative such as the 14 negative references to love of money, power, other gods and status.
Three verses command humanity to love Allah and only 2 verses are about how Allah loves a believer. There are 25 verses about how Allah does not love kafirs (unbelievers; the worst of all creature). This leaves only 5 verses about love in the entire book. Of these 5, 3 are about loving kin or a ‘Muslim brother’ (ignored on a daily basis). One verse commands a Muslim to give for the love of Allah. This leaves only one quasi-universal verse about love: give what you love to charity and even this is contaminated by dualism since the requisite Muslim charity only goes to other Muslims. So, love your fellow man = NONE!
Nearly 500 verses (one out of every twelve) in the entire Qur'an speak of hell and over 400 speak negatively and encourage hatred or dislike of Jews, Christians, Idolaters and non muslims in general. One line in every five lines in the Quran is incomprehensible, even to Islamic scholars! What a god, what a prophet, what a book!
This really puts things in perspective and explains a lot. May I ask you for some sources? (Besides the Kuran itself 😅)
@@MrBjoern91 I and my 60 years research are the source. But this might help you.
Ref: Bill Warner - LOVE VERSUS FEAR IN THE KORAN: A STATISTICAL ANALYSIS AND REFORM ACCORDING TO GOLDEN RULE
@@venenareligioest410 thanks. I can't really find that book though. Only vague references to it are available online it seems. Do you have any idea where to find more info on it? Sorry to bother you, it just seemed so interesting what you commented
I know you are ignorant about the Quran, I can see what you are doing is copy and patsting. Anyways, Quran has 114 Chapters, and each chapter start with, "In the name of Allah the most gracious the most merciful"
It cant get any better than that.
you are soo much obsessed with Love, but is this not the reason why the western world is falling apart, in the name of "LOVE"?
@@muhammadkijera76 If you don't know that the quran shows hate, rage, threats and violence then you are the one that is truly ignorant. Especially, the hatred toward women. It's just terrible what this religion shows and the examples of mahamed (POLICE BE UPON HIM) were the worst in history in my opinion. Just gross. It's so easy to see.
Nice work Haney!
one thing I would love to see you make a video on is how muslims are knowingly harming their child by raising them muslim. the line of no compulsion in religion only applies if the person isn’t muslim already. so if parents raise their kids muslim, they must either stay muslim by force, or get executed by the state or fake their muslim status till death. when a parent chooses to raise their kid muslim there is no way out ever. at least if the parents raise their kids as non muslim they won’t be forced with the muslim identity. this also applies in other countries where people have christian laws applied to them and can change to the islamic law but if someone is born into islamic law they can’t change that
That's the point though. Raising your kids Muslim and making sure they stay that way after they grow up (beatings are prescribed). Making sure they marry a Muslim spouse and give birth to more Muslims (arranged marriage culture, interfaith marriages are borderline impossible or discouraged).
There is no element of choice in Islam. This is something Christians and Westerners will never realize.
If a holy book from the 7th century had a checksum after each line to prevent corruption, I might believe it.
It's not superhuman, not supernatural, it's something we can easily do today and just about possible even back then but it would have been impressive for that period in history.
That would be interesting.. math had been around since way before islam so it still wouldn't be divine, but more impressive than the current quran
The advice in the Qur'an is indeed a gem of wisdom - verify your sources for truth. That obviously includes the moral character and capacity of the person conveying the information. That's good advice for anybody anywhere and a safeguard against bad judgement of a situation. Sensible people do this everyday! The fact that you question this shows your own bias and desperate need for self-justification.
If the point of the verse was "verify all sources for truth" then the Quran could have simply said those exact words - it doesn't. It wouldn't contain the word Fasiq. Alladin also clearly explains that this verse doesn't talk about verifying information from sources that you trust implicitly and it's a reach to say that it does. It does not "obviously" mean too assess the moral character and capacity, because the verse defines the moral character for us, ie wicked or disobedient. Further, Alladin isn't questioning the wisdom of verifying your sources for truth, he is questioning how the message is conveyed in the Quran, so you are just using a straw man. The ultimate point of the video is to show how the Quran could be improved. It could be improved by simply stating 'when any person comes to you with information, verify it to avoid harm', but again, it doesn't. This is a common theme among all religious scriptures.
