"All I want for Christmas is you", but in the style of 6 classical composers 🎹🎄

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 709

  • @JosepCastanyerAlonso
    @JosepCastanyerAlonso  2 місяці тому +79

    🎶 Get Your Score Here: bit.ly/ChristmasScores
    Choose between a PDF version or a high-quality print! Both options come with an exclusive Bach-style variation and access to a special follow-along video on my channel. Plus, the print version features a beautifully illustrated cover by artist Sînziana Cadar. 🎹

  • @JulienCote-mx6bf
    @JulienCote-mx6bf 2 місяці тому +1219

    This man’s description says “I also play the piano a bit”.

    • @JoaoBarbosa-qj7jk
      @JoaoBarbosa-qj7jk 2 місяці тому +8

      Wilddd

    • @prince_z
      @prince_z 2 місяці тому +23

      Me that’s played piano 4 my whole entire life:👁️👄👁️

    • @prince_z
      @prince_z 2 місяці тому +32

      And if he plays the piano so well that imagine what he is like on the cello😭

    • @Tredecimus
      @Tredecimus 2 місяці тому +4

      He is right, isn’t he? Or would you say he doesn’t play the piano one bit?

    • @simplicitas5113
      @simplicitas5113 Місяць тому +5

      Average perfectionist pianist (all of us/them)

  • @VanVlearMusic
    @VanVlearMusic 2 місяці тому +479

    Oh snap it’s the guy with unreasonably good editing

    • @pietervoogt
      @pietervoogt 2 місяці тому +8

      Reminds me of the videos of Octopus Contrapunctus

  • @yriiiiiii
    @yriiiiiii 2 місяці тому +752

    So this was how it was, working retail in the 1800s, huh?

  • @kwilson5832
    @kwilson5832 Місяць тому +87

    I'm going to play the 'Mozart' version as some incidental music in church just before Christmas. Those folk who are too old to recognise 'All I Want for Christmas' will enjoy the classical music , while it will put a smile on the faces of those who do realise what I'm playing! Thank you for the inspiration!

  • @Salmagundiii
    @Salmagundiii 2 місяці тому +174

    LOL @ "more notes than fingers" for Rachmaninoff. This is devilishly clever as usual!

  • @filipelqj
    @filipelqj 2 місяці тому +329

    The Rach is perfect

    • @dogsbody49
      @dogsbody49 2 місяці тому

      Yes I agree. It was sublime. I could just listen to that all day.

    • @clutchmatic
      @clutchmatic 2 місяці тому +5

      "diabetes incoming" hahahahah.... Happy that he put Bartok last, as a player cleanser

  • @matthewmoore5934
    @matthewmoore5934 2 місяці тому +366

    Epic! All amazing but the Bartok - oh my! Love it! I remain flabbergasted to know that piano is not your primary instrument.

    • @puremusic_official
      @puremusic_official 2 місяці тому +3

      Same!

    • @famitracked
      @famitracked 2 місяці тому +11

      They were all absolutely incredible. I wish I had the ability to write this well.

    • @diegomaranan3571
      @diegomaranan3571 Місяць тому +6

      Agree! I mean they were all amazing, but the Rach and the Bartok had me laughing

    • @jenlau3954
      @jenlau3954 Місяць тому +4

      @@diegomaranan3571Same, I can totally feel the “MAKE MY WISH COME TRUUUEEE 😭” 😂

    • @privatprivat7410
      @privatprivat7410 Місяць тому

      Same😂

  • @BrendaFisher-v2t
    @BrendaFisher-v2t 2 місяці тому +305

    Love this! Not only is the talented playing fantastic, but the written commentary is SO clever, educational, and hilariously funny. You are a genius.

    • @anagromataf48
      @anagromataf48 2 місяці тому +2

      Like in the Barbie song. That was also great and funny.

    • @sebsoud
      @sebsoud 2 місяці тому +9

      I can't imagine how much time it took to be able to create this video (composing and memorizing all for playing and recording and then adding the funny comments...). That is a BIG gift!

