It's really sad that they didn't have Bernadette illustrate them herself. She actually makes REALLY lovely watercolour illustrations for her outfit designs that are much better than the ones they show here.
I was thinking that! The illustrations were not consistent with the historian's commentary. Also, the historian herself is a brilliant artist who could have done a perfect job at depicting her own descriptions.
I was also coming to say that Bernadette is an accomplished historical illustrator, and it was insulting that Glamour didn’t spring for a bit cleaner job to go with her explanations!
I imagine the illustrator didn't get to hear Bernadette's commentary directly, probably just a brief list of bullet points or something. I definitely agree they should've evaluated and revised irst instead of committing 100% to inaccurate designs right off the bat.
Love how she stresses how important the silhouette would be for the tine and the person illustrating it does none of that... she is an excellent artist, just let her draw it!
Yeah, I saw that, especially in the outdoors wear... At first I thought I was just distracted when Bernadette talked about the silhouette, but then realized she said that outfit was close to accurate, and that that chest shalt be poofed, whereas the artist basically made a noodle, that stang :\
RilesSweetPea Gacha, Bernadette Banner, the historian, is a great illustrator, I think they meant that Glamour should have let the historian illustrate, so it would match the commentary
@@Sundgoti yes we have seen on her channel the high quality of artistic interpretations, she is perfectly capable of in order to illustrate her projects 😍😍😍
I've scrolled past this video so many times, but thankfully caught sight of a suspiciously Bernadette-seeming person at the bottom, and what do you know, it was!!!😂
"How accurate is her outdoors outfit?" Bernadette: Pretty accurate, a bit too fitting at the top, but we're not too off-path! "And her whimsical dress?" Bernadette: She... Has the good shoes... And a wide hat... And a parasol! I love Bernadette's energy when it comes to make a critique of an outfit :)
It's always a bit strange to suggest something is of the wrong period. I can understand that being anachronistic when the style only existed after the period in which it is supposedly set. But to have Victorian clothing in the Edwardian Era? Surely that was quite common. I'm 40, and have clothes going back 20 or more years, and if they're well made and still fit, many more people will have kept their suits and dresses. Do people in charge of making costumes take this in to account, or must everything be exactly of the fashion of the day?
_"This is what Mary Poppins would have looked like if she lived in history."_ No, that's what Mary Poppins would have looked like if she lived in a noir movie as a detective in an oversized trench-coat. It's like the illustrator didn't even listen to the video, it's honestly worse than the movie portrayal.
I could sketch a much better illustration and have the silhouette be more accurate to a proper historical figure with definitely more shape than a blob. They should hire an illustrator that listens to the historian.
Bernadette: They wore corsets with an hourglass shape and patted the bust to enhance that shape. Illustrator: Alright, so just a straight dress without any shape to it?
I am a bit surprised that they do not name the experts in the titles. I thought that the figure looked like Bernadette so I clicked on the video, but it was a bit hard to see with how small she was. I am sure that the audience would be greatly expanded if the lovely people were named to allow for better search and easier recognition. Because 'Fashion Expert' sounds clickbaity and not very interesting, but 'Fashion Expert Bernadette Banner' tells me that I NEED TO CLICK NOW.
And... hum... Excuse-me... "Fashion Expert" when your expert is a fashion *historian* , when you are fact-checking an outfit for *historical accuracy* , is like telling your croquembouche is made by the best cook in the land while it's made by the best *pastry chef* I mean... you can add more credibility to your show and didn't take the opportunity, Glamour...
Love this episode. The presenter’s tone is quite friendly, a bit humorous, and as though she is actually talking with you instead of being pedantic. Will watch anything you invite this presenter to do.
She is not just a "presenter", but a devoted and talented expert. I am glad and surprised to see Glamour use someone of her caliber for a change. And having been a BB fan since the beginning, she has matured into a marvelous "presenter" and it is a joy to see her poise catch up with her talent!
Please let Bernadette do some art for this series, as she once was a professional costume illustrator. The artist you currently have can't seem to get the silhouettes right, and the lines and details are very simplistic. It looks cartoonish and often un-period, and doesn't match in tone or style the expertise of the historians we see.
Although... i think it might be the intention to simplify the lines in the film. It is not uncommon to alter the clothing or backgrounds to match their overall story or mood of the film’
Grace Law I agree! The flat, almost over-saturated colours, thick lineart, stylised unappealingly, just, eugh. Bernadette is a fantastic artist. Fashion illustrations shouldn’t look like those Twinkl worksheets you get in primary school
Im just a beginner on watching her, but she makes historical clothing herself and tries to do it like how the people in those times would. Aka by hand or by a handcranked sewing machine
I wish they got Bernadette to do the illustrations, she's a fantastic artist and the drawings in this video don't really match with what she's is talking about, otherwise a great video and I hope they invite Bernadette back in the future.
I love how Bernadette mentions accommodations having to be made for all the dancing! Obviously this video *is* about sort of correcting or critiquing the costumes (not in a mean way, just discussing them), but it's nice that she mentioned the practicality. Which makes sense, as Ms Banner is a practical lady herself.
@@MossyMozart I’m a big fan of Raissa. Bernadette hosted her for a panel during CoCoVid earlier this year (though I believe she only kept it up on her channel for a few weeks, unfortunately).
How would someone do this 100 years into the future? “2010’s fashionable women frequently donned yoga pants of a stretchy Lycra fabric paired with a large baggy T-shirt of a cotton material. Athletic slides were essential to the completion of the outfit, purely for function.”
