Many, many thanks for your excellent version of this work, one I have played and loved for over 50 years. And, as my harmony teacher always said, there is always something new to find in Bach’s music, you just have to keep listening.
The finest transcription of the Bach work yet, played to perfection, with perfect voicing and tonal clarity. A pleasure to listen to, and played with masterful professionalism. Bach indeed would be proud.
Superbe interprétation. Je ne saurai jamais jouer aussi bien mais c'est un plaisir d'écouter cet arrangement à quatre mains et pédalier. Quelle maîtrise de l'instrument et de ses registrations !
I have heard of the concept of 2 organists playing on 1 organ, but this is the first example I have actually seen/heard, and it works. Not sure why this has not been done more often, even if the ergonomics are a bit cramped for 2 players.
Fantastic use of all 3 manuals available. Excellent registrations - beautifully captures the essence of the original instrumentation / instruments, IMO. Bravo! 👏 _Edit: and pedals / pedalboard! (Mea culpa, excusez-moi, het spijt me...)_ _Edit 2: Bach violin concerto transcription 'for organ eight limbs'_ 😄
I'm overwhelmed. A brilliant transcription of this violin duo into a four-handed (and four feet) organ masterpiece. Perfect synchronicity from each organist. Bravo. Excellent choice of stops.
Very, very well done. I have a very intimate knowledge of the original piece and this transcription is simply awesome! Thank you so much for making and sharing this video. The Schnitger organ is so well suited to this performance as you have very wisely chosen your registrations. If this was available on a recording I would buy it right now!
Since Bach transcribed many of his works, especially the concerti, from instrument to instrument, it's not impossible he might have have made such a transcription himself! There are already two versions of this from Bach, the other for two harpsichords and strings.
Magnifique ! La transcription, l'interprétation, la registration, l'image, la prise de son... Tout cela au service d'une partition exceptionnelle. Merci pour tant de beauté !
I'm really speechless! What an amazing piece of music. It sounds beautiful an d it looks like both of you did this many times before. Thank you very much for sharing.
Fine transkription, beautiful played! Indeed I've never seen 2 organists sharing one seat. Nice! Thank god, that Busoni did a great job too in arranging Bach for piano. And one seat :)
Sublime. Les anges sont descendu du ciel pour nous apporter cette musique. Est-ce que je pourrais un jour jouer pareil ? Peut être dans la vie prochaine. ❤️
Great! The transcription is in C minor? Since it sounds like a transcription in C# minor, but the organ of the Martinikerk is intonated half a tone higher? Is the sheet music available somewhere?
Il y a années que je pratique l'orgue de cette façon avec une amie! (Sirtout les sonates en trio). Bravo aux professionnels qui npus rejoignent. Leo Houziaux (Bruxelles)
Geweldig gedaan samen. Prachtige transcriptie P-J de Boer! Ik zou het ritenuto in het laatste deel iets eerder hebben ingezet. Het eindigt naar mijn mening nu iets te abrupt. Maar verder subliem!
Are you really a married couple as mr Hoekman seems to know.? It sounds like that indeed and it is beautiful on one of the most beautiful organs in the world to my opinion.
I am only a "bachophile" recipient of organ music (however as a former citicen of Freiberg in Saxony in Germany with its large Silberman cathedral organ (aguably the best organ of the world according to organists) I am very pamperd indeed. And i often feel miserable how Bach is played. You however play quite perfect for me (clear inonation, not too fast. Could be in this form composed for organ by himself.... Only small weakness maybe is the instruments limited technical capabilities...Some interpretations of late cathedral organist Otto replay in my mind, ...But very nicely done....
Many, many thanks for your excellent version of this work, one I have played and loved for over 50 years. And, as my harmony teacher always said, there is always something new to find in Bach’s music, you just have to keep listening.
The finest transcription of the Bach work yet, played to perfection, with perfect voicing and tonal clarity. A pleasure to listen to, and played with masterful professionalism. Bach indeed would be proud.
Les organistes sont parmi les personnes les plus talentueuses et les plus humbles de cet univers. Superlatif !!
Superbe interprétation. Je ne saurai jamais jouer aussi bien mais c'est un plaisir d'écouter cet arrangement à quatre mains et pédalier. Quelle maîtrise de l'instrument et de ses registrations !
