@@guiwars2 im not sure that would be completely accurate.. .either we do see him use force heal as well, which i would think more light than dark. ,. def leans more dark than light, but seems to learning on both sides of the fence
@@Blizzard0fHope Sith are not suppose to be able to learn force heal, only lightside users. Since Kylo Rens theme played in the back round at the end im pressuming he is going to start the Knights of Ren that Kylo takes over and him saying that they would call him sith is just because he has a red lightsaber and kills Jedi.. i personally think. Also, he doesnt have sith eyes
That don’t matter because if sol goes to the Jedi temple he will say “ he identified as a sith” still lore breaking but yes lets cope with the fact this show can’t be consistent with anything lol
I think it's just his way of phrasing. The Sith were the ultimate archenemy of the Jedi. Aspiring dark siders won't pretend to be Sith to hide who they really are. They would claim to be Sith when they don't really understand what it truly means to be one. If your goal is to oppose or even destroy the Jedi, being a Sith is the highest ranking, most menacing enemy of them all.
Honestly, that's one of the things I've loved about this show from the very start -- the knowledge that anyone can die and that star power will not protect a character.
@@TheMovieCoupleAcolite episode 5 is the best star wars thing I have ever seen. These fights and choreography surpassed both the Phantom Menace movie and the clone wars episode.
There's a slight distinction in what he actually said and what we think. He said, "A jedi like you would call me sith." He said he had no name. Not quite the same. 🖖😎👍
Manny did a phenomenal acting performance as Sith Qimir, alongside with the character he voiced in Animated Video Game Adaptation, Kenshi Takahashi (young adult) from Mortal Kombat Legends III: Snow Blind.
I still can’t believe they brought the Cortosis armor from the books and comics into live action. It’s a material that nullifies blaster shots and temporarily disables lightsabers. In canon it was seen in the novel Thrawn: Alliances and in the Doctor Aphra comics. It’s incredibly rare and even harder to refine into armor, and while it’s relatively weak against strong impacts, it can nullify blaster bolts and deactivate lightsabers temporarily upon impact.
To address Dustin’s Ki-Adi-Mundi comment, all KAM sees is a holo video of Mae while she’s fighting Sol (and/or Indara) and at no point do they see a red lightsaber or anything to indicate Sith. Indara referred to Mae as a rogue force user, Vernestra said she must be trained by a Jedi, etc. And KAM has yet to see or know anything that’s going on Khofar. At this point, KAM has no reason to think it’s a Sith.
I've been thinking about how people have pointed out that twice when Qimir was doing his thing, the Kylo Ren music played. Does that mean he is an early Knight of Ren. Or maybe he is the first Ren? I think all we really know about them is that they were around before the galactic civil war, supposedly for centuries, but idk stories of the boogie man can be weird and unreliable. But they were around. Everything else we know is from Kylo-ish time that a group of raiders who claimed to be them or named themselves after the legend of the knights popped out of obscurity to fill the force power void left by the fallen jedi and, subsequently, the fallen sith, as well. So maybe this is Qimir Ren, who turns out actually starts the knights... collecting the acolytes he so desperately wants. Maybe Mae and/or Osha will be his first knight(s) by the end of the series. His vibe and outlook on the force is verrrry similar to theirs. If he is the first Ren, that would mean he's not a sith, no formal training or adherence to the sith ways, but there's not yet a name for what he actually is bc he hasn't yet formed the knights. And that's why he's like... eh I'm not anything in particular, but sith is the closest you can get so that's what you'd call me if you were looking for a label.
yes. i think he might be the founder of the knights. he even dresses like them. sort of ronin-like in black with a helmet. i think this show might be giving us the origin of the knights of ren.
Another absolute BANGER episode of this show. Some of the most savage, untethered action in Star Wars history. The choreography in this show so far is absolutely insane 😍
“I have no name. But the Jedi like you might call me ... Sith.” I think he's saying that the Jedi with their blinkered vision of the force would call him Sith, but i don't think he's actually saying that he is Sith himself.
He has reason to think the Jedi call any darksider Sith. The Jedi hunted some chill witches to extinction and took their kid. It’s just black and white with them.
@@JazzMaster01 youre right BUT imagine youre in this universe and you want to have a lightsaber and feel the force but you cannot be a jedi because you need training and everyhing else but there is another chance as a dark side to be kind of free of any codex and just be how you are. If i had a chance I would take it!
Qimir's bracer and helmet are made of cortosis, which reflects energy and temporarily shorts out light sabers on contact. Also, Qimir isn't a Sith lord, he's an illegitimate second apprentice to the reigning Sith lord, Darth Tenebrous. The "real" apprentice is Darth Plagueis. When Qimir says that what he is has no name, but that the Jedi would think he's a Sith, he's being accurate. Because of the Rule of Two, Qimir can't be an actual Sith in technical terms, but the Jedi wouldn't make that distinction. If they keep with canon, then Qimir's Sith name is "Venamis," although he can't carry the "Darth" title. Venamis attempted to betray Tenebrous, failed, and suffered a fate worse than death. I'm fairly sure that is what "The Acolyte" is about, telling the story of Venamis' betrayal and failure. Darth Tenebrous was learning the secrets of manipulating life from the coven of Force witches, so the Jedi went there and killed everyone, which is the big secret they're keeping. Tenebrous and Plagueis took what they learned from the witches and tried to learn how to create or manipulate life, then Plagueis kills Tenebrous and takes Sidious as an apprentice. Plagueis and Sidious experiment with the knowledge and unwittingly create Anakin Skywalker. Yo guys, Qimir very specifically didn't say he was a Sith. What he said was, "I have no name, but a Jedi like you might call me...Sith." I would also assume that they did the reveal at this point in the show because Qimir is not the Big Bad, he's just the primary antagonist fighting the heroes.