    • @MotifMusicStudios
      @MotifMusicStudios Місяць тому +3

      Agreed!

  • @jeff__w
    @jeff__w 2 місяці тому +108

    Dazzling! Sure, the arrangements and the playing are amazing but the onscreen text and graphics really sends the whole thing over the top!

    • @anagromataf48
      @anagromataf48 2 місяці тому +2

      That’s true 👍🏽

    • @M_SC
      @M_SC Місяць тому +1

      It’s a full package

  • @sunnywong1381
    @sunnywong1381 2 місяці тому +94

    PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE make an extended version of the Rachmaninoff-style parody !! 🙏🙏🙏

    • @jl-ju1pq
      @jl-ju1pq 2 місяці тому +7

      Couldn’t agree more! That one gave me goosebumps it was so good!

    • @selwyn1016
      @selwyn1016 Місяць тому +1

      Same

    • @simbathelion123
      @simbathelion123 Місяць тому

      I need this one aswell!!!!!!

  • @Sophie-lf9zn
    @Sophie-lf9zn Місяць тому +26

    I‘m OBSESSED with this style of video ♥️ As soon as you started playing Tchaikowsky I was like “this sounds like nutcracker“ and then came the sugar plum fairy 😂 And you’re so real for Bartoks “ugly ass chords“ lol. Rach was perfection, he‘s one of my favourite composers ☺️ so ✨dramatic✨
    I can‘t imagine the time and effort you have to put into composing, practicing, recording and editing this, so thank you!

  • @sarahclutter7649
    @sarahclutter7649 29 днів тому +8

    The Rachmaninoff is my favorite but also the Tchaikovsky. The text overlay definitely had me laughing 😂. Great pieces, well done! 👏🏻

  • @zwiadowca13
    @zwiadowca13 2 місяці тому +40

    I absolutely love this channel because it's actually "in the style". So many creators just do mashups with most basic classical themes

  • @iljatango
    @iljatango 2 місяці тому +53

    This is so funny, skilful, beautiful and witty it’s upsetting

  • @aleksandarbrzic8351
    @aleksandarbrzic8351 2 місяці тому +32

    I just love that "adorable looping" and the "innocent myxolydian swaying" makes me very warm overall 😇

  • @MYOB100
    @MYOB100 Місяць тому +18

    The Bartok one made me laugh out loud. Brilliant - bravo.

    • @lauraderr8017
      @lauraderr8017 Місяць тому

      Me too! I laughed the whole way through it!

  • @AndromedaCripps
    @AndromedaCripps Місяць тому +18

    Not everyone can really pull this off convincingly as good as Nahre Sol. You absolutely did. Captured the composers so perfectly and really came up with inventive variations on the melody and harmony!!!

    • @tab1717
      @tab1717 Місяць тому +4

      It’s not at all a competition but I actually think that Josep’s animation and composition skills are significantly more sophisticated!

    • @AndromedaCripps
      @AndromedaCripps Місяць тому +1

      @ I agree that the animation and humor is uniquely entertaining compared to a lot of the other videos in this format!! I actually noticed and thought to myself “wow… somebody spent hours animating all these little graphics….” while I was watching.
      But I’m very partial to Nahre’s composition skill and style 😊

  • @nadinefamille3855
    @nadinefamille3855 2 місяці тому +49

    You don't post a lot of videos, but omg, when you post one, it is something!! Your work is amazing. I love these "in the style of". Thank you!!!

  • @Phoenix3568
    @Phoenix3568 2 місяці тому +13

    I loved the Bartok! I think it actually quite excellently captured his style.

  • @sibionic
    @sibionic 2 місяці тому +43

    I love your flash card notes almost as much as your incredible playing, style and skill.

  • @inf1n1typlus1
    @inf1n1typlus1 Місяць тому +6

    That Brahms was beautiful, the half diminished 7th ascension 👌

  • @tab29155
    @tab29155 2 місяці тому +15

    The Rach one is magical

  • @sbeckmesser
    @sbeckmesser 2 місяці тому +25

    The Brahms and Bartok were my favorites as most closely approaching the original styles of those guys. Wish there had been Chopin and Philip Glass versions.

