I honestly feel so sorry for Soojin especially because she stood up for herself others came out with their story confirming that Soojin didn’t do anything..
@@Kpopcloud3 I’m so mad at cube as well ESPECIALLY because after it was announced Soojin is leaving the actor/idol who accused Soojin of bullying her, later on she said that she’s not sure if it was Soojin who bullied her.
It’s interesting how both Garam and Soojin were accused of bullying but were then said to be the ones getting bullied. I don’t know about other cases, but I wonder if it’s the same for anyone else. I’m inclined to believe that the bullies, now jealous, are out to get them and ruin their careers. I was bullied in school too and I would never tell their bosses and publicise it in an attempt to ruin their lives. Maybe it’s just me, but I’d much rather have the bully gone from my life than go through a battle like the accusers have. I really wish Soojin would come back though. She really was amazing
From what I have gotten from the friend the person who complained was the older sister and the younger sister and SSJ was part of a certain group in 7th grade and Soojin drifted away from them in 8th grade. The younger sister was still part of the said group and they started outing Soojin after that since she stopped hanging out with them. Which means that they started bullying her. Then came the issue where she was called to report or something and her mom came rushing because she was told that something happened to Soojin. Soojin was actually the victim in that issue and not the perpetrator. Which debunks what SSA said about Soojin bullying her. Also SSA was friends with that younger sister.
soojins was bullied from the other guys,that's doesn't prove she never bullied someone ,and no one ruin her lives,soojin's job was an idol, her bad image makes her couldn't do her job ,especially staying in a group, that's all, she could become a solo, a dancer, a tiktoker etc, she got lots of fans oversea, her life is not ruined by anyone but herself
@@shyesimnxde3207 the so called “victim” literally came out and said it wasn’t soojin on top of that it was even confirmed she wasn’t even the bully just say you’re an anti and go
It’s a common bullying tactic, actually. To accuse your victim of bullying you first. I imagine the accusers must be very jealous to see the success of the other person, and jealous people will often go to extremes to take down the person they are jealous of.
There is one other famous case, with the group AOA where a group member (Mina) accused another member (Jimin) of bullying her troughout their many years of AOA's carieer. Jimin got unspeakable amount of hate for it but it was later revealed that it was most likely the other way round; the accuser (Mina) was the one who was bullying Jimin. And no I don't think it's only you, I think it seems more common for the people who are bullied to forgive or try to forget and move on rather than try to get revenge or apology. Logically speaking why wanna try involving yourself with the bully again when they're not in your life anymore? I could be wrong but so many bullying accusations seem to point at the theory that the bullies are actually the ones who get jealous and try ruining the lives and carieers of their victims once more. This is why I dislike the cancel culture so much, because so many innocents have fallen to the false accusations of bullies, with help of the cancel culture mob. Even if they prove they're not guilty the deeper damage has already been done and many people are still gonna remember the victims as being the "bullies"
I think one of the biggest reasons they were able to stay afloat comes down to their leader. Don't get me wrong, the efforts of the entire group to continue to put on fierce performances despite all they went through of course had a huge part to play in their success. But with Soyeon's extensive talents for writing and producing music, she continued to make hits for them that were not only tailored to the individual members (ensuring that no one was left with an extra part or one that didn't suit their voice types), but also a variety of songs and styles that just fit their brand. The sound and aesthetic are always something new for the audience which keeps them interested, but are still close enough to the vibes that G-IDLE has always maintained that when you hear it, you know that's a G-IDLE song. Other groups might not have survived without a leader like her or a company that had already invested so much they weren't going to falter and let the group die- MONSTA X is an example of this. They have great producers within the group, but Starship had already begun a huge international campaign to push them, so there was no way they would allow the group to burn out. In G-IDLE's case, I think it really came down to the members (especially Soyeon) to pull the team out of the wreckage, especially when you consider that CUBE had/has other upcoming groups that they could have shifted focus towards if it became clear that G-IDLE was not salvageable.
Not to mention they were able to use the scandal to their advantage - don’t get me wrong it’s absolutely HORRIBLE what happened to soojin and 6idle. But they were smart with how they went about it. Their marketing strategy was out of this world. Not to mention they really fed into the narrative of “what was going to happen to them” and used the scandal/drama as momentum to help skyrocket their career to where it is. Truly genius. However I still miss ot6 idle dearly. Doesn’t feel the same - but regardless I’m still extremely proud of their success - I just wish that they all could’ve made it there together
100%. Her leadership is so admirable. The thing about Soyeon is that she's HUNGRY. I'm talking like, anime protagonist hungry. She's always looking for ways for her and her group to not only rise and go to the next level, but in the most impactful and meaningful way as possible. She certainly has her worries and doubts but at the end of the day she wants her team to win in the best way possible and absolutely be on top. She loves proving people wrong. I read somewhere on twitter that during a fan call, a fan told her that the concept photos of Nxde were badly received initially but then everyone loved it after Nxde got released, and the fan asked Soyeon if this was her plan. Soyeon said it was all planned and she actually expected to be criticized and cursed for the entire week. The fan asked if she was afraid of the hate, and Soyeon said something like what they did wasn't wrong, so she wasn't concerned at all. I think she has such strong beliefs and ambitions--really, her drive is the fire of IDLE.
... and Soyeon job as leader only gets more difficult from recent successes. The increased popularity from the success of Nxde and iLove will bring increased scrutiny and criticisms. Shuhua is now brimming with confidence and popularity and we know how blunt she can be with critics. Luckily Shuhua has Soyeon, Yuqi, Minnie, and Miyeon there to guide her as she comes into full blossom.
Well Soyeon was part of it and so is the others MIYEON was the First Member to face the Public during the scandal cuz shes the mc of mncd and gossip idle, Shuhua went back to her country promoting same with Minnie and Yuqi in their respective country and Soyeon Also released her 2nd solo album and also being such a good mentor in a TV show…
@@STAN_LOONA Not STAN LOONIES speaking lol.......yes, it was iconic asff with the album 'I Never Die' they rose from the ashes and achieved PAK 167 times, you can't name any comeback more iconic than this....
I will never ever forgive what those people did to Soojin especially SSA... Just because her career is dying, she immediately jumped into the hate bandwagon and destroyed a flourishing career of somebody else!
