Electronic Shifting - Is it worth it, and do you need it? - Road Cycling
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 чер 2024
- Electronic Shifting - Is it worth it, and do you need it? - A Guide to Road Cycling
One of the questions on the lips of most riders with a mechanical groupset is, “Is there really any benefit to upgrading to electrical?” Well, in this video, we’re going to answer exactly that.
Pro’s:
Shifting
Reduced maintenance
Control
Adaptive use
Cons:
Expensive.
Flat Battery.
Small Shifter Buttons
Problems can be hard to repair.
Chapters:
00:00 - Intro
00:50 - The industry is changing
01:34 - The Price to upgrade
02:35 - What is good about electronic shifting
06:30 - What is not so good about electronic shifting
11:10 - How do you decide
About Ribble Valley Cyclist:
I am a regular road cyclist based in the North West of England. I have been a cyclist my whole life, and try to get out every day. The purpose of my UA-cam channel is to share the knowledge I’ve built up in my 40 years as a cyclist.
Follow me on Facebook:
/ ribblevalleycyclist
Follow me on Instagram:
/ ribblevalley_cyclist
See my routes on Komoot:
www.komoot.com/user/184990942...
Follow me on UA-cam:
/ @ribblevalleycyclist
Email me:
ribblevalleycyclist@gmail.com
Additional footage from #RideShimano
/ @rideshimano
#bikerepair #bikemaintenance #roadbike #workshop #bikecare #wintercycling #review #cycling #cyclinglife #ribblevalleycyclist #roadcycling - Спорт
It's easy to be a luddite, Especially to us British, compared to our European neighbours we are easily 6 years behind when it comes to ebikes and their usage ( don't even get started on wine, coffee, food and lifestyle) BUT since the year dot progress is progress and will not be stopped. Value ??? When in the real world has value EVER had anything to do with cycling!! for most of us who cycle for competition/ pleasure/relaxation/fitness/companionship/and our mental health ??Have the best you can have when it comes to your best bicycle, because this is your passion and also it's mental & physical health. and those two things you can't put a pound sign on . If ( and i get it ) the feel of something mechanical that is perfectly adjusted floats your boat then yes go for cable operated , and also the maintenance / tuning of it may also hold pride & contentment ..... BUT in that case IF something working perfectly does float your boat then electronic shifting DOES work perfectly EVERYTIME. And where you wont be needing to maintain it , you can spend that time instead playing with the settings which are almost infinite to get it perfected for you and your riding style instead, OR the next ride that you are planning . ELECTRONIC shifting is simply the way to go .
Smilebikes, you have it. Everything you say here is what this video is all about. I especially like the point "" I think I'll pin your comment. Oh, and coffee, buy an Italian machine, and import the beans........ However, I suspect you already know and do that 😉
You obviously didn't watch the worlds or any major tour. They break down all the time
By "progress" you mean pointless consumerism and destruction of the planet?
1. Cycling used to not be expensive. 2. I can afford a pinarelo but will never buy one because I care about value.
@pierrex3226 the entire history of cycling has been about Independance and Access. It would appear the industry is hell bent on removing both. "Craft beer" bullsh*t
I've been riding for nearly 60 years and have never broken a gear cable. However I've been knocked off a few times and fallen off more than a few times and prefer the cost of mechanical replacements rather than the expense of electronic components. I'll stick with mechanical. It just works.
Not broken a gear cable in 60 years.... Wish I was that lucky!
Only cable that has ever failed on me is on my first cheap 10-speed as a pre-teen. One does not need to shift on descents very much if at all. Only when the descent flattens or transitions to uphill. My '89 Bianchi has never needed a cable change. Never broken a derailleur. This guy is full of it when talking about reliability. Mechanical is absolutely reliable.
Agree, not been going that long, probably 40ish, and I have never ever broken a shifter cable. Fallen and damaged shifters, mechs? Plenty.
The 11 speed Shimano shifters have a design flaw that makes it much easier to break the cables 😵
@@ribblevalleycyclistthat’s when preventive maintenance comes in. Change cables regularly before they break!
One of the joys for me on a bike is mechanically moving those derailleurs and feeling the shifts. For me it's all about being part of the machine not just about being an operator.
Fair point well made.
You're symbiotic with your mechanical bike no more than an electronic one. You did not select the alloys. You did not draw the drawings. You did not write the assembly instructions. You did not 5 axis the parts. You did anodize, etch, metallize whatever the components. You didn't paint them. You couldn't have imagined them. And neither could I. So you, nor me, are or ever be "part of the machine". You need to actually irl try di2 and to stop this gaslighting nonsense about mechanical. Di2 is insane and I wish people had told me sooner
LOL! People who prefer cars with manual transmissions have a similar argument.
But...but..but....That's a totally different thing there!! Manual in a car means you control when to shift. More RPMS is good! On the bike, it may be a motor moving the derailleur, but you still have to make it do it!
@@dentatusdentatus1592
You just move a stupid lever. There is nothing special with doing this.
Im still on 10 speed ultegra and 11 speed aram GX. Its absolutely great. No charging, no batteries running flat because a strap was over the shifter button. I can fix and service cable my self and it is a lot cheaper. Electronic might be a bit better, but its not for me.
Have tried DI2 and etap and yeah it is easy and works, but still using Ultegra 6800 mechanical. Just prefer the feel of shift manually, if that is the word to describe it. And I know alot of guys on electric that shift poorly and are noisy due to poor maintenance in regard to chains, jockey wheels and basic cleaning.
Same here. I don't race, so what's good enough is good enough.
No charging a battery that lasts 6 months 😢😢😢 such a good point
battery charging, I'm too disorganised to pre-charge my battery prior to a spur of the moment run out
@@hgm8337 yeah, to be fair I charge my watch up to ride and lights as needed to keep riding through the winter, but its just another thing to keep charged up.
I used to have ultegra Di2 until one day my bike fell over from leaning against a wall; rear mech never worked again. Went back to mechanical, never been happier.
Interesting. Thanks for sharing 👍
Was on my mind for Ultegra di2 , this comment change my mind
😀 I used to drive a car until one day a tree fell on it, never worked again. Went back to horse drawn carriage, never been happier.