    • @geckofeet
      @geckofeet Місяць тому +1

      Thumb up for Chopin, down for Glass, down for Glass, down for Glass, down for Glass, down for Glass (ad lib until the copier runs out of toner)

    • @sbeckmesser
      @sbeckmesser Місяць тому

      @geckofeet I had imagined the Glass going last. So he could gradually fade out the picture and sound. Like the end of Neptune in Holst's Planets.

  • @ssmith9745
    @ssmith9745 2 місяці тому +4

    How can one person be so gifted in so many ways? A superb pianist *and* a talented composer (of parodies anyway!); he's very conversant with music history, theory and analysis -- and he seems to have discovered how to teach those subjects without the students even noticing that they're being educated! He appears to have all the skills needed to record, edit, and produce professional-quality audio and video (unless he employs a 20-person team of sound engineers, lighting technicians, make-up artists, camera operators, etc.!). I'd say he's a bit of a graphic-design genius! Plus he has a delightful sense of humour and a way with words... he's young, slender, well-featured, and has good skin... and all he wants for Christmas is... me??! ;-)

  • @CurtisPrevo
    @CurtisPrevo 2 місяці тому +14

    I kind of expected a Schubert Erlkönig-esque intro, but i can't be disappointed with what we were given.

  • @MB-ez7lf
    @MB-ez7lf 2 місяці тому +13

    I am not a musician but I love and listen to all these composers. The cheeky commentary is brilliant and breaks open the musical content to help me understand

    • @M_SC
      @M_SC Місяць тому

      Yes it does

  • @matthewsackman
    @matthewsackman 2 місяці тому +21

    Always saving the best til last! The Ravel in the Barbie was the best, and the Bartok here, so good!

    • @maximilianellis1311
      @maximilianellis1311 2 місяці тому

      Yeah he always puts the really fun wild card at the end

  • @rainbowlibrary.
    @rainbowlibrary. Місяць тому +12

    This is actually so underrated! quality editing ,quality music ,quality video!!!!

  • @robertwilliams3846
    @robertwilliams3846 Місяць тому +8

    !!!!!PHENOMENAL!!!!! Your TALENT is completely off the scales!!!! THANK YOU for sharing your INCREDIBLE GIFT!!!❤️❤️❤️

  • @dianagolovin7827
    @dianagolovin7827 Місяць тому +11

    Petition to make a longer music vid of the Rachmaninoff version!

  • @RokeLibrarian
    @RokeLibrarian Місяць тому +1

    As someone who plays a few of these composers, it's almost as if you sat down with them and knew them personally. I just can't get over how the last one was absolutely 100% Bartok. And the funny thing is that he actually did stuff like this: he took simple folk melodies and changed them into... Bartok. If he was alive today he would have probably transcribed Mariah Carey himself. Awesome job man

  • @anagromataf48
    @anagromataf48 2 місяці тому +16

    WOW!!!! Great 👍🏽
    Absolut großartig.
    Der Rachmaninow hat mir am besten gefallen. Da war die Melodie am einfachsten rauszuhören.

    • @Ma-lk2gn
      @Ma-lk2gn 2 місяці тому +2

      Stimmttt!! Und die Begleitungen waren einfach perfekt nh? 👌

    • @mangomerkel2005
      @mangomerkel2005 2 місяці тому +2

      Rachmaninoff hat er wirklich gut getroffen. Einige Elemente hat er sich vom Liebesleid, der Cellosonate und der zweiten Sinfonie geborgt und sie fantastisch auf das Thema angewendet. Dazu noch die schönen Sequenzen mit sehr melancholischen und einfühlsamen Akkordfolgen.
      Mir hat es auf jeden Fall das "Rachmaninoff-Gefühl" gegeben, was bei mir ein sehr gutes Zeichen für Authentizität von Sergej Wassiljewitsch ist.