@@hoz1711_ This verse warns the believers against trusting information from a "fasiq" (deceitful, duplicitous, untrustworthy person). Checking the source is the first principle of verification. It's the perfect advice which cannot be improved. That's why no one should trust someone who hides behind a mask and uses a name like "Alladin".
@@AnalyseThat you’ve just moved the goalposts from what your originally said. You initially state the verse includes the “obvious” directions to assess moral character, now you’re actually agreeing with Alladin in saying the verse only applies to a Fasiq! Which still doesn’t address any of the arguments made in the video - does the verse or any other verse, tell us what to do when a believer or trustworthy person spreads harmful misinformation by accident? If it did, the verse would be clearer and speak to a wider variety of situations, and thus improved.
Good advice does not necessarily equal complete advice. The verse provides partially good advice, at best.
Ps, You call people out for having a bias, when your arguments are either 1) a strawman or 2) different from the first argument you made 3) calling out a persons youtube handle or for wearing a mask.
@@hoz1711_ Perhaps it's worth pointing out that the guidance of the Qur'an is only for the believers; unbelievers, on the other hand, are expected to be misguided by the same because they are among the "fasiq". It's like a mental person trying to diagnose their own issues - it can't be done.
@@AnalyseThat bro didn’t even watch the video lol
So strange that so many quran verses sound like Muhammad talking.
(49:4) Surely most of those who call out to you, (O Prophet), from behind the apartments, are devoid of understanding. (49:5) If they were patient until you went out to them, that would have been better for them. Allah is super clever and smart yardiyarda.
He invokes allah to fight his fights on his behalf
Who brought up the Bible? I think it's not a divine book either. Please avoid whataboutism
@@ApostateAladdinby the way Bible is the ordained word of God. Every scripture is written through inspiration received from the Spirit of God.
Your discovery of fake Muhammad and Allah does not mean that God of Christians is also fake.
There is a Creator and you well know it. And there is only ONE WAY HE ordained to get to HIM.
@lahleolivia
Your instinct is right. Many of the verses are indeed words of Muhammad himself
@@ApostateAladdinI pray that you not only saved the Muslims out from the cult but also from hell.
God bless you!
My problem with islam is the mother of Jesus now the sister of Moses.
Allah forgot?
it's an interesting family tree..
They are two totally different people in the quraan
Both of them have the same name, so they probably got confused.
@@Al-Muzil both of them have the same name, but the quran means it literally as if he got confused bc the sister of moses and the mother of Jesus have the name. Sister in faith is a reach, considering she's supposed to follow David has the zabur until Jesus gets his gospel and starts his "prophetic mission". She can't be moses sister in faith, Jews would rather say they are his followers, not companions like the muhammed sees his first followers.
@@M_A_R_I_A_M399_5there's a verse that makes it seems they are the same person due to them being named mariam.
I am currently deconstructing from Christianity but i really appreciate this channel and the other subscribers are really awesome as well.
6:32 “the benefit of the doubt” & “cutting him some slack” my ass, you brought that point home brotha! 😂😂😂 I just LOVE THIS .. taking a verse .. a story or a Hadith and bashing it down!! .. keep it up!! ✨✨
Thank you for all your efforts. I just had a thought, what if moham could use social media today? What would those tweets look like and tiktok posts ?? Dude
Unhinged..
Excellent breakdown of the verse.
"Life gets busy, and there's a lot to know."
I love that. Sometimes I feel a pressure, entirely self-imposed, to get on the level of this or that historian or science communicator in whichever video I'm watching. Which is absurd. No one is even halfway decent on every subject. It's okay to not know something. All any of us can do is learn.
Point being, I find that quote reassuring.
You videos are absolutely top notch. Haven't seen such analysis of Islam in a long time. This channel deserves more subscribers.
By the way i have a topic that is worth of making a video.
'Parallels Between the Qur'an and Late Antique Judeo-Christian Literature'
There's a fantastic article from wiki Islam on this topic but i think it should be put on video format.
