This 25 minutes shows us what occupation architecture means, with the walls of shame, the psagot occupation site and its investigation, the viaducts cutting through the Palestinian land, and many other researches. you have to watch. I learned a lot as an architect. Many thanks to Eyal Weizmana and his team
As an architect myself, we learn a very different aspect of architecture from Eyal Weizman. I follow him and his research with curiosity and love them. FREE PALESTINE!
Really open your eyes to the enormity of the extent how Israel has consistently inflicted horrors on a helpless civilian population. If Israel has a right to defend itself shouldn't Palestinians also have that right ? Greedy people will never thrive in this world . Only for a time. Educate yourselves people instead of putting emotion before common sense on this conflict. Not another "nakba" !
Not true. An Architect designs buildings. What has this guy designed? His commentary on the israel-palestinian conflict has very little to do with architecture. Why don't you just admit that you hate jews?
@@DaveyDisc "People should just do their job and speaking truth to power means you hate the people who are oppressed by said power". Get out of here with this fascist bs.
@@TeknoSquirrel Lol. What fascist bs? Because I asked very straight forward questions about this "brilliant architect" and the relevance to architect....? You haven't bothered responding, just ordered me out. Who is the fascist here LOL get a clue buddy
QUOTE 2:51 - “The settlements which are here in blue have been built like wedges not only to serve the colonists themselves but consciously to create material damage cutting apart the very sort of fragile Palestinian built fabric. Architecture is used by architect as a weapon.” I was privileged to visit Israel for three weeks in ’84. It was part of a project that I found myself catapulted into. I was imprinted to be religious, where the father is the head of the household. What he said was law. I found myself as a true bonafide widow, in religious terms “Wife of God” I had reached the pinnacle. I couldn’t get any closer to God (spiritually) than that. My past attitude had always been one of Worship. (a feeling or expression of reverence and adoration of a deity). I set out to prove if this was factual. I had the means financially. I was going to visit his castle on earth, Jerusalem. I even got to spend 5 minutes by myself in his tomb, thanks to a guard there. I choose not to spend my time buying things but I opted to experience the “country of Israel” as a culture. What impressed me at that time, was how rubble was cleared away, only to build structures on top of its clearing. Our tour guide, had the uncanny ability to have open access to anywhere, Jewish and Arab alike and best of all, no waiting in lines. If, we look at the Middle Eastern Conflict “the separation of Palestinians by the Israeli’s” it bears the markings of INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY not the intelligence of water molecules. “Blue water is the only known example of a ‘natural color caused by VIBRATIONAL transitions.’” Fresh and salt water know how to co-exist “harmoniously” on this earth, without boundaries. So, “Why would the Israeli’s insist on behaving as a specific frequency (the rate at which something is repeated over a particular period of time.) Could it be something as simple as a color? Could IS-RAY-OF-LIGHTS be the clue? During WWII, the “yellow armbands” represented the holocaust. This would automatically turn off the rods in the eyeball. And, once the color of the rods (yellow) within the eyeball is turned off, perception naturally fills in the space. Does this sound familiar? Is this not what the video reveals” It appears that post WWII Zionists are continuously responding to “always, always trust your first gut instincts. if you feel something’s wrong. it usually is.” “Even though I walk through the darkest (Palestine) valley, I (Israel) will fear no evil, for thou are with me, thy (yellow) rod and thy staff they comfort me.” - Psalm 23:4 Too simple? Maybe, not. It’s obvious peace talks were never meant to work, because they don’t address the true cause. This issue lies close to my heart, “in the Netherlands an underground newspaper printed 300,000 yellow stars with the statement ‘Jews and non Jews are one and the same on May 1st, 1942.” My aunt died in Ravensbruck concentration camp on Jan 9, 1944, as a political prisoner in the Netherlands.
merci pour la vidéo qui fait réfléchir sur les problématiques des conflits a tout les étages dans le mondes pour par l'architectures na pas de frontières aux contraire apport des visions d'un respect entre les hommes les femmes et les enfants . merci encore pour la vidéo .
Yes. We know. It all started when they hit back. We remember how the Palestinians stormed the streets of Odessa, Warsaw and Minsk - attacking every Jew in their way.
