Math Olympiad Problem, which is greater?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 18

  • @shawon265
    @shawon265 2 місяці тому +2

    Essentially we are asking which is larger, 70^(1/70) or 71^(1/71). In other words, is x^(⅟x)=ˣ√x increasing or decreasing near x=70. You can use differentiation to check for slope there. Or simply note that exponentiation grows much faster than x. So for large values of x, value of ˣ√x is decreasing.
    So, ⁷⁰√70 > ⁷¹√71.

  • @Fernandes-jm3uu
    @Fernandes-jm3uu 2 місяці тому

    Please, How to Solve this Exercise? WHICH IS BIGGER? 17^23 or 19^13?

  • @TheMail518
    @TheMail518 2 місяці тому +4

    probably 70^71 is bigger

    • @CST1992
      @CST1992 2 місяці тому +1

      yeah, because the extra exponent beats the lower base. In fact the difference is about 26 times.
      Edit: the difference is actually exactly what he calculated: 70/e.

    • @rio1628
      @rio1628 2 місяці тому

      Not probably brother thats a huge damn difference 💀

    • @robertveith6383
      @robertveith6383 2 місяці тому

      ​@@rio1628-- *Stop* with your major cursing, you rude *jerk!* It is ignorant and needless.
      In fact, go back and delete that word.

    • @forcelifeforce
      @forcelifeforce 2 місяці тому

      @@rio1628 -- Take your major cursing *OFF* of the forum. It has no place on here.

  • @jimv9210
    @jimv9210 2 місяці тому

    If you rearrange the general comparison to (x+1)/x vs Ln(x+1)/Ln(x) it seems pretty obvious that
    the left side will be larger since the arguments of the logs change faster than the logs. But is this
    always true? No, it isn't. Both expressions are equal at x = 2.293166287. Below that, the ratio of the
    logs is greater. Does anyone know if that number has any significance in some other context?

  • @robertveith6383
    @robertveith6383 2 місяці тому +1

    *@ Math Window* You made it too complicated.
    71^70 vs. 70^71
    Divide each side by 70^70:
    (71/70)^70 vs. 70^1
    [(70 + 1)/70]^70 vs. 70
    (1 + 1/70)^70 vs. 70
    e = lim as x --> oo of (1 + 1/x)^x = 2.718...
    (1 + 1/70)^70 < 70
    Therefore, 71^70 < 70^71.

    • @patricksheldon5859
      @patricksheldon5859 2 місяці тому

      Yeah I always start these by dividing the lesser base to the power of lesser exponent

    • @Fred-yq3fs
      @Fred-yq3fs 2 місяці тому

      The intermediate limit you're using is not a Y12 "known fact", so not a good proof for the competition.

    • @robertveith6383
      @robertveith6383 2 місяці тому

      ​@@Fred-yq3fs -- I just used the same step for the limit as Math Window. Do you have (an) alternative step(s) to replace what I wrote for the Olympiad Competition?

  • @Fred-yq3fs
    @Fred-yq3fs 2 місяці тому +1

    That's pretty basic stuff. A good year 11 should manage this.
    ln(71^70/70^71) =
    70Ln(1+1/70) - ln(70)
    but for all x>0 we know ln(1+x)0
    So:
    70ln(1+1/70) < 1
    As e < 70 and Ln is an increasing function, we have
    -ln(70)

  • @FarhadJahani
    @FarhadJahani 2 місяці тому

    nice

  • @wiggles7976
    @wiggles7976 2 місяці тому

    I just compared (70)(ln(71)) and (71)(ln(70)) with a calculator.

  • @akaRicoSanchez
    @akaRicoSanchez 2 місяці тому

    I did it the dumb way: I compared (x+1)^x to x^(x+1). At 1 (x+1)^x is greater. At 2 also, but at 3 x^(x+1) is the greater of the two function and obviously will be greater for all greater x. So for x = 70, x^(x+1) also wins.

    • @robertveith6383
      @robertveith6383 2 місяці тому

      No, it just happened to be greater at x = 3. There is no "obviously" about it, and your statement is not a proof.