@@KBKriechbaum the difference being I'd expect my bike to still work after falling over but I wouldn't expect your car to still work after being under a tree.
@@kieron88ward Well, the point is that rear mech is fragile in general, has nothing to do with DI2. If you bend it, every rear mech will give you troubles until you fix it or replace bent part. Often the hanger. Making it tough enough to survive every fall is like making a car tough enough to survive the tree, not feasible.
Kudos to this post. I am an old rider using mechanical. I prefer the feel and force it takes to actuate the levers and I can service them all myself. I still have a mean handshake at 60yrs and am not a fan of electronic shifters or disc brakes. I can already lock up and skid with rim brakes just fine. Thank you for the content!
Hi BH,
Thanks, glad you liked it..... and glad to read you've still got a mean handshake 🤣
On the subject of electronic/mechanical and rim/disc…… For me, both have their place, so both should be manufactured. However, it’s all about the profit.
Thanks for watching.
Jon
Trust me once you have had disc brakes and electronic shifting you will not go back to crappy mechanical gears and rim brakes you just won’t.
@MrChippiechappie clearly, you never learnt how to set up rim brakes properly.
Locking the wheels is not the sign of a good braking system. You can push disc brakes harder than rim pads and the wheels don't skid. The bike decelerates in a controlled manner.
@westinthewest no, but the ABILITY to lock the wheels is a good sign of an efficient braking system. What you say about pushing disc brakes harder than rim brakes is simply not true. It all depends on the TYRES.
I've switched from a 2x to a 1x mechanical groupset and I gotta say, some of the downsides of mechanical shifting are taken care of by that. It's so much easier to index the gears now and takes about a minute. And since I'm a weekend warrior I don't care much about the performance. If it works, it works. What I do care about is availability and affordability of parts. So I guess I'll stick with mechanical for a while.
Thanks, Nick. The 1x mechanical standpoint is a good point.
Thanks for sharing.
Jon
I've had di2 for ages and even though mechanical was fun and tactile I'll never go back. Di2 for life.
I'm a 77 yo for whom fiddling with mechanicals is part of the fun. My main bike is a 2003 Lemond Tormelet. The mix of 105 and Deore 3x7 shifts perfectly. One can do the micro shift on front mech by adjusting the limit screw just past the resting shift position. In fact, that's essential for a good shift. It helps to have robust hands. My mate with hand arthritis does have Di2 and loves it. He has had all the issues mentioned. Dead battery, intermittent cable issues, etc. When dust had fouled his chain so the rear stopped shifting we did not consider a mechanical issue till getting the bike on a stand.
This is he best review of the issues I've seen.
Hi Bruce,
Thanks for your comments. A 2003 Lemond Tourmalet..... nice!
It's good that your pal with arthritis gets to ride still, maybe thats when electronic is good?
Thanks again, Bruce 👍
I'm almost 50 yo now and got a SRAM Force etap. Money can buy happiness... I might not be faster, but I simply love the electronic sequential shifting. Cheers!
I've got same experience... except of I'd swap my age with you if you O.K. ?
Same here. I love SRAM Force, especially in sequential. The little noise it makes when automatically shifting the front mech never gets old. I recently bought a bike with Di2. I think eTap is easier because there's one small paddle, not two, especially in winter with thicker gloves, but still love it. I don't mind paying the extra $ knowing I'll still cruise along at the same speed as a mechanical groupset, but it's still nice! 🙂
While you mentioned that electronic shifting is more certain, one thing I have noticed on my daily 13 mile each way commute across London is that the shifting certainty means that I change gear more often, I don't sit in the "wrong" gear anymore because changing gear is so reliable. My speed is slightly increased and my perceived effort is reduced.
Interesting point 👍
Funny thing is, I notice the exact same thing when I finally upgraded from down tube shifters
Agreed and you don't have the urge to grind small hills up with the big ring because the front derailleur shifts so well.
You're right, I do shift more with electronic because I know it's easier to do it. I use more of the cassette.
Looking for an automatic shifting?
Ive got over 60 high end bikes from 12spd DA to 9spd record.
Main thing is a straight hanger and properly tuned gears.
Best groupset overall is 7800. IYKYK.
Hey Durianrider,
Thanks for paying my little channel a visit 👍
Ain't gonna disagree with any of that...... Not sure I like the idea of maintaining 60 bikes though 😬
Thanks,
Jon
I’m fully satisfied with all the clarifications between E shifting and mechanical. I was thankful I hang around on my mechanical shifters, it works for me. I subscibe to your channel.
Tried electronic for 2000kms & compared to mechanical couldn't wait to get rid of it. Main cons: gotta regularly recharge, more expensive, replacement parts cost more, less connected with the bike...For the professional peloton it makes sense but for casual & leisure cyclists it's overkill imho
My sentiments exactly. Although I have never tried electronic shifting, I am sure it is superior; but how good does it need to be? My GRX mechanical in conjunction with Jagwire Pro shifts wonderfully well.
If you link the electronic groupset with your headunit, it'll prompt you when the batteries are almost dead, and when you do get the prompt, you still have 10% remaining. Offcourse, if you ignore that or don't link it, it's your own fault that it died because of an empty battery.
Yes it's more expensive, but maintenance free and will deliver a perfect shift every time. That for me is enough to go electronic
I even use di2 on my indoor bike for 3 years now, oh yes, no more damaged cables becasue of the sweat. No need to adjust cable tension or replace cables. Never had an empty battery
@@klaasv88 don't have or need a headunit or ride indoors or had cables damaged due to sweat. I was able to monitor the battery level via phone app. I used electronic shifting to see what all the fuss was about & to give it the benefit of the doubt. Felt it like a gimmick. I prefer the lever throw to shift gears rather than press buttons. As I said earlier with electronic shifting I felt less connected to the bike. I ride approximately 15000kms per year & mechanical shifting with rim brakes has made me very happy for the last 80000kms.
I’ve only charged my di2 twice this year and I ride around 100 mile a week. Not massive miles but the battery life isn’t an issue at least not on di2.
