China Is An Unaccountable Actor: Views From India, Australia and US
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 чер 2024
- The Quadrilateral Security Dialogue is becoming increasingly important to Indian, Japanese, Australian, and American efforts to balance Chinese power and extend the rules-based order in the Indo-Pacific. Its strategic importance to Australia was underscored this May when Prime Minister Anthony Albanese made the Quad leaders’ meeting in Tokyo his first foreign engagement as Prime Minister.
At this special event, the Lowy Institute’s Executive Director Dr. Michael Fullilove discussed the Quad’s evolving role with leading thinkers from two other Quad countries:
Dr. Kori Schake, Director, Foreign and Defense Policy Studies, American Enterprise Institute, United States
Dr. Samir Saran, President, Observer Research Foundation, India
This video was originally produced and published by the Lowy Institute, Sydney.
The original video can be found here: • Kori Schake and Samir ...
#SamirSaranonQuad #FutureofQuad #QuadrilateralSecurityDialogue
Subscribe, follow and engage with us:
UA-cam: / orfdelhi
Facebook: / orfonline
ORF Twitter: / orfonline
Raisina Dialogue Twitter: / raisinadialogue
Instagram: / orfonline
Dr. Kori is a waste of time. High on emotions and low on substance. Sameer was spot on.
She is just a spokesperson for Biden
Most Americans lack substance compared to Asians, who have to really work hard in understanding context. Americans are strong on what has happened to them in the last 15 mins and what is needed by them in the next 2 hours.
well said...point blank useless. Dr is questionable , must be giving them out at 7/11 in the US
She must be high, he says China is maligned because Vietnam is nervous but then Vietnam humiliated US’s, and then Vietnam signs recently a big deal with China. Philippines did the same with China on trade and people to people exchange there are more Filipinos working and making a living in China than US and India combined. Does nervous countries behave this way? Kori is irrational and high on coffee. Don’t want to see here again in any interview panel.
she sounds like she's doped up on something
The (USA) America call it "Liberation" instead of "Invasion". That was what US call it in Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, Syria, Yemen, Somalia and the list goes on... Why the double standard? Confused... Please enlighten. Genuine question...
Instances of the United States "liberated" or overthrowing, or attempting to overthrow, a foreign government since the Second World War. (* indicates successful ouster of a government)
China 1949 to early 1960s
Albania 1949-53
East Germany 1950s
Iran 1953 *
Guatemala 1954 *
Costa Rica mid-1950s
Syria 1956-7
Egypt 1957
Indonesia 1957-8
British Guiana 1953-64 *
Iraq 1963 *
North Vietnam 1945-73
Cambodia 1955-70 *
Laos 1958 *, 1959 *, 1960 *
Ecuador 1960-63 *
Congo 1960 *
France 1965
Brazil 1962-64 *
Dominican Republic 1963 *
Cuba 1959 to present
Bolivia 1964 *
Indonesia 1965 *
Ghana 1966 *
Chile 1964-73 *
Greece 1967 *
Costa Rica 1970-71
Bolivia 1971 *
Australia 1973-75 *
Angola 1975, 1980s
Zaire 1975
Portugal 1974-76 *
Jamaica 1976-80 *
Seychelles 1979-81
Chad 1981-82 *
Grenada 1983 *
South Yemen 1982-84
Suriname 1982-84
Fiji 1987 *
Libya 1980s
Nicaragua 1981-90 *
Panama 1989 *
Bulgaria 1990 *
Albania 1991 *
Iraq 1991
Afghanistan 1980s *
Somalia 1993
Yugoslavia 1999-2000 *
Ecuador 2000 *
Afghanistan 2001 *
Venezuela 2002 *
Iraq 2003 *
Haiti 2004 *
Somalia 2007 to present
Honduras 2009 *
Libya 2011 *
Syria 2012
Ukraine 2014 *
2014 - 2022 - 6 countries yet to verify.
Pakistan 2022 *
You list a lot of interventions, in some of which the role of the USA has not been established, or was not unique or central to the outcome (Syria, Libya, Somali, Yemen?). There is a level of hypocrisy in Western narratives, they have a dubious track record in the 20th century (and before), but the context of each of these cases is too different to lump them together and discuss here. And the development (and protection) of universal human rights and international law is a recent thing (2nd half of the 20th century).
Some other points then: interventions in Iran, Chile, or Panama were typically not framed as a liberation, in fact few people even knew about USA involvement at the time (or cared about it).
