Shocking similarities in Indo-European Myths. Zeus Pater = Ju-piter = Dyaus Pitr (Indian)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 лют 2025
- This is a lecture about a chapter of my world history book called:
"In Search of the Sublime - A world history of humanity's relentless pursuit of scientific truth, moral excellence, and enlightenment."
Read the book for FREE at:
worldhistorybook.com
Or buy it on Amazon:
www.amazon.com...
Kind regards,
Stephan P. Dinkgreve
MSc Theoretical Physics
Amsterdam
I've watched a lot of these types of videos, but I enjoyed the level of detail you went into and the number of connections that you've illustrated. Thanks for making this!
The oldest evidence of this culture traces back to India as vedas mentions a river at its prime (which got extinct around 1500 BCE). Saraswati river at its prime existee around 6000 BCE which also corraborates with the astronomical references given in Vedas which traces back to same timeline. All aspects of indo european culture can be found in India but not all aspects of the culture in India are present in other European countries. With the evidence of such diversity, ot further proves that india is the source of indo European culture.
@phoenixj1299 naditama Saraswati river is still good and going in Afghanistan. Who told you it dried up? Pajeet😂😂
@@Dasyuhan Your statement is as relevant as claiming "Amazon forest is in Antarctica". As expected from a descendant of defeated people.
@phoenixj1299 pajeet my son halmand river is literally called Haraxvati River in Old persian and avestan. Everyone knows sanskrit s turns into persian h
Sindhu - hindu
Asura - ahura
Sapta - hapta
Saraswati - haraxwati
Also speaking of defeated people, The entire pajeetad and pajitistan is resulted of Some of our European Aryans kings interbred with your old daasa women who are referred to in rigveda as ayajna (yajna-less) anyavrata (people with different vows) avrata (vow-less people) anaas (nose-less) anindra (indra-less) daasa and dasyu. Thats exactly how you also got our language, religion, and culture, with indra zeus pater (dyaus pita) being the supreme god. however, you created corruption in all of that due to the influence of the old languages and cultures of pajeetistan meluha. Over time OUR language morphed into the currupt formed called vedic sanskrit and vedas were composed in that currupt language which then eventually turned into your modern languages and European religion eventually turned into curruption called hinduism with cartoon non vedic characters such as shiva, rama, krishna, durga, kaali, hamuman, and so on and you. You preserve only some of the old european gods and rituals but in a very scant and distorted form. You preserve none of the roots.
@phoenixj1299 indraless kqau danq iiting daasas with weak genetics who have always been dominated by aryans, persian, greeks, huns, scythians, arabs, turks, mongols, british, and Chinese are now calling other people defeated 😂😂
@phoenixj1299
indraless kqau danq iiting daasas with weak genetics who have always been ruled by aryans, persian, greeks, huns, scythians, arabs, turks, mongols, british, and Chinese are now calling other people defeated 😂😂
There is a story in Rig Veda called the battle of 10 kings clearly mentioning that out of those 10 only 1 became victorious called Bharat whose name after India i.e. Bharat comes from.
Some of the kings who lost were banished out of Indian Sub-continent and theory is they migrated into Europe. This happened 6-8 thousand year ago if u try to date it as per astronomical data!!
Saar India number 1 saaaar
@@SoldadoCatolico saar jesass white saar
sarrr money sarr.
@@samuraiRoniz yes, the five Aryan tribes Purus, Druhyu, Anu, Turvashu and Yadu were altogether in the Indian subcontinent. But later after a major internal battle between the Aryan tribes, the Bharats a branch of Purus emerged victorious, expelling the Druhyu(proto European) and Anu(proto Iranians) so they were forced to leave India. The Druhyu went via Central Asia into the steppes and the Anus went via West Asia into Asia minor. It is they that conquered Eurasia and formed the later Mlecchs races re Sakas etc. While they fought together against the Bharatas, they also fought each other fiercely for the supremacy of Eurasia. In this battle the Iranians ended up being the dominant tribe. The Druhyu ended up fleeing into far western Europe where they started the Celtic empire. The Germanic, italic, Slavic and Tocharian people are off shoots of the Druhyus.
None of this is made up, this is documented up history written clear as day in the oldest IE literature the Vedic Corpus. European scholars simply can't admit and have cooked up this PIE theory as denial, looking for an imaginary PIE people as their ancestors.
@@Agnostic7773 that what ur mother moaned while I gave it to her!!
India is the cradle of civilization ❤
Uh, probably not. One of the very earliest, but probably not first. Really depends on your definition of civilization though.
Bharat... Is the Cradle of Civilization . 🚩🚩🚩
The Indian civilization was the largest civilization but not the first.
😂😂 Please tell what you're taking, seems interesting.
Where is the Indus river?
@@youknow6968i am an intellect and study philosoply, but i think ur from an opium producing bankrupt state 😂. Which ignorant religious book are you reading?
But Dyaus is neither king of god nor thunder god . He is pithrudevatha not king of gods . King of gods is indra which resembles with jupiter and zues too . Dyaus represents the pithrudevatha of space not sky . I think u got confused .dyuas is one of 8 vasus . But indra is one of adityas . Indras behaviour which almost resembles zues 😂. Not dyaus . Dyaus incarnation is bheeshma . Indra incarnation is all five Pandavas which big story to tell .
+1
You are wrong! Indra became the king of gods after he was born, before Indra it was the primordial gods dyeus pitr and mather. Just like how zeus became the king of God later but wasn't the king of gods before he wasn't born, lol.
Dyeus is like ouranos who was the grandfather of zeus.
It's literally in the name crap skin, holy shit giving india internet access was a grave mistake.
Indra is name position not a person or gods name @@akhilvijendra2018
@@shivam_shinde yeah so what, I know it is a position (and do you know even brahma is a position?) but it was occupied by someone, whoever occupied it will be called Indra. So the son of Dyaus became Indra or occupied that position, that is still aligned with what I said.
In true to recent archeology which proved Rigveda and many Indus scripts are found to be Rigvedic sentences, Aryans are sure from ancient Indus valley civilization or Indus Saraswathi civilization!! They are the original founders of Indus civilization!
@@Saraswathiputra lol no. that have been debunked left and right by the whole world multiple times. Don't embrace yourself 😂😂
@@tsarvladimirputin409as far i know their is no word in Dravidian which is natively used by Dravidians ( for things which found or used in indus civilization ) example= for swastika ( all Dravidians language uses Sankrit loan word swastika was used in Indus Neolithic to peak of civilization time )
So does term yagna( fire altar found in kalibangan Indus 2900bce )
is yakanam in Dravidian ( fire ritual ) = yasna in Iranian
Bricks in Tamil mean
"senkan" ( which mean burned up , dried )
But this word common with old Indo Europeans language rather the Dravidian
Sek in Sankrit
Sekkai ( prakrit)
Sengen ( Germanic)
Siccare ( Latin )
@@tsarvladimirputin409most used crop in indus culture = wheat = Sankrit ( gothuma ) gandhum in Persian Tamil = kotuma
But kotuma in Tamil simply mean wheat
But in Sankrit and Persian it taken from two word used for wheat as to describe it's physical appearance meaning "earth smoke/ dust"
Which proof Sankrit Persian have origin of word rather than Tamil which taken loan word and they don't have knowledge of its core meaning
@@greaterbharat4175 whats your point
@@tsarvladimirputin409barely( yava in sankrit) was also highly used crop in indus and they don't have word in Tamil they actually used english loan word ( as parli)
😅
There are common myths. In india many of these myths became religion, then expanded, branched, adopted, adapted and still growing without an end in sight. Well, after all we all are just existential, so why bother about reason and proofs. Only problem is some think they are better than others and a problem starts.
