Anthe punul mairandii kide sollunge Lag nu sonna eriyuthuna Malayalam movie eduke sollu Tamilan kasu le thinnure pekuthii engalukku advice mairu pandrana?
என் 11 வயது மகன் கல்கியின் பொன்னியின் செல்வனை படித்து இருக்கிறான்....அவனுக்கு PS 2 மிகவும் பிடித்தது......இது மணிரத்னத்தின் பொன்னியின் செல்வன், ஒரு 3 மணி நேர படத்தில் இவ்வளவு detail தான் காட்ட முடியும் அப்பா என்று எனக்கு அவன் சொன்ன போது நான் ஆச்சர்ய பட்டென்......அவன் சொன்னது - எதிர்காலத்தில் என் generation advanced animation use பண்ணி முழு நாவலையும் கல்கியின் கற்பனையை முழுதாக எடுக்கும்! காத்திருப்போம்
@@kathirm7733 இந்த வெறியை குழந்தைக்கு கடத்த கூடாது. ரவிதாசன் என்கிற பிராம்மணன் தான் கரிகாலனை கொன்றான் என்று அவனுக்கு தெரியும் ஆனால் ஒட்டு மொத்த பிராமனர்களும் தவறு இல்லை...என் ஆழ்வார்க்கடியான், அனிருத்த பிரம்மராயர் கூட பிராமணர்கள் தான்....அதனால் என் மகன் வயதிலேயே சிறியவன்....சில பேர் மூளை வளர்ச்சி அடையாத சிறியவர்கள்
Ellam correct thaan but neenga itha love storya paathu eduthingana athuku KARIKALANIN KADHAL nu per vachi irukanum aprm ethuku sambathamae illama ponniyin selvan per vachinga
இவர்தான் "தான் வாழ்ந்த காலத்தில் கலைஞர் கருணாநிதி என்று ஒருவர் இருந்தார்" என்று நாளைய வரலாற்றில் ஒரு சிறு குறிப்பு மட்டுமே இருக்கும் என்று ஆணவத்துடன் பேசியவர்
@@triplemtruckers8537 To enjoy good healthy state of mind is enough. Dirty mind like yours only will talk dirty talk like this. Ponniyin Selvan novel is still a hit since 1950. Surely without support of dirty minded guys like you. you guys are example of cheap exceptions. so exceptions are not examples. People like you guys are making confusion to yourself and others and confusing entire society. thats why you are in that level. Hope you understand I am not talking about how much money you make, how healthy to the society you are.
This is not kaki's ponniy in selvan. Jeyamohan's "Nandhini" Tamil Film. As a kalki's PS Fan I was not satisfied. I miss the twists and humours, Manimegalai, senthan amuthan.
Audience - movie is boring, lagging, not engaging Other directors - sorry guys ,I will rectify it in the next movie Maniratnam and his kannis - you don't have the standards to review my cinema because you dunno to appreciate art.
புளூசட்டை எதிர்மறை காய்ச்சலால் பாதிக்கப்பட்டு கவலைக்கிடமான நிலையில் இருக்கிறார். அதைப் பார்க்கும் மற்றவர்களுக்கும் நொடிக்குள் தொற்றுகிறது. கவனமாக இருங்கள்.
One must accept ps2 is not upto the mark and it doesn't meet expected quality. The movie story telling is flat. Would have been better if director spent more time and money in making ps rather than finishing in 360 days.
True As the story is complex And top of that the idiot mani changed the climax which is not in novel So he failed to satisfy both reader and non readers! And top of that crowning ceremony is so flat ! I really appreciate crowning ceremony of baahubali just to enhance how a kingdom has different types of padai
Not only that. First 15 minutes about nandhini and adhithya karikalan is not needed according to me. instead that 15 minutes could had spent with explaining how senthan amuthan is real heir. movie could had been better. also the way the climax ceremony sworn is could had been better as in the novel. Arulmozhi suddenly keep the crown on Senthan Amuthan would had been good.
How dare he says "ppl who say lag dun have cinema knowledge" ..... Audience have the right to say whether the movie is "lag" "boring" etc.... Because we pay money and they beg us for watching the movie so that they can get their yield (box office) .... How dare this guy he says that audience should not say that a movie is "lag" He thinks great about himself that he is a legendary artist who is always right and no one should say he has given boring output
Well explained.. We rarely get few variety of flims in tamil cinema which are like live cinema else we get same type of flims giving importance worshipping heroism..I haven't read book not going to attempt to read because to be frank most of the people dont have patience and time I am one of them..I respect book readers but Most of youngsters who told in reviews they have read the book.. I hope thats big lie these days we hear half cooked stories from UA-cam..I like this version of ponniyin selvan . It's a great work, everyone worked with great dedication and succeeded..
@@ramankv7717 தகவலுக்கு நன்றி . பூநூல் என் சாதி அடையாளத்தை அறிமுகப்படுத்தியது யார் ? சற்று பணம் அதிகமாக கொடுத்தால் எவருக்கும் பூநூல் அணிவித்து சடங்குகள் செய்யும் பார்ப்பனிய.
