Is Diamond Tiara Illegitimate?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 вер 2024
  • We all know Diamond Tiara acts like a little bastard. But is it possible she really is one?
    (No hate to illegitimate children by the way, it's just fun to swear at ponies. And it stops UA-cam from stealing my comments section).
    ---
    Vectors featured in this video by:
    -Luckreza8 (Glimmer pointing at horn)
    -Sketchmcreations (Glimmer Shrug)
    -AnEvilZebra (Filly Applejack)
    -Rustle-Rose (Teenage Applejack)
    -Warmio161 (Colt Big McIntosh)
    -Cheezedoodle96 (Teenage Big McIntosh)
    -CloudyGlow (Bright Mac)
  • Фільми й анімація

КОМЕНТАРІ • 264

  • @caffeinatedpossum
    @caffeinatedpossum 2 роки тому +933

    Honestly it wouldn't surprise me if Diamond Tiara was a newborn during these flashback scenes like Applebloom was because Spoiled Milk would 100% have child-locked Filthy Rich had it meant she could abuse his humble and responsible nature to force him to marry her.

    • @devonm042690
      @devonm042690 2 роки тому +85

      Spoiled is a gold digger. She probably got him drunk or something, did it like they do on the discovery channel while he was more pliable, and then twisted the story somehow before the hangover faded. Then she discovered she was with child. Considering how submissive Filthy is to Spoiled, she probably has his fortune effectively held hostage by legal terms she was able to mete out as the holder of this 'unplanned' child. If he ever steps out of line, she'll file for divorce and take the Rich legacy to the bank on the way home. Something like that.

    • @somnodaur8064
      @somnodaur8064 2 роки тому +23

      @@devonm042690 thats super dark.

    • @adolfodef
      @adolfodef 2 роки тому +46

      @@devonm042690 It was "implied" that Filthy was NOT supposed to be the next "heir" of the fortune made by his grandfather (the same one Granny described back in her backstory in Season 2), who was still alive (in the flashback of that epsiode) since she explicitly manipulated Filthy just by sugesting that she would go & talk to him directly.
      The newborn Diamond Tiara was likely the "last" on his succession line [youngest]. He prefered to bypass ALL other ponies before her (those who had being waiting patiently for his death just to get his fortune), by setting a special legal fund that only DT would be able to use (once she becomes an adult); posibly explaining WHY her "Magical Fate" is about "bending the will of other ponies" [but through her future money/influence, not a supernatural skill like Fluttershy].
      Spoiled Milk "acquired" control/custody over this "last descendant" at the right moment, since it would be imposible for him to survive long enough so her child could grow up to have her own.
      She forced a situation were she "could" just decide one day to take her daughter "far away" from the Rich Family [unless she was "bound" by mare-trimony first].

    • @QueenMeowTigeress
      @QueenMeowTigeress 2 роки тому +4

      @@devonm042690 daaaaamn shes evil!

    • @SilverSpoonRiche
      @SilverSpoonRiche 2 місяці тому

      You forget, there has not been a single flashback scene we have ever seen a baby Bloom. Not one. Bloom is a paradox. She had to be born 10yrs before Diamond was even conceived because her mother passed when AJ was a blank flank and yet she is the same age as DT.

  • @axescilias
    @axescilias 2 роки тому +1000

    i thought you were going to suggest that spoiled milk had a partner before fifthy rich and got pregnant and got married to fifthy to cover it up lol

    • @pastelstrawberry3774
      @pastelstrawberry3774 2 роки тому +22

      Just noting that it is filthy rich lol

    • @jemimahrajakumar7770
      @jemimahrajakumar7770 2 роки тому +50

      Me too. Diamond tiara doesn't share much with her father, right?

    • @unripetheberrby6283
      @unripetheberrby6283 2 роки тому +3

      Hah me too...

    • @oreo_6206
      @oreo_6206 2 роки тому +2

      me too

    • @cdcdrr
      @cdcdrr 2 роки тому +16

      I was thinking Spoiled Rich cheated on her husband. Come on, you wouldn't put it past her.

  • @wolfstar1253
    @wolfstar1253 2 роки тому +1151

    I’ve tried numerous times to guesstimate what the character ages are in this show and every single time it’s almost given me a brain aneurysm

    • @Sel7in
      @Sel7in 2 роки тому +35

      pretty sure twilight is 27 yrs old, or younger such as 22 or 21, etc. i may be a bit off though, but it’s around there

    • @Mercinater
      @Mercinater 2 роки тому +4

      @@Sel7in Isn’t she a teenager?

