The Debate Between Rabbi Mizrachi with a Skeptic (Designer Barhami Hakakian)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 гру 2014
- Follow up with the skeptic can be viewed here:
• Aftermath of the debat...
Rabbi Mizrachi is a world renowned speaker proving that the Torah given to us by Moshe is divine without any doubt. Visit www.divineinformation.com/ for other lectures, events, DVD's, and more!
im not jew. im a Math teacher. i have to admite, this rabbi proof me there is a creator
Better than a world cup soccer match!
It is hard to prove that the carbon dating of dinosaurs 🦖🦕 are only 4000 years old. Noachs ark must have been for local animals only and I think it's impossible to fit all animal pairs onto a man made boat. That's over 5 million species.
@@noahqyain7311 you have to understand that some animals came from 1 animal, you didn't have 5 million species in Noah's time, you had at least 50, or even maybe 30
@@HKBH736
It is impossible to know how many animals existed in the past.
What about plants? How could they recover from the flood?
@noahqyain7311 Not all species are the size of elephants.
Birds had the rafters, etc.
And, suppose some of the species were miraculously gnome or DNA?
The Ark, The Flood, all were miracles.
I love how the Rabbi isn't phased by ego games. They try so hard to pull him into it but he doesn't even flinch.
He's a tough cookie like Trump and other people with high emotional intelligence
Rabbi Mizrachi speaks the truth, in absolute terms. This gentleman had no business speaking on these topics, he showed a lack of education, research, and confidence in his approach.
My question is why doesn’t the rabbi debate someone more competent
@@juvileebecause he cares about making Jews religious not to argue with atheists who will not change their mind.
@@uria702 Note how I didn't say "atheist".
Amazing patience the rabbi has. Great man.
Moshe is proud of him!
@@lutchdomanengroomupadiachy7281 he is Moshe
@@johnlopez5777 hes not
I’m not jewish, but Rabbi Mizrachi made me a believer on the one true G’d of Israel, he knocked it out the park...
He means well but some things he said are at best not factual. He mentioned that a man survived falling from the twin towers and he said Hitler may have had Jewish blood. Both are wrong.
@@noahqyain7311 Sorry but both claims are 100% correct. A man named Pasquale Buzelli is one of 16 survivors of the Twin Towers collapse. And Hitler's maternal grandmother had jewish blood
Rabbi Mizrachi illustrates his points calmly and sharp as a tack, without the need to misuse complicated words. The skeptic is dogmatic, diffuse, and needlessly emotional. It's frustrating to watch because he constantly keeps throwing the debate off-tangent and keeps cutting the rabbi off.
He couldn't disprove anything the Rabbi said then at the end he says he is not qualified to argue. Debate lost.
Dear Rabbi....your a true man of God...you did a great job!!! I been listening to your lectors the last seven years...the best investment for my soul!!!!
The "skeptic" is not aggressive and idt he is a scientist 🥼 at best he isn't well versed in rhetoric.
Not Jewish but I enjoy watching the rabbi's videos
@@altinokz
My skeptical and rational journey led me to become an atheist, anti-theist and anti-Judaist (the Jewish religion is a major reason why other primitivities exist; Christianity and Islam). I dislike all religions, and I dislike Judaism the most.
@@altinokz
The Torah is nothing more than a compilation of primitive writings compiled by different authors, and the modern scholarly consensus is that no such Moses figure existed (or that an Exodus event ever happened). Absolutely no Egyptian document records such a major event as the Exodus describes (it was nothing more than a pretentious history written for a pretentious people (the Israelites were originally Canaanites; self-hating Canaanites). Modern archeology, history, and chemistry are in disagreement with the biblical narratives (most of the writings in the Tanakh contradict each other, it is made up of different books by different authors with different theological doctrines). El the supreme god in the Canaanite pantheon was the original God of the Israelites (Isra"el"), YHWH was introduced to the Israelites later in history, and the Israelites grew attached to the god concept that is YHWH. They loved that concept so much that they merged El with YHWH, El was just another name for YHWH when Yahwism became dominant in Israel's early history (3,000 years ago). Modern linguistics and archeology show that the Israelites were originally Canaanites, even the Hebrew language was originally referred to in the Tanakh as the "language of Canaan", and it became known as "Hebrew" later on. The Book of Genesis was written around the time when the Jews were exposed to Zoroastrianism, and while Josiah did make Yahwism into a strictly henotheistic religion (and also may have been responsible for the creation of the immoral Book of Joshua), the Jews coming across the Zoroastrian religion transformed their religion into a monotheistic one. Most of the supposed "prophecies" in the Bible were documented much after the times they were claimed to have traditionally been put into place, and much of this is of many examples of something known as post-diction. I do not read the Torah in the traditional manner that many delusional Jews do, I prefer to take the Torah and Tanakh to a critical and skeptical approach. Your analogy was pointless, and I do not want to continue this discussion further with you, I am not in a very positive mood right now, and you are simply not worth my time.
