What If Old Obi Wan SAVED Darth Vader on the Death Star

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 483

  • @PentePatrolStarWars
    @PentePatrolStarWars  Рік тому +58

    We are announcing a NEW 75,000 Subscriber Lightsaber Giveaway, Sponsored by Artsabers: instagram.com/p/CrdsW99OsLw/?igshid=YmMyMTA2M2Y=
    Instructions:
    Subscribe to PPSW on UA-cam
    Follow @artsabers on Instagram: instagram.com/artsabers?igshid=YmMyMTA2M2Y=
    Share post on your personal story
    Like the Instagram post & tag 2 friends and you’ll be entered to win! (Comment multiple times by tagging 2 friends per comment to get extra entries for a better chance to win!)

    • @brokenbridge6316
      @brokenbridge6316 Рік тому +1

      You make a really nice story this time around. Happy 4th of July.

    • @brokenbridge6316
      @brokenbridge6316 Рік тому +2

      "What if" Sabine Wren was Force-Sensitive?

    • @Blackout-Official-edits
      @Blackout-Official-edits Рік тому +6

      What if Darth Vader managed to heal his body, fully?

    • @NicholasIrvin
      @NicholasIrvin Рік тому +1

      love the videos but here is a good idea for you to use on your channel what if obi wan had a padawan that was mandaorian in clone wars
      briliant idea or waht?

    • @jacksonconley5117
      @jacksonconley5117 Рік тому +3

      What If Obi Wan Never Followed Padme to Mustafar?

  • @hulksteranddestroyer2153
    @hulksteranddestroyer2153 Рік тому +358

    “WHO TELLS A 10 YEAR OLD THEIR BIO LOGICAL FATHER KILLED THEIR BIOLOGICAL MOTHER AND COMITED MASS GENOCIDE, FOR FUNSIES.” had me dying of laughter

  • @produccionesluxy
    @produccionesluxy 10 місяців тому +46

    I just love the idea of vader energetically confused say "is han Solo, my son?? "

  • @OvertMysteryChannel
    @OvertMysteryChannel Рік тому +229

    Vader didn't destroy Alderaan, he didn't even suggest that planet or relay the order...nor did the Emperor. Moff Tarkin made that decision. Also, in the books, Palpatine thought it was a mistake to pick Alderaan because of the favor they held in the senate.

    • @RedRipperDragon
      @RedRipperDragon Рік тому +40

      This, tarkin was the clown who had the planet popped. Also idk if vader gave the order to kill the Lars, troopers were simply told to get the Droids and who knows what happened at the homestead. Maybe there is more in the novel but I didn't read it.

    • @Patrick-ut3sy
      @Patrick-ut3sy 7 місяців тому +4

      I believe in Legends, he did give the order and watched va hologram from the Devastator. Not sure about canon.

    • @charlestaylor253
      @charlestaylor253 3 місяці тому +3

      In retrospect, Tarkin was lucky to have died on the Death Star. Palps wouldn't have been exactly "pleased" with him for destroying Alderaan. 🤪

  • @RyanTheDark
    @RyanTheDark Рік тому +367

    I love how you had Vader go out heroically. Too many people justify his actions or ignore them all together. Two decades of torment and pain on the innocent cannot be ignored.

    • @bobafett1313
      @bobafett1313 Рік тому +42

      While I’m not saying Vader was innocent Tarkin was the one in control of the Death Star not Vader. All Vader did was hold onto Leia as it destroyed Alderaan. Sure he could have possibly stopped it but the blame is on Tarkin. Palpatine was the one ordering Vader as his attack dog. To me Palpatine is more to blame than Vader but Vader was also evil.
      Then you have the debate of Vader vs Anakin, Anakin being a hero who protected the innocent vs Vader who was evil and oppressed the innocent. The Jedi themselves were not pure good either.

    • @FamilyChannel-yv1xv
      @FamilyChannel-yv1xv Рік тому +22

      ​@@bobafett1313Vader did so much more than just watch a planet get blown up...

    • @redaxer2908
      @redaxer2908 Рік тому +24

      @@bobafett1313 Vader was aiding in the direct protection of the Death Star by capturing and torturing Leia. That makes him absolutely guilty just like the engineers who listened to orders and fired the shot.

    • @VestedUTuber
      @VestedUTuber Рік тому +26

      I just want to comment on this, letting Vader live isn't necessarily justifying or ignoring his actions. It depends on the context. Honestly, with the kind of stuff Vader did, killing him would be an empty and insufficient punishment, and a state of permanent atonement, attempting to right his wrongs but knowing it will never truly be enough, would be more fitting.
      People who call for his death are effectively letting him off easy. If a redeemed Vader _didn't_ want to atone, then that's a problem. But if he does? Let him.