    • @thedarknessmagician5234
      @thedarknessmagician5234 2 роки тому +73

      She’s definitely not a teenager. I think DWK said it best in his Equestria Girls videos when he pointed out that the main six all live away from their parents and (mostly) on there own. Plus, they are considered fully functioning members of society with their own careers. Twilight especially is one of the leading government officials of the entire kingdom, so I don’t think she would be a teenager if she was given that much power and responsibility. My best guess is that the mane six are all young adults (early to mid 20s in human years) at the start of the series, and then somewhere between five and ten years pass over the course of the show. As for the CMC, I’d say their probably around age ten or so when the show starts. The numbers aren’t perfect, and there’s no massive changes in terms of the characters age presented by the show (except the CMC getting their Cutiemarks which is typically seen as either starting puberty or finishing it), but there are a lot of details in the show both in terms of how the characters act and how much time passes in the world to support this idea. However, we may never know for certain how old the characters are. Maybe if we could figure out how long a damn “moon” is, then it would be easier.

    • @Mercinater
      @Mercinater 2 роки тому +2

      @@thedarknessmagician5234 Ohh ok I understand, thank you lmao

    • @Sel7in
      @Sel7in 2 роки тому +6

      @@Mercinateri think that in equestria girls, twilight an her friends are teens. Most like 16-17 or maybe even 15

  • @johnsmith9165
    @johnsmith9165 2 роки тому +405

    Trying to figure out the timeline of this show is a nightmare and a half. When you consider the implications of Equestria Girls, it's up to at least three nightmares. As near as I can tell, the entire first seven seasons and the movie cover about TWO AND A HALF YEARS of in-universe time. It's a mess.

    • @cameoshadowness7757
      @cameoshadowness7757 2 роки тому +9

      The universes officially travel in different speeds.

    • @adolfodef
      @adolfodef 2 роки тому +16

      @@cameoshadowness7757 No. They do not run at different timerates. Simply because it is THE SAME universe.
      In the first Equestria Girls movie, the "portal" shutdowns when a star is eclipsed by the Moon (of CHS´s "Earth").
      The portal does not "link dimensions", but rather is just a STARGATE between two planets that "share the same sky" on the Milky Way Galaxy.
      -> The "eclipsed star" is the yellow Sun of Equestria ("Kitalphar"), in the constelation of "Equuleus" [ Latin for "little horse" ], originally from the greek mythology associated with the foal "Celeris" .

    • @cameoshadowness7757
      @cameoshadowness7757 2 роки тому +11

      @@adolfodef except they aren't... they don't both have the same magic, they have different characters, different main species, let's not forget how Celestia and Luna are both over 1000 years yet are just adults (not even elderly) in the EqG verse and all the other characters and their differences. They are different universes. Saying they're the same ignores the factors in each one of them. They are WAY TOO DIFFERENT to be the same universe. On top of that, they have too many similarities to be the same universe but simply a different planet. They litterally have alternates of the Mane cast and many other characters- which is a staple for alternate universes.
      What you're saying still makes no sense when guess what? Planets DO RUN ON DIFFERENT TIMES! A planet like Mars rotates slower than Earth, MLP and EqG, even in YOUR EXPLINATION can and would likely still go by different times. We, in this universe, have witnessed Earth like planets with different rotation and day and night cycles.
      On top of that, less than 1 school year for the EqG verse went by when more than one season passed in the Mane verse. The fact that she show
      Also if you know ANYTHING about alternate universes, or just MLP in general, just because a similar looking sky, it means absolutely nothing.
      Also putting quotes on portal shows you don't understand what a portal even is. A portal is a gateway... so even if it's used for another planet in the same universe- according to you- IT IS STILL A PORTAL. A "Stargate" is a type of portal...
      There is also a difference between alternate universes and alternate dimensions...
      You... you don't know what you're talking about and it shows.

    • @jamstarr
      @jamstarr 2 роки тому +2

      Or 3, if we take into consideration the hearths warming episodes

    • @johnsmith9165
      @johnsmith9165 2 роки тому +2

      @@jamstarr Some of those can overlap, and should in order to make the rest of it work. A Hearth's Warming Tail could take place a few days before the holiday itself, allowing it to be the same year as Hearthbreakers.

  • @DulcetNuance
    @DulcetNuance 2 роки тому +462

    Cant get over somepony naming their child Filthy Rich... I mean ok... He did become rich and his cutie mark *does match* his name. But Spoiled Milk? You must just hate your child to name her that. Ether that, or its her destiny to be a rich pony's trophy wife... Not exactly the kind of thought you want to have when you consider the shows target demographic. But hey, at least Diamond Tiara is a name without an instant negative implication.

    • @stunthead
      @stunthead  2 роки тому +151

      I don’t delve into head canons much, but part of me thinks that Spoiled Rich’s nastiness is due to a belief that her special talent is being a trophy wife. If only there was a group of three young friends who specialised in helping ponies figure out the true meaning of their cutie marks…

    • @DulcetNuance
      @DulcetNuance 2 роки тому +16

      Woe is me, woe unto thou, woe unto her; possessed with such terrible affliction. Alas, redemption is beyond reach for no such group of young fillies exists.