Deposing a theocratic or autocratic regime (Iran, Iraq, Afghanistan) could be considered liberation by many people, both in those countries and certainly by USA. Of course, USA has also installed dictators or kept them in power.
Thirdly, nations have always used subterfuge to establish regime change or protect their economic interest in other countries, since before the count of time. This is not the same as invading with an army and taking over control.
US can justify anything and everything. It's called Manifest Destiny
The Permanent Court of Arbitration in Hague is Not a UN agency. Please don't use the term "UN Court". US stealing Diego Garcia islands from Mauritius was ruled illegal by the World court which is a UN Agency. US and UK ignored the ruling.
I don't know how the South China Sea dispute has anything to do with the Solomon Islands security agreement with China. US and Australia was trying to plot a regime change in Solomon Islands and this prompted the Solomon Islands to seek a security arrangement with China.
Most of the west and Indians are brainwashed by their media to believe China is the problem.
Australian army commit genocide in Afghanistan along side with the U.S. and was never hold accountable.
3 stooges with a lackey token brown guy 🤣
why I cannot see the three replies?
what happen to the socalled free media youtube?
It is fine and dandyt for the QUAD for having bases in the first island chain just less than 400 km from the coast of China and periodically sailed war ships within 200 km from the coast of China yet Australia get upset when China develop relationships with the Pacific islands? Double standards or hypocrisy?
You have been brainwashed with propaganda.
They are white what do you expect 😂😂
It's high time dictators in Africa, should think twice about investing their ill-gotten fortunes in America, Britain and European countries. You have seen how innocent Russian citizens have been victimised. Invest at home, Africa is your home where you belong.
34:00 Dr. Kori seemed to have no clue what was happening in Ukraine. Was he fooled by her own mainstream media or was she promoting the false information on purpose?
Absolutely loved Samir's straight to the point viewpoints in very objective manner.
Not all his views are correct he just creates fear because he doesn’t understand. If he wants to understand China has he even visited China?
Sycophants needed always.
😁 India cannot even pay to upgrade its own trains and roads but wanted to help the Pacific Islands? John Laughland gave a great lecture about fiction and reality in world affairs. I guessed Samir had not heard it.
@@cheeho9698 Well, we all know that which country wants be Numero Uno without Fighting a real war, which has NEVER happened in Human History. A country where ppl can't criticize its rulers. A country where its citizens are merely living as slaves. A country where its companies have to serve its rulers for imperialist designs. I can go on and on .... but, so much for Fiction vs Reality.
@@vka3 Being a supercilious and continuing ignorance to interests of others' is rather detestable. Times have changed.
‘Thief always think others are thieves because they know theft too well from being thief .’
Shame
stupid thought
Are you talking about the Chinese CCP folks?😜😜😜😜
@@jspillai1869 I am talking about democracy war criminal and their pet.
@@user-bp7gy2lq4g And Chinese CCP are holier than thou 🤣😂😅😂
This Indian dude is on fire. They're rising up from their slumber.
When they say rule based world order. Who defines the rule ? UN or just like before only West ? if UN, we welcome, if West, Please No more West defined Rule over the UN Rule.
Of course the Anglos whites, which the Chinese already slapped blinken face in Alaska in 2021! You are not in a position to say this phrase from the position of strength. I think it meant ph*ck u Antony Blinken.
Sameer is blunt.
He shamed everysingle one here with facts.
Most americans dont care about facts. and most chinese dont deem anything as fact unless it comes out of a hole of chinese communist party. so no fun. Sameer and india would win only if they are able to show profitability to USA. ONLY MONEY IS IMPORTANT FOR USA. No values. No History. No Vision. ALL MONEY.
He has nothing in his mind except anti china propaganda.
Scholarly yet firmly down-to-earth.
Sameer, your analysis is brilliant, because you are specific with your actionable items and deliverables. Kudos!
Sycophants needed always.
Today, China owns most major unicorns of India. China is massively involved in Indian main street, not just at the borders in Ladakh. China has huge trade surplus with India. Policy makers should stop blustering rhetoric, and be more fact based.
1.) Why China invest in many Indian Unicorns ?
Because Indian investors and banks have no faith in their fellow countrymen.
2.) Why China has huge trade surplus with India ?
Because India has nothing worth exporting to China that China needs but Australia, Japan, South Korea and Taiwan etc have HUGE Trade surplus with China.
