Salam Sheikh, I think the point where photos can’t be properly deleted isn’t 100% true. You can erase data by overwriting the physical location on the hard drive where the photo is stored with arbitrary data. This can be done with freely available software. However I don’t expect the average person to understand or know how to do this so it better for sisters not to take the photo in the first place.
A more important point is your device is connected to the internet. No matter how secure you think it is there is a possibility that some program malicious or normal will upload it to the cloud and at that point you have no control over what happens.
Jazahk Sheik. Pls this draws my attention to video games in which characters are digitally created. Assuming the game meets the minimum halal requirements (no music, nudity, violence, shirk, and islamophobia) what about the drawings of the characters? (As I've just learnt from you that its a major sin on the creator)
This is more detailed but one of my brothers draws mixed creatures some times on his computer 💻 and the other brother does 3D modeling and some times he models figures or people for video games. What is the ruling
So we cant take photos or pictures of ourselves with our children as covered hijabi mom with family photos for memory? Is this not allowed?im confused,subhanallah i know he says women can't be photographed meaning if they are naked in anyway but if covered then it should be okey right? I also have one photo of my father who passed away 30 years go during civil war in my country, may allah mercy on him, it's the only memory i have of him since i was 2 when he died..
It can be retrieved at any moment it’s not truly yours only and the deceased photos aren’t permissible. He answers your question at 9:07. It’s a form of shirk
Thanks for the great video Sheikh… just a quick question on image making and drawing…. Does this apply to all images? Or just those that imitate living things? Fir example, can I draw a picture of t-shirt, or perhaps can I 3-D model someone wear a t-shirt and face without including the face?
You can make drawing without souls like tress many say you can make a face without facail features but I am kinda confused about it so I recommend to search .there are many living creature without soul , like corona virus .... .
A man went to pray, leaving his laptop in his hotel room.. came back and found everything was stolen.. it had pictures of his 4 wives, daughters, ect...
Is it permissible to draw non living things? And even though plants are living being can we draw them? Also what about school activities for children where they have an art class and are asked to draw things that may or may not be living things?
You can draw things without souls tress have no souls and if the teacher ask you to draw a living thing and you should explain because Allah rule is always first .
If it's just a copy of living people and the image hasn't been doctored to create something new and it isn't exposing women to strangers then it should be fine to print. Whether it is physical or virtual would be irrelevant. Having said that, the risk with a physical copy is that it could be worshipped unwittingly or otherwise. Some people tend to treat photos of dead people with Reverence and talk to it, pray to it etc. At dojos they have photos of dead masters and bow to it.
@@s0bad the risk begins when one captures the image not when he prints it!! The word image in my opinion covers all type of images of living things whether it's through camera or by hands. That's why no one has ever gave any sound explanation and I don't think any human can ever do that. Haram is haram except in the case of necessity and certain circumstances. And Allāh knows best. The hadith doesn't differentiate between drawings and other type of images if you were to differentiate then you can even say that sculptures are haram but drawing is halal or vice versa while all of these are haram.
I have to say the arguments of this video are weak and I'm not convinced of the distinction made between photography/video videography and other art forms and images. Shaykh Yusuf al Qardawi states in in his book halal Wal haram FIL Islam that it is art dedicated to create idols that people worship, that is haram. I find this a more plausible argument. Photography is also an art form, so adre videos. You can adjust the lighting an effects to bring about a certain composition and mood etc. The problem with declaring art totally haram is that you have to be consistent, this discussion is full of holes as far as I'm concerned.
The hadith is crystal clear, where does it say in the sunnah that it is only forbidden if it's made for shirk purposes? I wouldn't trust fatwas that are based on "logic" with disregard for the text. As for the photo / video being art, the sheikh made a great comparison to a mirror, as for editing photos and videos to make them look better etc. then islamqa says that's haram so it is indeed consistent. Akhi my advice is that usually people who argue about this subject, along with music, generally do it because they are already commited to it in some way or as a hobby, but the hereafter is not worth losing for something clear.
The answer is pictures aren’t mimicking the creation of Allah, because you are capturing a picture OF the creation of Allah. If I take a picture of my cat or if I draw a picture of my cat, I would say that the photograph is my cat and drawing is me trying to mimick what Allah has created my cat to be
Jazak Allahu khairan for the well captioned videos! May Allah bless the owner and team of this channel.
Ma sha Allah. Barak Allah feek.
Salam Sheikh, I think the point where photos can’t be properly deleted isn’t 100% true. You can erase data by overwriting the physical location on the hard drive where the photo is stored with arbitrary data. This can be done with freely available software.
However I don’t expect the average person to understand or know how to do this so it better for sisters not to take the photo in the first place.
A more important point is your device is connected to the internet. No matter how secure you think it is there is a possibility that some program malicious or normal will upload it to the cloud and at that point you have no control over what happens.
Jazakallahu khairan for the ilm
Sallalahu Alayhi Wa sallam
جزاک اللہ خیرا
and what if I break my previous mobile phone/destroy it instead of giving it away or selling it?