Brahma the Creator, Vishnu the Preserver, Shiva the destroyer = the three Fates:
Clotho spins the thread of life.
Lachesis measures the length of the thread.
Atropos cuts the thread with scissors.
Indian mythology is beautiful
@@nurulhudavijapurwala4936please don’t call it a myth 🙏🏼
If there's no evidence of truth it's called a mythology.
And pseudo evidence of certain things aren't evidence at all. The reality represent all things with proof and evidence.
But yet Indian mythology is so beautiful because i have a right to call it mythology if I say adam-eve mythology then I'll be killed by allegation of blasphemy.
That's make me proud Hindu.
@@nurulhudavijapurwala4936 evidence is there! What more do you want?
(...) God the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit.
The counter-culture Pagans hate that fact as much as the scripture thumping Jews.
It is "theology". No "myth". The English language disparages Indo & Greek philosophies and theologies as "myth", while only christian stories are dressed with "theo".
the word Europe is derivative of latin/roman europa which is actually Eos+ropa eos is greek ropa/roopa is sanskrit ropa/roopa means a form of appearance it means someone who has taken a form from eos or is like eos, greek eos primordial Goddess derivative of sanskrit Ish/Esha supreme God/Goddess
eire Goddess
no from Eos s has been omitted to form Eorope/Europe
ΕΥΡΩΠΗ ->ΕΥΡ-ΩΠΗ ->the woman who has big and beautiful eyes
Phoenician word Erob: "where the sun set". Phoenicians were the tutors of the Hellenised “Greeks"
Err u ba literally means ‘dark/foggy/cloudy’ ‘it’ ‘is’. And corresponds with the fact that Europe was seen as a cloudy and less sunny place than what we were previously used to.
There is saying “atithi devo bhava” in Sanskrit meaning we should think of guests as God.
I think in the Lithuania their own mythology also twin gods horse gods and they also the name very similar to Sanskrit name Ashwin in the lithuanian word is Ašvieniai
This is a good presentation but the „shocking“ in the video title is irritating. The paleolithic continuity paradigm for a common linguistic & cultural origin of IE people was independently was established by three independent researchers already back in the 1990s. Manifold attempts of reconstructing a common PIE origin of Indo-European mythologies had been carried out before as the similarities are conspicuous.
Shocking was a pun because of the thunder gods shown
@@Stephans_History_of_the_World Ah, okay. Well, then it makes sense. Thanks for your prompt reply
@@Stephans_History_of_the_WorldFor me its shocking! because many of the lone words mentioned here in Greek language presumably originated from Vedic Sanskrit. Watch this linguistic researcher/scholar video and what he said. It seems he has a collection of 400 common cognitions from Indo European languages Sanskrit, Greek, Latin and majority of them he says...... listen to the clip.
ua-cam.com/users/clipUgkxdoWcgW1dZLYOR1c63S120osiLAmObsfG?si=-egDhBdcZT4firoX
Well had he titled it "The Ho-hum similarities..." would I have just become a new subscriber, LOL?
Also shocking, awe, wondrous, it’s exciting stuff ,
I absolutely adore the clarity and calm of your videos - thank you so much from Germany! You are an amazing person to listen to, I could do so for hours haha. Also just ordered the book from Amazon and I'm very much looking forward to reading it!
Why would something that’s nearly been common knowledge within academia for a long time now be so ‘shocking?’
Not everyone in the world is within academia. And common knowledge cannot be shocking? You're confusing surprising with shocking.
Because it's not common knowledge outside linguistic academia.
@@talknight2 it is. Whole world knows this
@Dasyuhan I doubt a single person I know has ever even heard the term "proto-Indo-European"
Beacuse is proved false and mentioned in books
We are so deeply connected to each other that not only we share the stories, poetries and heroes but the way we sing them. Eg. Listen to sam ved recitstion, then avestan recitation, tora recitation and psalm recitation. I find some interesting musical connect between them.
Bible is semitic, it has nothing to do with any vedas or avesta
Just so you know the Torah recitation is Hebrew which is Semitic culture. Semitic and Indo-European cultures are two different metacivilizations . The Semitic metacivilization includes Hebrew/Jewish and Arabic/Muslim/Syriac cultures. The Semitic cultures are staunchly monotheistic and bare little resemblance to Hinduism, Buddhism, Zoroastrianism and early European Paganism.
@thinkingcitizen yeah he's a tool. He think indo european family as some ground breaking ancient alien which shows whole world is connected
So Hinduism is not original to India?
@@taifshamsClosely related .
What specific parts of their vocabulary led you to conclude that they valued poetry?
Also I've read that no one has established exactly what Soma was. How do you know it was Meade?
Still this was a very cool video.
-They have words for calling to mind poems and for divinely inspired storytellers.
-soma was a plant. It is not known which one. Somehow this word got tangled up with the vocabulary of mead, which is simple honey wine. Perhaps because they are both intoxicating. But they were not the same.
Also, from my book: " Besides bards, Posidonius also recorded the vates, who foretold the future. The word “vates” appeared in Latin as “uates,” meaning an “inspired poet” and is related to “wops” (“possessed”) in Gothic, “wuot” (“frenzied”) in Old High German, and “wod” (“song”) in Old English. This link between poetry and divine possession appears several times among the Indo-European languages. The Sanskrit word “rsi” (or “rishi,” meaning “sage”) turns out to be related to the German word “rasen,” meaning “to rage.” Similarly, the Greek word for “seer” is “mantis,” which originally meant “frenzied.” "
“Shocking similarities in neighboring cultures” sounds like lapse in logic for someone discussing history.
It's a pun about Zeus's lighting bolt...
@ It’s a bad pun.
@@l05tw0bbl3 Just because you didn't get it doesn't mean it's bad...
India and Portugal are neighbours???
Dear Stephan, I don't fault you for this narrative, given that it was well crafted during a period of colonization of the world from Europe. This PIE narrative was built when William Jones, and Englishman, working as a judge in British India in the 1800s discovered significant similarities between Sanskrit and many of the European Languages. On further studies it was understood that Sanskrit was the most evolved language of all languages known to mankind at that time, and the fact that Greek and latin were "distorted" versions of Sanskrit. In fact, many western linguists of modern times have concluded that Sanskrit represents the fullest version of the "Indo-European" languages.
It begs the question, If Sanskrit is the most evolved, why did they feel compelled to create a "fictional language" (mother language) called "Proto-Indo European" (PIE).... it was here the colonial mindsets came into play that the INDIANS could not have developed something so sophisticated that EUROPEANS would have show their linkage to an Indic development. Hence the Hypothesis of a parent language "that must have existed" which is the parent of Sanskrit, Greek and Latin...... which resided around Southern Russia / Steppe region (purely because it was mid way between India and Europe, no other empirical basis.
The big challenge for them was "how do we bring sanskrit back to India from the Steppe Region".... Ah Ha!! now here is where the Aryan Invasion Theory got espoused, that the Steppe people came with Sanskrit from the West around 1500 BCE and build the vedic civilization.... in the last few decades the Aryan Invasion Theory (AIT) is in tatters, basis multi-disciplinary evidences on the fake narrative of an external invasion... the fields of science that have dealt of body blow to the AIT believers are the following: (1) Textual Evidence from the Rig Veda; (2) Linguistics; (3) Archeology; (4) Astronomy; (5) Genetics studies; (6) Hydrology /Climatology. Read scholars like Michel Danino, Nilesh Oak, Raj Vedam, Srikant Telegari, and Rupa Bhatty to name a few.
