CONVERSING ISLAM with Hamza Ali Abbasi - Episode - 6
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 жов 2024
- CONVERSING ISLAM with Hamza Ali Abbasi - Episode - 6
🔴 SUBSCRIBE 🔔: www.youtube.co...
▶ DONATIONS: www.ghamidi.or...
▶ About Ghamidi Center Of Islamic Learning:
"Ghamidi Center of Islamic Learning", an initiative of Al-Mawrid US, is established with a single purpose, to educate people of all ages about moral, ethical, and humane values as taught in Islam. Our aim is to separate history and culture from Islam and teach it in its purest form as a field of knowledge and not enforce it as a creed. We base our instruction method on argument and logic and encourage healthy criticism. An institute where traditional and historical knowledge can be understood as well as challenged with reason.
▶ DONATIONS: www.ghamidi.or...
▶ CONNECT with us:
◼ WEBSITE: www.ghamidi.org
◼ FACEBOOK: / ghamidicil
◼ UA-cam: / ghamidicil
#GCIL #JavedAhmedGhamidi #ConversingIslam #HamzaAbbasi #HassanIlyas #AlMawrid
GET THE APP To Ask Questions and Join Community Discussions! www.ghamidi.org/app
JazakAllah. I can’t tell you how much these talks are helping me - a struggling Muslim. For the first time I feel I am finding a connection. May Allah bless you both for your efforts. Hassan bhai your knowledge and ‘andaaz-e-guftugu’ is amazing.
Agreed, your expressions are our hearts
چھوٹا مفتی ( حسن) بہت پیارا لگ رہا ہے
Alhamdulillah
ماشاءاللہ حسن بھائی
I really appreciate Hasan Ilyas bhai's humbleness/steadfastness/patience. Indeed, he is a true student of Ustaaz e muhtaram Jsved ahmed ghamidi.
بہت خوب ....اللہ پاک مکتبِ فراحی و غامدی کو جزائے خیر عطاء فرمائے ...اللہ تعالیٰ آپ دونوں کے علم و عمل میں برکت و وسعت اور استقامت عنائیت فرمائے ...آپ کی اس کوشش کو دنیا میں مقبولِ عام کرے اور آپ کیلئے توشہِ آخرت بنائے ...آمین...یا رب العالمین
Bahut hi aala, hamza ali ki awaz is program ko moqammal sunne par majboor kar deti hai.
شاندار
یہ چھوٹا مفتی ماشااللہ بہت سمجھدار ہے
اللہ کریم جزائے خیر عطا فرمائے
جناب الیاس صاحب اپ ہر ملک مین ایسے ادارہ قاءم کـر ین تاکہ امت کو صحیح علم مل سکے
I'm 100% sure that 95% viewers can connect with thoughts of Hassan ilyas bhai....i think purely because of his background....much humble and fluent speaker....may Allah bless you both!❤️
These conversations are an amazing effort on your part. All of you who are involved in bringing these forward, may Allah be pleased with you all. Looking forward to further episodes ❤️
Good work jazakAllah
Ma Sha Allah. Great effort. May Allah guide us all to follow the true interpretation of Islam.
Bahut khoob, Allah ap logo ki koshish ko kamyab kare Aameen
Masha'Allah.
Very critical point , but comprehensively explained especially at 10:00 in minutes line.
Mode of explanation is very logical & well organized with examples, even easily understandable for an ordinary person. Jazzak'Allah.
ماشااللہ اچھی بیٹھک رہی۔
اب آپ آہستہ آہستہ ریڈ زون میں جا رہے ہیں جہاں بہت زیادہ تنقید کا سامنا کرنا پڑے گا۔ امید ہے آپ صبر تحمل استقامت کا دامن پکڑ کر رکھیں گے۔ جب آپ حق بات کریں گے مخلفت اور صبر دونوں اکٹھے آئیں گے۔ اللہ پاک مدد کرے۔
حمزہ عباسی تو کھل کر سامنے انا چاہتا ہے
کوئی لگی لپٹی نہین
ماشااللہ
I belong to india nice topic for young generation big fan both of you
JazakAllah khair ❤❤❤
Aap logon ki tahqik sy hamary sawalon ka jawab ham ko mil raha hai , Allah aap ko kamyab kary or aap esi tarhan hamarh zahnon mai uthny waly sawalon ka jawab dayty rahny Aameen summa Aameen
it helped me alott.. alhamdulillah...!!!owe you both for such a worthful effort
بہت خوبصورت مکالمہ
Humza bhai thanks for bring such a good program under Ghamdi's umbrella, but please let Br. Ilyas finish his points, we really want to hear him without interruption. Your points are good as well but plz let him finish explanation, it will easy to understand with continuity.