    • @adolfodef
      @adolfodef 2 роки тому +19

      @@stunthead Then she would had discovered what her cutiemark was SUPPOSED to ment: "Professional Diamond Cutter" (Jeweler).
      Just like how "Common_Gemstone Finder" (Miner) was Rarity´s "Default Magical Destiny" (before -executive medling- _a sonic rainboom_ from a -certain white alicorn- _young pegasus_ changed things around).
      It would be TOO crazy to think that -She- is also somehow "responsable" of Applejack´s "special childhood" ? [we do not know exactly _how_ -(or rather, why)- had to become "parent-less" ].

    • @MultiStormywaters
      @MultiStormywaters 2 роки тому +16

      Maybe this is like an apple family thing where everybody gets an apple themed name, but she’s from the dairy themed ponies that cheese sandwich is from.

  • @windygleam9821
    @windygleam9821 2 роки тому +268

    That makes sense. This is the most possible explanation. The flashbacks in S5E18 show that her mother is the one who accompanied her most of her childhood.

  • @sunlightswift
    @sunlightswift 2 роки тому +150

    Believe it or not, you can actually produce offspring before you decide to get married. And it's actually fairly common

    • @pinkglitter93
      @pinkglitter93 2 роки тому +31

      This! I was born a year before my parents got married. So yeah, it is most likely that Diamond Tiara was just born out of wedlock, before the wedding.

    • @SynestriaVI
      @SynestriaVI 2 роки тому +51

      I don't think anyone is arguing that - but from a social standpoint, for ponies within a higher social class, it would be seen as one of the worst possible things. This happens in real life, as well.

    • @TheCentriole
      @TheCentriole 2 роки тому +5

      If you want to go straight to pony hell, you can

    • @Solanin0803
      @Solanin0803 2 роки тому +5

      @@TheCentriole These guy better go back to reading their pony Bible

    • @CajunReveler
      @CajunReveler 2 роки тому +5

      Yep, I was born and then my parents started to hate eachother. Amazing.

  • @Cantersoft
    @Cantersoft 2 роки тому +239

    The only question is, why did they wait so many years after Diamond Tiara's birth to get married? Looks like Diamond Tiara may have been born around the same time as Applebloom, so by the time Filthy Rich mentions he's getting married, Diamond Tiara should already have been a young filly.
    Also, what's going on at the end of this video? XD

    • @stunthead
      @stunthead  2 роки тому +40

      Research

    • @Akanisen049
      @Akanisen049 2 роки тому +72

      There's also the possibility that she isn't even Filthy Rich's daughter, he could be her step dad. No real proof to that, but it could explain the gap between her birth and them getting married.

    • @stunthead
      @stunthead  2 роки тому +53

      Aaah, Step Parents! I didn’t consider that. Good work, outside-the-box thinker!

    • @wolfie1703
      @wolfie1703 2 роки тому +20

      My friend's parent's didn't marry until my friend was in 2nd grade because they didn't think gettinng married was important

    • @gadaboutgriffon4446
      @gadaboutgriffon4446 2 роки тому +8

      @@Akanisen049 I was thinking it made more sense that spoiled milk already had diamond tiara before marrying Mr rich. She could be a divorced then got together with filthy rich

  • @linkinlog8543
    @linkinlog8543 2 роки тому +27

    I’m a bastard child (by biblical terms)
    I need more representation of bastard children

  • @Mica-kb3pj
    @Mica-kb3pj 2 роки тому +63

    It amazes me that even two years after G4 has ended there are still so many fascinating fan theories left to explore. Nice work.

    • @eriskhaos7311
      @eriskhaos7311 2 роки тому +7

      I’m sorry, it’s been HOW LONG???

  • @monikaem7331
    @monikaem7331 2 роки тому +113

    Even ignoring the inconsistency of models, Applebloom had to have been born by Where the Apple Lies, and I argue this with the fact Granny Smith is the one running the farm, and the conflict is Applejack and Big Mac arguing over which one of them she should pick to take over, which would make absolutely no sense unless their parents were already... gone.

    • @rabio02
      @rabio02 2 роки тому +3

      I always thought its bc they decided to keep apple bloom in her crib for the entirety of those episodes to avoid any questions

  • @liliththefirehawk796
    @liliththefirehawk796 2 роки тому +105

    Fyi, Spoiled Milk’s name is also Spoiled Rich lmao, just check the wiki, she’s referred to in the show using both names. You were technically correct either way ;)

    • @stunthead
      @stunthead  2 роки тому +26

      Oh I know, just trying to be consistent :)

    • @liliththefirehawk796
      @liliththefirehawk796 2 роки тому +1

      @@stunthead Ah, valid.