Bach is here! And he's smiling
2nd movement at 4:20
3rd movement at 10:25
A great transcription on that marvellous Schnitger organ. Thank you
Samen spelen als man en vrouw is toch écht top, mogen jullie vaker doen!
I have heard of the concept of 2 organists playing on 1 organ, but this is the first example I have actually seen/heard, and it works. Not sure why this has not been done more often, even if the ergonomics are a bit cramped for 2 players.
やはりバッハはパイプオルガンに限ります。
2人で弾くオルガンには深みがあり、絶妙で本当に心地よいです。
何回も繰り返し聴いています。
お気に入りの動画です。
Quelle musicalité dans le jeu, le phrasé... Bravo, c'est vraiment très beau !
Fantastic use of all 3 manuals available. Excellent registrations - beautifully captures the essence of the original instrumentation / instruments, IMO.
Bravo! 👏
_Edit: and pedals / pedalboard! (Mea culpa, excusez-moi, het spijt me...)_
_Edit 2: Bach violin concerto transcription 'for organ eight limbs'_ 😄
Wat een meesterlijk samenspel, ongelooflijk mooi!
Magnifique transcription de ce concerto, dans un tempo que je trouve parfait, avec de belles sonorités de cet orgue. Merci !🥰
What a superb transcription and performance on this great instrument!
Perfect tempo and beautiful phrasing.
Thank you Anne-Gaëlle and Pieter-Jelle!
Ecco la bellezza che salverà il mondo! Bravissimi!
Merci pour ces formidables transcription et registration - bon courage!
Bardzo pięknie zagrane. Świetnie brzmiący temat główny i wariacje.
What an absolute fabulous performance of this beautiful Bach concerto!
I'm overwhelmed. A brilliant transcription of this violin duo into a four-handed (and four feet) organ masterpiece. Perfect synchronicity from each organist. Bravo. Excellent choice of stops.
Spectacular. Clear voices, great tone.
Very, very well done. I have a very intimate knowledge of the original piece and this transcription is simply awesome! Thank you so much for making and sharing this video. The Schnitger organ is so well suited to this performance as you have very wisely chosen your registrations. If this was available on a recording I would buy it right now!
Excellent!
amo svisceratamente Bach, ma anche chi lo interpreta in questo modo....Splendido ...da brividi tutto il tempo Bravissimi...
Wow 😊❤so beautiful playing , first time I hear the double violin concerto on the organ . Bravo 👏
Geweldig! Twee top organisten bezig met die prachtige monumentale muziek van Bach.
Sublime... Absolument sublime...
That's a beautiful thing both to listen to and to watch! I think Bach would have approved.
Since Bach transcribed many of his works, especially the concerti, from instrument to instrument, it's not impossible he might have have made such a transcription himself! There are already two versions of this from Bach, the other for two harpsichords and strings.
Comme ç'est beau... tout simplement !
Perfectly beautiful! A very delicate touch!
Thank you for posting.
Einfach WUNDERBAR!!!
Dankeschön!
Oh, yes! Very, very good. Thank you! An excellent transcription, and a superb performance by both performers.
Brilliant!
Magnifique !
Impressionnant de voir ces 4 mains et pieds se promener sur tout les claviers en même temps! Bravo pour la performance et pour l' interprétation!
Flawless, and thanks for posting!
Super schitterend gespeeld op prachtig Schitger orgel Martinikerk Groningen
Speechless, the transcription is a masterpiece, your playing is perfect
Heerlijk, dank jullie wel!!
BRAVO.
Superb playing and wonderful sound recording!
This is amazing!
sublime.Please do more alike, exquiste!
Magnifique ! La transcription, l'interprétation, la registration, l'image, la prise de son... Tout cela au service d'une partition exceptionnelle. Merci pour tant de beauté !
Je confirme chaque mot du commentaire de Nicolas Delcey : MERCI pour tant de beauté ! Catherine.
Delightful!
I'm really speechless! What an amazing piece of music. It sounds beautiful an d it looks like both of you did this many times before.
Thank you very much for sharing.
Bravo, c’est splendide!
Tout simplement magnifique !
