Everything Wrong With Split In 16 Minutes Or Less
Вставка
- Опубліковано 24 тра 2017
- Split! The movie that put M. Night back on the map! I guess. I mean... I don't know... I watched it and thought it was just okay, and the connection to another film felt forced and saccarine. But what do I know? I'm just an Internet asshole, so...
Next week: Super-obscure superhero sins and not-so-obscure superhero sins.
May is Mental Health Month, and it's a subject that means a lot to us here at CinemaSins.
In fact, we’re partnering with Mental Health America (MHA) to not only to raise awareness of mental health issues - but also to raise a little money, too. We’ve got a brand-new Cinema Sins t-shirt in the shop, and all of the profits from the sale of the shirt will be donated to our friends at MHA.
Click here to check out or purchase the shirt: www.districtlines.com/109796-C...
Remember, no movie is without sin! Which movie's sins should we expose next?!
Podcast: / cinemasins
Sins Video Playlist: • Everything Wrong With ...
Tweet us: / cinemasins
Reddit with us: / cinemasins
Tumble us: / cinema-sins
Call us: 405-459-7466
Jeremy's book: theablesbook.com Merch: teespring.com/stores/cinemasi... - Фільми й анімація
The TRUE sin is James McAvoy not being listed 23 times as the credits rolled.
(Wow. 9K likes. Boy, do I feel special. 😅)
24*
25?
@@skeletoncreek6446 You know what's funnier than 24?
@@killjoytw1nk what
@@skeletoncreek6446 25!
I wonder if directors ever watch cinemasins' reviews of their movies and are like, "How the fuck did I miss that?"
Probably the Russo Brothers. They watch Honest Trailers, so they most likely watch CinemaSins too. I think the guys who directed John Wick also do.
Kyle D That would be funny if they did
I think they have a program where they get the directors to talk about the cinema sins. Or is that the honest trailers one?
Kyle D If they did, it would probably go like this: "Man, we should really reduce the logo times! ...Yeah... What? Why?... We need to get the Copyrights to make a Microsoft computer... Oh yeah!... How the heck did we miss that!... That makes no sense..."
Kyle D they probably laugh at it like we do
As he was spraying the other 2 girls I would've already been out of the car
I am milan 😂😂😂 facts
It's called the freeze response
We all like to think highly of how we would react in a situation like that, buuuut... Yeah, Fight/Flight/Freeze usually ends up with freezing. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
@@bb-ih9hg no it doesnt usually end up with freezing, its kind of an evolutionary flaw, most humans go for fight/flight.
Wouldn't even be selfish you'd be running to get help FFS although maybe shock happened, and she couldn't move for all she knew her dad was just killed! I was in a car wreck that happened suddenly totaling my small car, & couldn't move after sitting outside it.
If I'm going to be honest this movie was very fascinating to me.
Except that the split personalities aren't even accurate to real life D.I.D
A depressed teenager Who watches anime lmao It should be. You portray a minority right, portray a community right.
@@wouldntyouliketoknowweathe9145
To be fair, this series of movies (unbreakable, split, and glass) is based off of people with special powers. I wouldn't take the accuracy in the portrayal of the personality disorder with a grain of salt.
@@nebbysgalaxy I wonder how many people who make that complaint have actually bothered to research D.I.D. and how many are just automatically saying it because it's what "smart" people are supposed to say. I mean, I'd love to hear a person WITH D.I.D. compare and contrast their own experiences with how the disorder is portrayed in films (I'd love that to be done with every mental illness that's portrayed in films) but that complaint coming from someone with no more knowledge of the disorder than the people who made the film is just eye-roll-inducing.
Andrea Greenwood I haven’t seen the movies but from what I HAVE seen, as a person with DID, it’s at the very least a harmful portrayal. A few youtubers with DID have made videos about glass and split, n they explain it pretty well. I don’t remember what the points were but I know one thing the online DID community was laughing at was the idea that alters change clothes when they front (which is only the case for me if one of the girls puts on a dress or smth and I front while I’m at the house, at which point I’ll put on my own clothes, take off makeup, etc for my comfort)
This is what happens when professor X tries to control too many minds.
Varinder Bhandal noice
Varinder Bhandal Or when Logan and Flash decide to drop everything and screw up the timeline.
"I bind the Phoenix with power of AHHHHHH!!!"
This is more like Charles becoming his son Legion(David).
FireSpawner yea this is actually part of the X-Men franchise and he's Legion, how else does he have super Powers.
Should've also added 30 sins for Dr. Fletcher, a woman who probably spent many years studying reverse psychology, telling Dennis that she didn't agree with him holding the girls and that he needed to let them go. Because in reality she could've said she understood and left and called the cops. But no. He had to take her too.
No, she could just SAY F*ING NAME!
Aaliyah Strong I would have treated those girls better. kept them warm and well fed. clip their toenails. make sure the ropes were tight but not uncomfortable.
...these replies are kind of disturbing
Aaliyah Strong yeah the replies got creepy
*ding*
James McAvoy being able to play 23 people in one movie, remembering the differences in how each of them talk, walk, act, & getting into the mindset of each is great acting! He definitely deserved an Oscar just based on that alone.
The character had maybe 23 personalities but the very most of them arent really shown besides a few seconds. So it was maybe 5. Great of course but far away from playing 23 roles at the same time
@@KurtMidas1510 Also its not like he's having live conversations with different personalities in one take. If you want to see true talent like that look up Phil Hendrie.
@@KurtMidas1510 more were shown in the ending
Hauntingly powerful performance
My mom has DID and it's not like how media portrays but it really is a sad reality for her and I wish people understood it more
Samantha. Baker I really want to know more about it. I think the good thing about a movie like this is that it starts a conversation. I had no idea it existed until I heard about this movie and since then I’ve been able to learn a little more about it
@@fashionfrenzy55433 What did you learn?