    • @bobafett1313
      @bobafett1313 Рік тому +8

      @@FamilyChannel-yv1xv I know I’m talking about just that moment in particular, he didn’t have the responsibility it was Tarkin

  • @HectorCotto97
    @HectorCotto97 Рік тому +96

    Idk why so many people keep saying that Vader destroyed Leia's planet when it wasn't even Vader who ordered its destruction. If memory serves Vader just happen to be in the room when it happened, he literally just sorta stood there while the guy who was ACTUALLY in charge ordered the destruction of her planet. Heck I don't even remember if Vader even said anything that entire scene, I distinctly remember him just sorta standing there menacingly the entire time.

    • @bayonetta8418
      @bayonetta8418 Рік тому +18

      Yeah, it was Moff Tarkin who gave the order and I think there's a comic book that says Vader did not approve of the destruction of Alderaan and thought it was excessive.

    • @Arkilos
      @Arkilos 7 місяців тому +3

      when you are the helm all actions of the people under you becomes your responsibility, "on his ship, there is nothing that isn't under the captains control. "

    • @glauberglousger956
      @glauberglousger956 6 місяців тому +5

      ​@@ArkilosTarkin was above Vader, so, nothing could be done about that

    • @gengarzilla1685
      @gengarzilla1685 5 місяців тому +6

      But Vader _wasn't_ at the helm, he was explicitly subordinate to Tarkin during this time on the Death Star. Vader cannot be realistically blamed for Alderaan's destruction.

  • @thesenate329
    @thesenate329 Рік тому +173

    Here's a few ideas:
    - What if Darth Vader discovered that Leia was his daughter in A New Hope?
    - What if every force user in the galaxy suddenly lost their connection to the force during the Clone Wars?
    - What if Alderann had a giant mirror that deflected the laser beam back to the Death Star?
    - What if Watto was the chosen one?
    - What if the senate refused to give Palpatine emergency powers?
    - What if Obi-Wan and Anakin left the Jedi Order to work at Dex's diner?
    - What if Anakin was defeated by the younglings?
    - What if Obi-Wan died after jumping out of the window of Padme's apartment?

    • @seeigecannon
      @seeigecannon Рік тому +13

      What if R2-D2 was shot off the Queen's ship in Episode 1, but a different astromech managed to fix the shields?
      What if the Queen's ship was blown up by the blockade?
      What if Greedo shot Han?
      What if Anakin was welcomed into Jedi training by the Council?
      What if Han did the Kessel Run in 12km/AU/lightyear?
      What if Anakin got 2nd place in the pod race?

    • @priestbob5116
      @priestbob5116 Рік тому +3

    • @neochozo
      @neochozo Рік тому +22

      I’m laughing far harder than I should be at “What if Anakin was defeated by the younglings?”

    • @speedstick8981
      @speedstick8981 Рік тому +3

      @@seeigecannon12 parsecs if I recall.

    • @TheMimiSard
      @TheMimiSard Рік тому +1

      I think I have read at least two fanfics of Vader finding out who Leia is, but both are time travel fix-its.

  • @TheCroutonCrusader
    @TheCroutonCrusader Рік тому +31

    19:43
    Why does Obi-Wan have a habit of taking Anakin’s sabers? 😂

  • @patrioticjustice9040
    @patrioticjustice9040 Рік тому +43

    That would have made for one hell of an awkward conversation on the Falcon.
    Luke: But Ben, you told me Vader betrayed and murdered my father.
    Vader: *WHAT?!*

    • @krispalermo8133
      @krispalermo8133 Рік тому +10

      Ben: "Luke, .. Leia is your sister and Anakin's/Vader's daughter."
      Leia, Luke, Vader, " .. WHAT ... !?"
      Ben " Leia is also Chewie's niece."
      R2, " .. beep yep."
      C3p0, " No R2 I don't see the family resemblance of the princess looking and sounding like a wookie."

  • @ANETERNALNEMESIS
    @ANETERNALNEMESIS Рік тому +91

    Technically, Tarkin was in command of the Death Star. He gave the order to destroy Alderann, not Vader. In the new canon, Vader didn't have Owen and Beru killed, he didn't even know they were the ones raising Luke. Other than that this is great!