Splendide...... Comme ça sonne bien. Cet orgue est remarquable ; quel est-il
Orgue schniger eglise saint martin de Groningen
This is perfection, Brilliant. Merci.
Fabuleux ! BRAVO
Beautiful transcription indeed !
BRILLIANT!! WONDERFUL!
Fantastic!
Instant goosebumps. Thank you!
This is a marvellous transcription, with beautiful registration. Is that a tremulant I hear in the second movement?
Fine transkription, beautiful played! Indeed I've never seen 2 organists sharing one seat. Nice! Thank god, that Busoni did a great job too in arranging Bach for piano. And one seat :)
well done, intimate registration nicely expresing character of this magnificient BACH masterwork
Marvellous!! Bravi!
Sublime. Les anges sont descendu du ciel pour nous apporter cette musique. Est-ce que je pourrais un jour jouer pareil ? Peut être dans la vie prochaine. ❤️
Oh zo mooi en wat een vakmanschap spelen Julie nog zo van die dubbelconcert
Bernard België
De primeras parece un submarino!! Bravo!! Buenísima transcripción ... Qué opinaría Bach ?... Por cierto...gran parecido al actor Stephen Merchant 😂
Just found this marvelous piece. The "green monster" was "the jolly green giant" here. April 28, 2022. From Chicago, U.S.A.
Una excelente transcripción e interpretación. Bravo !!!
maravilloso...
BRAVO !!!
AMAZING!
Great!
The transcription is in C minor? Since it sounds like a transcription in C# minor, but the organ of the Martinikerk is intonated half a tone higher?
Is the sheet music available somewhere?
Yes, in C minor to avoid having to rewrite too many passages in the high register. The sheet music is not yet available but it certainly will one day.
Dios ! chicos , pero que cosa tan hermosa ,es una belleza , felicitaciones es un trabajo precioso, gracias.
Million like for this
Perfection.
Like 100. Superbe.
hop ! dans mes favoris !
Heel vet. Die solisten op verschillende registers is echt epic. Jammer dat die BC niet helemaal doordrukt nog. Maar heel vet.
waanzinnig mooi!
knap / talent / vakmanschap / meesters in t vak
Il y a années que je pratique l'orgue de cette façon avec une amie! (Sirtout les sonates en trio). Bravo aux professionnels qui npus rejoignent. Leo Houziaux (Bruxelles)
Any chance this can be posted somewhere like SoundCloud where it can be heard in higher quality?
Emocionante , que lindo,gracias.
Is the score published?
Excellent playing 👍......can anyone tell me if there exist sheets for misic...I see that lot's of people asking....but there is no answer.....
Great
Bellísimo
Absolutely fabulous! A terrific adaption with gorgeous registration. Were there also two pedal parts?
Thank you! Yes, there was also a double pedal part.
@@PieterJelledeBoer any chance of the score? 🙂
Geweldig gedaan samen. Prachtige transcriptie P-J de Boer!
Ik zou het ritenuto in het laatste deel iets eerder hebben ingezet. Het eindigt naar mijn mening nu iets te abrupt. Maar verder subliem!
Bach would have loved this, I'm sure!
Donde puedo conseguir la partitura?
Is there anywhere I can get the sheet music for this?
Are you really a married couple as mr Hoekman seems to know.? It sounds like that indeed and it is beautiful on one of the most beautiful organs in the world to my opinion.
Merci c est vrai
Magnifique ! Dommage que le pédalier ne soit pas montré, alors qu'il participe largement à la beauté de cette interprétation.
It sounds like a married couple. Is the transcription available?
Uauuuu... 🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌
Hut ab!
Fortiche de le jouer avec une telle aisance. Beaucoup s'y sont frottés...
Why am I watching the guy who turns the pages...
I am only a "bachophile" recipient of organ music (however as a former citicen of Freiberg in Saxony in Germany with its large Silberman cathedral organ (aguably the best organ of the world according to organists) I am very pamperd indeed. And i often feel miserable how Bach is played. You however play quite perfect for me (clear inonation, not too fast. Could be in this form composed for organ by himself.... Only small weakness maybe is the instruments limited technical capabilities...Some interpretations of late cathedral organist Otto replay in my mind, ...But very nicely done....
Taivaallista
Fantastic!