ForThe Republic Very obviously faked, and even if that was Charlie’s “genuine” reaction he never released it or streamed it which means no one would have access to it, which means its faked. Are you dumb?
I almost threw away my phone at that jumpscare. Glad to see that even when Charlie gets genuinely startled, he is still more composed than a fucking rock.
Outlast: Charlie opens a door with hanging bodies and screams "What are you so scared about" very casually Medal of Honor: Sees a leaf in his window, loses his shit Foliage is Charlie's weakness.
uhh pretty sure people instinctively scream and alert friends not because they want to help their friends, but so their friends can help them. It wouldn't make sense if humans developed an instinct via natural selection to sacrifice themselves for the people who didnt share the same trait because the people who self sacrifice would be dead, and therefore unable to pass along the self-sacrifical trait. So i doubt screaming exists "for the good of the pack" so to speak, but rather to take advantage of being in a pack in the first place.
I'm not saying self-sacrificial traits aren't selected for, I'm saying that screaming is more likely a trait that exists because of the "teamwork" element rather than the sacrificial element, and based on that reasoning saying that instinctual screaming happens for the purpose of self sacrifice isn't logical.
This right here is a Guinness world record bois, don't ever forget the time stamp 2:32. Fear of Nightmares is the first horror game to ever scare Charlie.
The funniest part about this is the fact that the werewolf isn't touching the ground. It just floats at you and instead of scaring me I just burst out laughing and then laughed harder when critical got startled lol
"This game is just absolute---" *JUMP SCARE* Right as he was about to trash the game, the werewolf shows up and opened his eyes to the pinnacle of horror.
+Lasciel You should pay him more respect for as he has been opening chips packs for his whole life now, just so we can have cool walking sounds. Respect him.
That jumpscare made me laugh. You were about to say something bad about the game and that came outta nowhere, I started laughing and then he said it startled him lmfao
The werewolf chupacabra person guy clearly was covered in leaves. There was nothing you could do Charlie. Don't feel bad. I got startled too from just how unexpected and ridiculous it was.
Crazy that this was only about 5 years ago. Charlie has grown so much since then, and has gotten a huge following. It makes me super happy to see just how far he's gone :D
Even funnier, he got angry because out of all the things, Layers of Fear, Tattletail, FNaF, the *good* games that could (and should) have earned the medal for actually scaring him, this half-assed mess of ones and zeroes was the one to do it. He wasn't just angered, he was humiliated.
@Sir quackles The fourth It's scary in that it behaves like a hacked or cursed game, messes with it's own files. If you were going in blind it would be spooky imo. That or you only looked at the steam page
The reason why that scared you was because you didn't expect anything good or genuinely scary to come from such a horribly designed game, so you let your guard down, and the second you did, the game used that split second of comfort to attack. I bet you play it again, you now know what the game has in store. It won't catch you off-guard ever again.
It's actually more because the jumpscares aren't usually this quick to happen. Usually the monster stands there and then pops up in front of you, or you know that there's a monster in the area and when you die it's a jumpscare. Here, it was so quick, like Charlie wasn't able to do anything, with no indication it was going to happen at all, it's not surprising it will startle you, because it's completely unfair.
i still come back and watch this video occasionally. i’ve been watching you for about 3 years now and this is absolutely the greatest video i’ve seen from you and on youtube in general. thank you
We are acknowledging the fact that this is the *first time* Cr1tikal got *startled* by a *horror game.* I’m pretty sure at least a quarter of the fan base knows that the MoH video was the first time we know that Cr1tikal got startled.
I just love how it just *instantly* shut him up And the way it cuts to the title screen the split second after makes it feel like there was a jump-cut there, as if something happened that we didn’t get to see
This video has literally the best natural comedic timing ever the jump scare followed by an immediate 3 second silence then hearing “…of every horror game-“ 😭☠️🤣🤣
Man I wish I could relive that moment again. I've been as sick as a dog for days and now my godamn sinuses are clearer than glass. That was like watching an amazing movie with a twist that can't be unrevealed.
it's ingeneous, really. it makes you let down your guard because you're laughing at how bad it is, and then it gets you with a quarter-second jumpscare.
this is legitimately one of the funniest videos you've ever made, and I've been watching for a long time. That reaction to that God-awful shitscare was one of the funniest things I've ever seen.
