КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @EveryPaisaMatters
    @EveryPaisaMatters 20 днів тому +20

    Will you Invest in NPS Vatsalya for kids?

    • @raiamit1601
      @raiamit1601 20 днів тому +1

      No

    • @sanket492
      @sanket492 20 днів тому +2

      No, as we can only withdraw only 20% of amount after 18 years

    • @shailendrarai3082
      @shailendrarai3082 19 днів тому +6

      @@EveryPaisaMatters "No" is not a good answer. "Never" is the most suitable answer.

    • @rishi221986
      @rishi221986 19 днів тому +4

      No direct mutual fund is much better option

    • @AmitSinghIndia
      @AmitSinghIndia 19 днів тому +2

      No ..

  • @adityashrestha5214
    @adityashrestha5214 20 днів тому +70

    This country seriously needs a qualified finance minister.

    • @ankitdwivedi6966
      @ankitdwivedi6966 20 днів тому +6

      @@adityashrestha5214 true, she is worst FM till date.

    • @Lifesavingtraveling
      @Lifesavingtraveling 19 днів тому

      Retirement is best option to secure money as tender age ppl tempted to lavish life

    • @AmitSharma-sp3tr
      @AmitSharma-sp3tr 19 днів тому +1

      Qualified nahi bhai, anpad hi thik mannage karega..
      Jyada Qualified ka natiza to dikh hi raha
      Middle class family ka watt laga diya, garibo ko muft dene ke naam pe....

    • @Manojkumar-yk4ic
      @Manojkumar-yk4ic 19 днів тому

      @@adityashrestha5214 नालायक आदमी persent India fast growing economy in the world under finance minister

    • @mohmmadabutalibmohmmadabut8109
      @mohmmadabutalibmohmmadabut8109 18 днів тому

      @@adityashrestha5214 I agree with you

  • @shettigarrammohan2201
    @shettigarrammohan2201 19 днів тому +22

    It is better to open one mutual fund for kids and invest in sensex or Nifty 50 as a SIP which can gives 12-14% return in long run. At 18yrs, you can transfer that corpur to your kid simple as that. No condition like lock in or purchasing annuity.

  • @Abhibee4018
    @Abhibee4018 19 днів тому +36

    Who needs pension for minors, FM is mentally bankrupt

  • @tanmoykar4981
    @tanmoykar4981 16 днів тому +2

    Missing information in this video:
    1. Parents sign needs to be uploaded after eKYC verification
    2. Birth certificate needs to be uploaded in jpg/jpeg format
    3. Additional ~₹18 charged for account creation & the this will be a virtual PRAN for the minor
    4. Minors bank account details is optional

  • @rahmathullahg7127
    @rahmathullahg7127 20 днів тому +16

    Useless scheme.. Because as you said everyone needs money at the time of 18 years old for education ..we couldn't take entire money..

  • @amit5036ma
    @amit5036ma 20 днів тому +2

    Thanks Sir for such a detail video in simple language

  • @tofeeqmalik46
    @tofeeqmalik46 18 днів тому +2

    75% equity matlab stock market share investment in equity??

    • @nagarjunayt
      @nagarjunayt 18 днів тому

      Yes. You have option to choose as much equity as you want till a maximum of 75%

  • @dindian5823
    @dindian5823 19 днів тому +9

    parents putting money in ppf for future of minor are not criminals.
    Anyway one doesn't get tax credit beyond 1.5 lacs what's your problem than Nirmalaji.
    You are acting like a dictator and making sure BJP doesn't win the next time... I single handedly hold you responsible for such a messy implementation of GST and now this PPF screw-up.
    What do open category children do for their education if they are even denied this money for which their parents will pay IT

  • @naveenavadhani
    @naveenavadhani 19 днів тому +3

    Which minor kid will have PAN card. Great analysis

    • @veenahegde7441
      @veenahegde7441 19 днів тому +1

      If u invest money for your minor children

    • @avi2chauvinist4blr
      @avi2chauvinist4blr 18 днів тому +2

      Even a just born kid with birth certificate can have a pan card. U have to know things before commenting

    • @tofeeqmalik46
      @tofeeqmalik46 18 днів тому

      @@avi2chauvinist4blr xD

    • @structural_trader
      @structural_trader 18 днів тому +1

      Yes minor can have a pan card ....