Movie has its moments but it crumbles on the over storytelling and flat narration..vikram death is peak of the moment...but it comes very very deep in the movie upto where one need patience....climax seems fake vasaline for jayamravi as he doesn't have anything in the movie .. Overall it's a decent watch...
கல்கியின் பொன்னியின் செல்வன் கதையின் brand image மற்றும் அந்த கதைக்கான goodwill ஐ பயன்படுத்தி படத்தின் வியாபாரத்தை promote செய்த மணிரத்னம் ஏன் படத்துக்கு ஆங்கிலத்தில் PS-1 & PS-2 என்று பெயர் வைத்தார்? இது என்ன Mission impossible (MI) & Men in black (MIB) மாதிரியா? PS stands for Post Script
Mani ratnam and jeyamohan are both geniuses. Thaazhvumanapaanmaiyil brahmanargalai veruppadhurkku badhilaga ninggalum avargalai pol arivil sirandhavargalaaga muyarchiyunggal. Vaai savadaal mathum poraadhu.Empty vessel makes a lot of sound😊.
This guy doesn’t read history properly.. chozhas who are shiva devotees have namam.. Sundara chola or anyone except Nandhini has that long haired head.. shivaji in raja raja cholan has that long hair do . Even napoleon in vishwaroopam song has good costumes.. this is no way related to cholas..
Adthithan sava mothu he believed that nandhini was his sister atha yen da mathi kadhal padam yedukura. Everything is based on adthithan avar savanum vendi val nakshathiram nikkuthu athu kizha vizhura mario illa mariyira mario kuda shot illa what kinda of story telling this.
Let’s leave aside all historical inaccuracies and unnecessary politics both ps1 and ps2 were boring movies . Maniratnam strength is romance, human emotions and fantastic camera but he is not good for making grand movies that needs to show war and grand scenes .
You are expecting fantacy and larger than life movies for which you should not watch Mani Ratnam movies rather should watch Rajamouli and Director Hari movies ,Mani Ratnam is a realistic movie maker combined with integrating human instincts in subtle manner , you should watch his Iruvar movie for more artistic values . Mani Ratnam made PS1and PS2 in a realistic and artistically showing characters aesthetically and war scenes realistically without any unbelievable exaggeration.
Who told you this movie was grand and needed war ? It is also a romance and a story of human emotion which all the actors showed. It's about loyalty, admiration, friendship
The same people who praised thalapathy, nayakan, alaipayuthey , criticized PS2 and they have full rights to do so .... The very same cinema knowledge/sense of people told them to praise alaipayuthey , told people to criticize PS2...... And hence you don't have the right to say that " those who say movie is lag they don't have cinema sense "
To the brahmin haters in the comments, The brahmin community itself has so many divisions. You guys are making a connection between current tamil brahmins to so called brahmins 2000 years ago. Doesnt make any sense.
Not a hater of any sect, but why does Kalki have to change the identity of the four conspirators who were responsible for the death of Aaditha Karikaalan? The movie also portrays the four conspirators as close as possible to being barbaric.
The movie is even worse, it’s delusional to think a warrior / crown prince would force his hand and make Nandini kill him, leaving they entire kingdom and chola legacy in jeopardy.
Aditha Karikalan death : 1. Real killers - 4 brahmins from Udayarkudi Chola inscriptions 2. Killers according to Kalki - fictional character Nandini and Pandyan spies 3. Killers according to Mani Ratnam and Jeyamohan - committed suicide by pushing knife into himself Well done da agraharam puliyodharais...
உலகில் உயிர் வாழும் அறிவாளிகளில் மிகவும் முக்கியமானவர் இந்த ஜெயமோகன். இவருக்கு கூகுளை , விக்கிப்பீடியாவை விட, லண்டன் லைப்ரரியை விட நிறைய தெரியும். இவ்வளவு அறிவுள்ள எல்லாம் தெரிந்த ஜெயமோகனுக்கு அமெரிக்க அரசு நோபல் பரிசு ஆஸ்கார் உள்ளிட்ட விருதுகளைத் தந்து கௌரவிக்க வேண்டும்.
Marvel movies laam based from marvel comics but adhukunu comics la irukuradaye movie la edhu nu sonna mudyuma ? Apdi dhn idhuvum....this movie is based on Kalki's Novel but that doesn't mean it should be exactly like the book Also idhae writer dhn viduthalai yum edutharu apo terlaya ivar brahmin nu ? Inga mozhil, jaadi, madam nu ellarum arasiyal dhn panranga....anda arasiyal sindhanaiya manasula yethikitu inga naama hatred dhn spread pannitu irukomo. Edhuku ? Oru padam adha rasichoma nu vitranum!! Edhuku ivlo vanmam.....tamil oh aariyam oh yaara irundalum anda perla aaluravan dhn aaluran......makkal enga naalum adhae kastam dhn padrom.....modhal idealogies ah mattumae nambuna..adha vechu dhn avanga arasiyal pandranga......just spread humanity!!!
