What works in favour of Orlinski is his youth and innocence. He has this natural and pure boyish attitude, that is so charming. Stutzmann on the other hand is the real 'male' among rhese three - excuse me please.:) But there's more strength, solidity and dark gloom to her voice than to the two mens' voices ... and I love this brilliant artistic play of crossing the lines...
I love each of them! Their interpretations are a little different, because they have personalities and voices different, but I have been very interested, and moved! Thank you very much to all them!
What a wonderful collection of voices. I hadn't previously heard, Philippe Jaroussky...But I will look forward to hearing much more of this Beautiful Voice 🥰🥰🥰🎼
Дуже красиве і насичене барвами контральто Nathalie Stutzmann. Aле І Philipp Jarossky i Józef Orliński теж чудово співають І техніка у них прекрасна. ❤❤❤
Philippe Jaroussky nunca decepciona, siempre tiene un desempeño admirable, pero definitivamente Nathalie Stutzmann hace gala de su versátil y extraordinaria voz. Mi querido Jakub evidencia su potencial, pero todavía le falta para el virtuosismo requerido en esta interpretación
Since I listened to JJO for the first time, I have been so impressed with his way of singing, natural, straightforward, clear... Pure artistry. And...he retained his masculine colour voice. Jaroussky sounds like a female... Despite his fantastic artistry, I much prefer Orlinski. So my vote is: Orlinski, Stutzmann, Jaroussky.
Трудный выбор!Выделяю их всех среди исполнителей барочной музыки!Больше всего понравился Орлински, чисто свежо и трогает! Голос Филлипа звучит в этой арии несколько искусственно и напряжённо. Штуцман великолепна, но на мой взгляд местами сильно занижает тональность!
Je ne saurais attribuer ma préférence à l'un ou à l'autre. Stutzmann propose une version certes plus lente mais un peu plus riche notamment en roulant les "r". Orlinski est toujours aussi clair avec une technique maîtrisée et sans bavure. Jaroussky d'ordinaire je ne le trouve pas intéressant mais là il est agréable à écouter. Mais encore un fois pour plus d'objectivité, il faudrait en savoir plus, au regard de leur carrière, du déploiement de leur voix, sur le moment ou ont été prit ces enregistrements.
Bu parçada Nathalie Stutzmann harikuladeydi! Ses çarpmaları diğer söyleyenlere göre çok doğal yapılmış, hiç zorlanmadan çıkıveriyor gibiydi... Kıyaslamak belki doğru değil ama kulağımıza sadece bu parçayı esas alarak daha iyi olan kişiyi söylüyoruz, bu yaptığımız söyleyen kişilerden çok biz dinleyiciler için faydalı oluyor
Philippe has excellent delivery, as has has Nathalie. First me, Philippe is too feminine sounding , Natalie has fine timbre, but the most rounded, richer timbre is Orlinski's. All have phenomenal elasticity & skill.
Between the battle of light and darkness of the Baroque,I find that Stutzmann as well as Joroussky lead in the darkest shadows and my darling Cecilia Bartoli is the brightest light.Not meaning that either light or darkness is better,just a contrast.
Please stop doing this. Your previous posts have been so lovingly put together for the betterment of the music. Let’s not become like the classical opera fans who enjoy nothing more than tearing down their favourite artists with posts like “who disappointed you most ?”
I am aware that it is impossible to appreciate differently different performances, when we like I have to strong preferences for one voice or another...
Déjà que j'ai du mal a me prêter a ce jeu du classement entre chanteurs, mais là c'est impossible vraiment... Qd bien même j'ai un faible pour la voix de Nathalie stutzmann et puis c'est dans son interprétation que j'ai découvert cet air, ce qui joue
Jakub Józef Orliński ❤
I am delighted with the timbre of J.J. Orlinski, beautifully
JJO is my favorite, but all are beautiful
JAKUB JÓZEF ORLIŃSKI !!!
Jakub Józef Orliński.
Jakub, jesteś cudowny. Dziękuję z całego serca. Niech Ci Bóg błogosławi jeszcze więcej obficie. ❤❤❤
JAKUB SUPREMO
What works in favour of Orlinski is his youth and innocence. He has this natural and pure boyish attitude, that is so charming.