This is just too depressing to watch, does not bring out the best in me, bailing at 10 min. Lots of positive things to look at...... Low points in human ignorance could be an appropriate title for this series.
גגות אדומים זה פשוט יפה , ככה תמיד בנו פה , כמות השיש והחרסינה שיש בארץ מתקופות קודמות מלמדת על כך , זה שהערבים לא בונים ככה לא מזיז לי. ככה בונים בתוך הקו הירוק בלי קשר ליצור פרובוקציות , זה פשוט יפה ומתאים לאזור ים תיכוני כמו ישראל.
Wow this is a racist comment section. At the end of the day both sides in this conflict are equally responsible for the violence. Conflict takes at least two. Violence should be condemned on both sides and no more money or weapons should be sent to either of them until they sort it out. However one side has a lot more power, as shown in this episode, to stop the conflict but refuses to do so. Now this man is using his skills positively in a place where positivety at times seems lost at least in it's media portrayal
***** I mean I'd say it would have always been so. Israel is a war machine and Palestine is has literally no ability to defend itself without the aid of terrorists.
You can't build a home in the USA without a permit. Or most places. Why should palestinians be given a free pass to do anything? Your logic is moronic.
what a bunch of bull crap 1:13 why should the solider let him close? he knows perfectly well the nearby population is hostile to the Israeli army and attempts have been made to shot them with small arms.. why would the solider let him closer under that risk? 3:11 the map he holds in his hand is different then the one displayed just a moment before. 4:44 what is wrong with trying to give a neighborhood character? these things are being done all over the world in cities with high tourist rate 5:46 ever wonder why are there such high walls around the bridge? stones and gun fire for arab homes is the reason. 6:37 what?! are u kidding me? a. there is nothing stoping arab homes from using red bricks on their roofs, b.the Israeli air force does not need that kind of visual mark to know where are the jewish homes and where are the arab homes. 7:02 lololololol these are houses not optical devises, people live there, that all animation is ridicules, yes people like living on high grounds that is only natural to wish for a view from your house, this is not done as a part of some grand scheme. 7:40 the translation misses some small nuances, the guy says that out of fear of suicide attacks they didn't use buses so whenever he or a member of his family wanted to go somewhere they needed to find other solutions. and now when the wall is up they don't live in fear 9:20 the borders the checkpoints the fences were put there after the acts of violence against Israel for our protection, the arab population can blame their leadership for it, the valley is not Israel fault and just sounds ridicules when he says it. 11:06 get over it highways are being built all over the world all the time and people movement get restricted by it all the time all over the world including Israeli citizens. 11:30 well yes it make sense to make the soldiers less visible and thus less vulnerable, if they were visible I bet he would say that the soldiers are visible in order to oppress. 13:28 omg red roofs lol 13:48 ye well the place was a war zone with heavy fighting not lala land, the army did what was needed to find the terrorists and protect its soldiers. its the "resistances" fault to hide inside the heart of the city within population 16:39 ok fine u are right next time we will ask our soldiers to go trough the streets like lams to the slaughter, will make it much easier for the enemy to use i.e.ds and ambush tactics on known paths, sorry note taken (sarcasm) 19:07 the soldier steps in, risks his life and ask her to move, she tells him to f*** off so they make way, and there she goes saying she was hoping to die, I wonder what would happen in America if someone would tell a policemen to f*** off or anywhere else in the world for that matter, Italian policeman or Russian solider, try it. 23:03 a sad story that has nothing to do with architecture, and only one side telling the story
***** I wish to respond to what u have said here, but there is actually zero relevant content in you last comment. and again I say, no one pays me for commenting on youtube, that would be ridicules by anyone's standards
***** lol so much paranoia so much suspicion and imagination, I type my comments here since I want people to hear the other side of the story and not only the palestinian narrative, I do it since al Jazeera is biased and some people use it as their main news source and should hear the other side even if u really really don't want to. I am sorry for bursting your illusions of a beautiful simple story of david and goliath, for this more complex way of thinking that better represents reality, u are free to continue to ignore it
+Safa Joma Let's face it, Safa, your views are no different from those of ISIS. You understand so little about building a world founded upon peace and love. It appears that your paramount objective is to create a world free of what you call "infidels." Where I come from that's aptly called genocide.