Don't feel bad cr1tikal that was so unexpected that I think anyone would have been startled. It wasn't scary at all but if someones gonna scream in my ear and jump at me like the face hugger from alien then yes I will flinch.
I'd never actually watched the full thing but my respect for Charlie has gone up infinitely for finding out that he didn't refund the game because the jumpscare earned the purchase
My friend and I sent each other funny vids so he ends up sending me this and tell my to skip to were u get the lantern, and I'm just genuinely saying your reaction to the jumps scare was freaking hilarious.
"This game is just absolute-"
_Jumpscare_
"…Of every horror game, I ever played…"
“…None of them have genuinely startled me, until now.”
@@k-boi420that's a really nice profile picture..
@@k-boi420 nice pfp my guy
@@k-boi420SUSSY
@@k-boi420ur pfp made me have flashback of that one undertale por...
No screams, no yells, only monotone voice after the jumpscare. Amazing.
There's none because he edited it out lol
@@adammusleh5992 No, he was always pretty monotone (not really any more, he actually laughs from time to time now)
@@consume_egg1338 here's the unedited version of this
ua-cam.com/video/yezrzjBAiyQ/v-deo.html
@@adammusleh5992 now that IS the edited version.
ForThe Republic Very obviously faked, and even if that was Charlie’s “genuine” reaction he never released it or streamed it which means no one would have access to it, which means its faked. Are you dumb?
"This game is absolut-"
Famous last words.
REUAAÀAA-
@@CVswhndja of every horror game I’ve ever played none of them have scared me until now 😐
the absolute epitome of bad jumpscares
@@RONALDII0 just fucking ambushed by a chupacabra
@@barrysmith6595 With a split second of a loud noise
I almost threw away my phone at that jumpscare. Glad to see that even when Charlie gets genuinely startled, he is still more composed than a fucking rock.
same tbh
I just laughed too damn hard from the instant switch to the menu.
Cr1tikal: *Hardly any reaction*
“That genuinely startled me”
I wish I could be as stone cold as this man.
+Darth Mawrak I can consciously reprogram myself to do either response.
Darth Mawrak when I go on coasters I try and scream and it just sounds like I'm breathing loudly
Outlast: Charlie opens a door with hanging bodies and screams
"What are you so scared about" very casually
Medal of Honor: Sees a leaf in his window, loses his shit
Foliage is Charlie's weakness.
uhh pretty sure people instinctively scream and alert friends not because they want to help their friends, but so their friends can help them. It wouldn't make sense if humans developed an instinct via natural selection to sacrifice themselves for the people who didnt share the same trait because the people who self sacrifice would be dead, and therefore unable to pass along the self-sacrifical trait. So i doubt screaming exists "for the good of the pack" so to speak, but rather to take advantage of being in a pack in the first place.
I'm not saying self-sacrificial traits aren't selected for, I'm saying that screaming is more likely a trait that exists because of the "teamwork" element rather than the sacrificial element, and based on that reasoning saying that instinctual screaming happens for the purpose of self sacrifice isn't logical.
This right here is a Guinness world record bois, don't ever forget the time stamp 2:32. Fear of Nightmares is the first horror game to ever scare Charlie.
alex garcia We should celebrate
Barry The Slinger drinks are on me tonight 🍻
Cheers
Screenshot saved
Barry The Slinger *beers
“this game is absolute-“
*REEEEEEEEEE*
2:53 this analogy is absolutely wild
Fr😭
I wasn't even scared by the jumpscare I was just laughing about how fast it went from jumpscare to menu screen
KillerKhye ladies and gentlemen we have a turbo chad in the comments
I was just laughing at how ugly the werewolf was
Same for me i was laughing my ass off
Same.
It was just
*BLLEARRGH*
:)
I freaking love your pfp. Cry of the cat!
I wish I saw Charlie’s reaction when he was jumpscared.
His eyebrows barely rose
He looked like this
owo owo OwO >w< owo
Your profile picture scared me so badly because I thought there was a spider on my screen
Probably jumped a whole millimeter up.
