As long as it makes sense story wise and it’s not for nostalgic bait then I think they should come back. Because I do believe Obi-Wan and Anakin still have stories to tell. I still want a season two of Obi-Wan just because I wanna see his force ghost journey! I wanted to be him and Qui-gon training to be a force ghost and that’s all the serious needs to be. You don’t need other characters make it intimate series about Obi-Wan’s journey.
@@KianGunner bring in natalie too. Imagine a scene of vader remembering padme. I think there's even a comic where he meets one of her handmaiden lookalikes.
I still don't understand the hate for filoni from a lot of people. Clone Wars, Rebels, Mandalorian, etc. He's had his share of unsuccessful projects too, but so did lucas. And he really seems to understand the heart of star wars, based on what I've seen and read in interviews.
Are you kidding me????? Not one of those three projects you mentioned were failures. Everyone I have every talked to about those shows have loved them.
Some people don't like that the his new live-action shows have become so interconnected with the animated shows that it feels alienating to casual SW fans who aren’t familiar with the animated shows.
This makes sense to me for him to return. I am worried though they are going to show the Mortis gods clone wars episode in live action. That is one of my biggest worries. But as for Hayden to come back, it makes sense to me because I don’t think his story is over. I think he is the new father for the Mortis gods and we will see the mother finally. That’s where I think this story is headed.
I just want his appearance to have purpose and not feel like a gimmick. He could have access to knowledge and insights that Anakin doesn't, that could help in his foreign galaxy.
@@MrHughMungus it wasn't until the clone wars that they started to be used as child soldiers. Surrounded by all that death all the time, and then betrayed by the clones, who they thought they could trust, probably every jedi or kid that survived 66 would have severe ptsd.
I was hopeing to see second seasons of Obi-Wan Kenobi and Ahsoka next year. Maybe we can see a lightsaber duel between Darth Vader and Darth Maul in Obi-Wan Kenobi 2 with a three-year time jump and Galen Marek in live action in Ahsoka season 2.
Well they kneweach other quite well, if Obi Wan's force ghost is still knocking about it makes sense that he might check in now and then instead of just floating about, or whatever it is force ghosts do in their spare time.
Rosario Dawson is a great actress, but I feel like a lot of her scenes were phoned in on this show (was much better on mando). I also really wish her lightsaber scenes were better. I couldn't put my finger on it, but it just felt like maybe she was really nervous and was afraid of the choreography?
I think her performance is more indicative of Ahsoka's depiction in rebels, seeing how the experience she accumulated carrying into adulthood has made her more emotionally reserved
I hope rossariontrains more with saber fighting or they get a stunt double, the saber fighting felt way to slow, especially when she fought anakin. You could tell Hayden had to slow down for her to keep up and it just felt like a rehearsal instead of a battle for the scene
Many people called bringing back RDJ into the MCU as desperate, and I disagreed heavily. Bringing Ewan McGregor back, for Ashoka, feels desperate. Obi Wan is dead, so it would be either force ghost Obi Wan mentoring Ashoka, which I don’t like since his mission was completed during Return of the Jedi and he could rest in peace. Or it will be flashbacks, which I don’t like the idea of.
More soulless and useless cameos whose only purpose is fan service and nostalgia bait, meant to distract viewers from realizing how horrible the writing is. Sorry, but everything Filoni and Favreau write feels like it’s straight out of a mid-tier video game. I’ll miss Andor and Skeleton Crew, man. I can’t believe Filoni and his key jingling have so many fans
@ Just like that lame arc in Season 1, I’m sure the story was written with the sole purpose of including some nostalgic, well-known characters again, not because it feels necessary
@francesco3089 oh yeah, because the entire crux of ahsokas arc in the show totally had nothing to do with her struggle with the idea of being the protégé of Vader and Anakin.
I don't care anymore. I don't get excited about Star Wars at all. Can't even watch the original trilogy because they've ruined it for me with the sequels, especially the last one (don't even remember the title).
They need to bring in big names because they know their show is shit. Well, they should know. Problem is, the show with Kenobi and Vader is even worse. Good luck Filoni, you hack
They need to use Hayden and Ewan while they still can… don’t want them to age out like Harrison, Mark and Carrie
As long as it makes sense story wise and it’s not for nostalgic bait then I think they should come back. Because I do believe Obi-Wan and Anakin still have stories to tell.
I still want a season two of Obi-Wan just because I wanna see his force ghost journey! I wanted to be him and Qui-gon training to be a force ghost and that’s all the serious needs to be. You don’t need other characters make it intimate series about Obi-Wan’s journey.
@@KianGunner bring in natalie too. Imagine a scene of vader remembering padme. I think there's even a comic where he meets one of her handmaiden lookalikes.
Ahsoka is not that kid from the clone wars anymore. She has been through a lot after the clone wars. That's why she is the way she is.
My god if we get obi wan in his clone wars armor ill be satisfied
LOL, Star Wars Episode X : “ Cornucopia of Bummer “ 😆✌🏽
Ahoska was better than a lot of Star Wars but for sure had it's issues
im not the biggest fan of the character from clone wars but it's honestly my favorite star wars show since obiwan
Tell me you don’t know Ahsokas character without saying you don’t understand her character.
I still don't understand the hate for filoni from a lot of people. Clone Wars, Rebels, Mandalorian, etc. He's had his share of unsuccessful projects too, but so did lucas. And he really seems to understand the heart of star wars, based on what I've seen and read in interviews.
Are you kidding me????? Not one of those three projects you mentioned were failures. Everyone I have every talked to about those shows have loved them.