True bro + But Marvel or Harry Potter franchise le koode highlighted scenes ellame book le iruntha maariye irukkum + Cause they don't disappoint the readers also + Anthe yukthi PS le illaiye + Kundhathai Josiyar scene for example + He will predict that Vaanathi will marry Raja Raja Chozhan and Kundhavai with Vanthiyathevan + Vaanathi kitte oru vishyam extra solvaaru + Vaanathi's son will be a great warrior too + And as we know it's Rajendra Cholan + Another incident climax le Ponniyin Selvan Senthan Amuthanukku thaan manimudi suttuvaar + And once Poonguzhali will said to Senthan Amuthan that she will marry to a royal king and finally her dream comes true by marrying Senthan + Ithu ellame mukkiyamaana scenes + Readers ku ituthaan veenum + But athuve illame poonaa yethukku Ponniyin Selvan ? Real history vechi Raja Raja Cholan story sollirukalaame ? 👍
Inthe film le manimagudam scene le koodhe Senthan Amuthan + Poonguzhali illave illai + Crown thaan tharale + Coronation scene le koode illaiye + Nyayamaa ? Ponniyin Selvan thanakku uthavi senjavangale nandri marapaaraa + Poonguzhali padage Buddha viharathukku time ku kondu poogale naa Ponniyin Selvan will be death + Uyir kaapathunavangale maranthuruvaara Ponniyin Selvan ? Kalki's main character Poonguzhali and Senthan Amudhan + Movie le side kicks character maari vechirukaange + Truly not acceptable 😢👍
I was disappointed with ps 2 as it was very rushed and they missed important points such as Arunmozhi love on pongualzi and also the truth about Sendan Amudhan Birth and he is also the heir for cholan Also, Kundavi and Vandiyathevan marriage or engagement was missing. The worst was Karikalan sucide was unjustified.The entire cast did a great job, especially Vikram, and Aishwarya climax was great.
Aditha Karikalan death : 1. Real killers - 4 brahmins from Udayarkudi Chola inscriptions 2. Killers according to Kalki - fictional character Nandini and Pandyan spies 3. Killers according to Mani Ratnam and Jeyamohan - committed suicide by pushing knife into himself Well done da agraharam puliyodahrais!
I can only say that the writer and the director thinks that Tamil Audience are Stupid who cannot understand a complex narrative. And the writer in this interview also acknowledges it by saying Tamil people has no intellect to enjoy the original narrative as written by Kalki
Unga mella thappu sonna thiruthi nxt time nalla yedunga aatha vittutu cinema pakka theriyathu lag aa iruntha lag nu thaan solluvanga.ungaluku mattum vantha aathu goosebump illa yellorukkum vantha thaan goosebump
Something said subtle......thats all....everywhere ps1 and ps2 they spk a lot abt history nd novel...but u have said cinema is cinema....just entertain...enjoy the scenes.....but still dont say this as history and take ur school gng children...and feed this story...this is not history
Read the book, the names of those Brahmins have been applied to non Brahmins only. Jayamohan made no decisions, mani ratnam is hated by all Brahmins, he's of Dravidian ideology, and he wrote this. And in the book there are very strong hints he committed suicide
@@jaxsetbertoncarlism8873 ya that’s what kalaki tried to tweek the history and PS changed it completely as bandits / Buddhist monks.. 😡 but we know the history from udaiyarkudi temple that those were Brahmins
Another PERINGAYA DUBBA Jayamohan He is not suits for Cinema.. He works for Payment.. If u pay more he can change story like .. SUNDARA CHIOLAN KLLED ATHITHYA KARIKALAN.. He can write novel but Not for cinema...
JeyaMohan , don't force or show brahminism in your movie. We Like PONNIYIN SELVAN History not PONNIYIN SELVAN story written by KALKI. Udayar KOVIL Kalveetu sonna ni odi poi paduthupa, Karikalan was killed by Brahmins and ArulMozhi avargalai oda vittar. Saivism is great but not the brahminism and HInduism.
To all crew and cast of PS2. Henceforth, don't venture to destroy the history and a great novel. It's painful to see the diversion from the history and the ugly way of bringing unwanted scenes from reality. Hope all team members would have understood what I mean to say. Not to have a huge budget for such cinemas.
I think you could show some little respect while talking in the group. He clearly says on which angle he made the story. that is his wish, but changing the climax only was not good.
ps-1,ps-2 are such a amazing movie. indha movie waste nu solravan oru muthal kootame. ithu onnum rajamouli fantasy movie illa. just mani ratnam movie. sema cinematography. ivanungalukku fights and shooting kaatuna super movie nu solluvanunga. worst people.inga pesuravan oruthanukku kooda varalaaru theriyathu.
Aditha Karikalan death : 1. Real killers - 4 brahmins from Udayarkudi Chola inscriptions 2. Killers according to Kalki - fictional character Nandini and Pandyan spies 3. Killers according to Mani Ratnam and Jeyamohan - committed suicide by pushing knife into himself Well done da agraharam puliyodahrais!
Neenga yennatha uthar vittalum ponnyn selvan history ye vera mathiri commercial cinema kaga change panna thappu..amarar kalki ku kaal thoosi ku varathu nee eluthuna script
நல்லாவே உருட்டுங்க..கேரள நம்பூத்...திரி...RSS. Having done great injustice to the truth of the great history of Chola Dynasty, you all are blowing your own trumpet without shame. Your clan should kneel down before the legends and giants of celluloid world. I.e. Sivaji Ganesan, APN, Kannadasan, MSV, TMS, Sridar who were all famous for their scintillating contribution. ..Listen and go through my play , Chola Prince Athitha Karikalan (not Athithya Karikalan) which was broadcast thro ALL INDIA RADIO, in 2018, drama competition week. You have butchered the Chola history with the high tint of notoriety.