Nice..did not know this but that makes a lot of sense and if correct may shut up a lot of the "But the Lore is This people who are complaining that the show is screwing up the Lore its not at all then.
That's a very accurate description of what's occurring during this era. Darth Tenebrous is the Sith Lord that's experimenting with using the Force to create life. The tie-in with the Witches makes sense. Somehow, the incidents in this episode must be covered up by these Jedi because 100 years in the future, the Jedi of the Phantom Menace thinks the Sith are extinct.
@@ECA2 Everyone is going to die before the show ends. Its the only way. I think from the Jedi perspective, what happened is that Master Sol led a team to intercept the prime murder suspect before she could kill the wookie dude, and nobody ever returned from the mission.
I think this might be telling the story of Plagueis rather than Tenebrous, with Qimir being Plagueis' apprentice. I don't believe Venamis is included in current canon (although I'm admittedly no expert).
@@ModeMan101 Its true that both Tenebrous and Venamis are currently Legends, but they keep pulling characters and concepts from Legends and canonizing them through the various shows.
To be fair he DIDNT flat out say he was a sith, he said he has no name but a jedi like sol would CALL him sith. That seems very intebtionally worded, they also played kylo rens motif for him twice. I think hes gonna turn out to be the first Ren, ot a sith
Qimir is trying to form the knights of ren. Since the knights of ren was never known about those 100 years bc they killed the ones that found out about their appearance but are known to use dark side power. Which is why he is looking for an acolyte. Read the knights of ren comic to understand a bit more bc he has all the feature of the knights of ren if you look closely.
Apparently the stranger's/master's/Qimir's helmet and brace/band around his left arm is made of a very rare material that is called cortosis. It can deflect blaster fire, stun rings, and lightsaber strikes, and can temporarily negate/short out lightsabers if it touches/hits the emitter of the lightsaber blade. However, it is fibrous and much more brittle compared to Beskar armor, because with repeated strikes, a lightsaber can still cut through it 🤔.
Sol feeling a familiarity with Qimir probably does have bigger meaning, but I figured Yord's reaction was simply because of the earlier interaction in the shop. And Qimir knows it's not Mae - he saw the tattoo. Same as I'm pretty sure Sol knows it is Mae, given his little "Where is she?" "Who?" "Your sister" interaction.
Dustin its Jecki not Jackie..put some respect on her name!! Also the Rashomon is for what happened on Brendok Plus they never said how long the stun lasts And another thing (this comment is getting edited alot) he said "You jedi would call me Sith" never "I'm a Sith"
Ah this episode was a game changer thanks to the incredible lightsaber battle and the bread crumbs dropped by Qimir. Qimir seriously is the breakout character throughout every episode he has appeared in so far. Also the armor he wore can also short circuit the lightsaber and it's called Cortosis metal.
16:45 Not necessarily a plot hole, people have different reactions to stuns depending on their durability. Remember when we saw Ahsoka train to block blaster fire and she built a resistance to stuns?
While the reveal wasn’t really a shock I like how they did it. The only questions I have now: 1. What happened during the fire 2. What’s Sol hiding and what’s his relationship with the Sith 3. What’s going to happen to Mae and Osha
Pretty sure Qimir knows he has Osha. Like Dustin mentioned, she has short hair, she has a wound in her side and has a tattoo on her arm that Mae doesn’t which he got a clear look at.
also, he healed her. if it was mae, he would have killed her while she was knocked out. he didnt want mae as an acolyte anymore. he definitely knows it's osha.
It would reveal maby why so mand "sith" are sith but do not follow any sith codex and are just pretty much training themselfes and doing whatever they want.
Win it/The Stranger didn’t say he is a Sith. He said the Jedi would call him a Sith but he didn’t call himself a Sith. A lot of reactors assume he said he is a Sith but he never did. I believe Qimir/The Stranger might be the founder of the Knights of Ren.
I was also thinking that there was some deeper history between Yord, Sol, and Qimir, but they would have recognized him before when they were tracking Mae. They all interrogated him together, so that may be the familiarity that they had.
I was gonna say, they already met and questioned him when they were looking for Mae so that's where they know him from. They didn't act like they knew him at that point when they first found him.
Also- the Kylo Ren theme underneath that last scene with Qimir. Could be a Knights of Ren origin/connection there (and play into the "I have no name [for what I am]"-type angle), instead of a straight-out Sith (especially if Qimir is a rival apprentice to Plagueis- and would fit into the theme of a splinter order/rogue Jedi already suggested in the series, which would further murky the water in terms of the Jedi believing that the Sith could return a century later). With Sol's darkness, being so tormented by his emotions this whole show.... could Sol actually end up becoming the Acolyte? A fallen Sol would be so tragic- but would also wrap up the biggest "if Qimir is a Sith, then how did Sol not tell the Jedi" question outside of the sisters.
Mae is either gonna kill Sol or like completely discredit him and erase evidence this episode gave me Darth Bane trilogy vibes especially the second book where a group of jedi discovered that Darth Bane was still alive with his apprentice and they killed all the jedi and put the blame on someone else
@marshsundeen good theory but I was thinking of Sol like Mae as Osha tells everyone that he suddenly snapped and killed everyone that way when he tries to tells the jedi about the sith nobody believes him treachery is the way of the sith
Considering how obvious the reveal was, I'm assuming there's more to the mystery. A show rarely puts all of its cards on the table in episode 5 of 8. My theory is that the Sith that Mae encountered, there's two of them. There's a second one and they pulled a Scream on our asses. My guesses are that either Indira or Mother Korril are involved.
This looks likes the origins of the Knights of Ren, not Sith, if you ask me. The Sith already have a long lineage of masters and apprentices going back a long time, probably back to when they were a race and in large numbers. The Knights of Ren are a more recent version of forcer-users that also will use the dark side.
