Seahawks Analysis: Whole NFL may have F'd up w/ the DK Metcalf DISRESPECT?! | Not Top-15?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 108

  • @TheCharlesAtoz
    @TheCharlesAtoz 3 місяці тому +21

    The Seahawks roster has always talked about 'chips on their shoulders.' This will just fuel that sentiment in DK's mind! The Hawks are a cohesive team, that will turn into motivation that will spill out from the locker room onto the playing field.

    • @thetamoonedme7340
      @thetamoonedme7340 3 місяці тому +1

      New coaching staff in the off season, after a playoffs miss, means new team in the new season. We will see what THIS team is soon enough. 🤙🏾

  • @andrewstokes9841
    @andrewstokes9841 3 місяці тому +18

    As Seahawks fan Cooper Cup was slaying everyone before he got hurt, it was pissing me off .

    • @dannyb5328
      @dannyb5328 3 місяці тому +2

      Yeah man, they wanna crown a new king every year like Davantae Adams said.

  • @awk_cosmic7425
    @awk_cosmic7425 3 місяці тому +9

    Appreciate you always putting out great things Murph🤞🏽

  • @toypianos469
    @toypianos469 3 місяці тому +6

    9-13 would be fair. Great breakdown. I love watching him play. 2024 is interesting. If the Oline improves and if Grubb at Geno's hits we probably should do an extension at the end of the season, right? That market is blowing up year over year.

  • @matthewphillips5911
    @matthewphillips5911 3 місяці тому +7

    DK may not have done enough to warrant a top ten, but shunting him off the honorable mention to the third tier makes me wonder how much the media elements influenced subtle decisions. But yeah, maybe getting disrespected will put a fire in DK (and the rest of the team who get overlooked all the time).

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому

      Are there others inside of those parameters from a small market?

    • @matthewphillips5911
      @matthewphillips5911 3 місяці тому

      @@TopBillinSports Not sure I understand the question. I was thinking that teams with smaller markets (like Tennesee) get ignored in favor of New York, Boston, etc.
      If you meant players on the Seahawks, I have a couple in mind.

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому

      @@matthewphillips5911 - I meant it how it's said. You're blaming the media instead of the player, when players who are above him are also from smaller market teams.
      I have for years dissected his game and some people called me biased, which makes zero sense, but now that NFL execs, scouts, and analysts say it, it's now a media market thing?

  • @Kamuela1972
    @Kamuela1972 3 місяці тому +3

    It starts with Geno and the protection. IF Geno gets the time to allow plays to develop, DK will reap the benefits from this. This will certainly open up the running game AND give JSN and Lockett more open looks. Add the TE into the mix, add BoBo AND Zach Charbonet and a Grub style offense, you might see DK grabbing more than 100 receptions AND 1500 receiving yards.

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому

      Listen to what I'm telling you in the video opposed to just saying the generic stuff everyone says...It's Year 6: It's time you stop blaming everyone else and put the onus on Metcalf. There are people above him on this list with way worse QB and OL siutations. DJ Moore played with Justin Fields, Sam Darnold, etc for the Panthers and Bears, respectively. But he knows how to run routes and has great hands.

  • @beetlejuiceification
    @beetlejuiceification 3 місяці тому +4

    Sometimes people will say Metcalf is “not all that” based upon his value in fantasy leagues. Fantasy rankings are written based upon “ what have you done for me lately,” not how much press or name recognition a player gets. I myself try to steer away from Metcalf because he was not used enough to score points for my teams. I am a long time ardent Seahawk loving fan. As a Seahawk fan, I believe Coach Carroll did not use him well. Why? For too long he was used confusingly, and intermittently. He never became a dominate WR game after game. Sometimes he just disappears on offense. As good as he is said to be, he can go three weeks and score one touchdown…yeah… like that. And during that time he can earn terrible bone head penalties that leave my son and I just shaking our heads. If he is all that why does that go down? The same thing happened to Jaxon, he was widely hearalded as all pro talent but did nothing the first six games last year. Then he gradually started to play. But six games? I think the powers that be got openly frustrated with Carroll and his offensive strategies with his coaches for letting highly heralded & costly talent put up midline numbers. I definetly think Metcalf should be top 15 but only if his production expectations matches his salary.