+Safa Joma I have already evaluated your background, Safa, and have spoken to several of your neighbors. Speaking of cruelty you occupy a Holy Land that rightfully belongs to another faith. You have 57 muslim-majority countries already but nothing is ever enough for you. You make no compromises in an effort to achieve peace. You justify the murder of innocents and dismiss their suffering. You and your leaders praise those as martyrs who slaughter babies and women and the elderly. If that is not cruelty what is? You only talk about your right to self-determination while completely dismissing the right to self-determination of those who have been indigenous to the land for 2000 years before you even became a faith. You have no comprehension whatsoever of what it means to live in peace and in harmony with others, specifically Christian and Jews...And that is why we will never have peace until you teach your children to love life more than they hate the infidel.
+Safa Joma Safa, I live in what you and your Palestinian HAMAS brethren call Palestine. But those of us true believers who seek love and peace call it Israel.
+Safa Joma Safa, Tou and I both know that over 12,500 rockets came in from that territory, your Gaza, Palestinian Hamas Gaza, into the land of Israel murdering Jewish civilians indiscriminately. That is not my opinion. That is a statement of unequivocal fact. The Palestinian Hamas Charter expressly states that its objective is the destruction of the Jewish state. I ask you a simple question: How does one make peace with a murderous Islamic regime like that?
+Safa Joma As I said before, Safa (the "young girl" who hides behind her avatar), only when you teach your children to love life more than they hate me, then can there at that point be peace. Also isn't it funny how many videos you have on your UA-cam channel that glorify death? Remarkable how on each one of your videos the whole time your Mujahideen are screaming Allahu Akbar. The fact is there is no difference from you and Hamas, Hezbollah, ISIS, Al Nusra, Al-Qaeda, Boko Harem, Al Shabab, Abu Sayyaf, Muslim Brotherhood, Islamic Jihad, Jaama Islamiya, PFLP, Lakshar Al Taiba, PLO... unfortunately the list goes on and on and on.
Wow this is a racist comment section. At the end of the day both sides in this conflict are equally responsible for the violence. Conflict takes at least two. Violence should be condemned on both sides and no more money or weapons should be sent to either of them until they sort it out. However one side has a lot more power, as shown in this episode, to stop the conflict but refuses to do so. Now this man is using his skills positively in a place where positivety at times seems lost at least in it's media portrayal
next time dont shoot rockets from street , or dont start war , or dont brake the ceasefire . simple logic . and numbers dont say anything about who is good or bad , the israelis invest money in technolagy like iron dome to save life terrorists invest money in terror .
Without a doubt, one of the best documentaries I've ever seen. And I've literally watched about a thousand of them.
Same
Incredible documentary. Weizman's forensic architecture project is so fascinating.
The least we can do is like this video so the algorithm helps spread the video inshaallah. keep up for good works, mashallah ❤
Old but still an extremely relevant documentary it seems
Excellent video. Chilling testimony and so clear. Thank you.
This 25 minutes shows us what occupation architecture means, with the walls of shame, the psagot occupation site and its investigation, the viaducts cutting through the Palestinian land, and many other researches. you have to watch. I learned a lot as an architect. Many thanks to Eyal Weizmana and his team
As an architect myself, we learn a very different aspect of architecture from Eyal Weizman. I follow him and his research with curiosity and love them. FREE PALESTINE!
Really open your eyes to the enormity of the extent how Israel has consistently inflicted horrors on a helpless civilian population. If Israel has a right to defend itself shouldn't Palestinians also have that right ? Greedy people will never thrive in this world . Only for a time. Educate yourselves people instead of putting emotion before common sense on this conflict. Not another "nakba" !
One of the most informative documentaries I have seen...
thank you for this illuminating program. let us hope this will clear the misconceptions of some people about israeli 's war on gaza.
i love how he calls the military tower a tube
非常好的一部纪录短片，生动表现了建筑与暴力的关系。
暴力不仅仅来源于枪炮，也可以来源于一个被建筑物所构造出来的敌对环境，通过这种敌对环境的压迫来迫使其中的居民屈服于设计者的意志。
I feel sick watching this. The evil genius in it is bone chilling. Very confronting, very shocking and scary.
this is great! GRACIAS POR REVOLUCIONAR EL PERIODISMO!