    • @collegebro85
      @collegebro85 Рік тому +18

      Exactly, even during the OT, it was established Boba Fett incinerated Owen and Beru over a bounty for the droids, hence why Vader told him “and this time, no incinerations” in episode V

    • @charlestaylor253
      @charlestaylor253 3 місяці тому +1

      ​@@collegebro85
      Fett: 'I love the smell of incinerations in the morning!'

  • @wb7585
    @wb7585 Рік тому +22

    Vader: - realizes who Leia was-
    Roger: that's a wooopies

  • @benjaminobienu5297
    @benjaminobienu5297 Рік тому +30

    This is absolutely unique, Mr. Pente Patrol. I love Vader choosing the redemption path but, simultaneously, holding accountability for his actions on what he did to innocent people he killed and tearing up a bit for this indeed an emotional story. That is an excellent story, my friend; please keep up the great work, and may the force be with you!

  • @LokiturnedmeintoaFrog
    @LokiturnedmeintoaFrog Рік тому +12

    Ben: "By the way Luke, this is you're father"

  • @ericcrabtree7075
    @ericcrabtree7075 Рік тому +16

    Leia - you blew up my planet 😡
    Vader - noooooo that was your uncle Tarkin 😉

  • @kurtpaulsen6579
    @kurtpaulsen6579 Рік тому +10

    One small point... I will concede the Lars farm being on Vader, but the call to destroy Alderaan was Tarkin, all Tarkin... He made that call and due to Tarkin's status in the eyes of Palpatine, Vader could not have countermanded the order that Tarkin gave... In fact, Tarkin was one of only a few people Vader would take direction from...

  • @locoarticwolf2181
    @locoarticwolf2181 Рік тому +91

    What if Ventress Killed Grevious during their duel on Dathomir?
    What if Ashoka redeemed Vader on Malachor?
    What if Maul and Kenobi made peace on Tatooine and teamed up?
    What if Vader won the Darksaber, ruling Mandalore?
    What if Anakin/Vader was a double agent playing the long game?
    What if Thrawn joined the Republic?
    What if Vader survived and lead the Imperial Remnant.
    What if Padme managed to free Anakin’s Mother?
    What if Hondo actually traded in a Captive Dooku instead of double crossing?
    What if Echos of Oblivion didn’t happen in SWTOR and Vitiate/Valkrion returned during the movies akin to your Darth JarJar fic spanning the saga?
    What if Vader and Thrawn lead a Imperial Rebellion separate from the main one?
    What if Starkiller survived and trained the Skywalker Twins?
    What if Lord Starkiller replaced Vader in the Original Trilogy after TFU1 Darkside Ending (not counting DLC)
    What if Legends New Republic fought the First/Final Order?
    What if the Empire was Good and the Rebels were Bad?

    • @JohnGeorgeBauerBuis
      @JohnGeorgeBauerBuis Рік тому

      Very interesting. A strong New Republic would definitely beat the ‘First Order’, not instantly, but they would definitely beat them.

    • @josh10177
      @josh10177 Рік тому

      To a regular Joe making his way B re galaxy. The empire Was good and the rebellion Was bad. the battle of Yavin was the empires' 9-11. And Luke was bin Laden

  • @chefmatthewlafferty
    @chefmatthewlafferty Рік тому +11

    Technically, it was Tarkin who ordered the destruction of Alderaan. Vader didn't stop him because his hands were tied, figuratively.

  • @TheKasimkage
    @TheKasimkage Рік тому +3

    14:29 “Ambassador of Genocide” is an awesome wrestler name.
    “Era of Terror” is also an awesome metal band name.

  • @TheSeptacle
    @TheSeptacle Рік тому +3

    I’ve never much like fan fictions, but I thought this one was very good. I loved the scene where Anakin reconciles with his family. And I have to give you props for incorporating basically every Canon piece of Star Wars media into one fanfiction.

  • @locoarticwolf2181
    @locoarticwolf2181 Рік тому +42

    I hope things turn out well here. Looks like a redemption on the Death Star. But knowing Star Wars. Maybe sacrifice’s must be made.

    • @wargamesmaster
      @wargamesmaster Рік тому +5

      Yeah... Vader oversaw the destruction of Alderaan AND tortured his own daughter (he didn't know who she was but still...) and that's only the latest crimes he commited at this point, it will not end well for him.

  • @RyuKaguya
    @RyuKaguya Рік тому +6

    To be fair Alderaan was all Tarkin. Vader just watched.