India has a big generic pharmaceutical Industry but most Indians do not know that the main active or pharmaceutical active raw materials are imported from China. Trade to improve each other nations' populations instead of listening to these anti China demogogues is more important.
I just found out that india export lots human hair to china.
@@HafiZzZzZz yes, true. They are then made into wigs and exported to US and EU.
Samir Sharan- Seedhi baat no bakwaas
21:11 pakisthan always like to be in trouble...at this point u am certain that india is just waiting to pakisthan to self destruct themselves..which has already started and then deal with them
Oh they are almost there
Few more years and there will be no Pakistan
Mark my words
By exchanging nukes?
Cccp bots are all over the comment section ranting out their supremacist ideas about themselves and belittling others!!
Accountable to who and why ? Are any of us accountable to China ?
Shame
@Amrit Waiba Arey bura maan gaye kya..
aapka chin se paisa aane hi waala hain. Bhikari ki zindagi mubarak ho aapko
@Amrit Waiba in future not just USA it would be an obligation of it's allies too to maintian a dollar hagemony over the period of next 10-20 years
@Amrit Waiba That’s not how macroeconomics works boy! Yen is one of the most devalued currencies but is 3rd on the list of foreign reserves in the world. 1 position above yuan. Keep your bs out of intellectual conversations
@@abhaypatel4292 US allies feel pains just having a slightest thought of it
The presenter of this programme is OUT OF TOUCH!!!
Great to know he is on the black list of Russia...👍
Still hasn't changed, Mr. Saran.
Vishal Jood had a target painted on him by a minister of the Australian government, Alex Hawke.
You may let this slide, but we will not, and we will seek retribution.
The anglo-saxons will be made to exit the vast Australian continent. They took it from the indigenous Australian people and it is up to Indians to throw them out and restore the balance by correcting historical injustices.
Why it is the responsibilty of Indians or someone else....?? If you want someone out then take actions yourself
@@mohitgautam184 Yes, Indians want the anglos out and will take actions themselves.
Ever time I listen to Samir Saran I learn something. Not only is he articulate but he also has some original thoughts on global issues. It's a pleasure to listen to him.
Talk is hot air. Where are all the 5, 10, 15, 20, etc. year plans of all these countries in question? Which countries claims to have these plans. More importantly can any of these countries show. evidence of meeting the goals of these plans. There is one country discussed that has such a plan but more importantly, this country can show concrete evidence of meeting their goals. The proof is in the pudding.... the rest is all hot air and rhetoric. 💡
Ukraine definitely performed heroically. And Russia suffered a hug defeat initially around Kiev. However, this, along with the toughest economic sanction ever formed, fails to change the Ukraine War fundamentally. Russia is going to win and it did not even mobilize yet. The only question is how much the price Putin is willing to pay to get how big the victory.
This is NOT a Putin war but a war for the survival of the Russian Federation. Russians paid a big price fighting the Nazi Germany. The only nation that lost more people were the Chinese. Nobody mentions the 27 million Russians who died but instead we are always inundated with the supposed 6 million European non-Semitic Jews. The price that Russia is ready to inflict on its enemies will be extremely high that no human beings will ever endure it again.
Russia will not win.
@@ROTHSTEIN01 Do you really believe that a bunch of homosexuals and lesbians from the West who have practiced slavery and colonialism and now neocolonialism and above all genocides across the globe will be victorious over the not so bad Russians? Unless you eat human waste for breakfast and supper deliciously, it cannot happen. The corruption of Western civilization is beyond imagination and God who created them cannot allow such a system to continue for ever. Bye bye Europe and western civilization.
@@baruasafi5880 I agree that if another person in charge of Russia this war will likely happen for the same reason. So this is not a war caused by Putin personally. But Putin is the Russian Leader now and his decisive influence on the decision of the war is the most important. In that sense, you can it a Putin's War, like the Iraq War is Bush's War.
@@qingzhou9983 for virtually 30 years Russia has been asking for a New Security Architecture for Europe and has been rebuffed as being a defeated power, a gas station etc. The war in Ukraine is NOT a Putin war but a collective will of the majority of Russian people realizing that they are about to be surrounded and disabled by a series of attacks. Read history and wake up how western imperialists have attempted to invade Russia and dismember it.
In the Last 2 years, trade between India & China has dramatically increased. So I guess everything between them is honky dowry.
Trade and politics are separate entities in India.
@@2KSnSLifestyle boycotting China is work, buying Chinese products is life？
Son why us do trade with china 😁
@@rajibchakroborthy4181 because it's profitable.
