For Valour: The Victoria Cross | Mark Smith

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 115

  • @Perspectiveon
    @Perspectiveon Рік тому +13

    I'm a retired Army Major - served seven tours during the 90s in former Joguslavia and the Middle East - awarded two Destinguished Service Medals ao bling, but what makes me proud is being a relative of a dane getting awarded the VC in WW II. He was a sailor in the danish merchant marine and joined the Brits after Denmark was occupied by the Nazis April 9th 1940. He served with SBS - Special forces and fell near Bologna/Italy April 9th 1945 at the age of 24 with the rank of Major. Was awarded the VC posthumously. Earlier in the war he was awarded the Military Cross 3 times. Still makes me sad thinking about him serving for practically the entire war and falling just one month before VE Day. His name was Anders Lassen. He in turn was related to another dane awarded the VC 1918 during WW I - Thomas Dinesen Canadian Royal Highlanders died 1979 aged 86.

  • @leshughes748
    @leshughes748 2 роки тому +22

    I am a stone mason, and I was privileged to hand carve the vc on a headstone for the first soldier from the Coldstream guards. I was also present at the ceremony of the unveiling. God save the queen. 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🇬🇧🇺🇦🇺🇸🇪🇺🇨🇦🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🇮🇱I am humbled. ❤️

    • @3vimages471
      @3vimages471 Рік тому

      What soldier and where is the headstone please?

  • @martinplatt5928
    @martinplatt5928 10 місяців тому +4

    Mark Smith is without doubt an incredible raconteur and medals expert. Great watching this!

  • @paulwright9749
    @paulwright9749 7 місяців тому +4

    Mark Smith is a great storyteller. I’m sat here watching this with tears in my eyes. 🇬🇧🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🇬🇧🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿

  • @duncanselvester1045
    @duncanselvester1045 3 роки тому +23

    What a wonderful way to spend an hour!! Superb.
    This should be a compulsory history lesson in schools.
    I am in awe, my measly three trinkets (none for charging a machine gun nest!) still make my boys proud, but actually they have no clue.

  • @angussmith4305
    @angussmith4305 3 роки тому +12

    I come from many years of utter hatred of desk bound Mod civil servants , I have to say if ever there should be cause for an immediate Kinghthood it should be for Mr. Smith and the citation should read ...... honesty humility and accuracy on behalf of the nation!

  • @bethlightfoot4334
    @bethlightfoot4334 4 роки тому +31

    Probably the most interesting and informative talks on youtube.

  • @mastacraft
    @mastacraft Рік тому +4

    Mark you champion🏆 of our forefathers and mothers. Respect from the great grandson of a VC holder.

  • @elliottgoad3128
    @elliottgoad3128 10 місяців тому +3

    One of the best talks l have seen in this series.

  • @andrewkusabs1740
    @andrewkusabs1740 Рік тому +3

    Absolutely wonderful tales of the heroism of extraordinary human beings related by a man who knows what he’s talking about

  • @islandhopperstuart
    @islandhopperstuart Рік тому +2

    Fascinating: what a fabulous speaker. Thanks WFA.

  • @markb9868
    @markb9868 Рік тому +5

    What a wonderful raconteur on such an emotive subject . Can we hear more from him please

  • @Lava1964
    @Lava1964 3 роки тому +3

    I came across this terrific clip by accident. What a total delight it was.

  • @sandywilkie564
    @sandywilkie564 Рік тому +1

    One of the best things I’ve ever watched. Thank you.

  • @brianford8493
    @brianford8493 7 місяців тому +2

    That was brilliant ta!

  • @tommarshall1660
    @tommarshall1660 5 років тому +10

    Just watched it with tears in my eyes. Wow.

  • @bobmiller7502
    @bobmiller7502 2 роки тому

    Dam good story teller, thanks 4 sharing,,never STOP loving,,bobble&MrTao,xx

  • @tectoramia-sz1lu
    @tectoramia-sz1lu Рік тому

    Brilliant, I've watched this a couple of times.

  • @noeldonovan3363
    @noeldonovan3363 2 роки тому

    Wonderful, so interesting and informative... Glued to it for the full hour... Well done Mark Smith...

  • @lorlabear
    @lorlabear Рік тому

    A very informative talk, which I thoroughly enjoyed. Thank you.

  • @paralogregt
    @paralogregt 3 роки тому +1

    Fantastic presentation. Good to hear the truth about where the bronze comes from.

  • @jamesmorgan2015
    @jamesmorgan2015 22 дні тому

    Wonderful

  • @rogersmith5738
    @rogersmith5738 2 роки тому

    OMG! Great talk Mark, thank you very much for this.

