I like to imagine that this is the canonical of what happened, just minus the racing them bit Silver Sonic was made first as a prototype to test if a Robot Sonic could even be built. Mecha in Sonic 3 was testing if a slimmer, but bulky design could harness the chaos/master emerald’s power And Metal was built to test if a robot could match Sonic’s speed and personality.
@@Jesus-jb4zz The little planet was over Never lake for a little time and Eggman can repair or build his machines very fast, because after the death egg crashed on Angel Island (after and before launch base), while sonic was going to lava reef zone, he repaired it quickly, the zone backgrounds can tell that sonic 3&k (sonic story) happend in 2-3 days. Metal sonic was made before sonic arrived, because his holograms were in past. If i was Eggman i would make a rival to my worst enemy before he arrives and crashes everything and run some tests. The whole thing is happening in present, because you play most of zones in present and only last act in future. Sonic goes to future to find eggman and destroy his machines.
Let's be honest I think we all knew Metal Sonic was going to win. He was designed for speed and to learn from his enemies. Edit: an idea I had was that mecha sonic could be the badass soldier used by Eggman in most games, and that metal sonic would be lying in wait over his next move. Although another option is to make the two of them like partners working under Eggman (if you have to keep metal under eggman). In sonic adventure there were two robots on Eggman ship, one was metal sonic, and the other was later confirmed to be mecha sonic in the comics. If they were in Sonic Heroes I imagined that metal Sonic would still do what he does but Mecha Sonic would be reprogramed by him to work Underneath Him. Then after they lose Eggman would reprogram the both of them to be loyal to him and so he would have Mecha and metal by his side. Then maybe in the battle for Angel Island IDW Story mecha and metal could both have Neo forms, although that would admittedly be a little harder to write in. I think Sega just needs to find a way to use both of them in a way that defines power and speed. Metal Sonic is powerful but he's more faster than he is powerful, fittingly Mecha Sonic could be more powerful than he is fast. I know that's a lot like silver sonic but there's no reason both of them can be fast or capable of spin dashing and using the rockets on their feet to some extent. In other words Mecha Sonic is still fast and athletic but he's loaded with more weapons and tougher armor , while Metal Sonic is faster in flight and has electric field build up and Crystal missiles (sonic heroes). Essentially they would be like a Sonic and Knuckles dynamic, both are athletic and quick to some extent but once focus is power and the others is speed
from my knowledge, Metal was meant to be a copy of sonic, made to out do sonic in his field, being speed. Silver Sonic was supposed to be a bulky tanky sorta Guard to the Death Egg, meant to defend Robotnik and distract Sonic while Robotnik preps the Death Egg Robot. While Mecha Sonic is meant to be a direct upgrade to Silver Sonic, he is tankier than Silver Sonic, being able to fight both Sonic and then Knuckles before being destroyed and he also has better AI than Silver Sonic making him able to pilot Robotnik's "Egg-O-Matic" as well as use the machinery that can connect to the Egg-O-Matic. When it comes to the retro games, Mecha is superior in all fields except Movement Speed and Processing Speed, which is Metal's expertise. so yeah Metal should be able to win in a race while Mecha would win in a fight. But when it comes to the modern series, of course Metal will no doubt win in both a fight and a race, due to how more powerful Metal has become and how Mecha has not made any new appearances.
I've always seen mecha sonic as being more terminator inspired tbh, and the silver sonic design is probably based on the weird western mohawk design of classic sonic (the worst)
Interviewer: "So you all are the fastest robots in Eggman's army. . .what skills do you have to win?" Silver Sonic: "Haha ball form go spinney." Mecha Sonic: "I murdered Eggrobo in cold blood. That and I'm a super saiyen." Metal Sonic: "Depression." God bless my robo boi
@@theprincemonster7575 Kinda depends on the interpretation. He was certainly aiming for Knuckles, but I think that he didn't really care if he hurt Eggrobo or not, since he ignores his partner's death completely.
1:18 and beyond reminds me of Wacky Races. He's going so fast that if he just kept going normally he would easily win, but he still turns around to sabotage the guy way behind him
Alternative title : Robotnik is choosing the robot that would replace metal sonic by making racing themselves Édit : well look like it would still be metal
In a way, it's kinda sad... He's so desperate to prove his the real sonic. And when he's defeated, he wanted an answer as to why did he still lose... But all he got is one lame-@$$ answer of "beCOz wE r SoNiC HEroEs !" Like, WHAT KIND OF ANSWER IS THAT ?
Ngl yes he dosen't think he is fake he just wants to be a real breathing creature but what did he got it was "Because we are Sonic heroes" what is this even kids will say this is dumb and also the fact that actually mecha sonic sufferd more even tho metal sonic is the fastest but mecha is the most powerful he was tired of being controlled so he just stood up and left and what did they do they destroyed him but later he came back and actually became good so in that I would say mecha's story is more sad and more inspiring than metal sonic but still both have suffered
@@arpitaghosal767 How did Mecha Sonic MK.II suffer more? He got destroyed once, Metal got destroyed so many more times, also I don't remember Mecha Sonic MK.II ever going against Eggman (Except for in Scrapnick island, but that happens *WAY* later)
Aero he’s not an official character. Not to mention he is an irrelevant, overrated, dated creepypasta that’s not even scary anymore, no offense. Like ooOooOo hyper realistic blood and spooky red eyes of evil I’m shaking and crying. Not to mention He’s not even a robot for Christ sake. I don’t know why you thought of that idea.