  • @jaydub1249
    @jaydub1249 17 днів тому +2

    Very impressive! Usually this sort of pastiche just uses a recognizable accompaniment or rhythmic feature from a well-known piece by the composer and pastes the popular tune onto it. These actually analyzed the compositional techniques and preferences. Well-done, sir!

  • @mind_bender6424
    @mind_bender6424 2 місяці тому +2

    Danke!

  • @Anil18834
    @Anil18834 Місяць тому +2

    This is SOOO JOYFUL and quirky and I'm here for it ❤
    I laughed the whole video 😂
    Your notes are also great! Mozart's loop, Beethoven's pathetique and hammer, Marx as Brahms etc.
    Glad the UA-cam algorithm brought you to me. I didn't know you were all I wanted for Christmas, but I'm glad I got it!
    Happy Holidays

  • @jaegertiger384
    @jaegertiger384 Місяць тому +7

    Woukd like to hear Chopin's version...
    and Schumann too.

  • @michaelmarsten4019
    @michaelmarsten4019 Місяць тому +1

    I MUST add: This virtuoso's humorous treatment in each style is truly Divinely Hilarious!

  • @avnishsingh-lx6ju
    @avnishsingh-lx6ju 2 місяці тому +10

    The rach was absolutely perfect ❤

  • @merlinsmustche
    @merlinsmustche 2 місяці тому +16

    OMG this is absolutely BRILLIANT

  • @poogamoo6786
    @poogamoo6786 2 місяці тому +10

    This is so perfect I can’t even explain

  • @RoyZivMusic
    @RoyZivMusic 2 місяці тому +5

    beautifully done. Pleasure to listen to and read the animated text. killed it

  • @imallears4
    @imallears4 14 днів тому +1

    Huge numbers of heartfelt appreciative words
    for your spot- on clevernesses.

  • @simonschulten3879
    @simonschulten3879 2 місяці тому +6

    Bartok really did it for me. Well done! Now I want even more of this 😊

  • @TheSLUSO
    @TheSLUSO 2 місяці тому +6

    BRILLIANT as always... the hammers in the Beethoven variation completely cracked me up!!! 😁 Thank you for your talent, humor, and obvious charm!

    • @MargoB
      @MargoB Місяць тому

      🔨. 😂

  • @magnusgro4366
    @magnusgro4366 2 місяці тому +8

    5:18 That left hand reminds me of the middle part of Chopin's Ballade No. 1

  • @sebespatak
    @sebespatak 2 місяці тому +7

    thanks mate, it was phenomenal

  • @rafixnc
    @rafixnc 28 днів тому +7

    A clear reference do Symphony No.2 Adagio from Rachmaninoff: 4:29

  • @composerman3000
    @composerman3000 8 днів тому +1

    the bartók is SOOOO good

  • @dannyneumann4547
    @dannyneumann4547 2 місяці тому +24

    These videos are always very good, but for a second or two you captured the full magic of Rachmaninoff and it nearly brought a tear to my eye

  • @swoper2
    @swoper2 2 місяці тому +14

    Loved it! The Commentary really adds.

  • @honey8ter
    @honey8ter Місяць тому +7

    how is the editing for this, this good? not to mention the terrific piano playing oh my god

  • @marinakaratzoglou4298
    @marinakaratzoglou4298 2 місяці тому +4

    Extraordinary! Loved every minute! Thank you for this wonderful, inspiring medley. 🙏 I also laughed so hard with the on screen comments! Brilliant!

  • @jonathanliang4275
    @jonathanliang4275 2 місяці тому +5

    For the Rach, the inspiration seems to be the Adagio from his 2nd Symphony if anybody was wondering and couldn't remember

  • @tinkalilova718
    @tinkalilova718 Місяць тому +5

    Extremely talented!!! 🌟 Thank you and love your Barbie girl 🎶🎶❤️❤️👏👏👏👏👏

  • @lighthouse66
    @lighthouse66 2 місяці тому +9

    Wowwww, this was so well conceived and performed! Clever and on point!