I use mechanical 105 shifting. I've done test rides on bikes with electronic shifting. I guess it's fine but I just don't get what the big deal is. People act like it's this huge upgrade and I'm like, meh. I think I'm just old fashioned. If I can use a bike with no electronics: no power meter, no bike computer, no electronic shifting, then that's what I'm going to do. I like having a bike be a purely mechanical, relatively simple machine.
Yeah, I found my computer distracting so I took it of my bike and haven’t used it since .
And you're right a bike is supposed to be simple and for anybody easy to maintained !!!
@@jean-paullanglois5452di2 is far easier to maintain than mechanical though. It's literally set and forget. You don't ever have to index or change cables or adjust.
While I don't regret going electronic on my Road Bike I admit to being a little underwhelmed by Di2. I never had issues with shifting or setting up mechanical, I actually quite like setting up/indexing gears. Never had a cable snap that I can remember, had a SRAM force return spring go once, took me a while to figure out why my rear mech' was automatically climbing the cassette!
I think I listened to much to the "YOU CAN NEVER GO BACK" people and expected to blown away but at the end of the day, you push a thing, and a thing moves a chain that's it! I know there's "synchro" and auto trim but I've been shifting 2X for 30 years my brain and muscle memory does that. I'll admit it shifts better and I like the satellite buttons for when I relax on the tops and settle into a long climb, (I'm one of the 3 or 4 people on the planet that purchased the Garmin remote who didn't hate it so I don't care about that function) but for me its just not the game changer or deal braker I expected and I'm not clambering to upgrade my mech' bikes any time soon.
I have a similar opinion on Rim Vs Disc Brakes, but being a 54kg whippet, I suspect Sir Isaac Newton has something to do with that one 😆
Hi Bikey McBeardface. Loved reading your thoughts.... a logical brain-dump from an experienced cyclist. I agree on all points. When it matters the most, there is no difference....... when you're shoving it along a long straight road, or climbing up 20% climb, it doesn't matter whether you've got Claris or Di2 Dura Ace, what matters is your effort..... and that the gear change happens if you need one. For me, the one thing I like is that I can flip between head unit screens..... So it's a lot to pay for such a small feature, and as you say, use the remote. One thing I should've mentioned in this video is the art of maintaining a bike. After all, any idiot can connect a Bluetooth device, or plug something in, but building a mechanical groupset is a skill we may lose.
Maybe one day I'll do that rim disc video thats in my head!
Thanks for sharing your thoughts.
There is a third option: the so called non-existing shifting. It's even faster than electronic shifting, no cables, charging, internal routing etc. needed. It's a marvelous system. Some also know it as the "single speed or fixed gear system"
your presentations are not boring. thank you❤
Great vid. Short answer to the question: Yes, it's worth it to upgrade to electronic. I've never had a dead battery, it shifts the same way every time, and it's far easier to shift while you're in the middle of an effort, or braking. No brainer.
All good points well mate.
Thanks,
Jon
I loved my 1970 Cinella full campy downtube levers, five speed cassette, tubular tires ( oh the glorious sound of silk tires humming at speed), rim brakes, and quick release with drop outs that did NOT need the skewers to be turned. The wheel just drops out. In the early days we did not even have speedometers! The most noticeable improvement in tech are the clipless pedals and shoes vs toe clips😊
That announcement was really clear and convincing. Thank you 🙏.
Glad it was helpful!
I just got my first bike with an electronic groupset, and I will never go back to mechanical. In terms of batteries, there is an easy solution: Use SRAM electronic group sets, such as Rival (most affordable), Force or Red (most expensive), rather than Di2. The SRAM batteries are way cheaper and easier to replace and charge. In fact, that was one of the reasons I got SRAM, including the ability to take a spare battery on my long rides. Regarding the difference in price point of mechanical vs electronic group sets, that is just part of the game, save for an extra couple of months and enjoy! Life is short!
Hi Jay.... Enjoy that new bike 👍 And yeah, the SRAM battery system is pretty slick!
Thanks for watching,
Jon
Di2 battery last like 6 months, I have never bought a replace battery, battery has never got flat
@@echd1Great to know, but I still prefer the peace of mind that I can carry a spare on my long rides. Military life makes people, eh, different. LOL
There are someones stealing SRAM batteries while you are buying a coffee😅
@@harrywang2566 I never heard of that, but if true, the spare battery would be very helpful.
The only time I would stop for coffee would be during the "Ride to Conquer Cancer" or similar events, where they provide food. But on situations like that my bike would be attached to my hip at all times, since I had a Garmin watch stolen from my bike many years ago.
My point is that carrying a small 20 grams battery is not a big deal when I go for the 100km+ bike ride alone - my preferred type as I don't have to wait for weaker riders or try to follow the stronger ones and I can enjoy my pain in solitude. LOL
Nice perspective. The 2 genuinely high level racers I know, though, both run mechanical. Their bikes go in and out of cars/vans every weekend, and they've both had issues with batteries dying and/or finding themselves trying to diagnose an electronic gremlin at 1am in a hotel room. They both agree Di2 is objectively better, but it's once bitten, twice shy.
Thanks, JD, some good points there.
I ride a Specialized Roubaix Comp with SRAM Rival eTap shifting. SRAM has two advantages over Shimano, in my opinion. First, there is but one shift lever under each brake lever, so there is no fussing about trying to find the smaller level like with Di2. Second, if you do not check battery levels frequently enough and get caught on the road with a dead battery (and it WILL happen, hopefully only once!), it will be the one on the rear derailleur that is used more frequently. At this point, one merely selects the front chain wheel one uses more (the large if you are like me and do not do enormous hills!) then swap the batteries on the front and rear derailleurs, which will allow you to continue to shift on the cassette and get home, hopefully not letting it happen again! I upgraded to this bike last year from a 2018 Roubaix and do not regret it for a moment!
Yep, I just picked up the Roubaix SL8 Expert also with SRAM Rival and I love it.
Never had a problem finding the buttons on my Di2 Ultegra. Even with thick gloves. That being said I'm fine with my mechanical bikes too so I don't think electronic shifting is such a big upgrade anyway.
What a great channel, I thought your video explanation was perfect, thank you! I still use mechanical groupsets for my training and race (sportive) bikes and I have been riding seriously for over 30 years, so I am unlikely to change now. But I also have an ebike for riding around London and this has disc brakes and Di2 Alfine hub gears and is an absolute joy to ride. Almost no maintenance and superb braking on a heavy bike. What I really like is that I can stop at a traffic light and shift to 1st gear when stationary and the display shows me which gear I'm in.