@@2KSnSLifestyle same here
Bangladesh's are becoming smart in playing politics for china .......
Good for them..they can enjoy the swing between powers as long as they have strong strings of Sheikh Hasina in power
@@abhaypatel4292 I really like to see Bangladesh without sheikh hasina.. I don't follow Bangladesh politics but I hope they have something that can continue her model..
Bangladeshi are hard working people and with good attitude.
Is there any Lazy country?? There are only Lazy politicians
@@chubascomohd2688 yeah but they casually love to break temples rape and kill minorities....
When politics takes precedence over academics, discussions among scholars are meaningless. American opinion is the greatest politics!
WTF are you talking man?
Yes, and go around the world bombing and killing in the name of human rights? Tell that to the Veitnamese, Iraqis, Libyans and Afghanistanis. Also the Argentinians, Cubans etc.
Samir Saran is a smart guy, We need more people who can think and speak their thoughts like him.
And continue to do the work for the Anglo…! Soooo smart, in my view as a continuous line of a colony to the Anglo.
Saran is very intelligent for a person that sounds like Farhan Akthar👍😂
@Amrit Waiba Kaay boltos ha mulga?
She is great for lying though 🤣 I mean everything she said was not factual 🤣😂
But far better knowledge and frequency
@Amrit Waiba in your dreams btc
Lol
A plead to our Indian brothers and sisters, please stop saying Indo China Border, because India has physically border with Tibet in the past and still today with the Chinese occupied Tibet. India had never ever had a part of its land touching with China. China today stand on a land occupied since 1950 Tibet. The Border police force that had with India and Independent Tibet are still there and they are called Indo-Tibetan Border Police(ITBP) force. Jai Bharat! Jai Tibbat! Free Tibet!
Excellent point 👍
Tibet was a territory of Qing Dynasty until 1900s. At that time, Tibet claimed independent amid chaotic civil war in China. And to gain support from the British, Tibet signed border treaty with the British and gave out large chunk of land which is the cause of the dispute between China and India today.
But Modi doesn't have balls to recognize Tibet as an independent country!
@@rogerma7831 Wumao, stop distorting history. Tibet had remained Independent while Han China was ruled by the Mongols and Manchus and Chinese had remained under foreign Empires for thousands of years. It is lies and wish full thinking and concocted story of the CCP. Why did China built the great walls? For whom were you scared? The walls were built to keep the what China called „Barbarians“ Tibetans and the Mongols out. Tibet had signed treaties with China, Mongolia, Nepal and British India. Stop your lies, you cannot turned the lies into truth. Truth itself will take its course.
@Jiggy Lee The Royal Tibetan embassy is already operating in Dharamsala and we will get the necessary paperwork done😎
Which time video is this?
Not to sound too cheesy but the Eagle, Tiger/Elephant, Kangaroo, and Giant Squid can defeat a dragon easily.
Dragons are imaginary where as the Tiger is real.
LOL... so why fear...so much?
LOL... Chinese threat...QUAD..
Indian no 1 trading partner..
Aussie no 1 trading partner..
Japan no 1 trading partner...
USA no 2/3 trading partner...
Why don't QUAD decouple with China all together? You can level the threat!
But you won't have your iPhone, how sad!
@@blackknight4996 there is already an unannounced plan in QUAD and EU to make each other the largest trading partners where India will be the manufacturing hub. I mean, that's how China began it's journey of economic growth, with the help from US, EU and allies. So, be thankful that these countries are trading with you instead of boosting about it.
Giant Squid😂
somebody is going to get hurt...
China is both Australian and Indian no.1 trade partner. It means their people consider China as a true accountable actor, no matter how their politicians cry.
In India people are really unhappy over trade with China bcoz of Galwan incident!!
Slowly but surely we gonna reduce trade and dependence from cccp led china!!
😆😆😆😆ok cry baby China🇨🇳 currently is not India's largest treading partner it is USA🇺🇸 , you should check your information ok.
China🇨🇳 and never ever become a partner or friend because we indian believe in democratic system, but Chinese🇨🇳 believe in communist Party system.
@@anupamsatpathi2071 Because India recently has good buttkissing to USA in AUKUS USA sold a lot of its garbage weapons to India, instead of the normal civil business trade. Shame on you with your slums everywhere in India.
@@anupamsatpathi2071 USA made Covid19 has already killed your over 4.7 million Indians, it seems still your god, right? Another shame! Might there was no your loved one in those Indian deaths of pandemic.
