un metalero de sangre y de verdad no critica el cambio ni a los cambiados en una banda, simplemente escuchamos y listo, después que sea metal que suene a full volumen, o es que los que critican es por que quieren escuchar reGAYton?
Andi is an amazing singer with a unique voice, but there's songs that he can't sing due to different vocal ranges...This is a perfect example of that :)
Engraçado é que hoje em dia o Andi está cantando como nunca. O cara desenvolveu uma técnica absurda e os clássicos da era Kiske estão com uma performance muito superior as do passado...
Concordo MUITA COISA!!!!!! É impressionante ver esse cara cantando as musicas do Kiske. E o pior é que a gente sempre teve aquela expectativa muito alta com o Kiske. Ver os dois lado a lado cantando as musicas dá pra ver realmente que o Deris é tão bom quanto. E a voz dele é única. Depois dos keepers muita gente tentou copiar o Kiske, mas o Deris com essa voz mais rasgada é impossível. Sou mto fã.
Andi and Michael are a very different kind of singers. Of course Michael will sing his song better because it is his song. Andi is singing someone else´s song and he's not even missing a single note, but here we have a lot of people talking bullshit about Andi's technique.
No es tan obvio cuando ves que la mitad de los comentarios son criticas diciendo que Deris no canta como kiske..ambos son excelentes, es ridiculo compararlos
It´s ok but still I wonder who is giving the rights to perform it? After all it is a song written by a fucking power metal genious of our time - Kai Hansen.
I Really do not understanding why has several comments Criticizing Deris Voice, Is His Style, This song Was Made for a Tenor vocal, he is baritone, a big diference between Them, but, He did a good job in this Song. I See many Helloween's Fans being Disrespectful with Deris, Remember, That Man SAVES Helloween, and did great álbuns in his Era, The Dark Ride, Master Of The Rings, Time Of The Oath and Better Than Raw. Deris is a Great Singer, Kiske And Kai Have returned, So, Just Enjoy the Pumpkins United and Stop With Comparisons :)
Don't call those fools "Helloween fans". If a person loves and supports the band, they'd never say anything about any member, especially Deris who has been releasing and composing great stuff since 1994. You said it all. If Deris wouldn't have joined the band they'd probably had been disbanded.
Andi Deris is my favorite Power Metal singer, but I feel in this concert he should have song March of Time on his style, because he was trying to sing like Kiske and this is a song that demands a lot of high notes, if he singed it on his style he would have really nailed the song.
Im so fucking tired of every fucking helloween video where people always make up excuses for Andis shitty voice nowadays "Fucking soundengineer" "he cant hear himself". It seems Andi is the only one in the world that experience this at every gig!
Well.. about some of these comments. Thats fucking bullshit. This guy have great voice and i love this when he goes on the edge of his vocal range. This is not so serious, giving everything you have is the thing and this just sound fucking amazing
Andi Deris sings like he is suffering from serious constipation. More reason to have a Pumpkins United tour so the fans can hear this song the way it was meant to be (Kai and Kiske).
@chameleon metal La verdad siento que eres un amante desenfrenado por la forma de cantar de kiske y su voz claramente, quizá eso nuble tu juicio, pero siendo objetivos aunque kiske tenga una voz más lírica, la voz de Andi es única, en el sentido de que le entregó a helloween muchísima más versatilidad, ahora para que Kiske cantara en helloween ellos tuvieron que modificar su sonido practicamente, porque al mostrarle el walls of jericho a kiske, este se lo devolvió a kai , en fin, siento que kiske hizo historia con la banda al estar en los keepers, pero de esos álbumes no solo resalta la voz de él, es un conjunto de armonía musical, ahora si solo hablás mal de Andreas deris sin conocer su trayectoria en helloween , si escuchar temas como The King for a 1000 years , Push, The time of the oath, Revelations, Who is mr mad man, The dark Ride, worl of war, Paint a new world o los live " High" o " Live on the 3 continents " (entre muchas otras) en dónde aparte de ser la banda majestuosa musicalmente se aprecia la versatilidad de deris, creo que te quedas sin argumentos si solo apelas a la " magestuosidad de kiske" , nunca fue solo él , la banda no fue por él, es un excelente vocalista, pero estos siempre se llamaron helloween no"kiske y sus muchachos" y pues vamos , kiske jamás hubiese dado tal interpretación a un tema como the dark ride o push , who is mr mad man o long live the king, El propio weikath lo dijo( no en palabras textuales): " Andi puede subir a notas altas y puede gritar, yo escribo las canciones para él ,eso es fundamental en un cantante", y vale, aunque Kiske hizo historia con estos dos keppers tambien dejó un sin sabor tras sus dos últiimos álbumes, que aún siendo buenos la banda se iba alejando cada vez más de ese poder incontenible. Siendo Objetivos querido amigo, Andi deris llegó en el peor momento de la banda y con su carisma y su voz única lo entregó todo y por ello hoy día sigue siendo después de 26 años el cantante principal de HELLOWEEN. Tambien amo los temas con kiske, por que como dije no sólo es él , es la banda entera la que Amo y los temas de los Keepers son Majestuosos, pero jamás estaré de acuerdo con se menosprecie el trabajo de Deris en la banda que a la hora de la verdad ha sido mucho más duro y dinámico.