@@CuteTails_Doll the japanese manual is canon and calls the robot sonic in sonic 2 genesis (Mecha Sonic) For the one in master system/game gear that robot sonic is known as silver sonic also in the comics which ISN’t canon calls the mecha sonic SILVER SONIC also lego dimensions which ISN’T canon give the robot sonic from genesis a whole new name called (Robo Sonic) So Mecha Sonic Is The Canon Name.
@@ominicronikal0902 Metal definitly isn't faster than Sonic, but he definitly is faster than Mecha, there's a reason Metal is the one who always gets rebuilt.
@@sonicdml4175 is there really? The badniks of all machines come baack as well or the egg pawns that became outdated by shadow 05. Its just due to the fact he was always promoted in comercials and more people knew him that lead to his popularity not an in universe logic. I can buy that Metal is faster, If we dont count Super mecha but stronger? Nah, blud got that wall durability level
@knuckson8304 The other badnicks are just grunts, they only mean anything in large numbers, Metal isn't that. Also current Metal is waaaay above wall, considering it can take hits from Sonic.
@@sonicdml4175 You say that yet we see metal teaming up with metal in several fights, and If like just 14 badniks team up on him in lost world is that really all he is? You know what other robots took several hits to be defeated? Silver and Mecha sonic in their first appaance alone where Silver Sonic could one shot Ssonic mind you, You people always bring up how he comes back yet seem to forget people like Zavok do too as If that means anything, If the badniks from sonic 1 come back considered "his strongest mech" then metal coming back doesnt mean anything either. Sonic literally had to run away from the number of badniks in lost world so I guess 14 badniks > Metal Sonic then Way above wall level? Yeah I dont think so considering we see him losing to one several other times, he did take a few hits from sonic in generations tho, but he also managed to beat perfect chaos in base so in that game power never made sense. He does get a few more attacks over time but like... he is still slower than knuckles in a game about racing so I dont think he has been improved that much considering the only time when he was a threat was in Sonic heroes where he stole everyones powers. Come to think of it, Can metal even keep up with sonic boosting? He is outdated. Only games where sonic can boost and he races metal is rivals in which even knuckles is faster than metal and I dont even think Forces counts as he doesnt really try to race and even the avatar can do th boost and run on nothing (null void) Also If you think normal metal can be faster than even a super form (super mecha) idk what to tll you, It might not be fair but hey, when metal did get metal overlord hee didnt seem fast while Mecha had the jet thing
Silver Sonic had the strength, Mecha Sonic had the smarts, but metal had all that and beyond. (Also yes I know that he’s actually called Mecha Sonic mk.1, but I find it easier to call him silver Sonic.)
@@annoying_HK_guy Actually, they weren't. CD takes place before 2 (apparently), so Metal Sonic was technically Eggman's first attempt at a robot Sonic. I guess the reason he kept coming back was because out of all the models, his was more in line with the real Sonic and thus had the most potential for upgrades. I can only assume Silver Sonic and Mecha Sonic didn't have as much effort put into them compared to Metal Sonic. Silver was probably made as a quick distraction for Sonic getting on the Death Egg and Mecha was the same for preventing Sonic from boarding the Death Egg a second time.
Rose Supreme actualy he did made silver sonic diferent because he wated to make a robot to be strong not fast and i actualy think that mecha is stonger than metal and have still the same speed. And i think he is a neo metal sonic prototype because of how they look
Considering that Silver Sonic doesn't even have a consistent naming and is often confused with the 8 bit Silver Sonic...not to mention lacks a personality, he's not anything special. Mecha Sonic is pretty cool but mostly is remembered because of SMBZ. Otherwise he is a backstabbing traitor, having no quarrels with killing Eggrobo, or at least lacking any sense of guilt. Metal Sonic is an emotional wreck and deserves hugs. He already let himself die once before so he kinda deserved the win.
Well Silver Sonic is Mk I, Mecha Sonic is Mk II and I like to imagine Metal Sonic is like Perfect Cell. So we just had two prototypes go up against the finished product.
@@James179 Metal should win at races as he is designed for speed as seen with his movement method being a rocket and the others being wheels. But, if it has 1v1 combat, mecha sonic completely destroys the other 2 by a wide margin as he has a spin dash ,he can shoot energy from his chest and can absorb chaos energy making him complete invincible even without cause energy he is very strong seen as in sonic 3 and knuckles he took around 30 hits from sonic and knuckles between both stories.
Is not a lie, Metal is better than Meca(Silver) and Mecha Sonic. Saying "But Mecha Sonic can go super" means nothing to me. Metal could transform into Metal Overlord by himself without any chaos emeralds
@@loryx_0 Sonic never fights super mecha so I dont know what are you on about and second, knuckles can only damage super mecha when he has to recharge, the same character who knocked super sonic out of sonic Also you make it sound like metal beat sonic or was even an equal to him when all h does in the race is explode in a wall
@@shardsoftime0952 Shard is not faster, None of his feats in the comic were more impressive than sonic's. The comic where he traps him and tails dont showcase anything of the sort
Yeah, well until in the Sonic IDW Comics, he has been able to go in his Super form as Neo Metal Sonic(otherwise Super Neo Metal Sonic), before going to his Master Overlord form when he copied Sonic and Shadow's Biodata.
