Scalia on healthcare ruling: "Water over the dam"
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 лис 2012
- Justice Antonin Scalia has spent 26 years as a conservative leader on the Supreme Court. In a rare interview, he spoke to Charlie Rose about some of the court's most controversial rulings -- including the decision to uphold President Obama's Affordable Health Care Act.
I could see why he and RGB were friends. He seems like he was a really nice man.
*RBG
@@henrysmith8630 no Ruth Gayder Binsburg suits her best!
Even though Scalia comes across as a conservative I see integrity and fairness.Not a problem with this man
Because that is what conservatives are like, I think you’re confusing the fact that leftists don’t have integrity or fairness.
@@sirpillowofbread7904 true
@@sirpillowofbread7904 Conservatism is a mental illness
love that he talks like a normal person and not an academic scholar
What a candid and lighthearted interview, RIP Scalia and thank you for your dedication to upholding our democratic principles
Why did you copy the other guy lol
Scalia was one of the greatest justices to ever serve the court. He simply stated the truth, no matter what other people thought. Rest In Peace.
It's sad to see him go, while Sotamayor sits up there making bias decisions as a SCOTUS
@@bigsassyster He didn't "Go"...He was Shoved Out & Buried!😎
Murdered
@@thestation4768 We Lived 10-12 miles away from. that place.... In Texas, that's Next Door! Everybody here Knew/Knows he was Murdered! That's the Only Reason MSM told the FEW Facts they did!😡
@@oldcait6886 I'm from Dallas, what did you hear?
Thank you for posting this, CBS News! 😀
I love Scalia
Our fellow Americans will miss him after we continue to loose our rights.
Americans who say they love America is tested on voting day.
Keep on voting Democratic!
How much more freedoms will we loose?
Every single one of them.
+Logic Time, I guess you love racism, homophobia, and sexism
@@brainboy109 I don't think he is any of those things, just from looking at his history of cases.
Rest in Peace Scalia. It is sad to see so many celebrating death. Scalia lead a great life and now the country mourns his death. We shouldn't celebrate death, and I find it sickening for those who do.
+Theodore Numbers Nobody's celebrating his death, but you can't deny that him leaving the supreme court has huge implications. The same things would be said if he simply resigned. From what I've heard of him, I'd probably strongly disagree with him on almost every issue, but in spite of that, as a human being, rest in peace Scalia.
+DaffyDaffyDaffy33322 Tons of people are, you can scroll down the comments of this video to see someone celebrating with "ding dong the witch is dead."
+Theodore Numbers, why not celebrate his death? If it was up to him we would have a healthcare system that caused the death of tens of thousands of uninsured Americans each year! I say, Cheers! The witch is dead! RIP, rest in piss
If you are born you die...soo...
Joshua Bryant Hopefully only a few people abuse their power and say such hateful disgusting things like Scalia did in between though
Wish he stayed on the bench forever.
Who came up with the term bench?
You mean for like thousands upon millions of years?
It boggles the mind how an originalist and textualist could think the Judicial Branch has the power to stop a state from counting its votes.
And the current crop of originalists don't consider anything "water over the damn".
I really like the way he used to think
I remember when President Reagan chose to nominate Judge Scalia. Many people though his views were dradical and even dangerous.
He was certainly very radical, I think you could reasonably say he totally changed the way we look at legislation and ended the idea of constructionism.
Yet he was confirmed by a 97-0 vote?
I'm glad rambling, babbling, Charlie Rose is off the air... sheesh... he totally gets in the way of any sort of clear interview
R.I.P. Sir...
They're very good at printing paper at school.
That's very business-y.
The anchor talks more than the guest.....:)
Scalia is probably the greatest supreme court judge that ever lived.
No question
Top 5, yes.
In the last hundred years
@JediNxf7 LOL Well maybe I was stretching it a bit :)
Looks like a great person to sit with on a bench in the middle of Central Park on a beautiful summer day with a cool breeze and talk about history and the constitution. Oh and with hotdogs in one hand and a coke or Pepsi on the other.
Government payed for his Healthcare
He gets a really bad rep, but if you actually read the discents and look at his philosophy it’s incredible.
He will be missed.
Why on earth does this video have “context”. Thanks UA-cam.
Believing in textualism is believing in separation of powers. If a justice is free to interpret a law they way they see fit at that time, then you might as well get rid of the legislative process. Don't think a law addresses the needs of today? Then pass a new law!
meet the Jackie Gleason of the court.
He looks very young for a older obese guy. He looks 50.
Looked. Looked. Don't you know he died?
@@Mad5am Talking in the context of the video. Hes alive in the video and he looks 50 in it, saying he looked 50 is past tense and not needed in this comment as its not a video about him being dead.
Those good Italian genes, man.
@@simondodd918 did a skincare routine that consisted of covering his face with pasta and meatballs over the eyes. Italian secret
@@fightttttt Your comment as written would imply he is still alive. At least that's how it reads to me and presumably other people.
except that he DIDNT want to be chief justice and they cut him off before he could finish.
