@@yahyamohamed4862 Sheikh Muhammad ibn Salih al-Uthaymeen has opined on Tablighi jamaat in these words. العلم معهم وجواز خروج العامّة معهم: س (20 ) اللقاء العاشر من لقاءت الباب المفتوح في أول خميس من شهر جمادى الأولى عام 1413هـ: فضيلة الشيخ المسألة وما فيها جماعة الدعوة الذين يخرجون ثلاث أيام هم جماعة التبليغ والدعوة المهم يا شيخ أنا بدأت الالتزام قريبا ، ومضطرب في هذا الأمر فيه بعض الشباب من الأخوان في عفيف يقول : لا تمشي لا تتبع الجماعة هذه ، ما أدري ، وفيه بعض العلماء في المدينة لا أذكر اسم هذا العالم قال : نصحني بالخروج معها ، فما رأي فضيلتكم في ذلك ؟ الجواب : الغالب أن كل المسائل يكون الناس فيها طرفين ووسطا من الناس من يثني على هؤلاء كثيرا وينصح بالخروج معهم ، ومنهم من يحذر منهم كما يحذر من الأسد ، ومنهم متوسط وأنا أرى أنّ الجماعة فيهم خير وفيهم دعوة ولهم تأثير لم ينله احد من الدعاة ، تأثيرهم واضح كم من فاسق هداه الله؟ وكم من كافر آمن ؟ ثم طبائعهم تواضع ، خلق ، إيثار ، ليس هو يوجد في الكثيرين ، ومن يقول أنهم ليس عندهم علم حديث أو سلف أو ما أشبه ذلك ، هم أهل خير ولاشك ، لكني أرى أن الذين يوجدون في المملكة لا يذهبون إلى باكستان وغيرها من البلاد الأخرى ، لأننا لا ندري عن عقائد أولئك ولا ندري عن مناهجهم ، لكن المنهج الذي عليه أصحابنا هنا في المملكة منهج لا غبار عليه ،وليس فيه شيء ، وأما تقيد الدعوة بثلاث أيام أو أربعة أيام أو شهرين أو أربعة اشهر أو ستة أو سنتين فهذه ما لها وجه ، ولكنهم هم يرون أن هذا من باب التنظيم ، وانه إذا خرج ثلاثة أيام وعرف انه مقيد بهذا الأيام الثلاثة استقام وعزف عن الدنيا ، فهذه مسالة تنظيمية ما هي بشرع ، ما هي عبادة ، فأرى بارك الله فيك إن كان لك اتجاه لطلب العلم أفضل لك ، لان طلب العلم فيه خير ، والناس الآن محتاجون لعلماء أهل سنة راسخين في العلم ، وان كان ما عندك قدرة على طلب العلم وخرجت معهم لأجل أن تصفي نفسك فهذا لا بأس به ، وفيه كثيرون هداهم الله عز وجل على أيديهم Translation Question: I have started to become committed recently, praise be to Allaah. In our area there is the Jamaa?at al-Tableegh, who go out for thirty days or more. People say different things about them. Some say, don't go out with them, because their going out is an innovation (bidah) and they have some mistaken ideas. Others advised me to go out with them. What is the correct view concerning that? Should I go out with them or not?. HIS ANSWER (Al-Baab al-Maftooh, no. 10, P. 304.) Answer: Praise be to Allaah. We have already discussed this group and some of their pros and cons. Usually in every issue there are two extremes and a middle way. Some people praise this group a great deal and encourage going out with them; others condemn them a great deal and warn against them more than they would warn you about a lion. And some people tread a middle path between those two extremes. I think that there is some good in this group; they call others to Islam and have a clear influence that no other daaiyahs have had. Many kaafirs have become believers at their hands, and many evil doers has Allaah guided through them. Moreover they have an attitude of humility and selflessness that is not found in many others. Some people say that they have no knowledge of hadeeth, and so on. They are undoubtedly good people, but I think that those of them who are in Saudi do not go to Pakistan or other countries, and we do not know anything about the aqeedah of those people (in other countries) or their manhaj (methodology). But there is nothing wrong with the manhaj followed by our companions here in Saudi. With regard to limiting dawah to three or four days, or to two or four or six months, or two years, there is no sharaee evidence for that. But they think that this has to do with organization (of groups). If a person goes out for three days, and knows that he is limited to these three days, he will focus his mind and forget about worldly matters. This is the matter of organization, and is not an act of worship or a matter of shareeah. I think, may Allaah bless you, that if you have the opportunity to seek knowledge then it is better to do that, because seeking knowledge is good and the people nowadays have a great need for scholars who have knowledge of the Sunnah and who are well-versed in knowledge. If you are not able to seek knowledge, and you go out with them in order to purify yourself, there is nothing wrong with that. There are many people whom Allaah has guided at their hands. And Allaah is the Source of strength
Sheikh I pointed this mistake to one of the teacher who forces this book on every student and visitor. Her answer was amazing, 'Hadees is Hadees, if its batil or true'. Knowing the level of their knowledge, I left that group forever. Alhamdulillah
@@rashidahmedsagar5813 ... You want to unite the Muslims by reading such a dirty book ? ....... Read Quran translations, Ahadees and 'seerah ' books in the 'ejtemas"
@@rashidahmedsagar5813 ... You are ignorant and you don't know that you are ignorant and how can I make you understand that you don't know? and the surprising thing is that you don't know, and that you don't know, that, you don't know.
@@rashidahmedsagar5813 ... Zakaria Kandalvi writes on page 13/12, Fadha'il Namaaz, Fadha'il 'A'maal, Vol I: "It has been reported from a number of companions and from amongst them Hadhrat Uthman, Hadhrat Abu Hurayrah, Hadhrat Anas, etc. in different wordings that there are some people who possess the ability of Kashf. They can feel the sins being committed by people. Therefore the story of the Imam of the world Hadhrat Abu Haneefah is famous that he used to stand outside the Masjid of Koofah and see the sins of the people fall out as they performed wudu." (Kandalvi continues): It has also been reported from Hadhrat Uthman that the Prophet said: ((Those who possess such abilities should not become arrogant)) Astaghfirullah. What heavens are going to hide such lies and heresy! This is Sufism at its extreme my brothers. Kandalvi was so bold that he attributed the aqeedah of Kashf to the Noble Companions! He threw the mud of Ibn Arabee at the Companions! His companions attesting to people who can see ghaib? Allaahu Akbar! Zakariah Kandalvi had no hesitation in such fabrication that not only goes against the Deen itself but also Mustafa (sal-Allaahu `alayhe wa sallam) and so many of his Companions!
@@simplyshujat - Sure, but it was a comparison of Hadith-books! So it is even better to read both, Quran with Tafsir (of Shaykh Abdurrahman AsSadi an easier Tafsir for the folks) and Riyad As Salihin with commentary of Shaykh ibn Uthaymin!
جزاكم الله خيرا أحسن الجزاء Believe me shaykh your videos have had a big impact on my life and I always benefit tremendously from them and please continue the uploads جعل الله هذا في ميزان حسناتكم
10 Things to escape Hell Fire: 1. Tauba: Repentance from heart 2. Istagfar: Repentance from tongue 3. Doing good deeds 4. Dua and Istagfar done by other believers for you 5. Pain & sufferings in this world 6. Azaab ul Qabar 7. Punishment and trials of the day of Judgment 8. Good deeds gifted by the loved ones 9. Intercession of our Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) on the day of Judgment 10. The Mercy of Allah سُبْحَانَهُ وَتَعَالَى
@Chungus Han 🐺 🗻 translation of the Urdu book faza’il-e-zikr translated by Shafiq Ahmad page 212 Zam Zam Publishers. “Allamah Sha’raani has related in his book “Meezanul Kubra” about hadhrat Imam Abu hanifa that when he happened to see somebody performing ablution, he could also see sins that were being washed away in the water…”
My turning point to tawheed was this book, once I was in jamat reading Quran because I thought that's all we do with all the time we have! But nah while I was busy reading the word of Allah the amir(head of the jamah) asked me to stop reading Quran and let's sit in halqa for fazal e amal. That's it, I questioned him why we are givibg importance over Quran, since the fazail amal was all about ferries and dreams of Ashraf Ali thanwi and Mohammed Ilyas khandalwi, he said that's what we do in jamat. I then researched more about the concept of jamat then to my knowledge I found that it came in dream to Mohammed Ilyas while he was enroute to hajj pilgrimage(while they claim it was sunnah) all of this truth Allah has placed before my eyes so that I can follow the path of rightly guided companions.
Tableegh a gateway for Tawheed & A'maal = ibadah You don't have to except Fazail A'maal go with Riyahud Saliheen or Maktaba Ahadith but also read from the Hasan narrations from Fazail Never stop partaking in this work of Dawah Alhamdulillah We all have become better Muslims from this effort Barakallah Hu Feek Was Salaam
@@al-ansaree3146 if ur judging every book in this world just by listening someone's negativity and dividing lectures which is titled of being on ri8 path in ummat rather then doing any ri8 nd positive work using positive actions nd words then no one is the biggest idiot than u....idiots k bhi ustaab bolsakte aap Jaise logo ku
Lagta hai aapke sheikh ku lifafe Patle milre shyd UA-cam se....islye ye mashoor or maroof kitaab jsse laakho log hidayat pe aagye islaam me aagye taoba krne wale bangya uske khilaaf me kare to milte shyd samjh liye allah unko meku sari ummat ko hidayat de or ummat me jodne ka kaam krne ki taofeeq de na k todne ka
@@syedadnanahmed2158 dont use foul language aakhi, u dont have to defend ur firqa or scholars and blame any other school of thoughts. This is just an effiet of removing fabrications from deen. Fabrication = lie
@@justahopeus so do we need to remove Ibn Majah's Sunan which has 99 munkar (denounce) and maudu (fabricated) hadiths and Ibn Qayyim's Kitab ur rooh which also has fabricated hadiths?
fear allah do not overpraise anyone like this Al-Miqdād (may Allah be pleased with him) reported that a person began to praise ‘Uthmān (may Allah be pleased with him). So Al-Miqdād knelt down and threw gravel on his (the flatterer's) face. Thereupon, ‘Uthmān said: "What is the matter with you?" He said: "The Messenger of Allah (may Allah's peace and blessings be upon him) said: 'When you see those who praise others, throw dust upon their faces.'" [Muslim]
This was my first book after becoming Muslim back in the mid 80’s. Alhamdullilah Allah protected me and guided me away from this and those who still rely upon it. Shaykh, how should dispose of such books if not wanting to keep stored away or on a shelf taking up space?
I burned 3 of them and buried the ashes. I bought them from the Masjid with the intention of destroying them. There is Arabic and mention of Allah so this is the respectful way of getting rid of them.
@@davidrosa4156 I can see the Immense hatred of y'all salafis towards Ahlus Sunnah. Just because the book contains some weak ahadith, doesn't mean you've to burn it or whatever. Y'all should go and burn hadith books like Ibn Majāh which too has daif and mawdu ahadith.
@@Dr.ShadAli, it contains much more and much worse than a “few” fabricated ahadith. I will mention too that many of those ahadith were taken from books that were written specifically to warn people about fabrications. It was the stories in the book that are attributed to no person, so we can’t find out if the writer was honourable or dishonourable. The stories contain people who claim they can see the unseen and worse. If I invite you to a banquet and when it is time to eat I tell you that, “Oh, by the way, a few of these dishes contain poison so make dua that Allah will protect you from it before you eat”. Now, would you make dua and eat or would you say “I’m out of here” and leave my banquet? If you end up on one (or more) of the turn offs from the mustaqeem, you flirt with hellfire. I’ll finish by noting the way you labeled me a Salafi, like I’m a member if a sect, concerns me. We need to be strong together and not divide. This is why I do not sit with people that I identify are in a sect or people of biddah. So I will wear your label knowing the true meaning of the word.
