you are so right!. I was starting to wonder if she truly was a bad actress while I was watching arrow, to the point where me and my friends were practically hoping that it was her in the coffin (and were very happy when that proved right).But I kinda went quiet when she appeared as the Siren on the flash, I thought she was really really good. It was a little later when I found out she appeared in supernatural (and soo forgot that she did! was a big fan of this show for first 5 seasons and was soo annoyed when she was replayed with that other lady). This scene alone shows that she is a good actress but it also points more towards a theory that I had. That she is much better at playing a villain (or in this case a morally ambiguous character). I felt like the actress was out of her element as the heroic, goody too shoes on arrow, she was way over the top and melodramatic.
@Nolan Palmer it's not that she's better at playing villains or morally ambiguous characters in my opinion. I, personally, really thought her drug addiction/alcoholism arc was really well acted. I have loved ones that went through what her character did in Season 2 and I can honestly say, it was really harrowing to see mental illness portrayed so raw on screen. The problem is, freaking Marc Guggenheim and Wendy Mericle don't know how to write the Black Canary. Black Canary, in the comics, is a character who has both a heroic side to her as well as a rebellious/sassy edge. If you combine Earth-1 Laurel's compassion with Earth-2 Laurel's (Black Siren) sassy/rebellious edge, you actually have a really accurate Black Canary. The problem is, the producers on Arrow pander to a bunch of teenagers and make everything about some poorly written knockoff of Chloe from Smallville.
I agree. I think everything on Supernatural favored her - the script, the directing, the hair and makeup. Laurel is just... meh, and it's not the actress' fault, that's just the way the character's written. And tbh, Supernatural beats Arrow any way of the week.
With all those smirks Genevieve was throwing, you can tell she was evil from the start even though Ruby was always meant to be evil. I think Katie would of been able to pull it off, considering everyone thought she wasn't evil, she than could of stab them in the back. It would of been alot believeble
On arrow recently, she’s been playing the multiverse version of Laurel, which is evil/anti hero, VERY much like Ruby. She even went back to totally blonde for it :) She’s a great actress, but DAMN is this sass and evil she plays so well
yeah her arc is just terrible and just impossible to believe in. lawyer to drug addict to superhero? no just no. She thinks shes such a badass to the point where its laughable. almost died when she thought she could take down merlyn hahah rant over
She said in an interview that she lost loads of weight for her role on arrow like the alcohol addition arc Laurel had on the show. Which is sad because Arrow treated her like shit
Katie Cassidy gave Ruby depth, wit and knows how to effectively feign vulnerability to hide her true intentions, all the while being fun character to watch. With all due respect to Genevieve, Katie Cassidy IS Ruby.
If only the Winchesters were a little bit open-minded back then, they befriended king of hell later but gave ruby a hard time. If they accepted Ruby, they would have sought for ways to revert her back to human again . They would have found human blood injection method way earlier and turn her back into a human again, like they did with crowley and deamon.
O-M-F-G!! I knew i've seem Laurel from Arrow somewhere... I can't believe she was Ruby, i loved her back then lmao. How could i not remember right away o.o
I agree too! The blonde Ruby gave off a more awesome feeling and Katie Cassidy was so boss in the role. But still Genevieve Cortes (Padalecki) is still an amazing woman outside her character :)
I love this version of Ruby, and missed her so much 😭😭😭 Gen was pretty and delivered her own version of Ruby (and there might be change on the script of this character's purpose in S4) and it's good, but I'd definitely grow to love Ruby through Katie's over the second one.. (don't get me wrong because I like Gen too she's a good actress, only that I preferred the Katie's version of the role 😊)
I loooove Katie Cassidy and Lauren Cohan... Since i have a broken leg i stay home all the day, and i watch supernatural (all the day) and i dream about Ruby on the night lol. If Supernatural producers read this : bring back Bobby, Bela and Ruby(K Cassidy) Okay ??
i love it when katie plays in roles like this, I love her but i hate horror movies and that’s the majority that she plays in, ik SPN and Arrow aren’t far from it but they’re different😂😂
Katie cassidy version of ruby is kind of bossing dean around so the very first demon azeal eyes demon death and lilth eye color is white while lilth prossening ruby on this season 3 ep
Back when the show aired her character wasn’t as well liked as it is now so they told Katie that they were cutting her pay way down. When she got mad (as one would) they offered to let her out of her contract and so she left. I read that on a different video but I think it’s true.
