What If Obi Wan Saved Dooku From Anakin Skywalker

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 614

  • @PentePatrolStarWars
    @PentePatrolStarWars  Рік тому +90

    Subscribe for a Chance to Win a Lightsaber in our 90k Subscriber Lightsaber Giveaway!!
    Lightsaber Giveaway: forms.gle/QfEXMddaEGvibd2h6
    Ownasaber: ownasaber.com/

    • @DarthNox66
      @DarthNox66 Рік тому +3

      Okay, when will the winner of this giveaway be announced? I've already ordered 2, and it would be really great to get a third.

    • @Yapftl
      @Yapftl Рік тому +3

      @@DarthNox66 it will probably be announced on his first or second video after he gets 90k subs

    • @stubannati
      @stubannati Рік тому +3

      WHY DO YOU KEEP KILLING PADMÉ?

    • @brokenbridge6316
      @brokenbridge6316 Рік тому +4

      This story went in some very unique n fun places. I really liked this one. Great job PP.

    • @DarthNox66
      @DarthNox66 Рік тому +2

      @@Yapftl Okay, thanks

  • @K369-v3o
    @K369-v3o Рік тому +343

    As the invisible hand crashed through the atmosphere of coruscant, Obi-wan took has hands away from the controls of the falling ship, he placed his arms above his head and looked towards the restrained Count Dooku.
    In a witty tone he exclaimed: "Look, Dooku!!! No hands!"

  • @Esgles
    @Esgles Рік тому +547

    I actually think Dooku could have been redeemed in this scenario because seeing the republic be changed is what he always wanted

    • @Grayg
      @Grayg Рік тому +23

      well, he was also a human supremacist so idk

    • @J10005
      @J10005 Рік тому +68

      ​@@GraygThat depends on the writer. Tales of the Jedi seems like a he was a populist of some sort who hated the corrupt elite

    • @Elyseon
      @Elyseon Рік тому +8

      ​@@GraygAnd his idea of the new order was a literal New Order. SS with lightsabers.

    • @aidonbrion950
      @aidonbrion950 Рік тому +4

      @@Elyseonpopulist love authoritarianism

    • @TheMimiSard
      @TheMimiSard Рік тому +22

      I propose a small alternate to this story that Dooku got his peace in Jedi custody, while he lived for a short while after his capture he would be able to work through things. His health is on a fast downwards, because frankly he's an old man who just got his hands cut off, but his last days he might be able to think through things.
      Conversely, maybe his constant thought that the Jedi should have been able to get his hint about the Sith Lord kept him feeling bitter at them for what he perceived a their blindness, and thus his last days remained Dark.
      Take or leave your preferred concept. I just like Jedi!Maul at the end.

  • @soularprimestudios5930
    @soularprimestudios5930 Рік тому +356

    I do believe the council would be pissed if they knew about Palpatine dawging Anakin to kill Dooku when he didn't want to...in a scenario he didn't do it and its reported by Obi-Wan...

  • @Fortnite_Frost_Clips
    @Fortnite_Frost_Clips Рік тому +319

    “This party is over” my favorite line of Mace Windu’s

  • @RyanTheDark
    @RyanTheDark Рік тому +472

    This is amazing. Saddening that the love of Anakin's life died but at least he got a chance to move on.

  • @barneseffect
    @barneseffect Рік тому +154

    Obi-wan isn't dumb. Based on his prior knowledge when Dooku told him a Sith lord was controlling the senate and seeing this manipulation first hand, I think he'd assess the situation pretty quickly. He'd very likely be reinforced by a nod of confirmation from Dooku. But from that point, who knows where that would have went!

  • @jeremyfong5684
    @jeremyfong5684 7 місяців тому +24

    "General Grievous, you're shorter than I expected"

  • @cvl9053
    @cvl9053 Рік тому +152

    What do you mean Palpatine wasn't affected by the order 18. He is the Senate.

    • @lelouchvibritannia4028
      @lelouchvibritannia4028 Рік тому +35

      Not. Yet.

    • @captainpanic3616
      @captainpanic3616 7 місяців тому +12

      It’s Treason the

    • @xyrodoggs4425
      @xyrodoggs4425 5 місяців тому +4

      *ignites lightsaber and screams

    • @SupermanYT.
      @SupermanYT. 5 місяців тому +3

      *Proceeds to cut down two jedi*

    • @ItzarReal
      @ItzarReal 4 місяці тому +5

      @@SupermanYT. *mace window has joined the chat*
      more like mace out the window lolololol

  • @jarmoliebrand2005
    @jarmoliebrand2005 Рік тому +110

    I loved the conversation between Anakin and Obi-Wan near the end, after Palpatine was already defeated. I haven’t really seen too many what ifs allow characters the breathing room to express their feelings after Palpatine’s death.

    • @PentePatrolStarWars
      @PentePatrolStarWars  Рік тому +12

      I'm so glad you enjoyed that aspect! I always want the characters to feel down to earth in these, without it dragging, and I'm glad that it's enjoyed!

  • @spideysg1163
    @spideysg1163 Рік тому +1007

    What if Darth Plagueis secretly survived Palpatines assassination attempt?

    • @furious_pie466
      @furious_pie466 Рік тому +281

      Palpatine: ironic he could save others from death but not himsel-
      Plagueis: are you sure about that

    • @kahneanimated2655
      @kahneanimated2655 Рік тому +54

      He has done that I'm multiple videos my friend

    • @dadha4663
      @dadha4663 Рік тому +43

      Sequels what they should’ve beem

    • @furious_pie466
      @furious_pie466 Рік тому +26

      @pokeclipz Either that or maybe he would hide in the shadows and wait until the perfect opportunity to sweep the rewards from Palpatine

    • @hackman669
      @hackman669 Рік тому +5

      That a boy 😁

  • @A-W80
    @A-W80 Рік тому +13

    I love the way the Jedi counsel are wrote here

  • @Norcalcoach
    @Norcalcoach Рік тому +11

    Out of all of these this is by far my favorite.