Therefore if AIT is dead, then the Sanskrit Language must have originated many thousands of years prior to 1500 BCE, and to say that PIE (a synthetic / fictional language) every existed is also questionable (no evidence has been provided by believers of this doctrine in over 250 years since it was developed as a hypothesis).
Happy to take your questions. You should do a program on the contrary view to this 250-300 year old narrative, which has past its sell by date.
In my other video on the Indo-Europeans I give the evidence for the Steppe theory.
Its relatively easy to find some clues, even mutlidisciplinary, that point in any direction one pleases. The great majority of evidence point to the steppes --- words in common in IE languages show a nomadic life style (no words for cities etc) and the animals and plants in common point to the steppes.
Also, there is now archeological evidence that matches all the migration waves from the steppes.
Also, calling something colonialist just because it is from the 19th century is falacious. A lot of old notions are since rejected. (And there is evidence that the Out of India theory has a political-religous agenda)
Anyway, thanks for taking the time to write the long response. Im not even saying there are no flaws in PIE. Time will tell. Thats the nature of science. Yet its wise to look into the mainstream argumentation properly before attempting alternative theories. PIE research is very advanced (check for instance Oxford Introduction to PIE by Adams abd Mallory)
Also be mindful that the work of Danino has been heavily criticized (doesnt mean that its wrong, but your account gives the impression that the matter is settled)
That said, I might just at some point read into the out of india hypothesis and give then a fair go. Agenda is pretty full at the moment thougj
@@Stephans_History_of_the_World the unfortunate challenge is the ‘Out of India’ theory is easily labelled as a Political - religious agenda. I have no problem if Indic Vedic history comes from the Steppe, the challenge is here:
1. This is riddled with significant assumptions…. PIE itself is a big assumption. Let’s say even it PIE existed (in 300 years no proof has surfaced)…. Also the other big assumption is … if PIE even existed, it is assumed IT DEFINITELY DID NOT ORIGINATE in India… which is another sweeping assumption.
2. Surely if the nomadic hunters came from the Steppe, the Rig Veda would have at least one mention of these settlers … not a single mention.
3. Indus Valley got discovered in the 1920s, and western Indologists made a sweeping assumption, that is pre-Vedic. Which means a sophisticated civilization like the Indus Valley gave up their civilizational beliefs and practices in one sweep in and around 1500 BCE, without a trace… how unrealistic is that. Without the existence of social media or any such tools to make this complete change over happened.
4. Indic Vedic literature, is a huge library of literature … from the 4 Vedas to Srimad Bhagvatam, to the Satapata Brahmanas, to the Puranas, Surya Sidhanta, to voluminous literature on sciences to astronomy, medicine, mathematics, metallurgy…. All getting developed within a 900 year period (1500 BCE - 600 BCE)…. Completely arbitrary timeline, and unrealistic assumption of such huge developments happening in such a short time span.
5. It was enough for Max Mueller to say in one line “Indic Astronomy is not reliable”… nobody asked him for proof or evidence and it was taken as a hard evidence … because Max Mueller said so. Last I checked he was no Astronomer of any repute to judge Indic Astronomy.
6. For the longest time the Rig Veda was held as Mythology (the very title of your channel)…. What if it is not Myth… but recorded history??? The Saraswati river was called a mythological river… now science (hydrology studies) has strong evidence of its existence. If it existed then how could the Steppe people write about it sitting in the Sind region, about a river which is thousands of Kilometres away from the Sapt-Sind region.
You disparaged Nilesh Oak's work on dating of the Mahabharata at and around 5561 BCE, saying there was no writing evidence during that time. Why should that preclude scholars of that time, recording events on the basis of Astronomical markers, a rich tradition of India. Also a long tradition of oral recitation of this history passed down the centuries, which has preserved the right pronunciation of the words (from the tip of South India to the Northern most parts of India, vedic mantras are chanted in exactly the same manner. The oral tradition as meant that the Vedas mantras and their recitation is done in a unique consistent manner, irrespective of the shifting languages over the last 10,000 years).
So the big point is Steppe hypothesis is riddled with massive assumptions. We should challenge old paradigms with new evidence and analysis which shines a brighter light on our past. We welcome your partnership to challenge these old paradigms. I have no political or religious agenda. In fact, i do not believe in any organised religion. But I am in it for a pure pursuit of the TRUTH… based on evidence, tested hypothesis and pointed inferences. Please come with an open mind and allow ourselves the opportunity to marvel at the history of our planet and civilizations.
🙏
From the land if Greece everything started and no from the steps .Not a single city of this populous tribe has been discovered there
b. Not a single skeletal find has been found that has been anthropologically studied as an Indo-European model or type.
c. No ancient geographer (Strabo, Polybius, Arrian, etc.) mentions the existence of such a populous race and finally
d. no ancient book has been found in which the existence of this otherwise imaginary race is mentioned....So this theory is highly unscientific, which unfortunately still survives today, 214 years after its invention, despite the objections of the most reputable scientists:
Indo-European, or rather Indo-Germanic, theory was developed by the Nazis from older British colonialists theorys. They did not know about the expeditions of Criassus, Dionysus, Persis, nor the kingdoms of Menander in the West Indies. Instead of telling the truth, they built an entire language from scratch and a non-existent culture just to bury the Greek presence and Indo-Greek culture. Why? to create the theory of the Aryan race.
Meth: also the origin of “methyl”, as found in chemistry, eg. Methyl alcohol, aka methanol.
meth -> from greek word ΜΕΘΗ(methy) ->when you drink too much alcohol
The reversal of terms to reflect different points of view… amazing!
Excellent video, dense with information. Notable
Linear A and B Greek and early Greek in general consistently prove Zeus was always a very minor deity until his cult and mythology developed much later.
West gave genocide, slavery, colonization, plague, Holocaust, mass starvation
East, mainly India, gave compassion, wisdom, Yoga, Buddhism, number system, Sanskrit, Kama Sutra, joy and happiness.
dude grow up.......even the computer came from tech.... by being trivial you are making us look bad
The computer or mobile phone you are typing, internet, social media, and also the language you are typing all came from west. Think rationally rather than in your narrow nationalist mindset.
West industrialization was dependent on de-industrialization of India.
British implemented Final Solution on India, just like Hitler implemented Final Solution on Jews.
And don't forget that India gave us the near slavery of the caste system when mentioning your cultural heritage
West industrialization was dependent on de-industrialization of India.
British implemented Final Solution on India, just like Hitler implemented Final Solution on Jews.
Different castes were actually different professional categories like soldiers, farmers, politicians, scholars etc etc.
There was NO difference between Churchill and Hitler.
Case closed.
Indo-European with no founds of any texts those people the invented that myth
I would LOVE to see a deeper dive into the idea of "glory unfading" in Greek and broader European culture.
Hector, as he as facing death by Achilles, famously stated: "Let me not die ingloriously, and without a struggle, but let me first do some great thing that shall be told among men hereafter."
In China, at the other end of Eurasia, the idea of being a glorious warrior hero and being remembered for eternity is seen as a fool's errand. The men who attempted this in Three Kingdoms all came to ignoble ends.
Hector, Achilles were fiction ;)
Indian propaganda running rampant in the comment section. Did you fools even watch the video? Lol
Yup
Mittanis people used ikshvaku names rather than rigvedic/ vedic
Ikshvaku were later Aryans ( originally non Aryans) but gain same status as Aryans
Ikshvaku people used names like dasaratha, tursharatha ( mittanis tasaratta )
Which never been used by puru Bharat ( original rigvedic Aryans)
They used term like kuru ( iranic kurush) , puru,yadu , brigu, sudas , devodas , asvinu
U suffix more prone commonly used by original Aryans
Wasn't Ikshvaku the founder of Solar dynasty?