    • @naveenavadhani
      @naveenavadhani 18 днів тому +1

      Sorry never knew that

  • @jijnasuagnihotri3618
    @jijnasuagnihotri3618 18 днів тому +1

    Nice presentation

  • @nagarjunayt
    @nagarjunayt 18 днів тому +1

    I don't understand the problem of the majority commenters including the OP here. Whats wrong in investing in a Pension Fund for your kids!? NPS as a product could be considered as one of the investment options for the future of the child. The point of a pension scheme itself is that you're saving for one's retirement. Why are you always worried about withdrawing funds from it!? The same criticism was meted out to normal NPS as well.

    • @DennyJohny
      @DennyJohny 18 днів тому +1

      If you are a welthy person then your comment is valid. Most of the people are middle class so for us this scheme is not good. What about if I die ? Child cant touch this money till she come to age 60 ? Who will take care her study ? Okay we can take term insurance but what about PTD or PPD for me ? We need to think all aspect as a middle class.

    • @nagarjunayt
      @nagarjunayt 15 днів тому

      @@DennyJohny That's why I've mentioned that this can be one of the investment options and not the only option. Please read my comment again. You're saving for your child's pension, not for any other needs. If you invest your savings in this fund, then you're not planning it right. That's why one needs to do goal based planning. What needs of the child should you plan for?
      Education and Marriage. If it's a single income family, you need money to run the family as well. Then the products that you invest in should have similar maturity timelines.
      E.g. if you have a 8 year old kid and you're saving for his/her college education, the goal is 10 years away. Hence, you should invest in large and midcap funds, obviously not NPS.
      If we always think about NPS as a product where your money gets locked, then there's no point of calling it as a pension scheme. Pension is for retirement. Not for withdrawal at any time. Even then, you have partial withdrawal options.

  • @Saswati_me
    @Saswati_me 14 днів тому

    deposited 1000, but, did not receive the PRAN NUMBER YET

  • @vineethmohananparakkat1385
    @vineethmohananparakkat1385 9 днів тому

    If there is no tax benefits during investment or withdrawal then what is the actual benefit of this scheme compared to others?

    • @cyberbully7718
      @cyberbully7718 4 дні тому

      There is the 2 lakhs limit under the 80C and 80CC(D) and the interest generated is also not taxed as per LTCG but the downside would be the mandatory annuity investment of 40% of the maturity corpus.

  • @Swarn2603
    @Swarn2603 19 днів тому

    Very informative and clear 👍👍

  • @zaheer1044
    @zaheer1044 19 днів тому +3

    Ye scheme hai ya scam, matalab bachhe ka retirement ab main plan karu, ye FM and government please hire one or 2 educated person

  • @sumanpaulchowdhury8333
    @sumanpaulchowdhury8333 16 днів тому

    If you have to keep your money locked in for 3 years then why not ELSS?

  • @jpyadav5546
    @jpyadav5546 17 днів тому +2

    कर्मचारियों को ops देते-देते, अब बच्चों को पेंशन देने लगा,,15-15 लाख रुपये कहाँ गया

    • @prasoon4u910
      @prasoon4u910 17 днів тому +1

      Khata khat bank me jama hai, ja ke nikaal le

  • @sandipsasmal4172
    @sandipsasmal4172 8 днів тому

    Newborn baby ka PAN card hota hai kya

  • @tanmaychoudhary5141
    @tanmaychoudhary5141 19 днів тому +1

    Pan is not compulsory for minor.

  • @jasmineortiz5551
    @jasmineortiz5551 19 днів тому +1

    Is the stock market actually getting better or is this the Election time manipulation to entice new investors, I'm currently sitting on an inheritance of 300k and i'm wondering do I invest in stocks or Gold?

    • @nealremy6635
      @nealremy6635 19 днів тому

      buy bitcoin! it is decentralized and most secure, thus healthy competition among many miners

    • @veronaconley1953
      @veronaconley1953 19 днів тому

      market crash is inevitable, but there are actually strategies to mitigate risk and profit consistently, tho such executions are usually carried out by investment experts

    • @Udaan0007
      @Udaan0007 19 днів тому

      BKL aa gaya scam karne.

  • @gauravkumars
    @gauravkumars 19 днів тому +1

    They've unnecessarily complicated it, our NPS Tier2 is perfectly good for this purpose. It gives us the benefit of low annual expense...and ability to withdraw 100% at the time of need later...no questions asked...

  • @usahoop26
    @usahoop26 19 днів тому

    What is difference, if any one invest in mutual funds other than this? There will not be any condition in simple Mutual Fund investment.

  • @shriganesh23
    @shriganesh23 10 днів тому

    बच्चे मायनर है तो PAN निकाल सकते है काय

  • @Udaan0007
    @Udaan0007 19 днів тому

    No unless 80% of maturity amount is eligible for withdrawal at the age of 18 for education needs of children.
    Also maturity amount must be tax exempt.