Qimir even asked Mae why she didn't suspect him. He knew it was obvious too. I don't mind that. The real mystery is what happened on Brendok. It's probably not going to show Sol in a good light.
Qimir didn't leave the lightsaber behind. It got carried up with him when he got briefly abducted by the umbramoths. Also, it seemed pretty clear that Sol, upon reviving from the stun, was a bit unsettled and confused -- and maybe Mae used a little bit of Force suggestion on him to encourage him to immediately depart? As for leaving the bodies behind... come on. Not everyone is at Yoda, Anakin, Luke, or Rey power levels. Most Jedi probably can't easily hoist a whole body and carry it for literal HOURS, let alone seven or eight of them, and knowing that the bad guy is still around would definitely be a reason to get the hell out of the jungle ASAP.
They intentionally laid the ground for Qimir to be the Sith from the start. If things aren't setup viewers get upset it's some rando out of nowhere. If things are setup viewers are upset it wasn't a surprise rando.
16:49 "You never could block." --Mae I don't know how you'd block a blast, but apparently it can be done. 18:50 Sol spends the whole series calling Osha by her name to only ask, "where is she. Your sister?" Sol knows this is Mae. He chose these words to throw Mae and the audience off. He came to get Mae, wasn't going to lose the opportunity she presented him. How is this going to play out? Mother Aniseya and Mother Koril wanted Osha and Mae to stay together because the two need each other, they complete each other; they are two sides of the same coin: "You're with me, I'm with you Always one, but born as two As above sits the stars, and below lies the sea, I give you you, and you give me me" --Mae and Osha They never got to finish their training, but now they get that chance. Qimir has taken Osha and he's going to show her the Dark Side, which is her coven's witchcraft, the side she rejected 16 years ago. Sol has Mae, and Mae is going to see a different perspective, the Light Side of the Force. The next three episodes should be interesting. We still have one more flashback with Kelnacca fighting someone on Brendok. And Master Vernestra using her whip lightsaber. Can't wait!
It's not just a Sith who could potentially fight a group of Jedi like this. Any strong Dark Side Force User could if they are a strong lightsaber duelist and strong enough in the Force. Even the Jedi vary wildly in how good they are with a lightsaber. Hell, General Grievous could take on multiple Jedi and kill them without even having the Force. Also, remember that Ahsoka was a Padawan when she fought Grievous, and wasn't even a Jedi when she defeated Maul, and Obi-Wan was a Padawan when he beat Maul. So being a Padawan doesn't mean you can't hold your own. Qimir didn't actually say he was a Sith. He only said that a Jedi like Sol might call him a Sith. He might be something else. And his reveal of being Qimir, isn't for us, it's for the other characters. Lastly, stun weapons usually only knock out an individual for a few minutes, although some could stay knocked out for up to an hour. So Mae getting up so quickly is not a plot hole.
Ki-Adi doesn't know yet. He knows someone is killing Jedi, but not that a Sith is involved. Only the ones involved in the fight know. Who knows if that information will actually get out. I also don't like that people are agreeing that Sol is responsible for Jecki's death because he brought her. Let's totally forget the fact that Qimir stabbed her 3 times and is the whole reason they're there in the first place. Yes, she's a child, but she proved she was more than capable. I know she died, but lots of Jedi died in the battle.
I think it’s a great representation of a sith from that era. He’s young. I thought he was probably an apprentice the current Sith Lord at that time but now I’m not sure. It would make sense if he had just killed his master and is seeking an apprentice. Also because he’d be feeling especially powerful and confident at that time.
@@firstlast-wm3li OK, what's "cope"? I purposely didn't watch any interviews with the cast or creators. Maybe that's why I am not hating on the show as much as other people are.
@@jeffcummins8639I'm not hating either. It's not perfect. The writing is terrible, but I can appreciate some good things once in a while. Also, he's a Sith.
He did emphasize that ambiguity- though he also did say that the Jedi say he shouldn't exist. Whether that is just playing into the "Jedi makes the rules" or "what a Jedi thinks I am" persecution ambiguities, or actually into the hidden Sith, it's hard to say yet.
Not really anything to do with coping. It’s literally what he said. I can Google the script for you, if you find it easier to understand in written form.
the helmet could be either made from Mandalorian Beskar or that other element, Cortosis. Cortosis/Cortosis-Weave can withstand the blows of energy sabers and can actually temporarily short a lightsaber
Not sure if he is officially a Sith though. He just said the Jedi could refer to him as one since he has darkness in him. I wonder if he has a master that may show up?
Finally been waiting for your guys reaction. I’ve been calling him Darth Zipperface. I’m still trying to come to terms with Jecki and Yord. It’s heartbreaking. Loved the Sith though I’m curious how they’ll continue after this.
I do think Qimir's taunting of Mae "You really didn't know it was me, not even a little bit?" is more a touch on the fact the audience saw it was obvious and the fact Mae didnt see it was quite telling
Ok this was my favorite episode so much action and intensity I'm just gonna call him Manny as well haha but Manny is jacked what the heck Darth zipper is way to powerful, and SOL WHAT ARE YOU HIDING. Also forgot to mention the lightsaber fights were awesome including hand to hand
I can't wait to see Kelnacca with black eyes under witch control in a flashback in Episode 7 (IMDb) fighting Torbin and Sol!❤ I think Sol will recognize Mae. She may be able to hide her mark on her forehead, but she doesn't have a tattoo on her arm like Osha🤣 Very interesting how Qimir proved that it is possible to kill a Jedi without a weapon and without Jedi rules. It's very ironic that he killed Yord, the Jedi who lived strictly by the rules! I found the Kylo Ren Theme, which played when Qimir found Osha at the end, interesting. Maybe he was the first Knight of Ren? Greetings from Germany😊
Although it's Qimir and it seemed obvious...it was SO well done that I don't care. Heck, that's not the main mystery of the show anyway. What happened 16 years ago is.