@@prasoonjha1816kuru Empire came after ikshwaku
Describing Ikshvaku Dynasty as Non Aryan is no offense but Really Really Dumb. The ancient PIE tale of The king and the god (H₃rḗḱs dei̯wós-kwe) can be seen in Rig Veda as the account of King Harischandra who belongs to the Ikshvaku Lineage. Additionally, Ikshvaku is Father Manu's eldest son. So Yeah.
@@pakshirajan8585 rigvedic Aryas called dasa as non Aryans .
Dasa were were indo European "daha / dahae"
Being Indo Europeans is nothing to do with "Aryans"
Danava were non Aryan ( danu race / descendants of rigvedic godess danu )
Which is pagan Celtic called themselves or their gods ( tribe of danu )
Vala/ valasur was non Aryan demon in RigVeda ( slavic god veles )
Mittani times even in India Yajur veda in use in most cases while Saraswathi river dried 1900BC which made Mittanis to appear in 1700BC in Syria! They moved as settlements! Rigveda kept as oldest!!
Sanskrit the foundation of many Indian languages is of proto-Indo-European roots.....also the features are similar, obviously evolved over the years
dev/dew is still referred to large devilish beings in persian.
😂😂😂😂 persia before zoroastriasm follow the same vedic culture that Indian follows 😂
Check the history first rather than considering deus as devils..
It's only ahura mazda when zoroastriasm flourished and he abandoned the vedic culture and introduced new religion like zoroastriasm to persians 😂😂😂
@@xijinping9024 ok and? also yall dont follow the same vedic culture. i dont see any cow sacrifices being made anymore.
Indians and Iranians were clearly siblings who had a dispute, claiming one group as their personal gods (Devas and Ahuras) and the other group as their personal demons (Asuras and Daevas). It was a family dispute lol.
1)In Ramayana(ancient Indian text), Sugriva (one character in Ramayana) metioned world at that time from east to west & north to south....he mentioned that dont go beyond half Europe because there it is full of glaciers......Kindly watch youtube video by Nilesh Oak-Sugriva's Atlas for detials
2)Also genetical study support that groups moved from Africa settled in India & Central asia (R1a1a(spread all over the world....watch youtube video of Abhijit Chavda regarding this...
3)main ritual of mentioned by ancient people in VEDA( ancient Indian text) & AGASTA(old persian text)is Fire Worship ( Indian call it Homa in Sanskrit) which you dont find beyond Azarbaizan
So in my opinion this are cental asian -Indian culture & languages spead in europe
Recent excavation in South India found skeleton of one Indian King with 2 Greek bodyguard
Dude why would global audience watch Hindu Nationalist and Mythology believers video who thinks hanuman is real
Dyaus pitr wrong
Dyau shw cha tvam prithivi cha nah pitarau subhage grinatoh gabhir addhi
This the slok
It's actually o heaven and earth(prithvi )our parents (pitarau) idk how they got here dyaus pitr in Sanskrit.
This from rig ved: oldest hindu text much much older then greek and latin
Can you check for instance Rig Veda 1.89.4. It says pitā dyauh, translated as father heaven. (Mata prthivi, pita dyauh --- mother earth, father heaven)
@Stephans_History_of_the_World it's interesting even if look at the word pitarau and parents
It's maybe true there's some connections
sanskrti evolved only during gupta periods, there are no sign sanskrit in Indus valley civilizatiob
@@kapil4417037sanskrit is gods language not gupta period language
@@kapil4417037it has been deciphered and considered close to sanskrit
Good talk. It is fascinating how all the Indo European religions, cultures and languages are related. The controversy is in who and when where, as well as different political agendas these ideas brought. We should seek unity, not only with Indo Europeans but mankind.
13:00: Ymir did not creat people. He was killed by gods to create the universe or at least the Earth.
He did create human. Afteeward his body was cut up to make the earth --- "Ymir was a frost giant. From the sweat of his two armpits came a man and a woman, and one of his legs made love to the other and fathered a six-headed son, ancestor of giants. Odin and his brothers killed Ymir and made the earth out of his flesh, the mountains from his bones,
the trees from his hair, the sky from his skull, and the sea and lakes from his
blood."
@@Stephans_History_of_the_World No offense, but this seems highly unlikely, even for a child to believe.
@@Stephans_History_of_the_World , these man and woman were not humans, they were giants, and humans, Askr and Embla, were later created from trees. Anyway, this is nowadays the most favored way to see it.
I am fairly certain that Old Chinese had significant contact with speakers of the Indo-European language family. In addition to obvious borrowings of horse and chariot related words, some of the more religious words may be borrowings too. Including the concept of a sky father, leading to words like bright, shine, day, god all seem to be related to PIE's *dyeu.
Hanji OC PIE English Borrowed meaning
帝 *tˤek-s *deiwos deity god, emperor
昭 *taw *dyeu tiwes in Old English bright
照 *taw-s *dyeu tiwes in Old English shine
朝 *taw *dyéws tiwes in Old English morning, day, facing, dynasty
Also, mead that is religiously significant to PIE speakers is borrowed into OC to just mean honey. Here are other somewhat religious words that seem to have been borrowed from PIE.
Hanji OC PIE English Borrowed meaning
蜜 *mit *médʰu mead honey
歿 *mˤut *mer mort death
卒 *[ts]ˤut *dheu- die death
活 *[ɡ]ʷˁat *gwei- viva live, vibrant
先 *sˤər *sen- root for senior first, before
牘 *lˤok *dek- doc a wood panel for writing documents
羆 *praj *bher- brown bear brown bear
Obvious horse and chariot related PIE loanwords in OC.
Hanji OC PIE English Borrowed meaning
駒 *[k]ˤ(r)ok-s *ḱr̥sos horse steed
馬 *mˤraʔ *márkos mare horse
車 *C.q(r)a *krsos car chariot, car
軒 *qʰa[r] *kers- car roofed chariot
軲轆 *gukluk *kʷékʷlos wheel pulley
轂 *[k]ˤok *kʷékʷlos wheel wheel hub
輻 *pәk *spei- spoke spoke
轉 *tronʔ *terə turn turn
輪 *[r]u[n] *ri-ne-a- run wheel
軛 *qˤ[i]k *yeug- yoke yoke
約 *[q](r)ewk *yeug- yoke binding agreement
Some of the other words that are likely PIE loanwords in OC.
Hanji OC PIE English Borrowed meaning
夾 *kˤep *ghrebh grasp clasp
窟 *[kʰ]ˤut *kutą cot cot
屯 *[d]ˤun *dhu-no- town town
球 *[g](r)[u] *gleu- clew ball
號 *[C.g]ˤaw *gal- call call
何 *[g]ˤaj *kwo- what what
磨 *mˤaj *mele- mill mill
給 *[k](r)[ə]p *ghabh- give give
蓋 *[k]ˤap-s *kaput- cap lid
垣 *[ɢ]ʷar wendʰ- wall wall
園 *C.ɢʷa[n] wendʰ- wall garden
圓 *ɢʷen wendʰ- wall encirclement, circle
孫 *[s]ˤu[n] *su(e)-nu- son grandson
株 *tro *drew-o- tree tree trunk
犬 *[k]ʷʰˤ[e][n]ʔ *kwon- canine canine
雁 *C.[ŋ]ˤrar-s *ghans goose goose
Zeus was Chinese whispers of Deus (god) from PIE Dyeu shine. Greco/Roman religion comes from the Near East/Egypt. However, the REAL caring god was De-meter (PIE origin: God mother~ Mother Earth, who was feeding the people). The other gods were for scaring/controlling the people.