Hannah Helton * puts up photo of 2010 me in oversized hoodie, jeans, and flip flops * "So would you say this is historically accurate?" "Absolutely not. No care has been taken to seasonal accuracy, much less accuracy of the overall era."
and let me say it looks bad. The way she puts on makeup compliments her features and gives her face definition. With this makeup, she looks bland and washed-out. And it completely and utterly clashes with her outfit
San Ram Yes, Augusta Longbottom wears a hat with a stuffed vulture on it .It is stated in the prisoner of Askaban when Neville put his Grandmother clothes on Boggart Snape.
Yes! I always thought it was a magical fashion detail, something bizarre and ridiculous, but now I feel much better informed! She was following a muggle fashion!
@@NWolfsson (Edit; Sorry I am tired, I misread your comment as a question. I'll go to sleep now, sorry again) (Below is my response to a comment I read wrong.) She put on different make up. Her face looks more polished-pale. Normally (I hope I don't sound offensive) her face has the colour of flower. Here, her face radiates pearl-shine. That's why.
Perhaps I'm missing something, but which video would they have linked? None of the videos on her channel seem particularly linked with this one. I see nothing 1910s or Mary Poppins themed.
I think if they did hire a Bernadette as a artist as well, they would have to pay her mare💰!....( Even though this video would have got even more views)
It may have been cut for time or because it wasn't directly relevant. It's hard with people like Bernadette who almost always seems to have something interesting and informative to say but the editors most likely have to give back a video that fits within an approved length of time.
'Fashion expert checks Mary Poppins wardrobe' Me: nice WAIT. IS THAT BERNADETTE?!?!?!?!?! ive been a long time fan of Bernadette and love her videos. Much love❤
In her own videos she talk a lot faster and I'm not sure how but it makes it sound more authentic and less annoying. She definitely enjoys using her broad vocabulary and that can seem a bit pompous if it comes out as premeditated.
@@Hope-si1kb She REALLY is nice and fun to be around and her voice suits her and its really her - tho for this video someone apparently wanted her to slow down for some reason. she is Naturally that precise & carefull in her enunciation - unlike most people who speak fast & slur their words..
@@Hope-si1kb i agree. However, in her own youtube videos, the talks in a much more natural tone hence it sounded better and not forced--maybe the reason she sounded annoying in here is because she is expected to talk slower for the sake of audience, and it definitely interfere with her usual image and speech character
fun fact: Mary Poppins's costume designer was Julie Andrews husband. They met when they were just kids, and when Walt Disney offered Julie the part, he asked her what was his husband job. When she said that he was an aspiring costume designer, he told her to tell him to bring his portfolio to Disney studio. And well... the rest is history.
I'm the exception to the rule... It's just that when I comment on Bernadette's videos, I proof-read thrice and use online dictionaries to make sure my spelling and grammar is at least comprehensible, because frankly, she doesn't deserve my usual writing style.
Bernadette Banner is a shining dress historian star! Eloquently presented accurate information without sounding stuffy. Glamour, you would be very wise to have Ms. Banner do more costume and wardrobe fact check vignettes. As her subscribers know, she's the BEST!!!! P.S. She is an excellent illustrator/artist, too!
@@SwordsmanRyan I get what you mean, but there are caveats. She says she adopted it unintentionally, because of her frequent trips to live and study in the UK (London etc). She speaks well and enjoys using interesting vocab, and if you watch more of her videos it isn't as jarring as the first. I felt the same way in the first video I saw of hers, I disliked that she was "lying" with her voice type, but honestly I stayed subbed and watched more and now absolutely adore her, I hope she never changes for anyone. Just because she speaks differently than most New Yorkers doesn't mean what she is saying is wrong or unworthy. She knows a LOT of fashion history and loves to share it for free with others online, which is amazing, and any of her quirks just make her human. Just my 2 cents.
That's how you make someone check the historical accuracy of a look in the movie, congratulations, Bernadette! You can see she really knows what she's talking about, rather than someone who doesn't even know the difference between stays and a corset.
@@clairefazel8470 until about 1800, women wore garments that were known as (a pair of) stays or (a pair of) bodies. The term "corset" only came in later. the terms "stays" and "corset" are often used to differentiate between the pre-1800 and the post-1800 shape *its a bit more complicated than that but its a very basic explaination.. and if you are interested if fun Interesting things like that Do check out Bernadettes you tubes.. she is an AMAZING seamstress.. just understand she is a master in her craft and fun too..
@@clairefazel8470 stays were mostly used before 1800. The easiest way to determine them is that they have straps on the shoulders and they open up through laces at the back, and have a wooden busk in the front. They are also mostly stiffened with cords and has no metal. Corsets on the other hand has a metal busk and opens up at the front, and the lacing at the back is more for adjustment of the corset. They're also stiffened with whalebone.
This is the best of Glamor's "What they got wrong/right" videos! So happy they listened to their viewers & got someone that specializes in the time period in question for the characters the video is about. This is the first one that I feel no need to correct anything.
Regarding the “entire stuffed birds” Ms. Banner mentioned at 12:35: these highly elaborate hats may have been decorated with birds of paradise and similarly ostentatious tropical birds. The rarer the bird, the more en vogue the hat. This practice led directly to the founding of the Audubon Society. The desire to decorate one’s hat with an entire flock of bluebirds or a cloud of egret feathers was having devastating effects on bird populations.