Cool animation. I personally would have had the Sonic & Knuckles mecha-sonic win though, because it was the newest model and because it looks the most bad-ass. Although there's no denying Sega likes to reference the CD model the most, I think most fans like the S&K one.
No Metal was the FINAL design and clearly the most advanced out of the 3 ! Coz Metal is the one that actually matched Sonic's speed. And Metal is actually stronger than the other 2, your judgement is biased.
@@justabrokezombie6252 well this aged like milk, considedring it has been confirmed CD takes place after 1. Looks like you are the only one biased here. The wall level robot aint stronger than either y'all keep talking about his speed but even knuckles outran him in rivals and he got beaten by tails in the classic spinoffs lol
So i guess the story of this is eggman decided to revive silver and mecha sonic and he made them do a race against metal sonic to see who's the better robot
fanmade dialogues *at race* metal sonic: so, this is the metal race, right? silver sonic: yeah, but I don't think that you can win, baby *laughs* Mecha sonic: yeah! *laughs* metal sonic: what's so funny? Mecha sonic: you are tinier than us, baby *laughs* metal sonic: I'm more mobile than you, big piece of scrap Mecha sonic: ow... Mecha sonic: but we with silver sonic have more weapons, pathetic child *laughs* eggman: the one who will be first, will be the best robot of you, the losers will get destroyed Mecha sonic: prepare to get trashed, baby *laughs* silver sonic: yeah *laughs* metal sonic: don't make fun of me, because the karma can get you eggman: the race will start in 3, 2, 1! *every robot speeds up* Mecha sonic: how on the earth metal is so fast! metal sonic: I told you that I'm more mobile Mecha sonic: that doesn't mean anything metal sonic: *goes to up* silver sonic: I don't need to get up *burst through the up road* metal sonic: aaaaaaaaa! *falls* Mecha sonic: pathetic *laughs* metal sonic: not so fast *use super booster* Mecha sonic: what the hell? silver sonic: *get hit by spikes and deactivates* eggman: pathetic garbage *destroys silver sonic* Mecha sonic: nooooooooo! metal sonic: catch me if you can *speeds up* Mecha sonic: he is too fast, I can't catch up him knuckles: *pushing the master emerald* why it's so heavy? metal sonic: *flying above knuckles and stuns him* knuckles: oh no Mecha sonic: oh yeah! the master emerald! *jumps on master emerald and turns super* metal sonic: too slow super Mecha sonic: *overtakes metal sonic* no, you're too slow metal sonic: hey! that's unfair! *boosts* super Mecha sonic: can you dodge this? *shoots at metal sonic with explosive rings* metal sonic: *dodges* super Mecha sonic: I'm not done! *trys to hit metal sonic* metal sonic: *dodges again* you missed! *spindashes* super Mecha sonic: hey! where are you going! *flys* eggman: it's almost finished super Mecha sonic: *overtakes metal sonic again* metal sonic: he is too fast... metal sonic: I have to take extreme measures *uses super booster and overtakes Mecha sonic* super Mecha sonic: nooooooooo! metal sonic: yes! super Mecha sonic: *hits wall* aaaaaaaaa! *gets destroyed* metal sonic: I told you about karma eggman: not bad metal sonic! you proved that you are the best robot! metal sonic: yay!
METAL SONIC WON YEAH BABY I WAS VOTING FOR HIM TO WIN AND HE DID!!!!Who else agree with me that metal sonic was suppose to win huh who agrees with me hm.
Let's be honest Metal is Faster than Meca Sonic and Mecha Sonic. Meca couldn't stop in time and stomped into the spikes cause he acts too slow for being a "obstacles race", Mecha Sonic maybe faster in reaction than Meca, but Metal still fast as Sonic is and his V Maximum Overdrive makes him four times faster. And yes, I am calling Silver Sonic "Meca Sonic" just because I don't like calling him "Silver".
Well he is suppose to win as if he didnt he would be the most useless robot ever as he designed to for speed and he only just beat mecha sonic who was built for power so given how close it was metal is still quite bad even at his speciality.
Metal Sonic can learn his enemy's and others' skills, abilitys, speeds and after just use it and Metal was race with Sonic once and he know now hlw much speed he needs, also because of this he can win easily a race or a battle
I like to imagine that this is the canonical of what happened, just minus the racing them bit
Silver Sonic was made first as a prototype to test if a Robot Sonic could even be built.
Mecha in Sonic 3 was testing if a slimmer, but bulky design could harness the chaos/master emerald’s power
And Metal was built to test if a robot could match Sonic’s speed and personality.
Im curious what the next robot sonic would look like
I'm pretty sure mecha was after metal sonic.
@@quickrevivesoda6759 kinda but metal was possibly from the future as you fight him in what is called the bad FUTURE
Silver Sonic is the one from the 8 bits version of Sonic 2, the 16 bits version is Mecha Sonic
@@Jesus-jb4zz The little planet was over Never lake for a little time and Eggman can repair or build his machines very fast, because after the death egg crashed on Angel Island (after and before launch base), while sonic was going to lava reef zone, he repaired it quickly, the zone backgrounds can tell that sonic 3&k (sonic story) happend in 2-3 days. Metal sonic was made before sonic arrived, because his holograms were in past. If i was Eggman i would make a rival to my worst enemy before he arrives and crashes everything and run some tests. The whole thing is happening in present, because you play most of zones in present and only last act in future. Sonic goes to future to find eggman and destroy his machines.