Reaction highlights 😂 : 9:37 Wendy: "Use the Force!!! ...OK, or headbutt." 12:54 Wendy: "Stop writing the show!" Dustin: "Sorry!" 13:08 Wendy: "He was hiding all those muscles." [silently fans self] 19:00 Dustin: "Let's... collect the dead?" Wendy: "Take the helmet back for proof...? We''re not gonna do any of that."
Well Ki-Adi doesn't know still that Qimir is involved let alone a Sith, but the whole point of that character is that he's wrong about everything, he was wrong about the siths extinction, he was also wrong about Dooku not being a murder
The show is very simplistic, and it feels like a cartoon for children. It is enjoyable, but it feels like it's not elaborated or thought through for adults to enjoy (like Andor). But, well.... I think Yord recognized Qimir from when they met in episode 2, and maybe that's also where Qimir thinks Sol could have recognized him from. But Idk. Qimir doesn't say he is a Sith... He says: "Jedi like you would call me Sith". As the show is so simplistic, though, that's probably what he is. I'm sad about Jekki and Yord. They were cool. 🫤😭 Especially her.
Hey guys, Great reaction 😁, loving this episode, it's what we've been looking for!! Sith have returned, to bad everyone has to die! Or at the very least maybe one served an kept the secret, because they (Jedi) thought the Sith were gone for over 1000 yrs. And to bring Cortosis, from the comics is brilliant, ( his helmet an other parts he wore short circuits lightsabers when touched by them.. very Cool 😎. Keep it up ❤ Lv ya mean it ❤️
He didn’t say he was a Sith, he said he had no name, but the Jedi might call him a Sith. Yord recognized him because they interrogated him in episode 2
I don't think Qimir is a Sith. He just said that the Jedi would call him that. I believe he was a Padawan who left the Order and discovered the Darkside on his own. But he wants to become a Sith. Remember, the Sith are always in pairs - a master and a student. That's why Qimir wants to have a student. He probably thinks this is how he becomes a real Sith.
He didn't say he was a Sith. He said Jedi might call him that. I think this is a worthwhile distinction.
I don’t think is a Sith, but he’s definitely a dark side user!
@@guiwars2 im not sure that would be completely accurate.. .either we do see him use force heal as well, which i would think more light than dark. ,. def leans more dark than light, but seems to learning on both sides of the fence
@@Blizzard0fHope Sith are not suppose to be able to learn force heal, only lightside users. Since Kylo Rens theme played in the back round at the end im pressuming he is going to start the Knights of Ren that Kylo takes over and him saying that they would call him sith is just because he has a red lightsaber and kills Jedi.. i personally think. Also, he doesnt have sith eyes
That don’t matter because if sol goes to the Jedi temple he will say “ he identified as a sith” still lore breaking but yes lets cope with the fact this show can’t be consistent with anything lol
I think it's just his way of phrasing. The Sith were the ultimate archenemy of the Jedi. Aspiring dark siders won't pretend to be Sith to hide who they really are. They would claim to be Sith when they don't really understand what it truly means to be one. If your goal is to oppose or even destroy the Jedi, being a Sith is the highest ranking, most menacing enemy of them all.
Cortosis is able to short out lightsabers. Manny did not miss arm day at the gym! I really felt that all Red Shirts were doomed. RIP Jecki and Yord.
Honestly, that's one of the things I've loved about this show from the very start -- the knowledge that anyone can die and that star power will not protect a character.
“He doesn’t follow the rule of combat!”
Jack Sparrow: pirate!
hahaha!
@@TheMovieCoupleAcolite episode 5 is the best star wars thing I have ever seen. These fights and choreography surpassed both the Phantom Menace movie and the clone wars episode.
That’s hilarious! Manny said he was playing Qimir with a Jack Sparrow vibe.
You forgot that they all met Qimir when Osha pretended to be Mae in the Apothecary shop.
Exactly what I was going to say. They both seemed to overthink it, probably in the hope that it would be something more interesting than that.
Yeah exactly. I think they forgot they all met him at the apocathary shop.
@@JH-mo7xm "You seem familiar." "Yeah, dude, we met like three days ago."
There's a slight distinction in what he actually said and what we think.
He said, "A jedi like you would call me sith." He said he had no name. Not quite the same. 🖖😎👍
They have said that they made it obvious on purpose that he was the Sith because there was so much mystery in the story
Best episode yet. Manny was great. Amazing fighting. Justice for yord and jecki 😢
I'm hoping Manny gets a lot more work off this. He's certainly got the dramatic chops, and can handle himself in a screen fight.
@@AndrewMcColl and he has the looks too. and the ARMS xD
Manny did a phenomenal acting performance as Sith Qimir, alongside with the character he voiced in Animated Video Game Adaptation, Kenshi Takahashi (young adult) from Mortal Kombat Legends III: Snow Blind.
Dude, Jecki went out a legend, like Ahsoka level legend!
For real.
She duel wielded green lightsabers too
I still can’t believe they brought the Cortosis armor from the books and comics into live action. It’s a material that nullifies blaster shots and temporarily disables lightsabers. In canon it was seen in the novel Thrawn: Alliances and in the Doctor Aphra comics.
It’s incredibly rare and even harder to refine into armor, and while it’s relatively weak against strong impacts, it can nullify blaster bolts and deactivate lightsabers temporarily upon impact.