What the fuck is it that Charlie Rose finds so fucking amusing that he cannot stop laughing?
Scalia was a great justice--- too bad he was murdered before his time. A horrific loss.
Feliciano Leon he wasn’t murdered
@@jacobbonfante3037 wake up idiot he was murdered by the clinton operatives but the mainstream media won't tell you
@@geesi9645 well it sure backfired for those Clinton ops didn't it
@@andrewpearson1903 sure we got trump happy days
@@geesi9645 Mission accomplished
God I miss him.
Susie Que Me, too. 🤔
I prefer an interviewer who speaks less than the person they are interviewing.
Why cant Charlie Rose stop talking? We came to hear the Judge.
THIS IS BULL NO GOVERNMENT CAN FORCE THE PEOPLE TO BUY ANY INSURANCE LOOKING OUT FOR CORPRATION NOT THE PEOPLE AND WHY DO THE COURTS OR GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEE DECIDES OUR RIGHTS THATS THE PEOPLES RIGHTS
Yes good juris. That Robert's "BUT" was a low blow. Terrible.
Few great public servants the last few decades. Scalia definitely. Raygun. Not sure about who else.
I'd say probably Lincoln, Washington, Jefferson, Hamilton, FDR, LBJ, Kagan.
Congress passed a healthcare law, what was so controversial? The individual mandate should not have been a tax, but in the end, it didn't matter because Obamacare didn't depend upon it. The real mistake was never made, which would have been to go back to insurance before Obamacare.
A WIN WIN FOR POLITICS BUT A LOSER FOR THE MIDDLE CLASS.
The Bush vs Gore ruling was really stupid. The idea that you have to have the same ballot machines and counted in the same manner.
Graham6762 Moreover , he and his buds were not ordained by God, he was APPOINTED by a PREZ and the PREZ returned the FAVOR and is a prime reason that the Court can not be trusted. You scratch mine and I’ll scratch yours. Now they are about to do it again!
No.
I just wish more shared his constitutional ideology
Barrett seems pretty similar, considering she clerked for him, is a textualist, and is pretty brilliant
Evan Roden She's also in a cult
@@candicehoneycutt4318 I mean, it's hard to say. I'd agree that it seems cult-y, but it's too subjective and hasn't had any impacts on her decisions.
And the World is laughing at s now
I would like to know in detail the reason some of you disliked Justice Scalia?
+AMERICAs MOSQUEs INFILTRATION F- Correctnes, he was a homophobic asshole
+trump “2016” ! Did "the Donald" actually say that in response to Mr. Gabe"s comment? I am not defending, or agreeing with what he wrote (Mr. Gabe)....however, Trump has had exactly one real challenge in his life....negotiating his Mom's birth canal, which obviously he did.....He's here....after that, given his Dad's position in the NY real estate community he could have "thrown-up" on investor's Florsheim's on the 1st & 15th of the month consistently & still made a fortune!! The man was in the "Son Business...." How actually intelligent could a person be who utters these words......."People are amazed at how smart I am." This guy Trump isn't even remotely bright.....yet could still win.....Yikes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
trump !
Most dumbest... oh yes... it be the most dumbester comment.
trump !
Take an English class kid and grow up.
***** stop being a moron and at least try to defend your view you sack of horse shit liberal.
he thinks "they're a good supreme court according to their philosophies" here. murderers are good murderers according to their philosophy as well.. what could that even mean
I wonder if Charlie Rose walked around naked for Scalia before the interview.
Scalia, great man--great American----great Sicilian-American
Lol.
I love my teachers.
+ Tony Boy (Bud)+ no, but I was in a little known program there, w/only 13 students, where we & our professors for 3 years, had to agree: support communism, pledge support of 110% marginal tax rate on more than $75k/yr & for the first $75k, 90%, agree to defend either Clinton, WHEN indicted on any felony & FALN, decry the fall of the USSR, pledge allegiance to Putin, & agree to worship to Stalin.
Make some sense please
Don't go to church to be around good people.
Schools!
Do people like visa cards
Not an issue of law it’s an issue if practicality. I could respect Scalia if he didn’t undo his whole jurisprudence with that weak justification for his ruling
He’s consistent in being vapid for sure
"Antonine"?
Rose is (was) the most annoying interviewer I have ever heard. He wouldn’t let the interviewee talk. Who wants to hear Rose babbling and laughing while a great intellect is trying to respond to his (often idiotic or half baked) questions?
Whether you agree or disagree with the late Justice Antonin Scalia's judicial philosophy he had a brilliant legal mind and had a great personality and sense of humor 😂.
Lonzo just copies me.
Yet I posted a bunch of better information online.
An originalist talking about practicality.
what a horrible interview, this reporter thought he was the star, let the real star talk!
The man is just such a liar. Gore vs Bush wasn't a poltical decison? Give me a break. What Constitutional text says that Florida has to stop counting votes. Can anyone really believe that if Gore was ahead in the last vote recount, the 5 conservatives would have said stop the recount?