It is hard.....we have DID too
I agree! I don't have nor know anyone with DID, but I've watched videos by people that have it and it just makes me angry. Movies and shows portray people with DID as murderers, crazy or weird. This movie would be great if it didn't contribute to the misundertanding of what DID is
Alex Katakuna I totally agree, a movie about DID could be fascinating but they turned it into a borderline offensive misinterpretation of an actual thing (I wasn’t sure whether to call it an illness/disorder/something different sorry) that people suffer from
cinema sins is the way to watch films for free
William LU films that you also might have never watched
William LU *find out if a film is worth watching by looking at the number of sins or more quickly, the video time
Bazooka Sniper It's exactly what I do. And typically, the movies I think would be stupid are the ones that have tons of sins.
Exactly!! I feel like I've watched all these movies when I've really seen 10 min of it ahaha
William LU 👏👏👏
Not an amazing movie, but holy shit James McAvoy really stepped up his game with this role. He's a killer actor.
Coolartist1110 omg
Hisoka Morou v6@@@ 7uaa
Nope, not really, you have literally no idea what yo are talking about and you just made the entire audience a little bit mre stupid by saying that.
Jace Carsonne I totally agree!
David James
Well if the topic is stupidity, maybe "yo" should practice your spelling a little bit "mre."
When insulting one's intelligence on the internet, one should be mindful of their own spelling and grammar.
10:37 - Tulane University is an actual university in New Orleans. Cinemasins gets a sin
I noticed that too and I had no idea if he was serious or just giving Tulane University shit
They also have a sister school in Oregon
2 years later and I had to scroll through the comments to make sure someone said this 😂 I live right outside of New Orleans and Tulane is actually quite a prestigious university!
Yam Fast that’s exactly what I was thinking lol
Lol...that might have been tongue-in-cheek :-) Tulane University is a well-known institution in the US (are these dudes Canadian or some bullshit? :-P)
"Everything Wrong With Split"
*Me, diagnosed with DID: Oh don't get me started-*
as someone with OSDD-1B ive had to tell so many people that Split is a HORRIBLE representation of dissociative disorders
M. Night Shyamalan did a horrible job with expressing that the diagnosis was wrong. Kevin doesn't have DID. He might've started with that but he is a classic super villain, which is better expressed in Glass, but it's still greatly misrepresented in this movie. Mr. Glass used Kevin's trauma to unleash the abilities he already had and it caused the misdiagnosis because regular human brains can't comprehend that super human ppl exist. The idea behind what he was trying to do was genius but his delivery was garbage and damaging to ppl who actually have DID. That's one thing that irks me about his movies, his attempt to leave things open to interpretation often fails to provide enough material to come even close to what he is trying to do.
literally i hated this movie so much-
it was so harmful and awful and the first reactions to us telling someone we exist as a system was 'so who's the evil one' and 'like the movie split' UGH
- elena
i did the same thing..
I didn't know it was so inaccurate. Wow. Thats crazy, especially knowing that Shaymalan consulted with different psychologists & neuroscientists to help create Mcavoys character. I wonder what went wrong...
When quiet girl didn't freak out when bad guy gassed the girls in the trailer... I thought that the twist would be that she didn't exist and was a 'detached' split personality.
endplanets *whoa*
endplanets I thought she was in on it the entire time only to come to find out she's the way she is because of her own mental illness / past trauma
I'd watch that!!
what a High Tension ending that would have been.
That's exactly what I thought.
The acting by him in this movie is amazing
jonathan lavezzi
I’m sinning you for playing the pronoun game, lol. Sorry, couldn’t resist.
In all honesty, though, James McAvoy did do an amazing job. Disappointed he didn’t get more credit for his performance.
@@j.p.6932 He would've gotten more credit if it wasnt for shit writing
Lmao no its not. This,movie is 100% rat ass
@@jamesvincent4472 thats your opinion.
James Vincent His acting made it better.
As someone with DID I find this whole movie really interesting..the portrayal of DID kind of upsets me but MacAvoy's performance is so incredible it makes me love this movie so much
The movie's not about accurately depicting DID. He literally has a super power. If u see the sequel it shows explains this more
@Joel Roy wdym? i thought it was supposed to be based off the mental illness DID
@@wendydiask even if the movie doesn't accurately depict DID, if someone without much knowledge watched the movie, that will be how they see people with DID
Have you ever seen Sybil, that was another movie with a protagonist who had DID. Except it was more focused on the character struggling with her childhood traumas and accepting her other identities as a part of herself. I don't know how accurate the movie is, but I do appreciate it for showing more the interpersonal struggles the character has without villanizing her.
Which one of you said that? XD
Cinimasins: Sins Unbreakable for not having a sequel
Also Cinimasins: Sins Unbreakable sequel for being a sequel to Unbreakable...
Because it isn't a sequel to Unbreakable, it's a different movie in the same universe, but has little to nothing to actually do with Unbreakable.
Lu Renner Well, this movie is a sequel to Unbreakable that has everything to do with this movie .
Spoiler alert : The train accident orchestrated by Mr Glass killed Kevin’s father. And without his father being here to protect him, he got abused by his mother. And ended up having the 23 personalities.
So yes it all starts from Unbreakable.
@@backstage7042 Even if that would not be the case, CS sins movies simply for stretching his counter and this is a good example of that
@@Milleniummeister I know I'm late to the debate, but CS sins everything. It's satire, not a movie review
@@OoMikkioO in quite a bit of these videos he’s says not to be taken seriously
James Mcavoy not being nominated for an Oscar
Sin
Young Herbert the movie came out around that year’s Oscar’s, so it was forgotten the next year. That was one of my first thoughts leaving the theater he was gonna get screwed.