Jazakallah
Hamza Abbasi i saw your video playing guitar on Ertugrul Ghazi. It was amazing! I think you should make movies on our Islamic history.
Jazak Allah
Mashallah may allah give you more strength Hassan Ilyas Bhai
I am living in Australia for 13 years in isolation since teen age.
I had similar journey like Hamza Bhai . I started watching alien and sci fi movies and alien god series .....then started to corelate it with Islam and other religions and came across ghanidi sahib 5/6 years ago.
Since then he is my source of help by rectifying confusions.
I would request you guys to explain tasawuf and weather islam has anything to do with Sufism
Great efforts from your team MashAllah. May Allah gives complete shifa to your daughter ilyas bhai and other sick people around the world.
Very informative and explanatory videos. Thank u for ur efforts. Jazakallah khairan
Allah Aap ko Jazaiye Khair de broad based discussion Excellent MashAllah
جزاکم اللہ خیرا
Eagerly waiting for the next episodes.
Stay Blessed
آمین
Nice explained! Jazak Allah
Great approach. It’s a difficult task. Let’s hope and pray that we start thinking with an open mind. Well done guys
May Allah bless you both and all the guys involved. What a beautiful effort!
HM Hassan Illiyaas very logical & Critical 👍♥️
Great sir😊
Thank you! ❤️
Can't wait for next episode. Brilliant work
Amazing conversations 👍
jazak Allah!
Quran rules cause it's the speech of Ultimate Ruler
great great work Allha bless you
laikin is ko samjany k lea educated hona bhut zaruri h
amm band to gustakhi he samjy ga
gamdi sab k follower b mostly educated he hn
Jazakallah khair. This series is really good! May Allah reward you all. Also, Can you please share the episode on inheritance ? I have been struggling to answer the inheritance question in case when a person leaves behind two daughters and parents
❤️❤️❤️❤️
I like your program
Next 14 Kab ayega
Interesting and engaging conversation, appreciate the effort. My internet gets interrupted and intersected when you use certain words. Even in USA internet is being monitored for certain words. Better to use certain words less often. Impressed with both of your vocabulary, choose wisely.
Wassalam rahemtullahi wa barkatahu!
Great!❤️♥️❤️
Iliyas sahab jab aap kisi hadees ko sahi ya ghalat batate hainto us hadeez ka no: bhi btaya kijiye
پہلے سے ایک نظریہ قائم کر کے قرآن پڑھیں تو اللہ کا کے احکام کی نفی کرتے ہیں کیونکہ اللہ نے قرآن میں کہ دیا کہ اس کتاب کوئی شک و شبہ کی گنجائش نہیں یہ سورۂ بقر کی پہلی آیت ہے
My Humble Advise to HASAN BHAI: Hasan bhai mustaqbil mein is baat ka qayal rakhein ki jab kabhi bhi ali abbas aap ka interview le rahein hon...toh unke tokne par aap apni baat ko incomplete na chod dein aap jabran apni baat puri karien. Warna aisa lagta hai ki koi kheemti mawad(content) bahar nikalne se ruk gaya hai..
Ali abbas bhai se mai kuch nahi kahoonga...bas aap thoda un par haavi ho jayein...