  • @Kubinda12345
    @Kubinda12345 Рік тому +32

    I've some ideas for What If:
    - What if Palpatine wasn't elected the chancellor of the Republic in Phantom Menace?
    - What if Anakin's bombing run managed to kill Grievous on Malevolence
    - What if it was Saw and not Steela who died on Onderon?
    - What if Anakin killed Dooku in their duel during the Rako Hardeen arc?
    - What if Tarkin died in the Citadel meaning there would be no Tarkin Doctrine for the Empire?
    - What if Qi'ra joined the Galactic Empire with Han perhaps becoming an ISB agent?
    - What if Han killed Darth Vader during the battle of Yavin?
    - What if the Ashmead's Lock's prisoners succeeded in assassinating Mon Mothma meaning that Leia would become chancellor and the New Republic wouldn't demilitarize?

    • @SuspiciousSandalsFromIstanbul
      @SuspiciousSandalsFromIstanbul Рік тому +1

      It’s a question but how would Han kill Vader?

    • @wargamesmaster
      @wargamesmaster Рік тому +1

      @@SuspiciousSandalsFromIstanbul He managed to surprise attack his escort TIE Fighters in Episode IV, he could have hit Vader at that moment.

    • @jacksonconley5117
      @jacksonconley5117 Рік тому +2

      All good ideas, but I would like “What If Obi-Wan Never Followed Padme to Mustafar.”

    • @SuspiciousSandalsFromIstanbul
      @SuspiciousSandalsFromIstanbul Рік тому +1

      @@wargamesmaster oh yeah I forgot about that bit in a new hope

  • @andrewgardiner1077
    @andrewgardiner1077 Рік тому +7

    Here’s one.
    What if Mace Windu tipped the Jedi off about Chancellor Palpatine being a Sith Lord, before he, Agen Kolar, Saesee Tiin, and Kit Fisto headed to confront him?

  • @Maik_Privat
    @Maik_Privat Рік тому +371

    What if Ahsoka and Ezra saved Plo from Order 66?

    • @wargamesmaster
      @wargamesmaster Рік тому +122

      This has so much potential, I'm in. Hell, I would watch a what if Ezra saved Dooku (he doesn't know who he is and if he saw the terrified old man about to be beheaded in front of a joyful Sidious, I can see Ezra saving him) when he was about to be killed video.

    • @MapHist28
      @MapHist28 Рік тому +12

      @@wargamesmaster i wish i could up vote this

    • @maxtombs361
      @maxtombs361 Рік тому +4

      Good one

    • @ajtv17
      @ajtv17 Рік тому +13

      Ezra wasn’t born then

    • @Fatherofheroesandheroines
      @Fatherofheroesandheroines Рік тому +8

      Except Ezra wasnt born. I believe Ahsoka though.

  • @Женёк-б5в
    @Женёк-б5в Рік тому +6

    Vader did not destroy Aldaran. Tarkin did it. Vader was just there nearby at this moment.

  • @ubercow6611
    @ubercow6611 Рік тому +36

    What if Chewbacca was given his medal after the battle of Yavin?

    • @enashinononomesan
      @enashinononomesan Рік тому +9

      He would be happy.

    • @Real_Amphy
      @Real_Amphy Рік тому +4

      We would have one less meme in the sequels.

    • @jackreacher4488
      @jackreacher4488 Рік тому +3

      In the novel he did, but the ribbon was too short to fit around his neck.

  • @MrMolay44
    @MrMolay44 Рік тому +31

    What if Bane succesfully possessed each Sith lords afterward?

  • @shankleythebest
    @shankleythebest Рік тому +5

    "he may have made a little oopsie"
    😂😂😂

    • @estherfu6288
      @estherfu6288 Рік тому

      😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @TarsonTalon
    @TarsonTalon Рік тому +7

    Ah man Thrawn done dirty again. I think seeing the Empire was broken, he'd probably try his shot at joining the Republic military. He didn't, after all, join the Empire for his own ambitions, but for the chance to save his people.

  • @Kubinda12345
    @Kubinda12345 Рік тому +18

    An interesting tearjerking scenario.
    However it's kind of funny that Vader's supposed greatest crime - destruction of Alderaan - was not his doing and he never even supported the Death Star.
    Nice insert of Andor characters like Dedra.
    I just want to know what happened with Gallius Rax and the Sith Eternal since neither of them were mentioned. Exegol probably exploded when the Sith died but what about Operation Cinder?

  • @AtlasMays
    @AtlasMays Рік тому +1

    "He may have made a little oopsie" is the understatement of the fucking year. I love it

  • @venator-yv1gw
    @venator-yv1gw Рік тому +16

    What if Anakin kept tinkering in the Jedi Temple and made himself a blaster?