  • @chaddwamboldt9763
    @chaddwamboldt9763 3 місяці тому

    thanks for a very honest and football accurate description of DK and, yeah, the potential is there but it's been there for 5 years now and he has absolutely plateaued, or actually, gotten a little worse. We can all say that's Waldren's or even PC's fault but simple things like, as you mention, poor route running, not highpointing the ball, or not even extending your arms out to catch the ball away from your body (or the DB), and just these ridiculous moments when he goes off schedule on some damn lark to punch wildly at some dang defender, it's just stupid, man. Now having said all of that, I do believe that this will get corrected under the new regime because both Mike Mac and Brubb are absolute technicians and will NOT tolerate that kind of play. I can see DK becoming a mix of, I'm going to say it, Rome Odunze (just love the guy love love love!) and Deebo, and I hope they start using him like the Niners do with Deebo. DK would break dudes in the middle of the field and PLEASE more more MOTION! Grubb is a motion freak, so you get DK going before the ball is even snapped and all that bulk having momentum now, NO ONE is going to want to hit dat! lol

  • @roxannerolle1319
    @roxannerolle1319 3 місяці тому +2

    I always view most of the talking heads in the NFL with a bit of contempt, but I cannot fault anyone for personal viewpoint. Stats tend to be the "measuring stick" most use to support what ever view they hold on certain players. Numbers don't lie. I like your take on the matter. Dennis Rodman, Junior himself could be motivated to a nightmare-ish level for defenders. I certainly do hope so...I love when talking heads eat crow. I would love to see DK shove it in their craws. Thanks Murph for the content.

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому +1

      These aren't talking heads. Please pay attention. NFL execs, scouts, and analysts aren't that.

    • @roxannerolle1319
      @roxannerolle1319 3 місяці тому +1

      @@TopBillinSports my bad, you are right

  • @lannybackes1053
    @lannybackes1053 3 місяці тому +1

    For many years, the mainstream sports media pundits, for one reason or another, are often seemingly biased against anyone playing in Seattle. Look how they are with Geno! Completely ignore his numbers. Throw shade saying last season he regressed, when the only regression in his numbers was due to him being injured and sitting for 2½ games. DK needs this to work on his game skills, concentration, route running. Potential isn't enough, he has good numbers, but we know, and I believe he knows that he can make them better.

  • @csick09
    @csick09 3 місяці тому +3

    He single handedly lost us two games last year because of dumb penalties

  • @yourecancelledfromsociety7551
    @yourecancelledfromsociety7551 3 місяці тому +2

    Best Dennis Rodman Jr coverage in youtube🫡

  • @justiceadams6623
    @justiceadams6623 3 місяці тому

    BILLIN never missed you would make a great scout for the Eagles they better take notes from you

  • @The_Quadfather
    @The_Quadfather 3 місяці тому +1

    If you take a look at fantasy rankings from last season... It almost mirrors their list.

  • @seda_11
    @seda_11 3 місяці тому +1

    I don't like his placement here but I don't think it is that egregious either. Starting at spot 8 with Mike Evans I start to disagree with the order of the list, 1-7 are pretty untouchable though. So I'd probably put DK in the 8-15 range somewhere. Like you said, his game has been pretty stagnant outside of some route improvements and he isn't fully utilizing his frame to make contested catches. So I could see why the league thinks of him more as a top 20 receiver than a top 10.

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому

      Great, levelheaded analysis as usual, bro! But you think DK is better than Mike Evans?

    • @seda_11
      @seda_11 3 місяці тому +1

      @@TopBillinSports Evans is just the first guy where there is an argument to be made... I might take him over DK for another year, but he is probably on the decline soon. About to turn 31 and has played 10 full seasons already. And some other guys on the honorable mentions I think might be better than him already.

  • @rubens397
    @rubens397 3 місяці тому

    Yeah I agree I don't think he earned a spot there yet but I hope he changes next season. We have a good receiver room but I don't really see him that much ahead of Lockett bc of his hands and route running. JSN and Bobo also great to have

  • @Zee-ip1xg
    @Zee-ip1xg 3 місяці тому +3

    Blessings Top Billin' So much unknown upcoming into this season, and this freshness and new-ness, should be alot of fun watching them, and your insight analysis videos.