Indian town planning and urban horticulture is getting worse and virtually non existent. Fast economic growth with corruption is resulting in unplanned and hapazard city development and urban ghettos without much greenery.
@Ashish Bagade that makes no sense. Demolition does not equal growth and also if demolition and anti corruption laws do not get introduced then we gonna have more and more chaos and unorderliness in India.
Really important issue
I thought I was the only one who thought about this 😂
Wow let me raise a random issue on a random youtube video.
That's a super answer, Saran, and a straight answer without mincing words.
She lies about Trump.
He slapped iraq invasion on face
Good to hear good to be optimistic and not pessimistic ,or over critical.. peaceful world for generations to come that is what we all want. Though we as children grew up hearing horror stories of two world wars. Jived through 1947. Horror became penniless overnight. Lived through experiments of converting religiously narrow minded people to become world minded citizens. Interesting time’s historically, survived it all holding on to my faith. I am Hindu l have return ticket.
Good post
Grt samir sir
Biden is doing a good job ? Who is the moderator from bbc ? 🤣 Maybe US can teach Russians who to scoot like inAfganasthan
Prepared questions , but no reaction to answers.
I'm Indian, there are lot of things I agree with Dr. Samir but there are also lot of other things I disagree with him. The fundamental problem with many so called 'Indian intellectuals' like Dr. Samir himself is that; we (Indian) are heavily influence by western ideology and their worldview, that we forgot to see the world with our own eyes as it should. We always judge or see the Chinese from a very western driven perspectives which often carries politically motivated agenda and vested interest. This is the reason why we know so little about China despite sharing thousand of KMs borders with them. And even if we do know something about them, we know it in a very wrong way fed by western media and their views. Thus suspicions and mistrust has grown. The west are happy about this division and enmity between India and China (two Asian giants with potential superpowers in the world) because we will be busy pulling each others leg, while the West, led by US, will continue to maintain their hegemony, dominate and dictate the world. But many couldn't realized this. DIVIDE and RULE policy is still Alive and Kicking. Beware!
Besides the recent border skirmishes in Ladakh, I see a lot of Indians were reminded and told repeatedly about the 1962 war with China, where we unfortunately lost, and we are angry about it and rightfully so. But have we ever recalled that; it was the Indian army (under British command) who fought the Chinese for British empire in Opium War, where the Chinese were defeated and Hon-Kong was captured and handover to British for centuries, It was Indian traders under British rule who flooded the Chinese market with drugs and Opium (against the Chinese will) making them a hell of a drug addict society. Chinese consider those days under western colonization as humiliation, just like India took the 1962 war defeat as humiliation. India is not happy that China support Pakistan, Likewise China is not happy that India is hosting Dalia Lama's government in exile in India and flirting Tibet issue. See, the thing is; we both (India-China) have disagreement and had done things in the past that we do not not like, but even then, neither India nor China had invaded and colonized each other like the western imperialist did. Despite the difference and fight, there was no looting, slaughtering and enslaving the whole population like the west did to India/China for centuries.
Our difference are manageable. Many of our conflicts can be resolved. But mind you, WESTERN world won't let that happen very easily for obvious reason stated above. Today, China wants to get back their rightful place in the world and heal their past humiliation, but I'm not sure if India is aspiring to get back its glorious past and correct the past humiliation inflicted by the colonial west. As long as our Indian minds are still colonized with western ideology and biased worldviews, it'll take much longer time for India to be truly independent of western hegemonic influence.
I also don't agree with him saying every young Indian hate China because of the recent events, and because they are different and they can never be like us. I mean, come on, Dr. Samir, that's a very shallow and childish way of putting things into perspectives. I do not expect such a narrow view from a prominent figure like you. It's true Indians are apprehensive about our relation with China due to the recent events, but that does mean we hate Chinese because they are Chinese and are different from us. Not all Indians are that narrow minded. It's like the West tell everyone in the world that 'Either you are with us or against us'. India has openly reject such shallow idea from the West, and here you are talking and judging like the west, though in a different context.
The real threat to world peace, progress and prosperity is the West led by US. Look back to the past centuries, the sufferings, the wars , the chaos etc. and you'll know the reason why?
The only thing childish here is your reply based solely on emotions. You clearly don't understand the concept of regional hegemony. India in itself wants a multipolar world but china will try everything to stop India growing economically to maintain its hegemony in Asia. That is the sole purpose of BRI. With BRI and string of pearls china is trying to create its hegemony through both land and ocean routes. Working with china means becoming it's vassal state. Grow up kid don't fall for Chinese propoganda.