Do consider
A perfect guidebook (ethics from god; objective morality) presupposes a perfect understanding (god). How does a perfect idea be translated into language and interpreted by human minds? There are so many people, with many perspectives, and complex changes in culture over time, how can these complex subjective experiences be united by the perfect idea? God’s perfect idea for imperfect humans. This ideology is circular in logic (why is the idea perfect? Because it comes from the perfect god who creates perfect ideas). How do we define and measure imperfection and perfection, and to what degree are humans able to comprehend god? Is perfection a human construct? A claim of perfection is paralyzing or stagnating. To prove perfection we need to comprehend perfection (how to prove something unknown?). So, how to live without a perfect guide? Use the imperfect knowable guide that is our current understanding of things.
Finally i found an islam critic who is not also a bigoted racist
Throwing shade at apostate prophet
The first thing that jumped out to me is So otherwise, the harm caused would have been justified?
wow these stories of muhammad almost attacking a tribe over a misunderstanding should really be emphasized when some muslims try to make excuses for him actually attacking other tribes, claiming they all including children were evil and somehow betrayed him and deserved death or slavery... who knows how it actually was
Collection of human ideas, sentiments and commands pertaining certain area and time...somethingl like this could be said about any "holy text"
3laddin your plants are looking on point 👏🏽
You claim that the Quran is eternal and uncreated and unchanged, so how could it be uncreated if abrogation is part of the doctrine ???
Wouldn’t the great allah have brought an ( finished ) Quran without abrogation??
The Quran was revealed to Muhammad and some verses were abrogated during his life time!
Did the great Allah changed his toughts within and in few years??
If so, then clearly the eternal Quran doesn’t exist!
God is perfect and all knowledgeable he wouldn’t change his mind like unsure , insecure human beings!!!
Impossible!
Can there even be ‘context’ with a book that is eternal, unchanging and unchangeable?
Why not?
@venenareligioest
that book “Quran” cannot be eternal, unchanging and unchangable.
The Muslims scholars just CREATED a verse in this Quran that gives Allah @ Jibril @ Muhammad and NOW Muslim Scholars the right to abrogate the verses in the Quran.
I wonder who is hearing from Jibril now that Muhammad is dead.
With the death of Muhammad, Jibril is also dead. And Muslims scholars are taking over the throne.
@@huios974
Your comment is incoherent.
Logic is clearly not your field.
@@alonzoharris9049 you Muslims are the least qualified to talk about logic.
When it comes to religion where one seek to live right before God, do you follow a man who is clearly corrupted? Unsound mind? Depressed and Suicidal?
Before you go any further to speak to others or condemn them, answer this question truthfully.
@@alonzoharris9049 Why NOT because the quran actually shows that it has changed right in Scripture. It's been bastardized to death and the scriptures even can prove that.
Did allah reveal his TORAH or was it written??
Thanks for the interesting and well researched videos Aladdin. Could you do a video on the ‘scientific miracles’ soon as someone who is studying science Im very tired of the misinformation.
Defending the Koran, as not being all bad, is akin to defending Mein Kampf, as not being all bad.
@@substance-1 Not really, both detail supremacist ideologies. The only difference is that one is somehow more socially acceptable than the other due to the sheer number of people who are brainwashed into it.
You got a good voice sir, it's calming and the accent is legit 👌
It’s so disturbing to here these stories about Mohammed while all along growing up I was taught the opposite, in the same breath why would the imams discuss these topics. And one last thing a language arabic that 99.99999 do not understand who I grew up with.
Your arguments are silly.
@@alonzoharris9049explain
I agree most are just accepting whatever their Iman told them without bothering to check. Gullible is the word.
You are wearing a jacket or top, so it must have been cold or winter. Oh, and your analysis was spot-on, as usual.
Perhaps lost in translation, so please if someone in the chat knows respond. The passage to me (english speaking, North American, ex-christian) sounded more like "Investigate even IF you think they are wicked, because they might still be right. " Or entertain the words of even the least trustworthy as you don't want to regret your own biases later. Obviously not the accepted take on this so I may have lost something.
How did you miss this?
[17:36] You shall not accept any information, unless you verify it for yourself. I have given you the hearing, the eyesight, and the brain, and you are responsible for using them.
Your great just found yoir channel
The many wildly different explanations for this verse and many others in the exegesis almost make me feel like the people who wrote the exegesis had no clue what the verses were really talking about and instead they just winged it and made up the explanations as they went!