Better a liar than a dolt like you!
Thank you for admitting that he was a liar.
How many more recounts should we have had? It had to end at some point.
Gore's position was a farce. He didn't want to recount Florida. He wanted to recount a few overwhelmingly Democratic counties and find the few thousand votes that he lacked. Sorry, Al. Womp! Womp!
no the courts have made mistakes in the past.. this is just another example.
Water over the dam is an answer unworthy of justice Scalia's intellect.
Perhaps not, but worthy of yours
Justice Barret will uphold his legacy well
Not really. She's a partisan hack.
"Get over it" and yet he moaned and groaned about Roe v Wade til the day he died.
On a consitutionality basis not out of morality. Difference.
Gore v Bush is rightly criticized on jurisprudential grounds, not just as a matter of political preference. It was one of the most consequential decisions in Sup Ct history, was wrongly decided on the law in the eyes of many, and yet Scalia had the gall to ask ppl to "get over it" just years afterward bc he didn't want to have to defend the majority's clear political agenda. And this is NOT to say that there isn't often a clear political agenda in other decisions. My point is simply that Scalia is being a major hypocrite here.
@@zolluuu okay why was it rightfully criticized?
zolluuu They Decided 7-2 that Florida went against the Constitution but decided should the vote 🗳 count end in certain counties? Yes it was time to 🛑 stop. The Gore team admitted years later they should ask for the Whole state to be counted
zolluuu He was part of the same party that told Democrats to “get over it” the minute Donald Trump was elected and yet tore their hair out, rent their garments, and gnashed their teeth for the entire eight years Obama was in office. This was par for the course.
Charlie Rose is one of the world's worst interviewers ever. He constantly interrupts the person he's speaking with, which drives me crazy!
no, but I was in a little known program there, w/only 13 students, where we & our professors for 3 years, had to agree: support communism, pledge support of 110% marginal tax rate on more than $75k/yr & for the first $75k, 90%, agree to defend either Clinton, WHEN indicted on any felony & FALN, decry the fall of the USSR, pledge allegiance to Putin, & agree to worship to Stalin.
Bush v. Gore didn't decide a presidential election 1:20 .........the New York Times and other newspapers recounted the votes post-election and found that Gore still would have lost Florida if the recount that the Supreme Court stopped had gone forward. "Examining the Vote, the Overview: Study of Disputed Florida Ballots Finds Justices Did Not Cast the Deciding Vote," New York Times, 11/12/2001
After trying to let my sickening cancer grandparents not get healthcare insurance because of pre existing conditions die ..What else does he believe that healthcare is a privilege.. A conservative on the people's life... what a Christian God who loves life before you are born and after been born .You are on your own !!
DON'T BE FOOL THIS GUY IS A CORPRATE LAWYER
Did he ever work in the private sector? I don’t know that he actually practiced
John Roberts legislating from the bench. Hoping to be beloved by the liberal media. Spineless!
Lol he was upholding legislation not writing it. Republicans were (and still are!) trying to get their activist judges to over turn duly passed legislation because they failed in congress because their ideas are so unpopular. That’s legislating from the bench!
Gore v. Bush was the beginning of the end for this Republic
When elites meet, observe the result
He was murdered for sure
The conservative judges are always the most intellectual and most principled
According to you
What a TERRIBLE interview
The jittery bird metrically detect because wood previously appreciate but a accessible literature. legal, cultured ground
I think he should conduct his conversations more like someone with great honor, not like a guy you meet at a bar. He seems a little to greasy for my likes.
You're racist. You just compared Scalia to a mafia goomba.
The bush vs gore decision by Justice Scalia and the rest of the conservative wing on the high court was strictly political and personal preference instead of which candidate won over a large portion of the American people. Being effective,cogent,substancisive and good or excellent manager,communicator and leader Vice President Gore had Governor bush and repeatability and coolness. He also had bush beat.
It was a 7-2 ruling with liberal justices also ruling with Scalia. So... what now?
@@deanwhaley1466 i still dont agree with the ruling!
@@kevinscholaronehill5734 well, the judicial courts are outside the reach of politics so I don't see why you would be. It's a fair and just assessment.
What made bush a more diverse and better candidate or president then gore?
@@kevinscholaronehill5734 who cares? That has little to do with legality and more to do with emotive sophistry
antonin scalia. contextualist, until it a case goes against his corporate buddies and his religious beliefs. but other than that, yeah he's consistent. lol. this hypocrite and throw in america's side won't be missed, trust me.
Your comment is both fact free and stupid.
Having fun with Gorsuch and Kavanaugh? Hahahahahaha
LOLOLOL what times we have here.
GREASY PIG..I'll bet it's toasty down there.
What a candid and lighthearted interview, RIP Scalia and thank you for your dedication to upholding our democratic principles
Lighthearted? What nonsense.
Why on earth does this video have “context”. Thanks UA-cam.