SubhanAllah I haven't seen richard for ages! May Allah guide him I still hope he'll become muslim one day he is respectful unlike some eritreans in the park..
Yet another Blogging Theology masterclass. Thank you so much Paul, loads of respect for Richard, such a refined gentleman Say: "O people of the Book! come to common terms as between us and you: that we worship none but Allah; that we associate no partners with Him; that we erect not from among ourselves Lords and patrons other than Allah." Al Imran, 64
50 Contradictions in the Qur'an : 1) Who sends disbelievers astray? Allah [Quran 35:8] Satan [Quran 4:119] 2). Who Was the First Muslim?
Muhammad [6:14, 163],
Moses [7:143],
Some Egyptians [26:51] Abraham [2:127-133, 3:67] Adam [2:37] 3). Can Allah be seen and did Muhammad see his Lord? Yes [S. 53:1-18, 81:15-29] No [6:102-103, 42:51]. 4). Were Warners Sent to All Mankind Before Muhammad? Yes [10:47, 16:35-36, 35:24], Muhammad supposedly is sent to a people who never had a messenger before [28:46, 32:3,
34:44, 36:2-6].
5). What will be the food for the people in Hell?
Dhar [Sura 88:6] Only foul pus from the washing of wounds [S. 69:36] They get to eat from the tree of Zaqqum [S. 37:66] 6). Can muslim a marry to idolturous women? The Qur'an forbids believers to marry idolatrous women [Sura 2:221] Quran calls Christians idolaters and unbelievers [9:28-33] still allows Muslims to marry Christian women [5:5] 7). Will Allah reward the good deeds of Unbelievers? No [S. 9:17 and 9:69] yes. [S. 99:7] 8). Should Muslims show kindness to their parents? the Quran commands all Muslims to show kindness to their parents, even if they are
disbelievers [17:23-24, 31:14-15, 29:8, etc.]. it demands not to show any love or friendship to those who oppose Muhammad, even if
they are their parents [9:23, 58:22].. 9). How many mothers does a Muslim have? Only one [58:2], At least ten [33:6] 10). How many angels were talking to Mary about the announciation of the birth of Jesus? Several angels [Sura 3:42,45] Only one [ Sura 19:17-21] 11). How Many years of Humans does Allah's day equal? 1,000 human years (Sura 22:47, 32:5) 50,000 human years (Sura 70:4) 12). How Many groups of people at the Last Judgement ? 3 groups of people (Sura 56:7) 2 groups of people ( 90:18-19, 99:6-8) 13). who takes the souls at death ? THE Angel of Death (Azrael) [32:11] THE angels (plural) [47:27] Allah [39:42] 14). How Many wings does Angels have ? Angels have 2, 3, or 4 pairs of wings [35:1] Gabriel had 600 wings. [Sahih Bukhari, Volume 4, Book 54, Number 455] Is'nt Gabriel an Angel. 15). How many days did Allah need to destroy the people of Aad? One day [54:19] several days [41:16; 69:6,7] 16). In How Many times Allah created the Heaven and Earth. six days (Sura 7:54, 10:3, 11:7, and 25:59) Eight Days ( 41:9-12 ) 17). Heavens or Earth? Which was created first? First earth and then heaven [2:29] First heaven and then earth [79:27-30]. 18). How process of Heaven and the Earth takes place. first apart and are called to come together [41:11] they were originally one piece and then ripped apart.[ 21:30] 19). What was man created from? A blood clot [96:1-2] water [21:30, 24:45, 25:54] "sounding" (i.e. burned) clay [15:26] dust [3:59, 30:20, 35:11] nothing [19:67] earth [11:61] a drop of thickened fluid [16:4, 75:37] 20). Where is Allah and his throne? Nearer than the jugular vein [50:16] Upon the water [11:7] 21). Does Allah command to do evil? No [7:28, 16:90] Yes [17:16, ] 22). Will there be inquiry in Paradise? No [23:101] Yes [37:27] 23). Who are protectors of Humans Angels [Sura 41:31] NO protector besides Allah [2:107, 29:22] 24). Who is wali. Allah [9:116, 17:111, 32:4, 42:28] Messenger and the believers [5:55, 9:71] 25). Does Allah forgive shirk? No [4:48, 116] Yes [4:153, 25:68-71] 26). Moses and the Injil? Jesus is born more than 1,000 years after Moses Allah speaks to Moses about what is written in the Injil [7:157] 27). Can slander of chaste women be forgiven? Yes [24:5] No [24:23] 28).How do people receive the record on Judgment Day? Behind their back [84:10] In their left hand [69:25] 29). Can angels disobey? No [16:49-50] Iblis Did [2:34] 30). Was Iblis an Angel or a Jinn? Jinn [18:50] Angel [2:34] 31). Who brings the revelation from Allah to Muhammad? Gabriel [2:97] Holy Spirit [16:102] 32). Did Noah and his family was saved from the flood? Yes [Sura 37:77] His Son was'nt [Sura 11:42-43] 33). Was pharoah repented in his face of death ? Yes [Sura 10:90-92] That such a thing was'nt happened [Sura 4:18] 34). Can Anyone change the Word of Allah? No [Sura 6:115 and 6:34 and 10:64] Allah replace it [16:101] 35). What is the punishment for adultery? Flogging with a 100 stripes (men and women) [24:2]
confine them to houses until death do claim them [4:15] 36). Who suffers the punishments of sins? Everyone is responsible for his own sins [S. 17:13-15, 53:38-42] Jews and Christians takes the sins of Muslims [Sahih Muslim 6668] 37). Will Christians enter Paradise? Yes [Sura 2:62 and 5:69] No [3:85] 38). What happened to pharoah when he chasing Moses and Israelites? Saved [10:92] Drowned [28:40, 17:103, 43:55] 39). When Commanded Pharaoh the Killing of the Sons When Moses was a Prophet and spoke God's truth to Pharaoh [40:23-25] When he was still an infant [20:38-39] 40). Wine: Good or bad? Wines are Satan's handiwork. [5:90, also 2:219] rivers of wine in jannah [47:15, also 83:22,25] 41). For Why jinns and Men created? Only to serve God [Sura 51:56] Made for Hell [Sura 7:179]. 42). Will all Muslims go to Hell? No [Sura 3:157-158] Yes [Sura 19:71] 43). Can there be a son without a consort? Allah cannot have a son without a consort [Sura 6:101] Mary can have a son without a consort because that is easy for Allah [Sura 19:21]. 44). Could Allah have a son? No [Sura 6:101] Yes [Sura 39:4] 45). how many are creators of Universe? Allah is "the best of creators" [23:14, 37:125] what does it means ''best of creators''. Are there many creators.