For the first hadith, when he was showing the arabic text, I could see on the other page the translation still being continued. So that raised my flag and after downloading the pdf, I could clearly see this man intentionally/unintentionally (Allahu Alam) hid the translation because he had to say "no one reads the arabic" implying the translation is not done correctly or some translations are skipped. But if you see the complete translation, you can find this in the paragraph: "Eminent theologians like Ibn Hajr, Abu Laith Samarqandi (Rahmatullah alaihim), and others, have mentioned this hadith in their books. Although I have not been able to trace the text in original books on hadith, yet otner hadiths, some of which have already been mentioned and some are to follow, corroborate its meaning." So the translator actually DID THE JOB to let us non-arabic speakers know that the Shaykh did not find the hadith himself but he found it in other scholars' books. And he also clarifies that he is mentioning this hadith because all these points are backed by other hadiths some of which he previously mentioned. May Allah protect us from spreading fitnah.
That still doesn't change the fact that even if you use Weak Hadith they can be used for virtues but fabricated Hadith are straight up Ally and we cannot defend Any Lies as Muslims. Also it doesn't matter if he clarified that he couldn't find the link or whether he was using it to make a point because using A lie to make a point still doesn't change the Lie. I'm not saying that sheikh did it on purpose, he's a human being and he probably didn't know that the Hadith was fake. That's why it's better for the common person to not use something in which they can't tell the difference. Just like the hadees about Adam A.S that can mess up someone's aqeedah about Islam. It's better that the sheikh who wrote the book, his sons update it but some Hadith can lead people to wrong beliefs which is dangerous. We can't present this to nonMuslims who want to come to Islam so why should we presmt this to Muslims.
Tablighi Jamaat intends to make their Jamaat heavy through spreading false promises like polytheist christians.. .... That's why Tablighi Jamaat Calls people to their Jamaat through mixing the falsehood with truth like polytheist christians........
Imam Ibn Taymiyyah (may ALLAH be pleased with him) said that whoever calls Husain bin Monsoor Hallaj as ALLAH's oli may be ignorant or he may be like him! But your peer sufis incuding Ashraf Ali Thanvi support the blasphemous crimes of monsoor hallaj (who claimed himself to be God). Even they consider him as a saint. Naujubillah.@Zaid Khan
Do you know why it's taught that To be a Christian, Keep repeating Jesus is GOD? Because anti-christ dajjal will say that "I am god & god's begotten son & worship me! True Muslims will reject anti-christ for blaspheming (death penalty by TRUE GOD's laws) Because Eesa messiah (peace be upon him) never said that “I am GOD or worship me! @Zaid Khan
Hadhrat Zakariyah(R.A) narrated in his kitaab ‘Fazaail Namaaz’ (p 28-31), where five gifts will be granted to the one who performs his salaat regularly and those who neglect it will be punished in fifteen different ways; five in this world, three at the time of death, three in the qabar, three after rising from the qabar. Hadhrat Zakariyah (R.A) narrated this on the authority of Ibn Hajar Makki Al-Haythammi from ‘Al-Zawaajir’, in the beginning it was said “some have said this has been mentioned in a hadeeth”. In addition to this Hadhrat Zakariyah(R.A) has mentioned many other references and corroborating narrations; ‘Al-Li-aalie’ of Hafiz Suyoothi (R.A) where it was stated that this hadeeth was narrated by Ibn Najjaar in ‘Taareekh Baghdad’ from Abu Hurairah (R.A). In ‘Meezaanul Ie’tiedaal’ it is written this hadeeth is baseless, it was made up by Ali bin Abbaas on Abu Bakr bin Ziyaad An-Nisaapuri. Hadhrat Zakariyah (R.A) further corroborated it with references to Imaam Ghazaali and the author of ‘Munabihaat’. Ultimately after seeing the practice of all these Ulama, Hadhrat Zakariyah (R.A) came to the conclusion that this narration is not baseless and can be narrated in targheeb wa tarheeb. The astonishment is on Hafiz Dhahabi (R.A) who in ‘Meezaan’ said this hadeeth is baseless but thereafter himself narrates it in ‘Kitaabul Kabaair’, saying “it is mentioned in hadeeth” (‘warada with a fathah) as if it is an extremely strong hadeeth.
Maulana Zakria R.A himself mentioned those Hadith which are weak. Ulama says that he included these hadees by himself because these Hadith are related to "Fazail" not "masail" we cannot take any weak Hadith related to masail because it will effect the "Sharia" whereas weak Hadith related to "Fazail" don't effect the serious matters,. Wallah o Alam.
He's not talking about weak Hadith ( Da'if ). He's talking about some fabricated Hadith ( Mawdu' ) in Fazail Amal. Know the difference between weak and fabricated Hadith.
in my country translation version that spread & read in mosque don't have the explanation hadith degree.. and most of the preacher just read textually without explaining the hadith degree
He's specifying the difference between weak and FABRICATED Hadiths. Do you know what fabricated means brother? Sahih al-Bukhari 106 Narrated `Ali: " لاَ تَكْذِبُوا عَلَىَّ، فَإِنَّهُ مَنْ كَذَبَ عَلَىَّ فَلْيَلِجِ النَّارَ " The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Do not tell a lie against me for whoever tells a lie against me (intentionally) then he will surely enter the Hell-fire."
@@user-zw7dk5lk3v The Urdu Word "Masail" مسائل Meaning in English is Topics. The other similar words are Mozuaat and Masail. The synonyms of Topics include are Affair, Argument, Business, Case, Division, Field, Head, Issue, Material, Matter, Motif, Motion, Motive, Point, Question, Resolution, Subject, Text, Theme, Theorem, Thesis, Proposition, Problem, Moot Point and Point In Question. Examples of Masail are Hajj, divorce, sacrifications, sadaqa, zakat prayers, etc And "Fazail" means benefits of good acts and deeds.
Thank you Brother Usman The need of the hour is to revise and revisit the Fazial Aamal so as to be more beneficial and helpful for the Tabliki Movement. Even I love the work Tablik is doing. Need of the hour is to revise the syllabus.
Brother they won't leave fazailay amal....bcoz it's there agenda to deviate muslim from deen e islam to deen thanvi.... U love there work??? They replaced Qur'an from masjid n placed fazailay amal on the mimber.. It's there own deen e thanvi.....n they are doing tableegh of deen e thanvi 🔥🔥
@@truthseekerIndian brother , no one in Tabligh forces anyone to follow the Fazail e Amal . Even I didn't even know who Maulana Thanvi is being a part of jamat since last 6 years . Only point is to bring Muslims closer to the masjid towards Allah swt and the sunnah of our Prophet pbuh. I swear there is no motive except this . There are many muslims today who are out of reach of Allah's deen . Can you comprehend how badly we need to reach them to bring them closer ? Please get in touch with the jamat , because the ground reality is way more different than we hear about them !
Yes, irani refeji shia will be led by the dajjal anticrist because the extremists shia rafeji who believe that Ali (Alaihas Salam)) is their ALLAH. Naujubillah and peer sufis as well as kabbalists jew, Illuminati & Freemasons and other devil worshipers who believe that Human beings can become God by reaching the highest level of spirituality. (I pet goat 2) And Trinitron Christian, buddiists, hindu and other polytheists believe that God comes to earth in human form (of Jesus, Buddha, ram, krishna, gonesh etc.)
The Mahdi in the Shia books is similair to the Dajjal mentioned in the authentic Hadiths. Brother Ebn Hussein had made a video that the followers of the Masih Ad-Dajjal will be the Shia. It has over 100k views now. The Shia are Jews in disguise. The one they are waiting for is the Dajjal and not the real Mahdi. Their 12th imam never existed. Look what they are wearing in Iran like the Shia in the video wears. Sahih Muslim 2944 Anas b. Malik reported that Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said: The Dajjal would be followed by seventy thousand Jews of Isfahan wearing Persian shawls. . @Zaid Khan
Last day I enquired about this from a person who is closely associated with TJ. He replied that we don't use fazail e amaal that much now, in arab countries Riaz-us-Saliheen is being widely used and in non arab countries muntakhib ahadees, which doesn't contain even weak narrations let alone fabricated, is being is widely used and current ameer of TJ, Maulana Saad, has also adviced the TJ members to try to use Bukhari and Muslim instead of other book. He also went on saying that he never has read the fazail e amaal though he bought it but never read it. I think it's a good thing to advise them about these faults which might corrupt aqeedah or might have other harms. One of the fault that I've noticed in TJ is that they take unnecessary on hikmat/hikmah. They try to refrain correcting immediately or for sometime the people of biddah and shirk and ask them to stop such acts. I think people like Sheikh Uthman should also advise on such things because TJ have been working on such a greater scale that many muslims around the world who have distanced themselves from deen Can benefit from it. BarakAllah feek.
Really well explained, Jzk khairun Shaykh. The educational and informative aspect of your Dawah videos is soo helpful, especially for brothers/sisters looking to research/study/get clarification on a particular matter. May Allah swt keep you protected, and assist you further in your Dawah efforts. Ameen
Dear Shaikh, As I understand, your first guiding light to hidaya was due to Tableeghi jamaat. Just think if those jamaatis who came to you spending their own money and took effort got inspiration from the same book. As someone who benefited from it and now at a high place with influence, your effort should've been to work with the central marakiz of Nizamuddin and Raiwind to remove the fabricated ahaadeeth and have people continue to benefit from such a great book that has been the reason for hidayah for millions of people in the subcontinent. If people of your stature do not get constructive and work towards repairing the ills of the society, who else will?
Its because you love your brother that you remind them that they are wrong, you do not love your brother if you keep silence and did not remind them about their wrong doing.
there is still Fazail ul Amal present in the Tablighi work but there has been a staunch change regarding this like Tablighi Jamat has taken up Muntakhab Ahadith and has promoted it extensively. Muntakhab is a compilation of Ahadiths regarding the daily life of a common Muslim. Riyad as Saliheen is also a famous read among the Tablighi Jamat.
Sh. Kandahlawi RA based his book on targheeb wa tahreeb, back when there wasn't google or shamela. Use whatever book you want like ryad al saliheen, but DO THE DAWAH WORK. This is the main issue.
You are right about doing the dawah work. However do not stick “use whatever book you want” in there. Sheikh Zakaria will be forgiven insha Allah and we pray for him due to his good work. He is not responsible in sha Allah for the people who choose to hold on to fabrications after his passing.
@Usāmah they need to address first on why they dont critique Ibn Majah's Sunan which has 99 munkar (denounce) and maudu (fabricated) hadiths and Ibn Qayyim's Kitab ur rooh which also has fabricated hadiths?
Interesting! While the overwhelming message is a positive one in that we must take greater care about the veracity of the hadith; however, I have a couple of points to consider. 1) Given that most Muslims would hold tafsir ibn katheer in much higher regards than fazail amal, do you maintain consistency in your judgement when you find multiple instances of non-verifiable fabricated Israeli narratives in such a major exegisis? 2) You quote a few examples and at least two of them you mention that the author/muhaqqiq clarifies that these are unfounded/unverifiable/false etc. If the author clarifies this then it serves an informative purpose only. How is this problematic when the unacceptability is clear to the authorship as well as the readership? 3) You mention this negatively affecting aqeedah, but non of the fabricated hadith you quoted conveys a detrimental theological connotation per se. So how have you made the leap from textual fabrication (congruent with permitted practice) to deviated belief?
1. tafsir ibn kathir and tabari are not to be read by just anyone they are books to be studied under teachers for the common people you have other books of tafasir such as tafsir as saadi 2. no its not clear to the reader. ive never even held the book in my life but ive been in many tableeghi circles where they start reading from it after maghrib and they'd be reading fabricated ahadith like its stamped with sahih they dont even mention the grading of it or what the author said about it. most people who use that book probably dont even know what terms like daif and mawdoo mean. 3. ofc there are more fabricated ahadith in the book then the ones hes just mentioned and some of them are pretty dodgy, like none of them is gonna be something extreme like rasulullah salallahu alayhi wasalam controls the sun and the moon, it would be something more minor which the common person might not pick up on . regardless there are better books to use to remind people, like riyadh as saliheen by imam an nawawi. that book is much much better and way more credible.