    • @augustday9483
      @augustday9483 2 роки тому +33

      Spoiled Rich's maiden name being Spoiled Milk is one of my favorite name puns from the show. Simply brilliant.

  • @augustday9483
    @augustday9483 Рік тому +12

    I really like the "older filly" or "teenager" design that Applejack had in Where the Apple Lies. I wish the CMC had gotten an upgrade to that character model once they got their cutie marks. It would have been nice to see some characters actually AGE during the show's lifespan. It's weird that after 9 seasons, the CMC still looked like fillies.

  • @MCLegoboy
    @MCLegoboy 2 роки тому +61

    It's a fun theory to say the least. As for the potential of her being adopted, I could actually see it happening only because of Spoiled Milk's vanity and not wanting to ruin whatever figure she has (kind of weird to talk about that for a cartoon horse but okay...), however I think it's more likely that Diamond Tiara is her biological child because of the colors they've chosen to design these characters. While already pretty uninvolved with Diamond Tiara's life, if the two weren't actually related, I could see it staining the whole family and Filthy Rich would have left with Diamond Tiara long ago. This family is only staying together because of Spoiled Rich's money and perhaps his infatuation with Spoiled Milk, unless you also have Diamond Tiara as their biological child, now they feel like they've got to be that family unit and keep their public image in the green. There are still a few other ways to have a child, but this is My Little Pony, why are we thinking about this so much? At it's simplest, Diamond Tiara is illegitimate, and at most complex, she's adopted (which sounds odd, but makes sense).

  • @YurieSnowie
    @YurieSnowie 2 роки тому +50

    great theory, i wasn't expecting this type of theory lmao, great video nonetheless, please make some more videos like these

    • @stunthead
      @stunthead  2 роки тому +8

      I will! If I can think of another theory with enough legs, of course… I’m a stickler for canon.

  • @DonnaPinciot
    @DonnaPinciot 2 роки тому +14

    A fourth option: Diamond Tiara was able to get in to the derby thanks to a generous 'donation' to the school that allowed the guidelines to be loosened a little.

  • @meatloaf-the-gaylord3264
    @meatloaf-the-gaylord3264 2 роки тому +13

    They did mention Applebloom was a late bloomer too, so it’s possible she is older than DT.

  • @unlimitedrabbit
    @unlimitedrabbit 2 роки тому +17

    She's not illegitimate. She's shown reading newspapers in Ponyville Confidential. (Joke)

  • @c1borgen
    @c1borgen 2 роки тому +17

    Stunthead hints that he is Australian for 6 minutes and 13 seconds

  • @SmokeTheHorsehog
    @SmokeTheHorsehog 2 роки тому +8

    I was initially confused with how Starlight was upside down, and then I realized the channel I was watching...

  • @cipkasvay
    @cipkasvay 2 роки тому +25

    Seeing this type of content from you was unexpected, but in a positive way. I really enjoy this style of video, and would like to see more in this style, no doubt!
    Keep up the good work

  • @kittycheshire5099
    @kittycheshire5099 2 роки тому +68

    I think it makes more sense for her to be adopted. She doesn't look anything like either of her parents.

  • @thedarknessmagician5234
    @thedarknessmagician5234 2 роки тому +18

    Can I just say that the upside-down Starlight fits you to a tee. Also, the theory is pretty solid. There is one thing that I think could disrupt it though. It’s possible that Filthy Rich and Spoiled Milk decided to have Diamond Tiara after they had initially decided to get married, but they didn’t want to wait until after the wedding to get busy. This would mean that they would’ve had Diamond WHILE they were still only fiancées, and it’s impossible to know how long they two were engaged to each other before they actually got married. Seeing as how picky and difficult Spoiled is, I don’t doubt that it may have taken the two well over a year or two to plan the wedding just because the bride couldn’t be satisfied with anything unless it was perfect. Plus, it’s not like “Where the Apple Lies” made any kind of mention of an upcoming wedding between the two, despite the fact that they were introduced as fiancées. Of course it would be a bit wired if they had been planning to get married for a long time and the Apple siblings were only just now hearing about it, but maybe the two just hadn’t had too many interactions with Filthy outside of business and this was just the first time they had met Spoiled (or maybe Filthy told Granny about Spoiled since she was in charge of the farm and she just never told Applejack or Big Mac). Now even if I’m correct, this would still mean that Diamond Tiara would’ve been born outside of wedlock, but I think it’s a bit better than being a complete and total bastard. Still, I have no real solid evidence to base my hypothesis on, so I concede that Stunthead’s theory has more support and better weight to it than my own. Congratulations my fellow pony connoisseur, you just gave the fandom a brand new head cannon!

