I like the calmness and educational level of the interviewed and the interviewer. Ms Feldman is a clear, honest and upright intellectual. I adore her resilience for what she is exposed to in today's fakely pro-Semitic and, for me, discursively dishonest and poisoned Germany.
I think you seem to forget that 6 million of our family members were sent to the gas chambers & 3000 years of Jew hatred while there was no Israel to blame it on 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
7:14 'They can get away with bullying as long as they use these rhetorical tools'. This is a very important point, and also explains in part why, contrary to the expectations of people who think this is about some sincere feelings of guilt, German Zionists often get NASTIER when they find out the person disagreeing with them is Jewish.
I'm not surprised he took it down. The first part was and still is such an important contribution to our domestic discourse, that's usually informed by people who are any combination of inept, evil and/or mentally unwell. She delivers her analysis and her invaluable insights with such relentless clarity, which undoubtedly had germany's media talking heads in fetal position, sobbing, because they just wouldn't be equipped to experience expertly presented facts, giving these losers their first brush with reality. the second eposode sucked, unfortunetly, why I'm welcomming the decision to take it down
Very interesting to hear, I was very curious to understand the mentality and thought process behind what is happening in Germany, the images of Police violence are absolutely shocking. Waiting for part 2
We germans can learn so much from her. Hopefully we will see more of Deborah soon!! I would love to read another book perhaps with some recipes of her grandmother! We germans know very little about jewish culture and tradition. All her books are wonderful. Really enjoyed reading. Deborah is brilliant ❤❤
total goosebumps ! I saw Deborah on a snippet of a German TV show, she was hardly understood by the other guests, and treated badly by the comments. I have to give her credit, she has a point here, that worries me deeply.
I do not really understand her either. To call a country "antisemitic" because the chancellor of the country used the word "mauscheln" is absurd. Being a German, I would have guessed that "mauscheln" stems from the German word "Maus" for "Mouse" (the animal), and not that it is connected to Moses. Many Germans critcize Israel because of the continuous war-mongering the leaders of the country show. This is the problem. This country has been in an almost constant state of war since its existence in modern times. And it was no different in ancient times, as reading the Old Testament shows. And always the leaders of Israel say it's the other ones who are doing wrong, the others were so "antisemitic", but it is never the Israeli government who is doing anything wrong. Almost impossible to believe that. Even for Germans.
My dad is kinda like that Arab guy who asked you about your passport. I get frustrated when he fails to distinguish Jews from Israelis. At one time, I accidentally exaggerated when I, frustrated, said "There are no Jews in Israel!" 😅 When we say "Scarlett Johansson is Danish", there's nobody who gets confused about where she lives, whether she's American, whether she's favours the Danish Social Democrats, the Red-Greens, Conservatives, or anyone else. Likewise, when we say "this person is Jewish", it's fundamentally unfair to suppose they would or should live in the Middle East or support any political factions in a foreign country. (I just read that Johansson actually has Danish citizenship but I've never heard of her ever living here, so I'm not sure it's correct, but still nobody goes "oh yea she's that Danish actress.")
Where is part two? Deborah is a brilliant anti zionist voice and a great speaker. ❤ Thank you for your courage. I would also love to hear more of Dr. Shir Hever or Daniel Barenboim and palestinians activists like Hebh Jamal.
I have just started the vid and I just wanna say for future eps: your casual setup (sitting on the couch having a chat) clashes a lot of with your partly formal outfit and results in a wrinkly and creased look of your clothes and uncomfortable-looking seating position and an overall unrelaxed vibe.
Interesting observation, I often notice uncomfortable awkward seating in podcast interviews and this is yet another version. At least the camera is not switching back and forth between faces or panning left and right continuously
Welcome to the club ! The situation is almost the same in France, where the extreme right took part in a "national demonstration""against "antisemitism"" in Paris last november...😢
Every time I listen to this person I kinda want to read up on everything mentioned. Sadly it's not time for me to become a literate person. Now, as put in a few of this video's last comments: "Where's the second part?" I think it's a rarely expressed and nouanced opinion she has, if I understand it correctly(probably I don't). What I agree upon in feeling at least is : not just in Germany , there's way more happening to delay resolution of a conflict around Israel's border and fascists in other countries politics are trying to only release aid whenever it can happen as demonstration of the "benefit" of fascist strategies. I am not going to say the majority of german politics is actively fascist , it is just very indifferent to all the contributions certain groups made to the creation of artificial perpetual aggression in the middle east or the soviet union through perpetraitors in the Kaiserzeit, Weimarer Republik and the third Reich. It's not as if we live in a warzone in Germany, we havethe time to reflect on the difference between countries in the middle east that turned out stable and those lied to by corrupt groups abroad or their political elite themselves working out autoritarian, feudal or even fascist dynamics. Those conflicts are what fascists around the world bank on - in my believe. Both sides - the supposed west and especially the most stable successors to ottoman power- should really use their ressources, to get civillians out of warzones and into systems able to prosper. Instead we go from, first, forgetting about how much effort was made, to convince civilians and reservists to become paramilitary or terrorists to reconquer Transjordania's share of the Ottoman Empire in order to restore it, to ,second, legitimizing aspirations for two states Israel-Gaza, to ,third, trying to establish fascist influence from abroad in Israel and Gaza , to , fourth, letting them " figure it out themselves" and back to forgetting we had in the first possible instance or even earlier fascist tendencies or governments implementing and funding the Dynamic we see today. Germany, I think , takes part in that , since "support for Israel" on one side doesn't turn into proactive refugee-policy for Gaza and the Westbank and in addition bringing other more stable countries to the discussion, wich could take on the safety infrastructure to deal with terrorism. It doesn't seem as if we'd let something like that happen easily and rarher frame that as well as ,allegedly subconsciously , Israel itself as a "Collonialism"(which it's certainly not being a crumb considering the former Ottoman expansion, or the fact that they never had.. back breaking forced labour camps to extract ressources for profit), all in one go.. Turkey, Syria and or Iran probably are a bad idea considering this task, altough that depends on which social peer group is mainly engaged. Egypt could maybe, Jordania does that probably, Israel does probably help civilians there already to get out of there or at least unmask and interupt their , now Hamas, government actions every now and then. That's just not how supposed german moderates want it, which is a theme getting worse the rurther "right" the party/member gets, they insist Palestine is a natural idea for a state until they see the violence escalation and then diffarmation against Muslims and Immigrants happens and agreement to support(actually we agree to not condemn!) for Israel's extremly delayed AND extremly exagerated military action.. Why the exageration happens I don't know, It could be relatively slowly over growing fascist ideology in Israel , or revenge or, as stated by Israel mostly: calculating the chance of how long Israel's military could wage war before the world forgets the rational reason again, which is to weaken Hamas amd destroy their military's infrastructure.. probably all three reasons , opinions amd staff are engaged, naturally, against each other and against Hamas and, sadly, the civilians in Gaza. Even worse is that this condition isn't unique and it maybe even is on the brighter side of the world's governments compositions.
To be fair though, Mrs Feldman has clashed with the whole German Jewish community, she even lost a court battle on defamation based on Feldman's claims that her detractors weren't actually Jews. They were, she lost that fight. She is seen as kind of a fringe voice, especially because of her tendency to declare other Jews as non-Jews.
Amazing interview!!! And thanks for taking your time to translate German terms and clarify who the politicians you discuss are, because someone living in another country may not know about. I was not aware of many of the things discussed in this interview I learned a lot! I enjoyed very much Deborah Feldman's viees and explanations or the situation and enjoyed very much the questions and clarifications made by the interviewer. Congratulations to you both looking forward to more!
I'm 10 minutes in to this podcast, listening to a convoluted long-winded critique of Germany's alliance with Israel, despite the latter having become radicalized in Feldman's opinion. But how and why is Israel any more extremist now than say ten years ago? The interviewer needs to be more forceful in interrupting Feldman's ramblings and prompt her to get to the point. I'm tuning out...
Herr Gluck, I have spoken with a number of Ger friends over the last 10 months and most are in denial of Germany's wierd relationship with Israel and all things Israeli and jewish.
It takes time to sniff out the leftists, she's given some clues, but people spew nonsense about Israel being Messianic fundamentalist or other gibberish when it's surrounded by fundamentalist Messianic Islamic Nations that vomit hate daily, denying that reality while blaming Israel is an often used tactic of the obtuse left
@@sakha2349 what’s weird about Germanys relationship with Israel? She’s an ally, as she should be and as every western nation with western values should be…
I kind of got the feeling, that you already had the story you wanted to tell and now you had to make things fit into that story, instead of first looking at the situation and then trying to come up with answers. That approach seems to deliver quite shallow insights.
Come on, Deborah Feldman, you turn this issue more and more into a narcistic show: NO , you are not the most hated jew in Germany - you are one among many. Just many people disagree with what you are saying and most likely the way you say it. That's it. To phantazise about being most hated is just a symptom of your narcism...sorry but this is really not helping anyone.
It's not about narcissism, but idpol. As to her intention behind that, there's no way of knowing if her adopting the colloquial misappropriation of idpol is a genuine mistake or not, due to how widespread of a phenomenon it is. Also, allistic people who aren't trained in informal logic tend to struggle differentiating correlation from causation.
I listened to a podcast yesterday and one of the reveals was that the US had given nuclear fission material to both Israel and Iran before the shah....
Ok some intersting things , but having read a recent article by jackson about visiting mansours home town , and his comments on the Resistance op in October, plus his MENTION of ukraine , .... my giving leeway to middle class liberal spiel .ended at 44minutes. Jacksons language vis a vis Palestinians is ...very ... distant .
Was Adenauer wrong? As Wolfgang Schäuble said: "At no point in time has Germany been fully sovereign after May 8, 1945"....Who shall we thank for that ?
As a German I was not aware that the word "mauscheln" is in some way disrespectful, I just thought it was colloquial anjd stands for achieving something in a way that is a little but not severely irregular. In English it would translate to: to fiddle or to wheel and deal. I don't think that just because a term is of Yiddish heritage makes it problematic.
My understanding is that it's not a Yiddish word, but a German word that references Jews as a description of hustling or scheming, which is quite different. It's more like saying "don't Jew me down" in American English (as in, "don't haggle with or be cheap with me") than using a Yiddish word like putz or chutzpah, isn't it? It's based on the Yiddish name for Moses, but it's not a Yiddish word, according to what I can find. It's possible some Yiddish speakers have used it but from what I'm finding it's literally just a way for German speakers to implicate Jewish people in underhanded behaviour.