  • @heritage195
    @heritage195 2 роки тому +1

    What a presentation! The best!!

    • @asnieres32
      @asnieres32 2 роки тому

      Mark Smith is a marvelous storyteller.

  • @raybenstead2548
    @raybenstead2548 6 років тому +6

    Really interesting lecture, enjoyed listening to him.

  • @markrunnalls7215
    @markrunnalls7215 2 роки тому

    Really great to listen to you chat Mark ,very interesting indeed ,thank you .

  • @julieblundell7421
    @julieblundell7421 5 років тому +2

    Brilliant, very interesting, I could listen to this man all night.

    • @andrewkusabs1740
      @andrewkusabs1740 5 років тому

      Julie Blundell Me too. I’ve shared it with my brothers and children.

  • @andybawn1
    @andybawn1 4 роки тому +4

    Most enjoyable talk

  • @localbod
    @localbod 6 років тому +7

    Thanks for posting this.
    Absolutely fascinating and so informative.

  • @stokiestewpotter7956
    @stokiestewpotter7956 2 роки тому

    Interesting, informative,a brilliant excellent lecture.
    So knowledgeable,thankyou.

  • @shoofly529
    @shoofly529 6 років тому +4

    Have watched it several times & decided to become a member.

  • @raymondjarvis765
    @raymondjarvis765 10 місяців тому +1

    I was lucky to meet two v.c. winners while I served ...smokey and price...both interesting individuals...never talked about how they won them just about my service as they both wanted to hear my aspirations....very personable guys..r.i.p

  • @eamoncadden7721
    @eamoncadden7721 Місяць тому

    brilliant guy

  • @RicTic66
    @RicTic66 7 років тому +5

    Fabulous lecture I really enjoyed it

  • @sbandsman1
    @sbandsman1 2 роки тому +1

    Visited the Ashcroft Collection last week at the IWM, So interesting AND even has "interactive " things for younger visitors. If anyone get the chance to visit make sure you have plenty of time as you will be so engrossed with the stories of ALL the awards time WILL fly.

    • @shoofly529
      @shoofly529 2 роки тому

      We're from the US & visited the IWM last Sunday. Highlight of our weekend trip.
      My wife, a physician,didn't like the diary entry directed towards the women starting hospitals, quote: "Go home & be still!"
      {When men were men :)}
      US women lost the football match on Friday :( Had a blast in the stands tho!

  • @dannywlm63
    @dannywlm63 4 роки тому +5

    I accepted the Victoria Cross were made from sebastobal cannons . Does in no way decrease the value, truly the highest possible honour and the hardest to win

  • @shotleylad
    @shotleylad 5 років тому +8

    A pity the Royal Artillery Museum had to close

  • @chrishewitt4220
    @chrishewitt4220 7 років тому +3

    Wonderful lecture. Very interesting.

  • @delbond5977
    @delbond5977 5 років тому +2

    Excellent talk. I was there.

  • @shlomomark2275
    @shlomomark2275 3 роки тому

    Excellent lecture

  • @buonafortuna8928
    @buonafortuna8928 3 роки тому

    Mark Smith is a great speaker

  • @shoofly529
    @shoofly529 2 роки тому +1

    "About 500. He was a Lewis gunner: he did the job for real."

  • @jschoir8114
    @jschoir8114 4 роки тому +1

    Very interesting and informative .

  • @daveenberg9075
    @daveenberg9075 3 роки тому +1

    Very interesting and heartfelt. As he said the importance is the story not the medal. My Grandfather enlisted with the Canadians in 1915 and he and his friends were placed in the 46th. Battalion. The Battalion was sent to England in the Fall of 1915 and the next year 155 of them were sent to the front as replacements for the 16th. Battalion (the Canadian Scottish). They first fought a Ypres and then were sent to The Somme. When the Battalion left The Somme on the 11th. of Oct. my Grandfather and his best friend found them self's as the only two members of their Platoon that had survived the Summer of 1916. The Battalion was sent directly from The Somme to Vimy Ridge. Easter 1917 the 16th. Battalion was in the first wave of the assault on the Ridge. My Grandfather and his best friend had been asked to both lead a squad as their Platoon was short NCO's and they were the only combat veterans. I quote from my Grandfather's memoirs" Milne and his squad got up against a machine gun. Milne had his men take cover in a small shell hole and went straight for the gun alone. All the time they were firing at him, when he got close they threw a grenade at him but he bombed them to death and comes back to his men and they went on. At the first objective a machine gun starts firing on them. He had his men take cover around a bend in the trench. He had more time and was able to get around in back of them and bombed them. He picked up the gun and bought it back to his men. He had killed twelve of them and put two machine guns out of action by himself. As we waited for the next creeping barrage to start one of our shells explored to soon. Short as we called it. My friend Milne was hit in his back and killed. My friend Milne was awarded the Victoria Cross the highest decoration of the British Army. The Scottish 51st. were on our right. It was one of their Officers that recommended him for it. What a man I wish I was half as brave as he was.Milne was the best." (427586 Pte. W.J. Milne V.C.) Deas Gu Cath

    • @edwardbutt691
      @edwardbutt691 3 роки тому

      Incredible story - thank you for sharing.