Aditha Karikalan death : 1. Real killers - 4 brahmins from Udayarkudi Chola inscriptions 2. Killers according to Kalki - fictional character Nandini and Pandyan spies 3. Killers according to Mani Ratnam and Jeyamohan - committed suicide by pushing knife into himself Well done da agraharam puliyodahrais!
But we can't be sure who killed him exactly on the basis of temple inscription which happened 1000 years ago right 😅common people's murder cases of recent times are being unsolved and tampering evidences so it's not a big surprise for us to think over whatsoever royal secrets would had been covered up in those days from revealing to people of chola dynasty. Anything could have happened 😕 one thing for sure he was murdered
@@DarthSidious7 next what Gandhi was not shot by Godse...he died due to stomach ache 🤣🤣 These thairsadhams and their whitewashing to cover up their ancestors atrocities 🤣🤣
🎶CINEULAGAM presents SOUND OF MADRAS🎶
Book Tickets👇
insider.in/sound-of-madras-may6-2023/event
📢Date & Venue: May 6th, CODISSIA GROUND (Coimbatore)
Anthe punul mairandii kide sollunge
Lag nu sonna eriyuthuna
Malayalam movie eduke sollu
Tamilan kasu le thinnure pekuthii engalukku advice mairu pandrana?
திரு. குமரவேல் அவர்களைப் பேட்டி எடுக்கலாமே
என் 11 வயது மகன் கல்கியின் பொன்னியின் செல்வனை படித்து இருக்கிறான்....அவனுக்கு PS 2 மிகவும் பிடித்தது......இது மணிரத்னத்தின் பொன்னியின் செல்வன், ஒரு 3 மணி நேர படத்தில் இவ்வளவு detail தான் காட்ட முடியும் அப்பா என்று எனக்கு அவன் சொன்ன போது நான் ஆச்சர்ய பட்டென்......அவன் சொன்னது - எதிர்காலத்தில் என் generation advanced animation use பண்ணி முழு நாவலையும் கல்கியின் கற்பனையை முழுதாக எடுக்கும்! காத்திருப்போம்
என் வாழ்த்துக்கள்
Yo avnta solu Adiththa karikalan la Kona thau 4 bramins nu atha animation pana solu maina poo nool
@@kathirm7733 இந்த வெறியை குழந்தைக்கு கடத்த கூடாது. ரவிதாசன் என்கிற பிராம்மணன் தான் கரிகாலனை கொன்றான் என்று அவனுக்கு தெரியும் ஆனால் ஒட்டு மொத்த பிராமனர்களும் தவறு இல்லை...என் ஆழ்வார்க்கடியான், அனிருத்த பிரம்மராயர் கூட பிராமணர்கள் தான்....அதனால் என் மகன் வயதிலேயே சிறியவன்....சில பேர் மூளை வளர்ச்சி அடையாத சிறியவர்கள்
Actually Ps-2 Movie is really nice - fantastic Music , screenplay , location and camera
Well said jayamohan sir 🎉🎉🎉
Movie is superb. To condense such a huge novel to a movie itself is an amazing job.forget the dravidiya detractors u have done a brilliant job!
Ellam correct thaan but neenga itha love storya paathu eduthingana athuku KARIKALANIN KADHAL nu per vachi irukanum aprm ethuku sambathamae illama ponniyin selvan per vachinga
Itha thaaan naan kekka vanthen... Nee keettuta 😂
Apo thana ellarum theatre kulla varuvanga
😂😂😂😂
Brahmins are even on that days, with pandyas and cholas don't curse them guys!! But Adithya karikalan was killed by Brahmin secretary of pandyas
PS not an ordinary movie it is a ART 🎭
Emotion driven action,tight screenplay will definitely result in activating every cell. Heart meets mind. Goosebumps.
இவர்தான் "தான் வாழ்ந்த காலத்தில் கலைஞர் கருணாநிதி என்று ஒருவர் இருந்தார்" என்று நாளைய வரலாற்றில் ஒரு சிறு குறிப்பு மட்டுமே இருக்கும் என்று ஆணவத்துடன் பேசியவர்
Useless fellow with inflated ego and presumed talent.
குறிப்பு கூட இருக்காது.
@@ramankv7717 Whos?
I had a nice time watching this Interview :)
Punul boys
@@triplemtruckers8537 To enjoy good healthy state of mind is enough. Dirty mind like yours only will talk dirty talk like this. Ponniyin Selvan novel is still a hit since 1950. Surely without support of dirty minded guys like you. you guys are example of cheap exceptions. so exceptions are not examples. People like you guys are making confusion to yourself and others and confusing entire society. thats why you are in that level. Hope you understand I am not talking about how much money you make, how healthy to the society you are.