@@altinokz
Also: do not lecture me in how the Hebrew Bible is different from the Christian Bible, I am well aware of the differences, and the grammar (nouns, verbs, syntactic structures etc.). I have the Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, and this is the fourth edition of the scholarly examination of the Hebrew Bible that is based off of the Leningrad Codex (Masoretic Text), I anticipate for the arrival of the Biblia Hebraica Quinta. I am also familiar with the Greek language (just as I, to an extent, know some of the contents presented in the oldest translation of the Hebrew Bible (Septuagint/LXX), and I am somewhat familiar with Aramaic (including its Syriac variants (Eastern and Western). I am finished conversing with you.
@@methodius8472 your name doesn’t seem to fit your narrative. You say there’s no proof of Moses of an exodus? Ok then explain how the world was created and how humans came into the world. And how are you living now
@@methodius8472 How can you explain that science PROOVES the Torah??
You are a genius Rabbi..that is why I listen to your 3 lessons daily..Very bright very gifted. You made renounce messianic Judaism Christianity..May HASHEM continue to be with you and your family...I am a Kenyan in Nairobi but now Jew. I know HASHEM will help to get conversion.
Chabad of Kenya - Chalbi Dr, Nairobi, Kenya . Look them up they can help with conversion if you are serious.
It is true that arrogance blinds people. How is it that Barhami Hakakian dares to go to a debate referring to the Tanakh without even having read all the Tanakh? Can't accept the answers because the ego doesn't allow it
it is delightful to witness two people with totally opposite views, discuss in such decent respectful manner, not interrupting each other... please allow me to express sincere gratitude to BOTH !!!
Shabbat Shalom! Rabbi Yosef Mizrachi, from South Africa & thank you for sharing this excellent debate with your followers
God Bless Israel!
Not the best choices to argue age of earth or evolution.
Rabbi Mizrachi is very knowledgeable, the ''designer'' got his mind big banged handed in a platter of Torah truth.
If someone will say judaism is fake, i will show them this video.
Everyone should love rabbi Yosef great men
Baruch hashem. Beautiful job rabbi mizrachi. Hashem should continue to bless you with this special gift of being able to show ppl the truth
He brought his iPad with a blank page. it's frustrating to see someone try to argue with the rabbi who doesn't know what he is fighting for and is trying to argue something he doesn't know 1% about great job rabbi
You're jealous for some reason.
The rabbi is brilliant
He is brilliant at rhetoric. He is well meaning.
I have not always believed in creation, now that I do, i can't understand why people don't believe. no mater what the Rabbi says this skeptic is blinded from the truth.
Good Job Rabbi, Hakaki just wanted to be heard on your network.
Fear of God is the beginning of wisdom.Bravo Rabbai.God bless Israel.
I looooooove you rabbi mizrachi may are great G-D give you long life and great health to continue teaching and reviling the TRUTH!
Rhonda L just because you have a question doesn't mean you can believe in a lie. It was already known to our forefathers that the temple will be destroyed it's not the animal that's the main thing it's keeping the Torah and having our heart connected to god, orthodox Judaism is doing just that. an example to this is rabbi mizrachi I suggest you listen to what he says
Rhonda L no need to baptize your fallowing a made up custom the new testament is not from GD so I won't read it .gd said clearly that there's no other except him what you believe is a forum of idle worship which is one of the greatest sins . there are over 80,000 religions and cults don't be fooled . the Torah was given in front of millions of men women and children and GD said it will never be changed .