@@KitchenerLeslie2 this is a nice movie but the way they depicted the dissociative identity disorder is disgustingly wrong. for people who think that this movie was not detrimental to people with the disorder, physically, emotionally, and mentally, imagine this: someone made a movie about autistic people pretending to be mentally ill but in reality they think like serial killers and are into torture, rape, and cannidbolism. now imagine how people with autism, and people who has autistic relatives or friends, would feel about it. the director did not poke fun at the disorder, but unconsciously created a huge stigma around the disorder. which is in ways much worse. because of this movie, millions believe that people with the disorder may have murderous and crazy personalities and shun them because if it. countless of them have gradually lost friends and people they trusted because of the stigmas. the director obviously didnt want nor expect a negative impact on people with this disorder, but it happened anyway. if this movie didnt exist, it would have made many people's lives easier. its extremely insulting and hurting. humans have the instinct to shun and persecute things that they fear, or dont know much about. there have been instances where people with the disorder have been hurt or even killed, reason being "he was a creep and it was in self defense because i dont know when hes gonna switch to an evil personality and kill us!" go search it up. this actually happened. many times. it doesnt matter if the movie wasnt meant to create a stigma. as long as people interpreted it wrongly, it would end up having a negative impact.the director and the actors could have put much more effort into speaking out before and after the movie release and addressing that nothing about the disorder depicted in the movie is actually real.
Kaiyu Not Caillou yeah I know. I’m an archeologist and all my friends think I carry a whip and hang out with a little Chinese kid...
Absolutely
Kaiyu Not Caillou beautifully said sadly not alot of people understand this.
Nothing for the fucking creepy uncle
OG 17 Uncle Jack
just me is that a "it's always sunny in Philadelphia" reference? If so, AMEN BROTHER!
I think he wanted to avoid talking about what was happening to her at home.
They mentioned in their "Everything Wrong With MusicVideoSins" episode that they won't cover any instances of sexual assault or anything that makes them feel really shitty in the morning.
Rawr.
With DID being a superpower in this universe i cant wait for the characters schizophrenia man and super depressed woman
i'd laugh my ass off at schizophrenia man. they would fuck it up and probably still be more accurate than all the "oh i'm a looney look at me being dangerous and ridiculous" you see in movies
abortoespacial And super depressed girl would be an emo quirky girl
@@4besideyouintime Would probably be like that SCP where anything he believes is real actually becomes real.
Well, there was a telepath who also had schizophrenia in the last movie abt x-men so you're not that far away
OH I HAVE A IDEA! Atusic man
She doesn't get out the car because that IS what introduces us to how she is "different" from the other girls. The trauma she endured, is most likely why she froze up. This is a big thing later in the movie.
He really is an amazing actor
Ethan Hudson agreed
Ethan Hudson he redeemed the film
totally agree
Imho he was not bad but... amazing?
Because he can play four or five klishee roles? I would not even consider this a challenge for a decent actor.
NoHarmony ...klishee
This was basically a werewolf movie without the werewolf. If they had made him a werewolf, it would have all fit perfectly.
For real, such a joke of a film.
Would make more sense and be less potentially offensive to those with psychological disorders.
Mr. Cool that would have been stupid
Lol the man waits til a full moon to eat the kids ... yea makes more since instead of the beast thing
yung witch If the beast didn't make sense to you then you probably need to rewatch it or something. Made perfect sense to me.
James literally deserves an award above an Oscar fo this role, the academy is stupid for not nominating him I hope he doesn't stop acting because he is TRULY one of the most talented actors in the industry
Here’s a little explanation for the “how Dennis has Barry’s accent and knows about fashion” sin
Okay, so, in D.I.D (Dissociative identify disorder, formerly multiple personality disorder) the host is the most common alter in the system. Barry in this case would be the host, he’s ‘out’ the most, he’s most likely been there the longest, etc. In D.I.D, the disorder has developed due to a severe trauma during childhood. What D.I.D is essentially is a defence mechanism for said trauma. The alters in the system will therefore adapt to be able to protect the body from potential attack. One of these defends mechanisms is other alters will act like the host to limit suspicion of there being more than one distinct personality in the body. They will mimic the host right down to accents, walking style, posture, hobbies, and so on. This mimicking is most often extremely accurate and so it goes unnoticed to most that it is not in fact the host that is present in the body at that time. It’s usually only people who are very close to the system, having known them for years, been close to them, know about the disorder, who can pick up these very very subtle differences and make out that it is not actually the host talking. Hope this helped?
Edit: I don’t have DID so if anything is a little off please correct me
THANK YOU. DID is a covert disorder, it develops between the ages of 6mo to 9yrs old specifically to enable a child to survive repeated abuse. Alters that can imitate other alters are *far* more common that alters that can't pretend to be anyone else. As someone with DID, this video is honestly even more misleading and ignorant that Split was, which is really saying something (Tulane University? Really??)
THANK YOU!! As someone with DID, it kept bothering me when he said the alters don’t know each other or the host. Almost all systems have an alter that can camouflage as the host
Thank you! I'm someone with DID as well, and that is very much how it goes. Although it takes time for the perfect mimicking to happen, DID is a DEFENSE MECHANISM and is built to be kept hidden or safe due to trauma, and most importantly, people don't actually tend to notice any differences. I have an alter with a Brooklyn accent and very charismatic charm who actually barely gets noticed unless he tells people, so.
Now I'm not diagnosed with DID but I do share a lot of symptoms with it and wouldn't be surprised if I get diagnosed with it one day. In my case, each of my different "sides" all tend to act like me when around others in the way that you described, but I don't think they do it on purpose. It's almost like a protective instinct.
all people with DID do you guys refer to yourselves as "we" as opposed to "I"? Because I've seen people say we have DID and tbh it just seems like shitty cringe to me. Thank you for your time and I am looking forward to your answers.
when you watch an "everything wrong with" instead of the movie
Noah Linforth you missed a 3rd of the movie honestly
You've missed out. Cinemasins has really gone down the tube, and has started sinning the movie for petty, trivial things.
Jesse Bond i think you're missing the point of the joke
Noah Linforth i still want to watch it lol
Noah Linforth same
i can't believe it wasn't mentioned how Casey was just placed in her uncle's care at the end. no hospital checkup, no police questioning, no psych evaluation. just, hey, get out of my cruiser and we'll pass you off to your uncle. i'm sure you're just hunky dory after your classmates were murdered, you were kidnapped and almost killed, and you've experienced severe trauma. of all the oversights, that was one of _the worst_ i've ever seen.