@@gannongarfin1634 Gosh your profile picture!
The funniest part about this is the fact that the werewolf isn't touching the ground. It just floats at you and instead of scaring me I just burst out laughing and then laughed harder when critical got startled lol
My dog when I'm back home from work 2:32
Hello daisy
What kind of dog is that
@@somisimons chihuahua
"It don't Bite"
Even when Cr1tikal is startled he still has a composure that would rival a god.
i cume pants
Dude, your everywhere I see on any videos...
Fuck off Justin young
Justin Young it just jumped 10 likes you like botter
Oh man, could it be possibly be actual people liking the comment? Nah it must be bots because the comment got 5 more likes when I refreshed the page.
Werewolf - 1
Leaf - 1
Charlie - 0
Medal of Honor
Cheerio
oh the leaf.
spaghetti matangi Medal of honor
Princess Yōsha how does Charlie get points?
I love how he was about to judge the game and just got assaulted by a flying chupacabra
Bro got so scared he pulled out the “never, in my 20 years of teaching,”
the only thing cr1tikal is scared of is the toilet when he flushes it
why flush it when you can shoot it?
Nope. The leaf in his Medal of Honor gameplay scared him
who doesn't hate those excessively loud automatic toilets that flush if you so much as scratch your nose?
And cockroaches
And cockroaches
wonder if these devs know that they just made fucking history by mildly startling charlie
this dev*
midget geodude sorry, i assumed this masterpiece of a video game had a team of no less than 100 behind it
Do you still wonder?
they made him jump in his seat like a 13 year old girl
@@Eternal_Fae0987 who just saw an overgrown uncircumcised penis for the first time
Bro was so scared, he pulled out the “Never in my 15 years of teaching” 💀
really original comment
@@N2ptune thank u 👍
"This game is just absolute---" *JUMP SCARE*
Right as he was about to trash the game, the werewolf shows up and opened his eyes to the pinnacle of horror.
the walk sounds like me opening a bag of chips
Atlas only you? 😂 not anyone else
Its like those creepy asmr videos with extra earape
+Lasciel You should pay him more respect for as he has been opening chips packs for his whole life now, just so we can have cool walking sounds. Respect him.
@@BoostedDoge talking to yourself bro
@@fuzzy8889 You said that 3 years after that comment i think you’re talking to yourself truly
2:32 You see Scarce walk out behind a tree
Yo
Yo
@Chris 3v yo
@@Kokabaxter yo
He just screams like that thing
I absolutely wheezed laughing at the jumpscare the sound and shitty character model was absolutely perfect
bro fr said "after all my years of teaching...."
That might be the 1 in 15 million gaming videos that would have genuinely gained something from a webcam recording the players face.
I think it’s funnier without it tbh
“That genuinely startled me. I’m shaking”
(Dead empty shark eyes. Clearly as motionless as a statue)
don't worry charlie, i jumped a little too. it was just so unexpected.
I almost accidentally punched myself in the face when I jumped
it sent shivers down my spine to be honest
DEMERN I like your hat👍🏼
Honestly I just laughed
Initial D Style It is still jump scare worthy lol
Yoooo dude you made it into Pewds’s newest video.
they are friends
Charile is Felix confirmed.
Thats why im here
Shut I know I just saw that.
Yaas
That jumpscare made me laugh. You were about to say something bad about the game and that came outta nowhere, I started laughing and then he said it startled him lmfao
I feel privileged to have just witnessed history today
I am here from the shit year of 2020
@@TheGlasgowGamer I am here from ok 2021
@@majorroberts3198 I am here from... idk 2022 just started so I can't say an accurate adjective yet
You actually did
Hahaha. Yeah, kinda. 2022 here
The werewolf chupacabra person guy clearly was covered in leaves. There was nothing you could do Charlie. Don't feel bad. I got startled too from just how unexpected and ridiculous it was.
I thought it was a cat that just flew onto his face.
Invader-sama Imagine how he would feel when getting jump scared from behind by a creeper in Minecraft...