And you're So Stupid You're So un-up-to date... Kiske back and join with Andi and all Hellowen's members in Pumkins United Tour 2017-2018 F*ck u...Kiske's fake fan..
Watch the Unisonic version of this song...that is more Helloween than this...Helloween is a good band with Deris with some good Albums like The time of the oath...Unisonic plays the old Helloween stuff better,because they have one original guitar player and the two original voices...Helloween has one original guitar player and original bass player but Deris can not sing the old songs...sorry...I hope one day they make a tour with the original line-up...Hansen,Weikath,Kiske,Grosskopf...and on drums Uli Kusch...I know the original line-up was without Kiske and with Ingo on drums...but you know what I mean..
I don't think So. i've watch Kiske Sang Hellowen's old Songs in WACKEN 2011 SUCKS!!!!!....He can't sing his Songs ANYMORE..So Annoying and Disgusting no..no..!!!
That's what happens when you hire a new singer with a diffrent register than your original. Andi is an Amazing singer and he's killer at singing his stuff live. For the Micheal stuff, I kind of wish he would just sing those songs in his own style but really he just wants to try to be as faithful to the Micheal era as possible and you can't fault him for the commitment.
I've heard Deris cover Kiske work and normally he does a damn fine job. But this song was not written for his range. This song has so many high notes and Deris's voice is too raspy to even reach them. It seems more like amutuer karaoke.
Andi es baritono y por lo tanto no puede llegar a los agudos del "gran" kiske. Si canta como lo hace hasta ahora es porque hasta ahi puede !! Ya Superenlo ahora es Andi Deris
Alexcode98 Exacto, la gente no entiende que tanto sus registros como timbres son muy distintos, estoy seguro que si Kiske intentara cantar canciones de Deris en muchas se es escucharía terrible...
Tell me what Michael Kiske has released since he left Helloween early in the 90's? A tons of shitty albums. The guy doesn't even like heavy metal hahahaha. Even you guys, his fanboys, don't buy his new stuff. He's got a great voice and that's all. Can't compose or create anything.
This is sad. They should never try to perform this piece live with Andi on vocals. They've dropped the piece 2-3 tones down and he still can't sing it properly. On the other hand, Kiske on Unisonic still KILLS this piece 50 years old that he is, hitting the exact notes he used to so many years ago...
He just didn't need to go to that pitch. His voice is naturally higher than Kiskes, so he doesn't actually need to hit the correct notes - shoulda just sung what felt right, instead his voice... ...sorta went all "fat".
Induction Pretentious and musically educated? - I might be wrong about that, but you know, music tends to fall apart when some fuckwit comes along and declares what does and what doesn't make "musical sense". Enjoy your... nothing. It's a big nothing.
this ver is quitely good. THe tone is lower compare to the original version. Not too high for him. And if you watch some show before 2000, you'll see Deris can hit high note (push, for example). But not now, it's past :(
Se que no es bueno entrar en comparaciones, pero creo que Helloween se equivoca poniendo a Deris en evidencia al hacerle cantar estos temas. Simplemente no puede y no debe porque lo hace fatal. Está a años luz de Kiske en lo que a voz se refiere.