வரலாற்றை வாசித்து எழுதியிருக்க. வேண்டும் எதற்கு பொய் சொல்ல இத்தனை தோரணை
Climix மிகபெரிய தவறு
Myself and my friend bought this book after seeing this pic.super film
This is not kaki's ponniy
in selvan. Jeyamohan's "Nandhini" Tamil Film. As a kalki's PS Fan I was not satisfied. I miss the twists and humours, Manimegalai, senthan amuthan.
Audience - movie is boring, lagging, not engaging
Other directors - sorry guys ,I will rectify it in the next movie
Maniratnam and his kannis - you don't have the standards to review my cinema because you dunno to appreciate art.
புளுகுறதுக்கும் ஒரு அளவு வேண்டாமா மேதாவி ஜெயமோகன் அவர்களே...
ப்ளுசட்டை மாறனின் விமர்சனத்தை அவசியம் பார்க்கவும்...
புளூசட்டை எதிர்மறை காய்ச்சலால் பாதிக்கப்பட்டு கவலைக்கிடமான நிலையில் இருக்கிறார். அதைப் பார்க்கும் மற்றவர்களுக்கும் நொடிக்குள் தொற்றுகிறது. கவனமாக இருங்கள்.
Past one year Blue Sattai Maran review is with lot of intention - Not real (I watched his review regularly now I stopped)
Change is imminent. Accept it.
Interesting!! Audience category was well explained👏 nice interview!
Punull boys 😂
One must accept ps2 is not upto the mark and it doesn't meet expected quality. The movie story telling is flat. Would have been better if director spent more time and money in making ps rather than finishing in 360 days.
True
As the story is complex
And top of that the idiot mani changed the climax which is not in novel
So he failed to satisfy both reader and non readers!
And top of that crowning ceremony is so flat !
I really appreciate crowning ceremony of baahubali just to enhance how a kingdom has different types of padai
Not only that. First 15 minutes about nandhini and adhithya karikalan is not needed according to me. instead that 15 minutes could had spent with explaining how senthan amuthan is real heir. movie could had been better. also the way the climax ceremony sworn is could had been better as in the novel. Arulmozhi suddenly keep the crown on Senthan Amuthan would had been good.
How dare he says "ppl who say lag dun have cinema knowledge" ..... Audience have the right to say whether the movie is "lag" "boring" etc.... Because we pay money and they beg us for watching the movie so that they can get their yield (box office) .... How dare this guy he says that audience should not say that a movie is "lag"
He thinks great about himself that he is a legendary artist who is always right and no one should say he has given boring output
Excellent points sir👏
Well explained.. We rarely get few variety of flims in tamil cinema which are like live cinema else we get same type of flims giving importance worshipping heroism..I haven't read book not going to attempt to read because to be frank most of the people dont have patience and time I am one of them..I respect book readers but Most of youngsters who told in reviews they have read the book.. I hope thats big lie these days we hear half cooked stories from UA-cam..I like this version of ponniyin selvan . It's a great work, everyone worked with great dedication and succeeded..
தமிழர்கள் பணத்தில் தமிழர் வரலாற்றை திணிப்பதை தமிழர் நாம் எதற்க்கு கொண்டாடவேண்டும்?
சோழருக்கு எப்படி பூனூல்?
சத்ரியன் பூணூல் போடுவர்.
@@ramankv7717 அது தமிழர் முறையா? பூநூல் யார்ன் திணிப்பு?
@@smileinurhand
சத்ரியன் மட்டுமல்ல. மர வேலை , பொற்கொல்லர், இரும்பு வேலை செய்பவர், வணிகம் செய்பவர் என பலரும் பூணூல் போடும் பழக்கம் இருந்தது.
@@ramankv7717 தகவலுக்கு நன்றி .
பூநூல் என் சாதி அடையாளத்தை அறிமுகப்படுத்தியது யார் ?
சற்று பணம் அதிகமாக கொடுத்தால் எவருக்கும் பூநூல் அணிவித்து சடங்குகள் செய்யும் பார்ப்பனிய.
Wonderful analysis
Movie has its moments but it crumbles on the over storytelling and flat narration..vikram death is peak of the moment...but it comes very very deep in the movie upto where one need patience....climax seems fake vasaline for jayamravi as he doesn't have anything in the movie ..
Overall it's a decent watch...
கல்கியின் பொன்னியின் செல்வன் கதையின் brand image மற்றும் அந்த கதைக்கான goodwill ஐ பயன்படுத்தி படத்தின் வியாபாரத்தை promote செய்த மணிரத்னம் ஏன் படத்துக்கு ஆங்கிலத்தில் PS-1 & PS-2 என்று பெயர் வைத்தார்? இது என்ன Mission impossible (MI) & Men in black (MIB) மாதிரியா? PS stands for Post Script
Mani ratnam and jeyamohan are both geniuses. Thaazhvumanapaanmaiyil brahmanargalai veruppadhurkku badhilaga ninggalum avargalai pol arivil sirandhavargalaaga muyarchiyunggal. Vaai savadaal mathum poraadhu.Empty vessel makes a lot of sound😊.
This guy doesn’t read history properly.. chozhas who are shiva devotees have namam.. Sundara chola or anyone except Nandhini has that long haired head.. shivaji in raja raja cholan has that long hair do . Even napoleon in vishwaroopam song has good costumes.. this is no way related to cholas..