To address Dustin’s Ki-Adi-Mundi comment, all KAM sees is a holo video of Mae while she’s fighting Sol (and/or Indara) and at no point do they see a red lightsaber or anything to indicate Sith. Indara referred to Mae as a rogue force user, Vernestra said she must be trained by a Jedi, etc. And KAM has yet to see or know anything that’s going on Khofar.
At this point, KAM has no reason to think it’s a Sith.
Yes, 80% of the cast gets killed in this episode lmao 🔥🔥
Almost TPK
@@TheMovieCouple lol
I've been thinking about how people have pointed out that twice when Qimir was doing his thing, the Kylo Ren music played. Does that mean he is an early Knight of Ren. Or maybe he is the first Ren? I think all we really know about them is that they were around before the galactic civil war, supposedly for centuries, but idk stories of the boogie man can be weird and unreliable. But they were around. Everything else we know is from Kylo-ish time that a group of raiders who claimed to be them or named themselves after the legend of the knights popped out of obscurity to fill the force power void left by the fallen jedi and, subsequently, the fallen sith, as well. So maybe this is Qimir Ren, who turns out actually starts the knights... collecting the acolytes he so desperately wants. Maybe Mae and/or Osha will be his first knight(s) by the end of the series. His vibe and outlook on the force is verrrry similar to theirs. If he is the first Ren, that would mean he's not a sith, no formal training or adherence to the sith ways, but there's not yet a name for what he actually is bc he hasn't yet formed the knights. And that's why he's like... eh I'm not anything in particular, but sith is the closest you can get so that's what you'd call me if you were looking for a label.
yes. i think he might be the founder of the knights. he even dresses like them. sort of ronin-like in black with a helmet. i think this show might be giving us the origin of the knights of ren.
@@quinndelcarmen1384 I can totally get behind it if that's what they're doing. Really hope it is.
Another absolute BANGER episode of this show. Some of the most savage, untethered action in Star Wars history. The choreography in this show so far is absolutely insane 😍
This was REALLY next level..whoever did the fight Choreo needs a RAISE ASAP
fun fact: we can hear Kylo Ren’s theme playing in the background on the last scene with Qimir and Osha :)
Makes sense he is a Knight of Ren maybe?
maybe he is the first knight of the knights of ren
@@Deadpool-ts3tq hopefully 🙏🏻
“I have no name. But the Jedi like you might call me ... Sith.”
I think he's saying that the Jedi with their blinkered vision of the force would call him Sith, but i don't think he's actually saying that he is Sith himself.
He said some "might call him.. Sith" - I dont think he is claiming to be one but he said that he may be referred to as one based on what the jedi see
He also cites the Sith Code.
He has reason to think the Jedi call any darksider Sith. The Jedi hunted some chill witches to extinction and took their kid. It’s just black and white with them.
All black clothes. Red saber. Killing Jedi. Wants a pupil. Seems Sith to me🤷♂️
@@JazzMaster01 even if he ends up being Sith. I wouldn't mind. He's bad ass
@@JazzMaster01 youre right BUT imagine youre in this universe and you want to have a lightsaber and feel the force but you cannot be a jedi because you need training and everyhing else but there is another chance as a dark side to be kind of free of any codex and just be how you are. If i had a chance I would take it!
Qimir's bracer and helmet are made of cortosis, which reflects energy and temporarily shorts out light sabers on contact. Also, Qimir isn't a Sith lord, he's an illegitimate second apprentice to the reigning Sith lord, Darth Tenebrous. The "real" apprentice is Darth Plagueis. When Qimir says that what he is has no name, but that the Jedi would think he's a Sith, he's being accurate. Because of the Rule of Two, Qimir can't be an actual Sith in technical terms, but the Jedi wouldn't make that distinction. If they keep with canon, then Qimir's Sith name is "Venamis," although he can't carry the "Darth" title. Venamis attempted to betray Tenebrous, failed, and suffered a fate worse than death. I'm fairly sure that is what "The Acolyte" is about, telling the story of Venamis' betrayal and failure. Darth Tenebrous was learning the secrets of manipulating life from the coven of Force witches, so the Jedi went there and killed everyone, which is the big secret they're keeping. Tenebrous and Plagueis took what they learned from the witches and tried to learn how to create or manipulate life, then Plagueis kills Tenebrous and takes Sidious as an apprentice. Plagueis and Sidious experiment with the knowledge and unwittingly create Anakin Skywalker.
Yo guys, Qimir very specifically didn't say he was a Sith. What he said was, "I have no name, but a Jedi like you might call me...Sith." I would also assume that they did the reveal at this point in the show because Qimir is not the Big Bad, he's just the primary antagonist fighting the heroes.
Nice..did not know this but that makes a lot of sense and if correct may shut up a lot of the "But the Lore is This people who are complaining that the show is screwing up the Lore its not at all then.
That's a very accurate description of what's occurring during this era. Darth Tenebrous is the Sith Lord that's experimenting with using the Force to create life. The tie-in with the Witches makes sense. Somehow, the incidents in this episode must be covered up by these Jedi because 100 years in the future, the Jedi of the Phantom Menace thinks the Sith are extinct.
@@ECA2 Everyone is going to die before the show ends. Its the only way. I think from the Jedi perspective, what happened is that Master Sol led a team to intercept the prime murder suspect before she could kill the wookie dude, and nobody ever returned from the mission.
I think this might be telling the story of Plagueis rather than Tenebrous, with Qimir being Plagueis' apprentice. I don't believe Venamis is included in current canon (although I'm admittedly no expert).
@@ModeMan101 Its true that both Tenebrous and Venamis are currently Legends, but they keep pulling characters and concepts from Legends and canonizing them through the various shows.
everyone's like "go x-23" with jecki, while i'm like "go lyra silvertongue" xD
Thank you!!
To be fair he DIDNT flat out say he was a sith, he said he has no name but a jedi like sol would CALL him sith.