TeenDream888 thats where ur supposed to fill in the blanks
The Moons Rival fill in the blanks??? they literally handed her off to her uncle. if they'd ended it with her driving to the hospital, that would've made sense. you don't just chuck someone over to a relative in the middle of an investigation right after they were rescued. unless you're saying she magically was teleported to the hospital, checked out, interrogated, and then teleported back in her filthy clothes all in a five minute span.
No, they drive her to her uncle's house, and there is a very long, lingering shot of Casey not getting out of the car and the police officer realizing that something else is going on. It's easy enough to determine that yeah, Casey's going to come clean about the abuse she's gone through from that.
FurnaxIkki she's still at the zoo when they say her uncle is there to pick her up. while I'd also like to think Casey will open up to the officers, it's left to interpretation.
FurnaxIkki i hoped that was what that meant
sorry
I really liked this movie
James Mcavoy played all these characters really freaking well
he even plays james mcavoy really freaking well !
omg i agree evey time a new sin pops up i get really friggin
triggered
It is best movie
You don't, understand, the video; in the first place .
The acting was great, the problem was that it demonized an actual disorder that real people have and made them look like monsters
@@twinkiesnails8857
A movie
Turning people with a similar illness bad
A movie where said ill men turns into a beast that can walk on the ceiling.
Ok
Fun fact! Peoples alters are less likely to become a serial killer, etc- due to DID being from childhood trama, so this is horrible representation of DID too
I know I’m late to the reply. But all systems out there are not violent. Or will become a killer. A great TikTok creator described it perfectly. “No alter wants to inflict violence on anyone. This disorder is formed to protect against violence”.
@@rhylerpesht67 weird my alters are very....... uhh... well natural selection should make a comeback.
we are not very pro human....
i dont go on violent killing sprees because its too much of an inconvenience for me and i lack the resources to follow through.
however i have no qualms about people dying women children idfc.
literally!!
It's a SUPERHERO MOVIE!!!!! People with DID aren't superheros. Therefore, the acting and everything done by James is plausible bcze his character is NOT HUMAN!!! He's not like real people with DID!! This movie is not a documentary
@@Reese493 yeah sure, but if a superhero had, for instance, depression, it would still be represented like a real person with depression? surely?
You should have did the part when hedwig told Casey after he kissed her, "You might be pregnant now."
It's technically not a sin, Hedwig was very naive & uneducated, he wouldn't know pregnancy from baseball.
If anything I feel like then it'd be minus a sin
Tushies World there is also a corner in his room with cut outs of bra photos
Jeez isn't Hedwig nine? Who taught him about pregnancy?
Jareth The Goblin King lmao u right💀😂
Spongebob: Hey Patrick, I though of something funnier than 23 personalities
Patrick: Let me hear it.
Spongebob: 24 personalities
As a person with DID, I rate this comment joke 10/10.
@skylar ren Really??? How is that, I mean how it is like to have DID in the real world???.
Noisy.
Skylar Ren really? May I hear about it? I don't know if that's rude to ask but I'm really curious
I'm actually curious too. But would totally understand if that's a sensible subject so it's up to you
4:37 This is actually something that other personalities can do in actual people with DID. They can imitate each other fairly decently, but most alters are best at imitating the host (the personality that spends the most time in control) and the core (the personality that identifies with the body and uses the legal name) Although the skill with which they mimic each other varies.
Hey! Just some info on DID. They are called “ persecutors, ” different from “evil” alters. Yes they change clothes, imagine waking up in a body that’s not yours. And dissociating and changing can take 2 seconds if it’s a forced switch. Also it’s not as rare as you think. Not all alters are aware that they are part of a system. Just some info!
(also alters are not different personalities, they are different people/non-humans)
There's a difference between evil alters and persecutors
ExpressiveChaos thank you! i forgot i even wrote this, i’ve learned a lot more since then lol. hope you guys have a good day
Oblivion Recollection dude don’t be sorry, thank you. i’m dyslexic and mix up words a lot, thanks for correcting me
even had to edit both responses bc of it lmao
@Star Chaser personally not a system, just friends with a few and struggle with ptsd and dissociating so doing my best to support u guys :)
@@expressivechaos1727 im pretty sure theres no such thing as an "evil alter". Unless you mean alters that wear socks with sandals, which is pretty evil
YOU MISSED A SIN! In the parking lot scene, when they are all at the trunk, you can see the entire camera crew's feet in the reflection of the bumper.
Gravitydefier where?
You can also see the camera's shadow on the actor in the long hallway shot when the blonde first escapes.
Jordon Foss damn it, just about to say that
donde esta?
And when the dr is talking to her old lady friend, at the start of the scene the phone wire is already moving, which only coulda happened after she picked up the phone at the end of the scene
"Did they all have fidget spinners or something to keep them occupied"
Welcome to 2017
AlyciArt It's been almost half a year lol
I actually had to get a fidget spinner to occupy myself in hospital it was so boring.
AlyciArt lol
AlyciArt I was just about to write that!
AlyciArt Thank god 2018
THANK YOU for pointing out that DID simply isn't dangerous and some quirky superpower
"Everything wrong with split in 16 personalities or less"
KABDKDV
I have so many problems with that website so this comment was probably the funniest part of my day
"Asian music can help digestion"
*Gee by Girls' Generation starts playing*
Growl by EXO slowly gets louder
**twice plays**
Patricia: Cheer up girls.
Blood, Sweat, and Tears blast through speakers
plays that damn flute from "Mask Off"
Jozie Charles :) Yea🔥😹🙏🏻🔥
After watching several Cinemasins videos. I will never look at these movies the same way again.
You profile name says font look at your pic but how could no one look
Same, also I looked at your profile. The fuck you gonna do about it.
This movie is a good movie
Don't Look At my Profil
Why are you commenting on every channel I watch you fuck?
This movie is a prime example of an actor, taking a "meh" script and making a watchable movie. Go McAvoy, for real
it would've been better for a lot of people that people know this movie is fiction, and none at all like reality.
In fact, I can say the protagonist is much more like a person with a dissociative disorder due to how much she is spacing out and she had a flashback. She seems to have her head constantly in the clouds.
Alters are usually supposed to protect the person that's experiencing the trauma/abuse, like a caretaker.