As Christopher Hitchens said ‘Islam nearly got it right when they said ‘There is no god…’!
بيعجبنى دايما تحليلك 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Bless you and your videos Aladdin.
So good to see you post again, Aladdin
Hope you're doing well :3
I saw today that Jubilee is planning one of their middle ground episodes between Muslims and exmuslims
It's supposed to take place on the 16th or 18th of August and I thought I'd let you know
You're definitely one of the exmuslims that I'd be happy to have represent us and if you won't be able to partake in it, I hope you'll be able to let other exmuslim content creators know about this
Stay safe and have a great day
You said, “what’s easier to démoste is Imperfection versus what’s perfection.” Source?
The best evidence that Islam is false is that God is not a book.
👏😐
Very interesting and informative.
Great video.
5:00 "if there comes to you information double check it" LOL how in your mind do you imagine this improves the verse?
so any information including from people you trust your going to double check? thats called being paranoid .
the Quran is right you should double check information that come from enemies not information that comes from people you trust. this is also used by historians who also mistrust negative information given by enemies of a group
Yup its very true what you said in the beginning...........there are some pet phrases that non Muslim theists repeat again and again
No. It's necessary fight this evil ideology of Muhammad which teaches death penalty for those who leave Islam. Reference:
SAHIH BUKHARI 6922
Narrated `Ikrima:
Some Zanadiqa (atheists) were brought to `Ali and he burnt them. The news of this event, reached Ibn `Abbas who said, "If I had been in his place, I would not have burnt them, as Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) forbade it, saying, 'Do not punish anybody with Allah's punishment (fire).' I would have killed them according to the statement of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ), 'Whoever changed his Islamic religion, then kill him.'"
I'm binge-watching your videos and I only have one question that will refute everything you're trying to prove!!!!!! Why is your cat always sleeping in the background ? hhh he's so cute sleeping there peacefully while you're actively mercilessly destroying people's beliefs. I love your videos, and I love them even more because of that little fluff ball
i always wonder if not a single soul asked Mo what was those Muqatta'at actually means 🤔 or perhaps they just too afraid 😅
The Quran was not the focus of the universe, like believers claim. Many people simply didn't care to get involved in "debunking" it. And many have but either faced backlash or weren't recorded by Muslim scholars
I’d argue that, from the islamic perspective, your improvement upon the verse might not apply.
First of all, let’s suppose the news/نبأ being referenced was that of disobediance to Allah, which, from the islamic perspective, is incorrect and reprehensible.
The point of this verse could be “when there is a possibility of someone being disobedient, make sure first that the disobedience occurred.”
Most people, however, have difficulty ascertaining whether or not a situation is certain, and jump to certainty and blame prematurely. The use of the word فاسق then could more closely mirror the person’s conception of the situation and help the verse come to mind more immediately, giving it greater applicability.
I wish i could watch more of these videos..they are truly brilliant and well worth watching your videos.
Do you think you ttne quran would be as memorizable if the author made thr changes you suggest
Quran : The example of those who disbelieve is like that of one who shouts at what hears nothing but calls and cries cattle or sheep - deaf, dumb and blind, so they do not understand. CH: 2/171
(21:42) Tell them, (O Muhammad): "Who protects you, during the night or the day from the Most Compassionate Lord?"43 And yet they turn away from the Admonition of their Lord. (21:43)
- Quran always get it right :)
peepeepoopoo
Quran is nothing but Mohammed ranting to himself and reassuring himself. There is not a single verse dedicated to compassion for your fellow man, nothing to comfort a man in pain, nothing spiritual. Just ramblings of Mohammed about his domestic issues.
Thank you Aladdin, as always the video was insightful, thought provoking and made me view the verse from a few different angles. And no need to apologise for doing a video every couple of weeks, quality is always more important than quantity with this sort of content
Great video
Thank you for your efforts 🙏🙏
couldnt allah just tell muammed in advance
I once asked a Muslim friend of mine about missing contexts and explanations in the Qur'an, becuause to me they invalidate the "perfection"-claim.
He said that we should not expect perfect contextualizations and explanations of the verses in the Qur'an, because "life is a trial", and it would not be a trial if everything was served on a silver tray.
What do you make of this? Because frankly I do not know how to answer or counter that directly, the only way out beeing to adress the claim that life is a trial.