@@sethsur8477 that’s crazy. Man Katie Cassidy was so damn good in this show as the original Ruby. Such a waste of huge talent from her. I can’t believe she got dismissed. 😖😞
I don't care if Ruby's a demon I'd still... you know. Lemme ask a question: in the world of Supernatural can human males and demon females mate? Anybody?
Katie Cassidy was the best Ruby! I really missed her when she left.
Shocking! Aren't you afraid of the Jared girls tearing you apart for being mean to his wife....even though you are telling the truth.
DaLeadBull Yes Honestly, this is the best Ruby Version. (Ruby v1) haha
DaLeadBull I think she misses the fact she misses her chance more.
She really was the best Ruby!!!
Whhhaaa!? I just realized that's her. Lol
I'd say because of the straight long hair and almost no make up & her curvy eyelashes.
I prefer this Ruby to the other one.
So do I.
LuisXY 4 realz, I was very disappointed when that other chick took her place.
SaAaAaAaAMeE
LuisXY Same but if Katie never of left then Jared never would’ve met Genevieve
Gen was ok but I prefer this one
Supernatural, she's a good actress that's for sure.
This really shows her skills, but in arrow I feel that the scripts hold back her skills.
you are so right!. I was starting to wonder if she truly was a bad actress while I was watching arrow, to the point where me and my friends were practically hoping that it was her in the coffin (and were very happy when that proved right).But I kinda went quiet when she appeared as the Siren on the flash, I thought she was really really good. It was a little later when I found out she appeared in supernatural (and soo forgot that she did! was a big fan of this show for first 5 seasons and was soo annoyed when she was replayed with that other lady). This scene alone shows that she is a good actress but it also points more towards a theory that I had. That she is much better at playing a villain (or in this case a morally ambiguous character). I felt like the actress was out of her element as the heroic, goody too shoes on arrow, she was way over the top and melodramatic.
@Nolan Palmer it's not that she's better at playing villains or morally ambiguous characters in my opinion. I, personally, really thought her drug addiction/alcoholism arc was really well acted. I have loved ones that went through what her character did in Season 2 and I can honestly say, it was really harrowing to see mental illness portrayed so raw on screen. The problem is, freaking Marc Guggenheim and Wendy Mericle don't know how to write the Black Canary. Black Canary, in the comics, is a character who has both a heroic side to her as well as a rebellious/sassy edge. If you combine Earth-1 Laurel's compassion with Earth-2 Laurel's (Black Siren) sassy/rebellious edge, you actually have a really accurate Black Canary. The problem is, the producers on Arrow pander to a bunch of teenagers and make everything about some poorly written knockoff of Chloe from Smallville.
I agree. I think everything on Supernatural favored her - the script, the directing, the hair and makeup. Laurel is just... meh, and it's not the actress' fault, that's just the way the character's written. And tbh, Supernatural beats Arrow any way of the week.
@@FlowerTrollSanabsolutely agree
@@cas2914exactly
Seriously the best Ruby. So evil, witty and gorgeous all rolled into one.
This Ruby is still my fav villain from Supernatural.
She and Crowley are my favourites
Man I miss early days supernatural, when the world was still new and surprising.
With all those smirks Genevieve was throwing, you can tell she was evil from the start even though Ruby was always meant to be evil. I think Katie would of been able to pull it off, considering everyone thought she wasn't evil, she than could of stab them in the back. It would of been alot believeble
I didn't like Genevieve's acting choice. phew! there I said it.
Diane Winchester the writers and directors also told her to make that choice lol she didn’t make it own her own
she was so badass; loved her so much!
I love Katie Cassidy!! She was amazing in this season of Supernatural!! Love her so much!!! Black Canary!
Is it just me or was Katie a lot hotter as Ruby than she is as Laurel
She made a great ruby. The best one of the two.
It was like 10 years earlier lol
Laural is too damn skinny
On arrow recently, she’s been playing the multiverse version of Laurel, which is evil/anti hero, VERY much like Ruby. She even went back to totally blonde for it :)
She’s a great actress, but DAMN is this sass and evil she plays so well
They are both hot as hell. Ruby laurel sandwich mmmmm
She's hated so much in Arrow but loved so much in SPN.