Hi Richard,
Glad you're enjoying the content.
I rode an e-bike once with a similar hub..... what an amazing bit of kit. I had it in the workshop for repair, it was the mechanical (non Di2) version. Getting the back wheel off wasn't fun, I can tell you 🤣
I used the old version of sram red etap wireless and I loved it actually. Very crisp in shifting and quick.
Lag
Having just bought a bike with mechanical as my electric group set bike broke I can definitely say I’m swapping back to electric as it crisper changes and easier to change on hills.
Great video! Love all your output…. Very easy to understand! Thanks!
Great to hear, and glad you enjoyed it 👍
I was complaining about my r8020 hydraulic ultegra but after your video I started appreciate this group 😊
Great groupset 👍
Great discussion, thank you ! You slipped it a comment that may have gone past more then a few people, "if you are racing"... are you consistently operating at the top end of your fitness range and competing, you will want every available advantage, in that case, electronics and discs might be down your alley. Been on a bike and racing since the mid 70's, the technology back then obviously was very rudimentary, I remember seeing the first Regina 6 speed block and being excited. Everyone rode 531C frames and Campy, that's all there was to be. proper cyclist.
STI changed everything, before that the phenomena of Look clip less pedals, I was first off the rank with both, what they did for my racing was amazing, out of the saddle and shifting... yow
I've stayed with mechanical all this time, although I switched back to Campagnolo when Ergopower came out.
I stopped racing ten years ago, I still train hard and put in the kms, but have yet to fins a substantial reason as to why electric shift would be of benefit to me now, I just don't need it.... I did, road test a top of the range Cervelo not that long ago with the SRAM group, tubeless tyres and all that palaver.... you know, it was okay.. nothing there to justify the eye watering price of either the complete bike, or the group. where I live, in Chiang Mai, has a robust and very active cycling community full of young turks, some very very good, who like to have their S Works, Pinarellos and Cervelos, with disc brakes and full Di2. And of course, the correct shoes and clothing.
I'm digressing but the only real point is that, to me, my 11 speed Campy Chorus mechanical group works a treat, I can fix it myself if needed, rebuilding the shifters is easy, I have never yet been stuck out in the sticks praying for a phone signal ... Cheers, mate
Great read, Steve, thank you. Out of the saddle, and shifting...... You crazy kid 😉. As a lover og great engineering, Campagnolo is a beautiful thing. As I've said in other moments here, few 'Modern' cyclists know of the quality and simplicity that Campagnolo gives. One day I'll build up an old steel Pinarello, and fit it out with an old Campagnolo Record groupo.
@@ribblevalleycyclist a nice Columbus frame, beautiful...
What you said around 3:20 about over shifting; that's how you shift on the old lever style top tube and down tube shifters. That's cool they programmed it into indexed gears
Yeah, it is clever, thanks Caveman 👍
Great advice - thank you!
Excellent Video matte. Spot on about the balance, not favoring at all. Cheers from Brazil!
Thanks, glad you enjoyed it. And hello from England 👍
I think it depends - as most things - on the use case. I would recommend it on road bikes as the shifting really is super smooth, no maintenance due to wore out cables, no adjustments anymore once it's setted up. (the battery is very long lasting and durable as well)
But I wouldn't recommend it for gravel/offroad bikes as it seems a bit fragile to me in case of falling down or collisions with roots or whatever...
Completely agree with you, Hellebarde. Well said 👍
I thought I don’t need it, but now that I have it I don’t want to go back to old tech. I absolutely love it. As a matter of fact, I also bought a mountainbike with electronic shifting.
My thoughts too 👍
Fantastic explanation, very helpful!
Glad it was helpful!
Well thought out video. Enjoyed it.
Thanks, Julian, Glad you enjoyed it!
I run a mix of Rival (FD), Red (RD), and Force (Shifters). Incredible difference to my experience with mechanical over the years. Shifts flawlessly every time. Perfect too if you’re not comfortable servicing gear cables and making adjustments on a regular basis. Very reliable so far and the battery lasts a long time.
I've ridden both SRAM and Shimano for years. I wouldn't describe SRAM shifting as flawless. In races you're always missing shifts or shifting too far. Shifting up the cassette is like an old school friction shifter with sram.
just no dude. @@aaron___6014
I met a professional rider who was fuming at the way the electronics failed at a crucial stage of a race. He said, stuff the sponsors...when I'm in race mode, I want bullet proof reliability. And that is cable connected gear changes.
Exactly
If this is an Argument then maybe you should only ride on indoor trainers.
Enjoy your ride!
I doubt many pros would choose mechanical, it's just slower to shift and awkward if you're sprinting for example. Split seconds matter for them
@@pierrex3226 Nonsense... Mechanical s faster, period. The only limitation, and that goes for all systems and methods is the rotational speed of the drive train.
@@chaosengine3772 even if one or the other is faster, the question should be how much faster? The next question should be how much this small difference would make for 99% of riders? I don't see the payoff being their for most.
Nice to see you’re back 😊
Eyup! LDC. Hope you're well mate. Like is just getting in the way at the moment, struggling to find time to film. See you had a crack at Great Dun Fell the other day..... Nice one!
@@ribblevalleycyclist had a binge watch of your 3 videos last night spot on mate 😊
WOOW FANTASTIC! GREAT JOB MAN!
Cheers, Gheorghe, glad you liked it 👍
As I write this comment, I'm sitting at 11 22 in time in the video . Had this thought that I've learned more from this video that you made. Then I have in years and years of watching GCN. I'm just saying great job make more 🤯.
Thank you, Justin.
Had to watch the video at 11:22, just to see where you were when you came to this conclusion!!
Don't tell Simon or Ollie at GCN, they'll be most upset 🤣
"Does it make your life easier?" Was pretty much all I needed to hear! 😆 (I already migrated half of my bikes to SRAM Eagle AXS anyway, but still nice to hear it should stay easier, because everything always works fine when new. 😉)
Easy life is a good life 🤣
Thank you so much! Pressure from mates to go electronic but I have resisted. I will stay with the mechanical 105 for the new bike I am getting. This info made my mind up. Cheers!