    • @stunthead
      @stunthead  2 роки тому +8

      Thanks! I needed to represent myself in these videos but I didn’t really want an OC. I’m too much of a slave to canon.
      I wouldn’t claim to know the particulars of their wedding, and despite what I jokingly implied in the video, I never got the impression that Filthy Rich doesn’t love Spoiled. But that’s why I like this theory; it doesn’t hinge on any assumptions, it’s just logical reasoning based on what we already know to be true

    • @thedarknessmagician5234
      @thedarknessmagician5234 2 роки тому +4

      Indeed, I never really take theories like these too seriously. It’s just really fun to look for details and connections. I don’t know why, but there’s something extremely satisfying and hilarious about overthinking something simple. Thanks for the great video!

    • @adolfodef
      @adolfodef 2 роки тому +3

      @@stunthead My headcanon is that Filthy & Spoiled never "loved" each other in a profound, deeply romantical way (but of course they still do "liked liked" each other´s bodies very much, obviously).
      The idea of getting married was a convenient "solution" for both of them once an unexpected oportunity presented itself: Spoiled got pregnant by Filthy, who then told it to his grandfather (who then decided to give his fortune to his great granddaughter).
      -> By marrying the mother of the future owner of his family bussiness, Filthy became the current "regent" of his grandfather´s "kingdom"; while everypony waits for the "Princess" to become "Queen".

  • @TheCentriole
    @TheCentriole 2 роки тому +5

    "Stunthead, you can't just make an upside down canon character your OC."
    Stunthead:

    • @stunthead
      @stunthead  2 роки тому +1

      Haha pony go “WOW!”

  • @michaelbyrne5606
    @michaelbyrne5606 2 роки тому +10

    Before Spoiled Milk debuted…I was low key hoping that Starlight was Filthy’s ex who left on a phony “spiritual pilgrimage” when in truth she wanted to amass a fortune a la L. Ron Hubbard by creating Equitology

    • @Numbuh8578
      @Numbuh8578 Рік тому

      That would've been a cool plot twist

  • @wolfstar1253
    @wolfstar1253 2 роки тому +14

    I know the ending part was a joke but I honestly wouldn’t mind seeing an “Out of Context Lines” compilation

  • @pissapocalypse
    @pissapocalypse 2 роки тому +3

    Bruh I thought this said "Illiterate"
    And then I realized that in fact, I am the illiterate one

  • @lanfour4444
    @lanfour4444 2 роки тому +9

    2:42 "Your brain must be too full with career aspirations and social aptitude" Nice joke Stunthead, I laughed out loud.

  • @emilsingapurcan8054
    @emilsingapurcan8054 2 роки тому +6

    more of this, even if its just random nonsense!
    the really nice production quality is very greatly appreciated doh

  • @dogman15
    @dogman15 2 роки тому +8

    Well, you've convinced me.

  • @scifidino5022
    @scifidino5022 2 роки тому +8

    This video is so brilliant and funny XD! Gave me the hardest laugh I had in a while!
    I love the recurring "I am upside down" thing through out the video XD (especially 2:48)
    Also your voice is really calming and just nice to listen to. I would love to see more of these theory videos.
    6:10 was really unexpected XD

  • @shinypaintf588
    @shinypaintf588 2 роки тому +2

    i love it when you make videos like this!! they're great

  • @selfawaresnow
    @selfawaresnow 2 роки тому +6

    I loved the new type of vid! Keep up the good work Stunthead! :3

  • @TailsClock
    @TailsClock 2 роки тому +2

    I have never heard of you before, or of this theory. Not sure why I even clicked this. And now I'm subscribed to you.

  • @RockyMetal24
    @RockyMetal24 2 роки тому +8

    Timeline is confusing
    I counted at least 7 winters in mlp

  • @avacadotherainwing8457
    @avacadotherainwing8457 2 роки тому +4

    I'd never thought of this omg. My first thought when presented this was that it was possible that the younger diamond tiara could've used connections and bribery to get into the derby early. This theory is really nice though and I'll probably be stuck thinking about it for a while

  • @makennashuter6606
    @makennashuter6606 2 роки тому +4

    Lmao being named spoiled milk. Marrying into being spoiled rich was the only good move she could do.

  • @bquncy550
    @bquncy550 2 роки тому +23

    Pony Ages and Pony Genetics go hand in hand when being incoherent. Characters that have nothing to do with one another look related, while those that are related don’t. (For example, that Acorn couple in the Best Gift Ever look more related to each other, Cheese Sandwich and Grandpear then they do to their son, and than what Grandpear is to Pear Butter).
    The only exception to seems to be Trixie and the magician from Grannies Gone Wild, who’s said to be her father. But, then there’s also the mare who’s meant to apparently be her mother, and she’s just an orange version of Trixie.