  • @Dumb_Gaming05
    @Dumb_Gaming05 Рік тому +494

    What if Palpatine was hit by a 2016 Honda Civic?

    • @PWR_ADA
      @PWR_ADA 8 місяців тому +47

      If he got hit by a 2016 honda civic in the prequels or originals he would most likely die if the 2016 honda civic was going fast but if it was the sequels he would 100% survive the hit of the 2016 honda civic

    • @Anonsloth26
      @Anonsloth26 8 місяців тому +19

      Reminds me of one video (I don’t remember the title or main topic) when grievous crushed Palps’ spine out of anger during his capture before the BoC

    • @youvebeengnomeed
      @youvebeengnomeed 7 місяців тому +4

      love that

    • @Specter1997
      @Specter1997 7 місяців тому +1

      @@Anonsloth26 I think it was that one the Jedi rally behind Ahsoka after she got accused?

    • @Anonsloth26
      @Anonsloth26 7 місяців тому

      @@Specter1997 I believe it was, but I’m not entirely sure

  • @Kubinda12345
    @Kubinda12345 Рік тому +48

    I know that Palpatine was a Sith who wouldn't give up even an ounce of power for anything but it's interesting to assume that the war would end just because Dooku and Grievous were neutralized (both here and in the film). I mean the CIS Senate and Council was still active so what prevented them from voting a new head of state and continue the war? Sure, Dooku was behind the separatist movement but the CIS wasn't some gang but an ideology which tend to outlive their creators.

    • @marikam2998
      @marikam2998 Рік тому +3

      Well, Given that Dooku was Palpatine's Accomplice. Knew that Palpatine was The Sith Lord then Obi-Wan who stopped Anakin from Killing could be considered The Will Of The Force Itself because, Survivor Dooku could help prevent The Destruction Of The Republic. The Destruction Of The Old Jedi Order. And The Enslavement Of The Galaxy. Anakin was supposed to keep Dooku alive In The Revenge Of The Sith for the sake of this, but Anakin In blind rage. And because of his hatred of Dooku decided to cripple. And behead Dooku to get revenge on Dooku for losing his right arm. And for his Defeats on Geonosis in the first battle with Dooku. Having done this, Anakin thereby did not listen to the smart. And wise advice that personal feelings shouldn't get in the way of the cause Obi-Wan gave him on Geonosis when Anakin was his still 19- year-old Jedi Padawan. Dooku had a lot to say. And to know. About that Palpatine orchestrated the Trade Federation Invasion. The Battle Of Geonosis. The Clone Wars. Political Overthrow of Finis Valorum. Killing Qui-Gon. The Clone Army with chips in their heads. And If Palpatine knew about The Prophecy of The Chosen One. And was possibly guilty Shmi's Kidnapping. And in Shmi's Death then Dooku could have told. And know about of this too. This would make Dooku was too valuable a source of information so there was no point in doing to him what Anakin did to him. And if Dooku did not expect betrayal from Palpatine, then Dooku, having told everything about Palpatine, could cruelly take revenge on Palpatine for the fact that he decided to get rid of him for the sake of Anakin forever.

    • @Bluelyre
      @Bluelyre Рік тому +8

      I believe they intended to regroup, then Palpatine sent Vader to basically murder them all in one go at Mustafar.

    • @Elyseon
      @Elyseon Рік тому

      The ones running the CIS were a gang. A gang of greedy bankers, industrialists, and imperialist warmongers.

    • @Kamilohbk
      @Kamilohbk 10 місяців тому +6

      The CIS wanted peace, its what they told Vader when he was sent to erradicate them; they never intended to go as far as the blockade on Naboo. Remember they asked Sidius if that was legal.

    • @Elyseon
      @Elyseon 10 місяців тому +3

      @@Kamilohbk They were just cowardly profiteers. They were pretty quick to change their tune once the prospect of more power and wealth was flashed in front of them.

  • @darthrevan6316
    @darthrevan6316 Рік тому +36

    This one probably has the best ending in terms of consequences for the war, but still being overall a happy ending.

  • @Luneraurt
    @Luneraurt Рік тому +78

    aint no way anakin had the balls to call grievous short lmao

    • @PentePatrolStarWars
      @PentePatrolStarWars  Рік тому +13

      Lmao

    • @amitassasson1893
      @amitassasson1893 4 місяці тому +2

      I hope this is a joke lol

    • @lolstalgic9602
      @lolstalgic9602 3 місяці тому

      Knowing Anakin, he would go full gamer and drop every midget slur in the known Galaxy. Darth Farquaad doesn't stand a chance.

  • @Kubinda12345
    @Kubinda12345 Рік тому +108

    Poor Padme and the twins.
    But it's nice that the galaxy and Anakin didn't fall to darkness. I loved that you included the High Republic and your OC Desha Numa.
    It's also funny that Maul became Jedi. Bo Katan must've really loved it 😀

  • @Jarikraider
    @Jarikraider 8 місяців тому +3

    Given Palpatine's position in office, the number of years the war has gone on, and the fact he was just kidnapped and held hostage, I don't think Obi-wan would have been too surprised by Palpatine's eagerness to finish Dooku from an emotional or political standpoint.

  • @mcl4549
    @mcl4549 7 місяців тому +95

    Obi-wan with Dooku: "it's not the jedi way"
    Obi-wan with General Grievous:

    • @Goldstandard_1
      @Goldstandard_1 7 місяців тому +29

      well that a little bit different, grevious was actively trying to kill him, dooku was unarmed (literally)

    • @DropShotMLG
      @DropShotMLG 6 місяців тому +4

      @@Goldstandard_1literally the only reason he wasn’t supposed to kill him lol. it would’ve been considered revenge for his arm. he must’ve forgot kenobi literally cut a Sith in half😂

    • @SeanWinters
      @SeanWinters 5 місяців тому +8

      ​@@DropShotMLGA sith who also was trying to kill him?!? How do y'all not know the difference between self defence and revenge?