@@tomasabadi5374 No. The N-Word attributes to a black person. "Mauscheln" doesn't attribute to anyone, and it used for anyone. There is no discrimination in the word's meaning. So your comparison is a little too simple and doesn't fit.
@@kochendorfer6433 Nothing like a german with a literal Soros (101 Antisemitic trope) playlist on his youtube teaching me about antisemitism and racism. One can use the N-word to refer to anyone as well, people choose not to. The origin of both words lie in racism and derogatory, offensive slurs. Then Germans decided to keep using these racist antisemtic words for themselves. Congrats! Does not mean that the words origin does not come from antisemitism. Let me quickly google that for you de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mauscheln_(Verb)#:~:text=Das%20Verb%20mauscheln%20und%20das,also%20ein%20%E2%80%9Eabgekartetes%20Spiel%E2%80%9C
I don't understand her. Leaves her family - ok. The US is big but she chooses to go to Germany. Then there are over 200 countries, she chooses as a Jewish woman Germany. Now complains about antisemitism in Germany. Woman - take some accountability.
im the son of a german catholic father and a jewish israeli american mother ive lived in israel as well as stateside and krautland i hate her ..her career here in germany hs based on being a caeer jew in germany she only sees antisemetism on the right in germany ..she ignores islamist and leftist antisemetism ...the way it works in germany is if you are an israeli jew or non israeli jew that critises israel and islamaphobia the germans come and orgasm from it assuades their holocaust complex...she is disgustig einfach ekelhaft ...
Sorry, but declaring a word - in this case "mauscheln" to be somehow antisemitic is total bullshit and just shows that she doesn't understand some basics of communication. It's all about intention - and I guarantee that at least 95% of all germans don't know where "mauscheln" comes from. So only because you feel offended doesn't mean that someone meant to offend you - most of the time such an offend is more about your own hypocrisy than anything else. Another thing is the interpretation of the "Staatsräson" - it's a very abstract thing and I would assume that you did it mostly wrong. There's a bright criticism of Netanjahu in germany but at the same time there's some kind of responsibility to the existence of the israelian state. Both things need to be seen separately. In the end it was the hamas who started this war. And it was Oct7 that brought up the wording of the Staatsräson not the right turn of the knesset. Anyway the actions Netanyahu takes don't lead to any solution. I don't see anyone in germany who would endorse what's happening in Gaza. But the enemy is hamas - as long as they don't surrender and let their own people suffer, their people will suffer ...
Staatsräson comes from a merkel speech long before october 7th. Germany is helping this goverment fight this specific war with submarines and other weapons. There is no apstract support for some abstract concept of some idealised isreal. its always specific goverments doing specific things and currently that is commiting a lot of war crimes ostensibly to free the hostages. But big chuck of fromer hostages and hostages families actually don't want that war and want a negoiated deal, which israeli goverment has refused multiple times. You cant help israel but not help netanyahu as long as he is the leader. Hamas is horrible but israel has presented no strategy of how do deradicalise gazans, other than destruction and bloodshed which will just create codnditions for new hamas to rise even if you destroy the old one. If you want to "denazify" gaza you need also the marshial plan not only bombs. I.e. economic development investment, as well as democracy. Israel has shown no willingness for such a help. So its just war crimes and human suffering on all sides with no ling term plan so that bibi can stay in power cause as long as there is war he hopes to be secure in his position. And Germany suppotts this wuth money and weap9ms and diplomatic support at icj etc.
It is typical and it is very old, probably when the first real Hapsburg generation built the early forms of their empire, after the Reconquista, or in parallel. This is the commissioner. You create a position, this is a constructivistic task, and you put your friend on that seat, and he becomes the hub for everything and anything , and everything and everyone dealing with this item has to walk through this hub or else it is not legit.
If somebody using the word GLOBALISTS (Maaßen) is an Antisemit, than I am. And; by the the way: according to Annetta Kahane from the Antonio-Amadeo-Stiftung I also was an Antisemit when I questioned the Covid-Politics because beeing "Antiscience" means to be antisemitic. And issuing conspiricy-theories made me an antisemit because the first conspiracy-theory was targeted towards Jews. And even the Holocaust survivour Vera Sharav was called an Antisemite whne she called out the so called VACCINE connecting it to the Nuernberg Trails. They played with the phantay of sending the unvaccinated to Madagasgar and called unvaccinated People SOZIALSCHÄDLINGE and spoke of the TYRANY OF THE UNVACCINATED. Thes excluded us form public life. Hans Georg Maaßen was a critic of these completely undemocratic and fascist politics. And weather the scenes in Chemnitz were HETZJAGDEN? They were ugly, but not Hetzjagden.
Hostility and objection to the war crimes committed by the apartheid regime of the Israeli military occupation, which claimed the lives of more than 40,000 people in Palestine, is a humanitarian and moral duty imposed on us by our commitment to prevent the repetition of what happened to the Jews in advance. Never again for all of humanity
I read Feldman's book "Judenfetisch" and watched her movie with interest. However, her own plight in the Williamsburg orthodox community makes her blot out the extremism epedemic of the islamic world. - Her critique of German "Staatsräson" towards Israel is reasonable, however not every German who supports Zionism does so out of a cynical "Staatsräson". Or would you level the same critique at someone like, say, Douglas Murray, who strongly supports Zionism and the war on Hamas and Hisbollah? Critique of Israel and the Netanyahu government should not be leveled at fighting Hamas but at the fact that they don't have a plan for the future of Gaza and the West bank.