And that, Timeman is exactly why I made this video. Give you the basic facts, and you can make the decision for yourself.
Glad you liked it, and glad it helped.
Thanks,
Jon
I bought an electronic rear derailleur (SRAM GX AXS) for my MTB. It’s works well and is solid enough, but… if you aren’t diligent, you can forget to charge or lose a battery. Then you’re screwed on a ride. The contacts springs on my derailleur failed and wouldn’t connect with the battery, creating problems on a ride. They warrantied the derailleur, but I wasn’t comfortable with the cons vs the pros. If you break the derailleur, it’s about $500 min to replace. I do love how it cleans up the bike and simplifies it (less cables, easy to remove and clean).
I went back to mechanical and used Shimano SLX on my new bike. I don’t miss electronic. Rest assured, electronic is mostly about making much larger margins for the brands. Less about being that much better.
SRAM Rival is my setup. The biggest help I've had with it that I didn't anticpate, was the rear being totally wireless makes it really easy to remove the mech when I pack my bike for travel.
Good point.
Its no advantage over di2… you just unplug the RD and remove it
You've also got to remove the battery for Di2 to fly.... so its more intensive work.@@thedownunderverse
@@stuartfrancis519 might depend on where u are? Google tells me TSA doesn’t require it
You’re the first person I’ve seen explaining properly how electronic shifting works. Thanks. I’ll stick with mechanical , for now, though
Glad you found it useful. Stick with your mechanical for as long as you can, it's a great system.
Thanks for watching.
Jon
@@ribblevalleycyclist I had a derailleur failure, on my old Tiagra last year. Awkward as it’s different pull ratios from the newer Tiagra, but my local bike shop replaced it with an old 10 speed Ultegra derailleur they had left over from someone’s bike upgrade. Absolute bargain price and shifts better than ever. That would never happen with electronic!
Well done video. I was thinking about electronic shifting but you've convinced me that it really is;nt worth it in my case.
I've had a few companions whose battery died on a ride and it was a disappointment for them.
A well tuned and cleaned mech system is what I'm sticking with.
Thanks for a well balanced explanation.
Glad it was useful. Agreed, a well maintained groupset is a great solution to a simple problem 👍
I ride in a fairly salty road group, traded in my Cervelo S3 11 speed mechanical for a Cervelo Caledonia 5 with sram e tap 12 speed. Electronic shifting is instantaneous front and back. This helps immensely when riding with a fast pace road group, especially attacking hills. You are spot on, the e tap is totally brainless, just discovered your Chanel and am subscribing, keep up the good work👍✌🏼
Hi PACFAN,
Sounds like you're enjoying that new Cervelo! Mechanical is great, have it on my winter bike. But when you just don't need the hassle, electric is the way.
Thanks for the sub 👍
I have a Shimano 11 speed. electronic switching. I recently switched to this type of switching. But I can say that compared to the mechanics, the electronic group works clearly. For me, the difference is palpable. The only minus of this system is the price.
I embraced hydrolic disc brakes, but so far, I've resisted electronic shifting and the move to proprietary parts with fully integrated cables and hoses. Wanted a new bike so i got a modern steel Fairlight Strael v3 in mechanical 11 speed Ultegra. All cables and hoses routed externally, threaded BB, and standard bar, stem and seatpost. Couldn't be happier and if something breaks i can easily fix it myself with minimal fuss or cost.
Interestingly I've noticed some online articles and videos recently promoting the benefits of good old fashioned friction shifting. Generally i do wonder if there’s a growing movement to keep bikes as simple as possible and definitely a feeling that things have got way too expensive for what should be a simple and eco friendly machine.
I love your viewpoint !
After spending nearly 3 years on my 1st internally routed all-road bike (Trek Checkpoint), it felt so good ordering a Lynskey Titanium frameset with external routing and threaded bottom bracket. Can't wait to build it with my existing hodgepodge mechanical groupset of Gevenalle/Microshift shifters, Ultegra FD (Friction shifted!) & GRX RD.
@@swray2112 Adam from Zero Friction Cycling here on UA-cam criticized me for mentioning that I did a lot of ultrasonic bicycle component cleaning during COVID 19 . He saw it as a threat to their business thinking that I am nearby when I am in another part of Australia to him . I have a friend with a litespeed which was interesting to try some years ago . Adam has been known to speak inappropriately in his video clips at times . I have watched all those he has published over a few weeks . He means well but gets too carried away at times .
@@robertmcfadyen9156apparently he had a beef with Durian too
The return to simpler cycling, I agree, it's a thing. You should check this guy out, if you haven't already - www.youtube.com/@PathLessPedaledTV
Solid points!
Thankyou for info
I've got Sram etap, had it amazingly 5yrs, I got it as I really wanted it then, I love the logical left easy right hard aspect of shifting. Whereas di2 keeps the mechanical aspect; right rear up and down the back gears and left front gears - for me, the Sram stuff is better. I'm still getting a month out of it and even I'm amazed, still at every shift, tho it's reduced but theirs nothing like it 👌
I have a mix, so I just program the Di2 bikes to shift Sram-like. Of course, the FD is a bit different and occasionally catches me out when I try to double click on the Di2.
Long live mechanical shifting and rim brakes! Electronics are expensive. Also, it transforms bikes into electronic gadgets that go into the bin like a phone, rather than a life-long love affair.
That was the plan... obsolescence and proprietary components. To get people, every few years to buy more bikes and gear. I'm still rolling Campy Record Ergo Power from '93 that I can still get every single part for.
That is very true, it would potentially harm the close bond between me and my bicycle. What exactly is wrong with some components being slightly temperamental if it keeps you on your toes and tests your metal, am I able to lift my backside out the saddle and glide up this incline or not, gives the ride a bit of edge.
Mechanical all the way for me too. Rohloff and rim brakes! Viva!
I was offered Di2 for my 2020 Cannondale CAAD 13. I said no. If it ain't broke, don't fix it. I love my Shimano Ultegra 11spd mechanical. It shifts flawlessly.
It’s why I ride a single speed, bike with no suspension, why complicate cycling?. I also only drive a manual transmission car, with a carburetor and no radio, who needs those kinds of frills?