And if there are alters who hurt the body, it's because they are traumatized themselves.
But this movie is fictional. It's not what people are really like. It's rare that an alter would hurt you, unless you specifically attack them. Also, alters usually cannot act like other alters and for the descriptor of DID, you must have amnesia, but not everyone experiences amnesia between alters and thats whats called OSDD, other specified dissociative disorder.
really? nothing about the creepy fucking uncle??
Shandra Haggerty no, simply because this is a satire/comedic channel. including a pedophilic/rape scene as entertainment could be offensive to some and quite frankly disrespectful. he meant well leaving it out.
Well, actually, the review of Don't Breathe included the rape scene, although nothing was shown (neither was anything shown in this movie.) In both cases, that controversially dark element is actually a major plot point, and I agree with Shandra that it was strange to leave it out.
averythesuperhero the difference between the scene in don't breathe and split is the context in which Jeremy was able to utilize the sin. don't breathe reassures us there wasn't any physical contact involved and the blind man's twisted motive for kidnapping the girl wasn't for sexual gratification. split, on the other hand, there's no denying the movie implies the uncle does forcibly sexually assault his niece for the sole purpose of pleasure.
in other words I believe Jeremy couldn't come up with an appropriate way to sin the uncle without either coming off as too "jokey" or downplaying the seriousness of the scene by giving it less sins than it actually deserves.
He has addressed various instances such as this in a non-humorous way before. Like he presents them as an "im just saying" kind of way. He will just comment on how fucked something is and give it sins and move on, if that makes sense. And correct me if im wrong, but, is he not a father? I myself was really interested in his response to that side plot.
Billie Rydale I never thought Cinema Sins was so sensitive...
It's not just about killing virgins. He means by "untouched" that he's ridding the world of people who haven't suffered like he has. People who haven't been dealt a cruel hand in the world BY the world. And Casey's one of those people who has, so that's why she's spared because like he's suffered, she's suffered. Probably not as bad as he has, but they both have.
Probably not as bad? I think they made it pretty clear she was sexually abused.
+Holly T
It's subjective.
Yes
TP Licorice I didn't think a grown man telling a little girl to take all her clothes off to play animals was very subjective but hey...
Yes, but what I mean is she probably wasn't abused to the point that she has Multiple personalities like he does.
"That's pacist" okay mate now that's a sin I can appreciate
oh my god, this movie gets literally everything wrong about DID. it makes me wanna puke.
Yeah wtfff
the acting is good but its such a shit movie it represents DID so wrong
So, you’re telling me people with DID can’t climb walls with their superhuman strength?
Wait it got some things right
- human has it
-uh
"I don't know how you work with those people"
"What people?"
"Your patients!"
*That's pacist.*
😂😂😂😂😂
Pacist?
Alec Du Lac Usually he says racist even if it's actually sexist, homophobic, etc. So the fact he said "pacist", which isn't a real word, this time is a joke on the channel's running gag.
"I don't know how you work with those people"
"What people?"
"Oh, I duno doc. Mabey all of those web-designers who you, as a ID psychiatrist, have to deal with every day."
KillaBoy 28 i
Fr
"The girls' final moments of freedom are spend discovering the CinemaSins UA-cam channel for the first time." - Haha
ChannelX24 I literally read this as he said it! 😂
This right here is self-promotion done right my friend. I can just imagine Jeremy sitting there writing sins while watching and just instantly made the connection to his own channel when they said that.
Who's haha?
I would think he would remove a sin for that one.
ChannelX24 I liked this comment because A.. it's true and funny B..to give it an even 900
I have schizophrenia where I see multiple "realities" simultaneously and occasionally when under stress will "hear voices", but do not have multiple personalities. This movies was extremely interesting to me to imagine how hard it must be for people with the other end of the spectrum to deal with those voices when it is literally coming from their own selves instead of just being in their head.
Lmao i dont think serial killer portrayals romantacizing DID especially ones with superheroes are the best for that.
not everyone with DID cofronts (multiple identities being conscious at once), actually! I know multiple people diagnosed with it, and the amount that they are aware of the alters definitely varies person to person, some people might be very aware and can communicate between them, but some people just fully dissociate and lose stretches of time when one of their alters fronts! It's a lot more nuanced than media usually portrays.
Hope that helped a little!
None of this takes away from McAvoy's acting, which is extraordinary in this film. The plot is...what it is lol. That's what CinemaSins is for :-)
NO ONE CAUGHT THE CORNER OF THE SCREEN IN HER SHOULDER AT 3:17?! Major movie sin right there
Eagle eyes, and what the hell are you doing here 😂
Epic
mixiepixie7 why the fuck are you watching a video about a horror movie and you make doll videos lmao
Shen7272 innit lmao
@@squizzycupcakes3051 what?
This man talks about the lady saving emails from 4 years ago. I have unopened emails from 2011.
I got some from 05
I have an email box with THOUSANDS of unopened emails that go all the way back to 2004... because im too lazy to delete any emails that come in
i have unopened from 2007
I have unopened emails form 09
Nor to mention in that line of work I think it's the law that you have to keep that kinda stuff for some time or at least you would think it would be a good idea to hold on to any and all emails.
Having had an ex close friend who actually had DID (was diagnosed and everything), I found the movie incredibly distasteful. There’s some correct info but god I hate how Hollywood used the stigma around DID to portray people with it as crazy monsters- DID is an act of self preservation caused ~90% of the time by horrible childhood trauma.
Several times my friend was told “yeah I know about that, I saw the movie Split” so don’t any of ya’ll dare say that this movie isn’t contributing to the negative stigma around the disorder. It’s very much real
It’s Hollywood, and what do you expect Hollywood isn’t what it used to be, now it’s full of millennials with the same agenda as Neil Druckmann and Anita Sarkessian.
@@subjectalpha5652 hollywood was never how it used to be. Nothing but sick pervs
They should’ve just given his disorder a made up name cause they clearly took some liberties with how they portrayed it.
I mean honestly you're right but I have to say that this is a supernatural movie and anybody who leaves this movie with common sense would know this is not how people with actual DID act like they don't climb on walls or eat humans 😭
And I think people would realize that more if they watch the first movie in the series unbreakable.