I am sure at least 90% of all Germans aren't aware of the jiddish origine of that expression 'mauscheln' ( just like dozens other orirginal jiddish words)
@@stefankotz2242 the roots of that expression are (probably) going back to 17 18th century 'Rotwelsch ' ( a kind of jiddish 'Cockney') ....and as I already mentioned, nearly nobody nowaday is aware about it.....therefore it is not used in an anti semi tic ( out of censor reasons I have to write it this way) context
@derKosmoprolet369 just google the word mauschln and read the wikipedia article. Why are you making things up. Rotwelsch has partly jewish roots but was not a language primarly spooken primarly by jews, but rather Cricus folks, beggers, criminals and other traveling and marginalised people of various ethnicities in the german speaking world. But also "mauschln" doesnt come from rotwelsh either, so that's super irrelevant. Just google before you comment, its not difficult.
@@derKosmoprolet369btw. I feel you about the censors. I thinknyiyr stuff gets blocked automaticaly on youtube if you coomment too ofte. I think writing antisemitism is fine though
@@stefankotz2242 Actually I googled it before I wrote my last comment ( Et ymologists believing that the term is going back at 16./17th Cent spoken jiddish -- that's why I wrote 'probably ') ......and once I've seen a docu about the history of jews in Germany, in which was claimed Rotwelsch was based on jiddish ( probably some non-jewish 'Outlaws ' adopted it later on [?]) I'm afraid it's impossible to understand the parameters of the YT censor algo ( just too arbitrary)
She’s a bully. You only have to take a look at her social media accounts and how she is behaving there towards people who may have a different position than her.
I have studied linguistics, I have read Victor Klemperer's LTI, but I have never heard that the word mauscheln has any relation to antisemitism. I assume that 99 per cent of Germans don't know anything about the origin of it, either. Getting from "mauscheln" to "Moishe" and vice versa is pretty impossible for any German. It is weak proof that Germans are antisemitic, let alone Kanzler Scholz, who might be dull and boring, but certainly not antisemitic. Sorry, this is pretty far fetched. You are giving Germans too much credit for their linguistic competence. Being raised speaking Yiddish, you certainly are juggling those nuances far better than us. Love the dog, btw
That is the accepted etymology just start with german wikipedia on the word and you see the relevant sources for this history. I am not sure studying ligustics means you know the etimolgy of every word in the German language, so that's a weird thing to bring up. I don't think that scholz is an antisemite but I do think its legitimate to point out if he is using vocabulary with antisemitic history. Shouldn't really happen with professional speech writers and all. This is is not casual talking.
At least you're the greatest who's got all the answers. That's the most important thing. You shouldn't listen to other views. Just stay inside your echo chamber and turn the volume up
I like the calmness and educational level of the interviewed and the interviewer. Ms Feldman is a clear, honest and upright intellectual. I adore her resilience for what she is exposed to in today's fakely pro-Semitic and, for me, discursively dishonest and poisoned Germany.
I really like the interviewer. He is well informed and deeply engaged! Keep up the good work!
Love & Respect to Deborah for her decency and bravery.
As a Jew ….. blame Israel for everything….
I think you seem to forget that 6 million of our family members were sent to the gas chambers & 3000 years of Jew hatred while there was no Israel to blame it on 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
That is how the Portuguese jews feel as well! Zionism has destroyed the Jewish identity!
As a Jew... blame Jews for everything...
I think German fascism (pre- and post-1945) has some blame to bear 😅
7:14 'They can get away with bullying as long as they use these rhetorical tools'. This is a very important point, and also explains in part why, contrary to the expectations of people who think this is about some sincere feelings of guilt, German Zionists often get NASTIER when they find out the person disagreeing with them is Jewish.
so on point! one of the best conversations on the subject! Very compelling interview. Keep up the good work
what happened to part 2?
I'm not surprised he took it down. The first part was and still is such an important contribution to our domestic discourse, that's usually informed by people who are any combination of inept, evil and/or mentally unwell. She delivers her analysis and her invaluable insights with such relentless clarity, which undoubtedly had germany's media talking heads in fetal position, sobbing, because they just wouldn't be equipped to experience expertly presented facts, giving these losers their first brush with reality.
the second eposode sucked, unfortunetly, why I'm welcomming the decision to take it down
@@janreal84 why did it suck?
It was released just today
Congratulations to your first podcast release!
Great respect to Deborah for her courage....
Very interesting to hear, I was very curious to understand the mentality and thought process behind what is happening in Germany, the images of Police violence are absolutely shocking. Waiting for part 2
We germans can learn so much from her. Hopefully we will see more of Deborah soon!! I would love to read another book perhaps with some recipes of her grandmother! We germans know very little about jewish culture and tradition. All her books are wonderful. Really enjoyed reading. Deborah is brilliant ❤❤
Where is the second Part?
It's out now
total goosebumps !
I saw Deborah on a snippet of a German TV show, she was hardly understood by the other guests, and treated badly by the comments.
I have to give her credit, she has a point here, that worries me deeply.
I'm 40 minutes in and still am not getting her point, but I'm absorbing that she's a leftist with gripes.
