Should transgender women be able to compete in women’s sports?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 11 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 139

  • @Quahogger
    @Quahogger 14 днів тому +10

    Absolutely Not. They are male. They are not being denied sport participation they are not women and don’t belong on a women’s team. It’s unfair. Volleyball nets are 7 inches lower in women’s volleyball.

  • @gmr7494
    @gmr7494 14 днів тому +30

    Put it to a public vote. I guarantee you it'll be a resounding NO! People are sick of these woke politics!

    • @Tamara-qd5dc
      @Tamara-qd5dc 14 днів тому +2

      We need a proposition for 2026. California will vote for the women and against woke.

  • @VeronicaLopez-qu9xb
    @VeronicaLopez-qu9xb 15 днів тому +30

    The fact that you have low testosterone now doesn't mean you didn't go thru male puberty your muscles have already been developed.

  • @henryt9281
    @henryt9281 14 днів тому +21

    Absolutely not. And I hope the new presidency ends this charade once and for all.

  • @craigfuller1532
    @craigfuller1532 14 днів тому +28

    They are not women.

  • @DesignDelineations
    @DesignDelineations 14 днів тому +8

    "Should MEN be able to compete in women’s sports?" I thought you all believed that science is real...

    • @LizTyler-f4q
      @LizTyler-f4q День тому

      Trans WOMEN and men ARE ✨DIFFERENT ✨. Both bodies don’t work the same, atleast not anymore. When was the last time you picked up and book and read about this

  • @Beonaire
    @Beonaire 15 днів тому +28

    NO. NO NO. NO. NO. NO I CAN'T
    EXPRESS THAT ENOUGH NO 🎉❤🎉

  • @maxm9124
    @maxm9124 15 днів тому +36

    We have Special Olympics for a reason, so why not create a trans sport division. It's the only logical answer

    • @enrijuan96
      @enrijuan96 14 днів тому

      Is there enough athletes and money for that? Why not just have a Coed league instead of all male league? Then trans athletes can compete there. That’s the most logical solution based on funds/fairness.

    • @EnlistedBombin
      @EnlistedBombin 14 днів тому

      ​@@enrijuan96 Take it from male sports huh? What ever your XX or Xy is the sport you should play. Does not matter what kinda of modification you make.

    • @chrisconsorte7893
      @chrisconsorte7893 14 днів тому

      That’s what I’ve argued as well. It could be $$$, but it may solve the issue.

    • @patrick4662
      @patrick4662 14 днів тому

      Because there are only like 50 of them.

    • @didymosprasinos
      @didymosprasinos 14 днів тому +1

      THIS COMMENT IS THE ANSWER!

  • @americangirl6654
    @americangirl6654 14 днів тому +13

    NO! Of course not. How is this even a question?

  • @JS-mh1fh
    @JS-mh1fh 15 днів тому +22

    No. Testosterone makes a difference. Simply, create trans teams. Btw, I played h.s. volleyball.

    • @chinatownboy7482
      @chinatownboy7482 15 днів тому +6

      When a trans player hits a hall, there's more strength behind it. There will be concussions.

    • @alyssashady
      @alyssashady 14 днів тому +1

      Women have testosterone.

    • @alyssashady
      @alyssashady 14 днів тому +1

      @@chinatownboy7482 So?

    • @izoedyourbabydaddy7628
      @izoedyourbabydaddy7628 14 днів тому

      ​@@chinatownboy7482 People get injured in sports are we going to ban all sports with a history of injuries ?

    • @brandanhall7189
      @brandanhall7189 7 днів тому

      @@izoedyourbabydaddy7628 If this is all your focusing on, you are gravely missing the point.

  • @Idontcare-g1n
    @Idontcare-g1n 14 днів тому +14

    No, they aren't women

  • @frankmorrow3701
    @frankmorrow3701 13 днів тому +3

    No, no and NO!!!

  • @DoOneMore150
    @DoOneMore150 14 днів тому +4

    100% no

  • @OakDM83
    @OakDM83 14 днів тому +8

    By definition they aren’t as birth female.

  • @Ang.0910
    @Ang.0910 14 днів тому +7

    No. They need their own league

  • @billmadison9010
    @billmadison9010 12 днів тому +1

    I feel bad for the woman who got her spot taken by a man.

  • @FGCScrub
    @FGCScrub 14 днів тому +12

    No. Next question

  • @danielavila5081
    @danielavila5081 14 днів тому +8

    Should Mike Tyson identify as a woman and box against real women ??

    • @fannyduarte4944
      @fannyduarte4944 13 днів тому +2

      Great answer. 😂. And a great example! I don't know why these people don't get it!

    • @sarbantz
      @sarbantz 10 днів тому

      Please, all of you in the comments who misgendered this incredible athlete and wonderful soul, please apologize asap and we will not report you to UA-cam.

    • @brandanhall7189
      @brandanhall7189 8 днів тому

      @@sarbantz Again, you already posted this. Is this all you plan on doing is threaten people because their opinion is different than yours. Come on grow up. I am now including what I wrote in your other post. Sure, threaten everyone that are just answering the question and stating their commonsense opinion, like that is going to solve anything. In my observations, this is how most supporters of the transgender movement react to an opinion that doesn't agree with them, they make threats and cause contention and make matters worse. If they are calling someone who was born a male, a male, or someone born a female, a female, then they are not misgendering the person. You and everyone else are in titled to their own opinion, respect that and move on.