15:57 to 20:12
Adthithan sava mothu he believed that nandhini was his sister atha yen da mathi kadhal padam yedukura.
Everything is based on adthithan avar savanum vendi val nakshathiram nikkuthu athu kizha vizhura mario illa mariyira mario kuda shot illa what kinda of story telling this.
Screenplay dialogue rmba sumaruu
OMG he thinks he is the only genius existing in this universe…
Learn real history before commenting boy.
@@shaneethan523 it’s not about the history it’s about the attitude
@@kamalkumarjranjan1954 Ok. Sorry for the misunderstanding.
Let’s leave aside all historical inaccuracies and unnecessary politics both ps1 and ps2 were boring movies . Maniratnam strength is romance, human emotions and fantastic camera but he is not good for making grand movies that needs to show war and grand scenes .
You are expecting fantacy and larger than life movies for which you should not watch Mani Ratnam movies rather should watch Rajamouli and Director Hari movies ,Mani Ratnam is a realistic movie maker combined with integrating human instincts in subtle manner , you should watch his Iruvar movie for more artistic values . Mani Ratnam made PS1and PS2 in a realistic and artistically showing characters aesthetically and war scenes realistically without any unbelievable exaggeration.
Who told you this movie was grand and needed war ? It is also a romance and a story of human emotion which all the actors showed. It's about loyalty, admiration, friendship
The same people who praised thalapathy, nayakan, alaipayuthey , criticized PS2 and they have full rights to do so .... The very same cinema knowledge/sense of people told them to praise alaipayuthey , told people to criticize PS2...... And hence you don't have the right to say that " those who say movie is lag they don't have cinema sense "
To the brahmin haters in the comments, The brahmin community itself has so many divisions. You guys are making a connection between current tamil brahmins to so called brahmins 2000 years ago. Doesnt make any sense.
Not a hater of any sect, but why does Kalki have to change the identity of the four conspirators who were responsible for the death of Aaditha Karikaalan? The movie also portrays the four conspirators as close as possible to being barbaric.
The movie is even worse, it’s delusional to think a warrior / crown prince would force his hand and make Nandini kill him, leaving they entire kingdom and chola legacy in jeopardy.
You mean to say Tamil Parpanars are not brahmins? Who are the brahmins 2000 years ago? or do you say that Tamil parpanars or not Brahmins?
Dei nayeee innum ninge apdiye thanda irukinge bramane thevidiyaaa pasangala
Aditha Karikalan death :
1. Real killers - 4 brahmins from Udayarkudi Chola inscriptions
2. Killers according to Kalki - fictional character Nandini and Pandyan spies
3. Killers according to Mani Ratnam and Jeyamohan - committed suicide by pushing knife into himself
Well done da agraharam puliyodharais...
ஆணவத்தில் படம் எடுத்தால் இப்படிதான்😂
உலகில் உயிர் வாழும் அறிவாளிகளில் மிகவும் முக்கியமானவர் இந்த ஜெயமோகன். இவருக்கு கூகுளை , விக்கிப்பீடியாவை விட, லண்டன் லைப்ரரியை விட நிறைய தெரியும். இவ்வளவு அறிவுள்ள எல்லாம் தெரிந்த ஜெயமோகனுக்கு அமெரிக்க அரசு நோபல் பரிசு ஆஸ்கார் உள்ளிட்ட விருதுகளைத் தந்து கௌரவிக்க வேண்டும்.
இந்த படத்திற்கு மணிரத்னம் என்ற இயக்குநரும் இந்த வசனகர்த்தாவும் தேவையற்ற நபர்கள்.wasted
Marvel movies laam based from marvel comics but adhukunu comics la irukuradaye movie la edhu nu sonna mudyuma ? Apdi dhn idhuvum....this movie is based on Kalki's Novel but that doesn't mean it should be exactly like the book
Also idhae writer dhn viduthalai yum edutharu apo terlaya ivar brahmin nu ? Inga mozhil, jaadi, madam nu ellarum arasiyal dhn panranga....anda arasiyal sindhanaiya manasula yethikitu inga naama hatred dhn spread pannitu irukomo. Edhuku ? Oru padam adha rasichoma nu vitranum!! Edhuku ivlo vanmam.....tamil oh aariyam oh yaara irundalum anda perla aaluravan dhn aaluran......makkal enga naalum adhae kastam dhn padrom.....modhal idealogies ah mattumae nambuna..adha vechu dhn avanga arasiyal pandranga......just spread humanity!!!
Correct...
Btw jayamohan brahmin illa bro
@@pradeepshankar1292 naan general ah solran bro....
True bro. I watched PS2 yesterday and it was really entertaining from start to end.