I do not really understand her either. To call a country "antisemitic" because the chancellor of the country used the word "mauscheln" is absurd. Being a German, I would have guessed that "mauscheln" stems from the German word "Maus" for "Mouse" (the animal), and not that it is connected to Moses.
Many Germans critcize Israel because of the continuous war-mongering the leaders of the country show. This is the problem. This country has been in an almost constant state of war since its existence in modern times. And it was no different in ancient times, as reading the Old Testament shows. And always the leaders of Israel say it's the other ones who are doing wrong, the others were so "antisemitic", but it is never the Israeli government who is doing anything wrong. Almost impossible to believe that. Even for Germans.
My dad is kinda like that Arab guy who asked you about your passport. I get frustrated when he fails to distinguish Jews from Israelis. At one time, I accidentally exaggerated when I, frustrated, said "There are no Jews in Israel!" 😅
When we say "Scarlett Johansson is Danish", there's nobody who gets confused about where she lives, whether she's American, whether she's favours the Danish Social Democrats, the Red-Greens, Conservatives, or anyone else.
Likewise, when we say "this person is Jewish", it's fundamentally unfair to suppose they would or should live in the Middle East or support any political factions in a foreign country.
(I just read that Johansson actually has Danish citizenship but I've never heard of her ever living here, so I'm not sure it's correct, but still nobody goes "oh yea she's that Danish actress.")
Very clearly presented and informative. Thanks!
Where is part two? Deborah is a brilliant anti zionist voice and a great speaker. ❤ Thank you for your courage. I would also love to hear more of Dr. Shir Hever or Daniel Barenboim and palestinians activists like Hebh Jamal.
I have just started the vid and I just wanna say for future eps: your casual setup (sitting on the couch having a chat) clashes a lot of with your partly formal outfit and results in a wrinkly and creased look of your clothes and uncomfortable-looking seating position and an overall unrelaxed vibe.
Interesting observation, I often notice uncomfortable awkward seating in podcast interviews and this is yet another version. At least the camera is not switching back and forth between faces or panning left and right continuously
Welcome to the club ! The situation is almost the same in France, where the extreme right took part in a "national demonstration""against "antisemitism"" in Paris last november...😢
The extreme left has tolerated Jews who renounce their Zionism and Judaism for decades, now they're just broadening their intolerance.
26:50 what antisemitic word did Scholz use? I cant understand what they are saying and google gives me zero results on this topic
Found it it's "mauscheln" or "Gemäuschel"
Is this available as a podcast?
Really interesting interview !! I'm super looking forward to next week and more guests. I really appreciated the candidness she displays
Very interesting and insightful. Thank you
Can someone point me to the "Pressefreiheit" speech of scholz I can't seem to find it anywhere
Every time I listen to this person I kinda want to read up on everything mentioned. Sadly it's not time for me to become a literate person.
Now, as put in a few of this video's last comments:
"Where's the second part?"
I think it's a rarely expressed and nouanced opinion she has, if I understand it correctly(probably I don't). What I agree upon in feeling at least is : not just in Germany , there's way more happening to delay resolution of a conflict around Israel's border and fascists in other countries politics are trying to only release aid whenever it can happen as demonstration of the "benefit" of fascist strategies. I am not going to say the majority of german politics is actively fascist , it is just very indifferent to all the contributions certain groups made to the creation of artificial perpetual aggression in the middle east or the soviet union through perpetraitors in the Kaiserzeit, Weimarer Republik and the third Reich. It's not as if we live in a warzone in Germany, we havethe time to reflect on the difference between countries in the middle east that turned out stable and those lied to by corrupt groups abroad or their political elite themselves working out autoritarian, feudal or even fascist dynamics. Those conflicts are what fascists around the world bank on - in my believe. Both sides - the supposed west and especially the most stable successors to ottoman power- should really use their ressources, to get civillians out of warzones and into systems able to prosper. Instead we go from, first, forgetting about how much effort was made, to convince civilians and reservists to become paramilitary or terrorists to reconquer Transjordania's share of the Ottoman Empire in order to restore it, to ,second, legitimizing aspirations for two states Israel-Gaza, to ,third, trying to establish fascist influence from abroad in Israel and Gaza , to , fourth, letting them " figure it out themselves" and back to forgetting we had in the first possible instance or even earlier fascist tendencies or governments implementing and funding the Dynamic we see today. Germany, I think , takes part in that , since "support for Israel" on one side doesn't turn into proactive refugee-policy for Gaza and the Westbank and in addition bringing other more stable countries to the discussion, wich could take on the safety infrastructure to deal with terrorism. It doesn't seem as if we'd let something like that happen easily and rarher frame that as well as ,allegedly subconsciously , Israel itself as a "Collonialism"(which it's certainly not being a crumb considering the former Ottoman expansion, or the fact that they never had.. back breaking forced labour camps to extract ressources for profit), all in one go..
Turkey, Syria and or Iran probably are a bad idea considering this task, altough that depends on which social peer group is mainly engaged. Egypt could maybe, Jordania does that probably, Israel does probably help civilians there already to get out of there or at least unmask and interupt their , now Hamas, government actions every now and then. That's just not how supposed german moderates want it, which is a theme getting worse the rurther "right" the party/member gets, they insist Palestine is a natural idea for a state until they see the violence escalation and then diffarmation against Muslims and Immigrants happens and agreement to support(actually we agree to not condemn!) for Israel's extremly delayed AND extremly exagerated military action..