I feel like Mecha Sonic was only remembered because of SMBZ
That’s the reason I think he should be used more his design is just too good looking.
Not really
To be fair he was pretty darn cool in Sonic & Knuckles, especially with him transforming and basically commiting murder upon his own kind.
yep
Mecha Sonic was from Sonic 3 (& Knuckles)
Let's be honest I think we all knew Metal Sonic was going to win. He was designed for speed and to learn from his enemies.
Edit: an idea I had was that mecha sonic could be the badass soldier used by Eggman in most games, and that metal sonic would be lying in wait over his next move.
Although another option is to make the two of them like partners working under Eggman (if you have to keep metal under eggman). In sonic adventure there were two robots on Eggman ship, one was metal sonic, and the other was later confirmed to be mecha sonic in the comics. If they were in Sonic Heroes I imagined that metal Sonic would still do what he does but Mecha Sonic would be reprogramed by him to work Underneath Him. Then after they lose Eggman would reprogram the both of them to be loyal to him and so he would have Mecha and metal by his side. Then maybe in the battle for Angel Island IDW Story mecha and metal could both have Neo forms, although that would admittedly be a little harder to write in.
I think Sega just needs to find a way to use both of them in a way that defines power and speed. Metal Sonic is powerful but he's more faster than he is powerful, fittingly Mecha Sonic could be more powerful than he is fast. I know that's a lot like silver sonic but there's no reason both of them can be fast or capable of spin dashing and using the rockets on their feet to some extent. In other words Mecha Sonic is still fast and athletic but he's loaded with more weapons and tougher armor , while Metal Sonic is faster in flight and has electric field build up and Crystal missiles (sonic heroes). Essentially they would be like a Sonic and Knuckles dynamic, both are athletic and quick to some extent but once focus is power and the others is speed
Eh, I liked Mecha more
@@SpireGuy eh i like metal more
@@JackAndTom610 eh I liked silver more
Its the metal team
from my knowledge,
Metal was meant to be a copy of sonic, made to out do sonic in his field, being speed.
Silver Sonic was supposed to be a bulky tanky sorta Guard to the Death Egg, meant to defend Robotnik and distract Sonic while Robotnik preps the Death Egg Robot.
While Mecha Sonic is meant to be a direct upgrade to Silver Sonic,
he is tankier than Silver Sonic, being able to fight both Sonic and then Knuckles before being destroyed and he also has better AI than Silver Sonic making him able to pilot Robotnik's "Egg-O-Matic" as well as use the machinery that can connect to the Egg-O-Matic.
When it comes to the retro games, Mecha is superior in all fields except Movement Speed and Processing Speed, which is Metal's expertise.
so yeah Metal should be able to win in a race while Mecha would win in a fight.
But when it comes to the modern series, of course Metal will no doubt win in both a fight and a race, due to how more powerful Metal has become and how Mecha has not made any new appearances.
I just noticed something.
Metal Sonic looks like classic Sonic
Silver Sonic looks like SAT AM Sonic
Mecha Sonic looks like modern Sonic
I've always seen mecha sonic as being more terminator inspired tbh, and the silver sonic design is probably based on the weird western mohawk design of classic sonic (the worst)
James_179 I actually like the Mohawk tbh, I just don’t like some of the Sonic comic designs for some of the characters sometimes..
That's true lumpy your IQ is 300
Silver=sonic 2 mecha=sonic and knuckles metal=sonic cd
Mecha Sonic is my favorite, Eggman should bring him back
Interviewer: "So you all are the fastest robots in Eggman's army. . .what skills do you have to win?"
Silver Sonic: "Haha ball form go spinney."
Mecha Sonic: "I murdered Eggrobo in cold blood. That and I'm a super saiyen."
Metal Sonic: "Depression."
God bless my robo boi
Mecha Sonic Murdered Eggrobo By Mistake He Wanted To Kill Knuckles
@@theprincemonster7575 Kinda depends on the interpretation. He was certainly aiming for Knuckles, but I think that he didn't really care if he hurt Eggrobo or not, since he ignores his partner's death completely.
Shard: i defeated archie sonic (the most OP version of sonic)
@@Whatareyoudoinnhere Metal is my favorite
@@dabluepittoo-aqua4213 Right on.
1:18 and beyond reminds me of Wacky Races. He's going so fast that if he just kept going normally he would easily win, but he still turns around to sabotage the guy way behind him
When there's only one slice of pizza left:
Me and the bois:
It’s me and the boys actually
Eggman is the time before it spoils
True somehow
Pizza
@@RaymanFan-jp2bd then you arent cultured, bois is better when your talking about your friends
Is that Robotnik laugh when he activates his laser from 3ds generations? Nice!
The laughs are from the death egg robot in generations for everything else
Nah that was cd sonic
@@eeeeeeee4525 no.
Nah thats CD sonic
Rodotnik egg man
Alternative title :
Robotnik is choosing the robot that would replace metal sonic by making racing themselves
Édit : well look like it would still be metal
“Tortoise and the Hare,” Mecha. focus on the race.