I love (G)i-dle 💜 I hate soojin is gone 😢 I love their idc attitude and their style as a group.. I hope she comes back even as a solo artist if she can't be back in the group 😪 ❤
That one actress was the nail in the coffin, I also read that the actress never heard soojin directly smack talk and that she heard it from her friends that heard it from other people...like wtf
whenever I watch them I feel Soojins presence :) They will always be together for me, cause of how many things the girls adopted and learned from her over the years. Especially Shuhua who cooked Miso soup for the girls on their trip (which she learned from Soojin cause she always cooked it for her)
I start guessing which parts of the song would be Soojin's. Some of those parts still feel like they were made with her in mind. I was never this upset over someone leaving a group since Minzy left 2ne1. Really showed me how much I loved G-idle back then.
I’m not here to compare which idol deserves better and which agency dealt with their respective talents’ bullying scandals until it was done and dusted, I’m just here to state that whatever Soojin decides to do next, all we need to do is respect whatever that decision may be. The most important thing is that she is happy. We can adore Soojin the idol, but we must also consider the feelings of Seo Soojin the human being, the woman. If she wants to continue pursuing a singing or dancing career as a soloist, or an acting career, great. If she decides retire from the Kpop industry amd live like all of us, it’ll be a shame, but we just gotta respect her decision. One thing that will never change is the remaining members will never cast Soojin aside.
@@shyesimnxde3207Saying she's not necessary to the group when she's one of the reasons why (G)i-dle gained support when they debuted is ridiculous. You can't downplay someone's contribution to the group and the members just like that. It's really obvious that you're a new nevie.
It feels like company did not even bother to protect soojin they just kick her out and did not even clarify everything i felt really sad she deserve better i hope she come back as a solo bcz i really want to see her on stage again and i hope she doing well
well you gotta remember this is the same company that kicked hyuna and dawn because they announced they were dating when the company lied that they weren't
I don't believe the rumors were true and I think it's already been proven that Soojin is innocent but even if it was true, while bullying is extremely wrong, I don't understand the logic behind someone's career as an adult being ruined over something they did when they were 13/14 years old. Not only was that a child making a mistake, we are not who we were as children. I'm just glad that Soojin is back as a solo artist and that the girls have never forgotten her and keep incorporating Soojin in small aspects of their work (the cartoon in Nxde having a mole under her eye and being heavily inspired by Soojin's idol; multiple songs about Soojin; and more recently "Revenge"'s mv directly referencing Soojin's birthday). The girls haven't forgotten about her and neither have fans. Idk if we can hope for Soojin to join the group again after their contract is up in a year but I wish that we will at least get some interactions when they're no longer forbidden to interact in public.
Actually, true. She is the famous one and the leader. They actually became more famous after the scandal. No offense to fans but the group really thrives at their peak. Actually, there are some groups who really thrived after a scandal and this is why some fans accuse agencies promoting groups or new groups using a scandal.. 😅 not saying it’s a particular group but it happened a lot of times. Maybe Kokielit can make a video on who actually thrived after the scandal or who regained fame, or groups/agencies accused of using scandal as a marketing strategy to promote the groups. Anyway, I agree with you. As long as Soyeon is there, G-idke will thrive.
Very true. Some people call her problematic and stuff but they can't ignore the fact that Soyeon is really smart and talanted. She does her best for G-idle no matter what
@@rookie_s Kprofile votes are mostly from their debut era that's why..Soyeon was obviously the most popular at the time..now u can see it clearly especially by the fancam views..right now it was shuhua at the last spot in kprofile and soyeon is third but Shuhua has the most fancam views now
This made me cry having flashback to that horrible year we lost our precious soojin. I pray she is happy and living a peaceful life. She deserved better. Proud of all of these 6 women as a neverland!
They're making great job and they're really successful. Tomboy and nxde is doing great. It's so sad how an anonymous person can make up a story and these idols still will get canceled and all their effort and training for years go to waste. Of course not everyone is good ppl but that doesn't mean all of them are bad either and it's because of some anti's jealousy most of the time. And because same thing happened to Lucas, I'm really worried for his career. I just can't imagine NCT without him.
@@cmartinez2998 hopefully when IDLE’s contracts expire they cna get the royalties and ownership over their group name and songs and get Soojin back in the group
They were the strongest group i've known. Losing a popular member must have been really stressful but they managed to break through the nightmares and became even popular. Soyeon is really amazing. And for soojin, I congratulate her successful debut. I wish all of them the best :)
CUBE kicked out Hyuna!HYUNA!!! of all people she was keeping the lights on at CUBE are we even suprised at this? CUBE is literally the worst at managing the idols
I still enjoy their music but the group hasn’t been the same to me since Soojin left so I don’t keep up w/ them like I used to. I hope she’ll be back as a soloist one day.
Same till now I’m come and couldn’t stop thinking about how the group could been 6 members and soojin could slay this comeback and how the soojin could been on knowing bro with the group. You can’t tell me that is not really sad when that is supposed to be your forever members
Not really my friends were not intrested in them but after tomboy they staned them i guess they made stronger songs to save thier career thats why more people stans them more
I will never forgive CUBE for what they’ve done to Soojin and (G)I-DLE. Soojin was proven innocent but they still kicked her out. CUBE now just expects for the girls to just forget Soojin and to only worry about their current members. They’re friendships with Soojin were so sweet but CUBE ruined it. Screw you CUBE
I feel bad for soojin and the rest of the members. This should not be normal for idols to be accused of scandals. I know soojin would never smoke or do anything something so out of line. And what made it worse was that a actress decided to step in and also accused her of such scandals. The after math of all of the (G) Idle and soojin scandals led to soojin depart from cube entertainment, and left not only me but many other people in shock of the end. I feel so bad for soojin
she did smoke at the age of 12 lol,she was a bad behaves girl back then, can't believe a 12 years old smoking drinking and cursing ,when I was 12 years old I was wearing cartoon t-shirt fooling around
Bruhh, i think gidle really came back stronger. Their popularity now is not joke in sk. Nxde is their latest hit after tomboy where tomboy gets 167 paks and nxde gets 70+ paks (still counting). Gidle is on the right track🔥
I hate that when allegations like this happen, the conclusion is usually the same, that a member leaves because they don't want to bring harm to the group any longer, even if they are innocent. And I applaud them for doing so, for not being selfish and thinking of everyone else instead, but a lot of the times there ends up being no conclusive evidence to anything and they end up leaving without the truth ever coming to light. I wish idols and companies would be more willing to wait til all the investigating is done before making a huge decision on removing someone from the group. And I wish fans would wait for the evidence to come out before jumping to conclusions and taking sides. There are always three sides to every story, the first person, the second person, and the actual truth.
I still remember when in nxde they put this cartoon character which had a mole under its eye like Soojin. I still remember how in a transition in nxde they put a balloon “I never die”. I still remember how in the end of tomboy there were a lot of red heart balloons. I still *and will* remember how filthy cube is.