    • @DropShotMLG
      @DropShotMLG 5 місяців тому +2

      @@SeanWinters you forgot that Sith just destroyed his master before his eyes. Kenobi would have lost that duel had he not been rage/revenge amped.

    • @MeanBeanComedy
      @MeanBeanComedy 2 місяці тому +1

      ​@@DropShotMLG ...But he still had a right to kill Maul and Grievous, because they were trying to kill him.

  • @GamingDrummer89
    @GamingDrummer89 Рік тому +105

    I'm glad you only had Windu show up to help Obi-Wan and Anakin rather than Yoda. The fight would have become one-sided if Yoda was there and completely broken and anti-climactic if BOTH Windu and Yoda came at the same time. This made for a better ending than Palpatine just being taken out easily. His contingency plan with Order 18 was also a brilliant storytelling move on your part!

  • @randybentley2633
    @randybentley2633 Рік тому +12

    A follow-up to this could be how the lives that were forever affected by the rise of the Empire and the Rebellion that resulted would tread down different paths. The Ghost crew comes to mind as a good start.

  • @Exaris79
    @Exaris79 Рік тому +9

    Now to make this interesting, follow up this storyline with the Yuzha'an Vong's invasion. They were put in low priority since there was the Clone Wars. Now that the war is over, they would need to get more info about the Vong as well as Thrawn making official contact with the Republic regarding the Vong too.

  • @lelouchvibritannia4028
    @lelouchvibritannia4028 Рік тому +8

    I love this so much. It feels realistic, that there still is so much darkness and things to worry about, even after Sidious' death. The dialogue is done so well, I could literally feel the grief Anakin had for Padme's death.

  • @cbells__
    @cbells__ Рік тому +41

    this was honestly such a good video. i loved hearing obi wan help anakin by talking openly about satine. well done ppsw!

  • @johnpittsii7524
    @johnpittsii7524 Рік тому +21

    What if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan or Pong Krell. Also what if Anakin was sent to kayshaxx instead of Yoda. Also what if Anakin was an Jedi bounty hunter

  • @fumkioyuki8457
    @fumkioyuki8457 Рік тому +13

    Had a bad day eating noodles and watching this hopefully it makes me feel better

    • @fumkioyuki8457
      @fumkioyuki8457 Рік тому +3

      Sooo it worked great. Video

    • @PentePatrolStarWars
      @PentePatrolStarWars  Рік тому +3

      I'm so glad you enjoyed! I hope you're feeling better!

    • @fumkioyuki8457
      @fumkioyuki8457 Рік тому +1

      I did wish I could see the live chat on the device I was using cannot wait to see more of your work I love it so much

  • @BrandleyR
    @BrandleyR Рік тому +23

    What if Anakin accidently made C3PO force sensitive when the droid was made?

  • @Slasher3352
    @Slasher3352 Рік тому +18

    DAY:8 Heres some what ifs. 1.What if the Rebel Alliance was crushed on Hoth? 2.What if the Trade Federation peacefully resolved the Naboo crisis? 3.What if Qui-Gon Jinn had trained Darth Maul as a Jedi? 4.What if the Jedi Council discovered Palpatine's true identity earlier? 5.What if Leia became a Jedi Master in the sequel trilogy? and finally 6. What if the Jedi and Sith coexisted peacefully? PLEASE DO ONE OF THESE THEYRE ARE SO INTERESTING🙏🙏🙏

    • @BipolarBisexual
      @BipolarBisexual Рік тому +1

      The Rebel Alliance WAS defeated on hoth

    • @Slasher3352
      @Slasher3352 Рік тому +2

      @@BipolarBisexual it was but im talking destroyed

  • @grandclanka321
    @grandclanka321 10 місяців тому +1

    Honestly this is one of the best ROTS What Ifs I've seen, one reason being the whole cliche of the fact Dooku would immediately betray Palpatine, I feel this video portrays his views quite well and his quite obvious hints, I also like the fact that Dooku being alive wasn't the impact of what lead the end of Palpatine's plans but rather Obi Wan seeing what he was doing and trying to lead Anakin away from it, to add when Palpatine was getting antsy about Dooku not dying, also love the fact this portrays how arrogant Grievous was and the need to please his master, catharsis of my opinion on this is that this stands out and succeeds at that, it makes more sense to fit that of the characters like Dooku's alignment not changing and y'know, calling the jedi kinda dumb for not finding it out and chastising them for it, not to mention at the end where they converted Maul to a jedi, I'm not too sure how I particularly feel however a good end for the character, overall good job on the video!

  • @tonydalehopkins
    @tonydalehopkins Рік тому +71

    Yay! I love it when maul becomes a jedi! I love it when Anakin stays firmly in the light side!! I love it when the Jedi order disengages from the republic to return to their proper ways! I love it when most of the jedi survive!!! this has so many great points to it!!

    • @PentePatrolStarWars
      @PentePatrolStarWars  Рік тому +9

      Yesss I know! Gotta love the Maul redemption XD I'm so glad you enjoyed!

    • @ChrisBear1989
      @ChrisBear1989 Місяць тому

      The Jedi have always been connected to the Republic, if anything them separating goes against established canon. Even the OT made them be put with the Republic.

  • @Rjfromoutsouth.04
    @Rjfromoutsouth.04 Рік тому +7

    Pls do more of those animated sections that was sick

    • @haydenfowle7576
      @haydenfowle7576 Рік тому

      Using more Clone Wars Style that would be killer

  • @cartoonzentertainment
    @cartoonzentertainment Рік тому +14

    A surprise to be sure but a welcome one, also day 10 of what if all of Domino Squad survived the fall of Rishi?