  • @TheSlipperyNUwUdle
    @TheSlipperyNUwUdle 2 роки тому +3

    It’s always weird to hear her voice actress’s voice, cause when I grew up in the early 2000s she was also the voice of Kelly in the Barbie movies. Lol and that one random bratty ghost in the Inuyasha dub.

  • @magic_pink_horse
    @magic_pink_horse 2 роки тому +4

    The upside down Starlight hurts my brain but otherwise good video, mate 👍

  • @ryleedubbeld5417
    @ryleedubbeld5417 2 роки тому +6

    Spoilers:
    "If you like this video, then I'm sorry but it's already too late for you"
    Man you are killer at comedy. Thank you for filling most of your (Large, full) brain with the bare essentials of insanity juice. It is a fantastic past-time to sip through and enjoy. So thank you.

  • @karmageddon9047
    @karmageddon9047 2 роки тому +3

    honestly, i misremember Diamond Tiara as a unicorn so many times.

    • @lonelyronin2428
      @lonelyronin2428 2 роки тому +1

      I thought she was one at first too. Her family acts like nobility, and they're rich. The unicorn race are the rich and nobility, and act similar. Plus, tiara looks like a hitn when you dont look well at first glance.

  • @demalex-nv7ut
    @demalex-nv7ut 2 роки тому +3

    This video is so high quality for the silly it is
    Great job, i loved it

  • @lordmalal
    @lordmalal 2 роки тому +3

    DT's color palette is closer to Starlight's than to either of her parents. I would think they were related if they weren't different species.

    • @AstralArbourSys
      @AstralArbourSys 2 роки тому +1

      *cough* the cakes *cough*

    • @lonelyronin2428
      @lonelyronin2428 2 роки тому +3

      Ponies can take after one parent's species. Look at Scootaloo. Her mom is a pegasus, dad is a earth pony. Scootalo is a pegasus, but can't fly. That's because while pegasi bones are light, like a bird's, earth ponies have dense, normal bones for walking and widstandind the hard labor the farmers do. So its still possible, that DT is her daughter, but she took after her dad species wise, and mom colo r wise.

    • @lordmalal
      @lordmalal 2 роки тому

      @@lonelyronin2428 good point although I didn't think they are mother and daughter. I was thinking more like cousins or half siblings.

  • @clementine6890
    @clementine6890 2 роки тому +3

    I like the shotgun wedding idea, because if FR and SM were dating beforehand, AJ and BM probably would've already known about her, but they're only introduced to her as his fiancee

  • @moshu9952
    @moshu9952 2 роки тому +3

    My general idea of the characters ages is like,,,
    Mane 6 are between 18 and 22
    CMC are around 10 to 13
    The Cakes are in their thirties
    If that makes sense

    • @sakurarara4725
      @sakurarara4725 2 роки тому

      I think the mane 6 are around 23-26 tbh

  • @jessicu511
    @jessicu511 2 роки тому +5

    That's a weird question.

    • @stunthead
      @stunthead  2 роки тому +3

      I’m just trying to get my cutie mark in prying. It’s on my little chart

  • @alexcupo5346
    @alexcupo5346 2 роки тому +1

    diamond is older than apple bloom she gets her cutie mark first.

  • @oreo_6206
    @oreo_6206 2 роки тому +2

    oh my god the time differences are so inconsistent
    also is cheerily in her mid 40s to early 50s bc the fashions she’s wearing in the one flashback seem to very heavily imply that this was in the 80s

    • @stunthead
      @stunthead  2 роки тому +2

      I think it was a callback to The Call of the Cutie, where a past photo of Cheerilee has her dressed like that and she comments that “back then everypony wore their manes like that.” Where the Apple Lies confirms that, in actuality, it was just her who was dressed like that.

  • @misspinkpunkykat
    @misspinkpunkykat 2 роки тому +3

    I thought Diamond Tiara's biological mother died in childbirth and Milk was her stepmother.

  • @yourlocaltherapistfriend5091
    @yourlocaltherapistfriend5091 2 роки тому +1

    some parents must have really hated their child to call them 'spoiled milk'

  • @Terrestriellie
    @Terrestriellie 2 роки тому +1

    You seem to answer the questions I never thought to ask, and yet I get so fucking invested

  • @husky6732
    @husky6732 2 роки тому +4

    I feel like the issue here, is whether or not the characters age in human years, or in horse years. It also depends on when Rich and Spoiled met and when they got engaged. And by human standards, it's not impossible to get married and have a kid in just one year

  • @-ZH
    @-ZH 2 роки тому +3

    Sparkle seven flashback is definitely reliable.