@@SpinoBroshub 1) So in short your answer to the point I raised, seems to indicate that inconsistency in judgement has been applied. Very interesting! Though you have attempted to justify this. While the inconsistency is problematic per se, nevertheless, let's take a look at your rationale. If we hypothetically accept your attempt at explanation, it raises even more concerns namely, books of scholastic status require a higher level of scrutiny and veracity and not the other way round. Furthermore, your reasoning hinges on readership-type yet not sure how you reach such a definitive distinction of which readership has access to which books! At best you might have confused, 'advisory' for 'mandatory'. Nor is this distinction you make founded in reality. Today at least one of these books has been translated and is widely utilised by all scholars and laymen alike. The other book has also been partially translated. 2) This is circular reasoning and a fallacy. There are many other major books (Ibn Majah, Al Nasaee, Al Bukhari, Riyadh ul Saleheen) that also don't share the grading including riyadh ul saleheen. Notice it's the book you advise the layman to utilise. Again you seem to be extremely inconsistent in applying your judgement. I wonder what motivates you to be so selective. This time round your distinction of layman Vs scholar doesn't apply as you yourself recommend Riyadh Ul Saleheen for the lay person. As for the readership not comprehending daeef and mawdhoo, I appreciate they may not understand the in-depth concept as many who think they do very obviously don't either; nevertheless, there should be no difficulty for even a 7 year old in grasping the gist from the translation that it is a grading system and 'weak' is considered very low in the scale As for readership not mentioning the grading, this is your isolated experience and cannot be evidence for any serious discussion like this one. Furthermore, which is more credible? Text that contains grading regardless of readership stating it or not OR text that actually contains unverifiable fabricated narratives without any grading whatsoever so readership can't state it anyway? 3) Did you count these or have access to research? Could you present a quantitative comparison please? After all we are discussing rigour and veracity! I'll await this. Thanks in advance. Oh and please do provide a reference for the statement you attributed to as 'dodgy'. I'll await this. Thanks. I wonder if dodgy is your own classification. If you think what you referred to as dodgy is undesirable, then you obviously have not read the Israeli narratives in tafsir ibn kathir. Sigh. As you pointed out, as being someone who hasn't even held fazail amal, you sure seem to have some very strong claims about it yet very little about the books that were intially raised in point one above.
@@SpinoBroshub i agree riyad saliheen is miles better however faizal amal mentions the fabricated hadtih its the translator who made the mistake of not mentioning those fabrication also what your saying is not exclusive to tabligh there is many salafis who lack knowledge aswell
Alhamdulillah. Jazakallahu khair brother making this video and exposing this book. I myself a 4 months return from tableeghi jamah realised it later. request you to make full video exposing all false belief and content of the book, it will really help us use for dawah.
Brother you have been for 4 months in Allah path please don’t come into conclusion that theseahadith are fabricated, shaitan is making you to go astray, please please stop yourself from this… I agree fadail aamaal has dhaeef ahadith, but these are not fabricated,
@@safiafatima5565 what do u mean only daeef ? Will you follow daeef then ? Nontheless I can show you umpteen references of fabricated and daeef ahadith from fazaile amal series. I want you to explore yourself. Educate yourself sister before commenting. May Allah guide you !
when 99% of of the ummah is not on 5 times salah, zakah, honesty, modesty, akeedah, tawheed and even taharah why are are we even arguing about weak and fabricated hadeeth?
What do u mean then? 99% are not praying which is the first and foremost duty so stop all scholars from the rest of the work and concentrate and lecture on salah only.? This is what u mean.?
@@innocentfriend yes the scholar need to stop arguing and get off their backsides. What ever needed to be argued about has been done over the past 1400 years.
@@arifmunshi6833 Shaykh Uthman is out there doing da'wah to Muslims, non-Muslims and ALSO teaching us about hadith because that is his field of study, can't a guy multitask?
You did not watch the video because the Shaykh shows that even in the Arabic writing in the book Fazail e Amal is shows that are baseless and fabricated ahadith.. why would you defend such a book?
قبر کے پاس بیٹھ کر دعا کرنا ایک شخص کے بارے میں لکھا ۔ جس کے پاس نبی ﷺ کا بال تھا اس کی وفات ہوئی تو صلحاء میں بعض نے حضور اقدس ﷺ کی خواب میں زیارت کی حضور نے ارشاد فرمایا جس کہ جس کسی کو کوئی ضرورت ہو اس کی قبر پر بیٹھ کر اللہ تعالیٰ شانہ سے دعا کیا کرے ( فضائل درود ص ۱۵۷ ) سونچنے کی بات ہے یہی دیوبندی بریلویوں پر مشرک ہونے کا فتویٰ لگاتے ہیں ۔ ایک اور جھوٹا اور گستا خانہ قصہ حافظ ابو نعیم سفیان ثوری نے ایک شخص سے پوچھا اس نے کہا ایک آدمی نے ہاتھ میری ماں کے منھ پر پھیرا جس سے وہ بالکل روشن ہوگئی اور پیٹ پر ہاتھ پھیرا تو ورم بالکل جاتا رہا ۔ مینے اس عرض کیا کہ آپ کون ہیں کی میری اور میری ماں کی مصیبت کو آپ نے دور کیا انہونے فرمایا کہ میں تیرا نبی محمدﷺ ہوں ۔ جبکہ آئشہؓ فرماتی ہے کہ اللہ کی قسم نبی ﷺ نے اپنے ہاتھ سے کسی غیرمحرم عورت کا ہاتھ نہیں چھوا بلکہ اسن کو صرف بات چیٹ سے بیعت فرمایا ( مسلم ج ۲ صفحہ ۱۳۱ ) قارئین کرام ! میں نے صرف بطور نمونہ یہ مسائل درجہ کئے ہے ۔ روز قیامت کے حساب سے نڑر ہوکر ایسے جھوٹھے قصے نبی ﷺ کی طرف منسوب کئے ہیں اور ان کے معتقد ین اسی کو دین سمجھ بیٹھے ہیں ۔۔۔۔۔ اس کے بارے میں بھی قیامت میں سوال ہوگا۔۔۔۔۔
Moulan Zakaria sahibs funeral prayers were led by the Imam of the Prophet's Mosque, Shaykh Abdullah al-Zahim, and the body was taken for burial in the nearby Jannatul Baqi graveyard. How can i believe he is going to hell for writing such a book?? Can you clarify? What about the majority of Good hadees in it.. Will it have no effect on the readers??? Pls don't say Moulana Does not know about hadees... I am asking you for a clarification.. What is the fate of such a person who wrote such a book??? You could have atleast say "Zakaria Sahib " You people good at fiqh and below average at abstinence of this world... Pls don't use moulana zakria sahibs name, as if you both played hide and seek in your backyard... It was very rude of you... I am a 50/50 ( salafi/Deobandi ) and ex-tableegi 4 months saathi like you..
Ok...put aside the "fabricated Ahadeeth" We should just leave going for khurooj?? An effort which is benefiting people literally in every country of the world?! Pardon me but The respected Scholars talk does not make sense. Oh and the effort of Tabligh is organised by Scholars whom I'm sure can read Arabic!
I used to be around Muslim brothers who seemingly lived and died by this book. Asking them, for instance, why they don't read from the Qur'an Majid is a taboo subject. If you have the nerve to in fact ask it, they dismiss your question, stating in sum and substance that only the Alims/scholars could read from it as the Qur'an is too complicated a study. Sadly their behavior seems akin to the Hindus who refuse to read from their Holy Books (which forbid idolatry) and instead listen to their priests (who promote idolatry as a means to get near to God). Don't get me wrong, they are good people, but I fear they stubbornly refuse to educate themselves on Islam and instead push for an ascetic, monastic approach towards nearing Allah s.w.t.
I have myself very very bad experience with Tablighi jamaat. My aqidah was badly affected. Plus,I became a liar , telling ppl these fabricated thing and anecdotes.
@@fullsendit292 ,Not Lol,but Col. If you have Fazail e Aamal,go to Chapter Fazail e Durood, Anecdote no. 46.You will definitely realise how my aqidah would have been affected ( condition: if you are a true Muwahid)
Why are people like Mufti Taqi Usmani not ordering a change in these books? Literally he is considered as "Mufti e Azam Pakistan" and he's arguably the most revered scholar of Deoband. I'm PRETTY SURE if he records videos, if he gives khutbas and if he orders to take out these fabrications and lies upon the Prophet, the people at printing press can take them out.
do you think he cares or doesn't know? he even said that Abu Hanifa could see people's sins being washed away by water of wudu😂 so i wouldn't expect him to be saying stuff against fabrications or false stories
Brother when it comes to maslak mufti taqi usmani is dewabandi himself he knows everything about the book and his aqeeda is exactly the same as this book..
Ibn majah has 34 fabricated hadith according to ibn jawzi. Should we throw away ibn majah? Shaikh zakariya rahimallah wrote down commentary on the grading of each hadith. Please do read.
ibn majah is a hadith book, and each hadith has chain narration.. so whoever read & teach the book in public should explain the takrij & syarah (like any hadith book) however fadail amal don't have the chain, grading of hadith only find in the original text, not the translation one (in my country don't have it) and being used to give dakwa without explaining the takrij & syarah.. so common people can't differentiate which amal that should be followed
Are you really doing it bro?? Comparing apple and oranges. The book which is primary source of hadith ofourse have all kind if hadiths which scholars later on sifted through and graded them i. The basis of esma ur rejaal. Hadith collection books are not propagatory books. Fazail e aamaal isnt a book of collection
Thing of note is that the man who wrote this book was declared unwell by his doctors psychologically. He himself mentions he wrote this book while on leave because of his mental state.
The hadith about the 5 virtues of salat is in Al-kabair of Imam Ad-Dhahabi. Same grading from Imam Suyuti. It seems people pick and chose who they want to criticise, to serve their own purpose. Don't throw the baby out with the bathwater
Nafri Letap السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته As clearly stated in the video, Fadhā’il al-‘Āmāl was the subject of this video because it is widely distributed to common folks and relied upon without understanding the grading of the Hadīth. Just because someone other book or scholars recorded a extremely weak Hadīth that doesn’t mean you should promotes.
Jazakallahu khair for responding. Many books have weak hadith. I'm not promoting any book, just highlighting that certain people with certain inclinations are always scrutinising Fadail Amaal, no book is free of fault except the book of Allah. InshaAllah continue your good work, inviting the non-muslims to Islam.
Nafri Letap السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته May Allāh reward you for your sincere advice. The fact that many other books have weak and even fabricated Ahādīth and the fact that most of the Ahādīth in Fadhā’il al-‘Amāl was addressed in the video 0:35 .
Perhaps you could also do a video about the fabrications and the very weak hadiths mentioned in Kitab at-Tawhid written by Ibn Abd al-Wahhab? Or a video on the fabrications and very weak ahadith used in sharh of tahawiyyah by ibn Abi al-Izz? Or is this against your policy that you only make videos against certain groups not abiding by your manhaj?
In my experience in tabligh where I went over 10 times ranging sometimes 3 days and more. I think some parts of the jamat have changed and fixed their mistakes. There are updates versions where fabrications are thrown out. I think it's mainly in Canada and most mufti's in my province of Ontario and the rest of Canada I think are in the tabligh effort. I personally think these people are helping others to come back to the right path effectively, however I prefer other approaches personally. Edit: Sheikh zakariyyah kandhalwi is a great muhaddith. And I did my first 40 days which was a very eye opening and spiritual experience subhanallah
Whatever works for you brother..whatever motivates you and brings you close to your Deen. Its all good. However, you must admit, there's no global collective and organised dawah movement like the tabligh jamaat. Must respect the brothers who consistently give there time locally and non locally for this effort.
@@sahazi4780 issue for me is, whenever we have these bothers come to me, I feel like their ultimate goal is for me to spend 40 days, 10 days etc. Shouldn't their pure intention be for me to worship Allah and go masjid?