And I think they know they got some information wrong with this but they switched it for more interesting purposes and I hope people don't try to use this movie for educational purposes also.
Like why would you use a supernatural movie to learn about disorders 😭💀.
And also this is based off a kidnapper / serial killer who had the DID
I don't know their name this is just what I've heard.
Me, someone with DID
List of things wrong with Split: Everything
I'm still salty
fucking preach. same
As a system, agreed.
I love this movie
Her sitting there doing absolutely nothing while a stranger sits in her car and is in the process of sedating and kidnapping everyone, AND the kidnapper not sedating the main girl straight away like the others, is the most frustrating, stupid and sinful scene in a movie in recent memory.
Not really. Being paralyzed due to fear is one of the most common things in existence.
RockSolitude like is she fucking stupid?
Yeah, I agree it was weird. But I think M. Night was trying to say that he couldn't see her because he was so focused on the other girls he had been stalking for weeks. That is also why she moves so slowly. She realizes this fact quickly and knows she can't draw attention to herself. AT least that is how I read the scene. Either that...or it's just dumb, haha.
Tyler Collins I think you literally put more thought than M night did during that scene.
Man, it's almost as if she lives under the roof of a sexual predator and could easily be the type to be intimidated by a new threat and initially freeze with fear......NAH, that can't be it, I'm clearly thinking too hard about this!
"So Dad was just fucking laid out in the middle of a crowded parking until he woke up, with no help?"
Yep. That's Philly for ya.
probably robbed before he woke up
King of Prussia isn't part of Philly. So he's much safer than in Philly.
You forgot the "can't find the correct key cliche"
I had a friend (technically a few and a non friend) who had multiple personalities, and the way the four would interact with each other wasn't unlike how a group of vastly different siblings would interact. There were times she would argue with nobody, people she'd call a best friend one day, then suddenly hate the next day, but it'd always come back to her being a friend to herself.
For anyone curious (because everyone who ever met her asks this) the personalities boiled down to:
- Sally, an extroverted and giddy fun lover, with a Southern accent, despite her being Canadian. Her caretaker was from the South, and matches the personality quite closely.
- Mary, a quiet and usually unhappy person. This occurred when she was suffering depression during highschool, now it just resides as her "sad" self.
- Fiona, an EXTREMELY aggressive and hot headed tomboy. Never got an answer as to where it came from.
- Charlie. Her "first" personality. After a very traumatic experience early in her life, she was stuck in shock for a while. She can sometimes go back into it if she gets really stressed. It's terrifying not only to her, but it scared me too. I only saw it happen once, and it took a few days before she could be snapped back out of it.
(By the way, Fiona was my non friend. She just resented everyone.)
Dang I thought you were going to take off a sin for the part where McAvoy cycles through the personalities, just amazing acting
He'd already taken off 2.5 sins for his acting.
I know right, one of my favorite parts/scenes, so cool.
DoubleOscar oh, you actually want Cinemasins to show some critical thinking...WHAAAAAT? That's impossible, he doesn't have that.
You not going to mention the fact that the Desktop also has a Battery life icon... When it is quite clearly a desktop.
It could be a docking station/display port setup
ONE SIN FO YOU! DING
windows 10 has a battery icon
hOLY SHIT ITS GRACE
DID is definitely real, but this movie is such a bad representation of it
Nothing against the acting tho. The acting was great. Just the way DID was portrayed. Yes some people make develop a violent alter, but that's not only rare, but the person typically goes to get serious help when that happens when that switch and find themselves in a violent act.
@@mimsy1765 and aren't most violent alters self-harming in those cases?
@@gamehero6816 yeah we are violent tords are selves but not others
And now I'm late and I know what you're talking about but anybody with common sense would not walk out this movie and think this is how people would the DID actually act...
I mean they think people really climb on walls and eat humans it's a supernatural movie and I think people would notice that if they watch the first one unbreakable and this is actually based off a person I think they were a kidnapper / serial killer who had DID...
But I don't have the idea myself so yeah I'm not trying to offend anybody I just have to say that
@@Kevin_Theadore1 speak for your self bud.
id love to watch your entire species burn i can count on maybe two hands how many people id actually save. the rest yall can burn.
i dont go around "game ending" you all because well frankly its to much of an inconvenience. and i dont have the resources to follow through.
My husband has DID it's not how everyone makes it seem. He's the nicest person on earth. It's not as media makes it seem . Its sad almost pathetic how they tame a rare condition and make it seem like this
Productions Rex i think i’m a system (i suspect OSDD) and it’s nothing like this movie. granted, i’m still young, but most of my alters aren’t violent whatsoever! they’re protectors, sure, but never violent. we all get along quite well, i’d say, and we communicate well. it’s like any household, but this one is in one body!
People with DID are far more likely to be re-traumatized than doing the traumatization.
thats because in this movie its more of a super power and not normal DID. its pretty damn obvious considering how this man was able to pick up a car because he was a different personality. im pretty sure nobody thinks this is how DID works
@@uncleruckus6261 Literally leave. You clearly haven't seen how movies like this affect us and you're being really fucking dismissive. Especially considering people have used media like this to stigmatize actual systems
At around 3:16 you can see the bottom right edge of the superimposed desktop screen clip into the woman's shoulder. Surprised the experts who edited the movie let that one slip. haha!
Tiffany Rizzo how tf did u see that 😂😂
Dang, good eye!
as soon as I saw that I started scrolling down to see if anyone else had
I didnt see it but now I will have a better eye. Thanks :D
Tiffany Rizzo sTHANK YOU !! I'm not the only one who saw it
That explains why Charles Xavier is enemies and allies with Magneto now and then.