Stutzmann on the other hand is the real 'male' among rhese three - excuse me please.:)
But there's more strength, solidity and dark gloom to her voice than to the two mens' voices ... and I love this brilliant artistic play of crossing the lines...
Jakub 💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖
I love each of them! Their interpretations are a little different, because they have personalities and voices different, but I have been very interested, and moved! Thank you very much to all them!
Jakub Józef Orliński
Jakub Jozéf Orliński ! El mejor !
Jakub, sin duda alguna ♥
Jakubie jesteś boski, podbijaj świat !!!
Orlinski
Stutzmann is .... amazing!!!! Orlinski is ... great!
Jaroussky is the best. N. Stutzmann is very interesting, with her dark and velvety voice ...
Супер! Молодец Якоб!
Jaroussky’s language as emotional expression is the clearest. I like his sound best.
All are great, but Jaroussky fits me the best
Jakub!!
What a wonderful collection of voices. I hadn't previously heard, Philippe Jaroussky...But I will look forward to hearing much more of this Beautiful Voice 🥰🥰🥰🎼
This is a triumphant trilogy. They were born with an extraordinary gift! The music is so stirring
Thank you so much for posting.
Nathalie Stutzmann c'est quand même quelque chose !! No 1.
All are great, but I prefere Jaroussky.His voice is so clear, balanced and just beautiful
Дуже красиве і насичене барвами контральто Nathalie Stutzmann. Aле І Philipp Jarossky i Józef Orliński теж чудово співають І техніка у них прекрасна. ❤❤❤
Philippe and Nathalie
Philippe Jaroussky nunca decepciona, siempre tiene un desempeño admirable, pero definitivamente Nathalie Stutzmann hace gala de su versátil y extraordinaria voz. Mi querido Jakub evidencia su potencial, pero todavía le falta para el virtuosismo requerido en esta interpretación
Спасибо всем троим ! Великолепно!
Since I listened to JJO for the first time, I have been so impressed with his way of singing, natural, straightforward, clear... Pure artistry. And...he retained his masculine colour voice. Jaroussky sounds like a female... Despite his fantastic artistry, I much prefer Orlinski. So my vote is: Orlinski, Stutzmann, Jaroussky.
En fait, je vote comme vous!😊
Natalie Stutzmann posiada przepiękne kontralto. Dziękuję bardzo. Dankeschön. Vielen, vielen Dank.
Jakub
JJ Orliński ❤
jakub jozef definitely
JJO, beyond any competition ❤
Jarossky’s interpretation is always unique and his voice is brilliant...
Orlisky
all three soloists ❤
Both men appear rushed. Nathalie's voice is golden. ❤
Nathalie Stutzmann
Nathalie Stuzmann definitely!
La voz de Stutzmann es increíble, densa y enérgica, con unos graves redondos que los contratenores rara vez alcanzan. Después Orlinsky.
!Estoy de acuerdo!
Nathalie Stutzmann est inégalable, ici et toujours. Sans oublier, dans le passé récent, la merveilleuse Marilyn Horne!
Трудный выбор!Выделяю их всех среди исполнителей барочной музыки!Больше всего понравился Орлински, чисто свежо и трогает!
Голос Филлипа звучит в этой арии несколько искусственно и напряжённо.
Штуцман великолепна, но на мой взгляд местами сильно занижает тональность!
Jakub józef is doing better
Fantastic performances, all!
JJO!
All three are supreme though....incredibly talented and extremely rare.
Je ne saurais attribuer ma préférence à l'un ou à l'autre. Stutzmann propose une version certes plus lente mais un peu plus riche notamment en roulant les "r". Orlinski est toujours aussi clair avec une technique maîtrisée et sans bavure. Jaroussky d'ordinaire je ne le trouve pas intéressant mais là il est agréable à écouter. Mais encore un fois pour plus d'objectivité, il faudrait en savoir plus, au regard de leur carrière, du déploiement de leur voix, sur le moment ou ont été prit ces enregistrements.