I was actually dismissing electronic shifting as a gimmick. After seeing all the advantages here, I am starting saving up for one. Even though it's a lot of money extra, I think it's worth it, when you get older like me with a little arthritis.
Very good vid ! I'm not ready for it yet Lol but now I know more details and thanks for this !
Glad you found it useful, thanks 👍
I picked up a tt bike with di2 last year and it’s made my road bike with mechanical borderline unrideable because the electronic is just so much better. Perfect shift every time, it just never messes up. I get so aggravated on my road bike having to feather the shifter to try to micro adjust when it mis-shifts. Now I’m in the market for a used di2 groupo so that I’m not so mad on my road bike 😂
Creating this video has taught me that the vast majority of people that take issue with electric shifting........ don't have, and never have used electric shifting.
You just don't know how to adjust a derailler that all 😊!
I saw no purpose for electronic shifting until I got a bike that came with it. Now that I use it, I absolutely love it. Effortlessly shifting, no missed shifts, no adjusting. Would not want to go back to mechanical.
get a Life.Mate.
I didn't gel with Di2 at all even without gloves on. I found myself hitting the harder gear too often when on a steep climb in Portugal. Even after two weeks on the bike (Scott Addict) I still made the same error. I'm sure I'd eventually get used to it but I love bikepacking across Europe and love the push of the lever too much to change. I use 1x GRX as I dislike changing the front ring. Excellent points you made, fully agree with all 😊
I like my axs X0 on my eMTB and yes, I had a purely mechanical shifting previously over 50 years, but with the new pod, I shift even more relaxed 🙂
If you choose a SRAM electronic group set you could very easily change the batteries when they are worn out and if one battery goes dry during your ride you can change it with the other battery and still be able to change your rear gears and you can take the batteries of and charge them inside.
Agreed, the SRAM battery setup is slick
My first electronic group set is Ultegra 11 speed Di2 on my 2022 bmc road machine. First road bike with discs and just love them both. Very rare does my campy 10 speed record mech equipped Ti bike get an outing these days. I keep the mech set in very good condition, recently replaced the cables etc, however the electronic set is just crisper, no hassles with the front derailleur, and over all I just prefer the feel of the shifts. I am 68, so have had a few group sets in my time . Each to their own though
Very well done, thanks
Glad you liked it
I’m a di2 convert. It’s just great. Really is. I won’t be going back. Not sure why anyone would think a 1500 mile charge cycle would be a problem. Love the full synchro shifting. 👌🏻
With you there, Mendip, I love it too. Saying that though, the mechanical on my gravel is a good solution too.
I recently bought a new carbon disc bike. $2100. Full mech Ultegra. Same bike Di2 105 was $600 more. Just an incredible deal for smooth shifting, durable, classic and easy to maintain drivetrain. Would I like di2? Sure. But with this deal I’ll save the money.
Di2 105 over mech ultegra. $600 ? You gotta go di2.
@@royanderson3478 why? It is heavier, less premium feel, not cassette except 11-34... and mech Ultegra works flawlessly
I ride a bike with downtime shifters and recently got a chance to ride a bike with ultegra mechanical, during a fast group ride, and I have to say the smoother shifting ability definitely makes me faster!
Agreed. STI shifting was a game changer. It won races, fact!
@@ribblevalleycyclist Campy Ergo Power did too! Recall there was also indexed downtube shifters for years before they reach the brake levers.
It was all about the timing, stability and control differences from moving the hand, looking down or feeling the downtube shifters. From integrated brake-shifters, you have instant dumping of gears in mid sprint while having full control (even when braking) of the bike. No looking down or fumbling tight in a pack, following a wheel. That made a difference to how sprints were won.
I live in the hills and being able to shift in any position is awesome. Yes, keep it clean, but that goes for anything. I assume most have lights, radar, etc. Charging derailleur batteries is an afterthought. I have Sram Rival AXS. You can still ride hours after the light on the derailleur goes from green to amber.
thank you, I have learned a lot from this video!
Glad to hear it! Thanks 👍
Before I even watch the vid im going to say, although I really liked the mech groupset I had,,, I LOVE the electronic groupset I now have.
Haha.... And what do you want to add, now you've watched it?
@@ribblevalleycyclist Ill add I totally agree with all of your pros and cons, im very particular about the way I keep my bikes, they are ALWAYS impeccably spotless because I love tinkering with them and I love the tech side of things. Im not a cafe cruiser and for me Its about the performance as I try to squeeze every second out of my ride because thats what I love, (when I ride with my wife I take it easy soak up the scenery) so for me I would never go back, I LOVE Di2.
Glad to have found you, and after watching your video ,I will be stopping with my 10s 105 group set, simple to fix , cheap to repair and easy live with.
And that Paul, is exactly why I make these videos. The idea is to tell you what you need to know, and for you to make your own mind up.
Thanks, appreciate it 👍
I rebuilt my 2008 bike to R7000 a couple of years ago - just before Shimano went to 105 Di2. That’s really, really nice. Shifts are wonderful. Cable routing aside, (my 2008 Spec Roubaix is all external) my FD was the best build I’ve done. So nice.
Completely agree. I remember when I first went from 5800 to 7000, this difference was night and day. As far as shifting was concerned, the difference between 7000 & 8000 was negligible. Still using it to this day.
Nice explanation! 👌🏼
Glad you liked it!
I did Unbound 200 last year on my first Di2 bike and it was an amazing decision for many reasons - particularly hand fatigue!
One thing I've learned from this video is that hand fatigue is a big issue for long rides that electronic overcomes.
Thanks for watching and commenting.
I don't know how anyone can say you get hand fatigue from shifting. I can shift with barely any force with my pinky. I've tried it multiple times. I have ultegra 11spd. If it hurts your hand to shift a road bike, you are insanely frail and need to take some testosterone or something.
@@Silidons91Rubbish. My left wrist totally disagrees. Especially in the winter and especially when you do a lot of big-small-big chainrings shifting. No mech grouppo works as good as the Di2
P.S. I REALLY want to see a vid of you shifting small->big chainrings on a mech Ultegra using your pinky only. 😂
Hell yeah, night and day difference.