Allah Alone [39:62] 46). Can Muslim marry the wife of his adopted son? Yes [Sura 33:37] it is forbidden to adopt sons [Sura 33:4-5]. 47) Is Allah the only ruler and commander? Yes [Quran 18:26] No [Quran 3:26] 48) Is Allah omniscient? Yes [Quran 49:16] No [Quran 2:155] Allah needs to test you to know 49) Can only Allah see the unseen? Yes [Quran 10:20]
No, Solomon can too [Quran 27:39] 50) Is Allah kind and merciful? Yes [Quran 1:3] No [Quran 4:56] .
@@reijuv6008 every single one of these have been debunked. if you are too lazy to read, then just call into one of the muslim interfaith streams and discuss it.
@@reijuv6008 like i said, take up all your points in a live stream instead of hiding behind a keyboard and vomiting the misinformation you copy pasted from anti-islamic websites.
@@abdullahibnsohail4318 check it for yourself. rather than saying that to me, why don't you refute it yourself rather than depending on others? Even Islamic resource says that earth is FLAT!
I remember this brother from videos on speaker corner, one of the few respectable and honorable debaters. When he exposed godwin when it comes to prophet david forever will be epic :D I remember that
@@braderaku Please believe me that I was just teasing and not putting someone down intentionally. The comment says, "I can see why YOUR smart" but it should be YOU'RE (as in YOU ARE). YOUR vs YOU'RE. And since the "massive collection of books" suggests the reader is smart, not using YOU'RE suggests the opposite. Forgive me if I've offended anyone. I really was just teasing.
An excellent work you have been doing brother Paul ... and i like your quests too .. they are very knowledgable and very respectful ... There is one person in mind i would like you to talk to .. Its Joshua (Josh) from speakers corner (the big black man with the Cap) ... he is very knowledgeable and respectful person with a degree in theology .. i hope it happens soon .. thank you very much for your work and may Allah reward you in this life and the life after Like for Paul to see this suggestion 👍
I like Richard as he is thoughtful, soft spoken, humble, sincere and honest. When ever I see him I think about Speakers Corner with Adnan vs Godwin The question......Was David a prophet? And Richard steps in with the verse. It always puts a smile on my face. G-d bless him and bring him to a greater understanding. Thank you, Paul for another excellent guest.
@@Luffman123 that’s is an honest Christian man , unlike Muslims who never corrected MHijab with his mega blunder ‘Allah prays for the prophet’,applauding him as if he had said the most wonderful thing.
@@Cristina6537its called "shalawat", not praying or not even "dua"... only orientalis will translate it with "pray"... English languange is too easy compare too Arabic
Dear Brother in Christ, I saw a few of your video and it made me sad to learn you left christianity for your teachings are great, interesting and very helpful for all of us ! Thank you so much for it 🙂. I don't know how to reach you but I would like to go with you into some biblical scripture and study them with you to share some opinion, not to convince you but simply to exchange some view points. Thank you and keep serving God my brother 👍
Brother Paul peace upon u, thank u for a wonderful conversation, I would suggest to bring a Muslim scholar to explain the prophecies of prophet Mohammed in the bible if it is there or not historical. So we can learn more. Appreciate ur hard work Sir
Nice discussion. I remember seeing a conversation between Richard and Mohammed Hijab a while ago, he seems to be intelligent and respectful. However, his argument here is a bit confusing. Because he tries to argue that these prophecies "might be about Jesus" and that he "doesnt know". Well, if you dont know, how can you argue that Jesus is prophecied in the Old Testament. He kept saying that some of these passages "might be" referring to Jesus. And that is not a very compelling case. If you dont know for certain that any of these Old Testament prophecies refer to Jesus, or have any good arguments to support those claims, then you're shooting yourself in the foot.
I don't think that being honest and saying "I don't know" is necessarily "shooting yourself in the foot." I'd rather hear such words than listen to a scholar/preacher who thinks "he knows it all." May God guide us ( and me ) into all Truth. PEACE
❤️🧡💛💚🌎💜Sisi sote ni mtu yule yule anayeishi maisha katika miili mingi tofauti. Kila mtu unayekutana naye, ni wewe mwenyewe, unaishi katika mwili mwingine. Unaingiliana na wewe mwenyewe wakati wote. ukishaelewa hili, unaishi kwa umoja.
AS.WR.WB Paul I've just finished watching this episode and I enjoyed it. So thank you for not cutting it up into segments, so I didn't have to chase the rest of it. Great work👍as usual. Jazaakallahu kheyran.
I would like to express my general preference for long conversations and analyses with depth, as opposed to the brief clips that you refer to. The internet is slowly destroying our ability to concentrate! (That would include me, I'm afraid....) And a question for Paul - if I am not mistaken, you granted that Saul of Tarsus had been a Pharisee. But it seems to me that there is so much evidence that casts doubt on that. To name only a few examples: his having served as a henchman for the Sadducees; his (evidently) superficial grasp of Hebrew; the hellenestic bent of his home base. Certainly according to many orthodox Jewish rabbis as well as other scholars, the idea that he would have qualified as a student under Gamaliel is absurd. I may have misunderstood you. But in any case, I wonder if you would comment on this, or even address the question on another episode. Am enjoying your discussions so much and I hope that more people connect with your site. Thank you.
@Richard Appeal to authority is an informal fallacy and it is not a fallacy when the right authority is used in a right context to derive a coherent point.