This is why I love Metal Sonic. He's willing to do anything to win, even if it means possibly blowing up.
In a way, it's kinda sad... He's so desperate to prove his the real sonic. And when he's defeated, he wanted an answer as to why did he still lose... But all he got is one lame-@$$ answer of "beCOz wE r SoNiC HEroEs !" Like, WHAT KIND OF ANSWER IS THAT ?
@@justabrokezombie6252 agreed
Ngl yes he dosen't think he is fake he just wants to be a real breathing creature but what did he got it was "Because we are Sonic heroes" what is this even kids will say this is dumb and also the fact that actually mecha sonic sufferd more even tho metal sonic is the fastest but mecha is the most powerful he was tired of being controlled so he just stood up and left and what did they do they destroyed him but later he came back and actually became good so in that I would say mecha's story is more sad and more inspiring than metal sonic but still both have suffered
Also look at mecha's desing easily one of the best character designs in the world
@@arpitaghosal767
How did Mecha Sonic MK.II suffer more? He got destroyed once, Metal got destroyed so many more times, also I don't remember Mecha Sonic MK.II ever going against Eggman (Except for in Scrapnick island, but that happens *WAY* later)
Never ask a woman, her age
A man, his salary
Knuckles, what was he doing in Stardust Speedway with Master Emerald
The only way for mecha to turn super
Plot convience
0:04 in sonic heroes: -Team Metal
So Metal is the speed type. I assume silver is the power type, and mecha is the flight type?
Wouldn’t that be metal sonic,metal knuckles and the tails doll?
@@d3-penguin954 about Sonic.Exe? He'd be a better fit than good old metal
Aero he’s not an official character. Not to mention he is an irrelevant, overrated, dated creepypasta that’s not even scary anymore, no offense. Like ooOooOo hyper realistic blood and spooky red eyes of evil I’m shaking and crying. Not to mention He’s not even a robot for Christ sake. I don’t know why you thought of that idea.
Hammerless Penguin exactly
I like how 1:34 has the track's layout become similar to the original Stardust Speedway Act 3.
es muy similar por qué es el Starbucks de speedway original
Metal Sonic: Overused
Mecha Sonic: Underrated
Silver Sonic: Underutilized
What does Underutilized mean
@@BOX_corporation. Well the name says it. He practically isnt used
i wonder what happened with knuckles and the master emerald...
UH- I'm sure they'll be fine...
He probably used the master emerald as an umbrella to block the beam.
@@Vengefultildeath that makes perfect sense considering he was pretty much knocked out
Hablen español!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!😡
@@giocondamariaortega8224 weon el vídeo es en inglés, era obvio que habrían comentarios en inglés
Half expected Mecha to go "I'll crush you!"
Incredible seeing all the robot counter parts of sonic go up each other to see who is the true robot counter of sonic
Very cool video, James. You are very talented in animations. You deserved more recognition, but all in good time, right?
Anyway, good video, James
I am glad he proved he was the true Metal Sonic
Shard is the real metal sonic
@@shardsoftime0952
Shard doesn't even exist in the games (which are the main canon)
Awesome Video! Metal Sonic is the true Sonic the real Sonic.
What a Race, now I see why Silver Sonic & Mecha Sonic never appeared on the modern games, the two lost the race.
I mean, they appeared in the mc dlc, and it takes place in the modern era (it isnt canon, but wont change it)
@@VeeTheTelevisi0nLovePc ah yeah, they appeared in Archie/IDW Comics, true true
@@CuteTails_Dollthat’s mecha sonic mark i (the white one)
@@liyōnonainoroi I Like calling Mecha Sonic MK I as Silver Sonic just to not get confused lol
@@CuteTails_Doll the japanese manual is canon and calls the robot sonic in sonic 2 genesis (Mecha Sonic) For the one in master system/game gear that robot sonic is known as silver sonic also in the comics which ISN’t canon calls the mecha sonic SILVER SONIC also lego dimensions which ISN’T canon give the robot sonic from genesis a whole new name called (Robo Sonic) So Mecha Sonic Is The Canon Name.
Bruh , am glad yoy grew i was here when you had 3k subs or less
Love the hard work 🔥
Appreciate it, man! Thanks!
Boi, i almost won!!!
God I love all of these designs, my favorite has to be mecha sonic, he just looks so damn cool.
Je suis d'accord il est cool mecha sonic moi je suis fane de lui de puis que je les vu sur Bowers vs egman
0:51 rip silver sonic, he will probably never show up in another sonic game again ):
Unless they run out of ideas to give to an eggman team trio, then it can be
Speed-Metal sonic
Fly-Eggman
Power-Silver sonic
Plot twist:
Eggman testing his bots to see which one is the fastest
"Is something the matter it will take more than that" 🤣🤣🤣
Fun fact: metal can be 4 times faster than sonic but if he does that he will autodestruct
Where did you get that info?
Also if going that fast means you get destroyed, then you can't actually go that fast.
@@sonicdml4175 as i said in the manual for sonic cd says that but as i also said it will autodestruct him
Awesome James you animate super awesome
1:13 fire charging sound join the chat
Wow! You have done an excellent job!
Thanks, I'm glad you enjoyed!