    • @aaronprosser4018
      @aaronprosser4018 Рік тому +1

      The domino squad one has already been done by someone else.

  • @willwunsche6940
    @willwunsche6940 Рік тому +6

    I want to see this whole thing animated out in Clone Wars Season 7 animation quality. Honestly kind of crazy this is such a good alternative story in a UA-cam video. You did really good

  • @ISawFiveHoursOfSleep
    @ISawFiveHoursOfSleep Рік тому +36

    "Obi-Wan got engaged" I know exactly what you meant, but I couldn't help but picture Obi-Wan proposing to Windu after the fight. Cause of his lightsaber handling.

    • @PentePatrolStarWars
      @PentePatrolStarWars  Рік тому +12

      Lmao no, because literally same! I was reading it and all I could think of was a marriage haha

  • @davidmauriciogutierrezespi5244

    33:42 Anakin to the 501st after arriving at Tattoine: BRING ME JABBA
    *later on, on Nal Hutta*
    Some shiny: Is General Skywalker ok? Should we do something about... _points to Anakin_
    Anakin: _using the force to float and fire multiple blasters while throwing thermal detonators into the homes of the Hutts_
    Shiny: ...all that
    Fives: Nah, the general used to be a slave and the Hutts were the ones who sold him, it's therapeutic for him
    Appo: Just keep a watch in case the general's eyes turn yellow, if they do General Kenobi said we should stun him and call for him or Commander Tano
    Shiny: The eyes?
    Rex: _amused laughter_ Jedis are like that, you'll get used to it shiny

  • @chasetauscher9544
    @chasetauscher9544 Рік тому +67

    What if Anakin Skywalker was trained by Darth Vectivus?
    What if the Separatist Council discovered the truth about Palpatine?
    What if Thrawn was a Jedi?
    What if Mother Talzin found Maul on Lotho Minor?

    • @jorgenitales412
      @jorgenitales412 Рік тому +3

      this one is interesting.
      the only way I see vectivus making it to anakin...is through ironically being frozen in carbonite or having darth venamis have a backup plan in the form of cloning vectivus behind tenebrous back.
      or just force ghost before dying, darth marr did it and there's no way vectivus couldn't do that.
      remember, he died CENTURIES before 40ABY, that means this motherfucker was around during the high republic era and probably saw a young prime yoda.
      in fact, force ghost is the best way.
      anakin was tortured by gardulla before watto bought them so that event could be enough for vectivus to manifest to anakin and become his "dad".
      vectivus would totally build anakin up to become one hell of a sith lord.
      in fact, I see anakin taking a reverse path, starting as a sith lord and ending with him becoming a jedi.

    • @user-qc8jd5tw6s
      @user-qc8jd5tw6s Рік тому +6

      2nd one is intresting, you always see this what ifs from the republic view, it be intresting if the CIS found out palpys evil plan

    • @chasetauscher9544
      @chasetauscher9544 Рік тому +2

      @@user-qc8jd5tw6s Maybe someone got curious about the Clone Army’s funding.

    • @Elyseon
      @Elyseon Рік тому

      The separatists wouldn't care, being greedy bastards.

  • @Blazeyblazeyblaze
    @Blazeyblazeyblaze Рік тому +9

    What if adi gallia trained anakin skywalker?
    What if tiplar was able to block tups shot and not die?
    What if the battle of coruscant never happened?
    What if even piell survived the battle of lola sayu?
    What if dooku was a undercover agent for the jedi?

  • @TheBigKup
    @TheBigKup 11 місяців тому +1

    I love including “this party is over” for windu again gotta give Sam Jackson the badass one liner

  • @DeclanWhite1453
    @DeclanWhite1453 Рік тому +4

    The sheer Grind you have uploading this often is insane thanks for fueling my autism

  • @littlefoot5013
    @littlefoot5013 Рік тому +12

    What if Chewbacca was a Jedi?
    What if somehow a droid rebellion began during the Clone Wars that pitted droids against all sentients?
    What if Darth Maul trained Anakin Skywalker?
    What if the Republic built a Death Star during the Clone Wars?
    What if Luke and/or Leia were part of the Rogue One mission?
    What if the Council of 2000 and the Jedi worked together during Revenge of the Sith (in a deleted scene, the Council considered working with the Jedi, whom some of them thought were probably as upset with the Palpatine situation as the Jedi, but, for whatever reason, it never happened in Revenge of the Sith.)
    What if the Jedi joined the Separatists?

  • @a.d.janson
    @a.d.janson Рік тому +1

    Been listening
    To all your videos recently at work, your my entertainment on my 6 hour shift, five times a week for the last few weeks. Just now putting a face to your voice, love the videos. Thank you much.

  • @tyleroakley5848
    @tyleroakley5848 Рік тому +6

    Congratulations on 80k I hope that you reach 100k soon you earned every sub may the force be with you

    • @PentePatrolStarWars
      @PentePatrolStarWars  Рік тому

      Thank you so much! Can't wait to get there with you guys! May the force be with you!