The reason why the book said that Daniel is dated to the 2nd. 3rd and 4th century is because different parts were written at different times. Chapters 8 onwards were written in around 167 BCE. The other material predates that
Smashed it br Paul. Paul I think it would be great idea if you started a, book club and then we could discuss on a live stream... Just a thought, maybe, possibly🤔🤔🤔
I love the way that these brothers can disagree fundamentally, yet remain respectful and courteous. I suppose this is the difference between discussion in order to understand truth no matter where it comes from, and polemicism in order to win an argument regardless of the truth. 1:45:22 Respect to Richard for his readiness to go away and investigate the grammatical issue at the root of the misunderstanding.
What a remarkably civilized conversation. Wonder what would happen to speakers corner if it went online like this )) Jay Smith and alike would have burnt inside out seeing such civilized conversation
I agree with you. Too much UA-cam and especially real life conversations are filled with bitter debates, hate, lack of compassion for other's feelings/worldviews.
You're making good points about the book of Daniel, Paul. Many scholars believe it was written by an unknown author and that Daniel may not have been a real historical figure. Even my priest said his prophecies were written by someone else. This is why I am going through a faith crisis right now.
That may be because of accuracy of prophesies in the book of Daniel. Since many prophesies written in the book came true, the book must have been written later. False reasoning. What about prophesies of Isaiah? Is the book of Isaiah also written by an unknown author, and Isaiah never existed? How many prophets can one discredit to discredit the whole Bible. Almost all of them, starting with Moses... Some people often accuse others of "hate" and "disrespect" toward Islamic scriptures and prophet, while they themselves discredit Biblical scriptures and prophets, and see no problem doing so as a "totally justified intellectual" process nothing to do with hate or disrespect, trying anything and everything to rationalize and find any valid reason why their religion exists.
Hello there Paul, Hope you are having a great day. I was wondering if you have any content on Law vs Grace? I have been told that with grace the law is not longer applicable like dietary law. Thanks
@@BloggingTheology Yes indeed however the response I got was that was before the cross and after the cross these are no longer applicable but again in Acts we see the disciples still upholding the law Thanks for the response though will try to learn more about it. Really like that you introduced me to Bart Ehrman
@@Adam-oz1vm Yes indeed. James the head of the Jerusalem Church (and brother of Jesus) was a Torah observant Jew all his life. If his brother had abolished the law it makes James's position impossible to understand.
❤️🧡💛💚💙💜 ¡Somos todos la misma persona viviendo la vida en un montón de cuerpos diferentes, lo que significa que cada persona que conoces es realmente TÚ viviendo en otro cuerpo! Verás, estás interactuando con TI MISMO en todo momento y una vez que te des cuenta de esto puedes lograr UNIDAD✨🙏✨
I’ve got a question if you can do a video on it. I was wondering how did the church manage to get all the Bible manuscripts especially since the letters of Paul were distributed around how did they manage to collect everything and loose it all at the same time ?
I think Paul's letters, which made it into the New Testament, originate with Marcion, who created a prototype New Testament (an edited version of the Gospel according to Luke and Paul's letters) around 130CE. I hope that helps.
❤️🧡💛💚💙💜 We zijn allemaal dezelfde persoon die het leven ervaart in een heleboel verschillende lichamen, wat betekent dat elke persoon die je ontmoet, echt JIJ bent die in een ander lichaam leeft !!! Zie je, je hebt te allen tijde interactie met JEZELF en als je je dit eenmaal realiseert, kun je EENHEID bereiken
Very interesting and engaging discussion, i loved it! I watched all of it to the end with 2x speed (i do that with most videos on YT). It's good to upload full contents of the discussion, some people appreciate that. Of course you can choose to take parts of it and make small clips of it. Both work fine. 2:43:25 I like what you said here. It's hard to not see it as the word of God. Something about the text compels me to believe it's from on high. I would very much like to see a discussion someday between you and possibly Richard or anyone really, about the Quran. You can discuss anything about it and i'll watch it.
❤️🧡💛💚💙💜 We are all the same person experiencing life in a bunch of different bodies which means that every person that you meet is really YOU living in another body!!! You see, you are interacting with YOURSELF at all times and once you realize this you can achieve UNITY✨🙏✨
❤️🧡💛💚💙💜Pek çok farklı bedende hepimiz aynı kişiyiz, bu da tanıştığınız kişinin farklı bir bedende kendinizin olacağı anlamına gelir !!! Her zaman KENDİNİZ ile etkileşim halindesiniz ve bunu, dünyayı ve kendinizin tüm farklı versiyonlarını anladığınızı sevgiyle görüyorsunuz.
❤️🧡💛💚💙💜 نحن جميعًا نفس الشخص الذي نعيش الحياة في مجموعة من الأجسام المختلفة مما يعني أن كل شخص تقابله هو حقًا أنت تعيش في جسد آخر !!! كما ترى ، أنت تتفاعل مع نفسك في جميع الأوقات ، وبمجرد أن تدرك ذلك ، يمكنك تحقيق الوحدة ✨🙏✨
❤️🧡💛💚💙💜 כולנו אותו אדם שחווה את החיים בחבורה של גופים שונים מה שאומר שכל אדם שאתה פוגש הוא באמת אתה חי בגוף אחר !!! מה שאני מנסה לומר זה שאתה מתקשר עם עצמך כל הזמן וברגע שאתה מבין שאתה יכול להשיג אחדות✨🙏✨
According to Rabbi Mort of Mahi Ministries (on You tube) he tried to show the lineage of Mohammed (Pbuh) went through the line of David’s (Pbuh) sister.
If Book of Daniel is fictional, what is the point to argue about, we don't trying to apply law of gravity to Santa flying over houses on the Christmas day.
I thank Allah and then to Bro Paul Williams; it is a piece of very significant information for me that the Book of Daniel is actually considered as non-historical writing according to 99.9% of Bible Scholars. I always hear Christians citing Daniels to prove the prophecy for the New Testament version of Jesus.