PIE culture influenced the European peninsula of Asia as tribes were migrating via Anatolia (Balkans) & Caspian (via N/E Europe)
5:30 I think pretty much all slavic languages also have the word "med"
Yeah!
Moreover we have their distinctions which I don't find in Latin languages. At least in Russian, there are two types of "med", "med" (miod) and "mead" (miedovukha). Which is a brewed honey. Which used to be very popular in Russia like 500 years ago. Europeans had wine and wine was popular in Europe, to the same extent Mead(miedovukha) was popular in the 16 century Russia - which later transformed into "Kvas", as "Kvas" was poors man drink and mead was brewed by Russian Czars and Boyars.
@@korana6308 Yeah, similar in Serbian, we just say medovina but I don't think anyone drinks anything similar now
Honey in Sanskrit is मधु (madhu), and wine is मदिरा (madira). This is cognate with мёд (myod) in Slavic.
Veda in Sanskrit is वेद (vedə) or वेद् (ved). This is cognate with ведь (ved) in Slavic.
So, медведь in Sanskrit would mean a person who collects or gathers honey, but this could also be applied in case of animals, such as honey bees and black bears, but it would be incorrect to call a polar bear a медведь.
Many Russians have told me that the surname of Дмитрий Медведев, i.e. Medvedev, means a bear, but I remain unconvinced, and I think his ancestors were professional honey gatherers.
In Polish both - honey and alcohol made out of it - are called "miód" (pron. "myood") - a polish version of "myed"/"med" in other slavonic languages.
BTW it is typical of Polish language to use "o" or "ó" instead of "e" (like wiosna - vesna, AFAIK in the Middle Ages there was a process called "polish apophony" that changed vowels)
Over the time Iranians and Indians saperated and in isolation, culture started molding differently.
There is plenty of evidence now that the prehistoric inhabitants of Europe were black skinned but light eyed carnivorous people prior to 6000BCE. Migrants from Asia colonized and mixed with these people to produce modern European races. There prehistoric races of Europe were called danavas and hence the rivers of Europe are named Danube, donister, dniper etc.
These migrants are none other than the Aryan tribes of India.
Danavas are Demons danavas werr brothers of devas not europeans
Aryan tribes lol migrants india werr of aryans not migrants
No migrants came from Europe
@@SachinPotdar-p3q you don't seem to know Europe and Indian mythology well enough. Allow me to educate you. The European self identify as children of Danu, Celts for example call their ancestors Tuthata de Danan, meaning children of Danu. Danu is an ancient river Goddess(also identified with Aditi) this is why rivers in Europe from Easter Europe to Western Europe are named after Danu. Such as Danube, Don, Dniper etc. In Vedic texts, the ancestors of the European race are traced to an Aryan king yayati who married a Danava woman Shameshta. This also includes the tribes of druhyu(druids and later yavanas (Greeks). You can still see today on ancient greek frescos brown skinned warriors elites marrying white Danava greek women.
However, the Aryan tribes that intermarried with Danava women were considered fallen and were later regarded as Mlecchs, because they spoke corrupted Sanskrit. What these modern day European linguists call 'branches of PIE" is nothing more than creoles of Sanskrit.
Indians are the ancestors of modern European races. This was admitted by early European scholars themselves. But the majority Christian elite didn't't want to admit it, so they cooked up this theory of PIE and Aryan invasions of India.
@RajSingh-xn8qd danu is mother of danavas they are residents of indo gangetic plains not europe europe was breeding ground of savages
PIE is talked about here as if it were a done and settled conclusion when we dont have any proof for it at all. We have only inferred to arrive at a conjecture which is why its still open to debate. Words change with time and you can trace them back to arrive or show the original root word with linguistic archeology. Simplifications of sanskrit terms and linguustic structures indicate that, similar to pali, Avestan is derived from sanskrit. I think PIE is not a definitive scientific truth but only just a worked out and inferred conjectural model.
The Mitanni must have been a (or 10) lost tribe of Indo-Arians.
And it was only the elites that spoke an Indo-Iranian language. The commoners did not.
That's complete b*llshit mitanni people have spoken a isolate language😂😂😂 Persian peoples in mesopotamia only appear with de median people with the end of Assyrian empire😂😂😂
@@Stephans_History_of_the_Worldthat's the Brahmins, kshatriyas and vaishya according to rigveda ( 10th Mandala) the elites people
They genetically closer to ( autosomal dna ) to Iranian related people
The ancestory that "responsible" for Indus civilization
Whille peasants has admixture of other dna groups
Even with of highest steppe ancestory ( jats ,ror peasants are highest steppe ancestory in india)
Kalash ( non Varna people , in middle ages if person don't belong to any Varna simply he avarna / same as chandala/ lowest of lowest)
Kalash ,or other dardic group with highest steppe ancestory= untouchables like caste
@@ricardo82shadow123Persian are nothing to with mittanis ( originally called Marya people or marya-nuh)
Mittanis were admixture people of Marya Vedic people and ikshvaku ( Aryanized warriors, originally non Aryans tho ) and who probably adopted in Vedic Marya culture ( Marya was part of culturehood of Aryans where they used to make clan warband)
Marya was warband associated with young ,or virgin warriors
Mittanis as ikshvaku because they used same name as ikshvaku people used in Indian culture
(Still those who claim ikshvaku uses that names ) like dasaratha/ tusharatta ( mittanis name like tusaratta)
Wrong info mittani are different than ishkvaku ishkvaku are sun dynasty not mittani people@@greaterbharat4175
I love this. I’m a Dutch minded wordplay freak myself. Can’t help it. It’s the math my mind plays with all day while I work. I wish I knew of ways to be employed using this dutch gift but in America it just makes me sound crazy to share such discoveries. Everyone it seems here just wants to believe what they already think they know. Maybe should have called america “l’emmingica”…?
They're not myths, We call it 'Itihasa' which means History.
If don't understand anything west people's called it's mythology😁😄
Because it is mythology
@@TingTong2568 like your forefathers.
@@TingTong2568it is not mythology
@@Abhimanyu_Toxic my forefather believed in this crap too. Only rational ones knows this is bs
@@SachinPotdar-p3q bring evidence that it's not mythology
Wondering: if "men," bringing a poem to mind (= memory?} somehow relates to Mnemosyne, goddess of memory and mother of the poetic muses?? Srav,as and Slava, Sanskrit and Slavic for glory, fame?
aryan migration has been debunked long time ago, come up with original content
Aryan invasion theory is controversial. Not Aryan migration. Btw, the name Iran is a derivative of Airiya, the Avestan cognate of the Sanskrit Arya. In ancient times much of the area which is now Afghanistan was called Ariana.
@@himmsingz No point in trying to convince people who are driven by a political agenda.
@@prasoonjha1816 Just informing, not trying to convince.
@@prasoonjha1816 Aryan migration is legit.Indo aryans came from a place in Ukraine where they split into indo-european and indo aryans.Aryans when reached the indus valley civilization where praying rig vedic gods like Yama, Mithra,varuna,Indra etc but later abandoned praying all these gods and accepted the pre-harappan gods of mixed culture of proto-dravidians,mongoloids and austroloids.Those gods are shiva,shakthi.When you see the similarity with Indo-european's its only about rig edic gods and sanskrit.Pre harappan civilization had a proto- dravidian/proto-austrolid language.
There is dna evidence of that Also language 😂 you can't deny it , so migration was real
what is the verb for raiding cattle in sanskrit?
Av gam varetam az --- meaning "drive off cattle as booty." Source Oxford introduction to PIE, Mallory, Adams
brush indus vally civilization is more than 6000 years old. then how tf?