  • @komalchunarkar9
    @komalchunarkar9 20 днів тому +4

    इससे अच्छा तो म्यूच्यूअल फण्ड में पैसे investment करे
    सारा पैसो की withdrawal power अपने हाथ मे रहेगी और return भी ज्यादा मिलेगा.
    Waste of money scheame

  • @sumitpal1975
    @sumitpal1975 19 днів тому +1

    Sir , I have also opened minor account for my daughter 😊

  • @pradeepdas8104
    @pradeepdas8104 14 днів тому

    I have opened this account for my daughter in KFintech last week. I am also investing in Sukanya Smariddhi account, PPF and Mutual Funds for her future.

    • @EveryPaisaMatters
      @EveryPaisaMatters 14 днів тому

      Please don't invest here, invest in Mutual funds instead

    • @pradeepdas8104
      @pradeepdas8104 14 днів тому

      @@EveryPaisaMatters Already investing in Mutual Funds.

    • @EveryPaisaMatters
      @EveryPaisaMatters 14 днів тому

      Continue there and increase investment. This is a stupid scheme.

    • @pradeepdas8104
      @pradeepdas8104 14 днів тому +1

      @@EveryPaisaMatters But I like this scheme.

    • @kaushalkumarsingh6063
      @kaushalkumarsingh6063 10 днів тому

      @@pradeepdas8104 sir itna paisa h toh thoda muje dedo 🙏😭

  • @arunkewat6832
    @arunkewat6832 20 днів тому +4

    Isse achcha to RD hai.

  • @rajivgupta1964
    @rajivgupta1964 16 днів тому

    Doubtful new schemes like NPS vatsalya by govt on children financial safety after suddenly withdrawal/lower interest rate of children PPF a/c. What is the guarantee in the future that the govt will not change rules and regulations.
    After sudden change in children PPF a/c scheme at financial loss at cost of millions of children future education and marriage experience etc.

  • @vikramsinghrawat4151
    @vikramsinghrawat4151 15 днів тому

    Sir my daughter is special child can i open this account

  • @ashishchauhan9808
    @ashishchauhan9808 19 днів тому +1

    Gujrati mota bhai ka dimaag for having more funds from people … also minors don’t have PAN Card and Passports so is it for a particular class or segment of people ?

  • @rockstar4220
    @rockstar4220 19 днів тому

    Sir tax kitna honga

  • @divatherajput922
    @divatherajput922 19 днів тому

    Achha new born ka pan card kese bnega

    • @Lifesavingtraveling
      @Lifesavingtraveling 19 днів тому

      Zerodha ne bhi minor ke liye demat account open Kiya Hai
      Aur pan card online nsdl ki website me ban jayega

    • @Lauvbhangu
      @Lauvbhangu 19 днів тому

      Pan card guardian ka chahiye

  • @avijitdas4862
    @avijitdas4862 19 днів тому +1

    80% mandatory annuity purchase, seriously. This scheme is for govt. guaranteed income and not child's future or a tool for parent to utilize when needed. Better, buy a Gulak and save money in it, at least you will get all money back once you break it.

  • @me23xfhg
    @me23xfhg 16 днів тому +1

    The moment kid's wife claims for alimony 😅 all savings are gone except for nps and ppf

  • @technicaltripathi318
    @technicaltripathi318 19 днів тому +1

    Isme government ka bhi contribution hai kya

  • @riding_mutant3034
    @riding_mutant3034 19 днів тому +1

    Bankers are forced to open such accounts...

  • @viralshah2238
    @viralshah2238 18 днів тому

    Liquid fund mae dalo /Balance Advanced fund mae dalo rupya government mae scheme just joke hai

  • @carloslopez-bp7rp
    @carloslopez-bp7rp 19 днів тому +3

    ¡¡Asombroso!! Dios finalmente había cambiado mi vida a través de la Señor Alejandro Benedetti . 1500 cada diez días. Dios es bueno

    • @Victormateo581
      @Victormateo581 19 днів тому +3

      Vaya, ¿tú también conoces a Alejandro Benedetti?

    • @ArielVentas
      @ArielVentas 19 днів тому +2

      todos lo conocen. El es muy bueno en lo que hace. Un experto

    • @JosefinaKolosok
      @JosefinaKolosok 19 днів тому +2

      De hecho, el gobierno ha dicho que las cosas son más difíciles para sus ciudadanos y que no podemos quedarnos sentados y soportar todas las consecuencias de una mala gobernanza. Es obvio que nos dirigimos hacia la inflación; Siempre son los pobres los que reciben el golpe.