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому +2

      Blessings, brotha! Looking forward to it, no doubt!

  • @brianblank9921
    @brianblank9921 3 місяці тому

    Yo, murf. That's a great piece! DK fo sho getting dissed. Maybe the man will work on his hands and prove em' wrong. He's not top 10 until he makes those contested catches consistently.

  • @blakelywilliams4564
    @blakelywilliams4564 3 місяці тому

    DK is definitely gonna show out this year and prove somethin, especially working towards a contract year. Hes capable of touching 1500 yards, but we’ll see how he’s utilized in the new offense. Also im curious of where you’d rank the other two guys in Tyler Lockett and JSN? Do all three make the top 30? 40? Where are you at with the receiving core as a whole?

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому +1

      I'd put Lockett in the top-25'ish. JSN I think has a chance to be better than DK, but it's hard to toss him in the top-18 before he's earned it for me. Puka Nacua wasn't in that and he killed the NFL as a rookie.

  • @Telefiend
    @Telefiend 3 місяці тому +1

    DK can dominate at times, then he can take stupid penalties and drop balls at others. I am really hoping JSN gets an opportunity to fulfill his potential and takes the #1 spot.

  • @rawnchydeard4669
    @rawnchydeard4669 3 місяці тому +6

    Find me one team that wouldn’t sign him to a multi year deal right now.

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому +2

      Not sure what's that supposed to mean. Not being better than all these other great WRs doesn't mean he isn't good. I'm sure most teams would sign someone like a DJ Moore to a multi-year contract. There are more than 18 WRs in the NFL, my man, as there are like 5-6 per team. He's in elite company no matter what.

    • @rawnchydeard4669
      @rawnchydeard4669 3 місяці тому

      @@TopBillinSports what I’m saying is he’d be their #1 receiver. He has a unique skill set and in some offenses, he’s completely unstoppable. Ain’t many teams that wouldn’t give up plenty to get him. Sorry, I was posting in a couple of places and didn’t finish my thought! 🤣

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому +2

      Dude, what? Ok, bro. I'm not going down this rabbit hole again. People who know way more about this sport clearly disagree with that assessment.

  • @dannyb5328
    @dannyb5328 3 місяці тому +1

    Honestly I don’t really care where anyone ranks DK. In my personal opinion he’s rated about fine as is, but thats not to say theres no way he can improve.

    • @dannyb5328
      @dannyb5328 3 місяці тому +1

      Especially now that we grubbin at genos

  • @ASnareM
    @ASnareM 3 місяці тому +2

    Is Nico Collins really better than DK and these other guys? I got to watch more Texans games

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому

      Yes.

    • @ASnareM
      @ASnareM 3 місяці тому

      @@TopBillinSports I’ll keep a look out for the Top Billin’ Texans content too I guess lol

    • @isaiahmartin9026
      @isaiahmartin9026 3 місяці тому

      Maybe…let’s see him stack some of these good years.

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому

      I don't cover the Texans

  • @johnstratton6207
    @johnstratton6207 3 місяці тому +1

    If he played for the chiefs this wouldn’t be a discussion. It’s not his fault he doesn’t have better numbers than he already does. I put blame on coaching and the offense in general. We haven’t been great.

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому

      Yawn. Execs, Scouts, and Analysts don't care about numbers. They are analyzing the player. Tyreek Hill doesn't play for the Chiefs anymore and is actually putting up better numbers because he's a complete WR for all the reasons I named. In fact, there's not one Chief on this list. Can we please get some Real Football Heads on my channel who want to analyze this sport from something other than a casual fan-like perspective, people? Do me that one favor.

    • @johnlarsen5273
      @johnlarsen5273 3 місяці тому

      So True

  • @Zaknyfein
    @Zaknyfein 3 місяці тому

    A couple of years ago, in one of your most impactful analysis pieces for me, you labelled DK as "Iron Hands" and presented evidence to support the claim. If you believe that DK has overcome this issue then maybe he should have forced his way into the Top 10. Either way, at 24 million $ a year, I think he is a steal!

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому +1

      Lol it may have been more like "Cast Iron Skillet hands," as I'm a little more creative than that, but I certainly hear you, my man! Not sure where you're getting that I believe he no longer has those issues, though?