Well said.
Sammer raised a simple point, I'll repeat it and you try to implement that.
Make a placard criticizing Xi, try to showcase that in Beijing and you will know the nature of evil China state is. Everything else can be debated later.
Kolvicz D. Well said. Great respect for you. Sadly, as you mentioned, it is the so-called experts like Dr. Samic that influence Indians to hate China. There are so similarities among China and India, and both of them are a superpower in their own ways. If China and India can work together, the whole Asia will rise and prosper. That's what the west don't want.
@@pragyanshsingh6093 I get it, If I were to choose between democracy and autocracy/communist, I will 100% choose democracy any day. I was born and brought up in a democratic setup & environment that I believed is best for me and my country. Likewise Chinese people believed in their own system and it works for them despite many flaws and limitations it has. I really think this democracy vs Chinese communist system and which ideology should rule the world is bullsh*t and waste of time. We should only be worried if China is actively working to export their communist system to other countries forcefully like USA usually do using agencies like NED and CIA, along with sanctions and military might, and toppling foreign government and installing their own puppet government. So far we haven't seen any such ill intention from China for ideological supremacy outside of their own country, as opposed to the west. So, my point is "Live and Let live". If they are happy and content with their own system and if it works for them (though not perfect), then who are we to judge or worry about their business as long as they don't try to force their system on us. You and I cannot expect everyone on earth to think and behave like us. Only some ignorant Americans thinks they are the whole world and expect everyone else to be like them or else they are enemy/adversaries.!! Indian should be better than that. India embraced and hold pride in the diversity of our country. Let us keep that same broad view even to the outside world.
Unfortunately, the indians used to call the occupier of their country Sahib or my Sir which has never happened in the history of humanity, that was pure humiliation to India which once was a magnificent cultural and financial power. I hope India is not going to be used and fooled again by colonial Masters, the future belongs to Asia, including India. The enemy wants to divide and conquer
Tell that to China, who's using America's strategy of destabilizing neighbors countries so that they can't challenge them in future..
It's crazy how people still don't understand the debt trap after seeing what Sri Lanka and Pakistan is going through...
If you look at 2014 videos of Indian Modi govt after winning, you'll see modi govt was closer to putin and Xi(China even became no 1 trade partner of India putting US at 2)until India refused BRI(which would have destroyed Indian manufacturing sector) ... Chinese showed aggression and decades of peace on border was broken..
Xi was fully responsible...
@@THUGPUTIN Europe got rich because of colonising India, India has huge potential, for India is now or never, the Western powers want War between China and India, they would rather use India as a tool to control China, same as what they are doing with Ukraine, of course, Modi knows that the Western powers milked India and squeezed them out of everything, a wise person should think why suddenly they decided to use India against China. India should learn from China, the Chinese were humiliated even worse than the indians during the colonial period, but they learned to be independent and strong, and their development is magical. India should know that the world is shifting and that India is going to be one of the superpowers in a multi-polar world, however, the enemies of India will try to create turmoil between India and its neighbours. Indians should be aware of the manipulation.
The debt trap is also more relevant to IMF and western banking financial systems.
@@kevins4936 well said and I conquer - especially after reading about Bhagat Singhs life...
Australia? No 1 Lapdog of US
“Rule based order “ now means lie based order.
Oh we thought Quad is not about countering China under the order of the U.S.? Lol
samir sir just makes me so excited to listen him oooh man its sooo much exciting he is so specific and to the point it hits the point
The US representative was no match with the Indian counterpart. Some more intelligent person would have made the discussion more interesting.
They weren't debating each other.
@@antr7493 Forget debating , ,she wasn't even speaking !!
She was a damn anti trump nitwit
What is she smoking- Russia is crushing Ukraine and she is lying through her teeth- keep lying lady
She is a totally dishonest speaker
Free Tibet and evrything will fall in plac, as far as China is concerned!
Idiot.. it's not gonna happen..be silent when you don't have enough resources.. that's what China did
I wish she was my therapist. Her voice is so soothing it calm me down
I guess they need to also discuss about New Zealand's closer relationship with China.
The Maoris have taken back control of New Zealand! No more Anglo- Saxon New Zealand!!!
