Animatic vs animation - Monster - Star vs the Forces of Evil fan animatic
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 тра 2020
- Please watch in HD
--------
Follow me on my social media :
★ www.artofrhues.com
★ www.tumblr.com/blog/rhues
★ / artofrhues
--------
Follow Logan Redgrave on his social media :
★ / logan_misaki
★ / @loganredgrave9263 - Фільми й анімація
I can't fault him for the lighting but the speed of the animation was either to fast or to jerky, all of this can be fixed but I can definitely say that dramatic flair he's got shines in this animation and it is so fucking fantastic I can't word it properly
I think one of my biggest critics of the animation is that there are a lot of parts that move too quickly to the point where it doesn’t feel as smooth. I’m not sure if he utilizes a timing chart but it would greatly benefit him doing so. Especially where it feels like a shot needs to be a bit slower to convey what a scene is trying to convey. But he did it by himself without any direction besides the animatic. So this is really amazing! I love both of them! ❤️❤️
yeah I think logan could afford to take some creative liberty with the posing, because that was one of the jerkiest parts at times.
It's either he tried to keep the pace with the audio by making the frames more faster or he added more fps. If you compare animatic with animation, animation is always the faster one depending on how many fps you put, and how many duplicates of the same frame is there to make it seem slower.
I also feel like to lip sync was a little odd, it didn’t match up a lot of times.
@@necromarcy well its animation so I'm not really disappointed with anything. Since animation tends to be faster than the soundtrack or animatic
totally not a troll I see where you’re coming from, put the pacing just felt odd. It kinda felt like it was moving too fast just to match up with the frames changing in the animatic, which looks a little odd.
Just a heads up as a few people have asked after the last video...I would be thrilled if anyone else would like to animate any of my animatics. Please go ahead. Just give me a shout which one you want to do and send me a link when you're done so I can make another video similar to this to promote your work and do a little review :)
Ok
on it :) ♥
💖💗💖💗💖
Sorry, I prefer the one on the left.
It's an okay adaptation. I feel they cod have handled the lighting better. I had too much trouble seeing it and found myself defaulting to your animatic to see what was happening
same
Could you have done better?
@@SwimmingSirena that’s not a valid excuse. Someone who doesn’t know how to cook can tell someone who DOES know how to cook that they should improve, based on the taste, texture and smell.
It’s just called criticism and I’m sick and tired of seeing this sentence being used when someone brings up a valid piece of criticism.
@@j0bie I’m sorry. I didn’t mean for it to sound rude.
@@j0bie I didn’t realize that read in a different view, it was just… I have a word I can’t think of at the moment.
4:10 yup affirmative even in the climax i could feel that moment of the spells doing the classic and always emotional clash of powers with a end which hits me right in the feelings ^^
That's GORGEOUS
The animation is good. But is still very fast , paused, dark and the effects doesn't seems to be there .
(It's just My opinion sorry if i offended someone 😐)
You're okay! It's a simple critic. There's no harm in that 😊
@@midnightthoughts8519 i'm happy to hear that😅😅 thanks
@@ariadnaavalosagurto6475 no problem :')
Started tearing up again when she picked up Meteora, then placed her smiling baby back in her crib because we all know what will happen next.
The animation was amazing!!!!!
Dude that last part with the magic effects made me tear up
The animation is just amazing, specially with the effects like the powers that Eclipsa creates, it just fantastic the effort in it.
the only two issue i would say is the amount of darkness which makes a bit hard so to find Eclipsa in some scenes. That and the speed of the animation itself in Eclipsa, but besides this two things, the animation looks beautifully smooth and awesome i wish i could do something as great asthis.
THE ANIMATIONS AFTER 3:44 WERE ALL EPIC ESPECIALLY THE BLAST
Huh,I always thought you were a dude
_neat_
SAMME but i found out a while ago
Most people seem to think that xD
@@artofrhues its the short hair
DeliciousYumYum I thought that too but I wasn’t sure and I don’t like to assume genders
Wait what?
I feel the animatic is totally perfect, the animation has a lot of flaws like line art, colors and shadows BUT I admit that the glitter and bangs make them beautiful. I have no right to judge about the animation, as I don't know how to make one, but I do know that the colors and tones it uses are incorrect
that final shot gave me GOOSEBUMPS
The final blast scene was INCREDIBLE
The animation clearly has a lot of talent and hard work!
I am impressed that they used 3D with it. I think that they could have spaced out some frames of animation. The movements were very smooth and quick , and I think they could have benefited with having either some frames eased in and out to feel a bit more natural. I like the effects used! Even those could be turned into frames and have some removed to have it match too.
Very wonderful work, great job both of you!
Ohh i still remember seeing this animatic first and then think about how you show to us that moment when eclipsa got "sealed" ;) UFF is really amazing see again this dude with his version of your animatics xD the cabro logan is a monster
Dioooos es bellísimo :'3
Gracias por compartir mi animación
Thank You 💜👌
Holy shit that actually gave me chills at the end
The animation was either too bright or too dark. I prefer the original.
One person doing all the animation is hell
Wowoooo que lindo magnífico ❤️❤️❤️❤️ amo a eclipsa imagina isso maravilhoso
Eclipsa: "I'm not a monster!!!!"