The quran refers to the prophet Isa not the christian Jesus.The mistake came about with translating from Greek.Isa who was the son of Mary/Maryam has nothing in common with the Gospel Jesus who was Jeshu or Yeshua,their different historical identities became confused,"they were taken by similarity. One 'similarity'is the fact that Jeshu and Isa,which are entirely different names in their original Aramaic,can both be Iesous for Jesus,in Greek translation.from the book'conspiracy in Jerusalem by Kamal Salibi.
💜💙💚💛🧡❤️мы все один и тот же человек, живущий в кучке разных тел. Это означает, что каждый человек, которого вы встречаете, на самом деле ВЫ, живущий в другом теле.
لا يجوز ذكر رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم بدون الصلاة عليه any Muslim shouldn't say the prophet name without saying PBUH it's to give respect and part of Suna!
I found out that the Catholic and other churches taught that Jesus went to hell to save adam, eve and those prior to him after he’s crucified. Its called the Harrowing of Hell. Can you comment on this? Kinda made me think of Israk Mikraj on some parts
I really like this channel because unlike most religious channels (muslim or christian), you have a solid udnerstanding of both religions and their scripture.
I can't imagine him not being in paradise with the Mercy of God. He is used to a high level of studies in terms of academics, pretty sure he's educated at Oxford and just needs to come in contact with someone who is compatible and coming from the field of the Islamic sciences. He is true to what is true, and that only leads him to follow the trail of evidence. He would admit if he encountered a good enough reason from Islam to become Muslim, perhaps he can sense that there is and is actually building a strong foundation to stand on before he transitions. Either way whatever religion he is, everyone loves him!
Hearing christians, and i was one since a child (left it October 2020(thanks God for this pandemic and all the time it gave me to see this)), is very exhausting... They keep making turns and turns and turns...
Always found Richard to be polite and sincere. May Allah give him hidayat.
Ameen,indeed he is very respectable, I have watched many videos of him on Speakers Corner.
Ameen.
Suffering servant is not God ... God cannot be suffering servant ... good work bro Paul👌🏼👍
Greetings to both of you guys and especially to Mr Paul Williams.
Greetings A.A,
SubhanAllah I haven't seen richard for ages! May Allah guide him I still hope he'll become muslim one day he is respectful unlike some eritreans in the park..
Ameen
Eritreans? I think you mean Christians? 😂 Just checking as to not annoy our Eritrean Muslim brothers
We all respect richard, a wonderful fellow !
Richard, The most humble christian person in SC
Yet another Blogging Theology masterclass. Thank you so much Paul, loads of respect for Richard, such a refined gentleman
Say: "O people of the Book! come to common terms as between us and you: that we worship none but Allah; that we associate no partners with Him; that we erect not from among ourselves Lords and patrons other than Allah." Al Imran, 64
Nice!
@@BloggingTheology 🙏🤲
Richard might become the future Paul Williams. always liked him.
50 Contradictions in the Qur'an :
1) Who sends disbelievers astray?
Allah [Quran 35:8]
Satan [Quran 4:119]
2). Who Was the First Muslim?
Muhammad [6:14, 163],
Moses [7:143],
Some Egyptians [26:51]
Abraham [2:127-133, 3:67]
Adam [2:37]
3). Can Allah be seen and did Muhammad see his Lord?
Yes [S. 53:1-18, 81:15-29]
No [6:102-103, 42:51].
4). Were Warners Sent to All Mankind Before Muhammad?
Yes [10:47, 16:35-36, 35:24],
Muhammad supposedly is sent to a people who never had a messenger before [28:46, 32:3,
34:44, 36:2-6].
5). What will be the food for the people in Hell?
Dhar [Sura 88:6]
Only foul pus from the washing of wounds [S. 69:36]
They get to eat from the tree of Zaqqum [S. 37:66]
6). Can muslim a marry to idolturous women?
The Qur'an forbids believers to marry idolatrous women [Sura 2:221]
Quran calls Christians idolaters and unbelievers [9:28-33]
still allows Muslims to marry Christian women [5:5]
7). Will Allah reward the good deeds of Unbelievers?
No [S. 9:17 and 9:69]
yes. [S. 99:7]
8). Should Muslims show kindness to their parents?
the Quran commands all Muslims to show kindness to their parents, even if they are
disbelievers [17:23-24, 31:14-15, 29:8, etc.].
it demands not to show any love or friendship to those who oppose Muhammad, even if
they are their parents [9:23, 58:22]..
9). How many mothers does a Muslim have?
Only one [58:2],
At least ten [33:6]
10). How many angels were talking to Mary about the announciation of the birth of Jesus?
Several angels [Sura 3:42,45]
Only one [ Sura 19:17-21]
11). How Many years of Humans does Allah's day equal?
1,000 human years (Sura 22:47, 32:5)
50,000 human years (Sura 70:4)
12). How Many groups of people at the Last Judgement ?
3 groups of people (Sura 56:7)
2 groups of people ( 90:18-19, 99:6-8)
13). who takes the souls at death ?
THE Angel of Death (Azrael) [32:11]
THE angels (plural) [47:27]
Allah [39:42]
14). How Many wings does Angels have ?
Angels have 2, 3, or 4 pairs of wings [35:1]
Gabriel had 600 wings. [Sahih Bukhari, Volume 4, Book 54, Number 455]
Is'nt Gabriel an Angel.
15). How many days did Allah need to destroy the people of Aad?
One day [54:19]
several days [41:16; 69:6,7]
16). In How Many times Allah created the Heaven and Earth.
six days (Sura 7:54, 10:3, 11:7, and 25:59)
Eight Days ( 41:9-12 )
17). Heavens or Earth? Which was created first?
First earth and then heaven [2:29]
First heaven and then earth [79:27-30].
18). How process of Heaven and the Earth takes place.
first apart and are called to come together [41:11]
they were originally one piece and then ripped apart.[ 21:30]
19). What was man created from?
A blood clot [96:1-2]
water [21:30, 24:45, 25:54]
"sounding" (i.e. burned) clay [15:26]
dust [3:59, 30:20, 35:11]
nothing [19:67]
earth [11:61]
a drop of thickened fluid [16:4, 75:37]
20). Where is Allah and his throne?