That seems very intebtionally worded, they also played kylo rens motif for him twice. I think hes gonna turn out to be the first Ren, ot a sith
Qimir is trying to form the knights of ren. Since the knights of ren was never known about those 100 years bc they killed the ones that found out about their appearance but are known to use dark side power. Which is why he is looking for an acolyte. Read the knights of ren comic to understand a bit more bc he has all the feature of the knights of ren if you look closely.
Darth Swoll said the Jedi would refer to him as a Sith, but he never said he was one
Darth Swoll!!
Or Smilo Ren
🐐
Apparently the stranger's/master's/Qimir's helmet and brace/band around his left arm is made of a very rare material that is called cortosis. It can deflect blaster fire, stun rings, and lightsaber strikes, and can temporarily negate/short out lightsabers if it touches/hits the emitter of the lightsaber blade. However, it is fibrous and much more brittle compared to Beskar armor, because with repeated strikes, a lightsaber can still cut through it 🤔.
Sol feeling a familiarity with Qimir probably does have bigger meaning, but I figured Yord's reaction was simply because of the earlier interaction in the shop. And Qimir knows it's not Mae - he saw the tattoo. Same as I'm pretty sure Sol knows it is Mae, given his little "Where is she?" "Who?" "Your sister" interaction.
Dustin its Jecki not Jackie..put some respect on her name!!
Also the Rashomon is for what happened on Brendok
Plus they never said how long the stun lasts
And another thing (this comment is getting edited alot) he said "You jedi would call me Sith" never "I'm a Sith"
So his helmet and gauntlet are made of cortosis, its a brittle metal that can disrupt lightsabers and blasters
Ah this episode was a game changer thanks to the incredible lightsaber battle and the bread crumbs dropped by Qimir. Qimir seriously is the breakout character throughout every episode he has appeared in so far. Also the armor he wore can also short circuit the lightsaber and it's called Cortosis metal.
16:45 Not necessarily a plot hole, people have different reactions to stuns depending on their durability. Remember when we saw Ahsoka train to block blaster fire and she built a resistance to stuns?
While the reveal wasn’t really a shock I like how they did it. The only questions I have now:
1. What happened during the fire
2. What’s Sol hiding and what’s his relationship with the Sith
3. What’s going to happen to Mae and Osha
I think also these are peacetime Jedi, with very little practical fighting experience. Victims of their own success.
Pretty sure Qimir knows he has Osha. Like Dustin mentioned, she has short hair, she has a wound in her side and has a tattoo on her arm that Mae doesn’t which he got a clear look at.
also, he healed her. if it was mae, he would have killed her while she was knocked out. he didnt want mae as an acolyte anymore. he definitely knows it's osha.
WOW this show went from MID but interesting for the new Lore to HOLY HELL this is Incredible!!! AAAhhhh
He is the Apprentice, the master is yet to come.....
I just love the way Qimir fights
qimir's lines were so cold!
manny cooked with his performance!
Yord recognized him from the apothacary shop in ep 2
Oh that's right!
Oh, almost forgot, he never said he was Sith, he said the Jedi would call him Sith. So we will have to see, can't wait 😎 ✌️
It would reveal maby why so mand "sith" are sith but do not follow any sith codex and are just pretty much training themselfes and doing whatever they want.
Win it/The Stranger didn’t say he is a Sith. He said the Jedi would call him a Sith but he didn’t call himself a Sith. A lot of reactors assume he said he is a Sith but he never did. I believe Qimir/The Stranger might be the founder of the Knights of Ren.
i think so too. he even dresses like a knight of ren so maybe he is the founder. also...kylo's music.
Why does every ‘loose end’ have to be closed? How about some mystery
I was also thinking that there was some deeper history between Yord, Sol, and Qimir, but they would have recognized him before when they were tracking Mae. They all interrogated him together, so that may be the familiarity that they had.
I was gonna say, they already met and questioned him when they were looking for Mae so that's where they know him from. They didn't act like they knew him at that point when they first found him.
Dead men tell no tales.
Also- the Kylo Ren theme underneath that last scene with Qimir. Could be a Knights of Ren origin/connection there (and play into the "I have no name [for what I am]"-type angle), instead of a straight-out Sith (especially if Qimir is a rival apprentice to Plagueis- and would fit into the theme of a splinter order/rogue Jedi already suggested in the series, which would further murky the water in terms of the Jedi believing that the Sith could return a century later).
With Sol's darkness, being so tormented by his emotions this whole show.... could Sol actually end up becoming the Acolyte? A fallen Sol would be so tragic- but would also wrap up the biggest "if Qimir is a Sith, then how did Sol not tell the Jedi" question outside of the sisters.
Mae is either gonna kill Sol or like completely discredit him and erase evidence this episode gave me Darth Bane trilogy vibes especially the second book where a group of jedi discovered that Darth Bane was still alive with his apprentice and they killed all the jedi and put the blame on someone else
Kelnacca might get blamed.
@marshsundeen good theory but I was thinking of Sol like Mae as Osha tells everyone that he suddenly snapped and killed everyone that way when he tries to tells the jedi about the sith nobody believes him treachery is the way of the sith
Some of, if not the best, lightsaber fights in Star Wars history!!!!! Holy Moly 🔥🔥🔥🔥
Considering how obvious the reveal was, I'm assuming there's more to the mystery. A show rarely puts all of its cards on the table in episode 5 of 8. My theory is that the Sith that Mae encountered, there's two of them. There's a second one and they pulled a Scream on our asses. My guesses are that either Indira or Mother Korril are involved.
This looks likes the origins of the Knights of Ren, not Sith, if you ask me. The Sith already have a long lineage of masters and apprentices going back a long time, probably back to when they were a race and in large numbers. The Knights of Ren are a more recent version of forcer-users that also will use the dark side.