    • @lilknox2225
      @lilknox2225 Рік тому +4

      He just goes full on cal kestis, has a blaster and a lightsaber that can do 1million things

  • @ttlghosty
    @ttlghosty Рік тому +7

    Absolutely amazing video and congrats on 75k man, well earned and well deserved!!

  • @emelyu
    @emelyu Рік тому +11

    Vader did not give the order for Alderaan to be destroyed. Tarkin did. It would not surprise me if the Emperor told Tarkin to destroy Alderaan. Vader just stood there.

    • @Fordo007
      @Fordo007 Рік тому +6

      I’m the old EU Palpatine was livid Tarkin did it for the bad PR it brought.

  • @charleswiley9562
    @charleswiley9562 Рік тому +3

    DV looking at han: son? 🥺
    Ben: no the other one
    Dv: 🥹

  • @FFA441
    @FFA441 Рік тому +5

    Seeing anakin heal his kyber crystal and visions of his happiness would be alot of fun to see on screen. Dude deserves a happy ending for sure

  • @kevinfox500
    @kevinfox500 Рік тому +8

    Enjoyedit as usual. Excellent writing and narration. Well done, abd thank you.
    Turned a bad day into one I could make it through. Phantom limb waa acting up hard today. Needed the distraction, and this gem took my mind off it.
    Words can't express my gratitude, on these days.

  • @irruption4770
    @irruption4770 Рік тому +4

    What if Bastilla Shan Trained Anakin?
    What if Anakin was a Mando Jedi?
    What if Meetra Surik Trained Anakin?
    What if Anakin was Trained by Darth Sion (much like how Darth Nihilous did)
    What if Anakin Trained Barris Offee?

  • @rohandholakia3970
    @rohandholakia3970 Рік тому +5

    -What if anakin skywalker found the world between worlds during the clone wars and saved qui gon jinn
    -what if padme turned anakin back to the light
    -what if darth vader overthrew palpatine

  • @Edgar_Hoods
    @Edgar_Hoods Рік тому +2

    4:34 Well yes, but actually no. In the future, Han Solo is his son in law, but currently not.

  • @lanternkid1701
    @lanternkid1701 Рік тому +4

    This was very good. I enjoyed this immensely

  • @darealestwon
    @darealestwon Рік тому +3

    Your writing is really good. The one where Vader trained luke and subjugated palatine was the best! This one is good too.

  • @princessoscar3089
    @princessoscar3089 Рік тому +5

    Lol now do a "What if Vader learned Leia was his daughter during the KENOBI series"!!!

  • @blackcat940
    @blackcat940 Рік тому +12

    What if anakin went undercover instead of obi wan?
    What if padme was infertile?
    What if when anakin died he wakes up in his younger self?

    • @hackman669
      @hackman669 Рік тому +2

      So Anakin wakes up in a cloned body?

    • @blackcat940
      @blackcat940 Рік тому +3

      @@hackman669 no, more like waking up in the past.

  • @timothyschwartz5518
    @timothyschwartz5518 Рік тому +6

    What if Luke fell in love with Sabine Wren?
    What if Luke was raised by Boba Fett?
    What if Luke was raised by Rex?
    What if Quinlan Vos trained Luke?
    What if Luke was raised on Lothal?

    • @snookerdooker471
      @snookerdooker471 Рік тому +1

      How about what if Luke was raised by jar jar binks
      LOL!

    • @stefangonzo
      @stefangonzo Рік тому

      Luke raised by Rex. I'd like to see that

    • @timothyschwartz5518
      @timothyschwartz5518 Рік тому

      @stefangonzo I thought it was a good idea after reading the novelization of A New Hope were it had Luke meeting a Rex like character on Yavin IV also it could lead to other changes with like Luke joining the Rebel alliance earlier,being trained by both Ahsoka,and Kanan,and maybe a potential pairing with Sabine Wren.

  • @JoelGifted720
    @JoelGifted720 6 місяців тому

    “Yo dude, the light side is pretty chill maybe you can like come back or something” -Obi Wan Kenobi (NH)

  • @S0APS_
    @S0APS_ Рік тому +3

    What if the Amidalians and Crimson Dawn (Post Solo) survived. Remember, a million hands are stronger than one.

  • @brokenbridge6316
    @brokenbridge6316 Рік тому +11

    "What if" Sabine Wren was Force-Sensitive?