@@mohammedsalimahmed5230 Bro thier intention is same.. they come out of maajid and they go back to masjid (u go or u dont go).. they go back to masjid to learn and to teach.. and spending 10 days or 40 days is beneficial for you.. when they go out they stay in masjid they learn and teach in masjid.. so all these things are done in masjid.. so they are ultimately calling to masjid only… 😊
Assalamū ‘alaykum Sh. Uthman, I have a Tablighī background but I also follow the good work that you are doing besides following other dū’āt of Islam irrespective of their theological leanings as far as they fall within the ambit of Sunnī Islām. Our religion is vast and accommodating and can easily accommodate giants of our tradition with diametrically opposed views such as Hujjat Al Islām Abu Hamid Al Ghazzālī and Shaykh Al Islām Taqī ad Dīn ibn Taiymiyyāh rahim Allah ajmaīn. Please don’t narrow the vastness by casting a significant portion of the ummāh out of the fold of orthodoxy since majority of the Islamic scholarship in Egypt, Syria, North Africa, Al Andalus, Hind, Indonesia, Malaysia, Turkey, Central Asia, and many other lands of Islam have believed in the explanation of divine attributes of Allah in the light of Ashārī and Maturīdī framework instead of Shaykh Al Islām Ibn Taiymīyyāh rahimullah. The people commenting here negatively about such scholar should make sincere tawbāh for doing ghībā of so many of the ummāh lest they face Allāh’s wrath on the day of judgment. Sincerely. Your brother and well wisher.
He just explained that Al-Khandlawi is a liar and is rejected. He has other videos on why Tablighi isn't the right way. The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) used to say, when beginning a khutbah (sermon): " The best of speech is the Book of Allaah and the best of guidance is the guidance of Muhammad. The worst of things are those which are newly-invented, and every innovation is a going astray" (reported by Muslim, no. 867)
@@IbnHussain Shaykh Usman is a very sincere person who is knowledgeable as well, Allah be praised. But is he a proof (hujjah) for anyone? No. He will agree with me on this also. If your point is that he’s quoting Quran and Hadīth, well then, the other scholars are also quoting it and giving their proofs, aren’t they? Do you think the scholars of Islam are taught to call people towards their own views and not of Quran and Sunnah? This is a great slander indeed! Everyone of our scholars of the Islamic tradition frames his arguments and ideas using the framework of Quran and Sunnah. As a follower of scholars, and yes, you are one of them too unless you approach it without going to Shaykh Usman or anyone else, understands it THROUGH the lens of Islamic scholarship. If you don’t like or understand what Imam Razi said but you follow Ibn Qayyim that is fine but you’re still making taqlīd. At the end of the day, everyone is engaged in understanding the “intent” of the prophet (peace be upon him). I am not saying everyone’s opinion is correct. It may as well be Shaykh Usman who is correct and the opinion of Shaykh Zakariyya Al Kandelhvi is incorrect. How does that make Shaykh Zakariyya a liar or an evil person? It simply proves that Shaykh Usman was able to reach the correct opinion using the hermeneutical framework he uses to establish what is right and what is wrong.
@@IbnHussain Yes, Zakariyya Kandehlvi mentions he didn’t find any reference for the fabricated Hadīth and mentioned Abu Layth Samarqandi has mentioned it in his book. It’s obvious that Zakariyya Kandehlvi doesn’t see any issues in narrating weak narrations when it comes to virtuous deeds. Isn’t Imam Bukhari same when it comes to narrating weak narrations about virtuous deeds? His book Adab Al Mufrad has weak narrations, doesn’t it? As for the fabricated Hadīth in fadail ‘amaal, Zakariyya Kandehlvi didn’t admit that he knew that it was fabricated so I am willing to give him the benefit of the doubt.
I think you should research who Shayke Zakaria kandelwi was first. Your total knowledge and wisdom is equal to one of his finger tips. That's not an insult, but rather a compliment. You are still young with much to learn. Study the author, who spent decades teaching Hadith by the blessed grave, and research why he included the 'fake' Hadith. Then form an opinion. Fame isn't everything. You don't need to make a video on everything.
As salaamu alaikum Sheikh I request you to say mufti tariq masood that you are not a blind follower of hambali fiqh, because he has mentioned that you are hambali in fiqh
Hadhrat Dhun Noon Misri said," I saw a young man near the Ka'bah shareef who was performing much rukoo' and sujood. I asked him why was he praying so much (Sufis not pray so it was strange for this pir). He replied, "I am asking permission to return to my country." I then saw a piece of paper drop from the sky. It was written, "From Allaah the Most Majestic the Most Merciful to His thankful slave that return to your country. All your previous and future sins have been forgiven." Fazael e Hajj, story 15.
Fazail E Amaal was written more than 100 years back. The Ulema in Tabligi Jamaat should meet, discuss, consult with other Ulemas. Get all fabricated and weak Hadiths removed and republish the book.
Today this mufti is sitting in U.S.A and preaching Islam is the effort of Tabligh jamaat but these mushrooms don't reliase the rain drops which made them fluorish
@@pmsnoormohamedibrahim4678 But bro this doesn’t mean you will propagate fabricated hadiths among the masses.We are not against tablighi Jamaat we are against Fazail e Amaal they should consult with their scholars and remove all the fabricated (maudu) hadiths.
@@pmsnoormohamedibrahim4678 the insulting way you address people of knowledge as “mushrooms “ shows your ignorance and lack of Aftab, please go back to your scholars of tabling and tell them to teach you some manners and some respect
@@Umme-45 Mushroom is not disrespectful, i mean they are not experienced in the field of jurisprudence, that's it,Otherwise i don't have any personal vengeance with him....okay just mind your own business it will be good
Sheikh the book is part and parcel of their da’wah. Ive engaged many of their elder workers and leaders with regards to changing it, doesn’t seem like it will ever happen. It’s part of the hizbiyyah of the jama’ah. والله المستعان وعليه التكلان ولا حول ولا قوة الا بالله
Bis millah. We should still respect the scholar that wrote this book, even though we might disagree with him, this author has a title, and we should not delete his title lest it be out of spite or poor character. You refer to yourself by a title, you refered to another scholar by a title, but you ignored this mans title... not only does that show bias because there are many books with weak and fabricated hadith but it shows poor akhlaaq. May Allah bless me and all of us with guidance and good akhlaaq that will unite the Muslim ummah.
User user السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته Are you in agreement that books with fabricated Ahādīth should not be given out to the masses to read? I am amazed that you are worried about the honorary titles being used but not concerned that lies are being attributed to the Prophet صلى الله عليه وعلى آله وسلم a fabricated Hadīth is not a weak Hadīth it is Harām to attribute it to Rasūlullāh صلى الله عليه وعلى آله وسلم
@@MasjidRibat I don't know the verdict on the use of the different grades of hadith. I am not a mufti so i will not endeavor to make such a verdict. I would be perfectly happy if muftis sit down and discuss this and come to a verdict. And whatever the decision, it can be disseminated in a respectfull peaceful way, whilst at all times maintaining respect between all sides. Yes ideally there should be only one side, but the reality is that there are many sides/ preferences/ affiliations, some differences are trivial others not so, but all our words should be designed towards unity- focused, and strategic. biizniallah, Alhamdulilah you have wonderful way with your dawat, may Allah grant you a greater reach and greater success, may Allah make you the means of the entire ummah being united and knowledgeable about our deen. May Allah bring many people into the fold of Islam at your gentle hands. And May Allah grant me all of your good qualities. Maaf if i offended you Sheikh, i don't know Sheikh personally to have a private discussion. May Allah forgive us and guide us.
User user السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته That’s a great idea! I am willing to sit with any Mufti or Mawlana and discuss inshaAllah. You are a good person with good intentions so I encourage you to seek knowledge: here is an introduction you can easy understand inshaAllah ua-cam.com/play/PLExCKwROz20HG3bMIYe9gCtKJjbG5J1Z3.html
@@syedadnanahmed2158 Are you calling me an idiot or the Mufti? Ether way whoever teaches you such bad manners i don't want to connect with .. May Allāh bless you with better manners
What is your opinion of another book which some tablighis use called منتخب احاديث muntakhab ahadith Also in Middle East tablighis use رياض الصالحين riyadh ul-Saliheen
Amir in Delhi Markaz Maolana Saad has been telling these radical oldies to stop using this book for decades! Having said this, Maolana Saad is also not free from any errors, ask Darul Uloom Dewband!
But it goes to show the book is an issue more just the ahadeeth mentioned. Not the work of tabligh which I believe people are looking for and will now justify with this issue which is just a shame
@@malipat5809 With respect - the issue here i think is that common lay persons who make up the bulk of TJ brothers do not read Ibn Majah or Bukhari or Ibn Qayyim. They do not understand the sciences of ahadith however the FA is read daily and mostly without scholarly guidance. The brothers then use those fabricated and questionable ahadiths in their Dawah in order to strengthen their Imaan. The pitfalls of this institutionalized and irresponsible attitude towards material used in Dawah is evident from goofs that leading TJ scholar like MTJ keeps making e.g. Yusuf a.s. being humiliated and disgraced in public.
@@adesai5901 point taken bro, I did say I understand that shaykh was highlighting the problem that it’s encouraged to use by the masses, my point was if the broader context isn’t also highlighted regarding the compilation and the author then it would easily be misunderstood that the author is some kind of deviant and making compilations like this isn’t allowed, the link I shared shows this kind of work has been done by many and the author is far from a deviant (I know shaykh didn’t say this but it can easily be interpreted that way by people) If we leave people to make this judgment then the same would have to apply to all those great scholars that we benefit from and where will that take us! Just saying the broader understanding is needed when making these kinds of content filled vids
Allah protect you Shaykh you speak the truth
Talib آمين
www.ilmgate.org/the-issue-of-fabrication-in-fadail-amal/ have you try read this?
@@MasjidRibat ya sheikh make it clear fazail al amaal is book of ahlul bidaah tabliq is among the 71 groups that prophet mentioned
@@yahyamohamed4862 he wont because he knows its not
@@yahyamohamed4862 Sheikh Muhammad ibn Salih al-Uthaymeen has opined on Tablighi jamaat in these words. العلم معهم وجواز خروج العامّة معهم:
س (20 ) اللقاء العاشر من لقاءت الباب المفتوح في أول خميس من شهر جمادى الأولى عام 1413هـ:
فضيلة الشيخ المسألة وما فيها جماعة الدعوة الذين يخرجون ثلاث أيام هم جماعة التبليغ والدعوة المهم يا شيخ أنا بدأت الالتزام قريبا ، ومضطرب في هذا الأمر فيه بعض الشباب من الأخوان في عفيف يقول : لا تمشي لا تتبع الجماعة هذه ، ما أدري ، وفيه بعض العلماء في المدينة لا أذكر اسم هذا العالم قال : نصحني بالخروج معها ، فما رأي فضيلتكم في ذلك ؟
الجواب : الغالب أن كل المسائل يكون الناس فيها طرفين ووسطا من الناس من يثني على هؤلاء كثيرا وينصح بالخروج معهم ، ومنهم من يحذر منهم كما يحذر من الأسد ، ومنهم متوسط وأنا أرى أنّ الجماعة فيهم خير وفيهم دعوة ولهم تأثير لم ينله احد من الدعاة ، تأثيرهم واضح كم من فاسق هداه الله؟ وكم من كافر آمن ؟ ثم طبائعهم تواضع ، خلق ، إيثار ، ليس هو يوجد في الكثيرين ، ومن يقول أنهم ليس عندهم علم حديث أو سلف أو ما أشبه ذلك ، هم أهل خير ولاشك ، لكني أرى أن الذين يوجدون في المملكة لا يذهبون إلى باكستان وغيرها من البلاد الأخرى ، لأننا لا ندري عن عقائد أولئك ولا ندري عن مناهجهم ، لكن المنهج الذي عليه أصحابنا هنا في المملكة منهج لا غبار عليه ،وليس فيه شيء ، وأما تقيد الدعوة بثلاث أيام أو أربعة أيام أو شهرين أو أربعة اشهر أو ستة أو سنتين فهذه ما لها وجه ، ولكنهم هم يرون أن هذا من باب التنظيم ، وانه إذا خرج ثلاثة أيام وعرف انه مقيد بهذا الأيام الثلاثة استقام وعزف عن الدنيا ، فهذه مسالة تنظيمية ما هي بشرع ، ما هي عبادة ، فأرى بارك الله فيك إن كان لك اتجاه لطلب العلم أفضل لك ، لان طلب العلم فيه خير ، والناس الآن محتاجون لعلماء أهل سنة راسخين في العلم ، وان كان ما عندك قدرة على طلب العلم وخرجت معهم لأجل أن تصفي نفسك فهذا لا بأس به ، وفيه كثيرون هداهم الله عز وجل على أيديهم
Translation
Question: I have started to become committed recently, praise be to Allaah. In our area there is the Jamaa?at al-Tableegh, who go out for thirty days or more. People say different things about them. Some say, don't go out with them, because their going out is an innovation (bidah) and they have some mistaken ideas. Others advised me to go out with them. What is the correct view concerning that? Should I go out with them or not?.