Stamatis Zygas No he's just impersonating his son
I decided to read a book about D.I.D. after seeing this movie (because overthinking things is how I enjoy them) and it was surprisingly accurate in some ways. In real cases of D.I.D. some alternate personalities share co-cognizance (meaning that they can access each other's memories and even be aware at the same time); this explains why Kevin's personalities are aware of each other and members of the Horde all have the same information while personalities who aren't in the Horde are kept at least partially in the dark about their activities. The personalities having conversations with each other is also kind of accurate except that those conversations should be taking place inside Kevin's head. People with D.I.D. often get mistaken for schizophrenics because they report hearing voices (usually arguing with each other or commenting on their behavior) with the difference being that a person with schizophrenia usually perceives the voices as coming from outside of themselves while people with D.I.D. are aware that the voices are actually just in their own heads. They usually go through their early lives thinking that this is normal and don't realize until adulthood that not everyone's mind works that way. The video diaries also make sense because people with D.I.D. can experience time skips (like getting blackout drunk except no alcohol is required) so they usually get in the habit of recording their daily activities. It was CLEARLY included in the movie just t provide exposition but I didn't think it was such a terrible way of doing that. Obviously, the films main issue is its depiction of people with D.I.D. as being violent but that's the same issue that all films with mentally ill antagonists have and in this instance, it could at least be excused by the fact that Kevin is also some sort of metahuman and not JUST a guy with D.I.D. Can't argue with any of your other criticisms but I still love this movie. Good acting excuses a multitude of sins.
For anyone who bothered to read this far, here's a clown: =0)
you're delusional
Hedwig is my fav character. And I like his name because I'm a harry potter fan.
The guy who played Kevin is an AMAZING actor! Usually an actor takes on one role for a movie, but he played several different people in one!
Like Noomi Rapace´s payling 7 characters in "what happened to Monday?" it´s amazing
you should watch orphan black
Uhhh Eddie Murphy in doctor do little amd every movie with a twin thats not olaued with a twin
He's James mother fuckin McAvoy. Yes an amazing actor lol
Playing 7 different characters in one movie is about the same as playing 7 different characters across 7 different movies.
Im sinning you for brining up fidget spinners
Dead Chris I'm sinning you for your spelling
1Brick2Brick3 ik :(
I'm sinning you for bringing up sins.
Saunterblugget Hampterfuppinshire this whole channel is about sins
Dead Chris
*ding*
10:34 Tulane is a college in New Orleans, it isn't made up
I think it was a joke on how Tulane is just a huge party school, and therefore isn"t a real university
If CinemaSins thinks Tulane University is "made up" then they obviously didn't put much effort into fact-checking any of this.
True! But I did notice that her Master of Psychology degree was conferred by Tulane's School of Political Science for some reason (and it's spelled Scineces on the diploma as well).
What was with Shyamalan's obsession with the legs of the women in this movie? There were a couple of lengthy shots where the camera leered up the skirts of almost every female member of the cast...even the old lady!
The Dashboard upskirt fetish much
The Dashboard I don't mind
Nothing wrong with liking a woman's fine legs.
is anyone complaining?
He's indian. Let that answer it for you.
Yes, DID personalities are often aware of each other.
ONE SIN OFF!
Tulane University is an actual University
ONE SIN OFF!
@@Jeanpetit0930 Hey, someone who does their research, nice! :D
@@starkiller6558 *bows gracefully*
Huh, I vaguely remember reading about that.
It can't even be definitively proven as a real disorder, so no.
*1 second of logos*
CinemaSins: Thats a sin. *DING*
That Gee, Gee song at the end made my day
YOU MISSED A SIN! In the parking lot scene, when they are all at the trunk, you can see the entire camera crew's feet in the reflection of the bumper.
Edit: Follow me for memes
Nightcore Adapt where ??
I think he means at 0:50? kind of a stretch...
I think its visible in the actual movie, but the clip isn't shown in this CinemaSins video.
Toland Beyond d
Nightcore Adapt 300th like
Also, for Dennis to get out of the parking spot he would've had to pull out over the dad and run him over
that was aggravating. After that scene I thought the dad was in the trunk, and then the news bite said he survived and I was like WTF Shyamalan. Like, he's totally capable of kidnapping, attempted rape, murder and cannibalism, but killing the dad is beyond his sense of morals??
That moment you realize that CinemaSins is only as big as they are because people don’t want to pay for movies
Or because we love overrated movies like Split being called out for all their inconsistencies and plot holes
Kit split isn’t overrated at alllll
@@kit4796 he cherrypicks and his jokes are bad. I didn't watch him in a long time and decided to eatch him again, but he's trying too hard to be funny.
Actually, that’s not why I watch it. It’s a lighthearted humor channel that makes fun of movies. Please don’t be disrespectful and make blanket statements! There are people out there with other opinions 😅
@@leobe2104 agree the early stuff was better but whatever
5:13 I fucking love this sin. "The biggest grain of salt ever created" I love it. As someone with DID, this made me laugh so fuckin hard
my favorite sins ever:
- Prometheus School
- Discount known actor
- "You didn't hear that"
- all clichés
- every Whilhelm jokes
- "They survive this"
- We interrupt to bring you..
- Narration stuff
- when a character is a "dick to"
- Roll credits
- Private jokes about actors (like Liam Neeson not killing, Sean Bean not dying)
- Convenient / Inconvenient for the plot
- "Just in case you're confused with"
- Meanwhile in a different movie
What are your favorite ones ?
"ex machina"
"scene doesn't contain a lapdance"
CORALINE PARMENTIER, pianiste Ex machina
CORALINE PARMENTIER, pianiste "Let's talk about (character)'s plan"
GoshDarnBarnOwls Yeah I totally forgot those two ✌ haha
CORALINE PARMENTIER, pianiste "that's racist"
@CinemaSins to answer you question @4:37 "How does Dennis know how to act like Barry?" He has video journals to refer to for each personality. Recount Sins: 106.5
Jonathan Bernardo Good point, I forgot about that.
This time you beat Cinema sins in their own game..
Each personality knew each other. Hedwig mentioned that with the chairs and the light.
He missed the bumper car showing the camera crew so back up c;
Jonathan Bernardo if we're going semi-realistic, alters can have some memories from other alters. Like sort of leaking through, almost. And some alters, especially gatekeepers, managers, etc, often can see memories other alters hold. Alters being able to act like the host(s) (assuming Barry's a host) is also not uncommon. DID tries to hide itself, so to speak. Otherwise, the abused person could be putting themselves in more danger.