True bro + But Marvel or Harry Potter franchise le koode highlighted scenes ellame book le iruntha maariye irukkum + Cause they don't disappoint the readers also + Anthe yukthi PS le illaiye + Kundhathai Josiyar scene for example + He will predict that Vaanathi will marry Raja Raja Chozhan and Kundhavai with Vanthiyathevan + Vaanathi kitte oru vishyam extra solvaaru + Vaanathi's son will be a great warrior too + And as we know it's Rajendra Cholan + Another incident climax le Ponniyin Selvan Senthan Amuthanukku thaan manimudi suttuvaar + And once Poonguzhali will said to Senthan Amuthan that she will marry to a royal king and finally her dream comes true by marrying Senthan + Ithu ellame mukkiyamaana scenes + Readers ku ituthaan veenum + But athuve illame poonaa yethukku Ponniyin Selvan ? Real history vechi Raja Raja Cholan story sollirukalaame ? 👍
Inthe film le manimagudam scene le koodhe Senthan Amuthan + Poonguzhali illave illai + Crown thaan tharale + Coronation scene le koode illaiye + Nyayamaa ? Ponniyin Selvan thanakku uthavi senjavangale nandri marapaaraa + Poonguzhali padage Buddha viharathukku time ku kondu poogale naa Ponniyin Selvan will be death + Uyir kaapathunavangale maranthuruvaara Ponniyin Selvan ? Kalki's main character Poonguzhali and Senthan Amudhan + Movie le side kicks character maari vechirukaange + Truly not acceptable 😢👍
Sir ... We can give reasons for everything... But if your cinema cannot pull the audience to theatre its not a hit
nenacha madiriye ellam comments kazhuvi moonjila oothirikinga, magizhchi mattatra magizhchi....!
I was disappointed with ps 2 as it was very rushed and they missed important points such as Arunmozhi love on pongualzi and also the truth about Sendan Amudhan Birth and he is also the heir for cholan Also, Kundavi and Vandiyathevan marriage or engagement was missing. The worst was Karikalan sucide was unjustified.The entire cast did a great job, especially Vikram, and Aishwarya climax was great.
True to the core. Hats off.
Aditha Karikalan death :
1. Real killers - 4 brahmins from Udayarkudi Chola inscriptions
2. Killers according to Kalki - fictional character Nandini and Pandyan spies
3. Killers according to Mani Ratnam and Jeyamohan - committed suicide by pushing knife into himself
Well done da agraharam puliyodahrais!
@@thamizhdesiyan8204 not true. Writing your own history. Share a source for your "Chola inscriptions" 😂
This version made sure there were justification for every ones action. Had closure. Much better than Kalkis version
@@yevanooruvan7071 please they made Karikalan death to be suicide and yet you call that better than kalki. Where was manimagelai an important role...
I can only say that the writer and the director thinks that Tamil Audience are Stupid who cannot understand a complex narrative. And the writer in this interview also acknowledges it by saying Tamil people has no intellect to enjoy the original narrative as written by Kalki
Unga mella thappu sonna thiruthi nxt time nalla yedunga aatha vittutu cinema pakka theriyathu lag aa iruntha lag nu thaan solluvanga.ungaluku mattum vantha aathu goosebump illa yellorukkum vantha thaan goosebump
Something said subtle......thats all....everywhere ps1 and ps2 they spk a lot abt history nd novel...but u have said cinema is cinema....just entertain...enjoy the scenes.....but still dont say this as history and take ur school gng children...and feed this story...this is not history
திரு. குமரவேல் அவர்களை ஏன் பேட்டி எடுக்கவில்லை?
Views vantha petti edupanga. Ungala Gandu ethina parpeenga.
Will there be a ps3
4 Bramins kola Karangrtha Marika kalki mani Jaya mohan la nala mutuu and uruttu poi pithaltatam
Read the book, the names of those Brahmins have been applied to non Brahmins only. Jayamohan made no decisions, mani ratnam is hated by all Brahmins, he's of Dravidian ideology, and he wrote this. And in the book there are very strong hints he committed suicide
@@jaxsetbertoncarlism8873 ya that’s what kalaki tried to tweek the history and PS changed it completely as bandits / Buddhist monks.. 😡 but we know the history from udaiyarkudi temple that those were Brahmins
Another PERINGAYA DUBBA Jayamohan He is not suits for Cinema.. He works for Payment.. If u pay more he can change story like .. SUNDARA CHIOLAN KLLED ATHITHYA KARIKALAN.. He can write novel but Not for cinema...
He didn't decide anything, it's mani ratnams final say. Of course everyone works for payment
இவன் மட்டும் தான் உலகத்திலேயே அறிவாளி மாதிரி பேசுறான்.... பாப்பான் திமிரு
He is not even a brahmin u sick mind
JeyaMohan , don't force or show brahminism in your movie. We Like PONNIYIN SELVAN History not PONNIYIN SELVAN story written by KALKI. Udayar KOVIL Kalveetu sonna ni odi poi paduthupa, Karikalan was killed by Brahmins and ArulMozhi avargalai oda vittar. Saivism is great but not the brahminism and HInduism.
U semi literate moron kalki himself is a brahmin and jeyamohan is a sudra 😂
Dei engada brahminism kammikuranga kirukku mental... Nee oru padam eduthuruviya... Enannu kooda unaku theriyadhu... Kandatha kelappividatha kirukka
Then don't watch...if you don't like kalki's ponniyin selvan, don't watch the movie which is based on the novel..as simple as that...😂
Saivism is a part of Hinduism...stop living in denial
Padatha padama paruppa... Ina verila koovadha
Jaimohan waste
To all crew and cast of PS2. Henceforth, don't venture to destroy the history and a great novel. It's painful to see the diversion from the history and the ugly way of bringing unwanted scenes from reality. Hope all team members would have understood what I mean to say. Not to have a huge budget for such cinemas.