If you're interested in the history of various uses for birds of paradise, you should read "The Feather Thief" which talks about the Victorian-style method of fly-fishing and features a person who robbed an important natural history museum to source bird feathers of this purpose. Amazing read about history and contemporary issues with "traditions" that harmed our world in the past.
Sorry but I hope you could do a different style of drawing for these series, the final drawings never really give the full sense what the outfit would have looked like in film.
Seeing these illustrations in the same video as Bernadette, knowing her drawing style, made me wish they had asked her to do it. Not to mention the walking suit looked more 1920's than 1910. They neglected the Edwardian silhouette features that are in the back!
For those who are interested in seeing a closer to history version of the Mary Poppins' Jolly Holiday dress, the presenter Bernadette Banner has recently finished with her reconstruction of the dress according to the historical aesthetics and silhouettes. 10/10 recommend watching it, her cinematography and explanations remain beautiful throughout much like her explanations in this video
I love her channel. She is so perky and well informed. I taught history and still write historical fiction. Clothing mattered and still matters because humans wear clothes.
as somebody has been following Bernadette for a few years, you can tell how nervous she is but she still braving through to get her information out in an informative way. very proud of her.
i came to say that i love these vids before watching and OMG, the support this woman has is great!!! i'll go check her videos after this. thanks to all the people that are recommending her!
Amazing, amazing, amazing! 😍My only point of critique: The lovely Bernadette should have drawn the illustrations. She has a very delicate, sophisticated style of drawing mannequins and fashion, the ones you used looked way too cartoony for the interesting topic and well-spoken delivery.
@@jasminey1589 That's true. Then again it's no big deal to digitalize a drawing. I guess it's about maintaining a consistent style throughout their series, and maybe an existing contract with a designer.
Excuse me as I Bernadette fangirl over here, and I absolutely love the idea of having Morgan Donner do a Sleeping Beauty analysis or getting Karolina Zebrowska or even Cathy Hay to do a segment on here!
It actually makes sense that Mary Poppins' "workaday" clothes would be a little simpler, narrower, and older than the fashion magazines, so the old hat is forgivable due to accuracy, as servant women often wore out of date clothes and cast offs.
@J Freed - I always referred to my offcut pieces of fabric as "remnants" as my grandmother always did. And now, in just a few short months of discovering the lovely Bernadette, "cabbage" they are now called.
How could I roast you, Bernadette? It's nice, informative, with lovely English. It's only weird to see you like an anchor woman with a sterile background.
A very interesting video. But, I must point out that Bernadette doesn't take into account that Mary Poppins is a Timelord and some deviation in historical accuracy should be forgiven as she was bound to get a few details incorrect. :D
Her hat being dated makes sense! Didn’t Bert recognise her when he started drawing the iconic silhouette of her hat? They’ve met before, years prior, and she would have been wearing the same hat for him to recognise it :)
Did anyone else notice that Bernadette usually talks like five times faster? Maybe they asked her to slow down but I love the way she talks in her videos
FREAKING FINALLY! Thank you for picking a historian who knows the Era you have her talking about! I love Bernadette. AND A GOOD ARTIST? Who made this series good? I want to shake their hand!
Bernadette: emphasises silhouette
Illustrator: this shapeless blob is what was described
😂🙄
+
This comment made me laugh for a few minutes. So, thanks for that.
It's really sad that they didn't have Bernadette illustrate them herself. She actually makes REALLY lovely watercolour illustrations for her outfit designs that are much better than the ones they show here.
Omg Andrews knickers!
When?
I wish they had let Bernadette draw these... She’s a good illustrator
That was my thought as well.
Perhaps next time!
I would have preferred that too.
Oh! Such a good idea
agreed!
Bernadette: it looked like this
Illustrator: I do what I want
Lol
Lmaooo
This got me
Let’s be honest, we are all here for Bernadette
@George Washingmachine - Most of us like the series of Glamour fashion critiques. That they also utilize Ms Banner , too, is good.
i know right?
we all just came for victorian witch queen
Months late to this party--but OMG I LOVE YOUR SCREEN NAME. LOL
Indeed Mr. President of Washing-ton
Yup
Wonderful how the illustrations capture exactly nothing of what bernadette says about the clothes
Bernadette can draw, she could have done this no problem.
@@annapalmer2079 agreed
bernadette literally has done illustrations,,,
It'd be great if Bernadette covered Audrey Hepburn's wardrobe in My Fair Lady.
please make this happen!
Yes, please bring Bernadette back for My Fair Lady! It takes place around the same time period. And you could do a few more non-Disney movies!
Don't forget Hello Dolly
PLEEEEEEASE!!!
yes! that would be amazing
If you're going to have an illustrator, they need to listen to the historian. If not, there's absolutely no point in having them
They should've made Bernadette the illustrator. She's very good at that
Angenimatic Bits so true. She’s amazing❤️
I was thinking that! The illustrations were not consistent with the historian's commentary. Also, the historian herself is a brilliant artist who could have done a perfect job at depicting her own descriptions.
I was also coming to say that Bernadette is an accomplished historical illustrator, and it was insulting that Glamour didn’t spring for a bit cleaner job to go with her explanations!
I imagine the illustrator didn't get to hear Bernadette's commentary directly, probably just a brief list of bullet points or something. I definitely agree they should've evaluated and revised irst instead of committing 100% to inaccurate designs right off the bat.
I'm just here for Bernadette
Me too 😄
Me three!
Yeess! 😊 Bernadette is a perfect fit for this series!