It's crazy how James Mcavoy can switch voices so quick and easily. GOOD JOB JAMES!!!!!!
13:32
I literally just watched Glass with my family and you are absolutely right.
Fletcher- "Have these individuals, through their suffering, unlocked, the potential of the brain?"
Jeremy- "No..."
Me- XD
ECKS DEEEE LMAOOO HUEHUEHUEHUE SO FUNI
Sin on you guys for skipping McAvoys amazing transformation from one personality to another in one frame.
He flipped back and forth through more than one. He made me an instant fan. He's got chops
Did we watch the same video? He actually took sins off for McAvoys performance.
He also added sins due to the implausibility of being able to change clothes within the short time frames.
In CinemaSins that's a standing ovation.
1:02 *The girl has a crush on you and you count that as a SIN*
Lesson learned - "Dont be a virgin or else you'll get eaten by a supernatural, multi-personality cannibal."
Stormy Sky it’s not the fact of being a virgin or not. This is all very obvious to me..... He saw her scares. He realised she has some hard shit to deal with so she’s damaged.... like he is.
@@MarceyCarmichael but he wants to get rid of all the "untouched"
Stormy Sky but maybe his meaning of “untouched” isn’t what your thinking.
@@MarceyCarmichael maybe but also the way he used it in the video he thought of it as well as being a virgin
Stormy Sky Idk for sure what his meaning was. He had so many different personalities so who really knows. All I do know is when he saw the girls scars (obviously from her cutting herself) he realised she was just like him and didn’t need “to be shown” because she already knew pain. But hey.... the beauty of people is that we all see things and interpret things differently. If we were all the same, it’d be a pretty boring world huh 😊
"The girls final moments of freedom are spent discovering the Cinema Sins youtube channel for the first time".
.. this guy lol
C'mon no sins off for the soundtrack? That opening piece during the credits with the distorted cords was creepy as hell, and awesome!
I agree.
IKR, the track when Dennis became the Beast and the girls were trying to escape was amazing, especially hearing it in the theater.
ddable it’s almost like they use there own opinions to write the sins
What about the DVD menu?? It was so peaceful
No, the sin is that M. Night didn’t get James Newton Howard to score this one.
It's the terror that kept her in the car. She had her pinky on the lock and everything but fear is paralyzing.
I honestly didn't understand when descriptions in books would say things like, "Her hands were bound. But even if they weren't, she still wouldn't be able to move."
The fight or flight response aren't your only choices and freezing in situations like that is common.
I like the fact that he doesn’t actually mention anything important to the movie
Ive heard very split reviews about this movie!!
It's funny because it's actually true.
Jokes aside, me too, not even kidding. Some friends said it's amazing, and others say the whole supernatural aspect ruined it.
That's my thoughts on it, idk why people didn't like that about it.
TSTO Talk I fell off of my bed reading that Cuz I'm tired.
Ba Dum Chhh
3:30 The monitor screen is overlapping the therapist's arm, whoops
Good catch!
get this to the top ^ they dont usually miss these i dont think lol
no lie
Sean Palmer this
Why the fuck would they even use CGI for a monitor? smh
It makes me happy that the cinema wins video is longer than the cinema sins vid
The narrator acknowledging that it is rare to be diagnosed, makes me happy. I am clinically diagnosed with DID and it’s frustrating when people say that they diagnosed themselves.
You'd think that somebody would notice a random man passed out for over a half of a hour in a parking lot in Philly and help how but My experiences tell me otherwise.
James McAvoy is an amazing actor, i dont care what anyone says.. for me being an aspiring actor its gotta be tough as shit playing 20 somethin different characters in one... and doing it well
23 characters. But in the movie there were about 5 personalities that were focused on and the rest are on videos in the computer. Actor was very good, but the director pure bullshit.
Hannibal Rising )
Hannibal Rising yea i wish there could have been more screentime for a few of the other personalities instead of just showing 30 second clips of them on computers
I'd imagine most actors could easily do 20 different characters given the right words on the script, since most actors play different characters anyhow. Besides, movie editing does most of the work here.
Now, if we saw these transitions on stage, that would be a bit more impressive.
I don't think most actors could do it. Many actors take time to get into character and switching, convincingly, from one to another from one scene to the next is very hard to do. I agree that it would be more impressive on stage but that doesn't mean that just any actor could do it on the screen, hell you can find movies where some actors can't even do ONE character convincingly throughout an entire movie.
I love this movie so much!!! Thank you CinemaSins, anyway
I laughed so hard at this vid and your opinions. Hilarious! Keep it up!
7:35: So when he's being the 9 year old, can't the girls just beat him up or something or does he keep his adult strength?
John Doe he could call Dennis back
U cant beat up a guy with a nine year old brain, that's just sick
Jareth The Goblin King it’s also sick that he kidnapped three girls and keeping them in his underground room.
Dennis and Patricia were more involved with that
His lack of strength is shown when the girls are holding the door shut and Hedwig can't push it open but Dennis can
Unable to connect to the Internet when you have full WIFI bars and no errors? YES! Mine does that shit all the FKing time! End rant. Continue.
Theory: he disconnects his internet cable at the router but doesn't shut down the router. Devices would still have network connection but no internet.
ZesPak Yes but on standard operating systems it will display a warning sign next to the signal strength, stating that you have no internet connection.
I've got news for you.... you have a virus.
Your network traffic is being re-directed through a proxy server so that people can monitor your network traffic and steal your personal information.
This server is experiencing problems directing your traffic correctly, which leads to unexplained and intermittent failures, such as failing to load one web page, while loading another just fine. These errors are usually related to authentication problems, because the proxy server is probably in a different time zone.
Or not. Who knows? It's a mystery.
You 👏 guys 👏 need 👏 to 👏 do 👏 Glass 👏
When dennis got in the car, he was expecting only 2 girls to be there. He was spying on the two girls for three or four days before kidnapping them, so he didn’t expect there to be a third person in the front seat.
you would still SEEEEEEEEEEEEEE them....