THE QUESTION by Denny O'Neil | Reconstructing a Forgotten Hero
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 чер 2024
- An analysis of Denny O'Neil's 1987 run for "The Question," looking at how the character was reconstructed with a thematic blend of Zen philosophy and self-improvement.
The Question and all related characters are owned by DC Comics.
SUBSCRIBE: ua-cam.com/channels/1YT.html...
WATCH NEXT - I Was Wrong About Harley Quinn: • I Was Wrong About HARL...
FOLLOW ON TWITTER: / everykindofgeek
TIMESTAMPS:
0:00 Intro
2:18 Zen And Violence
5:10 I Heard A Joker About Hub City
7:46 Pushing The Envelope
9:40 Beyond Watchmen/Outro
Music:
A Nebula Inside - ELFL
Alienated - ELFL
Born in the 90's(instrumental) - Ameryh
Sunstorm - ELFL
Temple of Runha - ELFL
Voices:
Richard Dragon: Bard College of Citrus
Green Arrow: Critical Rants
#DCFandome
#DCcomics
#TheQuestion - Розваги
I've been a huge fan of The Question for such a long time. I watched him in Justice League Unlimited and read through his recent Black Label series and was always on the fence about the O'Neil run until I remembered that it's by one of my favorite artists Denys Cowan. Amazing video dude, well put together and informative.
Thanks, AJ! I was a pretty big fan of Vic's JLU appearances myself. It's a shame that he only gets mainstream attention through massive overhauls like the '86 run and 52, but hopefully the Black Label series is a sign that we're gonna see more of him in the future. Fingers crossed!
Oh, interesting. I am looking for comicbooks with the question. So you can recommend the „black label“ series?
I used to read this
I would kill for a live action series about the Question
I heard that James Gunn was actually making one. Not sure how credible it is, I'm pretty sure it was just a leak. Could be fake. Fingers crossed it isn't.
🤔
I love The Question. Ever since I watched him in JL Unlimited, I wanted to see more of the character. It has been years, and yet DC still have not collected the O Neil run in a new trade collection. I wish they would. The series is fantastic, and breathed new life Into Vic Sage.
Denny O'Neil is an absolute legend. The Question, Batman, Ra's Al Ghul. One of the best writers of the Silver Age if not all time
No arguments here.
Dennis O'neils "Question" run is one of my favorite comic book runs of all time. Years ago my grandmother got me a book for Christmas called "DC universe: a year by year visual chronicle" that was basically a time line of all of the comics published by DC up to around the time the new 52 started. Flipping through it I stummbled across the cover for issue 1 illustrated by Bill Sienkiewicz and the moment I saw it I knew that I had to read it. Thankfully the trade paper back collections were still relatively cheap at the time and I was able to track down the complete run. It's one of the few times that I'm glad that I judged a book by its cover art.
Can't go wrong with Sienkiewicz' art! I had kinda a similar experience coming across the run, and since then I keep coming back every now and then. There's always something more to discover, and I can't help but think The Question was some of O'Neil's greatest work because of that.
Not sure if ur an omnibus collector but Dennis O’Neil Question omnibus vol 1 comes out 6/28/22.
Another great work by Denny O'Neil, although (sadly) not as talked about as his works on Batman, Green Lantern & Green Arrow, or Iron Man.
I love the Question. Maybe it's because I watched Justice league unlimited as a kid and Question was awesome in it.
Ah The Question a character WB refuses to use. They won't put him in the movies because they might want a show and won't make a show because they might want to make a movie.
The Question was part of my regular buys in the late 80s, with 2000AD, Blue Beetle and Lone Wolf and Cub. As a teen I remember being really enamoured by him, I don't clearly remember why, certainly the anonymity of his disguise contributed to it. I do intend to return to many of those comics I loved as a teen in my renewed interest in comics. Though I have already gone back to the 2000AD of this period and so much of it stands up. Judge Dredd - Block Mania/Apocalypse War, Chopper - Song of the surfer, Slaine - The Horned God, Bad Company, Moore's The Ballad of Halo Jones and Morrison's Zenith. Oh and Massimo Belardinelli's art. The Dead is so trippy. Highly Recommended. There is just so much great stuff that has been produced since then to catch up on. Vertigo it seems was kicking arse. I just fnished Marvels and Punisher Max has replaced Dark Knight Returns as my favourite storylines from the American big 2. In the 80s I would never have believed that anything published by Marvel would transcend pulp stories for me.
Ha just found your channel and I think I binged 6 videos already … good stuff!
Great vid. love the question, he’s too good to be this unknown.
I wouldn't call him an unknown. He's nowhere near someone like Batman but he's had a pretty healthy cult following since 52 and his appearances in JLU. Just wish that translated into a few more books
I read this whole run about a week ago and loved it. However, I also really loved Renee Montoya's tenure as The Question. I feel Greg Rucka kind of being the heir to O'Neil when it came to these more spiritual and introspective type stories. Rucka even put callbacks to O'Neil in both 52 and his subsequent books with Renee. Great video!
Thanks so much!! I'm also a pretty big fan of Rucka's, especially his work on the Cry for Blood miniseries.
I would love for you to cover some of his work. I don't think any of the other comic video essayists have.