JJO for sure, and he is totally cute too!😀😀💗
Nathalie is my favorite
Orliński👍👍👍
Nathalie !She is magnificent !😊
Orlinski même si la voix de jarouski est d'une pureté cristalline . Je préfère la voix d'Eva Zaicik à celle de Nathalie Stutzmann
Précisément, la "pureté cristalline", ce n'est pas ce qu'on attend dans un air de fureur. il faut de la noirceur, des emportements, des contrastes.
Orlinsky is my favorite. But Stutzmann is also very good. It is just my taste.
Je préfère toujours Jakub Orlinski même si j'apprécie aussi Nathalie Stutzman.
Jakub, Jakub ,Jakub
Me gusta Stutzman y Philippe
Los tres son maravillosos. Incomparables y únicos.
Cada un@ tiene su belleza vocal.
Definitely Nathalie!!
Орлинский wow👌🌅
Stutzmann y Orlinski
Pour l'incarnation, la maîtrise du souffle et la tessiture, la prestation de Nathalie Stutzmann est la plus belle et la plus crédible.
Nathalie is the strongest with the most variation in dynamics and voice colour. I like all three.
Stutzmann sin duda, pero Orlinski tb me gusta.
Each its own accomplishment....to my ear there is more power and resonance in Stutzmann offering.
Nathalie 😻🌹
Bu parçada Nathalie Stutzmann harikuladeydi! Ses çarpmaları diğer söyleyenlere göre çok doğal yapılmış, hiç zorlanmadan çıkıveriyor gibiydi... Kıyaslamak belki doğru değil ama kulağımıza sadece bu parçayı esas alarak daha iyi olan kişiyi söylüyoruz, bu yaptığımız söyleyen kişilerden çok biz dinleyiciler için faydalı oluyor
Jaroussky all the way
Nathalie Stutzmann without a doubt.
Stutzmann's voice is thrilling.
Jakub Józef Orliński tem um "ar" mais contemporâneo na forma de catar, o que é lindo.
Je préfère Jakub Orlinski.
Nathalie Stutzmann, JJOrliński, Ph. Jaroussky
JJO!
Stutzmann all the way !
Stutzmann!! It's obvious
Jakub Orlinsky
Natalie muy buena interpretación 💗✌
it is Stutzman for me. they're all 10 of 10 but i gave her a 10+ a few extra digits for supra-perfection! yes, she's the winner here overall! : )
Jaroussky
Jackub, это лучшее исполнение, этой композиции.
Nathalie !!!!
Philippe has excellent delivery, as has has Nathalie. First me, Philippe is too feminine sounding , Natalie has fine timbre, but the most rounded, richer timbre is Orlinski's. All have phenomenal elasticity & skill.
Os três são bons.., mas ela me cativa muito !!!
Nathalie Stuzmman 100%
Жарусски в образе! Интересно слушать.Интонация,техника,темп на высоте.
Stutzmann Stutzmann il resto no! Vera voce di contralto
I would like to hear this aria sang by Franco Fagioli
Nice sound as always from Orlinski, but he is not furious (furibondo) at all. So I vote for Jaroussky and Stutzmann which I like both.
Jakub is the best
Orlinski le meilleur
Orlinski!
Between the battle of light and darkness of the Baroque,I find that Stutzmann as well as Joroussky lead in the darkest shadows and my darling Cecilia Bartoli is the brightest light.Not meaning that either light or darkness is better,just a contrast.
Please stop doing this. Your previous posts have been so lovingly put together for the betterment of the music. Let’s not become like the classical opera fans who enjoy nothing more than tearing down their favourite artists with posts like “who disappointed you most ?”
You are so right but which other way would you be able to hear them sing the same aria , one after the other?
🥰🥰🥰
Jaroussky es extraordinario en todos los sentidos, Stutzmann excelente, al joven polaco le falta más trabajo en las agilidades y mayor expresividad.
I am aware that it is impossible to appreciate differently different performances, when we like I have to strong preferences for one voice or another...
Orlinsky
Philippe & Natalie!!!
Christopher Lowrey
Christopher Lowrey
J.J.O. COSMIC!
Déjà que j'ai du mal a me prêter a ce jeu du classement entre chanteurs, mais là c'est impossible vraiment... Qd bien même j'ai un faible pour la voix de Nathalie stutzmann et puis c'est dans son interprétation que j'ai découvert cet air, ce qui joue
Idem!!
orlinski