  • @patriciasalem3606
    @patriciasalem3606 2 місяці тому +1

    "More notes than fingers..." 😂 They were all perfect, but the Rach especially so.

  • @stefankinasevych8875
    @stefankinasevych8875 2 місяці тому +30

    There are few videos that bring me as much enjoyment as yours. Bravo maestro ❤

  • @jefirestone7307
    @jefirestone7307 2 місяці тому +7

    Oh my gosh! Thank you for all this work. In addition to enjoying the variations, I learned something about each composer.

  • @AnthonyLOL..
    @AnthonyLOL.. Місяць тому +1

    This should be put on Spotify, UA-cam music and all other streaming platforms

  • @skylarlimex
    @skylarlimex 2 місяці тому +3

    Absolutely amazing stuff! Solid variations each in their own right, the Bartok is fabulous.

  • @vvpiano712
    @vvpiano712 28 днів тому +2

    My God this guy is genius! Love love love this! Equally amazing composing and narrating skills😁 its also a great fun way to learn styles of composers!!! Who is this guy??? Teaching somewhere improv? Or composition? Id take his class! 😊 thanks for such sofisticated fun. Gonna watch one more time. And then maybe few more😍 Genius!

  • @ganzeinfachjoerg543
    @ganzeinfachjoerg543 Місяць тому +1

    Love the Tchaikowsky-Style! And all the lovely visual effects!!🤩

  • @estelabohbouth1570
    @estelabohbouth1570 Місяць тому +2

    This is genius, congratulations!!!

  • @Lillyluri
    @Lillyluri 2 місяці тому +12

    First time watcher, immediate sub.
    The creativity! The skill! The editing!

  • @Htfsik
    @Htfsik 2 місяці тому +4

    Wow! That’s brilliant. Also insightful that old Sergei would not be able to resist the melody. 😅

  • @Trucidare
    @Trucidare 2 місяці тому +4

    Wow, I can't imagine the amount of effort it would have taken to make this video! Amazing job, and excellent performances!

  • @charlieruisseau2476
    @charlieruisseau2476 20 днів тому

    "secondary dominant buffet"gave me a good laugh.
    I really feel like I'm learning so much on these different composers thanks to your note. I look at them and then rewatch just to enjoy the beauty of your arrangements.
    Thank you Josep and a merry Christmas to you!

  • @user-Van_Veen
    @user-Van_Veen Місяць тому +1

    Oh, boy! Rachmaninoff and Bartok were extraordinary! Thank you!

  • @AlbaMartínezVila
    @AlbaMartínezVila 2 місяці тому +5

    I didnt know how much I needed this to calm myself down (well Barok didn’t help but LOL) so thank you and please keep doing this videos, as a former pianist I can imagine how much effort and dedication you poured yourself into this

  • @DERIVATIVES-mh6ej
    @DERIVATIVES-mh6ej 23 дні тому +1

    "Accompanyment as elaborate as the melody." I love you Rachmaninoff.

  • @samuelthomas8192
    @samuelthomas8192 Місяць тому

    5:10-5:14 is from the third movement of Rach’s sonata for cello and piano, towards the end. Gorgeous piece y’all should listen to.

  • @notdoubtnthomas
    @notdoubtnthomas 2 місяці тому +7

    This video is absolutely insane! Really amazing work, man!

  • @mrnnhnz
    @mrnnhnz 2 місяці тому +2

    "Diabetes incoming." 🤣🤣🤣🤣 ROFL! So much sugar! Love this channel. One of my favourites. Great work.

  • @almaselahruah
    @almaselahruah Місяць тому +2

    This is just breathtakingly perfect. Thank you.
    Would you maybe consider doing an ‘in the style of’ for ‘happy birthday’ please, so that we can share the love far and wide as a birthday treat!
    Qué pasada, as they say. You get MVP for the whole Internet.