Great documentary this clarifies so much!
Thank you for this magnificent documentary!
Amazing documentary and a brilliant architect.
Not true. An Architect designs buildings. What has this guy designed? His commentary on the israel-palestinian conflict has very little to do with architecture. Why don't you just admit that you hate jews?
@@DaveyDisc "People should just do their job and speaking truth to power means you hate the people who are oppressed by said power". Get out of here with this fascist bs.
@@TeknoSquirrel Lol. What fascist bs? Because I asked very straight forward questions about this "brilliant architect" and the relevance to architect....? You haven't bothered responding, just ordered me out. Who is the fascist here LOL get a clue buddy
And Canada knows all about this....I'm ashamed of being Canadian.
shar848 I don't know how-can you show me pls? :)
This video is a lie
@@alizakessler prove it
@@alizakesslerwhen the hearts are blind
That was pretty fascinating.
Great insight here thnx, question though could not figure out if we were looking at Warsaw back in WW2or South Africa during APARTHEID?
QUOTE 2:51 - “The settlements which are here in blue have been built like wedges not only to serve the colonists themselves but consciously to create material damage cutting apart the very sort of fragile Palestinian built fabric. Architecture is used by architect as a weapon.”
I was privileged to visit Israel for three weeks in ’84. It was part of a project that I found myself catapulted into. I was imprinted to be religious, where the father is the head of the household. What he said was law.
I found myself as a true bonafide widow, in religious terms “Wife of God” I had reached the pinnacle. I couldn’t get any closer to God (spiritually) than that. My past attitude had always been one of Worship. (a feeling or expression of reverence and adoration of a deity). I set out to prove if this was factual. I had the means financially. I was going to visit his castle on earth, Jerusalem. I even got to spend 5 minutes by myself in his tomb, thanks to a guard there.
I choose not to spend my time buying things but I opted to experience the “country of Israel” as a culture.
What impressed me at that time, was how rubble was cleared away, only to build structures on top of its clearing.
Our tour guide, had the uncanny ability to have open access to anywhere, Jewish and Arab alike and best of all, no waiting in lines.
If, we look at the Middle Eastern Conflict “the separation of Palestinians by the Israeli’s” it bears the markings of INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY not the intelligence of water molecules.
“Blue water is the only known example of a ‘natural color caused by VIBRATIONAL transitions.’” Fresh and salt water know how to co-exist “harmoniously” on this earth, without boundaries.
So, “Why would the Israeli’s insist on behaving as a specific frequency (the rate at which something is repeated over a particular period of time.) Could it be something as simple as a color? Could IS-RAY-OF-LIGHTS be the clue?
During WWII, the “yellow armbands” represented the holocaust. This would automatically turn off the rods in the eyeball. And, once the color of the rods (yellow) within the eyeball is turned off, perception naturally fills in the space. Does this sound familiar? Is this not what the video reveals”
It appears that post WWII Zionists are continuously responding to “always, always trust your first gut instincts. if you feel something’s wrong. it usually is.”
“Even though I walk through the darkest (Palestine) valley, I (Israel) will fear no evil, for thou are with me, thy (yellow) rod and thy staff they comfort me.” - Psalm 23:4
Too simple? Maybe, not. It’s obvious peace talks were never meant to work, because they don’t address the true cause.
This issue lies close to my heart, “in the Netherlands an underground newspaper printed 300,000 yellow stars with the statement ‘Jews and non Jews are one and the same on May 1st, 1942.” My aunt died in Ravensbruck concentration camp on Jan 9, 1944, as a political prisoner in the Netherlands.
Israel isn't the colonists
merci pour la vidéo qui fait réfléchir sur les problématiques des conflits a tout les étages dans le mondes pour par l'architectures na pas de frontières aux contraire apport des visions d'un respect entre les hommes les femmes et les enfants . merci encore pour la vidéo .
as an student, it was helpful for me to design
Stunning
another nice song at 11.30 min...... anyone? .......Nice Doc.!