    • @2394Joseph
      @2394Joseph 3 роки тому

      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Johnstone_Milne

  • @kennymilne6125
    @kennymilne6125 5 років тому +8

    There were many troops from Scotland and Ireland at the Battle of balaclava , not just English, and I'm sure there would have been Welshman there aswell , I keep forgetting it's the English army , not the British army

    • @donathandorko
      @donathandorko 4 роки тому +1

      Agreed but one of his most poignant descriptions of a VC winner was that Daniel Cambridge, of Ulster. England and and Britain are often intertwined and confused, mostly by Americans, but in this case by an Englishman. I'm sure if this was pointed out he would agree with you too and apologise.

    • @douglapointe6810
      @douglapointe6810 3 роки тому

      Kenny Milne ... Alexander Dunn VC was a Canadian in the charge. The first Canadian to be awarded the VC.

    • @kennymilne2176
      @kennymilne2176 3 роки тому

      @@douglapointe6810 Canadians have always shown themselves to be very brave , skilled and highly competent soldiers , god bless them

    • @mikedon5205
      @mikedon5205 Рік тому

      Agreed in fact I'd argue the majority would have come from Scotland and Ireland

  • @glenndwyer5786
    @glenndwyer5786 3 роки тому +1

    I got chills

  • @zaynevanday142
    @zaynevanday142 3 роки тому +2

    You don’t win a VC you earn it !

  • @billsandford3901
    @billsandford3901 7 років тому +1

    Great! I wonder is the replacement VC cast in 1972 was it for Gen. Milton Grieg VC ?

  • @markliske9588
    @markliske9588 Рік тому

    an interesting story, three Canadian soldiers who all lived on the same street in Winnipeg were awarded the Victoria Cross

  • @harryurz
    @harryurz 2 місяці тому

    Regarding verification of VC awards, Mark fails to mention Billy Bishop's unwitnessed actions on 2 June 1917, arguably a unique award.

  • @richardlympany6732
    @richardlympany6732 2 роки тому

    Fascinating

  • @gazpal
    @gazpal 3 роки тому +1

    My old workmate's grandfather earned the VC during WWI (Nov 1915). His family weren't aware of the medal until moving furniture - after his death in 1948 - and his boxed medal was discovered on top of a wardrobe.

    • @anthonyeaton5153
      @anthonyeaton5153 3 роки тому

      How could the family not know, all VCs were welcomed with huge crowds and brass bands. It could not be kept quiet.

    • @gazpal
      @gazpal 3 роки тому

      @@anthonyeaton5153 younger generation, the award wasn't mentioned, etc. War is hell and few choose to say much or wish to be reminded of the worst of times. He was a coalminer and simply focused on everyday life, working and raising his family .... His medal lay forgotten atop his wardrobe, to be rediscovered some time after his death. His name was Thomas Kenny V.C.

    • @anthonyeaton5153
      @anthonyeaton5153 3 роки тому

      @@gazpal it would still have been in the public domain newspapers etc. I think there wasn’t a VC awarded. Please let me know the winners name. Thank you.

    • @gazpal
      @gazpal 3 роки тому

      @@anthonyeaton5153 i used to work with his grandson and the medal's rediscovery received quite some write-up at the time.
      17424 Pte. Thomas Kenny V.C. - 13th Batt. D.L.I.
      His grandson was John Barber - my work colleague - who brought newspaper cuttings into work to show me, but the ongoing conversation we had was during the 1970's and long before the internet and readily available online information.
      www.lightinfantry.me.uk/vckenny.htm

    • @twinsonic
      @twinsonic 3 роки тому +1

      The VC and any other medals are not won, they are earned.

  • @Iazzaboyce
    @Iazzaboyce Рік тому +1

    Handling a genuine VC that way is not a great idea. If it were accidentally dropped it could easily dent. Correctly secured into an open box it could be studied and protected.

  • @Baskerville22
    @Baskerville22 5 років тому +3

    I would have liked to ask him if he thought that the degree of valour exhibited in the winning of more recently awarded VCs has been degraded compared to, say, WW1 era VCs.