HIS ANSWER (Al-Baab al-Maftooh, no. 10, P. 304.)
Answer: Praise be to Allaah. We have already discussed this group and some of their pros and cons.
Usually in every issue there are two extremes and a middle way. Some people praise this group a great deal and encourage going out with them; others condemn them a great deal and warn against them more than they would warn you about a lion. And some people tread a middle path between those two extremes.
I think that there is some good in this group; they call others to Islam and have a clear influence that no other daaiyahs have had. Many kaafirs have become believers at their hands, and many evil doers has Allaah guided through them.
Moreover they have an attitude of humility and selflessness that is not found in many others.
Some people say that they have no knowledge of hadeeth, and so on.
They are undoubtedly good people, but I think that those of them who are in Saudi do not go to Pakistan or other countries, and we do not know anything about the aqeedah of those people (in other countries) or their manhaj (methodology). But there is nothing wrong with the manhaj followed by our companions here in Saudi.
With regard to limiting dawah to three or four days, or to two or four or six months, or two years, there is no sharaee evidence for that. But they think that this has to do with organization (of groups). If a person goes out for three days, and knows that he is limited to these three days, he will focus his mind and forget about worldly matters.
This is the matter of organization, and is not an act of worship or a matter of shareeah.
I think, may Allaah bless you, that if you have the opportunity to seek knowledge then it is better to do that, because seeking knowledge is good and the people nowadays have a great need for scholars who have knowledge of the Sunnah and who are well-versed in knowledge.
If you are not able to seek knowledge, and you go out with them in order to purify yourself, there is nothing wrong with that.
There are many people whom Allaah has guided at their hands.
And Allaah is the Source of strength
I love the work tableghi jammat do but I agree you
Sheikh I pointed this mistake to one of the teacher who forces this book on every student and visitor. Her answer was amazing, 'Hadees is Hadees, if its batil or true'. Knowing the level of their knowledge, I left that group forever. Alhamdulillah
@@rashidahmedsagar5813 ... You want to unite the Muslims by reading such a dirty book ? ....... Read Quran translations, Ahadees and 'seerah ' books in the 'ejtemas"
@@rashidahmedsagar5813 ...
You are ignorant and you don't know that you are ignorant
and how can I make you understand that you don't know?
and the surprising thing is that you don't know,
and that you don't know, that, you don't know.
@@rashidahmedsagar5813 ... Zakaria Kandalvi writes on page 13/12, Fadha'il Namaaz, Fadha'il 'A'maal, Vol I:
"It has been reported from a number of companions and from amongst them Hadhrat Uthman, Hadhrat Abu Hurayrah, Hadhrat Anas, etc. in different wordings that there are some people who possess the ability of Kashf. They can feel the sins being committed by people. Therefore the story of the Imam of the world Hadhrat Abu Haneefah is famous that he used to stand outside the Masjid of Koofah and see the sins of the people fall out as they performed wudu." (Kandalvi continues): It has also been reported from Hadhrat Uthman that the Prophet said:
((Those who possess such abilities should not become arrogant))
Astaghfirullah. What heavens are going to hide such lies and heresy! This is Sufism at its extreme my brothers. Kandalvi was so bold that he attributed the aqeedah of Kashf to the Noble Companions! He threw the mud of Ibn Arabee at the Companions! His companions attesting to people who can see ghaib? Allaahu Akbar! Zakariah Kandalvi had no hesitation in such fabrication that not only goes against the Deen itself but also Mustafa (sal-Allaahu `alayhe wa sallam) and so many of his Companions!
@@nazeerpasha2075 Aqidah of Tableegi Jamat is more correct than Aqidah of the Salafi and Wahabi heretics. Sheikh Uthman is a kafir.
@@nazeerpasha2075 bro i can't find your quoted words in urdu version of fazael amal vol 1 page 12 13 of fazael namaz
Instead of reading Fazail-Ahmal, better to read Riyadus-Saliheen
Riyad as Salihin with explenation of Shaykh ibn Uthaymin !! 👌
instead of reading Riyadus- Saliheen, better to Read Quran.
@@simplyshujat - Sure, but it was a comparison of Hadith-books! So it is even better to read both, Quran with Tafsir (of Shaykh Abdurrahman AsSadi an easier Tafsir for the folks) and Riyad As Salihin with commentary of Shaykh ibn Uthaymin!
@@jomiller8668what is the name of book of explanation of sheikh uthaymeen?
@@sakibvhaii
It’s called Riyadh as-saliheen
جزاكم الله خيرا أحسن الجزاء
Believe me shaykh your videos have had a big impact on my life and I always benefit tremendously from them and please continue the uploads
جعل الله هذا في ميزان حسناتكم
ua-cam.com/video/ssJQMWHXE7k/v-deo.html
This is related
10 Things to escape Hell Fire:
1. Tauba: Repentance from heart
2. Istagfar: Repentance from tongue
3. Doing good deeds
4. Dua and Istagfar done by other believers for you
5. Pain & sufferings in this world
6. Azaab ul Qabar
7. Punishment and trials of the day of Judgment
8. Good deeds gifted by the loved ones
9. Intercession of our Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) on the day of Judgment
10. The Mercy of Allah سُبْحَانَهُ وَتَعَالَى
all is by mercy of Allah
Mercy of Allah comes first
I don't think it's categorical, it can be in any order it's not based on 1 being the first 10 being the last here. @@nahimwasit
You didnt mention daawat that all Ambiya (a.s) did
My parents just got me this book to read. May Allah guide them.
May ALLAH guide us all.
May ALLAH give you patience, especially towards your parents.
They did u a favour great book
@@notknownmirza743 it's a book that contains FABRICATED HADITH
@@notknownmirza743 the book has shirt and fabrications. It says that Abu Hanifa could see the sins falling of people when they made wudu.
@Chungus Han 🐺 🗻 translation of the Urdu book faza’il-e-zikr translated by Shafiq Ahmad page 212 Zam Zam Publishers. “Allamah Sha’raani has related in his book “Meezanul Kubra” about hadhrat Imam Abu hanifa that when he happened to see somebody performing ablution, he could also see sins that were being washed away in the water…”
Barakallahu feekum sheikh may allah bless you and make all of your affairs easy for you ameen
Jazakallah khair for your time and information
ua-cam.com/video/ssJQMWHXE7k/v-deo.html
Here is a bigger problem in faza'l amal
My turning point to tawheed was this book, once I was in jamat reading Quran because I thought that's all we do with all the time we have! But nah while I was busy reading the word of Allah the amir(head of the jamah) asked me to stop reading Quran and let's sit in halqa for fazal e amal. That's it, I questioned him why we are givibg importance over Quran, since the fazail amal was all about ferries and dreams of Ashraf Ali thanwi and Mohammed Ilyas khandalwi, he said that's what we do in jamat. I then researched more about the concept of jamat then to my knowledge I found that it came in dream to Mohammed Ilyas while he was enroute to hajj pilgrimage(while they claim it was sunnah) all of this truth Allah has placed before my eyes so that I can follow the path of rightly guided companions.
From tableegh to ahlul hadees... Alhamdulillah
Brother usman follows imam ahmad bin hanbal school of thoughts
Tableegh a gateway for Tawheed & A'maal = ibadah
You don't have to except Fazail A'maal go with Riyahud Saliheen or Maktaba Ahadith but also read from the Hasan narrations from Fazail
Never stop partaking in this work of Dawah Alhamdulillah
We all have become better Muslims from this effort
Barakallah Hu Feek
Was Salaam
So many people akeeda wrong because this book. Allah reward you for this video
Syed Adnan Ahmed Our Shaykh’s great manners and your foul language shows who is right and wrong
@@al-ansaree3146 if ur judging every book in this world just by listening someone's negativity and dividing lectures which is titled of being on ri8 path in ummat rather then doing any ri8 nd positive work using positive actions nd words then no one is the biggest idiot than u....idiots k bhi ustaab bolsakte aap Jaise logo ku
Lagta hai aapke sheikh ku lifafe Patle milre shyd UA-cam se....islye ye mashoor or maroof kitaab jsse laakho log hidayat pe aagye islaam me aagye taoba krne wale bangya uske khilaaf me kare to milte shyd samjh liye allah unko meku sari ummat ko hidayat de or ummat me jodne ka kaam krne ki taofeeq de na k todne ka
@@syedadnanahmed2158 dont use foul language aakhi, u dont have to defend ur firqa or scholars and blame any other school of thoughts. This is just an effiet of removing fabrications from deen. Fabrication = lie
@@justahopeus so do we need to remove Ibn Majah's Sunan which has 99 munkar (denounce) and maudu (fabricated) hadiths and Ibn Qayyim's Kitab ur rooh which also has fabricated hadiths?
Barakallahu fikum
I'm shocked! I grew up reading Fazail e amaal
Jaza kallahu khair
May Allah give us knowledge and understanding Emin
Shaykh you are the only truth left in this world. you are the this. ....you are the that. ....you have discovered the truth. you are are...........
fear allah do not overpraise anyone like this
Al-Miqdād (may Allah be pleased with him) reported that a person began to praise ‘Uthmān (may Allah be pleased with him). So Al-Miqdād knelt down and threw gravel on his (the flatterer's) face. Thereupon, ‘Uthmān said: "What is the matter with you?" He said: "The Messenger of Allah (may Allah's peace and blessings be upon him) said: 'When you see those who praise others, throw dust upon their faces.'" [Muslim]
This was my first book after becoming Muslim back in the mid 80’s. Alhamdullilah Allah protected me and guided me away from this and those who still rely upon it. Shaykh, how should dispose of such books if not wanting to keep stored away or on a shelf taking up space?
May be burn it or bury it
I burned 3 of them and buried the ashes. I bought them from the Masjid with the intention of destroying them. There is Arabic and mention of Allah so this is the respectful way of getting rid of them.
@@davidrosa4156 Barak Allahu feek
@@davidrosa4156 I can see the Immense hatred of y'all salafis towards Ahlus Sunnah. Just because the book contains some weak ahadith, doesn't mean you've to burn it or whatever. Y'all should go and burn hadith books like Ibn Majāh which too has daif and mawdu ahadith.
@@Dr.ShadAli, it contains much more and much worse than a “few” fabricated ahadith. I will mention too that many of those ahadith were taken from books that were written specifically to warn people about fabrications. It was the stories in the book that are attributed to no person, so we can’t find out if the writer was honourable or dishonourable. The stories contain people who claim they can see the unseen and worse. If I invite you to a banquet and when it is time to eat I tell you that, “Oh, by the way, a few of these dishes contain poison so make dua that Allah will protect you from it before you eat”. Now, would you make dua and eat or would you say “I’m out of here” and leave my banquet? If you end up on one (or more) of the turn offs from the mustaqeem, you flirt with hellfire. I’ll finish by noting the way you labeled me a Salafi, like I’m a member if a sect, concerns me. We need to be strong together and not divide. This is why I do not sit with people that I identify are in a sect or people of biddah. So I will wear your label knowing the true meaning of the word.