Why the exageration happens I don't know, It could be relatively slowly over growing fascist ideology in Israel , or revenge or, as stated by Israel mostly: calculating the chance of how long Israel's military could wage war before the world forgets the rational reason again, which is to weaken Hamas amd destroy their military's infrastructure.. probably all three reasons , opinions amd staff are engaged, naturally, against each other and against Hamas and, sadly, the civilians in Gaza. Even worse is that this condition isn't unique and it maybe even is on the brighter side of the world's governments compositions.
What??? We need to wait one week? Great interview ❤🎉
To be fair though, Mrs Feldman has clashed with the whole German Jewish community, she even lost a court battle on defamation based on Feldman's claims that her detractors weren't actually Jews. They were, she lost that fight. She is seen as kind of a fringe voice, especially because of her tendency to declare other Jews as non-Jews.
Nothing surprises me anymore !
"stay mad" - yeah like we have another choice, living in Germany!
Amazing interview!!! And thanks for taking your time to translate German terms and clarify who the politicians you discuss are, because someone living in another country may not know about. I was not aware of many of the things discussed in this interview I learned a lot! I enjoyed very much Deborah Feldman's viees and explanations or the situation and enjoyed very much the questions and clarifications made by the interviewer. Congratulations to you both looking forward to more!
I'm 10 minutes in to this podcast, listening to a convoluted long-winded critique of Germany's alliance with Israel, despite the latter having become radicalized in Feldman's opinion. But how and why is Israel any more extremist now than say ten years ago? The interviewer needs to be more forceful in interrupting Feldman's ramblings and prompt her to get to the point. I'm tuning out...
this is a podcast and not necessarily an interview. You can pass.
Herr Gluck, I have spoken with a number of Ger friends over the last 10 months and most are in denial of Germany's wierd relationship with Israel and all things Israeli and jewish.
She's the classic self hating psycho Jew for the prog points and attention.
It takes time to sniff out the leftists, she's given some clues, but people spew nonsense about Israel being Messianic fundamentalist or other gibberish when it's surrounded by fundamentalist Messianic Islamic Nations that vomit hate daily, denying that reality while blaming Israel is an often used tactic of the obtuse left
@@sakha2349 what’s weird about Germanys relationship with Israel? She’s an ally, as she should be and as every western nation with western values should be…
I kind of got the feeling, that you already had the story you wanted to tell and now you had to make things fit into that story, instead of first looking at the situation and then trying to come up with answers. That approach seems to deliver quite shallow insights.
Comment for the algorithm.
Come on, Deborah Feldman, you turn this issue more and more into a narcistic show: NO , you are not the most hated jew in Germany - you are one among many. Just many people disagree with what you are saying and most likely the way you say it. That's it.
To phantazise about being most hated is just a symptom of your narcism...sorry but this is really not helping anyone.
No. Most people in the world agree with her.
Only white Western Europeans disagree with her because they think Palestinians are subhumans.
It's not about narcissism, but idpol. As to her intention behind that, there's no way of knowing if her adopting the colloquial misappropriation of idpol is a genuine mistake or not, due to how widespread of a phenomenon it is. Also, allistic people who aren't trained in informal logic tend to struggle differentiating correlation from causation.
@@kathleenschubert1247 Germans shouldn't be allowed to comment in my opinion
It says a lot that this is the only thing you remembered or that matters to you after listening to an hour-long talk....
there are literally dozens of articles that support her claim. Stop using mental health terms to disqualify people.
Loved her honesty and journeying process ❤
thanks so much for this! wondering if you have any sources on the history of the founding of the zentralrat? working on a presentation at the moment
Searching up Konrad Adenauer Gründung des Zentralrats …
@@deborahfeldman7885 thank you :) and for all the important work you're doing
Adenauer´s Germany was the financier to Israel´s atomic bomb programm. (See: Gaby Weber)
I listened to a podcast yesterday and one of the reveals was that the US had given nuclear fission material to both Israel and Iran before the shah....
Interesting interview. Thank you for bold reflections. ❤
Ok some intersting things , but having read a recent article by jackson about visiting mansours home town , and his comments on the Resistance op in October, plus his MENTION of ukraine , .... my giving leeway to middle class liberal spiel .ended at 44minutes. Jacksons language vis a vis Palestinians is ...very ... distant .
Great interview, looking forward to Part 2
Illuminating conversation. Can’t wait for part 2.
Was hard to even find on youtube, James.
But tyvm for the ep.
love deborah !
Interesting. thanks!
we're twitter users, of course we're thumbs upping each other on UA-cam
Was Adenauer wrong?
As Wolfgang Schäuble said: "At no point in time has Germany been fully sovereign after May 8, 1945"....Who shall we thank for that ?
Good.
The Germans, they lost the war, stop whinning.
You have the same channel name as a very big anti- vaccination/right wimg channel. Is that intentional?
no
Alright, just wanted to make you aware :D
Their Ideologies are very similar.
@@einherjermarsjen531doesn't seem like that to me at all
This is such an excellent and revelatory interview. Hope for more from this channel!
Exceptional great interview. Congrats to both of you.