If u know CUBE actually forced they’re idols to starve themselves and whoever’s over the weight limit they would put it on the board and get embarrassed by seniors etc. Also theyre debut was delayed until SOYEON decided to step in. SOYEON and SOOJIN did the choreography while SOYEON wrote, (G)I-DLE was alone, CUBE didn’t even help them out on theyre debut. And SOYEON was in charge of directing the music videos’ CUBE is so cruel. You can search up something like” what did CUBE do to (G)I-DLE” “(G)I-DLE exposing CUBE”. I agree, CUBE is filthy.
That whole February bullying fiasco felt way too convenient. It’s like hundreds of people came together to start a witch hunt to see how many famous people’s careers they could destroy. Legitimate reasons or not, it felt very cruel and unusual
for fook sake, people change after middle school-high school ;______; WE ALL GROW UPPPPPPP, she didnt deserve to be kicked out of the band becouse of that. 80% of famous people were/are terrible poeple in real life and they live on their fancy life without their careers being ruined. I will always fight for my girl S.
@@rookie_s she is she's back to school and her friends talked that she's fine Now even if she's a bully people shouldn't react this way until things confirmed however bullying is a senstive topic in south Korea since its something very seen oftenly in schools the biggest problem is the one who got bullied might be accused as a bully just because they choosed to stay silent and move on.. I hope trainees who want to debut before they might move on they better fix the old problems because bullies won't let them successeed
(6)I-DLE forever!!!! But I can imagine that Soojin is maybe traumatized and doesn’t want to come back to the kpop industry…. I wish her and (G)I-dle the best
Seo Shin Ae is actually a devil 🥺 She destroyed Soojin for no reason and just kept silent when the truth was revealed. Is that fair for our Soojin, she was nice, and kind, and cared about everyone she met, then after all that’s what she received. 😢😢 after 3 years I still can’t believe what I have seen at that time. Totally a drama in real life, the liar totally lead the social media and no one cares about the unreasonable points in each story.
A very strong fandom, them creating a niche for themselves in the industry and owning it and most importantly, a general public that moves to the next topic very fast. I've noticed this with both IDLE and LE SSERAFIM.
Is is an amazing idol who deserved a whole lot more. She had such a bright future ahead but some people can't see her growing and put they everything to pull her down and the saddest part is they succeeded. I hate cube already for not doing good to Hyuna and dawn as well as CLC, but soojin throwing soojin out of group was my last straw.
just finished watching this and i'm about to cry again just like i did on august 14, 2021 when that news came out :'( i miss her so much, so i managed to fit her name into the heart on the 'I love' album cover and i'll leave the link to it once i figure out how to do that jo mi-yeon nicha yontararak (minnie) seo soo-jin jeon so-yeon song yu qi ye shu hua (G)I-DLE IS 6 #give_shuhua_her_soojin_unnie_back
I think Soyeon's allegations got disproven like days after the posts as people quickly pointed out the timelines the accuser was giving didn't line up with Soyeon's. Also, not sure if this is true or not, but I read somewhere that Soyeon was homeschooled through most of her childhood, and when she did go to high school, she only had a few friends because most of her time was spent in Idol training. I can't remember where I read that, so take that with a grain of salt.
Both CUBE and HYBE are to blame here, they literally allowed the real bullies to win and destroyed innocent people's hard work. I really wish there was a poetic justice but sadly what you learn from life is, bad people win most of the time. Best you can do is to be ready for it and adapt as fast as you can. If you sink low and don't fight back they only get worse. Best of luck and strength to Soojin and Garam. I learned all of these things much later but my heart will always be with them.
I will never forgive this actress named Seo Shin Ae and her friends for simply destroying a persons life. They made the situation worse which gained public attention.
I’ve said this before and i’ll say it again, Canceling adults and ruining their careers for something stupid they might’ve done or not when they were literal children is probably the dumbest most awful thing kpop stans learned to do.
I'm happy for them this year , I'm so sad cuz Soojin dream gone n how she face the hate for a year.. I miss her but i just want PEOPLE who make Soojin n IDLE cry + through the hard time cuz their statments or comments admit his mistakes IF IF they have guility feeling altghouh just a little bit, they should say sorry as personal to Soojin n IDLE members
What I find ridiculous is our society jumping on the hate bandwagon. So many people were saying horrible things about her(even garam) just cuz of those bullying allegations....is it fine for people to say horrible things just because "she's a bully". People know now that these allegations have huge holes/inconsistencies. People do change! Why can't you sit back and wait for a verdict instead of sending hate to kick people out. Garam had some of the worst hate tweets I was so disgusted. She's a 16yo child where is your humanity
Like isn't it normal to get into fight during school? It's not ideal but it happens. I feel like everyone goes through times like these. It's a shame that she has been kicked out
tru, especially since it was years ago :(. toxic fans pretend as if they’ve never gotten into a fight before. idk why ppl have to be hung up on these rumors, real or not.
@@llucieyy yes, people nowadays think they are "unproblematic". There will be times where you say or do stuff which you will regret, but it's essential to grow. That makes me sad. Maybe someday soojin can come back 🫰
Honestly, SSA did a horrible thing to Soojin considering that she's not that sure if SJ is really a part of the group that she was blaming for bullying. Like, don't give any statements if you are NOT sure about anything and just accusing. She can't blame Idle Fans for being frustrated with this and for now tormenting her because of what she did, for someone who supports the victim of bullying, this is a very wrong move for her.
I have a small hope that Soyeon is gonna get super rich because she makes all of gidle's songs and will make her own company after their contract with cube is over and have Soojin re-join gidle then.
I'm gonna say it, flame me if you want, idgaf. This Seo Shin Ae is a damn ish for making crap up about Soojin. She should have had a consequence for false reporting. It sounded like Soe Shin Ae was/is jealous of Soojin and wanted to see her fail.
Can we talk abt seo shin ae right now she literally fueled the fire here and if I'm not wrong after soojin was declared not in fault ssa said she doesn't remember properly if it was soojin like tf huh you literally ruined her career how would she feel if it was her 😑
no her english is not good, she means she was not sure soojin got kicked out from the ganster group,ssa is sure that soojin did bullied her,she said that at the other dm measage ,soojins fans are twisting ssa words try to made up "innocent evidence " for soojin
Cube Entertainment should have just paid off her victims at the outset like JYP did for ITZY's Lia's bullying victims. Give them enough money to make them never mention it ever again and the problem disappears.
coz soojin doesn't worth it, tomboy and nxde success already prove that soojin is not necessary to the group,idle is doing even better without her(double perfect all kill)
Lol cube handling things right is like hoping someday the clouds will rain diamonds. Other kpop idols from JYP were also accused (someone form I boygroup but can't remember who and which bg) and they simply met up and apologized, problem solved. Cube's management seems to have given the worst advice to Soojin, who insisted on not apologizing..