Your definition of perfection is illogical.
Your position is that a human being can only be perfect if there was no free will.
That’s basically what you are trying to say.
@@alonzoharris9049read your comments. I wonder who is far from logic 😂
@@marcocapelli7929
Can you show me the logic in his comment?
@@alonzoharris9049 like @marcocapelli7929 already said, you and logic are on two opposite sides. First off, you're putting words in ops "mouth?" He never said anything about free will.
If god is unchanging and his words are not perfect then that should be clear that he's not perfect. If I have insight into the future and I'm a god, I should be able to get everything right in the first try.
I don't need to test you if I already know what you're going to do, that's stupid.
@@alonzoharris9049 Thank you for your response. I can see why you might think that is the case. However, even if the Qur'an was perfectly explained, humans could still theoretically refuse to believe, so free will is not impaired.
Hello from New Zealand, AA 👋. Though I’m a staunch Christian I want to study the Quran to better understand Islam. Which version do you recommend I start with? Thanks so much for the info you’ve shared so far 🙏
just watch christian prince in youtube. he know Islam inside out. he going live almost everyday
What an interesting way for a non-muslim to learn about this religion. I will not bother to share my one and only and very, brief experience with the Quran myself. Warmest Wishes. Out For Now.
I keep getting ads to donate to a mosque in Sam Antonio on your vids. Fucking annoying! Hoping the algorithm starts learning the difference between Moose and Ex-Muslim content.
4:50 fixing the verse
Danke!
Thank you Lola!
Aladdin, you're missing (or forgetting) some essentials about the Quran. Consider the audience of the Quran, and if you're not sure who it is, reread the first and second chapter, especially the first one, really carefully. As a hint, who are the "maghdoobi 3alayhim," and what is their relationship with the "fasiqeen"? Also consider the audience of this verse, those who are already believers.
To a believer, it is a clear that a fasiq is a nonbeliever, and furthermore, one who is known to be a causer of harm. When in times of tension and anxiety and uncertainty (as the Muslims were in Medina), it is typical (from an emotional standpoint) to be more receptive to information which promotes distrust of another people. By mentioning the word fasiq, the verse reminds the believers who these people who create distrust really are-disbelieving people who do not operate by the same standards expected of a believer, so extra scrutiny is necessary. This may seem obvious, but many ideas in isolation may seem obvious, whereas the collection of a consistent set of these "obvious" ideas (Quran as a whole) is much less trivial.
Additionally, the Quran is a book in which every grammatically viable interpretation of any one verse is sound and accepted. An alternative understanding is that the "qawm" are a people which are with the disbelievers, so Allah swt asks the Muslims to be careful of hurting even the disbelievers if the source very well may be hearsay-yes not all wars/attacks taken were defensive, but the understanding is that offensive wars are to be avoided except for sound reasoning.
In your comment, you mention that the emphasis of the verse is to alleviate guilt from the believer rather than harm to others. Of course, the goal of a Muslim is to attain heaven, and this is something each Muslim is individually accountable for. It may sound harsh, but in a way, doing any favor for others is doing a favor for yourself-the ultimate goal is inherently selfish. Even if helping another just makes you happy or content, that's still a positive feeling that you seek for yourself. So at the end of the day, yes, the implications of your actions to yourself are what is most important, there is no mistake there.
*One who is known to be a causer of harm.*
I am curious. Who are they, these known to be a causer of harm? For example, suicide bombers do not consider themselves to be evil. They believe that the Qur'an is the literal word of God, and prophet Muhammad is the last prophet. In my opinion, Islam (much like other religion) teaches some (not all) terrible morals. These vague words like "wicked" or "know to be causer of harm" are used to justify horrible morality. Are Apostates "causer of harm?" What about gays? What about slave owners?
What qualifies someone as a causer of harm?
Non-Arab Muslims just recite and memorize the Quran verses, for practical matters they rely on local scholars
Ma sha' Allah
The Muslims scholars CREATED a verse in this Quran that gives Allah @ Jibril @ Muhammad and NOW Muslim Scholars the right to abrogate the verses in the Quran.
I wonder who is hearing from Jibril now that Muhammad is dead.