![Helloween - How Many Tears (United Alive 2018) [Full HD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/GIFzDXhvF8I/mqdefault.jpg)
Umas das melhores bandas desse mundo,, esse vocal teve a coragem de assumir a responsabilidade,,, admiro ele
Fantásticos Backing Vocals do Sascha Gerstner.
Mano, faz uma diferença enorme msm
fagner santos realmente incrível!
And he has improved a lot!
Verdade!!!
un metalero de sangre y de verdad no critica el cambio ni a los cambiados en una banda, simplemente escuchamos y listo, después que sea metal que suene a full volumen, o es que los que critican es por que quieren escuchar reGAYton?
luv this band, Ive been listening to them for 27 years. Deris, Kiske are both legends. That's why this band is No. 1 in my eyes.
Andi is an amazing singer with a unique voice, but there's songs that he can't sing due to different vocal ranges...This is a perfect example of that :)
I agree but kiske can't sing deris' songs like deris does it
Also. Deris had
Also a bigger vocal range than Kiske ever had.
You're right!
Deris is my favorite singer but I don't think about who's better!!!
I love this song but Deris just blew it up!
He sang false too 🤣
@@V3ntilator may, but the most important thing is how they approach these notes mix or falseto?
Engraçado é que hoje em dia o Andi está cantando como nunca. O cara desenvolveu uma técnica absurda e os clássicos da era Kiske estão com uma performance muito superior as do passado...
Concordo MUITA COISA!!!!!! É impressionante ver esse cara cantando as musicas do Kiske. E o pior é que a gente sempre teve aquela expectativa muito alta com o Kiske. Ver os dois lado a lado cantando as musicas dá pra ver realmente que o Deris é tão bom quanto. E a voz dele é única. Depois dos keepers muita gente tentou copiar o Kiske, mas o Deris com essa voz mais rasgada é impossível. Sou mto fã.
@@tonigeraci os dois juntos no show do rock in rio 2019 é coisa fina demais, a banda ficou forte demais com as adições de Kiske e Kai.
sascha backing vocals are awesome
Totally
Andi and Michael are a very different kind of singers. Of course Michael will sing his song better because it is his song. Andi is singing someone else´s song and he's not even missing a single note, but here we have a lot of people talking bullshit about Andi's technique.
what else do you expect from Kiske fantards?
Amadeus Dredd I love Andys voice and what he has done in Helloween, i altso loves Kiske,s voice.
Now in 2017 We can both togheter live. 😊👍👍
I just Love Andi unique voice ever though Kiske hit the high note
Deris takes him on the 2006 keeper of the 7 keys live song. Definitely better than Kiske.
Unisonic play guitar better
Awesome performance of Andi Deris in this song!
Love Dani. Dude kills it on the drums.
deris sou muito fan desse cara, manja muito meu!!!
Helloween is the best, anytime anywhere with anyone. They are the Power metal Gods.
Шедеврально, супер!
О да!
Greatttttt.
Helloween is one of our influences.
Andi no canta como kiske , y tampoco kiske canta como Deris no seamos estúpidos !!
creo que es muy obvio
jajaja yo si lo entendí !!! XD
No es tan obvio cuando ves que la mitad de los comentarios son criticas diciendo que Deris no canta como kiske..ambos son excelentes, es ridiculo compararlos
***** cierto. Los dos son buenos.
Exacto, pero la gente, por desgracia, solo se enfoca en comparar y decir que uno es mejor que otro...
cada uno tiene su propio estilo y ya
Helloween is the best of the best forever ...
o que mais me impressiona nos caras, é o respeito e a interatividade que eles tem com o publico !!!!
Damn Andi Deris must be tired as hell... That was awesome
infelizmente as musicas antigas são de tons muitos altos que o Deris não alcança ainda mais ao vivo,algo positivo é que ele não erra a letra.rsrs
fagner santos referência ao mago lione? Kk
Not bad..
I like Andy's voice.
yea, me too.
It´s ok but still I wonder who is giving the rights to perform it? After all it is a song written by a fucking power metal genious of our time - Kai Hansen.