Is it permissible to draw chemicals for school or drawing anatomy for anatomy/biology class?
Jazakallahu khair sir
Jazahk Sheik. Pls this draws my attention to video games in which characters are digitally created. Assuming the game meets the minimum halal requirements (no music, nudity, violence, shirk, and islamophobia) what about the drawings of the characters? (As I've just learnt from you that its a major sin on the creator)
This is more detailed but one of my brothers draws mixed creatures some times on his computer 💻 and the other brother does 3D modeling and some times he models figures or people for video games. What is the ruling
Same ruling, the prohibition is on all things that have souls like animals, humans, werewolves etc.
So we cant take photos or pictures of ourselves with our children as covered hijabi mom with family photos for memory? Is this not allowed?im confused,subhanallah i know he says women can't be photographed meaning if they are naked in anyway but if covered then it should be okey right? I also have one photo of my father who passed away 30 years go during civil war in my country, may allah mercy on him, it's the only memory i have of him since i was 2 when he died..
It can be retrieved at any moment it’s not truly yours only and the deceased photos aren’t permissible. He answers your question at 9:07. It’s a form of shirk
Thanks for the great video Sheikh… just a quick question on image making and drawing…. Does this apply to all images? Or just those that imitate living things? Fir example, can I draw a picture of t-shirt, or perhaps can I 3-D model someone wear a t-shirt and face without including the face?
3-D Model as in a digital sketch
You can make drawing without souls like tress many say you can make a face without facail features but I am kinda confused about it so I recommend to search .there are many living creature without soul , like corona virus .... .
A man went to pray, leaving his laptop in his hotel room.. came back and found everything was stolen.. it had pictures of his 4 wives, daughters, ect...
Is it permissible to draw non living things? And even though plants are living being can we draw them?
Also what about school activities for children where they have an art class and are asked to draw things that may or may not be living things?
You can draw things without souls tress have no souls and if the teacher ask you to draw a living thing and you should explain because Allah rule is always first .
There are so many living things without soul
But still search
Nowadays our phone taken by a phone is not the 100%same as our real face . So are they halal ? Ain't i changing the Allah's creation ?
Would it be allowed to print family photos to create albums etc
Send your questions on the website akhi
Sheikh said in other video that it is still haram.
If it's just a copy of living people and the image hasn't been doctored to create something new and it isn't exposing women to strangers then it should be fine to print. Whether it is physical or virtual would be irrelevant. Having said that, the risk with a physical copy is that it could be worshipped unwittingly or otherwise. Some people tend to treat photos of dead people with Reverence and talk to it, pray to it etc. At dojos they have photos of dead masters and bow to it.
@@s0bad the risk begins when one captures the image not when he prints it!! The word image in my opinion covers all type of images of living things whether it's through camera or by hands. That's why no one has ever gave any sound explanation and I don't think any human can ever do that. Haram is haram except in the case of necessity and certain circumstances. And Allāh knows best. The hadith doesn't differentiate between drawings and other type of images if you were to differentiate then you can even say that sculptures are haram but drawing is halal or vice versa while all of these are haram.
can i draw cartoon?
Salam, is it haram to draw people even if head separated from body?
Yes of course
Anything that is similar to Allah's creation. As the shaykh said.
What about drawing unreal things like a dragon or a minion or a magical thing like a unicorn?
I think it's haram as well.
Prohibited
Just a reminder.
Only Allah swt creates, no one else can.
Drawing is not creating. Building is not creating ,inventing is not creating.
I have to say the arguments of this video are weak and I'm not convinced of the distinction made between photography/video videography and other art forms and images. Shaykh Yusuf al Qardawi states in in his book halal Wal haram FIL Islam that it is art dedicated to create idols that people worship, that is haram. I find this a more plausible argument. Photography is also an art form, so adre videos. You can adjust the lighting an effects to bring about a certain composition and mood etc. The problem with declaring art totally haram is that you have to be consistent, this discussion is full of holes as far as I'm concerned.
The hadith is crystal clear, where does it say in the sunnah that it is only forbidden if it's made for shirk purposes? I wouldn't trust fatwas that are based on "logic" with disregard for the text. As for the photo / video being art, the sheikh made a great comparison to a mirror, as for editing photos and videos to make them look better etc. then islamqa says that's haram so it is indeed consistent.
Akhi my advice is that usually people who argue about this subject, along with music, generally do it because they are already commited to it in some way or as a hobby, but the hereafter is not worth losing for something clear.
The answer is pictures aren’t mimicking the creation of Allah, because you are capturing a picture OF the creation of Allah. If I take a picture of my cat or if I draw a picture of my cat, I would say that the photograph is my cat and drawing is me trying to mimick what Allah has created my cat to be
Very weak explanation
Well, are you even a muslim?
@@abdulbarikhan507 what he said so that you are questioning his deen?
Then why don't you try?
What’s so difficult to understand