But with the death of Muhammad, it is assumed Jibril is also dead. And Muslims scholars are taking over the throne.
0:48 spelling error
Smh.. this is why i shouldn't proof read my own work
Pobody's nerfect
@@ApostateAladdin 🤭😂
Very well articulated I give you that
Well made Aladdin
I really thought Harry Potter book came from Allah, it has more magical verses than Quran 😅
Nice one bro. I aspire to be like you one day. Courageous an eloquent...although i´m not sure eloquence can be learned.
@markorbit
If you seek the Lord and has good intention, He will blessed you with gift of eloquence.
God bless!
@@huios974 Which lord are you talking about? Vishnu?
@@markorbit4752 If you believe that Vishnu is the one who created you.
God says He created man in His likeness an image.
Now, do you look like a woman and have 4 hands as Vishnu?
God bless you with wisdom!
@@huios974 Well, if god created me in his/its image, then what an awful god he/it must be. I have serious back pain, my beard grows into my skin and causes all these inflamed bumps every week, My left hand craps all the time and i can´t use it. If i look like god, what a miserable, grumpy creature he must be.
@@huios974 yes, god says now prove those were god's words and prove how you know that.
The verse calls attention to credibility as a hallmark of good sources for taking information ,specifically and to confirm the accuracy of information generally.
you said there are proofs that the quran is changed by the prophets followers
if you want to say stuff like this in ur intro kindly give a backup statement and to ur pinned comment i think the quran won then?
The broken clock being right twice a day is far more right than the Koran.
The screenshots at 13:43 are hilarious 😭😭
I feel seen 😂
Can u lend me ur magic lamp alladin
.i want just 1 wish.... end of islam.
I think the Lord of the Rings trilogy is far better than the Quran😂
Alladin im clear on how you feel about the quran but how do you feel about the bible?
Happy 4th of July Aladdin hope you had a great day
Great video 👏
Allah seems to be able to deliver miracles at the drop of hat but in the critical matter of his eternal book why did he refrain from sending his perfect book complete - written on exquisite parchment and made by a pen dipped in liquid gold , gradually descending to earth in a blaze of glory to an expectant multitude? Instead we have an incredibly flawed and confusing process - bits written on palm leaves and bones, sections memorized and with many variants and parts lost and we have to have a murderous autocrat in the person of caliph Uthman to create a final recension and then all the evidence of past variants burnt? I'm well aware that the Koran itself tries to answer this objection but it would try to do that wouldn't it?
Brilliant as always ❤❤❤
Very reasonable 👌
14:53 the Quran was written and compiled by human scribes.
My problem is:
In the whole Quran, there is nowhere to find eve!
Where is Eve?? In the Quran?
Macho book
who cares
@@StanbyMode 😀😀
@@StanbyMode women are highly represented and respected in Islami!
And visible and absent!
She was certainly in it, but in Islam she had to wear so much thick clothing that no one would recognize her anymore as a woman and people mistook her for a jinn.
That's also why the quran talks so much nonsense about jinns.
@@reinercelsus8299 😀😀😀😂🧠 yes
Watched all of it 18:01
nice video! first time hearing about this verse!
someone who tells or shares misinformation is himself the wicked person. as simple as that. and if you can, try making a verse of your own. see if it even comes close with the verses of quran and plz don't copy.
Easy
"dont marry children"
"women and men have equel rights"
"slavery is bad"
"don't kill non Muslims and exMuslims"
I could go on and on
During an interview with Angelika Neuwirth, the distinguished Professor of Qur’anic studies, she argued that the Qur’an has never been successfully challenged by anyone, past or present:
"No one has succeeded, this is right… I really think that the Qur’an has even brought Western researchers embarrassment, who were not able to clarify how suddenly in an environment where there were not any appreciable written text, appeared the Qur’an with its richness of ideas and its magnificent wordings."
Did u read what exactly she say in essence.
@@urbandsouza7279
Go back to sleep.
wow, a professor of Quranic studies thinks the Quran is neat. Who would have thought?
🤔🤣😂🤣
LOL! Neuwirth doesn't teach that the Quran was divine or revealed by a god, but that it originated from christian and jewish debates in late antiquity.
Bro why are you so cute😍 Btw my phone just smacked into my face so that made me a little pissed off...
🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