Thank u for clear my concept keep it up hamza and hassan bhai
keep it brothers .topics are very informative but be care full Hamza and think 100 time before speak. let Hassan sahab to speak fluently and completed him his point of view,
mashallah samajh aa gei ab
Assalamualaikum. Thanks for both Hamza bhai and Hassan bhai for this great effort. May Allah shower His Blessings in both duniya and Akhirat. I wanted to ask a question. The approach is definitely right but as you have explained that Quran is the last and final piece of Allah message. So if we want the details , should we follow the ways of Sahabah or The Prophets before Risalat Maab SAW. For example, the way to offer prayers and many other things which are usually the symbolic representation of sects in our society. Thanks brothers
Assalam-O-Alaikum. I really LOVE your "Coversations". However, why don't you give reference of the Ahadith or Riwayat that you are mentioning in your conversation? Is it deliberate or you don't have the references?
Best episode
Assalam Walaikum. Sir kindly guide me from where can i start to understand Islam. I live in India and here most of my surrounding ppl are non muslims. I want to gain knowledge about my religion, a lot of time i am not able to ans to my friends, they ask me several qtns which im nt able to ans like why did Prophet Mohammad marry 4 women, hoors concept in jannah etc. I have aqeeda in Inslam but not able to gather proper knowledge. I too have many qtns like hamza sir had.
Hasan bhai, this is proved by experience that recorded video is better option than live.
Very good.make less repition.itwill save time.
Sir!! Mehrbaani frma kr video ki edtiing theek sy kr dain... Q k video sahi chlti nahi hai... Pasua ho ho kr chlti hai.
20:53
Assalam o alaikum
I have a Question that, as most people have stopped going to Masjid to offer prayers because of the coronavirus
As this is the last asharaa of Ramadan and Eid ul Fitr in coming near
Shuld we attend Namaz e Eid or should we offer it at our homes?
Jazakallah
Very good program for aqal waley Masha’Allah
Sir, tell me about the remaining episode of ghamidi sahb ki fikar pe aiteraaz ka jawab????
God bless you janb
Please ap bakri ny ayat kha li wali bat pori krn.thanx
Respected Ilias sir!!!Salam...!!aap thora quran ki jama k bare me clarify karen...
Hamza sir apne episode 5 se pehle ....does GOD exist? Pr ek program krna chahie tha. ..
Jin ahadees me musick ko sakht Najaiz qarar dya Gaya hy , kya wo osole muhadasen pe pori nai utarti? Please musick ke bary me Jo Ahades hen , un per bi roshni dalen aur Awam tak haq baat pohchayen.... jahan tak mera ilm hy , muge yahi pata chala hy hades me mosiqi gunnah ka kaam hy ... aap apni raye den aur wo Ahades bi discuss karen .
Why mist of the concerned people don't understand these things, I think it is very painful if we can't follow it and unnecessarily close our eyes and follow other people with out any logic
سر کیا ایک عام آدمی قرآن کو ترجمہ سے پڑھ کر سمجھ سکتا ہے اور اپنی زندگی کی بنیاد کو ٹھیک کر سکتا ہے؟
بالکل اسی طرح پڑھ اور سمجھ سکتا ہے جیسے صحابہ کرام پڑھ اور سمجھ سکتے تھے ورنہ اس قرآن کی حجت کیسے قائم ہوگی اللہ کے بندوں پہ
آپ ایک بار پورا قرآن سچے طالب علم کی طرح کسی درسی کتاب کی طرح پڑھ لیں اس کے نوٹس بنا لیں جو جو بات بنیادی آپ کو سمجھ آتی جائے ایک طرف لکھ لیں اور جن باتوں میں الجھن ہے وہ دوسری کسی نوٹس بک میں درج کر لیں اور جب جب جو بات سمجھ آتی جائے اسے اس دوسری کتاب سے نکالتے جائیں
آپ یقین کریں آپ ۸۰ فیصد سمجھ جائیں گے
اس کے بعدبھی کچھ الجھن ہو تو ان سوالوں کو ہمیں پیش کریں دیکھیں ہم آپ کی الجھن دور کرسکیں
a.a......jenab agr majority log kisi jhoot par jama nhi ho saktay....toh phr christan musalamanu sai ziyada hn toh inko ham jootay kyu kehtay hn....plzzz explain this issue....