  • @dylanh7600
    @dylanh7600 Рік тому +11

    Tarkin ordered the destuction, also i would not call obi a pro at teaching skywalkers😂

  • @nathanmarlowe4418
    @nathanmarlowe4418 Рік тому +2

    Anakin Vader was heartbroken and deceived, and deserves mercy and allowed to live

  • @Skarrier
    @Skarrier 2 дні тому

    19:59 - i think there wouldn't have been any "disappointment" on Sidious part, he would've basically sensed that Anakin is no longer a Sith and, like, disassembled him on atomic level the millisecond Anakin walked in his line of sight. That might've been one of the rare moments when Sidious actually gets overwhelmed by "classic sith-grade rage" instead of keeping his calm and plotting demeanor.

  • @DrJRaven
    @DrJRaven 11 місяців тому +2

    Very well presented. Thanks.

  • @oliversherman2414
    @oliversherman2414 Рік тому +1

    You always come up with the best scenarios

  • @danielharman572
    @danielharman572 Рік тому +4

    What if asoka tano told grandmaster yoda about what darth maul said to her about dark sidious grooming anakin skywalker for years in an attempt to make skywalker his dark side apprentice. What if she also told obi-wan kanobi as well. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.

  • @williebill73
    @williebill73 11 місяців тому

    I've been listening to your stories for awhile now and this will be the first time I comment. As a fan from when they first came out I gotta say that I've enjoyed your stories. I honestly think you should be a writer in your own right. Also I enjoy your creativity with the way you have done things. Also Vader has always been my favorite since I was 4. This was also back in 1977 btw. Again thank you for your stories. This old fan enjoys them more than you can know.

  • @chromxrobinandcorrinxcamil9031

    😳
    Didn’t expect to see this scenario.

  • @schitflowsdwnhil
    @schitflowsdwnhil Рік тому +2

    "looking forward to completing your training"

  • @coolpig3859
    @coolpig3859 Рік тому +2

    These videos are awesome they remind me a lot of Salad Saiyan’s DB what-if’s

  • @voryntheriolu2525
    @voryntheriolu2525 Рік тому +9

    What if Palpatine turned to the light during the clone wars?

  • @AORaiMechWork
    @AORaiMechWork Рік тому +3

    Dad mode vader activate

  • @redaxer2908
    @redaxer2908 Рік тому +1

    What if Uncle Owen and Aunt Beru lived?
    What if Anakin's mother lived?
    What if Anakin died in the podrace?
    What if Boba Fett was at the Battle of Endor?
    What if Han died from being frozen in carbonite?
    What if Luke fell to his death at Cloud City?
    What if Obi-Wan and Anakin fought Dooku together at Genosis?

  • @Fenris77
    @Fenris77 Рік тому

    17:31 Great now that they know they are siblings there will not be that awkward kiss on Echo Base, and thus avoid that horror...
    Great video btw. I great "What if". Been planning a Fanfiction that might have an early redemption for "Vader" in that one.

  • @brentbarr4679
    @brentbarr4679 Рік тому +2

    Dude you have to get this animated this is too good of a story not to. I hope this is something that could happen

  • @darrellhall6622
    @darrellhall6622 Рік тому +1

    Darth, before we fight, I have to tell you something.
    You are a father
    I HAVE A CHILD!!

  • @MarvinHartmann452
    @MarvinHartmann452 Рік тому +34

    What if George Lucas never sold his création to Disney ?

    • @surferdude4487
      @surferdude4487 Рік тому +4

      YES! This is a What If I would really like to see.

    • @Endrgamr262
      @Endrgamr262 Рік тому +3

      Easy nothing would have went to shit the end😂

    • @kevinfox500
      @kevinfox500 Рік тому +3

      ​@@Endrgamr262unless you ask the OT fanbois, eho feel it's been ruined since 97.
      Hell. I'm in. Especially if PPSW does it as a miniseries, or complete trilogy. Myself, I like all 3, and the EU.
      No. I refuse to call it Legends.

    • @lukerp1581
      @lukerp1581 Рік тому

      Do you idiots ever realize that Disney revived StarWars? StarWars wasn’t going anywhere without them

  • @Yapftl
    @Yapftl Рік тому +8

    What if Obi Wan survived the Death Star and fought Vader with Luke

  • @lukejohnson4975
    @lukejohnson4975 Рік тому +11

    What if Vader permitted Palpatine (Sidious) to kill Luke with force lightning on the Second Death Star, not returning fully to the light? What if Luke succumbed fully to his emotions and murdered his father Vader, onboard the Second Death Star, succeeding him as Palpatine's newest, and most powerful, apprentice?