Clicked “like“ before watching. That's what Bernadette does to me
Aren’t we all .... 😂
Literally everybody in the comments: only here for Bernadette, also make her draw the stuff instead
Yeah, I mean Bernadette is very good at drawing fashion too ❤
The illustrator is in no way a bad artist, they just didn't draw the things that Bernadette's saying.
Literally all the comments 🤣
and they’re all correct.
It deserves a remake!!!
After watching Karolina, I don’t trust Glamour, but since Bernadette’s in this video, it definitely means I can trust this video lol
Not the illustrator though they blatantly ignored what she was saying and showing
That is so true
Why can’t you trust Bernadette?
Star Laser ????
Oh! I misread lol
Edit: love love love Bernadette!!!
Love how she stresses how important the silhouette would be for the tine and the person illustrating it does none of that... she is an excellent artist, just let her draw it!
Yeah, I saw that, especially in the outdoors wear... At first I thought I was just distracted when Bernadette talked about the silhouette, but then realized she said that outfit was close to accurate, and that that chest shalt be poofed, whereas the artist basically made a noodle, that stang :\
You mean time*
Wait I’m confused...are you saying the artist shouldn’t listen to the historian? If not I mean no disrespect, just wondering.
RilesSweetPea Gacha, Bernadette Banner, the historian, is a great illustrator, I think they meant that Glamour should have let the historian illustrate, so it would match the commentary
@@Sundgoti yes we have seen on her channel the high quality of artistic interpretations, she is perfectly capable of in order to illustrate her projects 😍😍😍
I almost didn't recognize her without the cozy, naturally lit apartment behind her.
I've scrolled past this video so many times, but thankfully caught sight of a suspiciously Bernadette-seeming person at the bottom, and what do you know, it was!!!😂
roshpotter06 same
I feel like whoever touched up this video took a lot of liberties with Bernadette. I barely recognized her at first
Nikki Ruhl ik she looks very different
@@jerikagoddess she is definitely wearing more makeup!
"How accurate is her outdoors outfit?"
Bernadette: Pretty accurate, a bit too fitting at the top, but we're not too off-path!
"And her whimsical dress?"
Bernadette: She... Has the good shoes... And a wide hat... And a parasol!
I love Bernadette's energy when it comes to make a critique of an outfit :)
She always does her best to find things to compliment. It comes off as being doubly damning and I am more than here for it.
It's always a bit strange to suggest something is of the wrong period. I can understand that being anachronistic when the style only existed after the period in which it is supposedly set. But to have Victorian clothing in the Edwardian Era? Surely that was quite common. I'm 40, and have clothes going back 20 or more years, and if they're well made and still fit, many more people will have kept their suits and dresses. Do people in charge of making costumes take this in to account, or must everything be exactly of the fashion of the day?
_"This is what Mary Poppins would have looked like if she lived in history."_
No, that's what Mary Poppins would have looked like if she lived in a noir movie as a detective in an oversized trench-coat.
It's like the illustrator didn't even listen to the video, it's honestly worse than the movie portrayal.
Agreed.
As an illustrator myself, those drawings hurt my soul.
Spot on mate.
Ah yes let’s hire an illustrator to listen to Bernadette
Illustrator yEAH OK SO THE CORSET MAKES NO DIFFERENCE WE JUST THREY GREEN CLOTH AT HER
I could sketch a much better illustration and have the silhouette be more accurate to a proper historical figure with definitely more shape than a blob. They should hire an illustrator that listens to the historian.
Bernadette: They wore corsets with an hourglass shape and patted the bust to enhance that shape.
Illustrator: Alright, so just a straight dress without any shape to it?
Take note, Glamour, we are all here for Bernadette! Without suitable experts such as her, myself and many others don’t trust your historical videos.
Same
Preach
Oof
SAME
👏👏👏
*OUR VICTORIAN WITCH QUEEN HAS COME FORTh TO SERVE HISTORIC REALNESS*
420th like
Edit: No joke. (I realised after I posted that some people might think I'd be joking due to my username :v )
LET THE PRAISE BE GIVEN TO THE QUEEN
+
*YES*
*slowly waits for Karolina Żebrowska to do one of these*
*distant fangirl squealing*
She's just an enthusiast, if I'm correct. Bernadette is an actual historian
If Karolina and Bernadette did a collaboration, my head might explode.
Meme mom is more of a hobbyist who has done a lot of research while Bernadette is an actual historian. It would be awesome to see a colab though.
We need Morgan Donner too!
I am a bit surprised that they do not name the experts in the titles. I thought that the figure looked like Bernadette so I clicked on the video, but it was a bit hard to see with how small she was. I am sure that the audience would be greatly expanded if the lovely people were named to allow for better search and easier recognition.
Because 'Fashion Expert' sounds clickbaity and not very interesting, but 'Fashion Expert Bernadette Banner' tells me that I NEED TO CLICK NOW.
And... hum... Excuse-me... "Fashion Expert" when your expert is a fashion *historian* , when you are fact-checking an outfit for *historical accuracy* , is like telling your croquembouche is made by the best cook in the land while it's made by the best *pastry chef*
I mean... you can add more credibility to your show and didn't take the opportunity, Glamour...
im pretty sure they use it for clickbait, but not of the villainous kind
right!!!! The only reason that I clicked is because of her and I almost didn't because I couldn't tell if it was actually her or not.
But they did name her and even put her name and title in the video in a white banner....?
@@micaelaroyo4837 not in the title of the video or in the description if my memory is correct
Love this episode. The presenter’s tone is quite friendly, a bit humorous, and as though she is actually talking with you instead of being pedantic. Will watch anything you invite this presenter to do.
that's the powet Bernadette has
you should check out her channel!