Nearer than the jugular vein [50:16]
Upon the water [11:7]
21). Does Allah command to do evil?
No [7:28, 16:90]
Yes [17:16, ]
22). Will there be inquiry in Paradise?
No [23:101]
Yes [37:27]
23). Who are protectors of Humans
Angels [Sura 41:31]
NO protector besides Allah [2:107, 29:22]
24). Who is wali.
Allah [9:116, 17:111, 32:4, 42:28]
Messenger and the believers [5:55, 9:71]
25). Does Allah forgive shirk?
No [4:48, 116]
Yes [4:153, 25:68-71]
26). Moses and the Injil?
Jesus is born more than 1,000 years after Moses
Allah speaks to Moses about what is written in the Injil [7:157]
27). Can slander of chaste women be forgiven?
Yes [24:5]
No [24:23]
28).How do people receive the record on Judgment Day?
Behind their back [84:10]
In their left hand [69:25]
29). Can angels disobey?
No [16:49-50]
Iblis Did [2:34]
30). Was Iblis an Angel or a Jinn?
Jinn [18:50]
Angel [2:34]
31). Who brings the revelation from Allah to Muhammad?
Gabriel [2:97]
Holy Spirit [16:102]
32). Did Noah and his family was saved from the flood?
Yes [Sura 37:77]
His Son was'nt [Sura 11:42-43]
33). Was pharoah repented in his face of death ?
Yes [Sura 10:90-92]
That such a thing was'nt happened [Sura 4:18]
34). Can Anyone change the Word of Allah?
No [Sura 6:115 and 6:34 and 10:64]
Allah replace it [16:101]
35). What is the punishment for adultery?
Flogging with a 100 stripes (men and women) [24:2]
confine them to houses until death do claim them [4:15]
36). Who suffers the punishments of sins?
Everyone is responsible for his own sins [S. 17:13-15, 53:38-42]
Jews and Christians takes the sins of Muslims [Sahih Muslim 6668]
37). Will Christians enter Paradise?
Yes [Sura 2:62 and 5:69]
No [3:85]
38). What happened to pharoah when he chasing Moses and Israelites?
Saved [10:92]
Drowned [28:40, 17:103, 43:55]
39). When Commanded Pharaoh the Killing of the Sons
When Moses was a Prophet and spoke God's truth to Pharaoh [40:23-25]
When he was still an infant [20:38-39]
40). Wine: Good or bad?
Wines are Satan's handiwork. [5:90, also 2:219]
rivers of wine in jannah [47:15, also 83:22,25]
41). For Why jinns and Men created?
Only to serve God [Sura 51:56]
Made for Hell [Sura 7:179].
42). Will all Muslims go to Hell?
No [Sura 3:157-158]
Yes [Sura 19:71]
43). Can there be a son without a consort?
Allah cannot have a son without a consort [Sura 6:101]
Mary can have a son without a consort because that is easy for Allah [Sura 19:21].
44). Could Allah have a son?
No [Sura 6:101]
Yes [Sura 39:4]
45). how many are creators of Universe?
Allah is "the best of creators" [23:14, 37:125] what does it means ''best of creators''.
Are there many creators.
Allah Alone [39:62]
46). Can Muslim marry the wife of his adopted son?
Yes [Sura 33:37]
it is forbidden to adopt sons [Sura 33:4-5].
47) Is Allah the only ruler and commander?
Yes [Quran 18:26]
No [Quran 3:26]
48) Is Allah omniscient?
Yes [Quran 49:16]
No [Quran 2:155] Allah needs to test you to know
49) Can only Allah see the unseen?
Yes [Quran 10:20]
No, Solomon can too [Quran 27:39]
50) Is Allah kind and merciful?
Yes [Quran 1:3]
No [Quran 4:56]
.
@@reijuv6008 every single one of these have been debunked. if you are too lazy to read, then just call into one of the muslim interfaith streams and discuss it.
@@abdullahibnsohail4318 haha debunk?
or they twist allah clear words by
MIRACLE OF RE-INTERPRETATION?
@@reijuv6008 like i said, take up all your points in a live stream instead of hiding behind a keyboard and vomiting the misinformation you copy pasted from anti-islamic websites.
@@abdullahibnsohail4318 check it for yourself.
rather than saying that to me, why don't
you refute it yourself rather than depending on others?
Even Islamic resource says
that earth is FLAT!
I remember this brother from videos on speaker corner, one of the few respectable and honorable debaters. When he exposed godwin when it comes to prophet david forever will be epic :D I remember that
A great moment in Speakers' Corner history!
Amazing work brother Paul. Much love from South Africa.
After having that massive book collection of yours, i can see why your so smart
I'm going out on a limb here, but I'm guessing you don't see the irony in *you're* comment?
@@thewallcometh1444 I know this will make me sound less smart but can you explain the irony in that comment?
@@braderaku
Please believe me that I was just teasing and not putting someone down intentionally. The comment says, "I can see why YOUR smart" but it should be YOU'RE (as in YOU ARE).
YOUR vs YOU'RE.
And since the "massive collection of books" suggests the reader is smart, not using YOU'RE suggests the opposite.
Forgive me if I've offended anyone. I really was just teasing.
@@thewallcometh1444 I wasn't offended at all. No worries. I guess it just came out like that through writing.
@@braderaku
Thank you, brother. 💛
Am a simple man , I see a video from paul i click like
do you also smooch stones too?
Isn’t he the guy in SC who proved David(PBUH) was a Prophet written in the Bible? Adnan Rashid was there too
Ohh I remembered him! Nice guy!
A great moment in Speakers' Corner history!
@@BloggingTheology Glorious indeed 💕
Ohh i just remember after this comment!
😂😂
As you mentioned it, i recalled that honest attitude.
An excellent work you have been doing brother Paul ... and i like your quests too .. they are very knowledgable and very respectful ...
There is one person in mind i would like you to talk to ..