  • @MrOnepiece14
    @MrOnepiece14 11 місяців тому +1

    These stories are so cathartic and scratch such a good itch. Thanks so much

  • @reeceemms1643
    @reeceemms1643 Рік тому +5

    Day 22 of asking for one of these
    First this idea of a what if video that is like a choose your own adventure, where we get to effect the choices of the characters and we get multiple different endings. (for one of my what ifs that this could work well with is number three of what if Cal and Merrin had a daughter, because then we can make the decision of her path and have multiple endings, some good some bad then the viewers can see which one they get
    1) what if the Sith Empire returned during the High Republic era.
    2) another one of my favorites what if Jyn Erso survived combined with what if Jyn Erso met and fell in love with Luke Skywalker, (I know that is technically two but it's an interesting idea for a what if especially considering how many people were theorizing that Jyn Erso was going to be Luke's wife in canon and the mother of Ray during the lead up to Rogue one).
    3) what if Cal Kestic and Merrin had a daughter, (Jedi/Nightsister hybrid who tries to stick to the light but uses her Nightsister magic when under severe pressure in combat).
    4) just to see what happens what if the Daughter from the Mortis ark was a Jedi.
    5) what if Ezra and Sabine had a child
    6) What if Luke Skywalker fell in love with Doctor Aphra
    7) what if Padme was enslaved by the Hutts during the Clone wars
    8) what if Bo-Katan and Din Djaran fell in love during Mandalorian season 3 (like the original idea)
    9) what if the Daughter was a Jedi
    10) what if Padme was forced to marry for the Republic during the clone wars
    11) what if Galius Rax was at Endor
    1 and 2 are my favorite ones and so is the choose your own style

  • @davidrodrick2109
    @davidrodrick2109 Рік тому +5

    Here’s a couple:
    What if Anakin had nightmares of him striking down Obi Wan?
    What if Anakin did not lose his arm to Dooku?
    What if Shmi’s ghost came to comfort Anakin when he was in the Jedi temple while Mace went to confront Palpatine?

  • @plasmapea9822
    @plasmapea9822 Рік тому +13

    What if anakin turned back to the light during his duel on mustafar

  • @3.75istheway7
    @3.75istheway7 Рік тому +1

    Wow! I been with you a while and you have become my favorite person doing this! Great writing! The one when Anakin didn’t burn and meet obi wan a year later and hugged obi wan . All I could think about is the weight that came off his shoulders made me cry joy for obi wan!

  • @jaffarebellion292
    @jaffarebellion292 Рік тому +4

    I'd be interested in throwing a curveball into some of the later Legends books. What if Jacen Solo was never captured by the Yuuzhan Vong? It would change the entirety of the EU going forward.

  • @spartan078ben
    @spartan078ben Рік тому +13

    What if the Jedi Council saw Anakin's test of Asoka in Tales of the Jedi?

    • @haydenfowle7576
      @haydenfowle7576 Рік тому +3

      They would get that idea from Anakin and train their own students against Organic foes and more Jedi survive Order 66 thanks to Anakin and the Masters and Knights would practice against Clones and when Order 66 gets issued they would know how to react in that situation

  • @BLAKEBLUEJAY620
    @BLAKEBLUEJAY620 Рік тому +1

    This story was by far the best I've watch so far!!!!!!!!

  • @Derakin
    @Derakin Рік тому +26

    What if Anakin was reborn with all his memories?

    • @Jabes_1163
      @Jabes_1163 Рік тому +3

      That'd be awesome. Perhaps it'd happen during the Sequel Trilogy

  • @danielkim1634
    @danielkim1634 Рік тому +3

    Wow the annimation is crazy good

    • @PentePatrolStarWars
      @PentePatrolStarWars  Рік тому

      I'm glad you liked it! The full vid is right here: ua-cam.com/video/OWhEThZxIBk/v-deo.html

  • @Kubinda12345
    @Kubinda12345 Рік тому +30

    I've some ideas for What If:
    - What if Palpatine wasn't elected the chancellor of the Republic in Phantom Menace?
    - What if Anakin became friends with Iskat Akaris?
    - What if Anakin's bombing run managed to kill Grievous on Malevolence
    - What if it was Saw and not Steela who died on Onderon?
    - What if Anakin killed Dooku in their duel during the Rako Hardeen arc?
    - What if Tarkin died in the Citadel meaning there would be no Tarkin Doctrine for the Empire?
    - What if Qi'ra joined the Galactic Empire with Han perhaps becoming an ISB agent?
    - What if Han killed Darth Vader during the battle of Yavin?
    - What if the Ashmead's Lock's prisoners succeeded in assassinating Mon Mothma meaning that Leia would become chancellor and the New Republic wouldn't demilitarize?

  • @greencello599
    @greencello599 Рік тому +9

    What if Han Solo didn't take the job with Jabba the Hutt?
    What if Luke and Leia weren't separated and raised on Tatooine?
    Crossover: What if Obi-Wan made a deal to save Satine, only for her to die a different way in front of him, and during his exile, the being the deal was made with came to collect, leading Obi-Wan to become someone even Palpatine couldn't defeat, the Ghost Rider?
    What if Qui-Gon didn't take Jar-Jar with him to Mos Espa?
    What if Cobb Vanth really was a Mandalorian?
    What if the Tuskan Raiders didn't take Shmi?
    Crossover: What if the part of the Republic fleet under Obi-Wan's command encountered a wormhole that connected the Star Wars Galaxy with the Star Trek Universe and the first Starfleet vessel they make contact with is the Enterprise-D?
    What if Padmé discovered that Palpatine was the Sith Lord?
    What if certain events led to a young Hera Syndulla and Chopper joining the Bad Batch?
    Crossover: What if Obi-Wan and Satine in their teens crashed onto Earth near an almost empty community called Perfection, Nevada?
    What if R2-D2 decided to take a more active role in the Rebellion like Chopper?
    What if Aayla Secura was able to escape Felucia, meet up with Obi-Wan and Yoda, and argue against separating the Skywalker twins, leading to her and Obi-Wan to raising and training them?
    What if Han stopped Lando from cheating in Sabbac the first time they met?
    What if the Ghost Crew discovered the Death Star plans ahead of Rogue One?
    Crossover: What if Obi-Wan began to have the same strange dream about a far away world and an old woman called Mother Abigail, who calls him by name and tells him to bring all his friends and all the young ones to her, and upon waking up, Obi-Wan finds that others have been getting the same dream, including Satine, Aayla, Caleb Dume, Padmé, Cal Kestis, Boba Fett, Waxer, Boil, and several other Jedi, clones, and civilians?
    What if Qui-Gon was wounded after the first encounter with Maul and a different Jedi with their Padawan went back to Naboo?
    What if the Rebellion found abandoned Seperatist droid divisions and used them in scouting areas and planets?
    What if Ahsoka wasn't there to be accused when the Jedi Temple got bombed?
    What if Huyang was able to rescue the younglings, Padawans, and the wounded from the Jedi Temple during Order 66?
    What if after the Mandalorian Wars, the Jedi and Mandalorians agreed to train together as allies, leading to a much different Jedi Order to come about?