She has a youtube channel all about fashion history as well! It's Bernadette Banner!
Check her channel! Her dissing a cheap knockoff of her dress is insanely funny
She is not just a "presenter", but a devoted and talented expert. I am glad and surprised to see Glamour use someone of her caliber for a change. And having been a BB fan since the beginning, she has matured into a marvelous "presenter" and it is a joy to see her poise catch up with her talent!
I love how all of us in the comments are just here loudly proclaiming our excitement for Bernadette. 😂👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
How can we not?
Jess_Marie_G This is incredibly valid and fair, true.
That is so true
I love her Transatlantic Accent! It reminds me of the way very proper late uncle used to speak.
Because she is our Queen. Long may she reign
Please let Bernadette do some art for this series, as she once was a professional costume illustrator. The artist you currently have can't seem to get the silhouettes right, and the lines and details are very simplistic. It looks cartoonish and often un-period, and doesn't match in tone or style the expertise of the historians we see.
Agreed if she has the time of course
Although... i think it might be the intention to simplify the lines in the film. It is not uncommon to alter the clothing or backgrounds to match their overall story or mood of the film’
Grace Law I agree! The flat, almost over-saturated colours, thick lineart, stylised unappealingly, just, eugh. Bernadette is a fantastic artist. Fashion illustrations shouldn’t look like those Twinkl worksheets you get in primary school
@@bitethesehands52 What else does she do?
Im just a beginner on watching her, but she makes historical clothing herself and tries to do it like how the people in those times would. Aka by hand or by a handcranked sewing machine
I wish they got Bernadette to do the illustrations, she's a fantastic artist and the drawings in this video don't really match with what she's is talking about, otherwise a great video and I hope they invite Bernadette back in the future.
I love how Bernadette mentions accommodations having to be made for all the dancing! Obviously this video *is* about sort of correcting or critiquing the costumes (not in a mean way, just discussing them), but it's nice that she mentioned the practicality. Which makes sense, as Ms Banner is a practical lady herself.
I like to think that in universe Mary Poppins actually made it shorter because she knew that she would be dancing.
It’s strange to watch Bernadette talk so slowly. She usually talks so fast!
You can hear he start talking fast then slow herself down
Thank God you brought a historian who knows what she's talking about.
@Grucci Gru - Raissa Bretaña is great, too, when she does the critiques.
And who sites sources
@@MossyMozart I’m a big fan of Raissa. Bernadette hosted her for a panel during CoCoVid earlier this year (though I believe she only kept it up on her channel for a few weeks, unfortunately).
I'm three minutes in and the volume of information is twice what the other "fashion experts" gave.
How would someone do this 100 years into the future? “2010’s fashionable women frequently donned yoga pants of a stretchy Lycra fabric paired with a large baggy T-shirt of a cotton material. Athletic slides were essential to the completion of the outfit, purely for function.”
Hannah Helton * puts up photo of 2010 me in oversized hoodie, jeans, and flip flops * "So would you say this is historically accurate?" "Absolutely not. No care has been taken to seasonal accuracy, much less accuracy of the overall era."
It would be bernadette still, she doesn't age. She is 550 years old
completely accurate XD
"Women frequently donned yoga pants and loose t-shirts out of pure convenience and laziness..."
Well there's not really. Fashion trends right now
I didn’t notice how Victorian/Edwardian Bernadette’s usual makeup is until I saw her in the modern makeup they applied for this...
and let me say it looks bad. The way she puts on makeup compliments her features and gives her face definition. With this makeup, she looks bland and washed-out. And it completely and utterly clashes with her outfit
SAMEEE!
It honestly took me a second to realize it was her. Did someone see the old "women use to wear white lead makeup" and decide it was a good idea?
SAME I was looking at her thinking: somethings off here..
But honestly she still looks really pretty! Just not what we’re used to
I don’t notice
“And entire stuffed birds..”
omg Neville’s grandma had it :0
Srah Lisabeth birds? 😬
San Ram Yes, Augusta Longbottom wears a hat with a stuffed vulture on it .It is stated in the prisoner of Askaban when Neville put his Grandmother clothes on Boggart Snape.
SBCD omg yes
As did Carrie
Yes! I always thought it was a magical fashion detail, something bizarre and ridiculous, but now I feel much better informed! She was following a muggle fashion!
Who put modern makeup on my lovely Bernadette!!! And made her speak at normal person speed!
I knew something was off for me to doubt that it was her on the thumbnail...
ikr??? like it's not the same at all listening to her at normal speed
That weirdly explains why I didn't recognized her for months on the thumbnail x)
noooo! what a horrific crime to commit on lady sherlock holmes!
lady watson will solve the case of the modern makeup....
@@NWolfsson
(Edit; Sorry I am tired, I misread your comment as a question. I'll go to sleep now, sorry again)
(Below is my response to a comment I read wrong.)
She put on different make up. Her face looks more polished-pale.
Normally (I hope I don't sound offensive) her face has the colour of flower.
Here, her face radiates pearl-shine. That's why.
Bernadette: legend ❤️
Agreed!
@Scullery Maid I didn't! I built B up, I didn't comment on my own self image 😁
I agree
Truth!!!...trust few others!
I dont like that they didn't link Bernadette's youtube video....
not directly in the video, but they link her channel in the description
@@ewatokarz577 It would have been a nice thing to do, though. It's good to be nice.