Yaarum parkalena padam edukka mattanga. Aayiram kodi sambarikkuthu edukiranga. Neenga venumna oru ps edungalen
@@yevanooruvan7071 why should I. I am simply telling my opinion. None of you Hv a say on my comment. Mind it.
Ellathulaiyum notta sollikuttu...kalaiya rasika theriyadha kaaterikumbala marittu varanga...chi... PS2 is really superb... 3rd rate 4th grade politics panni panni than kevalamaana padam ellam oodudhu...
Punul nayeee
Ena mairuku cholanukku punul pode?
malayalam padam lag, but yarum sollamatinga ranga nu solringa la... apuram entha hair ku neenga tamil padathuku script work panringa....
I think you could show some little respect while talking in the group. He clearly says on which angle he made the story. that is his wish, but changing the climax only was not good.
ps-1,ps-2 are such a amazing movie. indha movie waste nu solravan oru muthal kootame. ithu onnum rajamouli fantasy movie illa. just mani ratnam movie. sema cinematography. ivanungalukku fights and shooting kaatuna super movie nu solluvanunga. worst people.inga pesuravan oruthanukku kooda varalaaru theriyathu.
Is this an intelligent exercise?
Boss..first try to accept negative reviews and improve it in your next projects.
BAHUBALI 9/10
PS1 6/10, PS2 3/10
IYO MANIRATNAM
Poonool 💩 thalisss intha mani 💩 ,intha jaya 💩
Even kalki added fictional characters and Stories to history in PS but adhu yepudi irkum.Marvelous novel and what u ppl have done to it?
Padam moka
I hate wat you did in ps . Worst ending.
Loosu ko mari pasura .. uruttu na urutu pee urutu....
Boring and slow script Mr. Jay Mohan.... It's just one time watchable definitely not repeatedly watchable like other movies....
Dabba movie really sumaar upma Lu ivlo pecchu
Even Kalki seems to be inspired by Mahabharatham and Ramayanam.
Odipoiru😂
Edu serupa naaye.....
@@yaathregan474😂😂😂😂 edhoda edha compare pandran parunga,,PS lam oru story nuru
eppadiyo....chozhan raaja va brahmin a maathiteenga.....that is your aim...suceeded..thu...
Aditha Karikalan death :
1. Real killers - 4 brahmins from Udayarkudi Chola inscriptions
2. Killers according to Kalki - fictional character Nandini and Pandyan spies
3. Killers according to Mani Ratnam and Jeyamohan - committed suicide by pushing knife into himself
Well done da agraharam puliyodahrais!
jaya mohan is a brahmin!!sangi
Ok fake
Dea poriki nayea
Neenga yennatha uthar vittalum ponnyn selvan history ye vera mathiri commercial cinema kaga change panna thappu..amarar kalki ku kaal thoosi ku varathu nee eluthuna script
Very well said
Dai, PS novel le fictional dhan. Naanum PS novel padichavandan.
Agmark noolandi
Poda poolandi
Sema mokka
அரசியல் பேசும் படைப்பாளிகள் மேல செம காண்டுல இருக்கான் போல ஜெமோ 😂😂😂😂
Poda baadu
Poda
😂
Po da poo nool
Poda poo lu
நல்லாவே உருட்டுங்க..கேரள நம்பூத்...திரி...RSS. Having done great injustice to the truth of the great history of Chola Dynasty, you all are blowing your own trumpet without shame.
Your clan should kneel down before the legends and giants of celluloid world. I.e. Sivaji Ganesan, APN, Kannadasan, MSV, TMS, Sridar who were all famous for their scintillating contribution. ..Listen and go through my play , Chola Prince Athitha Karikalan (not Athithya Karikalan) which was broadcast thro ALL INDIA RADIO, in 2018, drama competition week.
You have butchered the Chola history with the high tint of notoriety.
Aditha Karikalan death :
1. Real killers - 4 brahmins from Udayarkudi Chola inscriptions
2. Killers according to Kalki - fictional character Nandini and Pandyan spies
3. Killers according to Mani Ratnam and Jeyamohan - committed suicide by pushing knife into himself
Well done da agraharam puliyodahrais!
Not true. Even if you post this as a reply to every single comment it's still wrong 😂
But we can't be sure who killed him exactly on the basis of temple inscription which happened 1000 years ago right 😅common people's murder cases of recent times are being unsolved and tampering evidences so it's not a big surprise for us to think over whatsoever royal secrets would had been covered up in those days from revealing to people of chola dynasty. Anything could have happened 😕 one thing for sure he was murdered
@@eesha855 nice uruttu...next uruttu 🤡🤡
@@DarthSidious7 next what Gandhi was not shot by Godse...he died due to stomach ache 🤣🤣 These thairsadhams and their whitewashing to cover up their ancestors atrocities 🤣🤣
Dei pakistani poromboku.....
0:44 ola ola ola 😂😅
Mokka padam. Waste director uh