  • @noahsibahi-jackson8757
    @noahsibahi-jackson8757 Рік тому +2

    Haven’t watched you in a while, but it’s good to be back always loved your videos

  • @minimareanie1044
    @minimareanie1044 Рік тому +11

    Day 6 of asking what would happen if Dooku found and raised Ahsoka from a young age. It's just such an interesting concept to me.

  • @SpadesNeil
    @SpadesNeil Рік тому +21

    I like the idea that Palpatine had a contingency for if the Jedi went to the senate like that.

  • @SirSongi
    @SirSongi Рік тому +1

    When mace showed up, I straight geeked out LOL. GJ man

  • @ChanoCYBER9Avila
    @ChanoCYBER9Avila Рік тому +12

    What if Revan didn't die but was under Cryosleep deep in the temple and was awoken during the attack on the temple?

    • @yeetyskeet5548
      @yeetyskeet5548 Рік тому +2

      That would be realllllly sick will not lie

    • @ChanoCYBER9Avila
      @ChanoCYBER9Avila Рік тому +2

      @yeetyskeet5548 the restricted section is a good place to keep him

  • @SockyNoob
    @SockyNoob Рік тому +1

    I wish Star Wars had an alternate timeline series that answers these questions and shows different outcomes, a new version of Legends basically. Other media franchises have made non-canon alternate timeline series before without confusing everybody.

  • @Kevin-zz9du
    @Kevin-zz9du 24 дні тому +1

    This was VERY good.
    1 and only nitpick, is I feel Anakin would have had a total breakdown. May have even... ended it. He was an emotional being. He didn't have the same emotional control as the other Jedi.
    He seemed to take it way too calmly. Lol
    Beyond that, this was excellently written!

  • @TheOneWhoReportsForDuty
    @TheOneWhoReportsForDuty 11 місяців тому

    I love how you occasionally bring up Satine in these. It's a nice little callback and something that would definitely impact Obi Wans choices more if the movies were made now with Clone Wars in mind.

  • @ReubenRunacres
    @ReubenRunacres 5 місяців тому +2

    I feel like Grievous with a literal supercomputer for a brain would realize that Dooku had no hands

  • @michaelsmith622
    @michaelsmith622 Рік тому +11

    Palpitine: 😣 Doh!! Why at this moment did Obi Wanna have to wake up from his nap?

  • @DarthTiger2099
    @DarthTiger2099 Рік тому +1

    Man these videos can only get better. May the Force be with YOU.

  • @Fressedrt14
    @Fressedrt14 Рік тому +8

    I loved this scenario, it is sad that Padme dies in this version but a great story overall 🤘🏻😌🙌🏻🌌

  • @ttlghosty
    @ttlghosty Рік тому +8

    This was an absolutely amazing video! An interesting turn removing Padme from the picture.

  • @Bigdan678
    @Bigdan678 Рік тому +7

    Another beautiful story

  • @Armor_of_Torrent
    @Armor_of_Torrent Рік тому +10

    I love your stories. They're getting better and better!!