JazakALLAH khair brother for letting us know MashaALLAH May ALLAH SWT bless you
For the first hadith, when he was showing the arabic text, I could see on the other page the translation still being continued. So that raised my flag and after downloading the pdf, I could clearly see this man intentionally/unintentionally (Allahu Alam) hid the translation because he had to say "no one reads the arabic" implying the translation is not done correctly or some translations are skipped. But if you see the complete translation, you can find this in the paragraph:
"Eminent theologians like Ibn Hajr, Abu Laith Samarqandi (Rahmatullah alaihim), and others, have mentioned this hadith in their books. Although I have not been able to trace the text in original books on hadith, yet otner hadiths, some of which have already been mentioned and some are to follow, corroborate its meaning."
So the translator actually DID THE JOB to let us non-arabic speakers know that the Shaykh did not find the hadith himself but he found it in other scholars' books. And he also clarifies that he is mentioning this hadith because all these points are backed by other hadiths some of which he previously mentioned.
May Allah protect us from spreading fitnah.
That still doesn't change the fact that even if you use Weak Hadith they can be used for virtues but fabricated Hadith are straight up Ally and we cannot defend Any Lies as Muslims. Also it doesn't matter if he clarified that he couldn't find the link or whether he was using it to make a point because using A lie to make a point still doesn't change the Lie. I'm not saying that sheikh did it on purpose, he's a human being and he probably didn't know that the Hadith was fake. That's why it's better for the common person to not use something in which they can't tell the difference. Just like the hadees about Adam A.S that can mess up someone's aqeedah about Islam. It's better that the sheikh who wrote the book, his sons update it but some Hadith can lead people to wrong beliefs which is dangerous. We can't present this to nonMuslims who want to come to Islam so why should we presmt this to Muslims.
Tablighi Jamaat intends to make their Jamaat heavy through spreading false promises like polytheist christians.. ....
That's why Tablighi Jamaat Calls people to their Jamaat through mixing the falsehood with truth like polytheist christians........
@Zaid Khan Peer Sufis who support the blasphemous crimes of monsoor hallaj (who claimed himself to be God) are also Kabbalist Judaism (Jew).
Imam Ibn Taymiyyah (may ALLAH be pleased with him) said that whoever calls Husain bin Monsoor Hallaj as ALLAH's oli may be ignorant or he may be like him! But your peer sufis incuding Ashraf Ali Thanvi support the blasphemous crimes of monsoor hallaj (who claimed himself to be God). Even they consider him as a saint. Naujubillah.@Zaid Khan
Do you know why it's taught that To be a Christian, Keep repeating Jesus is GOD?
Because anti-christ dajjal will say that "I am god & god's begotten son & worship me!
True Muslims will reject anti-christ for blaspheming (death penalty by TRUE GOD's laws)
Because Eesa messiah (peace be upon him) never said that “I am GOD or worship me! @Zaid Khan
Hadhrat Zakariyah(R.A)
narrated in his kitaab ‘Fazaail Namaaz’ (p 28-31), where five gifts will be granted to the one who performs his salaat regularly and those who neglect it will be
punished in fifteen different ways; five in this world, three at the time of death, three in the qabar, three after rising from the qabar.
Hadhrat Zakariyah (R.A) narrated this on the authority of Ibn Hajar Makki Al-Haythammi from ‘Al-Zawaajir’, in the beginning it was said “some have said this has been mentioned in a hadeeth”. In addition to this Hadhrat Zakariyah(R.A) has mentioned many other references and corroborating narrations; ‘Al-Li-aalie’ of Hafiz Suyoothi (R.A)
where it was stated that this hadeeth was narrated by Ibn Najjaar in ‘Taareekh Baghdad’ from Abu Hurairah (R.A). In ‘Meezaanul Ie’tiedaal’ it is written this hadeeth is baseless, it was made up by Ali bin Abbaas on Abu Bakr bin Ziyaad An-Nisaapuri.
Hadhrat Zakariyah (R.A) further corroborated it with references to
Imaam Ghazaali and the author of ‘Munabihaat’. Ultimately after seeing the practice of all these Ulama, Hadhrat Zakariyah (R.A) came to the conclusion that this narration is not baseless and can be narrated in targheeb wa tarheeb.
The astonishment is on Hafiz Dhahabi (R.A) who in ‘Meezaan’ said this hadeeth is baseless but thereafter himself narrates it in ‘Kitaabul Kabaair’, saying “it is
mentioned in hadeeth” (‘warada with a fathah) as if it is an extremely strong
hadeeth.
Maulana Zakria R.A himself mentioned those Hadith which are weak. Ulama says that he included these hadees by himself because these Hadith are related to "Fazail" not "masail" we cannot take any weak Hadith related to masail because it will effect the "Sharia" whereas weak Hadith related to "Fazail" don't effect the serious matters,. Wallah o Alam.
He's not talking about weak Hadith ( Da'if ). He's talking about some fabricated Hadith ( Mawdu' ) in Fazail Amal. Know the difference between weak and fabricated Hadith.
in my country translation version that spread & read in mosque don't have the explanation hadith degree..
and most of the preacher just read textually without explaining the hadith degree
Salaam brother, what do fazail and mazail mean?
He's specifying the difference between weak and FABRICATED Hadiths. Do you know what fabricated means brother?
Sahih al-Bukhari 106
Narrated `Ali:
" لاَ تَكْذِبُوا عَلَىَّ، فَإِنَّهُ مَنْ كَذَبَ عَلَىَّ فَلْيَلِجِ النَّارَ "
The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Do not tell a lie against me for whoever tells a lie against me (intentionally) then he will surely enter the Hell-fire."
@@user-zw7dk5lk3v The Urdu Word "Masail" مسائل Meaning in English is Topics. The other similar words are Mozuaat and Masail. The synonyms of Topics include are Affair, Argument, Business, Case, Division, Field, Head, Issue, Material, Matter, Motif, Motion, Motive, Point, Question, Resolution, Subject, Text, Theme, Theorem, Thesis, Proposition, Problem, Moot Point and Point In Question. Examples of Masail are Hajj, divorce, sacrifications, sadaqa, zakat prayers, etc
And "Fazail" means benefits of good acts and deeds.
Thank you Brother Usman
The need of the hour is to revise and revisit the Fazial Aamal so as to be more beneficial and helpful for the Tabliki Movement.
Even I love the work Tablik is doing.
Need of the hour is to revise the syllabus.
Brother they won't leave fazailay amal....bcoz it's there agenda to deviate muslim from deen e islam to deen thanvi....
U love there work???
They replaced Qur'an from masjid n placed fazailay amal on the mimber..
It's there own deen e thanvi.....n they are doing tableegh of deen e thanvi 🔥🔥
@@truthseekerIndian brother , no one in Tabligh forces anyone to follow the Fazail e Amal . Even I didn't even know who Maulana Thanvi is being a part of jamat since last 6 years .
Only point is to bring Muslims closer to the masjid towards Allah swt and the sunnah of our Prophet pbuh.
I swear there is no motive except this . There are many muslims today who are out of reach of Allah's deen .
Can you comprehend how badly we need to reach them to bring them closer ?
Please get in touch with the jamat , because the ground reality is way more different than we hear about them !
@@jaimewhale2300 Tablighi Jamaat will follow dajjal considering him as their mahdi.
Yes, irani refeji shia will be led by the dajjal anticrist because the extremists shia rafeji who believe that Ali (Alaihas Salam)) is their ALLAH. Naujubillah and peer sufis as well as kabbalists jew, Illuminati & Freemasons and other devil worshipers who believe that Human beings can become God by reaching the highest level of spirituality. (I pet goat 2) And Trinitron Christian, buddiists, hindu and other polytheists believe that God comes to earth in human form (of Jesus, Buddha, ram, krishna, gonesh etc.)
The Mahdi in the Shia books is similair to the Dajjal mentioned in the authentic Hadiths. Brother Ebn Hussein had made a video that the followers of the Masih Ad-Dajjal will be the Shia. It has over 100k views now. The Shia are Jews in disguise. The one they are waiting for is the Dajjal and not the real Mahdi. Their 12th imam never existed. Look what they are wearing in Iran like the Shia in the video wears.
Sahih Muslim 2944
Anas b. Malik reported that Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said: The Dajjal would be followed by seventy thousand Jews of Isfahan wearing Persian shawls.
.
@Zaid Khan
Last day I enquired about this from a person who is closely associated with TJ.
He replied that we don't use fazail e amaal that much now, in arab countries Riaz-us-Saliheen is being widely used and in non arab countries muntakhib ahadees, which doesn't contain even weak narrations let alone fabricated, is being is widely used and current ameer of TJ, Maulana Saad, has also adviced the TJ members to try to use Bukhari and Muslim instead of other book. He also went on saying that he never has read the fazail e amaal though he bought it but never read it.
I think it's a good thing to advise them about these faults which might corrupt aqeedah or might have other harms. One of the fault that I've noticed in TJ is that they take unnecessary on hikmat/hikmah. They try to refrain correcting immediately or for sometime the people of biddah and shirk and ask them to stop such acts. I think people like Sheikh Uthman should also advise on such things because TJ have been working on such a greater scale that many muslims around the world who have distanced themselves from deen Can benefit from it. BarakAllah feek.
Really well explained, Jzk khairun Shaykh.
The educational and informative aspect of your Dawah videos is soo helpful, especially for brothers/sisters looking to research/study/get clarification on a particular matter.
May Allah swt keep you protected, and assist you further in your Dawah efforts. Ameen
SubhanAllah when the daleel if shown they resort to discrediting the sheikh. May Allah guide us
Just like they did with the Prophet and the pious people of the past
@@mikhan5191 👍
ua-cam.com/video/-sjRDu4ck6w/v-deo.html
I hope he also make daleel on Kitab ur rooh of Ibn Qayyim.
I hope he also make daleel on Kitab ur rooh of Ibn Qayyim.
Jazakallahu khairan sheikh 👍
Dear Shaikh,
As I understand, your first guiding light to hidaya was due to Tableeghi jamaat. Just think if those jamaatis who came to you spending their own money and took effort got inspiration from the same book.
As someone who benefited from it and now at a high place with influence, your effort should've been to work with the central marakiz of Nizamuddin and Raiwind to remove the fabricated ahaadeeth and have people continue to benefit from such a great book that has been the reason for hidayah for millions of people in the subcontinent.
If people of your stature do not get constructive and work towards repairing the ills of the society, who else will?
BEST COMMENT EVER!
👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
For some Shaikhs some hadees are fabricated but maybe its not,according to them its fabricated.
JazakAllah
Its because you love your brother that you remind them that they are wrong, you do not love your brother if you keep silence and did not remind them about their wrong doing.
JazakAllah Sheikh. May Allah SWT reward you accordingly. Ameen
Thank you sheikh , My Allah bless you janah .
From India
Dear respected sheikh pliz made available pdf for essential books to be accompanied by every student (not talaba), pliz
الحمد لله حاضر وجزاكم الله خيرا
there is still Fazail ul Amal present in the Tablighi work but there has been a staunch change regarding this like Tablighi Jamat has taken up
Muntakhab Ahadith and has promoted it extensively. Muntakhab is a compilation of Ahadiths regarding the daily life of a common Muslim. Riyad as Saliheen is also a famous read among the Tablighi Jamat.
It's about time alghamdulillah
May Allah guides us. Truth will prevail insha allah
Finally someone gives the explanation ... Jazzakumullah usman bhai ...
This is good. I never used to know much about that book.
JazakAllahu khair. Could you do a video on muntakhab ahadith. I’ve found weak hadiths in that as well
Shaykh we need more videos like this
Jazakallah khairan
So true...
Wow, I didn't know this.
بارك الله فيكم
hope our tablighi brothers see this
What is the hadith book he recommended ? I didn't get it sorry 🙂
Sh. Kandahlawi RA based his book on targheeb wa tahreeb, back when there wasn't google or shamela.
Use whatever book you want like ryad al saliheen, but DO THE DAWAH WORK. This is the main issue.
You are right about doing the dawah work. However do not stick “use whatever book you want” in there. Sheikh Zakaria will be forgiven insha Allah and we pray for him due to his good work. He is not responsible in sha Allah for the people who choose to hold on to fabrications after his passing.