@@Silidons91 Try doing a 12+ hour gravel race in the rolling Flint Hills of Kansas on mechanical shifting…I promise you’ll get some hand fatigue lol.
Is electronic shifting worth it? No.
Do I need it? No.
Do I want it? Yes!
I've been riding for 60 years and always embraced new tech, index gears (remember them?), brake shifters and now electronic gears. I've used etap for six years now with not a single problem. Price, don't care! Batteries, I carry a spare but have never used it. Shifting in the cold is dead easy. I am a minimalist so love the lack of stuff you get with etap. No cables on the bars, no cables in the frame or near the wheels. I wish I'd had them when I was racing in Yorkshire back in the day. I was always missing the break up the hill cause I couldn't find the right gear, at least that was my excuse.
well done, I'm sticking with my mechanical for now. I did find out the hard way that 10sp shimano shifters are VERY hard to come buy. I needed a left front and I couldn't find any online and my local shop had to go to ebay for them. They said this isn't the first time. Maybe 11 or 12 speed are easier to come by.
I agree with that, Barry. I'll need to locate a Tiagra mechanical hydronic lever in a few weeks, and I know I'm gonna have fun finding one!!
Thanks for watching.
Jon
A well set up and maintained 105 11s works flawlessly. The main problem is the drive to internal cables leaving a tortuous route from shifter to mech that just adds resistance and inaccuracies develop. I'm even using TRP compressionless cables and TRP Spyre brakes and they work perfectly too.
There is one situation whereby I could give SRAM kudos and that's for going wireless, and the ability to mix and match road STI's with MTB derailleurs so if you want to tune your gearing for where you live it's simple, no silly long b-screws and mech extenders and all those bodges...
You get my vote, Barry. Not gonna disagree with a single point you make there. 105, still a fantastic bit of kit, and you'll find 3 bikes in my stable running it.
I love the way my dura ace mechanical makes a reassuring little clunk and bang in gear every time.
I 100% prefer the mechanical shifting because of following reasons:
- cheaper
- more direct connection to your bicycle
- no batteries to be charged
- no batteries added to the mountain of waste
As the old saying goes, horses for courses. Both have their advantages and disadvantages.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts.
@@ribblevalleycyclist what is the advantage of adding batteries to the mountain of waste?
What a great video, so glad I found your channel. I think you put a great case for mechanical, though I’m still gonna go Di2…because I can! 😁👍🏻
Blessings from Dorset.🙏😎👍🏻
Hiya Steve in Dorset 👍
"You put a great case for mechanical"...... Most people have ranted at me for promoting electric over mechanical, so thank you for that.
Cheers
Jon
Great talking points!
Thanks, Unboxing. Oh, and the channel looks interesting!!
I have Di2 since 2015 and I personally love it. Yes it can have small issues and can be mare for people new to it when these issues arrive. I do love that you can interchange Dura Ace, Ultegra, XTR, XT and GRX (talking 11 speed), to make you perfect set up. For example, on my road bike, I use the XT display. This shows my gear and battery status, so avoids and power issues. It also doubles up as the Wireless sender and junction port. Shame this is not on 12 speed as yet, so will stick with 11 in the meanwhile. I agree not cheap, but not changing now.
I must admit, Darren, I love it too. This video sure has divided opinions!
I’ve ridden DI2 for the last few years alongside Dura Ace 9100 mechanical.
I tended to choose the mechanical bike as I prefer the ergonomics of the hoods and the gear changes are just as smooth.
I’ve now sold both DI2 bikes and have gone mechanical on all my bikes.
Gear cables with a modern group set are totally reliable and never need adjustment.
There is no worry about electronics packing up like a Dura Ace lever did on me.
The amount of times I’ve been on group rides and someone’s battery goes flat, it last happened last weekend.
Yep, I've been on a few club rides, and the Di2 Demon has struck.
All good points you make. Thanks, 👍
Di2 fails. Fact and it's not just battery
It is worth it. Let’s embrace the goodness of new technology.
I was agains electronic systems until I try it and I love it. Now I want it in all my bikes.
Most people are against it...... until they try it!
Gone 1x Sram Rival absolutely love it,nearly a year now no problems at all
Great video, thanks. Far better than the GCN tech coverage of the same subject. However... two things really. 1) Cost. At £750 more than mechanical, for bikes under £3K that most of us ride, it is going to mean significantly poorer components elsewhere, where it matters more: frame, wheels. 2) Complexity and Reliability. Less complex is better (always) - and simplicity is the essence of bicycle design. More complexity = less reliability (always). electronics anywhere on a bicycle is less reliable in the long term - so I don't agree with you on this. Over several years of riding in all weathers water gets in to Di2 connections and components, and then they die, usually suddenly, and you need new ones = complex and £big. On a mechanical the shifting gets gradually worse, so you notice and you put in new inner cables = easy and £small. Over recent years watching/riding/supporting the Fred Whitton I have seen loads more DNF than previously - almost all due to Di2 failures and not flat batteries either.
These are all valid points you bring, Robin. I too worry about electronic in poor weather, thats why I only use it on my summer/fine bike. For gravel, training, touring, workhorse, cargo, I use mechanical.
Fred Whitton.... Only ever done it once, that is where that photo was taken, as I'm sure you worked out.
I changed to electronic wireless shifting. Benefits: no cables anymore, no temperature issue with cable tension anymore. You set it up once and it is always accurate, shifting is fantastic especially when you do a technical curvy road and you need slow down and speed up, and the compensation shifting when you change gear at front then rear gears are adjusted. I will never go back to mechanical.
Absolutely worth every penny. On my 22 day tour. I was the only one with ZERO mechanical issues. And yes, poor shifting and broken shifter cables were seen in other traditional bikes.
It's interesting how this video had divided opinion! Thanks for sharing your thoughts, Anthony 👍
Straight to the point. I don't need it but I have the new sram force and it's so coool!
Well said
Do i need di2...no, do I want di2..... yes
Funny you should say that, that was supposed to be my closing line.... but I forgot 🤣
Do I need DI2 NO, do I want it.. NO
I'm a shimano fan boy, but man I'm tempted by wireless shifting.