@@mikaelwertti8100 Agreed. But they are still allowed to play it. It’s a Helloween song.
@@mikaelwertti8100 Helloween still have a good relationship with Kai Hansen, even in 90s they toured together (Helloween & Gamma Ray)
Grom kako su dobri... 🤞🤞🤞🤞🤞❤️💥
Bring back good memories
I Really do not understanding why has several comments Criticizing Deris Voice, Is His Style, This song Was Made for a Tenor vocal, he is baritone, a big diference between Them, but, He did a good job in this Song. I See many Helloween's Fans being Disrespectful with Deris, Remember, That Man SAVES Helloween, and did great álbuns in his Era, The Dark Ride, Master Of The Rings, Time Of The Oath and Better Than Raw. Deris is a Great Singer, Kiske And Kai Have returned, So, Just Enjoy the Pumpkins United and Stop With Comparisons :)
And to be honest I think he controls his high/mix voice very well, he just has a very distinctive tone that makes him either liked or hated
Don't call those fools "Helloween fans". If a person loves and supports the band, they'd never say anything about any member, especially Deris who has been releasing and composing great stuff since 1994.
You said it all. If Deris wouldn't have joined the band they'd probably had been disbanded.
Kiske is needed for this one
Una cancion extremadamente alta!!
power metal is my favorite music genre 😊😊😊
People will stop complaining about Andi Deris singing old Helloween songs now with the Pumpkins United tour with
I Want Kiske!
I got my ticket to see them live this october in Mexico City!!!
Nice Andi Deris vocal performance.
"Cause chime, marches chime..." :3
Andi Deris is my favorite Power Metal singer, but I feel in this concert he should have song March of Time on his style, because he was trying to sing like Kiske and this is a song that demands a lot of high notes, if he singed it on his style he would have really nailed the song.
2:25 , I was giving this a chance, but at this point I decided to close the window and wash up my ears.
Deris rules!!
Kiske.....Kiske.....10000000 veces maravillosa melodía y manera de atacar todos los giros del Sr. M . Kiske .
Great Deris.
Kiske bleibt Kiske. Amen.
THE RASMUS ON GUITAR? HAHAHA
Im so fucking tired of every fucking helloween video where people always make up excuses for Andis shitty voice nowadays "Fucking soundengineer" "he cant hear himself".
It seems Andi is the only one in the world that experience this at every gig!
Well.. about some of these comments. Thats fucking bullshit. This guy have great voice and i love this when he goes on the edge of his vocal range. This is not so serious, giving everything you have is the thing and this just sound fucking amazing
Give all we have and leave the others crying with themselfs :)
mến Chúc heloween cũng như a sk..♡Andi
Andi tries to sing it the Kiske style.. If he would sing it his way it probably will sound better
This is just perfect!... Andi is a GOD
Love Sascha
...from indonesia...✌
Very high Söng and Deris still nailed!!!!!!
DERIS HEEEEELLLLLLL YEAAAAAAAAAAAAA!!!
No Kiske , No Helloween
Andi Deris sings like he is suffering from serious constipation. More reason to have a Pumpkins United tour so the fans can hear this song the way it was meant to be (Kai and Kiske).
muy bueno por suerte deris llegaste a helloween
เพลงนี้เสียงจะทรงพลังมากมากถ้า kiske มาร้อง
I am here just watching people fighting over Kiske and Deris, while I still choose Hansen as the best Helloween vocals.
Same. Whenever someone says Helloween. I instantly think of original Helloween, like the first two albums...
Peoples have been comparing two singers all the time. Just listen and support the scene.