I like the lightsaber combat. Pure strategics and pretty much just overwhelming the enemy
Qimir even asked Mae why she didn't suspect him. He knew it was obvious too. I don't mind that. The real mystery is what happened on Brendok. It's probably not going to show Sol in a good light.
Qimir didn't leave the lightsaber behind. It got carried up with him when he got briefly abducted by the umbramoths. Also, it seemed pretty clear that Sol, upon reviving from the stun, was a bit unsettled and confused -- and maybe Mae used a little bit of Force suggestion on him to encourage him to immediately depart? As for leaving the bodies behind... come on. Not everyone is at Yoda, Anakin, Luke, or Rey power levels. Most Jedi probably can't easily hoist a whole body and carry it for literal HOURS, let alone seven or eight of them, and knowing that the bad guy is still around would definitely be a reason to get the hell out of the jungle ASAP.
They intentionally laid the ground for Qimir to be the Sith from the start. If things aren't setup viewers get upset it's some rando out of nowhere. If things are setup viewers are upset it wasn't a surprise rando.
Yord recognized him from when he was posing as the apothecary.
I have been eagerly awaiting THIS!!🍿☺️
16:49
"You never could block."
--Mae
I don't know how you'd block a blast, but apparently it can be done.
18:50 Sol spends the whole series calling Osha by her name to only ask, "where is she. Your sister?" Sol knows this is Mae. He chose these words to throw Mae and the audience off. He came to get Mae, wasn't going to lose the opportunity she presented him.
How is this going to play out?
Mother Aniseya and Mother Koril wanted Osha and Mae to stay together because the two need each other, they complete each other; they are two sides of the same coin:
"You're with me, I'm with you
Always one, but born as two
As above sits the stars, and below lies the sea,
I give you you, and you give me me"
--Mae and Osha
They never got to finish their training, but now they get that chance. Qimir has taken Osha and he's going to show her the Dark Side, which is her coven's witchcraft, the side she rejected 16 years ago. Sol has Mae, and Mae is going to see a different perspective, the Light Side of the Force.
The next three episodes should be interesting. We still have one more flashback with Kelnacca fighting someone on Brendok. And Master Vernestra using her whip lightsaber. Can't wait!
Mae blocked the stun shot with her arm, so presumably it softened the blow, while Sol got hit straight on.
It's not just a Sith who could potentially fight a group of Jedi like this. Any strong Dark Side Force User could if they are a strong lightsaber duelist and strong enough in the Force. Even the Jedi vary wildly in how good they are with a lightsaber. Hell, General Grievous could take on multiple Jedi and kill them without even having the Force.
Also, remember that Ahsoka was a Padawan when she fought Grievous, and wasn't even a Jedi when she defeated Maul, and Obi-Wan was a Padawan when he beat Maul. So being a Padawan doesn't mean you can't hold your own.
Qimir didn't actually say he was a Sith. He only said that a Jedi like Sol might call him a Sith. He might be something else. And his reveal of being Qimir, isn't for us, it's for the other characters.
Lastly, stun weapons usually only knock out an individual for a few minutes, although some could stay knocked out for up to an hour. So Mae getting up so quickly is not a plot hole.
They recognized him because they literally met him in episode 2. Great reaction by the way
oops, yep. thanks for the reminder 😅
Ki-Adi doesn't know yet. He knows someone is killing Jedi, but not that a Sith is involved. Only the ones involved in the fight know. Who knows if that information will actually get out.
I also don't like that people are agreeing that Sol is responsible for Jecki's death because he brought her. Let's totally forget the fact that Qimir stabbed her 3 times and is the whole reason they're there in the first place. Yes, she's a child, but she proved she was more than capable. I know she died, but lots of Jedi died in the battle.
He’s not a Sith. He says the Jedi would call him that.
@@jinxie712 I would agree, but Lucasfilm is officially saying he is a Sith now. Watch New Rockstars' breakdown. The showrunner confirmed it.
@@jinxie712Wrong.
I think it’s a great representation of a sith from that era. He’s young. I thought he was probably an apprentice the current Sith Lord at that time but now I’m not sure. It would make sense if he had just killed his master and is seeking an apprentice. Also because he’d be feeling especially powerful and confident at that time.
I also think it’s possible he’s the second apprentice of a sith master, who is preparing for one be defeated possibly at the hands of the other.
Actually he said he had no name but the Jedi might call him sith... could just be a dark side force user.
Enough with this cope. Leslye Headland, the showrunner, has confirmed in interviews that Qimir/The Stranger is a Sith.
@@firstlast-wm3li OK, what's "cope"? I purposely didn't watch any interviews with the cast or creators. Maybe that's why I am not hating on the show as much as other people are.
@@jeffcummins8639I'm not hating either. It's not perfect. The writing is terrible, but I can appreciate some good things once in a while. Also, he's a Sith.
He did emphasize that ambiguity- though he also did say that the Jedi say he shouldn't exist. Whether that is just playing into the "Jedi makes the rules" or "what a Jedi thinks I am" persecution ambiguities, or actually into the hidden Sith, it's hard to say yet.
Not really anything to do with coping. It’s literally what he said. I can Google the script for you, if you find it easier to understand in written form.
Jedi give people labels. This villian has no label. He just is.
Plus, they all met Qimir in the shop when they sent Osha in to talk to him.
the helmet could be either made from Mandalorian Beskar or that other element, Cortosis. Cortosis/Cortosis-Weave can withstand the blows of energy sabers and can actually temporarily short a lightsaber
Best saber choreography since Obi-wan vs Anakin
Not sure if he is officially a Sith though. He just said the Jedi could refer to him as one since he has darkness in him. I wonder if he has a master that may show up?