    • @fluffyfluffykatz
      @fluffyfluffykatz Місяць тому

      If you liked this video I'm sure you'll also like Nahre Sol's "in the style of __ composers" videos. She actually made one for the "Happy Birthday" song! ua-cam.com/video/ToO7OXDiV04/v-deo.html

    • @almaselahruah
      @almaselahruah Місяць тому

      Thank you! That’s brilliant!! !

  • @michaelmarsten4019
    @michaelmarsten4019 Місяць тому

    Some of the most truly exquisite piano playing this world's ever heard - and some of the most adorably creative improvisational talent!! Numerous pianists who would be specialists in musical paraphrasing could learn whole volumes of talent from this excellent young virtuoso!

  • @freudje
    @freudje 2 місяці тому +4

    You did it again! A masterpiece, and very funny at the same time ❤

  • @jackycal
    @jackycal 2 місяці тому +2

    that is a really great video. i feel like everyone is saying the rach worked best because it was the easiest to potentially use more of the original song chords, which you did tbf. nice work

  • @seanashmore8785
    @seanashmore8785 2 місяці тому +2

    'Your emotional support composer'.....absolute class!!

  • @brahmsian118
    @brahmsian118 2 місяці тому +3

    Oh, the Rach Cello Sonata reference was spot-on

  • @sergiotiempo5542
    @sergiotiempo5542 2 місяці тому +4

    Querido Josep, me sigues deslumbrando con tu talento y sabiduría! 🤯 bravo y gracias

    • @JosepCastanyerAlonso
      @JosepCastanyerAlonso  2 місяці тому +2

      Gracias Sergio! Espero que estés bien. Y muchas gracias por escuchar mis vídeos, es un honor. Espero que toquemos juntos algun día! 🎻🎹 /Josep CA

  • @lockjiang
    @lockjiang Місяць тому

    A well-designed, painfully-constructed and well-arranged video. this is art in itself. Love particularly the Rachmaninoff part

  • @flowingwaveart3224
    @flowingwaveart3224 11 днів тому

    Absolutely brilliant. Thank you. I had commented about Barbie girl that it was a whole semester of music theory/ comp in 6 minutes. This is second semester. You gave us a full year sequence in 12 astonishingly enjoyable minutes.

  • @barneypooch
    @barneypooch Місяць тому

    I wish you were in this room with me to hear my applause. Bravo, thank you and a very merry Christmas!

  • @hilarypower6217
    @hilarypower6217 26 днів тому

    Absolute genius! There is no other word. Season's greetings all

  • @levimatheri7682
    @levimatheri7682 2 місяці тому +39

    I lost it at 2:45 when he pulled Karl Marx 😂😂

  • @joseoriolquintanilladicent5003
    @joseoriolquintanilladicent5003 2 місяці тому +2

    Epic. M’encanta la edició del video, el teu humor, que vagis explicant la teoria/harmonia (acords, progressions, etc) que hi ha al darrere… i ja ni parlar-ne de la teva habilitat al piano!! Felicitats!

  • @teeriepeng
    @teeriepeng Місяць тому +1

    Amazing! Would you consider putting this on Spotify? I need these styles 24/7! Thank you so much!

  • @yayuuuhhhH
    @yayuuuhhhH 2 місяці тому +4

    every single one is perfect. I aspire to be able to compose stuff like this one day.

  • @classifiesconfidential4330
    @classifiesconfidential4330 Місяць тому +3

    I need a full brahms version ❤!!!!!!

  • @katec9893
    @katec9893 2 місяці тому +3

    Amazing. My favourite sections were 1,3,4 and 5.

  • @Dorran
    @Dorran 2 місяці тому +1

    OMGGGG YOU are my HEROOOO 😍😍 you are insane Josep 😂😂

  • @johncourtright1632
    @johncourtright1632 14 днів тому

    Truly creative and skillfully done! The annotations were brilliant and hilarious! Loved it!

  • @gerberjason6947
    @gerberjason6947 2 місяці тому +1

    Brilliant and hilarious. Literally laughing out loud. Please do the older guys too, you know, like Bach.