There is much we still don’t know about the migratory past of mankind, but it certainly did not begin in the steppes. Mankind walked out of Africa and moved north to the Mediterranean Sea. A flood divided and sent them all inland around the shores of what is now the Balkans.
Remember that our first language must have been very simple I.e., consisting of vowels and monosyllables. Only one such European language has been found and belongs to isolated variants of the Gheg dialect of the Albanian language. The Gheg dialects has 17 vowels and almost only monosyllables. No other European languages has that.
I have found out that the numbers 0-10 have an etymology in Albanian that is not found anywhere else. Our ancestors “wrote” the story of creation in our language.
Even the word numbers have a meaning. ‘Ne’ ‘um’ ‘ra’ (we) (are) (falling) indicating a “fall into creation” which reveals the origin story of the religious “fall from grace”.
0. Living sound / captured life (zero/ze rro)
1. Feel (Ni/ndi)
2. Know (dy/di)
3. The new (tri/tre = te re/te ri)
4. Everything that exists (katër/ka tër)
5. The seen and unseen (pes = pe/s’pe)
6. Is alive (gjashte = gja asht)
7. Body (shtatë = shtat)
8. With him (tetë = te të)
9. With her (nënte = nën të)
10. Gives life (dhjete = dhe jete)
0.
Even the symbols themselves reveal the meaning behind their form. The symbol 0 is a circle around a void, depicting the encapsulation of life in its primary form. The void is life (subject) before conception (form) which explains why 0 can’t be enumerated as a value while still having an existence.
Ze rro can have four meanings. ‘Ze’ means ‘sound’ and ‘catch/capture’ while rro/ro means ‘live’ and ‘protect/guard’. You can put them together however you like and you still get the origin story. The story is of gods profound purpose in existence and the physical and psychic journey (fall) as him and her in space and time.
Ooo... In Bangla There is a word called Gosti means clan or close relatives. I never realized the English word guest is so close to the bangla word. 😮😮😮 And the bangla word is even so close to the PIE word too.
Gosti also means a gang or group of people with similar interest in Tamil and who often hangout together
@@swedhamurugesh 😲😲😲.... Sometimes we can say that in Bangla as well.
There are so many surprising connections. For example; the English word 'Stand', Persian word 'Stan' and Sanskrit word "Sthan" come from the same PIE root.
@@prasoonjha1816 no such thing as PIE. they are corruptions of indic words including sanskrit.
@darkprince2490 how would you explain the regular correspondence between sanakrit and European languages then?
similarities symbolism is universe concepts related. that is third eye penealgland activates related and group of people ethinic language related but same information of yoga breathe technical secret message only..
Rigveda give elaborate tries of Aryans who mightated out of India after Dasa rajna or ten kings war! Being in Rigveda, it occured around 6000 years? This is very accurate information as it is in Vedas!Thosenames of Aryan family also given in details!! These people onlty settled in Iran and far beyond and created many civilizations! King Sudas who won Dasa rajna , imposed many diktats and forced to move with culture and language! Those westerners exactly twisted the historical truth keeping the present realities!!
Migration happened to India. Not from India.
Why should one not believe that Veda is copied from European culture ?
@@HNCTECH No ,it is old cock and bulk story! rRead, comments fully!
@@HiteshKumar-vq3bp why there is no indian dna in ancient or modern Europeans then?
@Saraswathiputra lol dasa rajna 😂 pajeet can't write a word of sanakrit properly as usual. learn to write sanskrit first pajeete. Rigveda is 3500 years old at best. Bettle of the 10 kings took place around that time like someone pointed out here. Yanmanay migration had already happened before that.
@Saraswathiputra if indians migrated out of india and settled in iran and far beyond and created many civs, why indian dna is not found in any of them 😂😂😂
Pajeet debunked in seconds 😂😂
Great job Stephan! However the neo santanani of India will claim the vice versa is true, i.e. Indian vedic culture was there already before everything else and influenced all the other cultures. These people are suppressing their own country men with casteism which is worse than racism. You are going to be trolled for a stream like this, be ready bro.Thanks and All the best!
dullit nigga begging their white master
Ah yes, the Dravidians came up with the religion despite being conquered & replaced in most of northern India, kinda funny considering traces of the old religion can still be found in Southern India while the more traditional IE pantheon exists in the north.
Are you idiot 🤔
Most of the atrocities committed against "so called" low castes are committed by "so called" Shudra layer of the society. Don't just believe me go check for yourself and do check government data as well as low caste activists who have themselves wrote about this paradox. So are the Shudra Mulnivasi ? and if not why are you "so called" Mulnivasis aligning with them ? Why not raise protest against them ?. Lastly and most importantly, who is a "Mulnivasi" ? Your ancestors did not come from Africa ? or you are a separate species altogether that originated in India ?
Those Aryans came from those very useless places like caspian or caucasus AND created mighty literatureand culture IN
India on touching Indian soil got superior knowledge? Is it? This is your theory!! How rubbish!! India has very ancient iNDUS CULTURE WHICH NOW PROVED TO BE 6000 YEARS OLD! WHAT YOU PEOPLE HAD IN YOUR THE SO CALLED ARYAN HOMELAND! You have to accept the truh!
oh and they always intermingled and recreated each others ideas as it suited them. whoever n wherever they were
I'm willing to challenge that proposition. Meat coming from the word Mead??? That's a bit of a stretch. And it also doesn't make sense, unless it's origins are further than the PIE root. We obviously always had meat, but honey was also discovered many thousand of years ago. Before the PIE originated. So something doesn't add up... In Russian for example there are two separate words for it - mied/miod = honey. And miedovukha - meaning the alcoholic beverage made from honey - mead. And meat is "miaso" which I'm willing to bet is connected to the word "matter".
But very interesting insight overall. Thank you. 👍
He just pronounced mead as meat
@@hilliunoindeed. He was referring to mead, a fermented drink made from honey.
ΜΕΛΙ is an ancient Greek word μελιτοῦμαι
μελίτωμα < μελιτοῦμαι
μελίτωσις
βλίττω < μλι-τιω < μελιτ-, μέλι
μελίρρυτος < μέλι + ῥέω
μελισσοκόμος
μελιττοκόμος < αττ. τ.
μελισσοτρόφος < μέλισσα + τρέφω
μελιττοτρόφος < αττ. τ.
μελισσουργός < μέλισσα + ἔργον
μελιττουργός < αττ. τ.
μελισσουργῶ
μελιττουργῶ < αττ. τ.
μελισσουργεῖον < μελισσουργός
μελισσουργία < μελισσουργός
μελίφθογγος < μέλι + φθόγγος
μελίφρων
μελίχλωρος...
μέλια
Μελίτη ...the derivatives of the word μελι honey, and there are hundreds more
There are pitfalls of "sounds-like therefore must be same" linguistics. One has to show the consistent changes in phonemes etc as the language spreads...and that again is highly technical and even problematic. I am not junking PIE linguistics - just asking for rigor even in YT presentations. Thanks all the same
Those Assirians in the history is in reality are those migrated Asuras long before from ancient India! they created Assirian Empire! They prayed with lot of respect their God as Ashurs or Ashura! This is the truth! That is why those Mittanis later migrated fron ancient India are actually Suras who immediately atatck Asuras aka Assirians in Syria because of enmity!
Indra is called the great asura in rigveda mate, pump the breaks with your fantasy novel
Sorry, but you are wrong. Assyrians were a Semitic people, related to the Akkadians and Arabs, who speak Semitic languages and have no trace of Sindic DNA that would trace them from any regions of ancient India.rom any regions of ancient India.