  • @PollexTheCat
    @PollexTheCat 2 роки тому +1

    alternatively: Diamond's parents got divorced at some point between her being born and the fiance flashback, and one of them is a step parent.

    • @nessesaryschoolthing
      @nessesaryschoolthing 2 роки тому +3

      Either that, or one of them died. Maybe she and Applebloom have more in common than she thinks

  • @vampires4life
    @vampires4life 2 роки тому +1

    AYO!? DIAMOND TIARA'S PARENTS WEREN'T MARRIED WHEN THEY HAD HER?
    LETZ GOOOOO A CHARACTER I CAN RELATE TO!! WOOO

  • @AddisonButts
    @AddisonButts 11 місяців тому

    what im getting from this is that spoiled milk baby trapped filthy rich.

  • @n00bxl71
    @n00bxl71 Рік тому

    5:52 "I will probably spill this" writen on an upside down mug

  • @alejandrootero8894
    @alejandrootero8894 11 місяців тому

    I'm glad to see your Starlight without blood

  • @DustyGamma
    @DustyGamma 2 роки тому

    I liked this video, and I already knew it was too late for me, but thanks for the reminder!

  • @GunnarClovis
    @GunnarClovis 2 роки тому +2

    *The state of hors fandom*

  • @navybr0wnie
    @navybr0wnie 2 роки тому

    trying to imagine this being talked about after 3 packs of ciggarates, 4 cases of beer, and a hit of weed.

  • @eeveefennecfox
    @eeveefennecfox 2 роки тому +2

    I've always thought they were like 6 to maybe 8 years old,cause I think all of the main characters are all teenagers until the end of the show,so it makes sense for the younger characters are probably 5,6 or even 8 years old,I wish the show would comfirm ages,but it's always fun to just speculate

  • @lordmalal
    @lordmalal 2 роки тому +3

    This totally canon scene makes it clear that DT couldn't have been adopted, since she makes fun of Scootaloo for being adopted herself: ua-cam.com/video/6TiE2FjcDXo/v-deo.html

  • @sea-morningstar
    @sea-morningstar 2 роки тому

    I legit thought the video was malfunctioning until I saw your pfp

  • @CookieFonster
    @CookieFonster 2 роки тому

    this video was so fascinating, blew my expectations to shreds

  • @galioncyapon3473
    @galioncyapon3473 2 роки тому +1

    What if spoiled isn't even her biological mother

  • @SydneyDenim
    @SydneyDenim 11 місяців тому

    The thumbnail cracks me up everytime

  • @calvinthedestroyer
    @calvinthedestroyer 2 роки тому +1

    Cheerily in her cheer uniform.... :)

  • @Viola_mlp
    @Viola_mlp 2 роки тому +2

    I gave up trying to pin down pony ages a long time ago... XD

  • @fairiesandlillies3471
    @fairiesandlillies3471 2 роки тому +1

    Spoilt Milk could have been married before ?

  • @commander8560
    @commander8560 2 роки тому

    I really just wanna forget this show

  • @drake_o_kid9490
    @drake_o_kid9490 2 роки тому

    my world has been turned upsided down

  • @jk844100
    @jk844100 2 роки тому +31

    The real question is; in this day and age does “having a child before marriage” even matter?
    Spoilers the answers is no.

  • @sandwich1920
    @sandwich1920 Місяць тому

    My theory is that Diamond Tiara is younger but still competed before the CMC because she got her cutie mark first. I mean she had a Cute-ceañera and everything

  • @TerribleFate
    @TerribleFate 2 роки тому +1

    Stunthead you're so funny. I wish you had discord so I can bully you back as much as you bully us, headmaster pony.

    • @stunthead
      @stunthead  2 роки тому +1

      Ha, keep dreaming, nerd! I’m far too scared of meaningful human interaction for that! 😎😎😎

    • @TerribleFate
      @TerribleFate 2 роки тому

      @@stunthead I'll see you in my dreams then. 😭😭😭😭

  • @SilverSpoonRiche
    @SilverSpoonRiche 2 місяці тому

    Not only that but Bloom and Diamond should be roughly 10yrs apart in age. So Pear Butter passed when AJ was a blank flank, we saw AJ leave the farm with only Granny and Brother to see her off but she had a pic of parents in her sack. But in this shot where she meets Spoiled she's a teenager and Diamond has yet to be conceived (we assume). SO, the only way Bloom could be born of the same mother is if she was 10yrs older than DT.

  • @bigpauly2703
    @bigpauly2703 2 роки тому +1

    she could be adopted

  • @alltheclovers532
    @alltheclovers532 2 роки тому

    Good work, from the title I thought it was going to be about an affair.

  • @konankid2340
    @konankid2340 2 роки тому

    more fun videos like this please!