OK how is she not allowed back now that's its over and it was bs. She deserves an apology from all of the people that gave her slack especially Cube. I mean over some bullying in middle school!? Some of the dumbest crap I have ever heard to cxl her. All I can think is she wants no part of Cube anymore. Especially when they just cut ties and really did nothing to defend her. I know I wouldnt. I love Gidle but Cube has left a stain on themselves Imo.
If companies just ignored hearsay accusations that took place before their idols were even apart of their company. And continued to make hit music. The shit would just blow over and they would still flourish. Especially a group like Gidle. They’re to strong. It would take way more than that for the fans to turn on them. I thibk it was more likely people lost interest in the group by getting rid of soojin. Cube probably wanted to see gidle fail. Soyeon too talented though. She wasn’t going to let that happen.
Seo Shin Ae committed career suicide by accusing SooJin. I will never watch (boycott) anything that Seo Shin Ae may be in. She seems to be inactive anyway. Hasn’t done much of anything since 2017.
im not sure I understand how they can make someone leave their group for allegations of bullying from years ago. In western culture, this would barely make a bleep and be quickly dismissed.
Not a fan but wth is wrong with these ‘former’ classmates? Lol why stuck yourselves in the past? Move on! These ‘idols’ have lives before they were even artists. They’re just normal people before they became idols. They’re not perfect.
Honestly idle is the real leader of 4th gen ggs they survived such a scandal and didn't fall out unlike many other ggs they were and are big and it seems nothing can really break them
i hope that Miss Soojin is doing great. its always heartbreaking to see the girls missing her, but at least they all have purple hearts on their Instagram accounts to show some love for Soojin:(
What has the past done with the people's current situation? In fact, it was during their elementary and high school days, wherein we tend to do unnecessary and stupid acts as a kid and teenagers. What's the big deal?
And yet, the inquiry into the unsubstantiated accusations against Soojin revealed that Soojin herself was a victim of School B***ying. SSA later admitted to not knowing if Soojin was actually a member of the group that b***ied her. No retraction, nothing. Karma is a wonderful thing. The only proper outcome to this is, Soojin's reinstatement to her group and apologies from the CEO of Cube Entertainment and Seo Shin-ae. #Alwayswithsoojin
no her english is not good, she means she was not sure soojin got kicked out from the ganster group,ssa is sure that soojin did bullied her,she said that at the other dm measage ,soojins fans are twisting ssa words try to made up "innocent evidence " for soojin and soojin got bullied from the others doesn't mean she never bullied, soojin got bad behaves at middle school, that's a fact
![[Knowing Bros] "Finding an Anti-Fan!"🤔 (G)I-DLE's Funniest Game Highlight🥰🤣](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/iXh17OladaE/mqdefault.jpg)
I honestly feel so sorry for Soojin especially because she stood up for herself others came out with their story confirming that Soojin didn’t do anything..
ikr the company shouldve done more .... i miss soojinnnn😭
@@Kpopcloud3 I’m so mad at cube as well ESPECIALLY because after it was announced Soojin is leaving the actor/idol who accused Soojin of bullying her, later on she said that she’s not sure if it was Soojin who bullied her.
@@monochyuu who remembers when there were rumors saying cube didn't file anything after two months of soojin being in hiatus
Soojin is innocent TT
@@alexoy2k I didn’t know about that but somehow it wouldn’t surprise me, honestly
It’s interesting how both Garam and Soojin were accused of bullying but were then said to be the ones getting bullied. I don’t know about other cases, but I wonder if it’s the same for anyone else. I’m inclined to believe that the bullies, now jealous, are out to get them and ruin their careers. I was bullied in school too and I would never tell their bosses and publicise it in an attempt to ruin their lives. Maybe it’s just me, but I’d much rather have the bully gone from my life than go through a battle like the accusers have. I really wish Soojin would come back though. She really was amazing
From what I have gotten from the friend the person who complained was the older sister and the younger sister and SSJ was part of a certain group in 7th grade and Soojin drifted away from them in 8th grade. The younger sister was still part of the said group and they started outing Soojin after that since she stopped hanging out with them. Which means that they started bullying her.
Then came the issue where she was called to report or something and her mom came rushing because she was told that something happened to Soojin. Soojin was actually the victim in that issue and not the perpetrator. Which debunks what SSA said about Soojin bullying her. Also SSA was friends with that younger sister.
soojins was bullied from the other guys,that's doesn't prove she never bullied someone ,and no one ruin her lives,soojin's job was an idol, her bad image makes her couldn't do her job ,especially staying in a group, that's all, she could become a solo, a dancer, a tiktoker etc, she got lots of fans oversea, her life is not ruined by anyone but herself
@@shyesimnxde3207 the so called “victim” literally came out and said it wasn’t soojin on top of that it was even confirmed she wasn’t even the bully just say you’re an anti and go
It’s a common bullying tactic, actually. To accuse your victim of bullying you first. I imagine the accusers must be very jealous to see the success of the other person, and jealous people will often go to extremes to take down the person they are jealous of.
There is one other famous case, with the group AOA where a group member (Mina) accused another member (Jimin) of bullying her troughout their many years of AOA's carieer. Jimin got unspeakable amount of hate for it but it was later revealed that it was most likely the other way round; the accuser (Mina) was the one who was bullying Jimin.
And no I don't think it's only you, I think it seems more common for the people who are bullied to forgive or try to forget and move on rather than try to get revenge or apology. Logically speaking why wanna try involving yourself with the bully again when they're not in your life anymore? I could be wrong but so many bullying accusations seem to point at the theory that the bullies are actually the ones who get jealous and try ruining the lives and carieers of their victims once more.
This is why I dislike the cancel culture so much, because so many innocents have fallen to the false accusations of bullies, with help of the cancel culture mob. Even if they prove they're not guilty the deeper damage has already been done and many people are still gonna remember the victims as being the "bullies"
I think one of the biggest reasons they were able to stay afloat comes down to their leader. Don't get me wrong, the efforts of the entire group to continue to put on fierce performances despite all they went through of course had a huge part to play in their success. But with Soyeon's extensive talents for writing and producing music, she continued to make hits for them that were not only tailored to the individual members (ensuring that no one was left with an extra part or one that didn't suit their voice types), but also a variety of songs and styles that just fit their brand. The sound and aesthetic are always something new for the audience which keeps them interested, but are still close enough to the vibes that G-IDLE has always maintained that when you hear it, you know that's a G-IDLE song. Other groups might not have survived without a leader like her or a company that had already invested so much they weren't going to falter and let the group die- MONSTA X is an example of this. They have great producers within the group, but Starship had already begun a huge international campaign to push them, so there was no way they would allow the group to burn out. In G-IDLE's case, I think it really came down to the members (especially Soyeon) to pull the team out of the wreckage, especially when you consider that CUBE had/has other upcoming groups that they could have shifted focus towards if it became clear that G-IDLE was not salvageable.