Cause she acts in SPN and is terrible in arrow haha
TheRushToRehab I think it's the writers.
yeah her arc is just terrible and just impossible to believe in. lawyer to drug addict to superhero? no just no. She thinks shes such a badass to the point where its laughable. almost died when she thought she could take down merlyn hahah rant over
+Sy A she's not hated on arrow at all
Sy A I never hated her on Arrow
I wish they kept Ruby on the show , and I wish her and Sam's relationship lasted longer
Jared Padalecki (sam) ended up marrying "the brunette" (Genevieve Cortese Padalecki) after meeting her on the show lol.
Anyone else think that she looks completely different now? I mean If you compare her now to this, it's almost a different person.
John Elford Yes
on this movie she is ~21 old, now she is 28 and looks really different.
She said in an interview that she lost loads of weight for her role on arrow like the alcohol addition arc Laurel had on the show. Which is sad because Arrow treated her like shit
@@Canareh2310 coz her character was shit. the latest version was far better.
This was filmed in 2007/2008. Can you believe she was only 21 ? God, what a woman!
When Supernatural was still great!! Miss these days.
I know... I wish it just ended after 5 seasons as planned and remained legendary.
best Ruby ever Katie Cassidy is awesome
One of the reason I fell in Love with Katie Cassidy. She is so beautiful and badass in Supernatural. But she's much more beautiful in Arrow.
*much more beautiful
She can have my soul ANYTIME!
thisisntmyceiling She's ugly, that's her vessel.
thisisntmyceiling She was 21 in that time now he is about 36 years old.
So Ruby became the Black Canary. Haha.
katie is the best ruby and love her at arrow
Me too
katie is awesome but tragedy is that she do awesome acting in arrow but she has been given less screen time in arrow.
+Kuldeep Singh even less now :/
barry messed with the timeline again!
clinton jackson 😂 love this comment
I miss her character so much.
I prefer Katie over Genevieve... sorry
Me too
Katie Cassidy gave Ruby depth, wit and knows how to effectively feign vulnerability to hide her true intentions, all the while being fun character to watch. With all due respect to Genevieve, Katie Cassidy IS Ruby.
Kate Cassidy was my favorite Ruby!
Can supernatural just snatch katie from arrow and bring her back to supernatural? Because clearly she gets treated better at SPN
Treated better as in getting fired because Supernatural couldn’t keep her character due to budgetary reasons? Nah. Neither show deserves Katie.
If only the Winchesters were a little bit open-minded back then, they befriended king of hell later but gave ruby a hard time. If they accepted Ruby, they would have sought for ways to revert her back to human again . They would have found human blood injection method way earlier and turn her back into a human again, like they did with crowley and deamon.
I never noticed that she's the same girl from Arrow, Laural Lance.
+jockadoobee what plastic surgery... she literally looks the same
Not plastic surgery. Massive weight loss and muscle gain from being on Arrow
Not to mentions she's like 10 years younger here
Me too, i just randomly found out. I was a big fan of Ruby but no so much of Laurel tho.
How can I love this Ruby so much but hate Laurel so bad?!😫They're the same person!!!
I agree with you so much!! I really enjoyed watching her play ruby
ForeverStar 21 They're 2 completely different characters... that's a stupid point.
+ForeverStar 21 The writers sux ass that's why, Laurel is bat shit crazy, and changes personality each season
No! I think she is an amazing character in both Supernatural and Arrow!
ForeverStar 21 you hate Laurel?!
Best of the two Rubies. Love her as "Black Siren" (Black Canary 2) on Arrow.
Well, Ruby's vessel is beautiful. Ruby herself...not so much.
By far the hottest Ruby, and this one was the first, the original
man I really loved first ruby in supernatural. i wish she was on sam and dean's side.
Always did loved first Ruby.
omg I never realized she was Laurel from Arrow...
yea. I was shocked as hell!
did you know that young Mary Winchester plays that one cupid bad guy in Arrow as well? I cant remember what the name of the character was
Tiffany Malm no I didn't know. Wow. They really have changed
Tiffany i knew i recognized her lol
I feel the same way. I knew Laurel looked familiar
O-M-F-G!! I knew i've seem Laurel from Arrow somewhere... I can't believe she was Ruby, i loved her back then lmao. How could i not remember right away o.o
Wow Katie looks sooo different I cant even recognize her!!! But her voice is pretty much the same it’s just matured a bit over the years
Katie Cassidy is best
really very beautifull
Every season Sam gets his ass kicked.
kate cassidy is good as this ruby why did they use someone else in the other seasons
Hottest actress on supernatural ever!!!!!!