  • @MisterJSF
    @MisterJSF Місяць тому +1

    GÉ NIAL !!! 👍🎹👍 Et les commentaires sont très marrants ! 😆

  • @christianeblais8822
    @christianeblais8822 23 дні тому

    Absolutely AMAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAZIIIIING ❣❣❣❣❣ From now on, you have a new fan in Italy!!!!! With all my admiration 🎵🎶🎹

  • @NikitaKarciauskas
    @NikitaKarciauskas 2 місяці тому +3

    What great and beautiful versions you game my ears to hear! Thank you!

  • @jiangyilin_official
    @jiangyilin_official Місяць тому +1

    Mariah should acknowledge this amazing achievement … congrats to your fantastic work of art!

    • @MissMichele1993
      @MissMichele1993 24 дні тому

      I think Mariah Carey can do what she wants. I agree with you that Josep did an amazing job. But I think it is a little bit humiliating that this song is next to I am a barbie girl and angry birds. Also the description says not a lot more about the song than that it is a pop song. To me and to many others Mariah Carey is not just some ordinary pop singer, but an icon with an inhuman talent and All I want for christmas is you is more than just a pop song. To me at least, and I know I am not the only one. I think she deserves more praise than this! We are lucky to have Mariah still in our midst and for the huge amount of impeccable work she made which is still growing.

    • @jiangyilin_official
      @jiangyilin_official 24 дні тому

      @@MissMichele1993 ​​⁠I see your point and yes, Mariah is an icon for sure with All I Want For Christmas being one of the most beloved festive songs nowadays. But if you view the song from a classical, strictly analytical aspect, then it is still a pop song in the end. That does not mean that she is being disrepected here, and her popularity is probably bigger than entire hours of classical music alltogether. But a pop song stays a pop song, no matter regarding its popularity, and it is simply incredible how much Josep developed her song by using all kind of various classical composition techniques. Again, I am not saying that this video will become more popular than Mariah’s original, but quality should not be solely measured on popularity either, and the quality here is undeniable from classical aspects, surpassing Mariah’s original rhythmic-harmonic-melodic structure.

    • @MissMichele1993
      @MissMichele1993 24 дні тому

      ​@@jiangyilin_official Hi, I did not mean to compare his piece to the original song, but to compare the song choices for his covers with each other. And piano skills and singing skills are very different skills and in my opinion not really appropriate for comparing. Some people will always say classical music is better. This is just an opinion (as is mine of course). The skill used in the songs Mariah sings is not often (or ever) duplicated with the same quality by someone else (also she wrote all of her songs except the covers). I think she deserves some respect and you can't put her songs in the same lane as I am a barbie girl and angry birds. As you already understood, I am a fan of her, and you are probably a big fan of classical music. Let's agree to disagree (if that is still the case) and enjoy music. Music is amazing!

    • @jiangyilin_official
      @jiangyilin_official 23 дні тому

      @@MissMichele1993 ​​⁠ I am a professional classical musician myself, but I enjoy other music genres a lot, especially in my free time so I can have a better life balance overall 🙃
      I can relate to your opinion that Mariah’s songs should not be associated/compared with some other songs. What I usually try to do then is focusing on the music itself: if it stands on its own with absolute greatness, then there will be no need for comparisons to enhance the quality, and I always try to blend out those comparisons as much as possible.
      So in this case, maybe you can blend out Angry Birds and Barbie Girl as Josep’s artistic freedom 😅 (because I honestly don’t think he chose those songs as comparisions, classical musicians usually don’t work in this way), but admire Mariah’s artistry instead that even made it to the classical music world? 😇
      And YES, music is absolutely amazing, I happily agree on that 🤜🏽🤛🏽

  • @MotifMusicStudios
    @MotifMusicStudios Місяць тому

    This is oh so clever and musical. Loved listening and appreciated the stylistic charm for each and the humour in the text. 'hold my sonata" [teehee]

  • @ElizabethDohertyThomas
    @ElizabethDohertyThomas 26 днів тому +1

    Holy macaroni... what did I see and hear just there? 👏👏👏👏