Rhonda L if GD would want us to fallow j then GD would appear again and tell us that he is making a complete change and deleting almost all the laws and commandments that he gave.
If he doesn't do that that means we are fallowing something that he forbids and wrote about many times not to fallow strange GDS and false prophets. People can say what they want but the truth won't change. Your belief is like the rest of the 80,000 that don't have a national Revelation like GD did one time and gave the Torah to the people that were living in that moment. The differents between us is that you think GD the creator of all needs js because there's no temple... We know that even without a template if we keep all the laws were still going to be OK gd doesn't need help.
Rhonda L rabbi mizrachi has many lectures in Divine information.com and all over UA-cam and some of his lectures talk about your questions . prayer isn't enough you need to keep the seven laws that the Gentiles were commanded to keep . if your mother is Jewish then you are a Jew and you need to keep all the laws that are written in the Torah there are obviously more details ... I appreciate your honesty I agree that the world doesn't look good ...
G-d Bless Israel!
one of the Best debates I've ever seen. Shalom!
I think Rabbi Mizrachi mispoke around the 16 minute mark when he said most scientists say that Earth is 4 million years old, it is agreed upon by most scientists that the Earth is around 4.54 billion years old, with a 50 million year margin of era.
Each time the man open his mouth, it makes the rabbi more intelligent. Everytime rabbi answer, i learned 😁
Of course God exists as the magnificent Creator of all good things. All praise to God. 🙏🏻🕊
the problem with humans, all humans that when the heart is inlove with some idea they can not see the lies and the mistakes. its like a girl or a boy that has a crash, they just cannot see if he/she is good for them or not. blinded.
the first question to start a debate is are you a lawer or a judge.? cos a lawer will never admit he is wrong.
a judge will (if he is honest)
i did tshuva cos i saw judasim
has all the answers!
the only thing I can admire about Hakakian is his chutzpah to take on this Giant of knowledge -
Nah you should not admre anything about him, he is my uncle
He is an atheist and a moron who pretends to be intelligent, he is a moron and it is now preserved on the internet for all to see
There is something wrong with people nwho arr adults and atheist..
He is a fake guy,
You're doing a great job Rabbi Yosef. I just wanna add, before time there is one more thing God created first and without it there is no beginning of creation and that is the Hebrew Language. And I learned that from another non-jewish brialliant man.
Great wisdom, Rabbi Yosef Mizrachi. GOD Bless You from the Philippines. 🙏
This poor naive kohen...I really hope he comes around. "A kohen is a terrible thing to waste"...
What is a Kohen please??
@@funbrothers5457essentially a priest in the English translation that was and will be a high worker in the house of g-d from the past and future houses
@@thesportsapex1787 is that the definition of a Kohen?
@@funbrothers5457 Yes
Rabbi, I'm wondering why you are debating with him he doesn't answer one straight answer.
i want to see this rabbi vs dawkins...it would be great ill pay the 60 bucks ppv lol
I TRULY ENJOYED THIS DEBATE...
thank you for clarify that small detail .
Dear Rabbi or other debate viewers ,Tell us please , what is the name of the scientist and the name of the film about the objections against creation speculations . Thank you
G-d bless Hacham Mizrahi! the other guy is eloquent but trapped in his desire to remain uncommited to the truth.
this designer does not deserve the rabbis attention for 2 hours. the rabbi also has amazing patience. i would have lost my temper and let him know what a babbling fool he is
LOVE, LOVE, LOVE IT.....THANK YOU ...
I laughed so much by you telling the truth. 😂😀
Some people are just ignorant, because they don't want to accept the shame on themselves that they have been wrong for all those years.
But I tell you something: Better to have shame in this world, than to have shame after your soul left your body, because that shame will be much much worse.
Thanks you for video and G-d bless you all!
wow very very interesting, watched 30 mins so far, will continue in few days later, have a quest. Chanukah sameach!
This shouldn’t be titled a debate , it was more like an education. He may chose to not listen But he heard.
Nah, he didn't hear,he is a moron
always good thanks
Amazing, Rabbi
im a christian and i like you!!! good words!!
Did you watch rabbi mizrachi debate a Christian?
Amazing!!!!!!!!
GREAT! Thank you Rabbi
Rabbi, this is such a waste of your time. This guy "wants' to appear intelligent but full of contradictions. very funny...