2:54 EDP445 be like
💀
Maybe undergrown but ye
Crazy that this was only about 5 years ago. Charlie has grown so much since then, and has gotten a huge following. It makes me super happy to see just how far he's gone :D
He got so angry because he got scared
Even funnier, he got angry because out of all the things, Layers of Fear, Tattletail, FNaF, the *good* games that could (and should) have earned the medal for actually scaring him, this half-assed mess of ones and zeroes was the one to do it. He wasn't just angered, he was humiliated.
The jump scare got me, and then the banter about it got me laugh crying. 10/10 best jump scare.
I felt stinging in my toes when I saw it, made me recoil a bit too. And im an experienced horrorgame player.
4 years later and still holds the crown of only horror game to jump scare Charlie. Amazing
I am going to be very, VERY honest here......
I pissed myself because of that jumpscare
Orange Julius kinky
?
Thats nice.
people be saying "kinky" and "nice"
Im dying cus the jumpscare just stops him mid-sentence.
There’s nothing to fear but fear itself and of course nightmares.
Oingo Boingo reference? 😍
2:36 bro pulled the “never in my 20 years of teaching”💀💀
That jumpscare was hilarious
Him commenting after that made me laugh even harder. Ah man I haven't had a good laugh in a while.
DDLC = Not startled
Some effortless low-poly werewolf = HOLY FUCK
@Sir quackles The fourth It's scary in that it behaves like a hacked or cursed game, messes with it's own files. If you were going in blind it would be spooky imo. That or you only looked at the steam page
@Sir quackles The fourth its psychological horror game not jumpscare game
@@NemyacX it literally has jumpscares lmao what are you even saying
@DatBoiSolar that's what it's supposed to imitate and subvert to be surprise scary. I may not fond of it myself, but I admit it's a cool concept
@@Ardeact noo so scary bro
My grandma when she finds out i haven't eaten. 2:33
deserves more likes
I went to the timestamp and got jumpscared again
This comment broke me
But instead of horror games it would b wars
2:32 he actually got scared but edited out his scream.
Nah, that’s how it actually is.
@@theangryvoltorb8638 nah thats his scream
To this day Charlie has never forgotten this. Sometimes even the simplest things can leave lifelong impressions. It's like beautiful poetry.
The reason why that scared you was because you didn't expect anything good or genuinely scary to come from such a horribly designed game, so you let your guard down, and the second you did, the game used that split second of comfort to attack. I bet you play it again, you now know what the game has in store. It won't catch you off-guard ever again.
Any more words of wisdom you stinky birb?
true
Spiffy holy shit you're so smart
It's actually more because the jumpscares aren't usually this quick to happen. Usually the monster stands there and then pops up in front of you, or you know that there's a monster in the area and when you die it's a jumpscare.
Here, it was so quick, like Charlie wasn't able to do anything, with no indication it was going to happen at all, it's not surprising it will startle you, because it's completely unfair.
also we didn't expect the game to actually work
It finally happened. This is what the apex of horror looks like.
i still come back and watch this video occasionally. i’ve been watching you for about 3 years now and this is absolutely the greatest video i’ve seen from you and on youtube in general. thank you
This must have become my most favourite video on the internet so far. That reaction, that commentary. It was so perfect.
Cr1tikal got scared by a leaf one time, are we just gonna ignore that this was not the first time he got jump scared?
Specifically the first time he got legit startled from a *horror game.* When he got scared by the leaf, that was in his Medal of Honor video.
We are acknowledging the fact that this is the *first time* Cr1tikal got *startled* by a *horror game.* I’m pretty sure at least a quarter of the fan base knows that the MoH video was the first time we know that Cr1tikal got startled.
ua-cam.com/video/W1PDaA_iX0w/v-deo.html
the leaf wasn't in the video game it was outside his window
Well yeah. It wasn't IN the video, but the audio of him getting scared by that leaf on his window was.
That jumpscare actually got me. It was so out of nowhere
"This game is just absolute--"
I just love how it just *instantly* shut him up
And the way it cuts to the title screen the split second after makes it feel like there was a jump-cut there, as if something happened that we didn’t get to see
lmao classic unity jump sound and infinite mountain climbing.