*proceeds to blast the high council with a lazar beam*
Its called defense
@@bokchoi8331 okay number 1. that comment was made a year ago. number 2. i was making a joke😭😭😭
@@pxierat happy year again btw
The shadows in the animation version make things kind of hard to see...
Aaah, so good!!! Really amazing!!
I love your animations, Mini-movies, clips!)
Ur really talantly!!!
Again ohhh how nice, love your work both of you
This is amazing. Both of these are perfect.
This looks amazing I love it AMAZING WORK YOU TWO
They both look stunningly amazing!!!
Woah it surely took a massive amount of time to animate that, congrats!!
THANK YOU.
An animatic is not an animation. People need to know the difference.
My God, I am totally in love with this video ... I can't get out of it 😭😭💕💕.
Wow it really does look amazing!
Those effects were gnarly!!!!
This is beautiful!
The animated fire and magic spells are absolutely STUNNING!!!
I fricken love your voice
I love your work❤️
Continueee toooo ready as ill ever be omg that was epic
Sheesh, the one on the right has too much contrast and it's too dark. Some movements also seem sped up and unnatural. :3
Beautiful, gorgeous, love it!
Saying this now, his animation is like a cross between original 2D and high work 3D. I do see spots were it needs a bit more sanding, but to be simply and blunt. I LOVE IT ALL!
I think everything about the animation recreation was AMAZING is just that some scenes are to dark that you can't see well the scene and other stuff but over all it's beautiful
Jeez that’s beautiful
I cried the first time i saw the animation, now im full out sobbing that was beautiful!!
I like certain parts of both of those and all I can think is that it would be even more awesome if they could work together on an animatic.
Amazing work is always❤😎
I love the animation well done love to se more like this😊
That ending was PERFECT 💕💕💕
Both are amazing!!!! = D
That’s amazing!!!!
that’s amazing 🤩
You just took an awesome character and made them better
Amazing
Dam that fire part in the animation was amazing
Fantastic , hiper fantastic my darling
the magic effects he did are GORGEOUS
I love both!!
I love it
The last frame. THE LAST FRAME!!! O^O AMAZING
sempre me arrepio com isso com isso ,_,
Where is the second part of "Ready as i'll ever be"?
remenber that the clip base was the tangled.
Wow, so Amazing!!! ❤️
Do you want to see SVTFOE again and fix that unfair ending? Then join the #SaveSVTFOE movement! An event is being organized this June 19 in which fans will demonstrate to Disney there is still material to develop the series as a 5°season, movie or sequel and telling how we would like these unsolved mysteries to be solved. It's not in the hands of Daron Nefcy but we do have her support! Search Team#SaveSVTFOE on Instagram and twitter for more information. You'll not regret it!
That was A M A Z I N G!!!!!!!
This is wonderfull, but I think that it was a little dark in some scenes, for example the part with the baby when they touch their forehead could be a little more lightning, and sometimes the animation decays a little, but this is really awesome, REALLY GOOD JOB, but I think that YOU CAN BE BETTER
Ahhhhhhhh- that fire transition.
3:10 look at her left arm
(I just pay attention to minor oversights)
I LOVE THIS! 💕💕💕
#KeepStarAlive
Me encantoooooo💕💕💕💕
I love this song it so good ♥️
i like your videos for star vs the forces of evil . I LOVE STARCO XD
Ni en los animes tienen tan buenos efectos y luces
Bueenoo...
both are great
Perfect
OMG! i NEED you to animate one day Lumity from The Owl House💕✨
I love your animatic, and the animation is really good. It’s just too bad most of it was too dark to see anything happening and then I would get blinded by the bright flashes of light from the flames or the ghosts. I see improvement from the last animation they did for your animatics.
woa the effects was very good tho
bruh there both good
ЭТО ДОСТОЙНО БОЛЬШИХ ПРОСМОТРОВ, ТЫ БОЛЬШАЯ(ОЙ) МОЛОДЕЦ))))
I CRIED MAN!!
Es hermoso!!!!!
The animation, especially those effects are lovely, but there are some parts that they overdid it such as in 2:53. Personally, I would like to see the emotion and expressions of the character changing, but the effects were distracting. Same with 3:43, cant see the emotions being displayed. Still fantastic job though
Soooo goodddddddd
Nice
OMG YAY AGAIN!!!
Both were so good, but I think, that the art of rhues animatic is better, but I loved the fire and special effects of the other one, they both was beautiful, :3
Please give us more star vs the forces of evil animatics Pleeaaasseee
I love more the animatic ♥ :3
I think animatic is more better than animation...
I really liked it and thought it was Awesome but it was really dark and couldn’t see all the movements but it was still amazing!
Cool
Isso foi perfeito
You should probably make more Star vs The Forces of Evil Animatics so we could do more
People are complaining about how the animated version is a lot more faster to where it doesn't feel smooth. Because that is how animation is, when you compare animation to animatics, the animation is always the faster paced one since there are a lot of frames, not drawings. Animation is more complex, so I see why it's not as smooth as people expect it to be. In the end, I like both very much and don't see any problem with the both of them.
It's very well done and you can tell a lot of work went into it, but calling it an animation is being generous. It feels more like a more detailed and framed animatic still.
Woow♥️♥️
It’s great, I mean he did ask for permission so that’s great too
I like both!😀
Os dois estão ótimos