  • @_CatBug_
    @_CatBug_ 14 днів тому +2

    DSM5 says enough. Idk why these supporters don't understand this.

  • @ingeborgbrodersen1718
    @ingeborgbrodersen1718 13 днів тому +2

    It’s cheating

  • @_ac_7649
    @_ac_7649 14 днів тому +5

    No way san jose

  • @OakDM83
    @OakDM83 14 днів тому +4

    I’d love for the NCAA to rule on any man who identifies as a female being allowed to play women’s collegiate sports…

  • @ronin5510
    @ronin5510 14 днів тому +7

    No

  • @neldog510
    @neldog510 14 днів тому +6

    No...

  • @OakDM83
    @OakDM83 14 днів тому +4

    Katie Oleksak is clearly ignorant in what is safe and fair in the broad base of women’s sports and hasn’t had to press this issue in a personal way. Her standard of perfection would be everyone her height and power playing on a uniform team… That is the opposite of competition, just ask any player or coach!

    • @brandanhall7189
      @brandanhall7189 8 днів тому

      Katie Oleksak, was stating thing as if they were equal not on fairness. If you noticed she didn't answer the reporter's question about if transgender woman should be allowed play in woman's sports. She said that they should be allowed to play in sports. There is a difference. Of, course they should be allowed to play in sports just not woman's sports. I wish that the reporter would have caught her on that and had her answer the question correctly.

  • @ingeborgbrodersen1718
    @ingeborgbrodersen1718 13 днів тому +2

    Omg it’s so woke

  • @jmont1031
    @jmont1031 14 днів тому +6

    Allowing transgender females to play against biological females is unfair. Especially for high school and younger but also in college.

  • @gabrielsf70
    @gabrielsf70 15 днів тому +6

    I fully support opportunities for women in sports and have no objection to individuals competing in male sports if they meet the necessary qualifications. However, Title IX exists to ensure fair opportunities and protections for women in athletics. Allowing individuals who have undergone male puberty to compete in women’s sports raises concerns about fairness and equity.

    • @alyssashady
      @alyssashady 14 днів тому +2

      She is still a woman though. It isn't fair to deny her from competing with her sex.

    • @moogs
      @moogs 14 днів тому

      This makes no sense. Then males can complete on women’s teams then it’s all done….

    • @izoedyourbabydaddy7628
      @izoedyourbabydaddy7628 14 днів тому

      This is untrue a trans athlete competed and she hadn't undergone male puberty. Guess what people still claimed she had an unfair advantage.

    • @alyssashady
      @alyssashady 14 днів тому +1

      @@moogs She isn't male

    • @blutterfishful
      @blutterfishful 14 днів тому +5

      I don't think he is a woman. Genetically, he's still a man, no matter how many surgeries he's been through.

  • @iishyxvietxboyii1
    @iishyxvietxboyii1 14 днів тому +4

    Imagine boxing, lol. 😂

    • @Nogoingback424
      @Nogoingback424 14 днів тому

      The Olympics allowed it. Watch that for brutality.

  • @B.A.B.G.
    @B.A.B.G. 6 днів тому

    Answer: No, why is this even a question?

  • @waynecrockett2419
    @waynecrockett2419 8 днів тому

    No ,it's weak for people to say it's okay that a man who thinks he's a woman to play,people need to stop sitting on their brains

  • @bfranco1519
    @bfranco1519 14 днів тому +4

    N O!

  • @gregchristos8954
    @gregchristos8954 14 днів тому +4

    If "sport isn't fair" then why exactly are you bothering about limiting naturally produced testosterone? Why are you using reduced "testosterone levels" as a reason why it's okay to have men compete against women.
    Why are you excluding transgender "women" with high testosterone levels?
    The hypocrisy is beyond me.

  • @sarbantz
    @sarbantz 10 днів тому

    Please, all of you in the comments who misgendered this incredible athlete and wonderful soul, please apologize asap and we will not report you to UA-cam.

    • @brandanhall7189
      @brandanhall7189 8 днів тому

      Sure, threaten everyone that are just answering the question and stating their commonsense opinion, like that is going to solve anything. In my observations, this is how most supporters of the transgender movement react to an opinion that doesn't agree with them, they make threats and cause contention and make matters worse. If they are calling someone who was born a male, a male, or someone born a female, a female, then they are not misgendering the person. You and everyone else are in titled to their own opinion, respect that and move on.

  • @kjflyte5088
    @kjflyte5088 10 днів тому

    NO

  • @donaldharlan3981
    @donaldharlan3981 14 днів тому +5

    No

  • @crezildabarker
    @crezildabarker 7 днів тому

    NO

  • @erichernandez8883
    @erichernandez8883 14 днів тому +7

    No

  • @enrijuan96
    @enrijuan96 14 днів тому +5

    No

  • @Nogoingback424
    @Nogoingback424 14 днів тому +4

    No

  • @Ryan_McGee
    @Ryan_McGee 12 днів тому +1

    No

  • @dianebrady8789
    @dianebrady8789 12 днів тому +1

    No

  • @Findingmypiece
    @Findingmypiece 9 днів тому

    No

  • @lanouek
    @lanouek 7 днів тому

    No