@@alexanderwood8565 Just like Ibn Qayyim on his Kitab ur rooh which also contain fabricated Hadith.
Jazakallahukhair
The world needs salaf that have the ikhlas like you
Sheikh uthman follows the salaf. If you say he is a salaf, then he wouldn’t be able to make this video😅😅😅
thank you Sheikh
Make a video on Kitāb ar-Rūh by ibn Qayyim too 🥱
He will never do that and we all know why. This is there typical Pseudo Salafi propaganda against Tablighi Jamaat and Fazail-e-Amaal.
@@muhammadhaazim Yes bro they're foolish as Hell
@@Dr.ShadAli Hmm, there hearts are filled with jealousy for other groups.
@Rick Astley Try not to blind follow your cult lol
@Usāmah they need to address first on why they dont critique Ibn Majah's Sunan which has 99 munkar (denounce) and maudu (fabricated) hadiths and Ibn Qayyim's Kitab ur rooh which also has fabricated hadiths?
Jazakallah khair Sheikh
جزاك اللهُ خيرًا
Abdul-Hakim Reese وإياكم
Jazaq Allah
Interesting!
While the overwhelming message is a positive one in that we must take greater care about the veracity of the hadith; however, I have a couple of points to consider.
1) Given that most Muslims would hold tafsir ibn katheer in much higher regards than fazail amal, do you maintain consistency in your judgement when you find multiple instances of non-verifiable fabricated Israeli narratives in such a major exegisis?
2) You quote a few examples and at least two of them you mention that the author/muhaqqiq clarifies that these are unfounded/unverifiable/false etc. If the author clarifies this then it serves an informative purpose only. How is this problematic when the unacceptability is clear to the authorship as well as the readership?
3) You mention this negatively affecting aqeedah, but non of the fabricated hadith you quoted conveys a detrimental theological connotation per se. So how have you made the leap from textual fabrication (congruent with permitted practice) to deviated belief?
Lol your right brother noticd how none of these salifis have given you an answer? They just barking a ideology but no real knowledge.
ua-cam.com/video/-sjRDu4ck6w/v-deo.html
1. tafsir ibn kathir and tabari are not to be read by just anyone they are books to be studied under teachers for the common people you have other books of tafasir such as tafsir as saadi 2. no its not clear to the reader. ive never even held the book in my life but ive been in many tableeghi circles where they start reading from it after maghrib and they'd be reading fabricated ahadith like its stamped with sahih they dont even mention the grading of it or what the author said about it. most people who use that book probably dont even know what terms like daif and mawdoo mean. 3. ofc there are more fabricated ahadith in the book then the ones hes just mentioned and some of them are pretty dodgy, like none of them is gonna be something extreme like rasulullah salallahu alayhi wasalam controls the sun and the moon, it would be something more minor which the common person might not pick up on . regardless there are better books to use to remind people, like riyadh as saliheen by imam an nawawi. that book is much much better and way more credible.
@@SpinoBroshub
1) So in short your answer to the point I raised, seems to indicate that inconsistency in judgement has been applied. Very interesting! Though you have attempted to justify this. While the inconsistency is problematic per se, nevertheless, let's take a look at your rationale.
If we hypothetically accept your attempt at explanation, it raises even more concerns namely, books of scholastic status require a higher level of scrutiny and veracity and not the other way round.
Furthermore, your reasoning hinges on readership-type yet not sure how you reach such a definitive distinction of which readership has access to which books! At best you might have confused, 'advisory' for 'mandatory'.
Nor is this distinction you make founded in reality. Today at least one of these books has been translated and is widely utilised by all scholars and laymen alike. The other book has also been partially translated.
2) This is circular reasoning and a fallacy. There are many other major books (Ibn Majah, Al Nasaee, Al Bukhari, Riyadh ul Saleheen) that also don't share the grading including riyadh ul saleheen. Notice it's the book you advise the layman to utilise. Again you seem to be extremely inconsistent in applying your judgement. I wonder what motivates you to be so selective. This time round your distinction of layman Vs scholar doesn't apply as you yourself recommend Riyadh Ul Saleheen for the lay person.
As for the readership not comprehending daeef and mawdhoo, I appreciate they may not understand the in-depth concept as many who think they do very obviously don't either; nevertheless, there should be no difficulty for even a 7 year old in grasping the gist from the translation that it is a grading system and 'weak' is considered very low in the scale
As for readership not mentioning the grading, this is your isolated experience and cannot be evidence for any serious discussion like this one. Furthermore, which is more credible? Text that contains grading regardless of readership stating it or not OR text that actually contains unverifiable fabricated narratives without any grading whatsoever so readership can't state it anyway?
3) Did you count these or have access to research? Could you present a quantitative comparison please? After all we are discussing rigour and veracity! I'll await this. Thanks in advance.
Oh and please do provide a reference for the statement you attributed to as 'dodgy'. I'll await this. Thanks. I wonder if dodgy is your own classification.
If you think what you referred to as dodgy is undesirable, then you obviously have not read the Israeli narratives in tafsir ibn kathir. Sigh.
As you pointed out, as being someone who hasn't even held fazail amal, you sure seem to have some very strong claims about it yet very little about the books that were intially raised in point one above.
@@SpinoBroshub i agree riyad saliheen is miles better however faizal amal mentions the fabricated hadtih its the translator who made the mistake of not mentioning those fabrication also what your saying is not exclusive to tabligh there is many salafis who lack knowledge aswell
Excellent
Alhamdulillah. Jazakallahu khair brother making this video and exposing this book. I myself a 4 months return from tableeghi jamah realised it later. request you to make full video exposing all false belief and content of the book, it will really help us use for dawah.
Im sure u could teach us all the false beliefs, since youve been for 4 months???
Brother you have been for 4 months in Allah path please don’t come into conclusion that theseahadith are fabricated, shaitan is making you to go astray, please please stop yourself from this… I agree fadail aamaal has dhaeef ahadith, but these are not fabricated,
@@safiafatima5565 what do u mean only daeef ? Will you follow daeef then ? Nontheless I can show you umpteen references of fabricated and daeef ahadith from fazaile amal series. I want you to explore yourself. Educate yourself sister before commenting. May Allah guide you !
JazakAllah khair
Was it necessary to use word EXPOSED?? as they are scammers !! You must be polite in your captions too. Do nasihat in ahsan way.
i think you should also make a video on ibn qayyim books
when 99% of of the ummah is not on 5 times salah, zakah, honesty, modesty, akeedah, tawheed and even taharah why are are we even arguing about weak and fabricated hadeeth?
What do u mean then? 99% are not praying which is the first and foremost duty so stop all scholars from the rest of the work and concentrate and lecture on salah only.? This is what u mean.?
@@innocentfriend yes the scholar need to stop arguing and get off their backsides. What ever needed to be argued about has been done over the past 1400 years.
@@arifmunshi6833 Shaykh Uthman is out there doing da'wah to Muslims, non-Muslims and ALSO teaching us about hadith because that is his field of study, can't a guy multitask?
99%?....proving fsbricstion once again.
@@rathernot6660 most people pray jumma Salah but where is everyone in fajr Salah. As an ummah we are all bark but no bite.
Jazakallah khair from indonesia
I am forwarding this to all my tableeghee relatives
@Lamin muhammad Kuyateh my book is the Quran. No faults in it.
@Lamin muhammad Kuyateh Who said anything about kitab ruh? Where is this ijma recorded?
You understand what Shaykh is saying? These hadiths are not weak but FABRICATION did scholars say you can use fabrications for Fazail?
@Lamin muhammad Kuyateh Did you watch the video?
You did not watch the video because the Shaykh shows that even in the Arabic writing in the book Fazail e Amal is shows that are baseless and fabricated ahadith.. why would you defend such a book?
Intellectual honesty requires that you listen to the Tablighi ulema before making wild accusations.
قبر کے پاس بیٹھ کر دعا کرنا
ایک شخص کے بارے میں لکھا ۔ جس کے پاس نبی ﷺ کا بال تھا اس کی وفات ہوئی تو صلحاء میں بعض نے حضور اقدس ﷺ کی خواب میں زیارت کی حضور نے ارشاد فرمایا جس کہ جس کسی کو کوئی ضرورت ہو اس کی قبر پر بیٹھ کر اللہ تعالیٰ شانہ سے دعا کیا کرے ( فضائل درود ص ۱۵۷ ) سونچنے کی بات ہے یہی دیوبندی بریلویوں پر مشرک ہونے کا فتویٰ لگاتے ہیں ۔
ایک اور جھوٹا اور گستا خانہ قصہ
حافظ ابو نعیم سفیان ثوری نے ایک شخص سے پوچھا اس نے کہا ایک آدمی نے ہاتھ میری ماں کے منھ پر پھیرا جس سے وہ بالکل روشن ہوگئی اور پیٹ پر ہاتھ پھیرا تو ورم بالکل جاتا رہا ۔ مینے اس عرض کیا کہ آپ کون ہیں کی میری اور میری ماں کی مصیبت کو آپ نے دور کیا انہونے فرمایا کہ میں تیرا نبی محمدﷺ ہوں ۔ جبکہ آئشہؓ فرماتی ہے کہ اللہ کی قسم نبی ﷺ نے اپنے ہاتھ سے کسی غیرمحرم عورت کا ہاتھ نہیں چھوا بلکہ اسن کو صرف بات چیٹ سے بیعت فرمایا ( مسلم ج ۲ صفحہ ۱۳۱ )
قارئین کرام ! میں نے صرف بطور نمونہ یہ مسائل درجہ کئے ہے ۔ روز قیامت کے حساب سے نڑر ہوکر ایسے جھوٹھے قصے نبی ﷺ کی طرف منسوب کئے ہیں اور ان کے معتقد ین اسی کو دین سمجھ بیٹھے ہیں ۔۔۔۔۔ اس کے بارے میں بھی قیامت میں سوال ہوگا۔۔۔۔۔
Moulan Zakaria sahibs funeral prayers were led by the Imam of the Prophet's Mosque, Shaykh Abdullah al-Zahim, and the body was taken for burial in the nearby Jannatul Baqi graveyard.
How can i believe he is going to hell for writing such a book??
Can you clarify?
What about the majority of Good hadees in it.. Will it have no effect on the readers???
Pls don't say Moulana Does not know about hadees...
I am asking you for a clarification..
What is the fate of such a person who wrote such a book???
You could have atleast say "Zakaria Sahib "
You people good at fiqh and below average at abstinence of this world...
Pls don't use moulana zakria sahibs name, as if you both played hide and seek in your backyard... It was very rude of you...
I am a 50/50 ( salafi/Deobandi ) and ex-tableegi 4 months saathi like you..
Wow. I feel you brother. I agree you with you.
Sir, ise urdu language me bhi record kr de.
Excellent information !!
Brother... Please comment on Ibn Qayyim R.A Book AL ROOH...
Every salafi seems to be ignoring your comment.
@@hashiramasayan162 .. they can’t dare.. all GAIR MUQALID are COWARD..
ua-cam.com/video/xE_Y-0Vd9eo/v-deo.html
Video regarding ar rooh
Ok...put aside the "fabricated Ahadeeth" We should just leave going for khurooj??
An effort which is benefiting people literally in every country of the world?!
Pardon me but The respected Scholars talk does not make sense.
Oh and the effort of Tabligh is organised by Scholars whom I'm sure can read Arabic!
Fabricated Hadith are a lie AGAINST the Prophet pbuh,so they CAN NOT be "put aside".
@MasjidRibat can I have the Hadiths in English mentioned I searched them up in a pdf and can't find them
I used to be around Muslim brothers who seemingly lived and died by this book. Asking them, for instance, why they don't read from the Qur'an Majid is a taboo subject. If you have the nerve to in fact ask it, they dismiss your question, stating in sum and substance that only the Alims/scholars could read from it as the Qur'an is too complicated a study. Sadly their behavior seems akin to the Hindus who refuse to read from their Holy Books (which forbid idolatry) and instead listen to their priests (who promote idolatry as a means to get near to God). Don't get me wrong, they are good people, but I fear they stubbornly refuse to educate themselves on Islam and instead push for an ascetic, monastic approach towards nearing Allah s.w.t.