    • @Zaknyfein
      @Zaknyfein 3 місяці тому

      @@TopBillinSports Possibly an assumption I should not have made!

  • @billburbank4314
    @billburbank4314 3 місяці тому

    To your point, I dont watch enough of these cats to be in a position to judge. That said, you line up those last 5 and othet hon mentions, and let GM pick them playground style, not sure he is still there when 10th guy is picked. But you aint wrong...he got the physical talents just need to improve a few key areas. He still a young buck.

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому

      Says who, though? You because you're a fan of his team. People who aren't biased chose those others with no parameters over him. Being a physical freak isn't as impressive to actual football people. Justin Jefferson putting up video game numbers and isn't anywhere near the athlete DK Metcalf is.

  • @johnlarsen5273
    @johnlarsen5273 3 місяці тому

    Say What! Give us a Break, Disrespect, Hawks are going to Soar & Score this year

  • @adamthompson8140
    @adamthompson8140 3 місяці тому

    Not disrespected at all. I probably have him ranked right around 20 ish. He really lacks two things that keep him from being elite. First, lateral quickness. Holy shit Murph, DK cuts about as well as a school bus. Not really his fault, more so the fault of physics. Just what happens when you’re tall and top heavy with a high center of gravity. Unfortunately it really hurts his route running ability. He won just 46% of his total routes last season and ranked 78th in target separation. Not good. More often than not, he’s well-covered.
    The second issue with DK is, as you know, his hands. He’s a very unnatural pass catcher and has a tendency to body-catch everything. Despite having a freakish vertical, he is not the go-up-and-get-it type and rarely comes back to the ball. His catch rate was just 55% last season but his contested catch rate was especially bad at 25%. A guy that big and that strong should have a much better contested catch rate and that would really help make up for his route running deficiencies.
    For those reasons, I have him outside the top 20 because without the ability to consistently create separation OR make contested catches, he’s a rather unreliable target. I can very easily find 20 WRs who are more reliable and efficient with their opportunities.

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому +1

      Gotcha, bro. I dig the analysis!! Good stuff

  • @briandieujuste1085
    @briandieujuste1085 3 місяці тому +5

    Nah he perfectly rated

  • @jermainepauling7551
    @jermainepauling7551 3 місяці тому

    Seahawks are the Miami heat of the nfl

  • @duaneho76
    @duaneho76 3 місяці тому

    This ranking might just make him an all around better team player.

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому +2

      That's actually not a bad thought at all!

  • @russobrien5453
    @russobrien5453 3 місяці тому

    D K is the man

  • @derricksanchez4755
    @derricksanchez4755 3 місяці тому

    He good but we know his hands be problems at times great player we all know

  • @michaelstrauss3769
    @michaelstrauss3769 3 місяці тому

    There are a lot of mouths to feed on the Seahawks. No knock on DK; it’s just not the path taken by Seattle Management.

  • @stayvigilant007
    @stayvigilant007 3 місяці тому

    DK is maybe a Top-5 athlete in the league, but has pork chops for hands sometimes! Strange hand placement.

  • @solomonloosli6364
    @solomonloosli6364 3 місяці тому

    South Alaska Seahawks

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому

      Big Love to South Alaska!!! Thank you, bro!!!

  • @andrewhaines9119
    @andrewhaines9119 3 місяці тому

    I'm all for Geno but DK was under thrown all year.

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому

      Sure he was, bro. The fact that you think football is all about deep balls speak volumes to me. Talk about some real football stuff. Talk about rounding off routes. Talk bout quitting on routes if you're not the primary. Talk about dropping perfectly placed passes. Talking about being 6-4 and not being a 50/50-ball monster. Talking about deep balls all the time is mad corny and casual. I literally made this video and talked about the nuances of the position for you to then turn around and talk about deep balls? Come on, bro.

  • @LifeAboveTreeLine99
    @LifeAboveTreeLine99 3 місяці тому

    “Your routes determine your targets” not correct. But we all know when someone calls you out you just get defensive and talk shit (which insecure people do) as a WR if you can’t run the route tree and do it at a high level than yes, but there is a lot more going on for someone to get the ball thrown to him. WR’s can run a great route and be wide open SEVERAL times a game and not get the ball.