Perhaps I'm missing something, but which video would they have linked? None of the videos on her channel seem particularly linked with this one. I see nothing 1910s or Mary Poppins themed.
The 1000th like
They did pin her comment
seriously guys hire a better artist. or let bernadette do it.
I think if they did hire a Bernadette as a artist as well, they would have to pay her mare💰!....( Even though this video would have got even more views)
um.. the drawing looks nothing like what she described or the photos lol (at least the outer layers)
Love how the artist rendering isn’t correct because they forgot the padding
Now, Bernadette wouldn't have forgotten the padding, if she had done the illustrations. LOL
Artist: *draws a sad noodle*
Bernadette: I said "accentuated silhouette", didn't I?
@@joannecarroll5504 I watched hers. It's in different style of anatomy. So, I doubt she sketch those illustrations.
i seriously dislike the illustrations... they couldnt even get the silhouette right
It’s Bernadette! She’s the reason I fell in love with historical fashions and started to sew :D
SAME!!
Same!
I don’t like how some of Bernadette’s statements seems cut off. I would’ve loved to see every single thing she had to say
It may have been cut for time or because it wasn't directly relevant. It's hard with people like Bernadette who almost always seems to have something interesting and informative to say but the editors most likely have to give back a video that fits within an approved length of time.
HOLY CRAP A FASHION HISTORIAN WHO KNOWS WHAT SHES DOING ON THIS SHOW. BERNADETTE BANNER WE STAN GIRL I LOVE YOUR RED DEATH GOWN ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
2:35 ohhh, do I know the combinations on the right...
Bernadette fans recognize those all but too easily
The absolute best thing about this video is that a lot of people seem to be discovering Bernadette.
For absolutely no reason youtube threw her channel into my random list....it’s oddly intriguing and generally never something I’d watch....so bizarre
That's exactly what happened to me and I don't regret it at all - Bernadette is such a lady :)
'Fashion expert checks Mary Poppins wardrobe'
Me: nice WAIT. IS THAT BERNADETTE?!?!?!?!?!
ive been a long time fan of Bernadette and love her videos. Much love❤
you can tell she slowed down her speech, it almost doesn’t suit her
Her voice really annoys me because it seems force or something, you know? No hate towards her, I'm sure she's nice
In her own videos she talk a lot faster and I'm not sure how but it makes it sound more authentic and less annoying. She definitely enjoys using her broad vocabulary and that can seem a bit pompous if it comes out as premeditated.
@@Hope-si1kb She REALLY is nice and fun to be around and her voice suits her and its really her - tho for this video someone apparently wanted her to slow down for some reason. she is Naturally that precise & carefull in her enunciation - unlike most people who speak fast & slur their words..
Hope
She spends her time between New York and London so... there you go.
@@Hope-si1kb i agree. However, in her own youtube videos, the talks in a much more natural tone hence it sounded better and not forced--maybe the reason she sounded annoying in here is because she is expected to talk slower for the sake of audience, and it definitely interfere with her usual image and speech character
fun fact: Mary Poppins's costume designer was Julie Andrews husband. They met when they were just kids, and when Walt Disney offered Julie the part, he asked her what was his husband job. When she said that he was an aspiring costume designer, he told her to tell him to bring his portfolio to Disney studio. And well... the rest is history.
I'm almost positive he was a set painter, not a costumer
@@quethesparkle in Mary Poppins he is credited as a design consultant, but Julie herself has told this story in many interviews.
i love how all of bernadette's fans have the best vocabulary
Elise M We can only aspire to equal our mentor.
irunamuk Truth!
I'm the exception to the rule... It's just that when I comment on Bernadette's videos, I proof-read thrice and use online dictionaries to make sure my spelling and grammar is at least comprehensible, because frankly, she doesn't deserve my usual writing style.
@@AbteilungsleiterinBeiAntifaEV I feel the same way
@@AbteilungsleiterinBeiAntifaEV ditto
Ok I like this one. She's great. Have her again.
*change the scratching marker noise*
ScorBug92 let it go.
ScorBug92 She’s Bernadette Banner she has a UA-cam channel. Please go and check it out she is amazing and needs more views.
god yes please change that noise. I love Bernadette but that marker noise almost had me clicking off the video really fast
I agree they really need to change that awful scratching marker noise
@@Mark_R_Tho that was completely unnecessary to say
It was a little odd to see Bernadette just sitting and talking as opposed to pointing, stitching, cutting or even drafting while she spoke.
Bernadette Banner is a shining dress historian star! Eloquently presented accurate information without sounding stuffy. Glamour, you would be very wise to have Ms. Banner do more costume and wardrobe fact check vignettes. As her subscribers know, she's the BEST!!!! P.S. She is an excellent illustrator/artist, too!
RumMonkeyable not only does she sound stuffy (to me) she also sounds fake. Either she has to push this silly affect all the way or cut it entirely.
@@SwordsmanRyan orrr just watch her videos.
@@SwordsmanRyan Not really an "affect". It's just good diction with a pinch of eloquence, both of which more of us could probably do with.
@@SwordsmanRyan I get what you mean, but there are caveats. She says she adopted it unintentionally, because of her frequent trips to live and study in the UK (London etc). She speaks well and enjoys using interesting vocab, and if you watch more of her videos it isn't as jarring as the first. I felt the same way in the first video I saw of hers, I disliked that she was "lying" with her voice type, but honestly I stayed subbed and watched more and now absolutely adore her, I hope she never changes for anyone. Just because she speaks differently than most New Yorkers doesn't mean what she is saying is wrong or unworthy. She knows a LOT of fashion history and loves to share it for free with others online, which is amazing, and any of her quirks just make her human. Just my 2 cents.