I'm here before Justin young with the Ninja picture gets two top comments again
yeah
I can here him coming now
Lmao so true
He hasn’t commented yet I think he’s dead
Oh god
I've replayed the jumpscare so many times that now I burst into laughter when I see that thing flying at charlie
2:27 best part
The jumpiest of scares. Funnily enough, it startled me, but I had just enough time to take in the weird polygonal body of the werewolf test model.
That was the worst/best jumpscare inthe universe.
Came back to watch the jumpscare. laughed as hard as I did back then. Honestly one of my favorite videos on UA-cam.
this is my comfort video. when i am sad and down in the depths of the dumps i come here. brings me up every time
oh, that's just the t-posing spider wolf that lives down the lane. pay him no mind.
My chest and head went right up at that scare and I thought "Oh now critical is gonna make me feel like a bitch".
Pleasantly surprised
Charlie’s reaction to the jumpscare made me laugh harder than I ever did before
I have watched so many videos of of this legend and not once have I seen him get any reaction of fear until today damn.
That jumpscare was fucking hilarious
2:33
MY EARS!
2:32 let’s congratulate sans for being the most calmest monster while being scared
The shitty clipart jumpscare, the sound effect, and the cutoff to the main menu never fails to make me laugh
This video has literally the best natural comedic timing ever the jump scare followed by an immediate 3 second silence then hearing “…of every horror game-“ 😭☠️🤣🤣
Coming back just to see the jump scare
Thank you pewdiepie
The way he explained his reaction is just perfect.
*gets jumpscared*
*writes an article*
The jumpscare is unpredictable
Charlie: This game is just absolute-
Monster: *Continue and you’ll see the answer*
2:32 I have spent the last 10 mins just replaying this and then putting at different speeds, this is truly remarkable.
Was sitting in a well lit room, middle of the day, laughing at how bad this game, and that jump scare still got me
Came back after the seeing the short to try to see Charlies reaction but sadly this was before the age of face cam
I rewatch this every so often to get a good chuckle
I appreciate this man with all my heart. His monotone voice and plain insults are basically everything.
You're a beautiful human Charlie
Man I wish I could relive that moment again. I've been as sick as a dog for days and now my godamn sinuses are clearer than glass. That was like watching an amazing movie with a twist that can't be unrevealed.
2:33 POV: you slammed the door after an argument with your mom
I love how a fourth of the video is him talking about how a jumpscare actually got him
I love that he kept the game after.
A horror game that looks really low budget and quickly rushed but actually ends up being genuinely scary is an amazing idea
Finally!! You got scared-ish I had to dig deep in the archives and after 2years of watching the channel I have been rewarded
This is the funniest shit I’ve seen in awhile
This shit after 5 years is still so funny
Watched this on lunch break. Jumped also and then laughed so hard I got into a coughing fit and nearly passed out. Thank you for this
it's ingeneous, really. it makes you let down your guard because you're laughing at how bad it is, and then it gets you with a quarter-second jumpscare.
It made me laugh cause how fast the creature went to the camera and All I hear is a loud ass scream and it just instantly cuts to the main menu 😂😂😂😂
2:32 what the fuck holy shit
That made me laugh. (still startled me, but I was immediately laughing right after)
I come back to this video every month this shig always cracks me up
Charlie, of all the games I've watched you play this one genuinely gave me a jump scare as well lmao
this is legitimately one of the funniest videos you've ever made, and I've been watching for a long time. That reaction to that God-awful shitscare was one of the funniest things I've ever seen.
Don't feel bad cr1tikal that was so unexpected that I think anyone would have been startled. It wasn't scary at all but if someones gonna scream in my ear and jump at me like the face hugger from alien then yes I will flinch.
I'd never actually watched the full thing but my respect for Charlie has gone up infinitely for finding out that he didn't refund the game because the jumpscare earned the purchase
My friend and I sent each other funny vids so he ends up sending me this and tell my to skip to were u get the lantern, and I'm just genuinely saying your reaction to the jumps scare was freaking hilarious.
This jumpscare worked cause it had no reason to happen and you just barely got in the game to get that immunity to the type of jumpscares it uses