  • @blazingflareon3670
    @blazingflareon3670 2 роки тому

    Starting watching your vids this week in Florida vacation. Nice to know you upload sometimes!

  • @ItsCooper
    @ItsCooper 2 роки тому +3

    Good content!

  • @javaskull
    @javaskull 6 місяців тому

    Well, the more likely explanation is he remarried and she’s his actual daughter and spoiled milk is her stepmother. Fits with the whole stepmother being evil thing.

  • @SNOWYSKY2001
    @SNOWYSKY2001 2 роки тому +1

    Hey, where did you get the video of the apple sibs being with their parents? Never seen that in the show (or the Netflix release at least..) Also WHERE CAN I FIND THE CLIP OF APPLEJACK SAYING "UNICORNIA WITH NO ACCENT?"

    • @stunthead
      @stunthead  2 роки тому

      That scene with the parents is from “Going to Seed,” S9E10 (depending on your area, season 9 may not have been released on Netflix). And the Unicornia clip is from the short “Best Gift Ever: Mystery Voice” which you should be able to find on UA-cam

  • @harukatakahashi8822
    @harukatakahashi8822 2 роки тому +1

    How come Starlight glimmer is upside like your profile and why are you putting your voice when Starlight glimmer when it feels like she's talking with your voice?

  • @hitnrun66
    @hitnrun66 2 роки тому +2

    I hate how youtube marks some as these videos for kids, i get it, but it sucks cuz theres no comments and you can’t add it to a playlist

    • @stunthead
      @stunthead  2 роки тому +1

      Yyyyyep, it sucks alright!

  • @thatdumbravegirl2689
    @thatdumbravegirl2689 2 роки тому +1

    i mean what about filthy rich being previously married and ended up having an oopsie baby and thats what led to a divorce between him and his presumably childfree previous partner

  • @technorunner1
    @technorunner1 2 роки тому +1

    Wait a minute.
    Did Big Mac do a double take on Cheerilee?

  • @gracieewart9282
    @gracieewart9282 2 роки тому

    I'm a bastard kid too. Don't worry Diamond. You'll turn out fine... I think.

  • @DyslexicWitch
    @DyslexicWitch 2 роки тому +1

    Ok but remember him, in the episode where the main 6 fight each other on who’s getting the ticket to the Grand Galloping Galla rarity mentions a pony named him who she refers to as celestas nephew but dose that make him Lunas kid? Who the hell was the baby daddy? Or is he related to cadence since she calls her her niece I think? Or maybe he’s adopted idk? Can you look into this please?

  • @thesleepybus4886
    @thesleepybus4886 2 роки тому +1

    I was sort of suspicious of who DiamondTiara's real dad was, because she doesn't look like FilthyRich or SpoiledRich at all, so maybe she has a different dad. But I could be completely wrong-

  • @Rikkiroo1008
    @Rikkiroo1008 2 роки тому +1

    so would this mean Spoiled Milk wanted to be rich, so she decided to like get pregnant to like lock Flithy Rich into staying in a relationship with her.

  • @svetakuklina8398
    @svetakuklina8398 2 роки тому

    I also noticed that rewatching "Where the apples lies".
    Like if Applejack was a teen then Applebloom was at least already born
    But I thought maybe DT was Filthy Rich's daughter and Spoiled was her stepmother

  • @skootergirl22
    @skootergirl22 2 роки тому

    Horses age differently to us humans 1 year is equivalent to 20 years I think

  • @Helpertin
    @Helpertin 2 роки тому

    Better explanation to it all... they didn't check for 100% consistency in obscure details while they were making a pony show ostensibly for little girls.

  • @rainbowdash7057
    @rainbowdash7057 2 роки тому

    I feel like it’s more like the show keeps forgetting what they write. Like Rainbow dash’s dad a completely different person from season one to the newer season.

    • @CookieFonster
      @CookieFonster 2 роки тому +1

      if you mean the flashback from Games Ponies Play (which was season 3!), fans at the time assumed the guy was rainbow dash's dad. but now that we've met her dad, it's reasonable to assume that he is just a different relative of rainbow dash's like an uncle or something.

  • @kuroryuken
    @kuroryuken 2 роки тому

    "If you liked this video, I'm sorry it's too late for you"
    Okay, that one was good XD

  • @gren8te319
    @gren8te319 2 роки тому

    2:32 good point

  • @GhostBestCat
    @GhostBestCat 2 роки тому +1

    So uh even if this did come out some minutes ago I'm surprised that no one commented about the ending audio but eh 😅😅😅

  • @HydroxTheCat
    @HydroxTheCat 2 роки тому

    Will you remember me when you go world famous and get the golden play button and stuff?

    • @stunthead
      @stunthead  2 роки тому

      Of course! I’ll remember you as “the commenter who wondered if I would remember them.”