@@synaestesia-bg3ew yep. The guy is a tool. British failed to educate these and now we have that
so. where do i get this methy? sounds nice :P
Greek and Roman culture are highly influenced by Indian culture
😂 what
@@nsayyed5469 A statue of Buddha has been found in Egypt. If you want, you can google it and read about that statue. And you can also read about India-Greek relations. Then there won't be a need to say (what)
@nsayyed5469 Whatever you heard...THE TRUTH DUDE
@@HiteshKumar-vq3bp yea india did everything like shitting on streets caste & all that now show us your pyramid b4 saying everything sprang from your inferior culture😂
It's more like the opposite.
If you find actual Sanskrit words used in Syria, what could be the direction of travel of languages?
North to south
@@tjdillashawfan769south to north. It's still practiced in INDIA, almost the oldest things are in INDIA obviously because it was way more civilized and there's a reason why Europeans were crazy about the richest land on earth - the INDIAN subcontinent.
@@rajendrajoshi983 when the whole un broken study and system exists in India and not syria.., not sure what your are saying.. Indian civilization moved outwards...
@@Cutestar6757 Yes. That's what I feel.
the current belief is that for a time syria was ruled by an indo aryan elite during the mittani empire
Some people think Indians established European countries. Dark skinned Indians migrated and created fair skinned, blue eyed, blond haired, tall aryans.
😅😅
True being fair skinned and blue eyed is so precious.. And liked evolved
Lol this is exactly why we don't take you Europeans seriously. This is exactly what your ancestors said when other European scholars (yes European scholars) who studied the Sanskrit literature came to realize Europeans were fathered by Indian Aryans kings. They absolutely hated the idea that dark skinned, brown heathen people were their ancestors. This only goes to show for racist people like you and your ancestors your objections are only skin deep.
Now what a rude awakening for you to now learn that the old people of Europe were black skinned, carnivores with light eyes. Yes, you got your light eyes, blonde hair and height and bulk from the people of old Europe interbreeding with Neanderthals. If it makes you feel any better you are closer to Neanderthals than we are ;) . However, your gene for fair skin and lactose tolerance comes from us Indians. Clearly, the gene mutations for lactose tolerance did not originate with the hunter gathers of old Europe, because you were carnivores who had not yet discovered agriculture. It is farmers that came to Europe circa 6000BCE that gave you the LP gene and fair skin gene, which you share with Indians.
Want to know what your actual ancestors of old Europe looked like? Look up 'cheddar man '
@@RajSingh-xn8qd it's amusing to see these soft middle class american whites pretending to be related to greeks, romans, forget about original vedic hindus.
@@HiteshKumar-vq3bp So Bollywood stars are mainly from Tamil Nadu, Karnakata and Kerala. Makes sense.
@@RajSingh-xn8qd Yeah, but you drive cars, use the internet, and flock to Canada, US, UK, Australia.
We are all one with common ancestral memories Peace Thanks
You seem to be slightly unprepared with the Sanskrit words, several of which you said don't make sense although I am well acquainted with Sanskrit terms being a native Hindi speaker. This is an immensely enlightening video but I wish I could relate more than I could.
There is another horse, Amaterasu's, which is killed by her brother, from The Pleiades, and makes her go in hiding. Prometheus stole The First Fire from Heaven from this same star cluster. Agni, the fire deity is from there also. Tauroctony with the blade placement at the shoulder is where The Pleiades is located. Thor fishes for The World Encompassing Serpent with a Bulls' head, denoting The Taurus Constellation. The Feathered Serpent (Who takes away The Sun.), The Thunderbird, and The Rainbow Serpent have the same origin. They are describing The Taurid Meteor Stream which needs no dispersion because space falls are global. Isis and Nefertari each hold a bovine shoulder blade at The Pleiades. Under Pillar 18 of Gobekli Tepe is a Row of Seven Birds and there is a sister site with two Auroch scapula placed over a grave. Plus, it is symbolically shown in Lascaux.
Amaterasu is the Japanese sun goddess, the personification of the sun. She was not killed by her brother Susanoo but locked herself into a cave because she was appalled about her brother‘s killing one of her servants (with a horse). This is not Indo-European mythology while the Pleiades are.
@@masehoart7569 The Pleiades are universal with the same story line; fire appears to come from them and takes away The Sun for long periods of time (Impact Winter) and many are depicted as flying serpents, compare the 2013 meteor to the two dragons chasing a bright pearl. Many think it was all made up when it describes the phenomena very well.
@ Please don’t explain Greek mythology to me - it’s sixth grade stuff! Amaterasu IS the sun, so in Greek mythology = Helios, Germanic mythology = Sunna, Egyptian = Ra(t), the t for the female version of Ra, Vodun = Mawu, etc.
Full video is based on imaginery comstruct of PIE language as the oldest one. Its completely proof less!
Sanskrut is the current oldest love language. The Rugved was written atleast 21000 years ago.
None of the other languages come any close to it.
Zeus and Juppiter only = Dyaus linguistically, it's a bit confusing since their names are cognate, but their mythic narratives are not. Dyaus is alot more like Ouranos. This is all pretty old news on the Indo-European news, too, not so much “shocking” anymore. Good video, though.
I wish it was on audible so I could listen to it ! ❤
Yeah, I have to figure that out at some point
Man is the word to mean retain, and so its used for mana(mind) memorizing, retaining in or storing in.
Sad that you don't mention the slavic branch. You can trace every connection you made down that way too.
Why you people always talk about Indo-European civilization not about chino-european or arab-european ?
Durga-Ishtar-Astarte-Aphrodite-Venus - connected by the gens Iulia to Isis of Ptolemaic Egypt.
There is a reason why the 'National Socialist' movement of Nazi Germany fascinated many with their political myth of a prehistoric Aryan civilization, symbolized by the Swastika.
Yet, in these stories is also the implication of corruption when Durga slays the regenerating Mahishasura who originated from a linneage of wise Rishi...
ua-cam.com/video/Np28O3Y_P2o/v-deo.htmlsi=YGeGsRvWqkp6_ws_
Italics, still existing, are an indoeuropean race coming from north east russia, indians have nothing to do with indoeuropeans…. Its about the region once occupied by Iranic people, indians vedic etc etc came after… if you have to do these type of similarities look into the jewish made abrahamitic cults instead, jewish Indian tribe of Calani, jews and indians, so not indoeuropeans, Abraham… Braham… etc etc star of david, star of vishnu….
Wished you would have talked about Perkunos. A weather god that carries a lighting bolt and a club or metal hammer.. He also fights a multi headed sea serpent..
@6:27 word "gwrhdhho" - just struck me its similarity to Polish "gardło" - which means "throat" (other slavonic languages have their own forms of evidently the same word). Obivously, the meaning is not the same but it may be a relation as a praise is usually made with this organ :).
Or perhaps it is related to Russian "гордиться", Ukrainian "гордитися" which means "to boast, take pride"?
There is also a clearly related word in Czech, Slovak: "hrdý" and in Polish "hardy" (all mean "proud" with perhaps a bit different semantics).
Wow..Gardhan means throat in sanskrit too
Fellows! Instead of fighting whose grand dad is oldest, pkease get to the point. Madhu is oldest wine and it was meant for sacred drinking only. So, please drink responsibly. This is oldest of all civilizations🎉
I wondered if the origin of the word 'asura' could be linked to assyrians?
very interesting ; I've recognised here two PIE words that sound very Breton : "gwerh" that sounds like "gwerzh", the traditional Breton laments or historical songs about past heroes and "klewes" and the Breton verb "klev/klevet" to hear.