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому

      If someone calls me out and all I do is get defensive and talk shit, then why do you continue to come to my channel? Why not simply hit "Don't recommend this channel." LIke, what does a grown man get out of going somewhere they don't like what goes on when they have the choice to not do it?

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому

      Answer me, please. It's 2024. Time out for being on this type of time. What do you get out of continuing to watch me?

    • @LifeAboveTreeLine99
      @LifeAboveTreeLine99 3 місяці тому

      @@TopBillinSports am I wrong?

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому

      The question is what do you get out of continuing to watch me if that's what you think?

    • @LifeAboveTreeLine99
      @LifeAboveTreeLine99 3 місяці тому

      @@TopBillinSports many if not the majority of your videos I enjoy, agree with and appreciate the view you take. But whenever I have pushed back a bit it turns into insults. Instead of explaining and discussing different views. No worries ✌🏽 it’s 2024 drop the ego and man up.

  • @dennator4395
    @dennator4395 3 місяці тому +1

    Bro, anybody claiming that DK is a more complete player than Tyreek Hill is outta their damn mind. 😂
    However, seeing his name as late as #19 is straight up disrespectful.
    So yeah, this should definitely be great motivation! 💯💪🏼🔥
    The sky just might be the limit for him with that new offense!
    It all depends on how they play into his abilities.
    Short to medium routes with some yards after the catch could be the way to go as standard.
    With more explosive plays sprinkled in-between. 😅😂
    How do you think they will use his skill set in this new Grubb O? 🔥
    Appreciate your hard work and you keeping it real. 💯

  • @TFT_guy
    @TFT_guy 3 місяці тому

    Metcalf is the most overrated mid receiver consider WR 1 ..his stats comes in garage games and stats

  • @UncleJimmyOutWest
    @UncleJimmyOutWest 3 місяці тому +5

    DK sucks! He gets way too many targets and he's prone to taking awful penalties. He has no discipline and he nevrr finishes his routes if he's not the #1 target. He should be traded. If you disagree, put him on your fantasy team to see how overrated he is. Get rid of DK!

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому +10

      Saying he sucks is as bad as saying he's the best, man. Being that extreme makes your point seem too outlandish to be taken seriously.

    • @ajmysholowsky
      @ajmysholowsky 3 місяці тому +4

      @@TopBillinSportsfor real like there should be valid criticism but just cause he makes mistakes doesn’t make him ass

    • @abr107
      @abr107 3 місяці тому

      You read the list and I kind of think of it as, " would I take the other receiver over DK. And until he's more productive and more consistent, I think it's a valid argument to have him where he's ranked

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому +2

      @@ajmysholowsky - Facts. Just like someone liking him, because he plays for their favorite team, doesn't make him better than every guy on this list, too. People just need to remove the emotions.

    • @JuniorP818
      @JuniorP818 3 місяці тому

      DK baby! Too 10 wideout for sure.
      Sick these casual fans not knowing anything about football, and yet have something to say, without putting in the work to search for valid statistics. Go hawks baby! Keep it up top billin!

  • @LifeAboveTreeLine99
    @LifeAboveTreeLine99 3 місяці тому

    🤡🤥🤥🫡

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому

      See. Your whole objective was to just get my attention and be a hater. How corny is that, bro? I didn't even say anything bad to you, I just wanted to know who does that? Seriously, it's 2024. Just a get a life and hit "Don't recommend this channel" and stop creating profile names to get another male's attention.

    • @LifeAboveTreeLine99
      @LifeAboveTreeLine99 3 місяці тому

      @@TopBillinSports you deflect. Never got blocked didn’t change my name for some reason for you. You’re just a lie!

    • @LifeAboveTreeLine99
      @LifeAboveTreeLine99 3 місяці тому

      Look it up and be honest.

    • @LifeAboveTreeLine99
      @LifeAboveTreeLine99 3 місяці тому

      @@TopBillinSports you know the truth. All you do is spin shit to what makes you look good. Truth is the truth. I’m done with ya corny ass

    • @TopBillinSports
      @TopBillinSports  3 місяці тому

      @@LifeAboveTreeLine99 - Imagine being done with someone when you came to get their attention? I can't be done with you because I never knew you existed for that to be the case. "Don't recommend this channel." Simple.