The talent on display in this video is honestly ridiculous, man. I’m so glad you turned me on to O’Neil’s run-I’m currently 10 issues in and loving it so far. Very excited to see where the rest of the run takes me
Zen and Violence was such a terrific arc. Had the TPB. Really loved it. Forcing Vic Sage to GROW.
I so thankful for finding your channel. I paid tribute to Denny years ago but I was too choked up to do it justice. Glad you did him better justice than I, sir.
I'm so excited for the omnibus and I'm glad i got the deluxe edition of watchman
let's be honest, we all love the question because of the justice league unlimited animated series, great video :-)
Thanks!!
I'm thrilled to find a genuine critique on UA-cam instead of the far more numerous ( and profitable ?) smears and I Hate This And You Should Too type of reviews . Well done !
Awesome video the definitive question. More O'Neill videos
Been reading the question omnibus. Damn is it good. Has the best elments of daredevil and batman. Reads like fine wine.
This is the best intro to the Question I've come across. Love it. 👍
Gotta check this series out sometime. Slight correction though Miracleman (aka Marvelman) predates Watchmen. It was written by Alan Moore back when he was at Warrior (he was also doing V for Vendetta).
I love the question, I found your video on the question reddit page! Your video is super well done! Keep it up and I look forward to your new content
Thanks very much!!
After watching Justice League Unlimited and listening to the 52 audio drama, I love the Question. I really like the exploration of unwavering morality, someone who has a code in a city of corrupt and dangerous people.
I can't wait to get me these Omnibuses! ;p
He’s awesome and his Memories lives forever ♥️💕🙏😊
Yooooo this video is incredible!
Thanks so much!
As I recall, back while it was running, Denny hinted that Hub City was actually inspired by East St. Louis 😬 Loved that series. Sage and Shiva at their best.
This was a great overview of the series that i read around 12 years ago in trade paperback volumes, that i borrowed from local library. They are out of print. I was engrossed in Vic Sage's personal journey of self improvement. This series effectively the pervasive effects of institutionalised corruption in Hub City. It would make for a great limited series for tv or streaming service.
DC Comics has republished most of the run in an Omnibus coming out in July 2022, which includes reprints of the letter columns. Hopefully a second volume will be published to complete the run, which includes The Question Quarterly.
Your video was so beautifully done! Great, as always!
The Question sounds weird and I'm very intrigued now.
Thanks! And yes, both the and the book are incredibly weird, but in the best possible way!
Not even Omar's video on The Question made me buy it but this one did. Can't wait to get the omni.
I really appreciate the insight into how O'Niel refocused the themes of the character. Great video mate 👍🏾
Thanks so much!
Very interesting and I like all his Memories
I have the first 20 issues or so of the 80’s Question series. It’s a shame it was never reprinted. Because of this, it’s outrageously expensive to find the Trade paperbacks. I think I saw the 3 or 4 volumes once being sold for like $800
I think they released a new omnibus collection not too long ago!
This was great! Thanks!
Amazing video!
Thanks!!
Awesome video and awesome character
Amazing video. How do you do that. Its great and makes me want to read it.
Great analysis
Thanks so much!
Yes
I love that music you used during this excellent video? Where’s that music from? Artist? Thanks!
I like the video, but I would recommend to turn down the volume of the music.
It's kinda weird that the Question is my favorite superhero, but I have less books about him, than others I can only tolerate most of the times. It's sad, that most books of him is OOP.
It’s a real shame, the medium’s chock-full of characters who have great potential but rarely get the exposure they deserve. Question even got a new limited series that was pretty good, but DC hasn’t pushed for the character and others like him the same way they’d push for Batman. Hope that changes soon.
Heard that Moore started to give flack to superheroes as a whole. I do understand why he dislikes more vapid characters like Deadpool and characters that are incorruptible, but he did change superheroes for the better, and it’s a shame that he fails to appreciate his influence.
True, although I think his complaints are more leveled at the companies than the characters. Moore's expressed plenty of love for more "optimistic" fare, but I'd imagine writing that only to get hamstrung by publishers has probably soured his opinions a bit.
The only authentic version of the Question was Steve Ditko's. There's no separating the character from Objectivist philosophy. Alan Moore thinks Objectivism is "fascist," which demonstrates he doesn't understand Objectivism at all. That said, I think Denny O'Neil is very talented, although the character he came up with was the Question in name only.
I prefer the Ditko version.
First off, Hub City is based off STL. And yeah, it's like that. It's actually horrible.
I believe O'Neil was from this area.
The Ditko Question was interesting, based on moral absolutes. A is A. That's it.
I don't see the re‐ imagined Vic Sage so much as deconstructing as the character grows. Shiva offers him one path, Dragon another. But he has to find his own way. He becomes a better person. JLU had a good take on him, and Jeff Combs was perfectly cast.
The comparison with Rorshach is hard to dodge. But here's the difference. Kovacs couldn't evolve as a person. Which is actually more like the Ditko version. It's almost a parody in a tragic way. O'Neil wrote Vic as a student and later a teacher.
Renee Montoya as Question was garbage.
Objectivism has almost 0 influence on comic books apart from 2 characters created by ditko.
Alan Moore has an extremely unjustified hatred of Steve ditko, and even insulted him in the documentary “in search of ditko”. He did this knowing full well ditko was an extremely private person that would never respond.