@@James179 yep! I also like your Sonic 3 & Knuckles animations as well., I watch your entire playlist. Awesome!
@Jian Guzman happy belated birthday to Joseph. hope he had an awesome one
Let's be honest, mecha only lost because he was trying to damage metal
I mean metal can be 4 times faster than sonic if he wanted to, I think metal sonic would win either way.
@@ominicronikal0902
Metal definitly isn't faster than Sonic, but he definitly is faster than Mecha, there's a reason Metal is the one who always gets rebuilt.
@@sonicdml4175 is there really? The badniks of all machines come baack as well or the egg pawns that became outdated by shadow 05. Its just due to the fact he was always promoted in comercials and more people knew him that lead to his popularity not an in universe logic. I can buy that Metal is faster, If we dont count Super mecha but stronger? Nah, blud got that wall durability level
@knuckson8304
The other badnicks are just grunts, they only mean anything in large numbers, Metal isn't that.
Also current Metal is waaaay above wall, considering it can take hits from Sonic.
@@sonicdml4175 You say that yet we see metal teaming up with metal in several fights, and If like just 14 badniks team up on him in lost world is that really all he is? You know what other robots took several hits to be defeated? Silver and Mecha sonic in their first appaance alone where Silver Sonic could one shot Ssonic mind you, You people always bring up how he comes back yet seem to forget people like Zavok do too as If that means anything, If the badniks from sonic 1 come back considered "his strongest mech" then metal coming back doesnt mean anything either. Sonic literally had to run away from the number of badniks in lost world so I guess 14 badniks > Metal Sonic then
Way above wall level? Yeah I dont think so considering we see him losing to one several other times, he did take a few hits from sonic in generations tho, but he also managed to beat perfect chaos in base so in that game power never made sense. He does get a few more attacks over time but like... he is still slower than knuckles in a game about racing so I dont think he has been improved that much considering the only time when he was a threat was in Sonic heroes where he stole everyones powers. Come to think of it, Can metal even keep up with sonic boosting? He is outdated. Only games where sonic can boost and he races metal is rivals in which even knuckles is faster than metal and I dont even think Forces counts as he doesnt really try to race and even the avatar can do th boost and run on nothing (null void)
Also If you think normal metal can be faster than even a super form (super mecha) idk what to tll you, It might not be fair but hey, when metal did get metal overlord hee didnt seem fast while Mecha had the jet thing
Me and the boys fighting for the last pizza slice
only one of them is built specifically for speed
The egg mobile
@@KennyBv Clearly!
That thing outruns Sonic on a daily basis, Metal Sonic however fails, every time.
Spectacular!
Silver Sonic had the strength, Mecha Sonic had the smarts, but metal had all that and beyond.
(Also yes I know that he’s actually called Mecha Sonic mk.1, but I find it easier to call him silver Sonic.)
Predictable ending. Would it really have hurt to have Mecha Sonic or Silver Sonic win?
If they win,it will create a plot hole since they were Metal'processors
@@annoying_HK_guy Actually, they weren't.
CD takes place before 2 (apparently), so Metal Sonic was technically Eggman's first attempt at a robot Sonic. I guess the reason he kept coming back was because out of all the models, his was more in line with the real Sonic and thus had the most potential for upgrades.
I can only assume Silver Sonic and Mecha Sonic didn't have as much effort put into them compared to Metal Sonic. Silver was probably made as a quick distraction for Sonic getting on the Death Egg and Mecha was the same for preventing Sonic from boarding the Death Egg a second time.
Rose Supreme actualy he did made silver sonic diferent because he wated to make a robot to be strong not fast and i actualy think that mecha is stonger than metal and have still the same speed. And i think he is a neo metal sonic prototype because of how they look
@@SegaMario im agree... Is not nesecary that the superior always won
Considering that Silver Sonic doesn't even have a consistent naming and is often confused with the 8 bit Silver Sonic...not to mention lacks a personality, he's not anything special.
Mecha Sonic is pretty cool but mostly is remembered because of SMBZ. Otherwise he is a backstabbing traitor, having no quarrels with killing Eggrobo, or at least lacking any sense of guilt.
Metal Sonic is an emotional wreck and deserves hugs. He already let himself die once before so he kinda deserved the win.
THIS IS SO COOL!!!!
Ah true metal, what does it feel like? That they're throwing projectiles at you while you want to win
Silver sonic:combat
Metal sonic:speed
Mecha sonic:mix of both
Metal is like the advanced version of both Mecha one and two I like all of their designs tho and I like all 3 of them this is a good video
Mecha sonic really said:
*"Thanks for the refill G."*
This is what the internet was supposed to be about
0:51
Is something the matter?
IT WILL TAKE MORE THAN THAT!
If only Mecha didnt fuck around with Metal, he woulda won.
I love the metal sonic form sonic 2 he seem the most robotic out of the batch +cool vid
Me encantó como mecha Sonic y silver sonic iban como ellos querían mientras metal Sonic respetaba la jugabilidad xd
si
Metal sonic: I OWN THESE TRACKS
This is how they decide which Metal Sonic to put in the games. And CD Metal always wins.
What is Knuckles even doing on Little Planet 😂
To give mecha assistants
He was a dumbass!!