Some people don't like that the his new live-action shows have become so interconnected with the animated shows that it feels alienating to casual SW fans who aren’t familiar with the animated shows.
None of George Lucas’s Star Wars projects failed
@@Fsudryden sorry for the confusion, I meant that those were great shows.
@@beanburritozz3044 i just meant that some weren't as well received as others.
This makes sense to me for him to return. I am worried though they are going to show the Mortis gods clone wars episode in live action. That is one of my biggest worries.
But as for Hayden to come back, it makes sense to me because I don’t think his story is over. I think he is the new father for the Mortis gods and we will see the mother finally. That’s where I think this story is headed.
i hope itll be force ghost obiwan instead of flashbacks.
Why isn't Ewan in ANDOR season 2!?
Or is he..
Because he definitely alive at this point..
I heard season 3 we will get Mace Windu, Season 4 Ki Aid Mundi, Season 5 Yaddle!!
I just want his appearance to have purpose and not feel like a gimmick. He could have access to knowledge and insights that Anakin doesn't, that could help in his foreign galaxy.
idk why everyone is so anti clone wars here
Yes give us Ewan mcgregor wearing is clone wars armor of the 212 battalion
Oh hell yes.
Does anybody know why John stopped reviewing Skeleton Crew episodes on the show?
Not sure, but someone asked a question and he said he’s still loving it.
because no one is watching it
Ashoka is different because she was a child Soilder with ptsd and had to overcome it
Right because every single Jedi didn't start training as a child right?..
@@MrHughMungusbetter late than never
@@MrHughMungus it wasn't until the clone wars that they started to be used as child soldiers. Surrounded by all that death all the time, and then betrayed by the clones, who they thought they could trust, probably every jedi or kid that survived 66 would have severe ptsd.
I want Clone Wars live action
I was hopeing to see second seasons of Obi-Wan Kenobi and Ahsoka next year. Maybe we can see a lightsaber duel between Darth Vader and Darth Maul in Obi-Wan Kenobi 2 with a three-year time jump and Galen Marek in live action in Ahsoka season 2.
HELLO THERE!
Well they kneweach other quite well, if Obi Wan's force ghost is still knocking about it makes sense that he might check in now and then instead of just floating about, or whatever it is force ghosts do in their spare time.
Yay more Member Berries
Rosario Dawson is a great actress, but I feel like a lot of her scenes were phoned in on this show (was much better on mando). I also really wish her lightsaber scenes were better. I couldn't put my finger on it, but it just felt like maybe she was really nervous and was afraid of the choreography?
I think her performance is more indicative of Ahsoka's depiction in rebels, seeing how the experience she accumulated carrying into adulthood has made her more emotionally reserved
@@TastenIV it was probably the choreography mixed with the awkward space in the volume. They really need to be on real sets next time.
No no no, please no.The only reason to bring Obi Wan back is for the member-berries.
No
Desperation.
I hope rossariontrains more with saber fighting or they get a stunt double, the saber fighting felt way to slow, especially when she fought anakin. You could tell Hayden had to slow down for her to keep up and it just felt like a rehearsal instead of a battle for the scene
Are you kidding me right now?? That lightsaber fight was intense! It’s not just about speed and flips.
I hope they got better writers and I hope rosario dawson and the girl who plays sabine get some better direction! Filoni shouldn't write or direct tbh
Why you always moaning about Ashoka John? it was actually quite good, especially the patterson cut.. daymm and your letting somebody else speak👀
Thank you! Every time he says it wasn’t good it annoys the hilt crap out of me I loved that show it was awesome
Because John is a very picky person when it comes to Star Wars.
because it was horrible garbage
@@MrHughMungus not everyone shares that opinion
Acolyte was horrible Garbage
This tells me more of the world Between Worlds which gives me hope that the retcon can still happen
World Between Worlds is hot hot garbage
@MrHughMungus well it is the only thing that could save Star Wars
@ how
“The Retcon” is never happening
Many people called bringing back RDJ into the MCU as desperate, and I disagreed heavily. Bringing Ewan McGregor back, for Ashoka, feels desperate. Obi Wan is dead, so it would be either force ghost Obi Wan mentoring Ashoka, which I don’t like since his mission was completed during Return of the Jedi and he could rest in peace. Or it will be flashbacks, which I don’t like the idea of.
Do you like anything? 😂😂
@@JoshWallcroft Disney Star Wars, your home for endless pointless prequels and nostalgia bait with a sprinkle of killing off legacy characters 1 by 1
Ashoka wasnt good but i guess more folding arm acting 😂
More soulless and useless cameos whose only purpose is fan service and nostalgia bait, meant to distract viewers from realizing how horrible the writing is. Sorry, but everything Filoni and Favreau write feels like it’s straight out of a mid-tier video game. I’ll miss Andor and Skeleton Crew, man. I can’t believe Filoni and his key jingling have so many fans
Are you talking about Anakin and Obi Wan? Useless cameos?
@ Just like that lame arc in Season 1, I’m sure the story was written with the sole purpose of including some nostalgic, well-known characters again, not because it feels necessary
@francesco3089 oh yeah, because the entire crux of ahsokas arc in the show totally had nothing to do with her struggle with the idea of being the protégé of Vader and Anakin.
@@francesco3089 you need to work on your media literacy
@@TreyJaySoSway yes
I don't care anymore. I don't get excited about Star Wars at all. Can't even watch the original trilogy because they've ruined it for me with the sequels, especially the last one (don't even remember the title).
They need to bring in big names because they know their show is shit. Well, they should know. Problem is, the show with Kenobi and Vader is even worse. Good luck Filoni, you hack