    • @MariaMantilla-fy4be
      @MariaMantilla-fy4be 19 днів тому +1

      Hoy llega a 50.000. Estoy realmente agradecido por todo el conocimiento y las pepitas que me han brindado durante los últimos meses.
      Comenzó con 20k en agosto de 2023

    • @Emilianojoaquin571
      @Emilianojoaquin571 19 днів тому +2

      Es un milagro y yo testificaría: ¡30.000 dólares cada 4 semanas! Ahora tengo una mansión grande y puedo permitirme cualquier cosa y también apoyar la obra de Dios y la iglesia

  • @babitaghosh8748
    @babitaghosh8748 20 днів тому

    🎉

  • @sandipsasmal4172
    @sandipsasmal4172 8 днів тому

    Pahla 48 second mein aapane bola bacche ka PAN card chahie

  • @abhishektiwari2247
    @abhishektiwari2247 20 днів тому

    18 years se jo baccha Kam hai, ooska pancard kaise bnega

    • @EveryPaisaMatters
      @EveryPaisaMatters 20 днів тому

      Ban jayega!

    • @saikatsfriend
      @saikatsfriend 19 днів тому +1

      Minor PAN Card hoga...NSDL website pe apply karke payment karne ke baad applied print copy along with all relevant documents given address jo ki Pune mein hai waha pe post karke hard copy vejna hoga

    • @partharniya2694
      @partharniya2694 19 днів тому

      Ban jayega

  • @sumanpaulchowdhury8333
    @sumanpaulchowdhury8333 16 днів тому

    Bogus scheme. For a 18 year old you need money for education, what's the need for annuity? Either you allow withdrawal of total amount or let them go to NPS tire II and when they attain 60 years allow them to either take the amount out or go for annuity. And again no tax benefit!! What the hell!!

  • @eriobotryavibes9914
    @eriobotryavibes9914 19 днів тому +1

    अपनी पेंशन का कोई जुगाड़ नहीं , बच्चों की पहले लगवा दें

  • @sanjaykumarsinha151
    @sanjaykumarsinha151 11 днів тому

    मैं अपने पैसे से बच्चों को पढ़ा सकता हु। ना कि उसके 60 साल की बाद पेंशन का ठेका लेना । मेरा व्यक्तिगत सोच है कि यह बहुत ही बेकार स्कीम है।

  • @vidhantiwari3314
    @vidhantiwari3314 14 днів тому

    अगर ये स्कीम श्रीमती निर्मला सीतारमण की छत्रछाया में रहेगी तो क्षमा करें ...हमारे बच्चे खुद अपना भविष्य बना लेंगे लेकिन उस lady की इजाद की हुई किसी भी स्कीम में नहीं फंसेगे

  • @tarheha1274
    @tarheha1274 20 днів тому +4

    Useless and hopeless scheme again

  • @nisargwalamk6732
    @nisargwalamk6732 19 днів тому

    LIC is the best

  • @deekshaseth459
    @deekshaseth459 16 днів тому

    NPS tier 1 for private people already Bakwaas, atleast liquidity should be given after 7 yr lock-in

  • @BhanupratapSingh001
    @BhanupratapSingh001 19 днів тому +1

    Listen this is pension scheme so it desgine as so. So many scheme for education go for those. Why u want everything in a scheme.
    Treat it as a pension scheme, not investment or education fund

  • @nisargwalamk6732
    @nisargwalamk6732 19 днів тому

    Children plan for lic

  • @tanveerrather7639
    @tanveerrather7639 16 днів тому

    Why should we invest in nps where only 9.5% annually return is possible instead of mutual funds where 20-25% annually return is possible..
    Backwas NPS

  • @SD_003
    @SD_003 16 днів тому

    What nonsense. Why would I invest for kid’s pension? Instead of education? 🤷🏼‍♂️

  • @sandeeprocks91
    @sandeeprocks91 20 днів тому +1

    Hopeless and useless just like APY

  • @drneerajguruji
    @drneerajguruji 20 днів тому +4

    बकवास स्कीम

  • @HareshShah-kd2uy
    @HareshShah-kd2uy 15 днів тому

    5 trelean economi Bana ne ke scheme.sarkar ko fayda investar ko 👍😂😂😂

  • @AjajulHaque-dj5dv
    @AjajulHaque-dj5dv 19 днів тому

    Ops allow toh kare pahle😂😂😂

  • @jeeteshkumar9425
    @jeeteshkumar9425 19 днів тому

    30 saal pichhe ka plan hai

  • @thegaganvinayak
    @thegaganvinayak 20 днів тому

    Isse best to mutual fund me daal lo. 500 sip

  • @amitpaul8700
    @amitpaul8700 19 днів тому +1

    Useless Scheme

  • @abhirupbanerjee3576
    @abhirupbanerjee3576 19 днів тому +1

    Not good scheme

  • @satvikkhare1844
    @satvikkhare1844 18 днів тому

    Please don’t do this st i pid scheme. This makes no sense that you put money in something that will mature after eternity. Better to give that money to your kid. Your kid will thank you later. Twitter has bashed this scheme left right and centre.