@@Creg-ev2qm why would he even do that
The important question is how did Knuckles even travel to the future
Who will win?
A robot who murdered Eggrobo in cold blood and Super Saiyan
Or
Metal Boi with speed
Do I have the say this
Me and the boys when there’s pizza rolls
There I said it
First Place: Metal Sonic
Second Place: Mecha Sonic
Last Place: Robo Sonic
Silver Sonic.
@@shardsoftime0952 Shard don't exist
Don't even trying to make something dumb
looks hard bro just supported u
That was interesting Metal sonic meet Me
Metal Sonic, the best Sonic Copy in the world
Odviusly, since the other two never came back in a Sonic game.
@@robobot8702 Mecha was in sonic adventure as a easter egg.
@@Saxton_Hoovy As a enemy they never came back.
Shard: ha! no !
That should be an actual Sonic level, including the super Mecha Sonic attacks at the end, that’d be sick.
The battle of metals:Sonic CD,Sonic 3&K and Sonic 2
The bad future stardust speedway makes sense because there are three robots are in there and they’re all bad.
It was very good!
Mecha Sonic has the most personality....thats why he's my favorite next to Neo Metal Sonic! But he got kinda cocky at the end
This animation is amazing! May I make this a fan game?
0:54 When Silver Sonic was destroyed why didn’t we see the Green Chaos Emerald that’s Inside It like we have In the other times It’s been destroyed.
Metal sonic: I AM THE REAL METAL SONIC
This would make a cool sonic game mode or mini game
Well Silver Sonic is Mk I, Mecha Sonic is Mk II and I like to imagine Metal Sonic is like Perfect Cell. So we just had two prototypes go up against the finished product.
I still can’t get over by the fact that Eggman built an heavier and slower version of Metal after the even of CD
Mecha Sonic + Master Emerald = The perfect metallic rival
This video was literally my idea I was all like who will win and then I found the best sprite animation
Metal overlord SHOULD watch this
metal sonic- the classic
Silver sonic- the clunky one
mecha sonic: the best design
So Even Super Mecha Sonic is not strong enough wow your animations are great man
Metal sonic will always be the best of the 3. Even if mecha is badass
mecha sonic should win
Mecha Sonic is odviusly slower than Metal. And V Maximum Overdrive makes him 4 times faster, so gg.
@@James179 Metal should win at races as he is designed for speed as seen with his movement method being a rocket and the others being wheels.
But, if it has 1v1 combat, mecha sonic completely destroys the other 2 by a wide margin as he has a spin dash ,he can shoot energy from his chest and can absorb chaos energy making him complete invincible even without cause energy he is very strong seen as in sonic 3 and knuckles he took around 30 hits from sonic and knuckles between both stories.
Just because Mecha Sonic transformed, doesn't mean he would win; the super forms have a time limit.
Eggman 1992: sliver sonic your useless
Eggman 1993 : metal sonic you're glorious
Me : dude
Silver sonic is found in sonic 2, Mecha sonic is found in sonic 3 (air, and knuckles), AND METAL IN SONIC CD, AND YOU CONNECTED THEM ALL?
Eggman’s dream, he gets to kill 2 Sonics.
ABAHAHAHAHHAAA
Good one.
COOOOOOOL
In the end, nobody defeats the door at the end of the race.
Fun fact this was the exact same music and metal sonic sound of the metal madness event
You mean the same Generations Metal Sonic track? SSS just used that.
I knew it! Metal Sonic is the superior model.
That is lie
Dario Montero no
Is not a lie, Metal is better than Meca(Silver) and Mecha Sonic. Saying "But Mecha Sonic can go super" means nothing to me. Metal could transform into Metal Overlord by himself without any chaos emeralds
@@4S14K yes
@@robobot8702 we know that metal sonic is superior, but it boring look him win... it would be funny look to silver sonic win
Imagine being faster than a super form, you only made Metal win to please the fans
Sonic on his base form beats super mecha sonic it’s obvious that metal sonic beats super mecha sonic
Imagine being faster than archie sonic...
That’s shard...
@@loryx_0 Sonic never fights super mecha so I dont know what are you on about
and second, knuckles can only damage super mecha when he has to recharge, the same character who knocked super sonic out of sonic
Also you make it sound like metal beat sonic or was even an equal to him when all h does in the race is explode in a wall
@@shardsoftime0952 Shard is not faster, None of his feats in the comic were more impressive than sonic's. The comic where he traps him and tails dont showcase anything of the sort
@@knuckson8304 two years later for that response lmao
Metal almost turned super using the master emerald in the mania animations
Yeah, well until in the Sonic IDW Comics, he has been able to go in his Super form as Neo Metal Sonic(otherwise Super Neo Metal Sonic), before going to his Master Overlord form when he copied Sonic and Shadow's Biodata.
Impressive. I knew Metal Sonic would win
I love the amen breaks
Cool animation. I personally would have had the Sonic & Knuckles mecha-sonic win though, because it was the newest model and because it looks the most bad-ass. Although there's no denying Sega likes to reference the CD model the most, I think most fans like the S&K one.
He has a cool design i must say, it kinda gives off a terminator vibe, but I feel most people really remember him because of his portrayal in SMBZ
Mecha Sonic is an older Robot-Copy Sonic than Metal Sonic. Remember, Sonic CD takes places between Sonic 3&K and Sonic 4
No Metal was the FINAL design and clearly the most advanced out of the 3 ! Coz Metal is the one that actually matched Sonic's speed. And Metal is actually stronger than the other 2, your judgement is biased.