Its Joshua (Josh) from speakers corner (the big black man with the Cap) ... he is very knowledgeable and respectful person with a degree in theology .. i hope it happens soon .. thank you very much for your work and may Allah reward you in this life and the life after
Like for Paul to see this suggestion 👍
استمتعت كثيرا بالحوار المحترم الهادف 👏
ريتشارد من أكثر المسيحيين احتراماً و صدقاً 💗
انتا من وين
@@rainman7769 انا بنت .. من مصر
I like Richard as he is thoughtful, soft spoken, humble, sincere and honest. When ever I see him I think about Speakers Corner with Adnan vs Godwin The question......Was David a prophet? And Richard steps in with the verse. It always puts a smile on my face. G-d bless him and bring him to a greater understanding. Thank you, Paul for another excellent guest.
Merci beaucoup pour ce partage et ce professionalisme. Un échange de qualité. Hâte de voir la suite de vos travaux et les futurs invités 👍❤️
Merci!
No, please do not chop the videos, I beg of you. This was an absolutely amazing video, thank you.
May ALLAH guide & bless Brother Richard in Islam . In Shaa ALLAH . Love you Brother Paul for the sake of ALLAH.
Ameen
Richard famous for being the guy who pointed out that David was a prophet
hahaha... now, i remember him, thanks mate
@@Luffman123
that’s is an honest Christian man , unlike Muslims who never corrected MHijab with his mega blunder ‘Allah prays for the prophet’,applauding him as if he had said the most wonderful thing.
@@Cristina6537its called "shalawat", not praying or not even "dua"... only orientalis will translate it with "pray"... English languange is too easy compare too Arabic
Assalam o Alaikum brother paul
ALLAH bless you
Salam Ahmad.
I like this approach to you speaking with people as apposed to speakers corner. Keep it up, and thank you for the video.
Thanks, will do!
Dear Brother in Christ, I saw a few of your video and it made me sad to learn you left christianity for your teachings are great, interesting and very helpful for all of us ! Thank you so much for it 🙂. I don't know how to reach you but I would like to go with you into some biblical scripture and study them with you to share some opinion, not to convince you but simply to exchange some view points. Thank you and keep serving God my brother 👍
This guy left Christianity?
Hey Richard, good to see you are healthy. can't wait to see this... Well done brother Paul that you got this man on your show.. Peace!
Alhamduillah we have brothers from christian backgrounds defending Islam. Some brothers try but it's not their field per se.
@Reshma Akthar yes, but he has a Christian background. He was raised christian/catholic. But he reverted to Islam
@Reshma Akthar oh 😂 I was referring to the general masses of muslim reverts who were christian who defend islam.
@@abuabbas3695 so is he reverted to islam?
@@saeedahmed1177 yes
@@abuabbas3695 are you sure Richard is reverted to islam?
Brother Paul peace upon u, thank u for a wonderful conversation, I would suggest to bring a Muslim scholar to explain the prophecies of prophet Mohammed in the bible if it is there or not historical. So we can learn more. Appreciate ur hard work Sir
Great. I'm one of the three people that made it to the end
well done! Even I didn't make it - I used a stunt double
@@BloggingTheology I wonder who the other two lucky ppl are
@@BloggingTheology also watched to the end
@@Sulaiman.galant you deserve a medal!!
Nice discussion. I remember seeing a conversation between Richard and Mohammed Hijab a while ago, he seems to be intelligent and respectful. However, his argument here is a bit confusing. Because he tries to argue that these prophecies "might be about Jesus" and that he "doesnt know". Well, if you dont know, how can you argue that Jesus is prophecied in the Old Testament. He kept saying that some of these passages "might be" referring to Jesus. And that is not a very compelling case. If you dont know for certain that any of these Old Testament prophecies refer to Jesus, or have any good arguments to support those claims, then you're shooting yourself in the foot.
I don't think that being honest and saying "I don't know" is necessarily "shooting yourself in the foot." I'd rather hear such words than listen to a scholar/preacher who thinks "he knows it all." May God guide us ( and me ) into all Truth. PEACE
Richard is the one who proved David is a prophet from the Bible...
Yes, he got a lot of hassle from the Christians for being truthful about that.
@@BloggingTheology He looks very sincere and honest..
No no Paul.. Chopping up is the worst! This long format is the way to go!!
Whenever verses were quoted from the bible, question remain are they really comes from God.
❤️🧡💛💚🌎💜Sisi sote ni mtu yule yule anayeishi maisha katika miili mingi tofauti. Kila mtu unayekutana naye, ni wewe mwenyewe, unaishi katika mwili mwingine. Unaingiliana na wewe mwenyewe wakati wote. ukishaelewa hili, unaishi kwa umoja.
AS.WR.WB Paul
I've just finished watching this episode and I enjoyed it. So thank you for not cutting it up into segments, so I didn't have to chase the rest of it.
Great work👍as usual.
Jazaakallahu kheyran.
Glad you enjoyed it!
Every prophet was reduced, tortured and humiliated by the people they were sent to not just Jesus. Every prophet were suffering servants of God .
I would like to express my general preference for long conversations and analyses with depth, as opposed to the brief clips that you refer to. The internet is slowly destroying our ability to concentrate! (That would include me, I'm afraid....)
And a question for Paul - if I am not mistaken, you granted that Saul of Tarsus had been a Pharisee. But it seems to me that there is so much evidence that casts doubt on that. To name only a few examples: his having served as a henchman for the Sadducees; his (evidently) superficial grasp of Hebrew; the hellenestic bent of his home base. Certainly according to many orthodox Jewish rabbis as well as other scholars, the idea that he would have qualified as a student under Gamaliel is absurd. I may have misunderstood you. But in any case, I wonder if you would comment on this, or even address the question on another episode. Am enjoying your discussions so much and I hope that more people connect with your site. Thank you.
@Richard
Appeal to authority is an informal fallacy and it is not a fallacy when the right authority is used in a right context to derive a coherent point.
For the record, I thought you guys were at least as exciting as the cinema. Thank you both very much.