  • @CharlieHepp
    @CharlieHepp 9 місяців тому +1

    Obi-Wan isn't dumb. Based on his prior knowledge when Dooku told him a Sith lord was controlling the senate and seeing this manipulation firsthand, I think he'd assess the situation pretty quickly. He'd very likely be reinforced by a nod of confirmation from Dooku. But from that point, who knows where that would have gone! There is no way Anakin had the balls to call grievous short lmao I'm glad you only had Windu show up to help Obi-Wan and Anakin rather than Yoda. The fight would have become one-sided if Yoda was there and completely broken and anti-climactic if BOTH Windu and Yoda came at the same time. This made for a better ending than Palpatine just being taken out easily. His contingency plan with Order 18 Wars is also a brilliant storytelling move on your part! What if Palpatine was hit by a 2016 Honda Civic? I loved the conversation between Anakin and Obi-Wan near the end after Palpatine was already defeated. I haven’t really seen too many what-ifs allow characters the breathing room to express their feelings after Palpatine’s death. I love the way the Jedi counsel is written here What do you mean Palpatine wasn't affected by Order 18. He is in the Senate. this was honestly such a good video. I loved hearing Obi want to help Anakin by talking openly about Satine. well done PSW! The sheer Grind you have uploading this often is insane thanks for fueling my autism I like the idea that Palpatine had a contingency for if the Jedi went to the senate like that. Out of all of these, this is by far my favorite. I know that Palpatine was a Sith who wouldn't give up even an ounce of power for anything but it's interesting to assume that the war would end just because Dooku and Grievous were neutralized (both here and in the film). I mean the CIS Senate and Council were still active so what prevented them from voting for a new head of state and continuing the war? Sure, Dooku was behind the separatist movement but the CIS wasn't some gang but an ideology that tends to outlive their creators. A follow-up to this could be how the lives that were forever affected by the rise of the Empire and the Rebellion that resulted would tread down different paths. The Ghost crew comes to mind as a good start. I feel like it really isn’t out of character for a prisoner to ask his rescuers to kill their captor. Yay! I love it when Maul becomes a Jedi! I love it when Anakin stays firmly on the light side!! I love it when the Jedi order disengages from the republic to return to their proper ways! I love it when most of the Jedi survive!!! this has so many great points to it!! Now to make this interesting, follow up this storyline with the Yuzha'an Vong's invasion. They were put in low priority since there was the Clone Wars. Now that the war is over, they would need to get more info about the Vong as well as Thrawn making official contact with the Republic regarding the Vong too. A surprise to be sure but a welcome one, also day 10 of What if all of Domino Squad survived the fall of Rishi? Poor Padme and the twins. But it's nice that the galaxy and Anakin didn't fall into darkness. I loved that you included the High Republic and your OC Desha Numa.
    It's also funny that Maul became Jedi. Bo Katan must've really loved it 😀on Day 6 of asking what would happen if Dooku found and raised Ahsoka from a young age. It's just such an interesting concept to me. To all your videos recently at work, you have my entertainment on my 6-hour shift, five times a week for the last few weeks. Just now putting a face to your voice, love the videos. Thank you very much. I love including “This Party is Over” for Windu Again gotta give Sam Jackson the badass one-liner This one probably has the best ending in terms of consequences for the war, but still overall a happy ending. I want to see this whole thing animated out in Clone Wars Season 7 animation quality. Honestly kind of crazy that this is such a good alternative story in a UA-cam video. You did really good
    Had a bad day eating noodles and watching this hopefully, it makes me feel better What if Anakin was reborn with all his memories? Wow! I have been with you a while and you have become my favorite person doing this! Great writing! The one when Anakin didn’t burn and met Obi-Wan a year later and hugged Obi-Wan. All I could think about was the weight that came off his shoulders made me cry joy for Obi-Wan! Congratulations on 80k I hope that you reach 100k soon you earned every sub may the force be with you These stories are so cathartic and scratch such a good itch. Thanks so much What if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan or Pong Krell. Also what if Anakin was sent to Kayshaxx instead of Yoda. Also what if Anakin was a Jedi bounty hunter Palpitine: 😣 Doh!! Why at this moment did Obi Wanna have to wake up from his nap? IP meeting ls do more of those animated sections that were sick DAY:8 Here are some what-ifs. 1. What if the Rebel Alliance was crushed on Hoth? 2. What if the Trade Federation peacefully resolved the Naboo crisis? 3. What if Qui-Gon Jinn had trained Darth Maul as a Jedi? 4. What if the Jedi Council discovered Palpatine's true identity earlier? 5. What if Leia became a Jedi Master in the sequel trilogy? and finally 6. What if the Jedi and Sith coexisted peacefully? PLEASE DO ONE OF THESE THEY ARE SO INTERESTING🙏🙏🙏I love your stories. They're getting better and better!! What if the Jedi Council saw Anakin's test of Asoka in Tales of the Jedi? The Palpatine end was him rolling a nat1 on charisma check lmao When Mace showed up, I straight geeked out LOL. GJ man The ultimate disrespect to Darth Sidious: Turning Maul to the light. That's a power play right there.
    Powerful one, great job mate.

  • @oliversherman2414
    @oliversherman2414 Рік тому +1

    I think the name for Order 18 is quite clever

  • @zachjames6181
    @zachjames6181 Рік тому +19

    what if Obiwan was Dooku's Padawan.

    • @hackman669
      @hackman669 Рік тому +1

      Why not Anakin? 😇😆👍

    • @zachjames6181
      @zachjames6181 Рік тому

      he already did that. ua-cam.com/video/SCFgyqkKB5A/v-deo.html @@hackman669

    • @PentePatrolStarWars
      @PentePatrolStarWars  Рік тому +1

      @hackman669 Dooku Trained Anakin: ua-cam.com/video/SCFgyqkKB5A/v-deo.html

  • @Shia10101
    @Shia10101 Рік тому +5

    Always love listening to these at work, keep em coming 🔥

  • @ThatAussieSiesta
    @ThatAussieSiesta Рік тому +10

    Another wonderful tale, a light hearted take even with the tragic loss of Padme.

  • @Ear4
    @Ear4 Рік тому +5

    I wish you had done more with Dooku, and I absolutely reject the idea that the Jedi would kill Dooku.

  • @RabbitineRabbitier
    @RabbitineRabbitier Рік тому +1

    It was a great think about story with Obi-Wan resonating with Anakin and The Jedi telling the truth and the idea of ​​Palpatine with Order 18
    but then you first mentioned Padme and about how Palpatine knew he was going to deal with inhibitor chips, but then I thought it wasn't about Order 18. I thought Palpatine was going to put an inhibitor chip inside Padme's head to control her to convince Anakin to go with him instead of listening to The Jedi.

  • @Deku-vo2dn
    @Deku-vo2dn Рік тому +1

    I find it crazy that if it wasn't for Dooku knocking Obi-Wan out he probably would had been alive. and Dooku telling the Jedi everything and that Palpatine is a Sith Lord.

  • @johnkim7890
    @johnkim7890 10 місяців тому

    "take a seat 'master skywalker'" Mace nodded with approval. xD I would have added that.

  • @ShivamKumar-ym9ek
    @ShivamKumar-ym9ek Рік тому +2

    this is incredible. one of the best theory's you've made

  • @bkoch1
    @bkoch1 Рік тому +3

    I’m waiting for a story in which Anakin does more than use his light saber to fight Palpatine. I think a story in which he kills Obi Wan and then goes to kill Padme triggers him to go dark side (like with his mom’s death). Whether he suddenly goes force lightning, or force choke/neck snap in a temporary moment.

  • @ethankearney8240
    @ethankearney8240 Рік тому +1

    Bro I thought I'd been subscribed to you but I wasn't. Subscribed! I love these videos. It's funny to me that people like you can write a more compelling story than Disney who owns the damn franchise.

  • @sithmaster345
    @sithmaster345 Рік тому +3

    0:06
    PPSW: We're doing a new lightsaber giveaway for 90,000-
    Me: *AW HAIL NAW, BRUH-*
    PPSW: -subscibers!
    Me: ..Oh. Okay, then.