"Eyal Weizman explains architecture's key role in the Israeli occupation of Palestine and the evolution of urban warfare."
no occupation and no Palestine
De stadsguerrilla is aldus volledig uitgedacht.
13:40 lol cutting the footage literally as he begins to pull his arm back to throw the stone. Nice
+TheAlbinoskunk I'm pretty sure a tank causes more devastation than stones.........
Thats not the point, the point is symbolism, rebellion
Yes. We know. It all started when they hit back. We remember how the Palestinians stormed the streets of Odessa, Warsaw and Minsk - attacking every Jew in their way.
if that's what you chose to pick out of a 25min feature and comment on, and with others having the same mentality, then no wonder (the) war persists.
Wow
This is just too depressing to watch, does not bring out the best in me, bailing at 10 min. Lots of positive things to look at...... Low points in human ignorance could be an appropriate title for this series.
Robert Aldo go buy a cupcake then
.
מסכים עם הרוב. הקטע עם הגגות האדומים - שטות גמורה. זו כבר פרובוקציה מיותרת. וזאת אני אומר בתור איש חיל האויר!
גגות אדומים זה פשוט יפה , ככה תמיד בנו פה , כמות השיש והחרסינה שיש בארץ מתקופות קודמות מלמדת על כך , זה שהערבים לא בונים ככה לא מזיז לי. ככה בונים בתוך הקו הירוק בלי קשר ליצור פרובוקציות , זה פשוט יפה ומתאים לאזור ים תיכוני כמו ישראל.
Wow this is a racist comment section. At the end of the day both sides in this conflict are equally responsible for the violence. Conflict takes at least two. Violence should be condemned on both sides and no more money or weapons should be sent to either of them until they sort it out. However one side has a lot more power, as shown in this episode, to stop the conflict but refuses to do so. Now this man is using his skills positively in a place where positivety at times seems lost at least in it's media portrayal
***** I mean I'd say it would have always been so. Israel is a war machine and Palestine is has literally no ability to defend itself without the aid of terrorists.
You can't build a home in the USA without a permit. Or most places. Why should palestinians be given a free pass to do anything? Your logic is moronic.
Would you say the same about Jews in WW2? "... At the end of the day both sides in this conflict are equally responsible for the violence...."?
No. It's not a tango.
what a bunch of bull crap
1:13 why should the solider let him close? he knows perfectly well the nearby population is hostile to the Israeli army and attempts have been made to shot them with small arms.. why would the solider let him closer under that risk?
3:11 the map he holds in his hand is different then the one displayed just a moment before.
4:44 what is wrong with trying to give a neighborhood character? these things are being done all over the world in cities with high tourist rate
5:46 ever wonder why are there such high walls around the bridge? stones and gun fire for arab homes is the reason.
6:37 what?! are u kidding me? a. there is nothing stoping arab homes from using red bricks on their roofs, b.the Israeli air force does not need that kind of visual mark to know where are the jewish homes and where are the arab homes.
7:02 lololololol these are houses not optical devises, people live there, that all animation is ridicules, yes people like living on high grounds that is only natural to wish for a view from your house, this is not done as a part of some grand scheme.
7:40 the translation misses some small nuances, the guy says that out of fear of suicide attacks they didn't use buses so whenever he or a member of his family wanted to go somewhere they needed to find other solutions. and now when the wall is up they don't live in fear
9:20 the borders the checkpoints the fences were put there after the acts of violence against Israel for our protection, the arab population can blame their leadership for it, the valley is not Israel fault and just sounds ridicules when he says it.
11:06 get over it highways are being built all over the world all the time and people movement get restricted by it all the time all over the world including Israeli citizens.
11:30 well yes it make sense to make the soldiers less visible and thus less vulnerable, if they were visible I bet he would say that the soldiers are visible in order to oppress.