Not to mention they were able to use the scandal to their advantage - don’t get me wrong it’s absolutely HORRIBLE what happened to soojin and 6idle. But they were smart with how they went about it. Their marketing strategy was out of this world. Not to mention they really fed into the narrative of “what was going to happen to them” and used the scandal/drama as momentum to help skyrocket their career to where it is. Truly genius. However I still miss ot6 idle dearly. Doesn’t feel the same - but regardless I’m still extremely proud of their success - I just wish that they all could’ve made it there together
period
100%. Her leadership is so admirable.
The thing about Soyeon is that she's HUNGRY. I'm talking like, anime protagonist hungry. She's always looking for ways for her and her group to not only rise and go to the next level, but in the most impactful and meaningful way as possible. She certainly has her worries and doubts but at the end of the day she wants her team to win in the best way possible and absolutely be on top. She loves proving people wrong. I read somewhere on twitter that during a fan call, a fan told her that the concept photos of Nxde were badly received initially but then everyone loved it after Nxde got released, and the fan asked Soyeon if this was her plan. Soyeon said it was all planned and she actually expected to be criticized and cursed for the entire week. The fan asked if she was afraid of the hate, and Soyeon said something like what they did wasn't wrong, so she wasn't concerned at all.
I think she has such strong beliefs and ambitions--really, her drive is the fire of IDLE.
... and Soyeon job as leader only gets more difficult from recent successes. The increased popularity from the success of Nxde and iLove will bring increased scrutiny and criticisms. Shuhua is now brimming with confidence and popularity and we know how blunt she can be with critics. Luckily Shuhua has Soyeon, Yuqi, Minnie, and Miyeon there to guide her as she comes into full blossom.
Well Soyeon was part of it and so is the others MIYEON was the First Member to face the Public during the scandal cuz shes the mc of mncd and gossip idle, Shuhua went back to her country promoting same with Minnie and Yuqi in their respective country and Soyeon Also released her 2nd solo album and also being such a good mentor in a TV show…
They really rose from ashes like the Phoenix. The fire was fierce, and they lost a beautiful feather, but remained strong and conquers to this day.
😬 cringe
@@STAN_LOONA bro stfu you’re giving orbits a bad name
❤❤❤
@@STAN_LOONA no it was nice, not everything has to be cringe
@@STAN_LOONA Not STAN LOONIES speaking lol.......yes, it was iconic asff with the album 'I Never Die' they rose from the ashes and achieved PAK 167 times, you can't name any comeback more iconic than this....
I will never ever forgive what those people did to Soojin especially SSA... Just because her career is dying, she immediately jumped into the hate bandwagon and destroyed a flourishing career of somebody else!
Im dont know that Seo shin ae still denied that shes take down soojin's whole career
SSA just deserves to not be in this world anymore after this whole thing
SSA I never pay any attention to her, she's jealous of Soojin
@@TonyKimtheamusementparkfan Let's not wish death or harm on anyone. Yes, she deserves consequences from her actions, but let's not wish death.
@@PinkMarshmallows agreed. A failed career might be a better wish
We will always support you Soojin. Hope your doing good, I know you must be extremely proud of Gidle❤️❤️❤️❤️
Nah nothing to be proud of,if I was gidle member I would have refuted to perform until apology to Soojin is issued and she's added back
I love (G)i-dle 💜 I hate soojin is gone 😢 I love their idc attitude and their style as a group.. I hope she comes back even as a solo artist if she can't be back in the group 😪 ❤
That one actress was the nail in the coffin, I also read that the actress never heard soojin directly smack talk and that she heard it from her friends that heard it from other people...like wtf
She have never said that. What are you on? It was just a rumor made by Soojin's fans.
whenever I watch them I feel Soojins presence :) They will always be together for me, cause of how many things the girls adopted and learned from her over the years. Especially Shuhua who cooked Miso soup for the girls on their trip (which she learned from Soojin cause she always cooked it for her)
And I hope Soojin is doing great, whatever she wants to do in the future, I'll keep thinking about her and root for my bias!!
I start guessing which parts of the song would be Soojin's. Some of those parts still feel like they were made with her in mind. I was never this upset over someone leaving a group since Minzy left 2ne1. Really showed me how much I loved G-idle back then.
I will always love and support Soojin ❤
I’m not here to compare which idol deserves better and which agency dealt with their respective talents’ bullying scandals until it was done and dusted, I’m just here to state that whatever Soojin decides to do next, all we need to do is respect whatever that decision may be. The most important thing is that she is happy. We can adore Soojin the idol, but we must also consider the feelings of Seo Soojin the human being, the woman. If she wants to continue pursuing a singing or dancing career as a soloist, or an acting career, great. If she decides retire from the Kpop industry amd live like all of us, it’ll be a shame, but we just gotta respect her decision. One thing that will never change is the remaining members will never cast Soojin aside.
CL, bangchan and soyeon are truely the best leaders ❤️
This! Say it louder!
It’s very heartbreaking how much hate soojin got and how unfairly treated she was..😞she deserves an apology
I’ll never get over ot6…
Soojin is as essential as all the other members :(
I miss her, and apparently the girls too :(
For real even now it’s kind hurts to watch them on tv show without soojin 😢
Like it’s would been ot6
idle is doing even better without her,that's proved she's not necessary to the group and shuhua finally got a chance to shine
@@shyesimnxde3207wtf is wrong with you
@@shyesimnxde3207Saying she's not necessary to the group when she's one of the reasons why (G)i-dle gained support when they debuted is ridiculous. You can't downplay someone's contribution to the group and the members just like that. It's really obvious that you're a new nevie.
I feel bad for Soojin but I think she did the right thing like I too wouldn't want to be with a company that can't defend me
It feels like company did not even bother to protect soojin they just kick her out and did not even clarify everything i felt really sad she deserve better i hope she come back as a solo bcz i really want to see her on stage again and i hope she doing well
well you gotta remember this is the same company that kicked hyuna and dawn because they announced they were dating when the company lied that they weren't
Yeah i know and i felt really bad for them im happy they living happily
Yeah 😢
cube did protect her,but cube need to protect the other 5 girls too
@@shyesimnxde3207 lmao 🤣 stop no they do not !!!!!