Another name I've heard for the masked one was "Darth Toothius". 😜
This is getting better and better
Kylo Grin. Darth Swole. Darth Teef. Smylo Ren. Zippy the Sith-head. Twisted Sithster.
Everyone in chat "but... HE NEVER SAID HE WAS A SITH" 😂😂😂😂
I don't want to be wrong because I don't remember the conversation with Anakin well but even Palpatine never told anyone he was a Sith
Finally been waiting for your guys reaction. I’ve been calling him Darth Zipperface. I’m still trying to come to terms with Jecki and Yord. It’s heartbreaking. Loved the Sith though I’m curious how they’ll continue after this.
NOBODY out of the reactors caught the Kylo REN theme haha good stuff
I do think Qimir's taunting of Mae "You really didn't know it was me, not even a little bit?" is more a touch on the fact the audience saw it was obvious and the fact Mae didnt see it was quite telling
i still think Qimir is an apprentice to the real Sith Lord cause who taught him ???
Are you forgetting that Ahsoka trained to be able to recover more quickly from stunners? Perhaps Mae did that, too.
they came out with a statement saying hes a sith lord, and him saying he wants a "pupil" clearly rule of two for the sith code.
They really did Naruto's Obito twist In this , they made "Quaimir" wear more backy clothes to hide his "guns" (muscles)😏
Am now wondering if the season will end with Osha learning about what Sol did and she becomes the acolyte.
Might mean nothing? The actress, Margarita Levieva who plays Mother Koril is the 4th Lead in Daredevil Born Again
Ok this was my favorite episode so much action and intensity I'm just gonna call him Manny as well haha but Manny is jacked what the heck Darth zipper is way to powerful, and SOL WHAT ARE YOU HIDING. Also forgot to mention the lightsaber fights were awesome including hand to hand
Did you like the bad guy getting away via giant bug attack?
@@TheRealBlackarrot it was 😎
NUTS!!!! 🔥🔥🤯🤯
Woop good Star Wars via The Acolyte on D+ 😋
I can't wait to see Kelnacca with black eyes under witch control in a flashback in Episode 7 (IMDb) fighting Torbin and Sol!❤
I think Sol will recognize Mae. She may be able to hide her mark on her forehead, but she doesn't have a tattoo on her arm like Osha🤣 Very interesting how Qimir proved that it is possible to kill a Jedi without a weapon and without Jedi rules. It's very ironic that he killed Yord, the Jedi who lived strictly by the rules! I found the Kylo Ren Theme, which played when Qimir found Osha at the end, interesting. Maybe he was the first Knight of Ren? Greetings from Germany😊
Although it's Qimir and it seemed obvious...it was SO well done that I don't care. Heck, that's not the main mystery of the show anyway. What happened 16 years ago is.
Reaction highlights 😂 :
9:37 Wendy: "Use the Force!!! ...OK, or headbutt."
12:54 Wendy: "Stop writing the show!" Dustin: "Sorry!"
13:08 Wendy: "He was hiding all those muscles." [silently fans self]
19:00 Dustin: "Let's... collect the dead?" Wendy: "Take the helmet back for proof...? We''re not gonna do any of that."
Well Ki-Adi doesn't know still that Qimir is involved let alone a Sith, but the whole point of that character is that he's wrong about everything, he was wrong about the siths extinction, he was also wrong about Dooku not being a murder
And brought up the droid attack on the Wookies. Causing yoda to leave the temple undefended.
How does it works that all complementary reviews on starwars s5 uploaded within an hour three days after show comes out?
I don't understand this comment?
Yord and Sol spoke to Qimir at the apothecaries.
In the beginning, Sith came first before Jedi was established during the Old Republic. Somehow, one sith created the Jedi order.
Keep in mind like in episode 3 the Sith already knew it was osha when she was trying to pretend she was her sister
He didn’t say im a sith.he said a Jedi like you might call me sith 🤦♂️
Those arms though....
😮
Well, technically he never called himself a Sith. He said “they (the Jedi) would call him Sith”.
The show is very simplistic, and it feels like a cartoon for children. It is enjoyable, but it feels like it's not elaborated or thought through for adults to enjoy (like Andor). But, well....
I think Yord recognized Qimir from when they met in episode 2, and maybe that's also where Qimir thinks Sol could have recognized him from. But Idk.
Qimir doesn't say he is a Sith... He says: "Jedi like you would call me Sith". As the show is so simplistic, though, that's probably what he is.
I'm sad about Jekki and Yord. They were cool. 🫤😭 Especially her.
The way Yord was killed was not super TV-14.
Great episode you guys keep it up 👍🏾
Thank you! Will do!
@@TheMovieCouple Your Welcome 👍🏾
Hey guys, Great reaction 😁, loving this episode, it's what we've been looking for!! Sith have returned, to bad everyone has to die! Or at the very least maybe one served an kept the secret, because they (Jedi) thought the Sith were gone for over 1000 yrs. And to bring Cortosis, from the comics is brilliant, ( his helmet an other parts he wore short circuits lightsabers when touched by them.. very Cool 😎. Keep it up ❤ Lv ya mean it ❤️
He didn’t say he was a Sith, he said he had no name, but the Jedi might call him a Sith. Yord recognized him because they interrogated him in episode 2
Qimir
Sorry Jedi, Sith happens...
Amazing episode. 👍🏾👍🏾
I don't think Qimir is a Sith. He just said that the Jedi would call him that. I believe he was a Padawan who left the Order and discovered the Darkside on his own. But he wants to become a Sith. Remember, the Sith are always in pairs - a master and a student. That's why Qimir wants to have a student. He probably thinks this is how he becomes a real Sith.
Beskar helmet 🪖 stops Jedi lightsabers and mind tricks…..right?
You two are the king and queen of wild assumptions lol
👑