As a German I was not aware that the word "mauscheln" is in some way disrespectful, I just thought it was colloquial anjd stands for achieving something in a way that is a little but not severely irregular. In English it would translate to: to fiddle or to wheel and deal. I don't think that just because a term is of Yiddish heritage makes it problematic.
My understanding is that it's not a Yiddish word, but a German word that references Jews as a description of hustling or scheming, which is quite different. It's more like saying "don't Jew me down" in American English (as in, "don't haggle with or be cheap with me") than using a Yiddish word like putz or chutzpah, isn't it? It's based on the Yiddish name for Moses, but it's not a Yiddish word, according to what I can find.
It's possible some Yiddish speakers have used it but from what I'm finding it's literally just a way for German speakers to implicate Jewish people in underhanded behaviour.
It's like saying the N word may have a racist past, but I'm not using it in a racist way so it's ok!
@@tomasabadi5374 No. The N-Word attributes to a black person. "Mauscheln" doesn't attribute to anyone, and it used for anyone. There is no discrimination in the word's meaning. So your comparison is a little too simple and doesn't fit.
@@kochendorfer6433 Nothing like a german with a literal Soros (101 Antisemitic trope) playlist on his youtube teaching me about antisemitism and racism. One can use the N-word to refer to anyone as well, people choose not to. The origin of both words lie in racism and derogatory, offensive slurs. Then Germans decided to keep using these racist antisemtic words for themselves. Congrats! Does not mean that the words origin does not come from antisemitism. Let me quickly google that for you de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mauscheln_(Verb)#:~:text=Das%20Verb%20mauscheln%20und%20das,also%20ein%20%E2%80%9Eabgekartetes%20Spiel%E2%80%9C
I don't understand her. Leaves her family - ok. The US is big but she chooses to go to Germany. Then there are over 200 countries, she chooses as a Jewish woman Germany. Now complains about antisemitism in Germany.
Woman - take some accountability.
im the son of a german catholic father and a jewish israeli american mother ive lived in israel as well as stateside and krautland i hate her ..her career here in germany hs based on being a caeer jew in germany she only sees antisemetism on the right in germany ..she ignores islamist and leftist antisemetism ...the way it works in germany is if you are an israeli jew or non israeli jew that critises israel and islamaphobia the germans come and orgasm from it assuades their holocaust complex...she is disgustig einfach ekelhaft ...
Nothing Jewish about Beinart's Islamist funded "'Jewish' Currents". 😂😂😂😂
Sorry, but declaring a word - in this case "mauscheln" to be somehow antisemitic is total bullshit and just shows that she doesn't understand some basics of communication. It's all about intention - and I guarantee that at least 95% of all germans don't know where "mauscheln" comes from. So only because you feel offended doesn't mean that someone meant to offend you - most of the time such an offend is more about your own hypocrisy than anything else.
Another thing is the interpretation of the
"Staatsräson" - it's a very abstract thing and I would assume that you did it mostly wrong. There's a bright criticism of Netanjahu in germany but at the same time there's some kind of responsibility to the existence of the israelian state. Both things need to be seen separately. In the end it was the hamas who started this war. And it was Oct7 that brought up the wording of the Staatsräson not the right turn of the knesset. Anyway the actions Netanyahu takes don't lead to any solution. I don't see anyone in germany who would endorse what's happening in Gaza. But the enemy is hamas - as long as they don't surrender and let their own people suffer, their people will suffer ...
Staatsräson comes from a merkel speech long before october 7th. Germany is helping this goverment fight this specific war with submarines and other weapons. There is no apstract support for some abstract concept of some idealised isreal. its always specific goverments doing specific things and currently that is commiting a lot of war crimes ostensibly to free the hostages. But big chuck of fromer hostages and hostages families actually don't want that war and want a negoiated deal, which israeli goverment has refused multiple times. You cant help israel but not help netanyahu as long as he is the leader. Hamas is horrible but israel has presented no strategy of how do deradicalise gazans, other than destruction and bloodshed which will just create codnditions for new hamas to rise even if you destroy the old one. If you want to "denazify" gaza you need also the marshial plan not only bombs. I.e. economic development investment, as well as democracy. Israel has shown no willingness for such a help. So its just war crimes and human suffering on all sides with no ling term plan so that bibi can stay in power cause as long as there is war he hopes to be secure in his position. And Germany suppotts this wuth money and weap9ms and diplomatic support at icj etc.
Aren't you a bit biased ? You are subscribed to AIJAC.
Doggy! 😍
Does an audio only version of the podcast exist? I did not find it.
Will watch the video later, but I have more opportunities to listen to podcast (especially on my way to work) than watching on youtube.
@@AliAlAda1Spotify
It is typical and it is very old, probably when the first real Hapsburg generation built the early forms of their empire, after the Reconquista, or in parallel.
This is the commissioner. You create a position, this is a constructivistic task, and you put your friend on that seat, and he becomes the hub for everything and anything , and everything and everyone dealing with this item has to walk through this hub or else it is not legit.
James jordan
What is the word that Scholz used?
Mauscheln
The sound is really bad in parts. First time, it appears, I didn't get this word, too.