I don't believe the rumors were true and I think it's already been proven that Soojin is innocent but even if it was true, while bullying is extremely wrong, I don't understand the logic behind someone's career as an adult being ruined over something they did when they were 13/14 years old. Not only was that a child making a mistake, we are not who we were as children.
I'm just glad that Soojin is back as a solo artist and that the girls have never forgotten her and keep incorporating Soojin in small aspects of their work (the cartoon in Nxde having a mole under her eye and being heavily inspired by Soojin's idol; multiple songs about Soojin; and more recently "Revenge"'s mv directly referencing Soojin's birthday). The girls haven't forgotten about her and neither have fans. Idk if we can hope for Soojin to join the group again after their contract is up in a year but I wish that we will at least get some interactions when they're no longer forbidden to interact in public.
We love you soojin, where ever you are right now, I hope you are safe and healthy❤
This just shows how hard it is to be an idol without false accusations and scandals
As long as Soyeons in the group she'll try her best to lead them
Actually, true. She is the famous one and the leader. They actually became more famous after the scandal. No offense to fans but the group really thrives at their peak. Actually, there are some groups who really thrived after a scandal and this is why some fans accuse agencies promoting groups or new groups using a scandal.. 😅 not saying it’s a particular group but it happened a lot of times. Maybe Kokielit can make a video on who actually thrived after the scandal or who regained fame, or groups/agencies accused of using scandal as a marketing strategy to promote the groups. Anyway, I agree with you. As long as Soyeon is there, G-idke will thrive.
Very true. Some people call her problematic and stuff but they can't ignore the fact that Soyeon is really smart and talanted. She does her best for G-idle no matter what
@@EVERYDODAMIES Soyeon is not famous at all actually nowadays she is the least biased in Idle and Soojin is actually the most biased member
@@thats_not_breezyshes_soo_windy I don’t think so, that’s not what it says on kprofiles
@@rookie_s Kprofile votes are mostly from their debut era that's why..Soyeon was obviously the most popular at the time..now u can see it clearly especially by the fancam views..right now it was shuhua at the last spot in kprofile and soyeon is third but Shuhua has the most fancam views now
This made me cry having flashback to that horrible year we lost our precious soojin. I pray she is happy and living a peaceful life. She deserved better. Proud of all of these 6 women as a neverland!
I miss Soojin a lot but I'm glad that other members are doing well. I hope Soojin at least comebacks as a solo artist if she wants to
They're making great job and they're really successful. Tomboy and nxde is doing great. It's so sad how an anonymous person can make up a story and these idols still will get canceled and all their effort and training for years go to waste. Of course not everyone is good ppl but that doesn't mean all of them are bad either and it's because of some anti's jealousy most of the time. And because same thing happened to Lucas, I'm really worried for his career. I just can't imagine NCT without him.
I miss Soojin 😭😭😭❤
SHE RETURN AS A SOLOIST WITH AGASSY LAST WEEK ON NOW 8TH 2023!!
JUSTICE FOR SOOJIN! WE WANT HER BACK!!!!!
I don't want her back with CUBE. I want her to be happy & if she returns to the industry I'll immediately support her to the best of my ability.
@@ZeriocTheTank but I want her with the group! 😓
@@cmartinez2998 hopefully when IDLE’s contracts expire they cna get the royalties and ownership over their group name and songs and get Soojin back in the group
They were the strongest group i've known. Losing a popular member must have been really stressful but they managed to break through the nightmares and became even popular. Soyeon is really amazing. And for soojin, I congratulate her successful debut. I wish all of them the best :)
I feel bad for Soojin, Seo shin ae must be punished for accusing her for no reason.
I don't care whatever it takes. I have to see Miss Seo Soojin on stage again!
CUBE kicked out Hyuna!HYUNA!!! of all people she was keeping the lights on at CUBE are we even suprised at this? CUBE is literally the worst at managing the idols
I still enjoy their music but the group hasn’t been the same to me since Soojin left so I don’t keep up w/ them like I used to. I hope she’ll be back as a soloist one day.
You should start doing that again, they are still very funny and still have great chemistry
is true soojin gone
but the members are so funny and charismatic
Same till now I’m come and couldn’t stop thinking about how the group could been 6 members and soojin could slay this comeback and how the soojin could been on knowing bro with the group. You can’t tell me that is not really sad when that is supposed to be your forever members
Not really my friends were not intrested in them but after tomboy they staned them i guess they made stronger songs to save thier career thats why more people stans them more
Thank you for this video ❤️
I love that you voice about this topic. I hope Seo Soojin the best and miss her so much.
I will never forgive CUBE for what they’ve done to Soojin and (G)I-DLE. Soojin was proven innocent but they still kicked her out. CUBE now just expects for the girls to just forget Soojin and to only worry about their current members. They’re friendships with Soojin were so sweet but CUBE ruined it. Screw you CUBE
Cube sucks
I feel bad for soojin and the rest of the members. This should not be normal for idols to be accused of scandals.
I know soojin would never smoke or do anything something so out of line.
And what made it worse was that a actress decided to step in and also accused her of such scandals.
The after math of all of the (G) Idle and soojin scandals led to soojin depart from cube entertainment, and left not only me but many other people in shock of the end. I feel so bad for soojin
Soojin literally said she did smoke lmao and u cant say u know someone that u never even met before 🤣🤣🤣
she did smoke at the age of 12 lol,she was a bad behaves girl back then, can't believe a 12 years old smoking drinking and cursing ,when I was 12 years old I was wearing cartoon t-shirt fooling around
Bruhh, i think gidle really came back stronger. Their popularity now is not joke in sk. Nxde is their latest hit after tomboy where tomboy gets 167 paks and nxde gets 70+ paks (still counting). Gidle is on the right track🔥
I hate that when allegations like this happen, the conclusion is usually the same, that a member leaves because they don't want to bring harm to the group any longer, even if they are innocent. And I applaud them for doing so, for not being selfish and thinking of everyone else instead, but a lot of the times there ends up being no conclusive evidence to anything and they end up leaving without the truth ever coming to light. I wish idols and companies would be more willing to wait til all the investigating is done before making a huge decision on removing someone from the group. And I wish fans would wait for the evidence to come out before jumping to conclusions and taking sides. There are always three sides to every story, the first person, the second person, and the actual truth.
I still remember when in nxde they put this cartoon character which had a mole under its eye like Soojin.