  • @thelastaustralian7583
    @thelastaustralian7583 3 роки тому +2

    lest we forget

  • @paulmckeand6477
    @paulmckeand6477 3 роки тому

    Well done

  • @larspederbjorendalhollaend4875
    @larspederbjorendalhollaend4875 3 роки тому

    Has the museum closed? Where are the exhibits now?

  • @catlee8064
    @catlee8064 9 місяців тому

    I have a few medals, from NI, bosnia, kosovo and the sandy countries....i have lots of stories, but id rather have my mind and my mates back.

  • @stephenmcdonald7908
    @stephenmcdonald7908 2 роки тому

    What an amazing and informative lecture.

  • @imedi
    @imedi 6 років тому +4

    16:47 pretty sure there were irish scots and welsh there too

    • @donathandorko
      @donathandorko 4 роки тому

      Agreed but one of his most poignant descriptions of a VC winner was that Daniel Cambridge, of Ulster. England and and Britain are often intertwined and confused, mostly by Americans, but in this case by an Englishman. I'm sure if this was pointed out he would agree with you too and apologise.

    • @asnieres32
      @asnieres32 2 роки тому

      @@donathandorko Daniel Cambridge was from Ireland.

  • @expatexpat6531
    @expatexpat6531 3 роки тому

    Wonderful talk.

  • @nickinportland
    @nickinportland 3 роки тому

    No one does history better than Britain

    • @asnieres32
      @asnieres32 2 роки тому

      No one does 'glorious' English history like England. You should learn another language and then get out a bit more.

  • @tectorama
    @tectorama 4 роки тому +1

    I think the baby may have been named "Daniel Tremendous McKenzie" not James ?

  • @daveferguson935
    @daveferguson935 3 роки тому

    Lest we forget.

  • @shlomomark2275
    @shlomomark2275 3 роки тому

    Was a VC awarded during the Northern Ireland conflict?

    • @paralogregt
      @paralogregt 3 роки тому +1

      No

    • @asnieres32
      @asnieres32 2 роки тому

      @@paralogregt No surprise. Not much valour happening.

  • @keithhodgson6489
    @keithhodgson6489 3 роки тому

    The best 56 minutes you could spend.

  • @Nounismisation
    @Nounismisation 6 років тому

    AHHH!! And now "My guns" !!!!

  • @MikeHarland-m2g
    @MikeHarland-m2g 8 місяців тому

    The English Channel should get the VC. For without it the German army would have over run Britain just like it had Europe. Then the US would not have been able to rescue us by sending men, arms, supplies for D day. There would not have been a D day. And the Germans might have defeated the Red army as it would not have been fighting in Western Europe.
    We were lucky to have 5he channel to save us.

  • @phililpb
    @phililpb Місяць тому

    it does not matter how many VC's Lord Ashcroft buys he does not have any

  • @anthonyeaton5153
    @anthonyeaton5153 3 роки тому

    Could you clarify what you have just written it doesn’t make sense.

  • @arjunuk1
    @arjunuk1 4 роки тому +2

    the first lady will be a medic, the RMAC i'm lead to believe they have the most. (to date 27 + 2 bars)

    • @anthonyeaton5153
      @anthonyeaton5153 3 роки тому

      27+2 what?

    • @joewalker2152
      @joewalker2152 3 роки тому

      @@anthonyeaton5153 It means they were awarded another VC. So if you are awarded two VCs at two different times you don't wear two VCs, you wear one and a "Bar" on the ribbon of the first one. It's the same for all gallantry awards in the British Armed Forces. D.S.O. and bar, Military Cross and bar etc, etc.. Also, you could be awarded more as in Military Cross and three bars.

  • @archangel1499
    @archangel1499 2 роки тому

    #VictoriaCross
    #SpecialAirService
    #TalaiasiLabalaba
    #BattleOfMirbat
    ✌🐉✌X

  • @tjwilliams7566
    @tjwilliams7566 2 роки тому

    Your name sir

  • @arthurmahy8493
    @arthurmahy8493 3 роки тому

    W

  • @zaynevanday142
    @zaynevanday142 3 роки тому

    Bloody Drop Shorts

  • @Nounismisation
    @Nounismisation 6 років тому

    "My left hand gun"?? My???

  • @EldeLDorELLEN
    @EldeLDorELLEN 4 роки тому

    Sounds like he is bagging Ashcroft
    Sounds a little like jealousy

  • @stevekells7283
    @stevekells7283 2 роки тому

    Very interesting

  • @paulmcewen
    @paulmcewen 10 місяців тому

    Only 3 people have been awarded the Victoria Cross twice, 2 were from the medical corps and the only fighting soldier a New Zealander Charles Hazlett Upham during WW2 was awarded his first one in Crete, and the second one in North Africa.