  • @davegrim4639
    @davegrim4639 Рік тому +4

    What if a character in the Legends continuity uses the World Between Worlds to change history, causing a divergence that creates the new Disney Canon? At what point do the two timelines diverge? Why would someone from Legends want to reset that timeline? Perhaps to spare the lives of the billions of lives lost in the Yuuzhan Vong invasion?
    Disney should have at least acknowledged and retconned the old EU continuity before going in a new direction. A story like this could have done this.

  • @kevincrawford8594
    @kevincrawford8594 Рік тому +1

    I like how the older version of Obi-Wan (Ewan) looks a lot like Sir Alec

  • @LordMayorOfDairyBell
    @LordMayorOfDairyBell Рік тому +3

    What if Vader lost his mind and became a mindless killer? He is just an animal without any form of higher thought.

  • @MichaelCollins-dl5om
    @MichaelCollins-dl5om Рік тому +6

    The thing is Vader did not destroy Alderaan, Tarkin did.

  • @creativespark61
    @creativespark61 Рік тому +1

    I need to get this off my chest because I have seen before and heard often in this video "Vader is to blame for Aderaan". But he wasn't because it was Tarkin's plan, and Tarkin ran the whole station, not Vader. Tarkin gave the final order.

  • @Iwillone
    @Iwillone Рік тому +4

    What if Han Solo was Anakin/Darth Vader’s son would actually be interesting 🤔

  • @TheMimiSard
    @TheMimiSard Рік тому +1

    This basically a fanfic in audio form, but different than a podfic.

  • @baliyae
    @baliyae Рік тому +8

    Technically, Luke saved Darth Vader *for* him in Return of the Jedi.

  • @generalobi-wan4693
    @generalobi-wan4693 Рік тому +2

    Bro thank you very much I never thought of this this is my favorite one so far since what if the sith empire returned
    Can you please make a video about what if Monster Zero was in Star Wars.

  • @lonewolf-0459
    @lonewolf-0459 Рік тому +6

    I would imagine that if Anakin ended up surviving an encounter where he killed Palpatine he would definitely need a new suit. I gather that it's not something most would think about in reguards to how it goes from cutting the head off the empire to him probably in a bacta tank getting a new suit. That can be left up to interpretation. The reason I felt like adding thos was because of the idea of the design for a new suit. Ultimately it can look exceptionally different from his suit when he was Vader given that suit was intentionally designed with limitations by the emperor. I would imagine said suit would have some mechanical life support systems that can be rather different than the ones seen on his previous suit given that was old tech but alongside that baring some reblance to the armor he wore during his time fighting in the clone wars, but furthermore it's coloring bearing potentially silver/white as a primary color that I can easily see being debated for another color but the color I don't want to really debate to much is some yellow accents as a callback/reminder of his old jedi starfighter which only had yellow as a callback/reminder of his speeder from episode 1.
    Beautiful what if video though I just had this idea run across in my head while watching this and felt I couldn't resist but add my thoughts in the comments. I am curious as to see what people would make of the idea of a suit for Anakin post redemption. I mean god knows what the life support and tech would look like but calling back to more pleasent days with the asphects is a good idea I feel. I just want to have a better idea as to what that would look like.

  • @seyacosmoprowertheseedrian2757

    Unusual what if but it could be fun
    What if one of the Clones (Such as Fives, Rex or Cody) was the Chosen One?

  • @peteandrepeat6979
    @peteandrepeat6979 Рік тому +2

    Bro I have a great fan fic idea: What if savage never died in TCW and lived on to train under maul until maul dies somehow (Vader, kenobi, sidious ect) then either Vader or sidious takes him up as their apprentice or new apprentice
    Please do this one it has so many possibilities and I would finally get to see one of the best cut off to early villains get more time to develop

    • @y.n.tryone4683
      @y.n.tryone4683 10 місяців тому

      Don’t think Vader would or could kill maul probally kenobi or sidious , and if he trained with maul , he would be a rival to Vader and sidious

  • @PrinceYamiUchihaCosplay
    @PrinceYamiUchihaCosplay 10 місяців тому

    27:51 always cracks me up every time I revisit this What-If

  • @Darth_Knightmare
    @Darth_Knightmare Рік тому +1

    Destroy his daughter homeworld and calls it just a oopsie 😂😂😂

  • @valkorian3172
    @valkorian3172 Рік тому +2

    What if Valkorian succeeded in consuming all life in the entire galaxy becoming a all powerful force god of death. Subsequently he was sent to a alternate universe during the clone wars.
    I wonder how Palpatine, Dooku, the Jedi order, the Republic and the Separatists react to Valkorian having more potential then Anakin. Being able to throw planets with the force.