Ain’t that always the case 😅
@@howarddavies136 go for it. 😊
I will switch to electronic once it will become cheaper than mechanical. And trust me, it will.
Currently it looks like the levers themselves are only slightly more expensive, but then the electronic shifters are signicantly more expensive.
In order to fully reap the benefits of electronic it needs to be fully wieless! No half measures like the cables that you still need to run from shifters into the battery. So, in summary, we just need to wait a little longer, it is not the time yet.
SRAM somehow, has the patent on wireless, so until the patent runs out, Shimano licenses the patent (not likely) or figure a cleaver way around it, Shimano electronic users are stuck with wires for the foreseeable future. Shimano, although still selling the 11 speed 105 mechanical for the time being, quit offering anything but DI2 with everything 12 speed. So it's not a question of when it will become cheaper, as it will be the only game in town for higher end users. Although it's been their practice to discount groupsets when a newer version comes out, other than that I don't see them reducing prices. Take a look at when the CD came out as an example. Not counting R&D, the audio CD was a mere fraction of the cost to make than the audio cassette, but because it was a newer and better technology, the price of an album went up roughly 60-70%. It never really went down. It takes significantly more tooling & precision to manufacture mechanical groupsets, especially the shifters, than electronic, just as the audio cassette. Stake holders in companies won't allow huge savings to be passed on to consumers, when it can become extra profit. Personally, I'm rooting for underdogs like Microshift, to clean their clocks, with great value & performing mechanical groupsets, which mostly depends on bike companies equipping new bikes with their products. So far Advent X is showing up on quite a few new bikes. Of course with huge profit margins of SRAM & Shimano, the can HEAVILY discount components to bike makers, so it will be an uphill battle.
I never trust anyone who says "trust me".
@@GoustiFruit Good for you.
@@swray2112 This is another idea that I forgot to mention: mechanical includes more value (labour) by default, so should be cheaper by defintion, this the main reason I think eventually mechanical will be more expenisve and reserved for just mechanical shifting and retro bikes enthusiasts... but Shimano and SRAM are milking the cyclists as much as they can with cheap to produce electronic shifting. Capitalism in action.
It will NEVER become cheaper than mechanical. You're going to be waiting a long time.
Great stuff, excelant said
Much appreciated
I'm still rocking my down tube shifters!
For me, electronic is worth it. No chain rub, perfect shifting each and every time, no readjusting the derailleurs after a few months of use like I had to do with mechanical, no cables to replace, bike looks better, just to name a few. If you have the extra money to make the switch, you will not regret it. I have 11-speed Sram Red E-tap. Only had one time that a battery was drained due to excessive amount of riding between charges. This was not a problem - swapped the front battery with the rear one and I was good to go.
single speed :)
I have a red etap 22 on my Cannondale. The Problem is the battery. The Sram shifting is much more intuitive than Shimano and you cannot mistake. And in the winter battery will got empty earlier. The Ultegra 8000 was the best Groupset I ever had.
Normally you can swap the front battery to the rear, as front derailer battery tend preserve more juice because rear derailer gets used more often when riding.
you can set up di2 to shift like etap.
Yes I did that a few times, I heard with DI2 that is not possible@@carlos_chen
Yes but the batteries are cheaper for Sram etap axs and it’s so easy to check your battery status just press the button on each derailleur if it’s a solid green light your good to go if it flashes red charge the battery it’s not difficult to do that the day before each ride is it?
Yes, absolutely right!@@MrChippiechappie
I love the GRX Di2 on my gravel bike, but I'm equally happy riding the Ultegra 6700 mechanical on my 10 year old road bike. I can do full maintenance and repairs on the old 6700, the Di2 will more than likely have to go to a bike shop if something fails.
Watching this made me wanna ride a fixie. Thanks.
Honestly like, I had just started getting into road biking after mountain biking for several years and I got a rival axs, best choice I could’ve made. Small things like where I lay my hands my body position just having a high quality hood, not to mention the really good experience. Even as a beginner electric shifting can accelerate your progression like crazy, I would Absolutley upgrade to electronic you had the option
Do you find the Rival hoods slippery? I went from Force to Rival (bought a new bike and having swapped components yet) and these hoods are hella slippery when sweating. I’ve actually bought a pair of gloves, which I typically don’t use
@@HoldenDoesBikeStuff that’s odd cause I find some of the force hoods that I’ve tried are a little more slick than my rival ones lol. I can’t say they’re sloppy for me but that could just be the way that I’m holding them, I hardly ever grab them straight on I’m always either on the drops or in an aero position arms on the bars kind of thing
Real world observation: Retired former amateur racer who spends appx. 3 months riding full time in the desert and nearby mountains in southern California. Every day I do a few hrs at least, many days are group rides much longer and at good pace, with lots of good riders, mostly well equipped. Since the electric shifting has been around, I personally have been with 4 dead battery people on remote rides. I've also had 4 or 5 friends show up on their old mechanical rim brakes..."Had to order a ______. It will be here in a month from_______(Name the manufacturer and country). There is no bike shop within 60 miles, so personally I always have spares for my Old school equipment and sometimes I have to fix things. But I never have to drive my bike to the city and leave it to be fixed by a technician. I don't have to find a power source for battery charging or a clean inviornment to bleed brakes. I just ride, every day the weather allows. Yes, I tune my Ultegra 8000 fairly often, but I'm a perfectionist when it comes to my bike. Yes, I replace the cables often because mine aren't inside the frame and it can be done during morning coffee.
One amusing thing I've found is in a group ride, everyone usually takes the front for a bit, but I tease my Aero bike buds and tell em, "Hey, you got 15 extra Watts now, get out there".…Doesn't work, but worth trying..😊
Nice read, Don. Sounds like you've got the Ballance just right 👍
4 bikes, two electronic (GRX di2 and Dura Ace di2), two mech (Force 1x). I'd say I love both. Have mech on my commuter bike (easy to maintain) and on my steel gravel bike (no need to charge, easy to fix on long trips) and elecronic on my road bike and performance gravel bike. What I love about elecronic on these : semi-synchro on the Dura Ace, so I can ride it as a 1x and the comfort on long hills ride, the ability to shift/brake and change a lot of gear in one press on the gravel, precious on technical climbs.