13:28 omg red roofs lol
13:48 ye well the place was a war zone with heavy fighting not lala land, the army did what was needed to find the terrorists and protect its soldiers. its the "resistances" fault to hide inside the heart of the city within population
16:39 ok fine u are right next time we will ask our soldiers to go trough the streets like lams to the slaughter, will make it much easier for the enemy to use i.e.ds and ambush tactics on known paths, sorry note taken (sarcasm)
19:07 the soldier steps in, risks his life and ask her to move, she tells him to f*** off so they make way, and there she goes saying she was hoping to die, I wonder what would happen in America if someone would tell a policemen to f*** off or anywhere else in the world for that matter, Italian policeman or Russian solider, try it.
23:03 a sad story that has nothing to do with architecture, and only one side telling the story
***** I wish to respond to what u have said here, but there is actually zero relevant content in you last comment.
and again I say, no one pays me for commenting on youtube, that would be ridicules by anyone's standards
***** lol so much paranoia so much suspicion and imagination, I type my comments here since I want people to hear the other side of the story and not only the palestinian narrative, I do it since al Jazeera is biased and some people use it as their main news source and should hear the other side even if u really really don't want to.
I am sorry for bursting your illusions of a beautiful simple story of david and goliath, for this more complex way of thinking that better represents reality, u are free to continue to ignore it
***** I never killed anyone and I never met or talked to anyone who killed anyone else
what brain detergent do you use!? it seems to work great!
ojo al piojo o snap u got me good, well done
Yawn.
I find it remarkable that he took 25 minutes to say absolutely nothing! What an utter waste.
+Safa Joma Let's face it, Safa, your views are no different from those of ISIS. You understand so little about building a world founded upon peace and love. It appears that your paramount objective is to create a world free of what you call "infidels." Where I come from that's aptly called genocide.
+Safa Joma I have already evaluated your background, Safa, and have spoken to several of your neighbors.
Speaking of cruelty you occupy a Holy Land that rightfully belongs to another faith. You have 57 muslim-majority countries already but nothing is ever enough for you. You make no compromises in an effort to achieve peace. You justify the murder of innocents and dismiss their suffering. You and your leaders praise those as martyrs who slaughter babies and women and the elderly. If that is not cruelty what is?
You only talk about your right to self-determination while completely dismissing the right to self-determination of those who have been indigenous to the land for 2000 years before you even became a faith.
You have no comprehension whatsoever of what it means to live in peace and in harmony with others, specifically Christian and Jews...And that is why we will never have peace until you teach your children to love life more than they hate the infidel.
+Safa Joma Safa, I live in what you and your Palestinian HAMAS brethren call Palestine. But those of us true believers who seek love and peace call it Israel.
+Safa Joma Safa, Tou and I both know that over 12,500 rockets came in from that territory, your Gaza, Palestinian Hamas Gaza, into the land of Israel murdering Jewish civilians indiscriminately. That is not my opinion. That is a statement of unequivocal fact. The Palestinian Hamas Charter expressly states that its objective is the destruction of the Jewish state.
I ask you a simple question: How does one make peace with a murderous Islamic regime like that?
+Safa Joma
As I said before, Safa (the "young girl" who hides behind her avatar), only when you teach your children to love life more than they hate me, then can there at that point be peace.
Also isn't it funny how many videos you have on your UA-cam channel that glorify death? Remarkable how on each one of your videos the whole time your Mujahideen are screaming Allahu Akbar.
The fact is there is no difference from you and Hamas, Hezbollah, ISIS, Al Nusra, Al-Qaeda, Boko Harem, Al Shabab, Abu Sayyaf, Muslim Brotherhood, Islamic Jihad, Jaama Islamiya, PFLP, Lakshar Al Taiba, PLO... unfortunately the list goes on and on and on.
Wow this is a racist comment section. At the end of the day both sides in this conflict are equally responsible for the violence. Conflict takes at least two. Violence should be condemned on both sides and no more money or weapons should be sent to either of them until they sort it out. However one side has a lot more power, as shown in this episode, to stop the conflict but refuses to do so. Now this man is using his skills positively in a place where positivety at times seems lost at least in it's media portrayal
next time dont shoot rockets from street , or dont start war , or dont brake the ceasefire . simple logic . and numbers dont say anything about who is good or bad , the israelis invest money in technolagy like iron dome to save life terrorists invest money in terror .