The reason why the book said that Daniel is dated to the 2nd. 3rd and 4th century is because different parts were written at different times. Chapters 8 onwards were written in around 167 BCE. The other material predates that
Thank you again for your content. Have a nice day insha'Allah
Smashed it br Paul. Paul I think it would be great idea if you started a, book club and then we could discuss on a live stream... Just a thought, maybe, possibly🤔🤔🤔
nice idea!
I love the way that these brothers can disagree fundamentally, yet remain respectful and courteous. I suppose this is the difference between discussion in order to understand truth no matter where it comes from, and polemicism in order to win an argument regardless of the truth.
1:45:22 Respect to Richard for his readiness to go away and investigate the grammatical issue at the root of the misunderstanding.
The Jewish leaders in the first century were the only ones able to judge whether Jesus was the promise king
What a remarkably civilized conversation. Wonder what would happen to speakers corner if it went online like this )) Jay Smith and alike would have burnt inside out seeing such civilized conversation
I agree with you. Too much UA-cam and especially real life conversations are filled with bitter debates, hate, lack of compassion for other's feelings/worldviews.
You're making good points about the book of Daniel, Paul. Many scholars believe it was written by an unknown author and that Daniel may not have been a real historical figure.
Even my priest said his prophecies were written by someone else.
This is why I am going through a faith crisis right now.
That may be because of accuracy of prophesies in the book of Daniel. Since many prophesies written in the book came true, the book must have been written later. False reasoning.
What about prophesies of Isaiah? Is the book of Isaiah also written by an unknown author, and Isaiah never existed? How many prophets can one discredit to discredit the whole Bible. Almost all of them, starting with Moses...
Some people often accuse others of "hate" and "disrespect" toward Islamic scriptures and prophet, while they themselves discredit Biblical scriptures and prophets, and see no problem doing so as a "totally justified intellectual" process nothing to do with hate or disrespect, trying anything and everything to rationalize and find any valid reason why their religion exists.
The wisdom and knowledge is amazing, I enjoyed every minute.
Glad you enjoyed it!
Hello there Paul,
Hope you are having a great day. I was wondering if you have any content on Law vs Grace?
I have been told that with grace the law is not longer applicable like dietary law.
Thanks
According to the gospel of Matthew Jesus upheld the Law, including the food laws.
@@BloggingTheology Yes indeed however the response I got was that was before the cross and after the cross these are no longer applicable but again in Acts we see the disciples still upholding the law
Thanks for the response though will try to learn more about it. Really like that you introduced me to Bart Ehrman
@@Adam-oz1vm Yes indeed. James the head of the Jerusalem Church (and brother of Jesus) was a Torah observant Jew all his life. If his brother had abolished the law it makes James's position impossible to understand.
I love the way brother Paul debates MashAllah
❤️🧡💛💚💙💜 ¡Somos todos la misma persona viviendo la vida en un montón de cuerpos diferentes, lo que significa que cada persona que conoces es realmente TÚ viviendo en otro cuerpo! Verás, estás interactuando con TI MISMO en todo momento y una vez que te des cuenta de esto puedes lograr UNIDAD✨🙏✨
Danke Bruder Paul.
Ist er deutscher ?
I’ve got a question if you can do a video on it. I was wondering how did the church manage to get all the Bible manuscripts especially since the letters of Paul were distributed around how did they manage to collect everything and loose it all at the same time ?
I think Paul's letters, which made it into the New Testament, originate with Marcion, who created a prototype New Testament (an edited version of the Gospel according to Luke and Paul's letters) around 130CE.
I hope that helps.
Paul please upload subtitles.
❤️🧡💛💚💙💜 We zijn allemaal dezelfde persoon die het leven ervaart in een heleboel verschillende lichamen, wat betekent dat elke persoon die je ontmoet, echt JIJ bent die in een ander lichaam leeft !!! Zie je, je hebt te allen tijde interactie met JEZELF en als je je dit eenmaal realiseert, kun je EENHEID bereiken
Very interesting and engaging discussion, i loved it! I watched all of it to the end with 2x speed (i do that with most videos on YT). It's good to upload full contents of the discussion, some people appreciate that. Of course you can choose to take parts of it and make small clips of it. Both work fine.
2:43:25 I like what you said here. It's hard to not see it as the word of God. Something about the text compels me to believe it's from on high. I would very much like to see a discussion someday between you and possibly Richard or anyone really, about the Quran. You can discuss anything about it and i'll watch it.
❤️🧡💛💚💙💜 We are all the same person experiencing life in a bunch of different bodies which means that every person that you meet is really YOU living in another body!!! You see, you are interacting with YOURSELF at all times and once you realize this you can achieve UNITY✨🙏✨
Are the rapists and murders also us?
Ma'sha'Allah a beautiful and well mannered vlog. May God bless you both for this fantastic vlog. Very informative and excellent indeed
Stay blessed 🙏
Thank you so much 😊
❤️🧡💛💚💙💜Twese turi umuntu umwe uba mumibiri itandukanye. Urabona, urimo gusabana nawe wenyine mugihe uganira nabandi. verisiyo idasanzwe nubunararibonye butandukanye mubuzima ariko imbere ntabwo dutandukanye. twarazimiye kuko dushakisha urukundo ahantu hatandukanye mugihe ahantu ho gusanga uru rukundo ari muri bose. Nizere ko ubona mumaso yabandi, roho yawe iri imbere.
"Presuppositions are absolutely crucial..." I agree 100%
❤️🧡💛💚💙💜Pek çok farklı bedende hepimiz aynı kişiyiz, bu da tanıştığınız kişinin farklı bir bedende kendinizin olacağı anlamına gelir !!! Her zaman KENDİNİZ ile etkileşim halindesiniz ve bunu, dünyayı ve kendinizin tüm farklı versiyonlarını anladığınızı sevgiyle görüyorsunuz.
I need Richard channel information do anyone know anything about ?