We saw Bangladesh view too, good inputs gathered
AT LAST we hear Samir Saran, an Indian who speaks with common sense
中国希望世界变成多极世界，有越多的大国力量互相均衡，世界越安全，美国再次发动战争的可能性越小。美国也改变了川普的美国第一的策略，也扶持其他国家力量的成长。中美的策略都利于其他国家的发展，甚至是印度，在中国看来，即便中印有矛盾，印度的发展也是利于中国的。
I thought UA-cam was banned in China😂
@Jiggy Lee lol
@@karandoshi8828 he is just stating an opinion. Why are you so butthurt?
I don't know from where you have that thought but it's utter foolish to think that two major powers would love to see a multipolar world..they want a bipolar world at best.. Multipolarism would slow down the events of conflict and squeeze the ways to react by major powers.. that's not gonna work..
Though great respect for China it would be of great difficulty for India to become a swing power
@Pluto Voltaire I think that’s a fake biased IQ study done by Charles Murray and his cronies to get rich by promoting junk science.
Can’t wait for trump to come back and kick out these wokes
The Chinese don't need to purchase any Australian goods if you chosen to be unfriendly toward them, no reason why Australian and the Chinese unable to work together unless Australian government remain chosen be 'Puppies' of U.S.
Proud of you Samir.
She is bonkers on Russian military successes in Ukraine !
11:13 is he joking? Biden doing a good job?
@Amrit Waiba have you forgotten Talwaar ghati incident.
You are right man ..spot on
32:25. I disagree. Putin has already stated they have nothing but time and are in no rush. It’s just these talking heads in the west that say the Russian army sucks. By the way I’m American. You’re welcome
Replace UK with India at the UN Security Council
The world is multipolar.. not unipolar anymore old days..
how refreshing :I:m listening to an American politician who tells it as it is Thank you.
Matter is prestige " is for maintain, whoo dislikes it ? Is egos , meaning what against loosing whatever with man life's firstly, definition of ego" and prestige to prestigious .
The US really needs to make clear what the rules are which make up the "Rules Based Order". For example, the US says China should abide by the United Nations Convention on Law of the Sea but the US itself is one of only two countries that are not signatories to the convention. Similarly, the US says that China should abide by the ruling of the World Court directed arbitration with respect to the dispute between China and the Philippines over the SCS. But the US does not recognise the jurisdiction of the World Court. It's clear then that UNCLOS and the World Court aren't part of the "Rules Based Order". So what is ? For example, what rule allowed the US to invade Iraq based on fabricated evidence of WMD, resulting in the deaths of a million people. Or the invasion of Afghanistan resulting in a quarter of a million deaths. Someone help me: what are the rules ! Then there are the many agreements that the US has reneged on such as the nuclear agreement with Iran, the intermediate range missile agreement etc. I guess these weren't part of the "Rules Based Order" so what is ? Finally, there is the International Criminal Court which the US has blocked from investigating US forces war crimes in Afghanistan. The US issued an executive order effectively criminalizing anyone who works at the ICC. Its lawyers, judges, researchers etc could now have their U.S. bank accounts frozen, U.S. visas revoked and travel to the U.S. denied.
Can I summarise what I think the "Rules Based Order" really is: It means that the US does what it likes and the rest of us do what we are told.
This is taken off the internet. Can't remember who posted the above, but I would like to attribute this to the writer, whoever you are.
Shame
exactly! sadly US, China, Russia, India, Indonesia, are all NOT signatories of the International Criminal Court
@Suraj Upadhyaya Godfathers' law.
USA needs Trump back.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_treaties_unsigned_or_unratified_by_the_United_States. USA is not part of many important treaties like UNCBD, Kyoto protocol, Basel convention… USA has a lot of bs it uses democracy and human rights to topple regimes.. Look at the history of regime change done by USA in Latin America,
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_involvement_in_regime_change
even the torch bearer of democracy supports autocratic governments which are in usa interest… it supported dictators like pinochet, Zia ul Haq, Suharto…
ZTE and Huawei are beyond any match. Other providers are dependent on Huawei. 60 to 70 percent of telecom petent are in ZTE and Huawei's hand. We, Indian, uses ZTE extensively. In Kolkata, BSNL has replaced Ericsson with ZTE and in the whole country, we replaced other by ZTE and Huawei. What we say and what we are doing is deferent. Politically we differ with China but economically we accept Chinese equipments and goods in larger quantities to produce cheaper goods for export and consumptions.
China or India or Us , the trouble makers are politicians
Indians are welcome to pay for high and premium priced goods from China!
What a great reply to that Bangladeshi!