Don’t you think the theory that the Indo-European language originated in Russia is somewhat half-baked? Recent studies suggest that the Indo-European language originated in western Iran. Genetic studies have discovered a Caucasus Hunter-Gatherers component that spread to the steppe and a similar Iranian Neolithic component (in the Zagros) that spread eastward. This component was found in Bronze Age Anatolia without steppe ancestry.
The Yamnaya were roughly 1/3 CHG or Iran_Neolithic. Iran_Neolithic ancestry comprises 40-60% of all modern Indians. Don’t you think Iranian Neolithic farmers migrated toward Russia around 7,000-8,000 years ago, forming the Yamnaya culture? Perhaps these people originated from Mehrgarh or Bhirrana in the Indian subcontinent, as India and Iran were better suited for human settlement 10,000 years ago than Russia, which experienced a cold and temperate climate heavily influenced by the last Ice Age.
The cow is significant in Indo-Aryan culture. The Indo-Europeans were central to the domestication of the bull/cow, the invention of the wheeled wagon, dairying practices, and milk consumption. However, the cow was domesticated in the Indus Valley Civilization over 9,000 years ago and in Anatolia separately. If one believes the steppe people domesticated the horse and then entered India, this migration never affected the genetic lineage of Indian cow breeds. Cattle genetics conclusively prove that no admixture of Taurine cattle into India has ever occurred. It seems silly to think that Indo-Aryans came to India without a single cow.
If we look at Russia, the Proto-Uralic language formed around the same time as the Indo-European language in relatively close proximity without any connection between them. In the Caucasus region or near the Black Sea, there are unrelated Kartvelian languages that formed around the same time or earlier than Indo-European.
Do you think the Burushaski language in northern Pakistan might be related to a pre-Proto-Indo-European language, given that haplogroup R2 is significantly present among the Burusho people? Haplogroup R2 is estimated to have emerged around 15,000 years ago, likely in the Indian subcontinent, while R1 originated in Central Asia and R itself in West and South Asia. It seems likely that the Indo-European language originated in Iran, the Indus Valley, or the BMAC culture.
You're way deeper into it than me. Thats the problem with being more of a world historian. I will keep what you wrote in mind when I pick up the subject again.
Not really shocking. The ancient world was dominated by the following areas: Egypt, mesapotamia, Persia and India (and parts of Africa???). Their influence on the rest of the world was, obviously, natural.
Medu, (also used by the Huns), is honey wine = medovina in Slavic languages. From med-honey.
Madhu..madhuram is sweet or intoxicated drink in Sanskrit
Linguistic foot print
Vedic Sur became Hur; Sindhu -. Hindu_in Greek Indu
Saraswati became Haraswati.
All of these prove that migration happened outwards from Bharat, not to Bharat.
Could be the Persians picked up the term Sindhu and changed it to Hindu when in the 6th century they expanded into India. On my video on the language tree I explain why the area above the black sea is regarded by most linguists as the origin of the language. For instance, you can look at words for animals and plants that appear in many languages and see where these animals and plants exist.
@@Stephans_History_of_the_Worldconcept of hapt hendu mentioned in Avesta so term itself is old like pre 1000bce
Beside Avesta mentioned outward migration of aryas from hapt hendu and daitya
( Central Asia/ BMAC and Indus)
Not in india
Vendidad mentioned hapt hendu is god created land for Aryans and due to climatic conditions ( work of old gods ) Aryan fleed to outside region
@@Stephans_History_of_the_Worldtheir is no warfare associated in Avesta with indus it was always aryan land
, however turria is mentioned warfare of Aryas happened against non Aryas for power
Turria is basically Eurasian steppe region
The first race mentioned they had warfare with was danus race ( race of danu river people) , Danube / don / dienster river people all this river ancestoral name is "danu"
Common culture of india,iran and europe. Eurasia and north africa is Cradle of human civilisation.
Nuanced and well researched ❤ from India
Its actually and outward miration from Indian subcontinent.
And most Europeans are decendents of Indians and middle easterns some of who in turn are decendants of Africans.
Also there was a proto indo european and proto avestan language which we call 'Chhand language' coz it was writen as rhyming stanzas...
And none of these is myth...
These are all recorded history...
Greek mythology is almost completely copied from ancient Indian history of written in Vedas & Ramayan & Mahabharat
I've always and I mean since I was child have always had a fascination with languages. I wanted to know if there was a mother/father tongue that was spoken by everyone in the beginning and what it may have sounded like. I know the tower of Babel story but hearing it this just does something to me. I find it hard to explain. What would we find if humanity found the first language ever spoken by us all?
I'm pretty sure it sounded like grunts and shrieks that meant, "hey, you", and "stop doing that".
@zipperpillow Lol you might be right.😂😂😂
Well, humans in similar circumstances are going to come up with similar ideas. Put enough human cultures together and, yeah, there will be coincidences.
But all others are converted into christanity, Islam only HInduism has survived!!!
The new testament was first written in a european language, koine greek. So they were Christians from that point on
What was the name of prometheus in indian mythology stephen?
Mātariśvan
those Greek took their knowlledge without writing system later it is incorporated where Egyptian interaction give details on this!! Egyptians expressed Greek were good souls but writing script!!! Can I ask how, those Panini referred in Greek!! Truth is like that only! Ancient spoken Sankrit very much interacted with various other dailect and changed! Again, Those migrating Asura Aryans have no practice of having Brahman clergy to safe guard vedic words and culture but suras! Of course, Greeks are only Suras who helped nine Asura kinga and tenth to support, That is ten king war! They are also forced out of India They very much pained to participate with Asura kings later and moved separately without any relation with Asuras!
@@Saraswathiputraindeed my friend...the Aryans that helped your king were greeks according to our books too!Diodoros of Sicely gives details...also Greeks had scripta ,Egyptians heroglyphics which is not consider as scripta,though heroglyphics is greek word too...thanks again
So shocking. Who would have ever imagined cultures that are descendants of the same cultural ancestor are similar. I’m gonna go sit on the toilet and marvel at this for a bit.
I don't think most people know that much of European, Indian and Iranian cultures are descended from the same culture.
Almost all of these etymologies are wrong. Mantras comes from manas as in mind, and medhu only occasionally is a synonym for honey. This guy clearly does not know Sanskrit
I'm not completely convinced, but things sound sound ,
Main source is "Indo-European
Poetry and Myth", by ML West, Oxford University Press. There you get a muuuch more detailed version.
@@thomasvieth578 what are you noy convinced of?
The repeated and systemathic exclusion of the Slavic mythology and culture from western historical studies is astounding. You mentioned pretty much everyone in this video but the largerst ethnic Indo-European group. And don't even start with "there is no written source of the Slavic mythology". Yes there is. The Slavic folklore has been written down. You are just too lazy to study it and too stuck in your cultural bubble. There are numerous references in the Slavic myths to the sky god, the divine twins, the goddess of dawn, the sun god, the serpent. Your book should be called: "The mythology of the Indoeuropeans exept for the Slavs as I can't be bothered to research them so let's pretend they don't exist". lol
That one source is Sanskrit. How long till Europeans let go off their fake pride and accept?
Try it to call Anatolia ‘Turkey’. It is anachronistic. Asia Minor is also correct.
The founding fathers of the Anglo-Saxons were Hengest and Horsa, brothers whose names meant stallion and horse.
Both made-up characters.
@@zipperpillow Yes, a combination of Romulus and Remus and Castor and Pollux. I think Hengest kills Horsa too.
Lol indo-european....such a made up word 😂 ......
The link between the Vajra and Zeus' bolt is a bit of a "click" moment.