This comment section is just the Bernadette hype train and I'm SO okay with that
YESSSSSSS
I literally saw Bernadette on the thumbnail and I was like "is that her? IT IS HER"
The modern ceramic makeup threw us all.
Bernadette is the best you should have got her to do the illustrations
100% agree with this one
Totally just here for Bernadette. Haven't bothered with Glamour magazine in years. So very happy to see this. I'll have to check out the series.
This series is pretty interesting.
Pj2457 The only thing that sucks is the generally stiff artist they absolutely refuse to replace
Pj2457 - Please DON'T tell them that you don't bother with "Glamour", then watch the video they pay to produce. They won't make more!
I love how dress historians are always dressed well... historically
You should check out her channel where she makes accurate period clothing (often in the original hand-sewing method!)
her walking skirt..to die for. and lady sherlock no words.
it's like other historians and their décor. im still in school but my room already looks like an antique shop
This is Ms. Banner's very usual manner of dress. She is a delight.
They finally got a legit historical fashion expert
I'm convinced Bernadette is in fact Mary Poppins in the future, and no one can tell me otherwise
Oh my god yes
I mean.... we have theories that she's actually immortal or a witch
I just said the same.
That's how you make someone check the historical accuracy of a look in the movie, congratulations, Bernadette! You can see she really knows what she's talking about, rather than someone who doesn't even know the difference between stays and a corset.
I'm new to this kind of fashion. VERY new. So could you tell me the difference?
@@clairefazel8470 me too, all I know is that the corset came after stays like a sequel :1
I just don’t remember what a stay is, but I know an ok bit about corsets. Just an ok bit.
@@clairefazel8470 until about 1800, women wore garments that were known as (a pair of) stays or (a pair of) bodies. The term "corset" only came in later. the terms "stays" and "corset" are often used to differentiate between the pre-1800 and the post-1800 shape *its a bit more complicated than that but its a very basic explaination.. and if you are interested if fun Interesting things like that Do check out Bernadettes you tubes.. she is an AMAZING seamstress.. just understand she is a master in her craft and fun too..
@@clairefazel8470 stays were mostly used before 1800. The easiest way to determine them is that they have straps on the shoulders and they open up through laces at the back, and have a wooden busk in the front. They are also mostly stiffened with cords and has no metal. Corsets on the other hand has a metal busk and opens up at the front, and the lacing at the back is more for adjustment of the corset. They're also stiffened with whalebone.
Am I the only one feeling like a proud mother because of Bernadettes collaboration with Glamour???? I saw her and had to watch it!!!!!
An ACTUAL fashion expert!? I live her SOOOO MUCH
Potassuim_Cation go watch her UA-cam channel! She makes clothes very similar to what she’s talking about by hand 😊💕
The others were also fashion experts/historian smh
This is the best of Glamor's "What they got wrong/right" videos!
So happy they listened to their viewers & got someone that specializes in the time period in question for the characters the video is about. This is the first one that I feel no need to correct anything.
Was anyone else kinda thrown off and weirded out by the lipstick shade and lack of cozy apartment?
I'm alittle thrown by her actually calling it a corset, too lol
The red lipstick looks gorgeous on her
Hey, that’s Bernadette! Great job Bernadette! What is with the drawings? That walking suit is nothing like Bernadette described.
Regarding the “entire stuffed birds” Ms. Banner mentioned at 12:35: these highly elaborate hats may have been decorated with birds of paradise and similarly ostentatious tropical birds. The rarer the bird, the more en vogue the hat.
This practice led directly to the founding of the Audubon Society. The desire to decorate one’s hat with an entire flock of bluebirds or a cloud of egret feathers was having devastating effects on bird populations.
If you're interested in the history of various uses for birds of paradise, you should read "The Feather Thief" which talks about the Victorian-style method of fly-fishing and features a person who robbed an important natural history museum to source bird feathers of this purpose. Amazing read about history and contemporary issues with "traditions" that harmed our world in the past.
Speaking of feathers...
The most expensive item lost in the sinking of the HMS Titanic was $2 million ( yes, I said million) in OSTRICH FEATHERS!!
Wow
@Tom Sanders wtf are you on
Bernadette! That's amazing! I love her youtube channel!
bernadette is such a good artist, why didn’t you let her draw
The way she speaks is so fascinating and enthralling, wow
Sorry but I hope you could do a different style of drawing for these series, the final drawings never really give the full sense what the outfit would have looked like in film.
They should have had Bernadette draw them. She is quite the illustrator for costumes.
Big agree extrae
It's not supposed to resemble the outfit on film, but what it should have looked liked had it been done historically accurately
Msfinable THEYRE drawn horribly and don’t allow you to see what it would look like if it were translated to film.
Seeing these illustrations in the same video as Bernadette, knowing her drawing style, made me wish they had asked her to do it. Not to mention the walking suit looked more 1920's than 1910. They neglected the Edwardian silhouette features that are in the back!
14:09 Julie Andrews cracking a joke at her first Oscars, in the 1960s, what a queen
Its so adorable
it was supercalifragilisticexpialidocious!
"i know you americans are famous for your hospitality, but this is really ridiculous"
BriTs amIriGhT
Me when I was on vacation
For those who are interested in seeing a closer to history version of the Mary Poppins' Jolly Holiday dress, the presenter Bernadette Banner has recently finished with her reconstruction of the dress according to the historical aesthetics and silhouettes.