If somebody using the word GLOBALISTS (Maaßen) is an Antisemit, than I am. And; by the the way: according to Annetta Kahane from the Antonio-Amadeo-Stiftung I also was an Antisemit when I questioned the Covid-Politics because beeing "Antiscience" means to be antisemitic. And issuing conspiricy-theories made me an antisemit because the first conspiracy-theory was targeted towards Jews. And even the Holocaust survivour Vera Sharav was called an Antisemite whne she called out the so called VACCINE connecting it to the Nuernberg Trails. They played with the phantay of sending the unvaccinated to Madagasgar and called unvaccinated People SOZIALSCHÄDLINGE and spoke of the TYRANY OF THE UNVACCINATED. Thes excluded us form public life. Hans Georg Maaßen was a critic of these completely undemocratic and fascist politics. And weather the scenes in Chemnitz were HETZJAGDEN? They were ugly, but not Hetzjagden.
Very interesting
Hostility and objection to the war crimes committed by the apartheid regime of the Israeli military occupation, which claimed the lives of more than 40,000 people in Palestine, is a humanitarian and moral duty imposed on us by our commitment to prevent the repetition of what happened to the Jews in advance. Never again for all of humanity
🚫🤡
Deborah Feldman is so reputable like Comical Ali from Iraq.
go on TrueAnon! Both of you lol
I read Feldman's book "Judenfetisch" and watched her movie with interest. However, her own plight in the Williamsburg orthodox community makes her blot out the extremism epedemic of the islamic world. - Her critique of German "Staatsräson" towards Israel is reasonable, however not every German who supports Zionism does so out of a cynical "Staatsräson". Or would you level the same critique at someone like, say, Douglas Murray, who strongly supports Zionism and the war on Hamas and Hisbollah?
Critique of Israel and the Netanyahu government should not be leveled at fighting Hamas but at the fact that they don't have a plan for the future of Gaza and the West bank.
They very obviously have a plan, Israel's leadership just refuses to publicize it, to put it in writing, to say it.
I am sure at least 90% of all Germans aren't aware of the jiddish origine of that expression 'mauscheln' ( just like dozens other orirginal jiddish words)
It is not a jiddish word at all though it is an antisemitic word that equates moses with conspiracy
@@stefankotz2242 the roots of that expression are (probably) going back to 17 18th century 'Rotwelsch ' ( a kind of jiddish 'Cockney') ....and as I already mentioned, nearly nobody nowaday is aware about it.....therefore it is not used in an anti semi tic ( out of censor reasons I have to write it this way) context
@derKosmoprolet369 just google the word mauschln and read the wikipedia article. Why are you making things up. Rotwelsch has partly jewish roots but was not a language primarly spooken primarly by jews, but rather Cricus folks, beggers, criminals and other traveling and marginalised people of various ethnicities in the german speaking world. But also "mauschln" doesnt come from rotwelsh either, so that's super irrelevant. Just google before you comment, its not difficult.
@@derKosmoprolet369btw. I feel you about the censors. I thinknyiyr stuff gets blocked automaticaly on youtube if you coomment too ofte. I think writing antisemitism is fine though
@@stefankotz2242 Actually I googled it before I wrote my last comment ( Et ymologists believing that the term is going back at 16./17th Cent spoken jiddish -- that's why I wrote 'probably ') ......and once I've seen a docu about the history of jews in Germany, in which was claimed Rotwelsch was based on jiddish ( probably some non-jewish 'Outlaws ' adopted it later on [?])
I'm afraid it's impossible to understand the parameters of the YT censor algo ( just too arbitrary)
She reminds me of Stella Goldschlag who collaborated with the Gestapo. After 5 minutes switched off. A Kapo.
She’s a bully. You only have to take a look at her social media accounts and how she is behaving there towards people who may have a different position than her.
What incredible rubbish is this! Talking for an hour without saying anything. Only vague nonsense.
lol. "ok"
Mad Brit in Germany
I have studied linguistics, I have read Victor Klemperer's LTI, but I have never heard that the word mauscheln has any relation to antisemitism. I assume that 99 per cent of Germans don't know anything about the origin of it, either. Getting from "mauscheln" to "Moishe" and vice versa is pretty impossible for any German. It is weak proof that Germans are antisemitic, let alone Kanzler Scholz, who might be dull and boring, but certainly not antisemitic. Sorry, this is pretty far fetched. You are giving Germans too much credit for their linguistic competence. Being raised speaking Yiddish, you certainly are juggling those nuances far better than us. Love the dog, btw
That is the accepted etymology just start with german wikipedia on the word and you see the relevant sources for this history. I am not sure studying ligustics means you know the etimolgy of every word in the German language, so that's a weird thing to bring up. I don't think that scholz is an antisemite but I do think its legitimate to point out if he is using vocabulary with antisemitic history. Shouldn't really happen with professional speech writers and all. This is is not casual talking.
Actually both of you should leave Germany.
That was just a plain lesson in left-green rainbow flag multiculty bullshit!
At least you're the greatest who's got all the answers. That's the most important thing. You shouldn't listen to other views. Just stay inside your echo chamber and turn the volume up
@@yamadakenji4143 I recommend to you to google the name Sarah Maria Sander. A wise young Jewish journalist from Germany ...
We stand 100% with Israel, all the way! ❤️🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱❤️
Cuck
Well, if you are German you are representing genocide for the second time.
#FREE PALESTINE🇵🇸❗️❗️❗️
npc alert
Who is we? The majority condemns and dislikes this apartheid terror state