Sir , when ever you code surah plz mention ayiat number
Plz somebody help me.... Tufan ha mind mn questions ka... Or kafir hony ka der k agr ghamdi sahb k views ko dykho gi tw islam sy nikl jao gi.... Mtlb aj tak pory islamic world mn or koiy kyou nae aaya jo aesy sochy in jesy or log kyou nae... Saudia mn b kbi kisi ny QURAN THEEK NAE prha kya... Aj tak kisi or k mind mn ye cheezn kyou nae aaiy...is ak bat ny bht pryshan kiya huwa mind accept nae krta or kisi k mind mn ye cheezn kyou nae aaiy...
یہ ضروری نہیں کسی اور نے سوچا نہ ہو۔ ہو سکتا ہے آپ کو اب تک ایسا سوچنے والا نظر نہ آیا ہو۔ سوال پوچھنے سے آپ مذہب سے خارج نہیں ہوتے۔ سوال پوچھئے۔
Assalamualaikum, I thought they will cover how Quran is word of God.
we human being has a tendency to mould the religion to fit our lifestyle. 'Lahavo' description is great here - for example, I like playing chess, and any room religion provides to I would latch on it. Or I play but if it doesn't compromise my responsibility to the serving to Allah.
Hamza Abbasi puts a good point on what if the career is more important than the responsibility to our creater...this is the perfect example for using anything divert from the key responsibility.
Secondly, the criticism on the ulema who interpreted it is as music.Tthe criticism is harsh and unfair from you both. What if the major diversion at that point in time was music comparing to now. i believe both of you will consider this aspect and exhibit the Islamic 'husnay zun (Think positive)'.
7
Ap comments dekhte b hen ya ni ??
Mene episode 4 pe comment kiya tha uska abi koi jawab nhi aya
What was the Animated series Hasan bhai talking about??
What has happened to yesterday's stream? It suddenly disappeared.
Had some audio issues. This is a fixed version.
@@GhamidiCIL Okay.thank u for clarification
I have been following Ghamidi Sb for some time now. I have watched all his long lectures and know his school of thought. I only would like to give you a few suggestions and I hope you guys will not be offended.
1)- You should first start by telling or convincing people that they should pick a simple translation of the Quran in there native language and read it cover to cover. This will at least help them in understand what exactly is in it. They will have their own view of the Quran.
2)- Choosing topics will not help because you are not giving your own verdict on it. Even on music you did not clarify it if it is halal or haram. In certain condition it is haram in others it is halal will not do it. If it is not haram in the Quran If it is not haram in Sahih Hadees why are you bothering about Asaar? You should have clearly said that it is not haram. Condition apply to all other things as well so they apply to this also.
3)- In my opinion, you guys don't want to deviate much from the traditional narrative and still somehow want to include that in your explanations. I think now is the time to tell people clearly that we should first read the QURAN cover to cover in translation and after that do other things.
I do not have any intention of offending anybody. These are just my opinions and nothing else. Would love to see a reply on this from any of you or from your center.
Your suggestions don't make sense.
Why the Day of Resurrection Allah will settle between two parties which was right and which was wrong in the world? Why not in their worldly life? The party which was right might then feel happy but what about the party which was wrong whom no expiation will be accepted from? In the system of justice generally prevailing in the world we punish a criminal for a crime he commits to discourage him from repeating that crime or committing any other offence in future. In other words, we punish him to reform him. We do this, also, to make other people desist from committing any crime. Similarly, people are rewarded for the good deeds they do in order to encourage and motivate not only them but others as well. This should be the concept of retribution and reward. But when Allah will punish sinners in the hereafter we don't see there exists this concept. What good result will the punishment achieve then? Who will Allah want to discourage and who will Allah want to encourage? So, if Allah really wants to reform the people He should give all the punishment and reward in this very life of theirs and not in the hereafter. The punishment Allah will give in the hereafter will tantamount to be a revenge. It is of no use to beat a person after he is dead. Of course, you can beat him after reviving him if you have that power. But, even then, you will do it only to satiate your desire of revenge; Your aim would not be to reform him. Allah's punishing in the hereafter seems to be of this sort because He possesses the power to subject a person to severe torment and yet not let him die. He will be justified to punish in the hereafter if his intention is to send the person back in this world duly reformed or to send him in any other world. The punishment in the hereafter is simply objective-less. What ultimately will be achieved is nothing.