+Mark Koyenov No such thing as a waste of time. The only waste is no time at all.
R. Mizrachi's right, every time! The skeptics will turn when the Messiah comes.
beautifully explained Rabbi
Great job Rabbi. There are two types of people Judges and Lawyers. Judges are genuinely looking for the truth whereas Lawyers don't care they just want to convince others. Before conducting a debate always get a commitment from the other to have an open mind and have a discussion as to what would constitutes proof. I can't help but think that the opposition just doesn't want to feel stupid and accept your argument. You must first address his ego.
Ignorance is man's biggest enemy, I used to be christian and the one thing I have realized more then ever after I became B'nei Noach is that some people choose to be ignorant of the Truth no matter how much proof you show them. I understand why Jews don't do evangelism like christians, it's a waste of time to try and convince someone who chooses to be ignorant. Thank you Rabbi Mizrachi.
Rabbi speaks truth 💙shalom💙
Mazel tov to rabbi Yosef mizrahi he is very good 👍 lecturer and well informed Torah Talmud Zohar scholar in Judaism Baruch hashem we are lucky to such Torah scholar thanks again for your video love & best wishes from Pakistani mashadi Jew shabbat ❤️💓❤️💓✋ shalom ❣️🙏 ❣️ Shahbaz gondal queens new York America
What’s the update on this guy did he become religious?
SO PROFOUND
Thank You
i think that it would be a good idea for Mr Hakakian to study the works Lubavitcher Rebbe and the books of Rabbi Avigdor Miller both ZTL
advisors to scientists. These matters are explained extensively. Thank you Rabbi Mizrachi ,may HASHEM BLESS YOU
The moderator should not have let the skeptic get away with the " no bones " proposition.
He kept going strong on the point because he wasn't told to stop due to the fact that it is an illogical point; that if applied consistently, we would question the existence of thousands of prominent people written about in history, as well as billions of " ordinary people!! "
Thank You, Rabbi...
Rabbi, don't debate this kind of man
The Torah is One, our God is One and His people are One. Chema Israel Hachem Elohenou, Hachem Ehad !
Amazing.
This guy has a brain of a 2 year old .. love you rebbe
Wow! They could not understand between the physical and spiritual world. It is so clear when Rabbi said spiritual doesn’t have time.
It was a very good lecture by the rabbi, Mr. Brahami did not raise it to a debate level. the Rabbi impressed me with the amount he retains from his sciences studies. A Couple of points 1. Math is not science but a tool of science 2. Science starts with a question followed by a theory followed by experiments followed by a conclusion with a stated level of certainty, but things changed. Since Darwin followed by Albert, a theory with zero proof is called science. TY.
Blessed are You HaShem our LORD for intelligence. LORD, Thank You truth is obvious, a lack is too. Blessed are You HaShem LORD, I pray for Israel and the peace for Your nation. I Love You ABBA
how come this guy can't be like a normal person and just watch Torah and science it's not that hard
Rabbi please answer me I have seen nowdays many Rabbi they shave thier beard and cut the sidelock of their hair including you as well... according to Torah Leviticus 19:27 you should not shave your beard or cut the sidegrowth of your hair... please answer
You can't understand one verse in the Torah without the Oral Torah explanation. The verse means you cannot destroy your/sidelocks by completely uprooting them with a fine razor. You can get a haircut scissors or a machine that doesn't give a close cut.
@@tylerg2951 indeed you are allowed to cut but not razor
Thank you Rabbi! ✨️💎✨️
“It’s better to know then to believe”
Thanks alot . I understand and I am trying to conversion.
2:45:00 Awesome ♥️
“Religion is the daughter of hope and fear explaining to ignorance the nature of the unknowable.” Ambrose Bierce -
The designer is a nice man, his understandings are secular, everything derives from that orientation. He doesn't want to be called a hillbilly by his friends by acknowledging G-d, so let him be happy. At worst he is misguided but still he must acknowledge his souls. It has been said that fashion is a death every change of clothes. I am sure Hashem loves this man and will eventually make him aware. As for Rabbi Mizrachi, his arguments are so quietly simple that only a secularist could be confused. But as for the designer (ironic huh?), his outer boundaries are science, and science's opinions are flavor of the day, as are the dictates of the fashion world. So I understand that too. Mr. Hakakian is a decent man and his behavior is good, so with such a man you can have differing opinions over a period of days. His emphasis is on reconciling Torah to secular learning; Torah doesn't change, we don't investigate G-d.