  • @timothyschwartz5518
    @timothyschwartz5518 Рік тому +2

    What if General Gervious killed Palpatine on the invisible hand?
    What if Anakin and Padme adopted Hera Syndulla?
    What if Anakin and Padme adopted Omega?
    What if Bariss was discovered before she could bomb the temple?
    What if Anakin was elected Supreme Chancellor after he saved Rotta the hutt?

  • @goonmal
    @goonmal Рік тому +1

    I PRAY THAT ONE DAY INSTEAD OF THESE AMAZING AUDIO STORIES THAT YOULL BE ABLE TO MAKE THESE STORIES INTO REAL LIFE FAN FIC MOVIES BECAUSE YOU HAVE THE ABSOLUTE BEST STORIES IVE EVER HEARD OF ALL TIME

  • @y.n.tryone4683
    @y.n.tryone4683 Рік тому +2

    36:04 I don’t think maul would ever go to the light side , I think he’s too far in the dark to embrace the light . He does have a hatred for the Jedi , I think your part 2 would have been maul and dooku in jail communicating each other in solitary confinement and maul using a dark side frenzy forge ability to break free and free dooku him having a hallway scene him and dooku escaping to malacore or exegole or the unknown region and plan to take control of the galaxy with crimson dawn and mandatory they go into hiding for years and come back and try take over , that would be a good sequel to your what if

  • @matthewmann8969
    @matthewmann8969 Рік тому +10

    What if Dooku in Revenge Of The Sith was able to destroy both Anakin And Obi Wan at the same time lets say he was just that good when he wanted to be and Palpatine did not rig or fix the fight?

  • @longsalad5334
    @longsalad5334 Рік тому +1

    The little bit about Maul at the end was really heartwarming

  • @thatdogguy9838
    @thatdogguy9838 Рік тому +4

    Okay man listen. There is this series of books about anakin as a padawan and obi wan as his master. And anakin had a rival. And that rivals master was obi wans rival as well when he was a padawan, but they later on became friends. She had a purple lightsaber i eblieve. Super niche legends stuff. What if the rival was anakins master and obi wan thaight anakins rival. For the legends enthusiasts my man. Also a really good read just in general. We had them at our local library, idk if you wnat to spend money on them but if there are summary videos give it a go

  • @barnir16
    @barnir16 Рік тому +2

    Powerful one, great job mate

  • @havok6280
    @havok6280 Рік тому +15

    The council didn't know Palpatine was a Sith. They distrusted him but Windu was shocked when Anakin told him.

  • @phageling9949
    @phageling9949 10 місяців тому +2

    I feel like it really isn’t out of character for a prisoner to ask his rescuers to kill their captor.

  • @Capsicle11
    @Capsicle11 Рік тому +2

    Never thought laden would sue but here I am crying

  • @seansmith8758
    @seansmith8758 5 місяців тому

    I really enjoyed this ride. This one truly stands out. Obi-Wan was able to save his brother. Sadly, Padme died, but with the emperor destroyed and the Sith defeated, Anakin restored balance to the force without the need for Luke to save him at his end. It's a cruel galaxy sometimes, but it was for the greater good. I was truly rivitid on this one. Bravissimo!!!

  • @thelukeofficial9626
    @thelukeofficial9626 Рік тому +1

    Disney really needs to do a what if because these are amazing

  • @dianesinger9729
    @dianesinger9729 Рік тому +19

    Amazing story as always. I liked how Anakin grew past his losses and became a true Jedi

    • @marikam2998
      @marikam2998 Рік тому +2

      Yeah, The Stories in which Anakin grew past his losses and became a True Jedi are always worth it.

    • @guilhermehank4938
      @guilhermehank4938 Рік тому +1

      A true man moves on from grief instead of causing more to the world around them

    • @stevesleg
      @stevesleg Рік тому

      @@guilhermehank4938Only a Jedi🤷‍♂️

    • @marikam2998
      @marikam2998 Рік тому

      @@guilhermehank4938 Yeah, This is also true. Perhaps it would be better if Anakin attacked Palpatine ater The Revenge Of The Sith. And Palpatine by killed him because, that way Anakin would have been freed from Palpatine. And rid myself of the guilt of Death Of The Rebels. And In The Death Of Jedi Survivors. Anakin lost everything in The Revenge Of The Sith, so the only thing he can choose is death because of Palpatine after the news of Padme's Death. However, in this case Yoda. And Obi-Wan would have had to secretly train Luke from birth. And Leia is like a Jedi until they grow up. And they won't be powerful enough to rid everyone of Palpatine. Although Obi-Wan, too, can be understood, he lost everything because of Palpatine. Because of Anakin. And because of Padme. At The Survivor. And The Crippled Anakin who, lost everything was left 2 children from Padme. While At Obi-Wan who, lost everything was left only Yoda, even though Obi-Wan after and started be attached to Anakin's Children of Anakin. And love to Anakin's Children later. And Anakin, although he betrayed him but he, was, like Yoda, all that At Obi-Wan could have left. And Therefore, if he killed Anakin then it could completely psychologically kill Obi-Wan who, whith Yoda lost everything because of Palpatine. Because of Anakin. And because of Padme In The Revenge Of The Sith.

    • @PentePatrolStarWars
      @PentePatrolStarWars  Рік тому +1

      I'm so glad you enjoyed!

  • @Yetigaming420
    @Yetigaming420 9 місяців тому +1

    I love how you had fun when anakin got to kill the hutts lol

  • @mark109s
    @mark109s Рік тому +2

    Great job, I loved this story. Thanks

  • @KeithDameo
    @KeithDameo Рік тому +1

    Definitely one of your better stories, though the ending with the lock them away and give them a peaceful death was... a little weird but over all I think you did a pretty good job in this one.

  • @hanzoofoasisworld7953
    @hanzoofoasisworld7953 Рік тому +10

    What if Pre Vizsla killed Maul?