  • @dhananjayshukla6299
    @dhananjayshukla6299 16 днів тому

    Delhi me केजरीवाल ke saraab wale sheme ka asar saaf saaf dikh raha hai

  • @Dcba3241
    @Dcba3241 19 днів тому +1

    Most foolish scheme heard . 😅

  • @safiqulalam7812
    @safiqulalam7812 20 днів тому +2

    Kiya Hain a? Bakwas cheej? Very disappointed.

  • @partharniya2694
    @partharniya2694 19 днів тому

    Apna paisa hum khud nahi nikal paye to koi matlab nahi hai,badi muskil se paisa bachata hai vo bhi esi scheme me laga do jisme nikal nahi paye to matlab nahi hai , parents ko bacche ki education shadi ke liye paisa chahiye , bachat to isme laga di ab paise kaha se aayenge unke paas .better hai ki MF me nivesh kar deve .

  • @hsjshshshlsjshss3342
    @hsjshshshlsjshss3342 20 днів тому +1

    No lic best

  • @partharniya2694
    @partharniya2694 19 днів тому

    Nps itna acha hota to sarkari karamchari virodh kyo karte ,aakhir vo bhi education log hai

    • @BhanupratapSingh001
      @BhanupratapSingh001 19 днів тому

      Because earlier they are getting pension earlier. This will cover those who don't have gov jobs.

  • @randomplay8746
    @randomplay8746 19 днів тому

    Usse bekar kuchh nai hoga

  • @djayeshv84
    @djayeshv84 17 днів тому

    Bekar scheme सिर्फ gst लेने के लिए होता है सब कुछ

  • @kamalpant3089
    @kamalpant3089 18 днів тому

    Yaha khud ke job ka pata nhi h or ye log children ke pension ki baat kr rhe h.. had h

  • @ElizabethDavid-d8j
    @ElizabethDavid-d8j 17 днів тому

    Grady Mount

  • @ratuldekaraja7323
    @ratuldekaraja7323 19 днів тому +1

    Bakwas Scheme😅

  • @bahutachhalaga1233
    @bahutachhalaga1233 20 днів тому +1

    Third class scheme

  • @nobuffer-indef
    @nobuffer-indef 10 днів тому

    Annuity bhai 1 number scam hai

  • @aniketanand2888
    @aniketanand2888 18 днів тому

    Abtak ka sabse ghatia FM.
    Hum pyaj nahi khate ,,,,
    Tum hawa Khao.....

  • @deekshaseth459
    @deekshaseth459 16 днів тому

    Totally bakwas scheme

  • @abhishekkumar-lf8cz
    @abhishekkumar-lf8cz 18 днів тому

    Bahut bekaar scheme hai

  • @HareshShah-kd2uy
    @HareshShah-kd2uy 15 днів тому

    Bogas scheme.

  • @lopamudrajha8698
    @lopamudrajha8698 17 днів тому

    Bekar scheme hai

  • @nobuffer-indef
    @nobuffer-indef 10 днів тому

    ye chindi scheme hai government ki

  • @SeedhiBaat1947
    @SeedhiBaat1947 16 днів тому

    Best ? Sharam karo thodi

  • @AmitSharma-sp3tr
    @AmitSharma-sp3tr 19 днів тому +1

    Nirmala ji ko bharat ratan se upar ka koi award se nawaja jana chahiye
    Middle class family ke saath jo khilwad ye mahila kar rahi hain wo bardast ke bahar ho chuka
    Sukanya samriddhi yojna bhi koi khas benefits nahi deta unko jo jyada investment nahi kar sakte
    Ya aise log jinka mahine ka income fix nahi rehta...
    Usko flexible banana tha ki pure 1 saal mein jitna ho sake utna deposit kijiye
    Kisi saal 10000, kisi saal 50000
    Jab jitna possible ho
    Lekin govt sirf khud ke liye fund arrangement mein lagi hai, is tarah ke chutiya banane wale scheme se.
    Isse best to sahara india tha, sabko diya hi diya