I still remember how in a transition in nxde they put a balloon “I never die”.
I still remember how in the end of tomboy there were a lot of red heart balloons.
I still *and will* remember how filthy cube is.
If u know CUBE actually forced they’re idols to starve themselves and whoever’s over the weight limit they would put it on the board and get embarrassed by seniors etc. Also theyre debut was delayed until SOYEON decided to step in. SOYEON and SOOJIN did the choreography while SOYEON wrote, (G)I-DLE was alone, CUBE didn’t even help them out on theyre debut. And SOYEON was in charge of directing the music videos’ CUBE is so cruel. You can search up something like” what did CUBE do to (G)I-DLE” “(G)I-DLE exposing CUBE”. I agree, CUBE is filthy.
@@shuhuazx Cube is nothing without gidle
@@Rosiest the only reason they’re surviving is bc of (g)i-dle
Still not over it! JUSTICE FOR SOOJIN!
Same
imagine if (g)i-dle drops cube and gets back soojin
That whole February bullying fiasco felt way too convenient. It’s like hundreds of people came together to start a witch hunt to see how many famous people’s careers they could destroy. Legitimate reasons or not, it felt very cruel and unusual
for fook sake, people change after middle school-high school ;______; WE ALL GROW UPPPPPPP, she didnt deserve to be kicked out of the band becouse of that. 80% of famous people were/are terrible poeple in real life and they live on their fancy life without their careers being ruined. I will always fight for my girl S.
#6i_dle4ever 🍒 🍒 🍒
As long as she moved on and is a better person now there shouldn't be any problem
@@homeland1128 lets all hope Soojin will come back one day to idle
Well, thats korea, u have to be perfect inside and out.
@@kiwiipeachii8980 "and is a better person now" xcuse me, Who?
Justice for Soojin 😔
they promoted individually except for shuhua, 4members are working so hard before the comeback
if only cube do everything they can. and seo shin ae should apologize for riding this bllying clout and those who accused her
Soojin,Kim Garam and Lucas...we really miss these angels
Idk about garam but everyone else yes, she wasn’t in the group long enough for me to see her as a bias or smtg
@@rsiogjtsjiflgtksjfijgsrljhlf True... Its pretty nice that alot of people stands with Garam❤️
@@rsiogjtsjiflgtksjfijgsrljhlf well that is true and devastating buts that’s not a reason to miss her, atleast hope she is safe and healthy
@@rookie_s she is she's back to school and her friends talked that she's fine
Now even if she's a bully people shouldn't react this way until things confirmed however bullying is a senstive topic in south Korea since its something very seen oftenly in schools the biggest problem is the one who got bullied might be accused as a bully just because they choosed to stay silent and move on.. I hope trainees who want to debut before they might move on they better fix the old problems because bullies won't let them successeed
@@fcys3532 I just said she wouldnt be my bias I'm not taking it to this extent lmao, but I do agree with what u said
That's why I'm angry with people who hate Soyeon because without her, their company will drop them
We want soojin back please soojin comeback please we are crying for you
I really miss you Soojin
(6)I-DLE forever!!!! But I can imagine that Soojin is maybe traumatized and doesn’t want to come back to the kpop industry…. I wish her and (G)I-dle the best
Seo Shin Ae is actually a devil 🥺 She destroyed Soojin for no reason and just kept silent when the truth was revealed. Is that fair for our Soojin, she was nice, and kind, and cared about everyone she met, then after all that’s what she received. 😢😢 after 3 years I still can’t believe what I have seen at that time. Totally a drama in real life, the liar totally lead the social media and no one cares about the unreasonable points in each story.
A very strong fandom, them creating a niche for themselves in the industry and owning it and most importantly, a general public that moves to the next topic very fast. I've noticed this with both IDLE and LE SSERAFIM.
Man I wish sujin was still in the group.
Is is an amazing idol who deserved a whole lot more. She had such a bright future ahead but some people can't see her growing and put they everything to pull her down and the saddest part is they succeeded. I hate cube already for not doing good to Hyuna and dawn as well as CLC, but soojin throwing soojin out of group was my last straw.
just finished watching this and i'm about to cry again just like i did on august 14, 2021 when that news came out :'( i miss her so much, so i managed to fit her name into the heart on the 'I love' album cover and i'll leave the link to it once i figure out how to do that
jo mi-yeon
nicha yontararak (minnie)
seo soo-jin
jeon so-yeon
song yu qi
ye shu hua
(G)I-DLE IS 6
#give_shuhua_her_soojin_unnie_back
I love Gidle
I think Soyeon's allegations got disproven like days after the posts as people quickly pointed out the timelines the accuser was giving didn't line up with Soyeon's. Also, not sure if this is true or not, but I read somewhere that Soyeon was homeschooled through most of her childhood, and when she did go to high school, she only had a few friends because most of her time was spent in Idol training. I can't remember where I read that, so take that with a grain of salt.
I miss Soojin so much! Why did this have to happen? It's so sad and frustratig.
Seo shin ae
They deserve so much love omg
Both CUBE and HYBE are to blame here, they literally allowed the real bullies to win and destroyed innocent people's hard work.
I really wish there was a poetic justice but sadly what you learn from life is, bad people win most of the time. Best you can do is to be ready for it and adapt as fast as you can. If you sink low and don't fight back they only get worse. Best of luck and strength to Soojin and Garam. I learned all of these things much later but my heart will always be with them.
I will never forgive this actress named Seo Shin Ae and her friends for simply destroying a persons life.
They made the situation worse which gained public attention.
After nxde I look forward to following g idle and supporting their work
I feel bad for soojin. She deserves better 😭
I will never forgive Cube for just letting Soojin get treated like garbage by these snakes. I miss her so much and I wish her the best.
I’ve said this before and i’ll say it again, Canceling adults and ruining their careers for something stupid they might’ve done or not when they were literal children is probably the dumbest most awful thing kpop stans learned to do.
bullying in korea is like saying nigg@ in us, saying taiwan is a country in china, every country have their own taboo
@@shyesimnxde3207 what are u even talking about
I'm happy for them this year , I'm so sad cuz Soojin dream gone n how she face the hate for a year.. I miss her but i just want PEOPLE who make Soojin n IDLE cry + through the hard time cuz their statments or comments admit his mistakes
IF IF they have guility feeling altghouh just a little bit, they should say sorry as personal to Soojin n IDLE members
I think OT5 is so successful is because of the fire it lit under the group. I think they seen how easily it can all be taken away from them.