I agree too! The blonde Ruby gave off a more awesome feeling and Katie Cassidy was so boss in the role. But still Genevieve Cortes (Padalecki) is still an amazing woman outside her character :)
I love this version of Ruby, and missed her so much 😭😭😭 Gen was pretty and delivered her own version of Ruby (and there might be change on the script of this character's purpose in S4) and it's good, but I'd definitely grow to love Ruby through Katie's over the second one..
(don't get me wrong because I like Gen too she's a good actress, only that I preferred the Katie's version of the role 😊)
Black canary
0:03, 0:06-0:09, 0:23-0:24, 0:26-0:32, 0:42-0:48, 0:51-0:59, 1:01-1:03, 1:07, 1:10-1:16. 1:28-1:29, 1:33, 1:43, 1:48-1:55, 2:05-2:13, 2:18-2:47, 2:51-2:55, 3:05-3:06, 3:29-3:31, 3:33, 3:39-3:44
Katie Cassidy is so much prettier than the other girl that played Ruby.
I know right
Sterling Pierce yes thaes right
Goddamn I loved Katie Cassidy.
Love Ruby and San winchester♥
I loooove Katie Cassidy and Lauren Cohan... Since i have a broken leg i stay home all the day, and i watch supernatural (all the day) and i dream about Ruby on the night lol. If Supernatural producers read this : bring back Bobby, Bela and Ruby(K Cassidy) Okay ??
Why not Genevieve;)
1:38 I laughed so hard
Talent...
She's gorgeous
The host may be attractive, but the demon itself doesn't have an appearance.
She's evil in supernatural, at least she died a hero as the black canary
I love both Rubies
Me too she was the best
Dang, I didn't realize she was Laurel in Arrow until I was watching a rerun of Supernatural. Then I noticed the resemblance and checked iMDB.
2:57. because I knew SAM wouldn't listen!
Funny thing is as boneheaded as Dean looked in this scene, he was right about all of it at the end.
sam sould have married this ruby insted of the other one.
i love it when katie plays in roles like this, I love her but i hate horror movies and that’s the majority that she plays in, ik SPN and Arrow aren’t far from it but they’re different😂😂
This Ruby was powerful and persuasive. The second was weak.
She is so young
Stop at 2:12
Incredible-awesome-beautiful face...
Katie's awesome.
Katie cassidy version of ruby is kind of bossing dean around so the very first demon azeal eyes demon death and lilth eye color is white while lilth prossening ruby on this season 3 ep
i wish katie as ruby and sam would get together :(
This ruby way hotter and way better
So while Oliver Sara were presumed dead laurel was possessed by ruby
Katie Cassidy was ridiculously hot at this point in her life. She is nowhere near this level in arrow. I swear she messed with her face or something
Lol she said she wanted Lilith dead, and she wasn't lying.
I Think she played with ruby better then laurel in arrow
Alba what about Black Siren?
She was the only one who played Ruby🥺
The superior Ruby! Supernatural fucked up when they replaced her.
Katie was so young here
LAUREL
Erm demon, manipulative is kind of in the job description
Aw, cut the best part out...
I much preferred this Ruby. Don’t like the replacement one. She’s obviously beautiful but I just wasn’t feeling her as the character.
Queen
ya i aggre the reason i guess the used the other ruby is that she is sam wife in real life.
i way rather have this ruby than the ugly one well other pretty one that other one is a 8/10 this ones a 12/10
Katie Cassidy.
Wow... You're stuck in '07, aren't you? Ruby is gone and so is Kripke...
she wasn't talking about Genevieve.
Laurel lance ♥
Yes she's a prtge
Because ruby traded bodies
punch comes next
Hey your talkin about Jared's wife the new ruby is
Is your refrigerator running
Why did she leave? The actress
sup Laural?
OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!......LAUREL WAS RUBY....She was ruby...
EPIC RUBY !!!!!!!!!
.Arrow SUCKS... she is badass
Why the hell did she leave?
Back when the show aired her character wasn’t as well liked as it is now so they told Katie that they were cutting her pay way down. When she got mad (as one would) they offered to let her out of her contract and so she left. I read that on a different video but I think it’s true.
@@sethsur8477 that’s crazy. Man Katie Cassidy was so damn good in this show as the original Ruby. Such a waste of huge talent from her. I can’t believe she got dismissed. 😖😞
also sams RL wife.
better than laurel hah
I don't care if Ruby's a demon I'd still... you know. Lemme ask a question: in the world of Supernatural can human males and demon females mate? Anybody?
Brunette was super hot