hasta cuando lo van a superar ya no esta kiske
+Sergio DuMort hay un video mas o menos reciente de kiske cantando esta cancion y todavia lo hace muy bien
+jfpbman pero kiske no es nada sin kai Andi tiene canciones de sobra para superar kiske nunca lo ara en su voz aun asi son buenos ambos
@chameleon metal
La verdad siento que eres un amante desenfrenado por la forma de cantar de kiske y su voz claramente, quizá eso nuble tu juicio, pero siendo objetivos aunque kiske tenga una voz más lírica, la voz de Andi es única, en el sentido de que le entregó a helloween muchísima más versatilidad, ahora para que Kiske cantara en helloween ellos tuvieron que modificar su sonido practicamente, porque al mostrarle el walls of jericho a kiske, este se lo devolvió a kai , en fin, siento que kiske hizo historia con la banda al estar en los keepers, pero de esos álbumes no solo resalta la voz de él, es un conjunto de armonía musical, ahora si solo hablás mal de Andreas deris sin conocer su trayectoria en helloween , si escuchar temas como The King for a 1000 years , Push, The time of the oath, Revelations, Who is mr mad man, The dark Ride, worl of war, Paint a new world o los live " High" o " Live on the 3 continents " (entre muchas otras) en dónde aparte de ser la banda majestuosa musicalmente se aprecia la versatilidad de deris, creo que te quedas sin argumentos si solo apelas a la " magestuosidad de kiske" , nunca fue solo él , la banda no fue por él, es un excelente vocalista, pero estos siempre se llamaron helloween no"kiske y sus muchachos" y pues vamos , kiske jamás hubiese dado tal interpretación a un tema como the dark ride o push , who is mr mad man o long live the king, El propio weikath lo dijo( no en palabras textuales): " Andi puede subir a notas altas y puede gritar, yo escribo las canciones para él ,eso es fundamental en un cantante", y vale, aunque Kiske hizo historia con estos dos keppers tambien dejó un sin sabor tras sus dos últiimos álbumes, que aún siendo buenos la banda se iba alejando cada vez más de ese poder incontenible.
Siendo Objetivos querido amigo, Andi deris llegó en el peor momento de la banda y con su carisma y su voz única lo entregó todo y por ello hoy día sigue siendo después de 26 años el cantante principal de HELLOWEEN.
Tambien amo los temas con kiske, por que como dije no sólo es él , es la banda entera la que Amo y los temas de los Keepers son Majestuosos, pero jamás estaré de acuerdo con se menosprecie el trabajo de Deris en la banda que a la hora de la verdad ha sido mucho más duro y dinámico.
deris drive is u name! great singer
no kiske, no march of time, sorry motori
and no brains... in your head
k,listen this pub karaoke.
and no blood... in your body
And you're So Stupid
You're So un-up-to date...
Kiske back and join with Andi and all Hellowen's members in Pumkins United Tour 2017-2018
F*ck u...Kiske's fake fan..
you don't say! shut the fuck up, you fucking moron!
Liked
impresionante metal forever
It's totally not bad for the way he sings. Gonna be so tough but he managed to finish it
Power metal deluxe!
if i were andy.ill be shy to sing this song.....
Watch the Unisonic version of this song...that is more Helloween than this...Helloween is a good band with Deris with some good Albums like The time of the oath...Unisonic plays the old Helloween stuff better,because they have one original guitar player and the two original voices...Helloween has one original guitar player and original bass player but Deris can not sing the old songs...sorry...I hope one day they make a tour with the original line-up...Hansen,Weikath,Kiske,Grosskopf...and on drums Uli Kusch...I know the original line-up was without Kiske and with Ingo on drums...but you know what I mean..
I don't think So. i've watch Kiske Sang Hellowen's old Songs in WACKEN 2011 SUCKS!!!!!....He can't sing his Songs ANYMORE..So Annoying and Disgusting no..no..!!!
Marco Lux say wut?
Andi Deris is like tortured in this song.. Anyway he is fantastic singer
Chime!
4:35 guitarist's voice sounds better...
Deris should just sing his songs. From Master of the rings and forward. Leave the good stuff from the old days to Hansen and Kiske... :-)
Hahaha
andy deris did a great job in this song.
Its really awful are you for real he cant sing Kiske songs for his life
+cappyu But i love kiske's voice! peace.
That's what happens when you hire a new singer with a diffrent register than your original. Andi is an Amazing singer and he's killer at singing his stuff live. For the Micheal stuff, I kind of wish he would just sing those songs in his own style but really he just wants to try to be as faithful to the Micheal era as possible and you can't fault him for the commitment.
I've heard Deris cover Kiske work and normally he does a damn fine job. But this song was not written for his range. This song has so many high notes and Deris's voice is too raspy to even reach them. It seems more like amutuer karaoke.