What I find ridiculous is our society jumping on the hate bandwagon. So many people were saying horrible things about her(even garam) just cuz of those bullying allegations....is it fine for people to say horrible things just because "she's a bully". People know now that these allegations have huge holes/inconsistencies. People do change! Why can't you sit back and wait for a verdict instead of sending hate to kick people out. Garam had some of the worst hate tweets I was so disgusted. She's a 16yo child where is your humanity
Like isn't it normal to get into fight during school? It's not ideal but it happens. I feel like everyone goes through times like these. It's a shame that she has been kicked out
tru, especially since it was years ago :(. toxic fans pretend as if they’ve never gotten into a fight before. idk why ppl have to be hung up on these rumors, real or not.
@@llucieyy yes, people nowadays think they are "unproblematic". There will be times where you say or do stuff which you will regret, but it's essential to grow. That makes me sad. Maybe someday soojin can come back 🫰
She is Soyeon’s favorite member and will always be I hope😭
Honestly, SSA did a horrible thing to Soojin considering that she's not that sure if SJ is really a part of the group that she was blaming for bullying. Like, don't give any statements if you are NOT sure about anything and just accusing. She can't blame Idle Fans for being frustrated with this and for now tormenting her because of what she did, for someone who supports the victim of bullying, this is a very wrong move for her.
Now soojin sign an exclusive contract with BPM Ent. wish we can see our queen to debut as a soloist very soon
IT WAS FALSE :c
@@jesygomez2425 would you like to send a link to it?
Gidle deserve more
It kinda feels like Seo Shin-ae got away with her accusations against Soojin. Shame on her
YES SHAME ON HER
I have a small hope that Soyeon is gonna get super rich because she makes all of gidle's songs and will make her own company after their contract with cube is over and have Soojin re-join gidle then.
I'm gonna say it, flame me if you want, idgaf. This Seo Shin Ae is a damn ish for making crap up about Soojin. She should have had a consequence for false reporting. It sounded like Soe Shin Ae was/is jealous of Soojin and wanted to see her fail.
Im so proud of them i love them so much my baby soojin and the babies dont deserve these shit
Can we talk abt seo shin ae right now she literally fueled the fire here and if I'm not wrong after soojin was declared not in fault ssa said she doesn't remember properly if it was soojin like tf huh you literally ruined her career how would she feel if it was her 😑
no her english is not good, she means she was not sure soojin got kicked out from the ganster group,ssa is sure that soojin did bullied her,she said that at the other dm measage ,soojins fans are twisting ssa words try to made up "innocent evidence " for soojin
4:56 I think u mean 2021
7:10 why did she skip brazil like that 😭 girlie really said denmark but not brazil
Cube Entertainment should have just paid off her victims at the outset like JYP did for ITZY's Lia's bullying victims.
Give them enough money to make them never mention it ever again and the problem disappears.
coz soojin doesn't worth it, tomboy and nxde success already prove that soojin is not necessary to the group,idle is doing even better without her(double perfect all kill)
Lol cube handling things right is like hoping someday the clouds will rain diamonds.
Other kpop idols from JYP were also accused (someone form I boygroup but can't remember who and which bg) and they simply met up and apologized, problem solved. Cube's management seems to have given the worst advice to Soojin, who insisted on not apologizing..
All of their careers almost ended because somebody lied for attention.
OK how is she not allowed back now that's its over and it was bs. She deserves an apology from all of the people that gave her slack especially Cube. I mean over some bullying in middle school!? Some of the dumbest crap I have ever heard to cxl her. All I can think is she wants no part of Cube anymore. Especially when they just cut ties and really did nothing to defend her. I know I wouldnt. I love Gidle but Cube has left a stain on themselves Imo.
If companies just ignored hearsay accusations that took place before their idols were even apart of their company. And continued to make hit music. The shit would just blow over and they would still flourish. Especially a group like Gidle. They’re to strong. It would take way more than that for the fans to turn on them. I thibk it was more likely people lost interest in the group by getting rid of soojin. Cube probably wanted to see gidle fail. Soyeon too talented though. She wasn’t going to let that happen.
it's crazy how kpop stans and company's don't care about the truth. they just care about drama and side with baseless accusations.
I miss Soojin, I just hope she ist alright and I realllyyy hope for cube to get their shit right and take her back, SOOJIN DESERVES BETTER THAN THIS!
Seo Shin Ae committed career suicide by accusing SooJin. I will never watch (boycott) anything that Seo Shin Ae may be in. She seems to be inactive anyway. Hasn’t done much of anything since 2017.
im not sure I understand how they can make someone leave their group for allegations of bullying from years ago. In western culture, this would barely make a bleep and be quickly dismissed.
its all bcz of Seo Shin Ae, She should've made it clear.
they got another PAK no group could achive 2 PAK in 1 year since twice in 2017, 2ne1 and big bang
The power of our queens✨
Soojin we miss you😢❤
Not a fan but wth is wrong with these ‘former’ classmates? Lol why stuck yourselves in the past? Move on! These ‘idols’ have lives before they were even artists. They’re just normal people before they became idols. They’re not perfect.
Hi
I miss her, i just hope she's ok
We're all sinners... Forgive and Forget'
Honestly idle is the real leader of 4th gen ggs they survived such a scandal and didn't fall out unlike many other ggs they were and are big and it seems nothing can really break them
Lol seo shin a was probably so jealous I’m so mad she got what she wanted
i hope that Miss Soojin is doing great.
its always heartbreaking to see the girls missing her, but at least they all have purple hearts on their Instagram accounts to show some love for Soojin:(
G-IDLE Will Have More Music In 2023
I wish Soojin was still in the group and I am really happy they mention Soojin in their comeback. ☹☹😭😭
What has the past done with the people's current situation? In fact, it was during their elementary and high school days, wherein we tend to do unnecessary and stupid acts as a kid and teenagers. What's the big deal?
And yet, the inquiry into the unsubstantiated accusations against Soojin revealed that Soojin herself was a victim of School B***ying. SSA later admitted to not knowing if Soojin was actually a member of the group that b***ied her. No retraction, nothing. Karma is a wonderful thing. The only proper outcome to this is, Soojin's reinstatement to her group and apologies from the CEO of Cube Entertainment and Seo Shin-ae.
#Alwayswithsoojin
no her english is not good, she means she was not sure soojin got kicked out from the ganster group,ssa is sure that soojin did bullied her,she said that at the other dm measage ,soojins fans are twisting ssa words try to made up "innocent evidence " for soojin
and soojin got bullied from the others doesn't mean she never bullied, soojin got bad behaves at middle school, that's a fact
@@shyesimnxde3207 I'm sitting here looking at the twitter texts. There is no twisting of anything.