It is always hard to listen to Richard tone of voice compared with Paul. Sorry but that's just me
Ur posts r getting more and more interesting day by day...many thanks
The great deception of forcing Jesus everywhere even in place of his God
When you have an idea in your head, you never let go. I think you pushed your interlocutor to the limit.
How on earth is this guy trying to get away with saying Daniel is fictional...
It's a shame there is only one like allowed on this feed .. excellent discussion ..
❤️🧡💛💚💙💜 نحن جميعًا نفس الشخص الذي نعيش الحياة في مجموعة من الأجسام المختلفة مما يعني أن كل شخص تقابله هو حقًا أنت تعيش في جسد آخر !!! كما ترى ، أنت تتفاعل مع نفسك في جميع الأوقات ، وبمجرد أن تدرك ذلك ، يمكنك تحقيق الوحدة ✨🙏✨
❤️🧡💛💚💙💜 כולנו אותו אדם שחווה את החיים בחבורה של גופים שונים מה שאומר שכל אדם שאתה פוגש הוא באמת אתה חי בגוף אחר !!! מה שאני מנסה לומר זה שאתה מתקשר עם עצמך כל הזמן וברגע שאתה מבין שאתה יכול להשיג אחדות✨🙏✨
What's that supposed to be?
According to Rabbi Mort of Mahi Ministries (on You tube) he tried to show the lineage of Mohammed (Pbuh) went through the line of David’s (Pbuh) sister.
Mohammed was a descendant of Kedar, one of the sons of Ishmael.
Wow, you uploaded again
Please reduce the ads
richard so polite as always.... i always happy to watch him debate with muslim. may allah guide and bless all of us
If Book of Daniel is fictional, what is the point to argue about, we don't trying to apply law of gravity to Santa flying over houses on the Christmas day.
I thank Allah and then to Bro Paul Williams; it is a piece of very significant information for me that the Book of Daniel is actually considered as non-historical writing according to 99.9% of Bible Scholars. I always hear Christians citing Daniels to prove the prophecy for the New Testament version of Jesus.
Hey @Blogging Theology what religion do you follow
Islam the religion of the all Prophets
@@rashedahmed1562 I agree
@@rashedahmed1562 where and when does he say that? Jzk
Check out old youtube video of Br Paul at the speaker's corner where he told his audiences that he is a muslim.
Please do a debate with Cosmic Skeptic, he keeps smearing Islam all the time.
Be great if you can get William Craig Lane on :)
Yep!
Ive just watched the whole video and found it very interesting
Please mention the sequence of discussion
I would but we discussed many subjects.
Paul Salaam, Please have a debate with Shaikh Usman Ibn Farooq.
The quran refers to the prophet Isa not the christian Jesus.The mistake came about with translating from Greek.Isa who was the son of Mary/Maryam has nothing in common with the Gospel Jesus who was Jeshu or Yeshua,their different historical identities became confused,"they were taken by similarity. One 'similarity'is the fact that Jeshu and Isa,which are entirely different names in their original Aramaic,can both be Iesous for Jesus,in Greek translation.from the book'conspiracy in Jerusalem by Kamal Salibi.
I love brother richard for the sake of God.
صلوا على الحبيب المصطفى
عليه افضل الصلاه والسلام 💖
عليه الصلاة والسلام
thank you so much
Welcome 😊
💜💙💚💛🧡❤️мы все один и тот же человек, живущий в кучке разных тел. Это означает, что каждый человек, которого вы встречаете, на самом деле ВЫ, живущий в другом теле.
Is and Was Paul of Tarsus a Prophet of God...?
Show me where David is a prophet...
In the New Testament.
Haha I remember this with Adnan
Would you leave Xtianity if we can show you that ?!
@@rashedahmed1562 bro I am a Muslim. Search on UA-cam for "show me where David is a prophet" and you will understand my comment :)
You've to edit with the link too...
Some of people did know what's the troll.
Bro Richard drink with your Right hand 🤲🏻 May Allah you accept Islam Amien
"O Paul thou shalt not chop the video".
This has got to be the most respectful & enlightening debate I've watched
❤️🧡💛💚💙💜 ኵላትና ኣብ እተፈላለየ ኣካላት እንነብር ሓደ ዓይነት ሰብ ኢና እዚ ማለት ከኣ ነፍሲ ወከፍ እትረኽቦ ሰብ ብሓቂ ኣብ ካልእ ኣካል ትነብር ኣሎኻ ማለት ኢዩ!!! ወትሩ ምስ ገዛእ ርእስኻ ኢኻ እትራኸብ ዘለኻ ነዚ ምስ ፈለጥካዮ ኸኣ ሓድነት ክትረክብ ትኽእል ኢኻ✨🙏✨
Fantastic job, Paul! Keep up the incredible work! May Allah protect you and bless you with good health. Ameen.
Got to agree he is one of the nicest Evangelical Christian's unlike some but pleasant and well mannered!
Bless him. 👍🏼
لا يجوز ذكر رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم بدون الصلاة عليه
any Muslim shouldn't say the prophet name without saying PBUH
it's to give respect and part of Suna!
I found out that the Catholic and other churches taught that Jesus went to hell to save adam, eve and those prior to him after he’s crucified. Its called the Harrowing of Hell. Can you comment on this? Kinda made me think of Israk Mikraj on some parts
Hey Richard 🙋. How are you? Good to see you.
Love from Bangladesh
I really like this channel because unlike most religious channels (muslim or christian), you have a solid udnerstanding of both religions and their scripture.
I can't imagine him not being in paradise with the Mercy of God. He is used to a high level of studies in terms of academics, pretty sure he's educated at Oxford and just needs to come in contact with someone who is compatible and coming from the field of the Islamic sciences. He is true to what is true, and that only leads him to follow the trail of evidence. He would admit if he encountered a good enough reason from Islam to become Muslim, perhaps he can sense that there is and is actually building a strong foundation to stand on before he transitions. Either way whatever religion he is, everyone loves him!
Hearing christians, and i was one since a child (left it October 2020(thanks God for this pandemic and all the time it gave me to see this)), is very exhausting... They keep making turns and turns and turns...
Richard likes to complicate the issue.