Unfortunately many rejected G-d in the Persian Jewish community after loving under a religious government in Iran
It is always worth his time, to rescue another fellow Jew, and in this case he is Kohen descendant, correct if I am wrong, Many skeptics have this same arguments, so hopefully many see and confirm that Torah is divine.
Rabbi is using complete logic, he is the master of logic in arguing. Love him.
I have watched 38 minutes of this and I think that Rabbi is wasting his time with this fellow, they’re still on the first question
Wouldn't having a good calculation of the lunar month only prove that they were calculating it for a while? Or is he claiming that God inspired this rabbi to know the answer?
No he is claiming that the shortest possible lunar time was passed down in the oral tradition starting with Moses at Sinai for over 1500 years until this story happened and the story was recorded in the Talmud.
Mizrachi is brilhant
this guy (the one the rabbi is debating) I'm sorry the rabbi keeps saying he's a smart man but he sounds a bit dumb to me. to explain what I mean would take to long but if you get what i mean...
+Eli Fried I found the Rabbi's calling the designer "clever" repeatedly was a skilled use of irony because of that term's ability to connote both intelligence as well as distrustworthiness.
16:23 is the best part.
I love Rabbi Mizrachi. We can learn Torah all day and night but the Beracha he has is to explain these extremely difficult concepts in Judaism to people who haven’t learned any Torah in years sometimes decades.
All the answers from The Rabbi was very clear, and I cannot believe this other guy was serious, please tell me he was a joke, because even to speak he took so long , he didn't even know what to say, and because he does not want to admit that the Rabbi is right , he keep going around and around talking no sense. I don't wanna disrespect nobody , but come on, even my 6 years old understood better, and this guy does not even have his on opinion, all he keep saying is : I'm not qualify to answer or to say anything, if you wanna find an excuse to not believe in the Creator or that the Torah is not divine, you can , because it's easier to leave without guidance and spirituality, because you have your own opinion about creation , because the ego is so big that is not going to let you see the truth.It's easier to find ways not to believe in G-D than just accept what is so clear like clean water. Don't let your ignorance kill your soul.
The bottom line is that people just can't even get over the first commandment.
The Rabbi was very clear but that other guy doesn't know what he is talking about.why would a designer come into an argument with a Rabbi really?
Wow it was so tough listening to that guy talk he gave me such brain damage couldn’t answer a single simple logical question wow this wasn’t even a debate idk why the rabbi wasted his time with this fool
This guy should stick to fashion nothing else
Love Rabbi
I love when the student in the audience told him he got you 😅
The planet is a dynamic being and I have every reason to believe that science may be wrong on many subjects but...
Debate? What debate...
There are skeptics and then there are professional skeptics this one is a dishonest professional skeptic. The Talmud states clearly "Lo ro'isi ayn oriah' translation - saying I haven't seen it is no proof that it does not exist. This guy just will not get off his issue of no bones in the desert.
Deserts are the result of ancient mining.
Shalom rabbi h
Rabbi vs Dawkins please
And the oral torah came before the written, because the words need to be said prior to writing, the Torah if formal law the oral is the teaching
Only a Creator would know how many trees to put on Earth for if there were too many, there would be too much oxygen and the earth would blow up, and the opposite, if there weren't enough trees you would be lacking oxygen to breathe.
So a Rabbi is in a debate with a slumlord? Do I have that right?
science lies. torah is truth
Exactly!! "Science" tells us something one week, and then tells us that what they told us the previous week is WRONG, and they've found "new" evidence, and we should now believe this "new" thing that they've found!! PREPOSTEROUS!!! Atheists don't think back far enough as to WHO created "Science"!!!
It's amazing how people never read the five books of Torah in Judaism even once,but deny everything in it..lolololol
this guy doesnt have the attention span to argue with a biblical mastermind
About Torah codes - it is simply fallacious, since our Masoretic Text is not the only text that exists.
The Talmudic version of Tanach was a bit different.
Therefore, most probably, in Talmud times, Torah codes did not exist.