Why was it removed yesterday?
Had some audio issues. This is a fixed version.
The argument about music is very weak music istrumrmtd is totally haram the correct position
I think u leave things in the middle for interpretation. Music is haram or not? Specifically which music is haram and which is halal. U never said it. If rap music is haram then is classical music halal? I think u should have said that in 50 min long conversation .
The point is, it is the content that will make a music, song, poem, painting bad or anything that make you forget your religious obligations. Rap is not necessarily Haram, similarly if you spent 20 hours on internet ignoring Namaz would not make internet Haram but how you use it.
Music itself of any kind is not haram but if you add FAHSH words or SHIRQ in any music or in any poetry in become haram. This is what they have explained it in this episode.
Salam brothers n sisters. Ma shaAllah doing a good job but a humble request to Hamza, u intrept a lot, better don't intrept him that often, it is harming his continuity.
جو اسلام کا تعارف اور تعریف ،جو اسلام کی وضاحت اور تعلیمات پیش کی گئی کیا ان میں کیا اب بھی گنجائش باقی تھی کہ وہ شخص جو اصول دین کے بنیادی ضابطوں سے بھی نابلد ہے وہ اسلام کے لیے دریچے واہ کرے گا۔میں تحقیق کا انکار نہٰں کرتا۔میں کہتا ہوں تحقیق ہو جستجو ہو۔لیکن اس کا ہرگز یہ مطلب نہیں کے کوئ بھی اآئے اور اپنے زعم اور گمان کو مذہب کے تعارف کا نام دے دے یہ قطعی درست نہیں ۔اسلاف کی تحقیق قابل تعریف ہی نہیں قابل تحسین بھی ہے ۔ان کی عمریں بھی زیادہ تھیں ان کا علم بھی نافع تھا۔ان کا اخلاص بھی عظیم تھا ۔ان کا سورس آف نالج بھی پیو تھا۔۔آج اس کے برعکس ہے ۔گوگل کی معلومات پر اکتفا کرکے خود کو نمایاں اور فلسفی سمجھنے کے زعم مٰں یہ سب کرنا میرے خیال میں درست نہیں ۔علماء فضلا مفتیان کرام دین کے امیں ہیں ۔یہ منصب انہی کو زیب دیتاہے ۔کبھی کسی عام شخص کو آپریشن تھیٹر میں جاکر کوئی بھی اسپتال اپریشن نہیں کرنے دیگا کیونکہ وہ نہ اس کا منصب اور نہ وہ اس فن کی باریکیوں کو جانتا ہے ۔لہذا پیارے دوستو!!کچھ خیال کریں ۔شہرت کا شارٹ راستہ مذہب کی نت نئی تعریف ۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔میں نے اپنے حصے کی بات کہہ دی ۔میرا رب حق بیان کرنے کی توفیق عطافرمائے
Literally nobody has ever claimed that companions of Prophet (pbuh) never made mistakes it's a strawman and a very stupid one. You are refuting a point that was never made in the first place. What majority of the scholars believe is that you should not condemn or criticise Sahabah. Scholars throughout history have for numerous times refuted and abrogated opinions expressed by Sahabah.
Christianity can not be compared with Islam. As bible is not available in its original form but Quran is still protected. So your comparison is absurd and wrong. Religion is not like science which changes it theories after every few years.
Ap center concept ko smjaein k kisi ky b opinion ko prefer krny sy pehly quran ko importance deain wrna quran ka ilam seekna mushkil ho jye ga
So you can easily say that original Bible does not exist, but for Hadith we treat it as 100% authentic, even though it is not directly from Prophet SAWW and there has been disagreement between four Imams and even ulema. We have no problem of using them to understand and superbimpose on message of Quran rather than understanding Hadith in light of Quran. How can we give same weightage to Hadith as Quran?
And we can also understand bible in the light of Quran
Dear brothers I am happy audio prblm ,which I had pointed out in some of last episod ,has been solved.May Allah I am able to listen to all future episods.
keep it up
A Rashid Khan India