Samir 9/10. Kori 3.5/10
Size of China ? Whoo will decide ? Power or justice ? Existence of "justice" is mortal ?
Practice what they preach. Don't desccriminate. Be responsible and open to change
that is precisely the problem. mind change is the most difficult.
Kosovo was colonised by America, is that international rules based order colonialism.
44:08 the Whites looking at each other be like," Well, Sameer is totally slaying us, y'know... " 🤣🤣🤣
Good ideas to work for World
Samir rocked again
There was discussion in Indian Lokasabha on russia's invasion of Ukrain.
It was in zero hour where no record is maintained of discussion.but, discussions were mde against russia.
Even opposition in india doesn't make any political chaos on Russia Ukraine war
What samir said its true
Sameer brings well articulated clarity to the session.
33:30 she need to wake up.
Russia has not even used 2% of it's soilders 🤣
Everytime I watched Samir… I see a slave trying to fit in with the masters… The first line is “Samir is a energized Bunny”… Poor fool, he’s kissing the rear of the master and tries to be smart… Really nothing new coming from his mouth but jealousy and anger😂
Types of bullying:
44 percent said they were called names.
43 percent said they were teased.
36 percent said a bully spread rumors or lies about them.
32 percent said they were pushed or shoved.
29 percent said they were hit, slapped, or kicked.
29 percent said they were left out.
27 percent said they were threatened.
27 percent said a bully stole their belongings.
24 percent said a bully made sexual comments or gestures.
10 percent said they were bullied online.
How many of your student will come to study.
Turkish propaganda about bayka bayraktar TB2 misled Azerbaijan campaign ; It was Israeli Harop drone that the stared in the show.
32:00
Dr. Samir Saran rocks
Excellent job of quashing the fallacies by the India rep in regards the oil import! What a load of cow dung by the white guy! Utter BS
Talking about India and US, we just have to wait a little longer!
55:10
Politics is confusing. India is with quad, but at the same time its with BRICS wherein China is included
India is a Double Header
When Samir speaks it is clear it can get's
Next FM of India
Thank you for a very informative discussion
Why would any country have to "account" to you crowd who don't even spell out who funds you?
Sameer Sir 🎊
Truly observed that China has lost that ear of a generation of hugely motiivated young Indians by its unbridled greed around the world and especially in India's neighbourhood.
and india lost multiple generation of hugely hardworking chinese via the persistently stagnant Indian political system doing disservice to its population. Disservices particularly in not abolishing the caste system, women equity and sensible economic reforms
@@ruoyuli4091 Caste system has NOTHING to with this. Incidently there is caste system of a sort EVERYWHERE. Secondly a social system does not disappear just by making a law. You can not abolish communist corrupt hierchy just by law. Legally there is NO caste system.
@@ruoyuli4091 China should be kicked out of UN as the so called President of China is never elected by people. CPC came to power using guns, let them win elections where people can vote and then they can reclaim the UN seat.
@@curiouscynic4357 proof is in the current state of india. You can argue all you want, but the chinese model is the one the global south are in awe of, not the india model, India adopted western liberal democracy without consolidating its unity as a country first. the division will persist until india can sorts its own division and put its focus on development.
@@Vikramreddy99 election doesn't produce good leaders automatically. Bush should be in jail
Sameer: my question to you? If you think China practices Censorship how about social media banning Trump? Or Modi’s internet blackout policy in Kashmir?
Europeans are father of colonialism....now that they don't have that same leverage , they're trying Human right violence shit.... look at your own backyard ,you all have destroyed much more any asian ,African combined
Well Pakistan stop sending jihadi into Kashmir we would never had and block out of internet...it wasn't total block out though... Apart from internet the local newspapers and radio channels and TV news was working all the time... internet was blocked to terrorists so that they cannot create unrest...and media was being unfair to trump...
If china is doing it to stop terrorism in china then it's alrighty....but we all know what happens there...
Indians still speak with our worst enemies, China included. Then why would we stop talking to Russia
Kori good lullaby. You put me to sleep.
31:03 expression 😁😁😁😍
21:11 'Pakistan always likes to be in trouble", that's how you go for the jugular vein and give a blow below the belt.... at the same time... great world play.
Talk to people of rest of Asia, Africa South American, to hear what they have to say!
mr biden can barely stand on his feet, shaking hand in air is just nightmare for many democrats atleast allow a physically competent person to be president.
Those countries in the Indo -Pacific Partnership should ask themselves how many of their member are not colonialist's in the past.