  • @jakethepancake
    @jakethepancake Рік тому +3

    This was a good one but how about this idea:
    What if Anakin was self-taught?

  • @danielharman572
    @danielharman572 Рік тому +2

    Yet another cool story. I enjoy your videos alot. All the best for you and yours. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.

  • @alexm.h.8270
    @alexm.h.8270 Рік тому +1

    nice video, but a little correction the order to destroy Alderaan wasn´t the Order of Vader!!! It was the Order of Tarkin, you can even see it in the 4 Movie. Tarkin give the Order, the only think Vader do is standing behind Leia without doing something

  • @misterosbam1931
    @misterosbam1931 Рік тому

    Been here since roughly 1K subscribers and I have no intention of leaving! I enjoy the use of AI images to get the specific one you need, I've never seen anyone do that before. Looking forward to seeing you grow as a creator!

  • @MrMikedejeuner
    @MrMikedejeuner Рік тому

    3:00
    what is the name of the background music ?

  • @RyanStarr-bn9dv
    @RyanStarr-bn9dv 9 місяців тому

    What if Obi Wan bought the death sticks?
    What if Anakin absolutely LOVED sand?
    What if Yoda had horrible diarrhea on Kashyyk?
    What about the droid attack on the Wookies?
    What if Qui Gon was clapping Shmi Skywalker?
    What if Anakin sucked at pod racing?

  • @vodkalord6941
    @vodkalord6941 Рік тому +3

    what if Palpatine didnt grant Anakin the title/rank of Darth ?
    what if Anakin bested obi wan on mustafar and obi wan ended up burned, disarmed but yoda saved him and turned him into a cyborg akin to general grievous?
    what if Anakin lost the pod race?

  • @billymiles6870
    @billymiles6870 Рік тому +7

    Vader did NOT give the order to destroy Alderaan. That was Tarken. He also did not kill Amidala. Get your facts straight. Sidius killed her through the Force. Please understand these things.

    • @potkan07
      @potkan07 Рік тому

      Sidious didn't kill her either, she lost will to live.

    • @jasonmcallen8954
      @jasonmcallen8954 Рік тому

      ​@@potkan07Hate to tell you. But the fans overruled Lucas' decision on that.

    • @jasonmcallen8954
      @jasonmcallen8954 Рік тому

      Vader still tortured Leia and countless innocents. But yeah small details like forgetting who ordered the destruction of a planet is hard to ignore. Though be careful, Pente is one of those types of youtube creators who attacks his critics. Even if they're valid.

    • @potkan07
      @potkan07 Рік тому

      @@jasonmcallen8954 nope

    • @jasonmcallen8954
      @jasonmcallen8954 Рік тому

      @@potkan07 Yep. Now cry your neckbeard tears.

  • @anathardayaldar
    @anathardayaldar Рік тому +1

    Palpatine should have been able to sense Vader's trechery.
    He went down alittle too conveniently.

  • @sylv48
    @sylv48 5 місяців тому

    "Vader may have made a little oopsy" 😂

  • @Kamilohbk
    @Kamilohbk 11 місяців тому

    Just one note: Thrawn wasnt promoted until right before the Battle of Endor, so with palpy dying this earlier, Thrawn would have been a simple Admiral.

  • @Goldstandard_1
    @Goldstandard_1 Рік тому +1

    I would like to think that Thrawn after he found out the empire was completely gone, would just return to his people, if they were ok with it, and live his life

  • @GalacticGamingClips
    @GalacticGamingClips 4 місяці тому

    I find it so weird when I finally see the face behind these story telling voices, I forget they are real people to 😂😂😂❤️

  • @AlohaJade808
    @AlohaJade808 Рік тому +1

    😂😂😂 the moment Obi-Wan told Anakin the children’s names!! If only that actually happened!! Hey George Lucas, wanna do a ReDo? A New Hope Redo? 🔁🤔 George, Have Obi-Wan tell Vader his children’s names during the fight in the hanger bay!!

  • @MacstersUndead
    @MacstersUndead Рік тому +3

    What if Greedo shot first and was hired by Kenobi to take them to Alderaan?

  • @mr.goodman3991
    @mr.goodman3991 Рік тому +1

    If Anakin doesn’t kill the emperor, then it would mean that, he was not the prophesied chosen one.
    The chosen one is, the one who brings balance to the force. Not light, nor dark.

  • @East_Coast_Toasty_Boy
    @East_Coast_Toasty_Boy Рік тому

    1:57 General Grevious has entered the chat.

  • @arturtourinho6449
    @arturtourinho6449 Рік тому +2

    I realy want that story to continue