Andi es baritono y por lo tanto no puede llegar a los agudos del "gran" kiske. Si canta como lo hace hasta ahora es porque hasta ahi puede !! Ya Superenlo ahora es Andi Deris
Alexcode98 Exacto, la gente no entiende que tanto sus registros como timbres son muy distintos, estoy seguro que si Kiske intentara cantar canciones de Deris en muchas se es escucharía terrible...
Y ahora son los 2, vamoooooos
Deris is Helloween
Andi is the best singer ever, even his sing someone else song......God Bless You Helloween
KISKE !!!!! .....deris
YAH..MARCH IN TIME...OLEH HELLOWEEN YANG RENCANANYA AKAN BERKUNJUNG KE SULAWESI UTARA ATAU METALLICA GROUP..MUSIK KITA LIHAT SAJA NANTI...??!!
wonder if ozzy would get as much hate for singing children of the sea heaven and hell etc.? i actually like this version :)
helloween is good in this song- unisonic is perfect in this song.
Andi se esforçando muito pro tom kiske
Nunca voy a entender por qué la banda no acomodo las canciones de los keeper al tono de deris, una tercera abajo y la canta super bien
acabou a voz do Deris ??????
Queda demostrado que estos temas le quedan muy grande a deris.Michel es y sera el mejor
Son diferentes, no hay mejor o peor
Tell me what Michael Kiske has released since he left Helloween early in the 90's? A tons of shitty albums. The guy doesn't even like heavy metal hahahaha. Even you guys, his fanboys, don't buy his new stuff.
He's got a great voice and that's all. Can't compose or create anything.
who's on drums?? Is that Dani?
This is sad. They should never try to perform this piece live with Andi on vocals. They've dropped the piece 2-3 tones down and he still can't sing it properly. On the other hand, Kiske on Unisonic still KILLS this piece 50 years old that he is, hitting the exact notes he used to so many years ago...
At least Deris sings in his range. A lot of singers don’t, and it shows.
Deris kiske is legend.
He just didn't need to go to that pitch. His voice is naturally higher than Kiskes, so he doesn't actually need to hit the correct notes - shoulda just sung what felt right, instead his voice... ...sorta went all "fat".
What you just said there didn't make any kind of musical fucking sense. It's almost as though you're just "slamming" arguments around.
Induction Pretentious and musically educated? - I might be wrong about that, but you know, music tends to fall apart when some fuckwit comes along and declares what does and what doesn't make "musical sense". Enjoy your... nothing. It's a big nothing.
@@Inductus You are right and edgar must be deaf or musically uneducated. Andy was flat throughout the whole song. Edgar is talking nonsense.
Andy is andy... Mike is all... is light n' shadows.
Andi Deris jamais vai superá Kiske.
Já superou. São 27 anos na banda e uma porrada de hit e álbum foda. Enquanto o Kiske...
dobry jest
明日から頑張ろ
Los 2 cantan bien
andy,andy,andy,andy, is helloween, ich liebe andy und helloween
DONT EVER TRY TO SING WHAT KISKE DOING FOR HELLOWEEN !!!!!
Deris es un verdadero cantante 😍
this ver is quitely good. THe tone is lower compare to the original version.
Not too high for him. And if you watch some show before 2000, you'll see Deris can hit high note (push, for example).
But not now, it's past :(
o kiske éo cara
Se que no es bueno entrar en comparaciones, pero creo que Helloween se equivoca poniendo a Deris en evidencia al hacerle cantar estos temas. Simplemente no puede y no debe porque lo hace fatal. Está a años luz de Kiske en lo que a voz se refiere.
Canta tu aveer como te sale supéralo ..sería es mejor...y es más humilde le tu kiske....😛
Andi Deris Carisma nota 10 : técnica,fôlego 2.rsrs
a idade chegou rsrsrs
Ele ainda canta na média kk mas no palco é bem mais performático que o Michael msm kk
It's not Kiske...
Tuned down😟
WTF? deris no deberias de cantar mas las canciones de la era Kiske.. no puedes... son mucho para ti...
Cabollantis Thronos Estoy seguro que para Kiske también seria demasiado cantar las canciones de Andi Deris..