10/10 recommend watching it, her cinematography and explanations remain beautiful throughout much like her explanations in this video
I love her channel. She is so perky and well informed. I taught history and still write historical fiction. Clothing mattered and still matters because humans wear clothes.
I briefly glanced over the thumbnail and had to do a double take... Bernadette! I am so happy!
as somebody has been following Bernadette for a few years, you can tell how nervous she is but she still braving through to get her information out in an informative way. very proud of her.
Great critique, Bernadette! ❤️ Who better to do this video than our own modern Edwardian? If only they had asked her to do the illustrations, too!
Maybe Karolina Zebrovska
Maybe Karolina Zebrowska.
@@As-jj2rc YES!
i came to say that i love these vids before watching and OMG, the support this woman has is great!!! i'll go check her videos after this. thanks to all the people that are recommending her!
Glamour... can we get Bernadette reviewing Mary queen of Scots or outlander Well all subscribe right away
Bernadette, my favorite seamstress!! I love this so much!!
Amazing, amazing, amazing! 😍My only point of critique: The lovely Bernadette should have drawn the illustrations. She has a very delicate, sophisticated style of drawing mannequins and fashion, the ones you used looked way too cartoony for the interesting topic and well-spoken delivery.
Elle-Iza Logan she may not be comfortable with digital illustration
@@jasminey1589 That's true. Then again it's no big deal to digitalize a drawing. I guess it's about maintaining a consistent style throughout their series, and maybe an existing contract with a designer.
This was such a fun video and Bernadette was the perfect person for it!
@Elizabeth H - And Ms Banner was very diplomatic in her criticism.
Excuse me as I Bernadette fangirl over here, and I absolutely love the idea of having Morgan Donner do a Sleeping Beauty analysis or getting Karolina Zebrowska or even Cathy Hay to do a segment on here!
It actually makes sense that Mary Poppins' "workaday" clothes would be a little simpler, narrower, and older than the fashion magazines, so the old hat is forgivable due to accuracy, as servant women often wore out of date clothes and cast offs.
Here supporting my girl Bernadette because I’m trash
@Scullery Maid hahaha YES!
You not trash, you are a Victorian lady.
@@lafeil oh no, I'm just quoting Bernadette. She uses the phrase "I'm trash" frequently in her videos.
#TrashforBernadette
@J Freed - I always referred to my offcut pieces of fabric as "remnants" as my grandmother always did. And now, in just a few short months of discovering the lovely Bernadette, "cabbage" they are now called.
How could I roast you, Bernadette?
It's nice, informative, with lovely English. It's only weird to see you like an anchor woman with a sterile background.
I know right? Bernadette without some obligatory sewing chaos around her is almost uncanny
And she's usually so fresh and fun, always excited about a new project... I miss seeing these adorable traits of her in this video
@@PatriciaSantos-wz2jc - I disagree with you. I found Ms Banner to be excited in this video. AND fresh and fun.
@@MossyMozart we only have different interpretations of the video, but the fact is that she is still amazing :)
Who is this made-up, slowly-spoken creature? Why, it's only my very favourite time traveller. You did a marvellous job, BB!
So happy to see Bernadette here! I love hearing her speak, she’s so easy to listen to. I’ve been enjoying the series with the other guests as well.
She's so gorgeous I demand that we all take a moment to appreciate her. Thank you
A very interesting video. But, I must point out that Bernadette doesn't take into account that Mary Poppins is a Timelord and some deviation in historical accuracy should be forgiven as she was bound to get a few details incorrect. :D
Dan Luedke well technically 😂 she said on her instagram that they cut out a time lord joke she did!
She said she referenced it but they cut it ☹️
Aww. Why would they cut such an important piece of Mary Poppins lore?
They did cut out her joke lol
@@itdano Because they're horrible people?
So pleased to see Bernadette here. Great job to all involved
This is like historical fashion news hour! Well done Glamour! Fantastic as usual Bernadette
YES BERNADETTE! i’m so happy that she’s in this video. honestly, i’m only here for her 😆 ❤️
Just here for Bernadette. She’s my favorite.
I love that Bernadette got to do this. She's so lovely!
Love that Bernadette is in this!
Omg!!!! Bernadette! She's THE BEST!!! ❤😍❤😍❤😍❤😍
Her hat being dated makes sense! Didn’t Bert recognise her when he started drawing the iconic silhouette of her hat? They’ve met before, years prior, and she would have been wearing the same hat for him to recognise it :)
I was wondering why she was tilting slightly, then I remember Bernadette has a form of scoliosis
Yup, she wore some kind of corset because of her curved spine.
Doesn't she look like the top dog tho
@@mangalover0149 it's called a back brace
zoë Thanks! I’m pretty sure I’ve seen the term before but never put two and two together.
I have scoliosis myself yet that didn't occur to me haha.
Did anyone else notice that Bernadette usually talks like five times faster? Maybe they asked her to slow down but I love the way she talks in her videos
I clicked because of Bernadette!! She's my most favorite UA-camr of all time and seeing her featured here is absolutely amazing!!!!!!!!!!!
FREAKING FINALLY! Thank you for picking a historian who knows the Era you have her talking about!
I love Bernadette.
AND A GOOD ARTIST? Who made this series good? I want to shake their hand!
I'm so glad she went on to make the outfit!!!
Just watched it! After I watched it I was like didn’t someone fashion check this in another video? And yes, yes they did. It was Bernadette 😆