@@justabrokezombie6252 well this aged like milk, considedring it has been confirmed CD takes place after 1. Looks like you are the only one biased here. The wall level robot aint stronger than either
y'all keep talking about his speed but even knuckles outran him in rivals and he got beaten by tails in the classic spinoffs lol
You can say this race is Pretty metal
Metal Sonic is Winner! Cool! :)
This explained why metel sonic was used more often
:WHEN THEY HAVE NOODLES AT 9 IN THE MORNING:
I think everyone wants metal to have more prominence in the saga
And thats how Silver Sonic and Mecha Sonic never appeared again
So i guess the story of this is eggman decided to revive silver and mecha sonic and he made them do a race against metal sonic to see who's the better robot
fanmade dialogues
*at race*
metal sonic: so, this is the metal race, right?
silver sonic: yeah, but I don't think that you can win, baby *laughs*
Mecha sonic: yeah! *laughs*
metal sonic: what's so funny?
Mecha sonic: you are tinier than us, baby *laughs*
metal sonic: I'm more mobile than you, big piece of scrap
Mecha sonic: ow...
Mecha sonic: but we with silver sonic have more weapons, pathetic child *laughs*
eggman: the one who will be first, will be the best robot of you, the losers will get destroyed
Mecha sonic: prepare to get trashed, baby *laughs*
silver sonic: yeah *laughs*
metal sonic: don't make fun of me, because the karma can get you
eggman: the race will start in 3, 2, 1!
*every robot speeds up*
Mecha sonic: how on the earth metal is so fast!
metal sonic: I told you that I'm more mobile
Mecha sonic: that doesn't mean anything
metal sonic: *goes to up*
silver sonic: I don't need to get up *burst through the up road*
metal sonic: aaaaaaaaa! *falls*
Mecha sonic: pathetic *laughs*
metal sonic: not so fast *use super booster*
Mecha sonic: what the hell?
silver sonic: *get hit by spikes and deactivates*
eggman: pathetic garbage *destroys silver sonic*
Mecha sonic: nooooooooo!
metal sonic: catch me if you can *speeds up*
Mecha sonic: he is too fast, I can't catch up him
knuckles: *pushing the master emerald* why it's so heavy?
metal sonic: *flying above knuckles and stuns him*
knuckles: oh no
Mecha sonic: oh yeah! the master emerald! *jumps on master emerald and turns super*
metal sonic: too slow
super Mecha sonic: *overtakes metal sonic* no, you're too slow
metal sonic: hey! that's unfair! *boosts*
super Mecha sonic: can you dodge this? *shoots at metal sonic with explosive rings*
metal sonic: *dodges*
super Mecha sonic: I'm not done! *trys to hit metal sonic*
metal sonic: *dodges again* you missed! *spindashes*
super Mecha sonic: hey! where are you going! *flys*
eggman: it's almost finished
super Mecha sonic: *overtakes metal sonic again*
metal sonic: he is too fast...
metal sonic: I have to take extreme measures *uses super booster and overtakes Mecha sonic*
super Mecha sonic: nooooooooo!
metal sonic: yes!
super Mecha sonic: *hits wall* aaaaaaaaa! *gets destroyed*
metal sonic: I told you about karma
eggman: not bad metal sonic! you proved that you are the best robot!
metal sonic: yay!
METAL SONIC WON YEAH BABY I WAS VOTING FOR HIM TO WIN AND HE DID!!!!Who else agree with me that metal sonic was suppose to win huh who agrees with me hm.
Let's be honest Metal is Faster than Meca Sonic and Mecha Sonic. Meca couldn't stop in time and stomped into the spikes cause he acts too slow for being a "obstacles race", Mecha Sonic maybe faster in reaction than Meca, but Metal still fast as Sonic is and his V Maximum Overdrive makes him four times faster. And yes, I am calling Silver Sonic "Meca Sonic" just because I don't like calling him "Silver".
Well he is suppose to win as if he didnt he would be the most useless robot ever as he designed to for speed and he only just beat mecha sonic who was built for power so given how close it was metal is still quite bad even at his speciality.
Ahh of course good ol metal Sonic for teh win
les go, that's what I'm talkin about
Metal Sonic’s rank: S rank!
This is how robotnik picks his robots
It would make sense for Metal Sonic to win cause Robo/Silver Sonic and Mecha Sonic were originally Metal Sonic Prototypes
In the timeline, Sonic CD is before Sonic 2 and Sonic 3
Mechasonic: **uses master emerald power**
Mechasonic:i can win the race now but.... Ama lose my time and attack metal sonic... Yea that can work*
Metal Sonic can learn his enemy's and others' skills, abilitys, speeds and after just use it and Metal was race with Sonic once and he know now hlw much speed he needs, also because of this he can win easily a race or a battle
I see... it's plain ol' vanilla mecha sonic and not SMBZ mecha sonic.
If it was SMBZ Mecha Sonic that would be one sided.
If it was SMBZ Mecha Sonic, Metal Sonic, Eggman, Knuckles and Silver Sonic would be hot piles of ash within a minute of the race starting