What a load of crap ive been in tabligh for years nobody denies quran
Reading quran for drawing rulings is the job of scholars. And common man can read Qur'an for spirituality. This is the difference
I have myself very very bad experience with Tablighi jamaat. My aqidah was badly affected. Plus,I became a liar , telling ppl these fabricated thing and anecdotes.
@@hilalmir5173 lol how was your aqeedah affected?
@@fullsendit292 ,Not Lol,but Col. If you have Fazail e Aamal,go to Chapter Fazail e Durood, Anecdote no. 46.You will definitely realise how my aqidah would have been affected ( condition: if you are a true Muwahid)
We should read Mishkaut مشکٰوة
Why are people like Mufti Taqi Usmani not ordering a change in these books? Literally he is considered as "Mufti e Azam Pakistan" and he's arguably the most revered scholar of Deoband. I'm PRETTY SURE if he records videos, if he gives khutbas and if he orders to take out these fabrications and lies upon the Prophet, the people at printing press can take them out.
do you think he cares or doesn't know?
he even said that Abu Hanifa could see people's sins being washed away by water of wudu😂
so i wouldn't expect him to be saying stuff against fabrications or false stories
@@mustafasaleem2092 ۔۔۔ تقی عثمانی بھی ایک دیوبندی ہے اور دیوبندی اکابر کے عقائد کا دفاع کرنا ان کا مذھبی فریضہ ہس
@@mustafasaleem2092 proof?
@@AbdulRahman-ci9rf ua-cam.com/video/ATpyMcBaD6Y/v-deo.html
Brother when it comes to maslak mufti taqi usmani is dewabandi himself he knows everything about the book and his aqeeda is exactly the same as this book..
mashaAllah thanks so much.
First correction when we talk about such great scholars who have passed away we should along with their name add Rahmatullah alaih.
Can someone refer to the Fadail of Amal by abdul Ghanee Al mAqdasee
Ibn majah has 34 fabricated hadith according to ibn jawzi. Should we throw away ibn majah? Shaikh zakariya rahimallah wrote down commentary on the grading of each hadith. Please do read.
ibn majah is a hadith book, and each hadith has chain narration.. so whoever read & teach the book in public should explain the takrij & syarah (like any hadith book)
however fadail amal don't have the chain, grading of hadith only find in the original text, not the translation one (in my country don't have it) and being used to give dakwa without explaining the takrij & syarah.. so common people can't differentiate which amal that should be followed
Are you really doing it bro?? Comparing apple and oranges. The book which is primary source of hadith ofourse have all kind if hadiths which scholars later on sifted through and graded them i. The basis of esma ur rejaal. Hadith collection books are not propagatory books. Fazail e aamaal isnt a book of collection
Or Ibn Qayyim Kitab ur rooh which also has Fabricated hadith.
I have it in my english translation.@@spikerz81
Thing of note is that the man who wrote this book was declared unwell by his doctors psychologically. He himself mentions he wrote this book while on leave because of his mental state.
The hadith about the 5 virtues of salat is in Al-kabair of Imam Ad-Dhahabi. Same grading from Imam Suyuti. It seems people pick and chose who they want to criticise, to serve their own purpose.
Don't throw the baby out with the bathwater
Nafri Letap السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
As clearly stated in the video, Fadhā’il al-‘Āmāl was the subject of this video because it is widely distributed to common folks and relied upon without understanding the grading of the Hadīth. Just because someone other book or scholars recorded a extremely weak Hadīth that doesn’t mean you should promotes.
Jazakallahu khair for responding. Many books have weak hadith. I'm not promoting any book, just highlighting that certain people with certain inclinations are always scrutinising Fadail Amaal, no book is free of fault except the book of Allah.
InshaAllah continue your good work, inviting the non-muslims to Islam.
Nafri Letap السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
May Allāh reward you for your sincere advice. The fact that many other books have weak and even fabricated Ahādīth and the fact that most of the Ahādīth in Fadhā’il al-‘Amāl was addressed in the video 0:35 .
Yes you did mention that. InshaAllah Allah will judge according to one's intention.
Nafri Letap آمين
And I ask Allāh to guide me and you to what Allāh loves
Nice thumbnail
That litteraly the book😂
Thx
Sallallaahu'alayhi sallam
Perhaps you could also do a video about the fabrications and the very weak hadiths mentioned in Kitab at-Tawhid written by Ibn Abd al-Wahhab? Or a video on the fabrications and very weak ahadith used in sharh of tahawiyyah by ibn Abi al-Izz?
Or is this against your policy that you only make videos against certain groups not abiding by your manhaj?
Please mention one fabricated hadith in Kitab at-Tawheed and one fabrication in Sharh at-Tahawiyyah, so that we can go and verify your claim.
I would love to see the very weak hadiths mentioned in kitab at tawheed or sharh tahawiyyah that you claimed.
He will never do it because it will be against his sect and Scholars.
@@muhammadhaazim ur implying that the sheikh is a muqallid? Ascertain ur claim with proofs thank you
@@rz9018 Obviously he is a follower of Salafi sect and its Scholars.
Jazak Allah khairan Shaikh.
In my experience in tabligh where I went over 10 times ranging sometimes 3 days and more. I think some parts of the jamat have changed and fixed their mistakes. There are updates versions where fabrications are thrown out. I think it's mainly in Canada and most mufti's in my province of Ontario and the rest of Canada I think are in the tabligh effort.
I personally think these people are helping others to come back to the right path effectively, however I prefer other approaches personally.
Edit: Sheikh zakariyyah kandhalwi is a great muhaddith.
And I did my first 40 days which was a very eye opening and spiritual experience subhanallah
Whatever works for you brother..whatever motivates you and brings you close to your Deen. Its all good.
However, you must admit, there's no global collective and organised dawah movement like the tabligh jamaat. Must respect the brothers who consistently give there time locally and non locally for this effort.
@@sahazi4780 issue for me is, whenever we have these bothers come to me, I feel like their ultimate goal is for me to spend 40 days, 10 days etc.
Shouldn't their pure intention be for me to worship Allah and go masjid?
Can you share some mosques in toronto where tabligh effort is carried out jazakallah
@@AyubKhan-jh4mp almost all masjids
@@mohammedsalimahmed5230 Bro thier intention is same.. they come out of maajid and they go back to masjid (u go or u dont go)..
they go back to masjid to learn and to teach.. and spending 10 days or 40 days is beneficial for you.. when they go out they stay in masjid they learn and teach in masjid.. so all these things are done in masjid.. so they are ultimately calling to masjid only… 😊
Assalamū ‘alaykum Sh. Uthman,
I have a Tablighī background but I also follow the good work that you are doing besides following other dū’āt of Islam irrespective of their theological leanings as far as they fall within the ambit of Sunnī Islām. Our religion is vast and accommodating and can easily accommodate giants of our tradition with diametrically opposed views such as Hujjat Al Islām Abu Hamid Al Ghazzālī and Shaykh Al Islām Taqī ad Dīn ibn Taiymiyyāh rahim Allah ajmaīn. Please don’t narrow the vastness by casting a significant portion of the ummāh out of the fold of orthodoxy since majority of the Islamic scholarship in Egypt, Syria, North Africa, Al Andalus, Hind, Indonesia, Malaysia, Turkey, Central Asia, and many other lands of Islam have believed in the explanation of divine attributes of Allah in the light of Ashārī and Maturīdī framework instead of Shaykh Al Islām Ibn Taiymīyyāh rahimullah. The people commenting here negatively about such scholar should make sincere tawbāh for doing ghībā of so many of the ummāh lest they face Allāh’s wrath on the day of judgment.
Sincerely.
Your brother and well wisher.
He just explained that Al-Khandlawi is a liar and is rejected.
He has other videos on why Tablighi isn't the right way.
The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) used to say, when beginning a khutbah (sermon): " The best of speech is the Book of Allaah and the best of guidance is the guidance of Muhammad. The worst of things are those which are newly-invented, and every innovation is a going astray" (reported by Muslim, no. 867)
@@IbnHussain Shaykh Usman is a very sincere person who is knowledgeable as well, Allah be praised. But is he a proof (hujjah) for anyone? No. He will agree with me on this also. If your point is that he’s quoting Quran and Hadīth, well then, the other scholars are also quoting it and giving their proofs, aren’t they? Do you think the scholars of Islam are taught to call people towards their own views and not of Quran and Sunnah? This is a great slander indeed! Everyone of our scholars of the Islamic tradition frames his arguments and ideas using the framework of Quran and Sunnah. As a follower of scholars, and yes, you are one of them too unless you approach it without going to Shaykh Usman or anyone else, understands it THROUGH the lens of Islamic scholarship. If you don’t like or understand what Imam Razi said but you follow Ibn Qayyim that is fine but you’re still making taqlīd. At the end of the day, everyone is engaged in understanding the “intent” of the prophet (peace be upon him). I am not saying everyone’s opinion is correct. It may as well be Shaykh Usman who is correct and the opinion of Shaykh Zakariyya Al Kandelhvi is incorrect. How does that make Shaykh Zakariyya a liar or an evil person? It simply proves that Shaykh Usman was able to reach the correct opinion using the hermeneutical framework he uses to establish what is right and what is wrong.
@@iqadeer Did you hear the part about those hadiths being mawdoo?
3:50 Abu Hatim /Imam Razi said he is Khadhab, that means liar.
@@IbnHussain Yes, Zakariyya Kandehlvi mentions he didn’t find any reference for the fabricated Hadīth and mentioned Abu Layth Samarqandi has mentioned it in his book. It’s obvious that Zakariyya Kandehlvi doesn’t see any issues in narrating weak narrations when it comes to virtuous deeds. Isn’t Imam Bukhari same when it comes to narrating weak narrations about virtuous deeds? His book Adab Al Mufrad has weak narrations, doesn’t it? As for the fabricated Hadīth in fadail ‘amaal, Zakariyya Kandehlvi didn’t admit that he knew that it was fabricated so I am willing to give him the benefit of the doubt.
I think you should research who Shayke Zakaria kandelwi was first.
Your total knowledge and wisdom is equal to one of his finger tips. That's not an insult, but rather a compliment.
You are still young with much to learn.
Study the author, who spent decades teaching Hadith by the blessed grave, and research why he included the 'fake' Hadith.
Then form an opinion.
Fame isn't everything. You don't need to make a video on everything.
I love fazail e aamal.❤
As salaamu alaikum
Sheikh I request you to say mufti tariq masood that you are not a blind follower of hambali fiqh, because he has mentioned that you are hambali in fiqh
Sheikh! Please provide proper reference so that the people who r not alim could also get that easily. Jazak Allah
Hadhrat Dhun Noon Misri said," I saw a young man near the Ka'bah shareef who was performing much rukoo' and sujood. I asked him why was he praying so much (Sufis not pray so it was strange for this pir). He replied, "I am asking permission to return to my country." I then saw a piece of paper drop from the sky. It was written, "From Allaah the Most Majestic the Most Merciful to His thankful slave that return to your country. All your previous and future sins have been forgiven." Fazael e Hajj, story 15.
Tariq Jameel also quoted these hadees many time .. make a video on him too
Fazail E Amaal was written more than 100 years back.
The Ulema in Tabligi Jamaat should meet, discuss, consult with other Ulemas. Get all fabricated and weak Hadiths removed and republish the book.
It is permissible to mention weak Ahadeeth out of virtue. However, it is sinful to propagate fabricated Ahadeeth.
Today this mufti is sitting in U.S.A and preaching Islam is the effort of Tabligh jamaat but these mushrooms don't reliase the rain drops which made them fluorish
@@pmsnoormohamedibrahim4678 But bro this doesn’t mean you will propagate fabricated hadiths among the masses.We are not against tablighi Jamaat we are against Fazail e Amaal they should consult with their scholars and remove all the fabricated (maudu) hadiths.
@@pmsnoormohamedibrahim4678 the insulting way you address people of knowledge as “mushrooms “ shows your ignorance and lack of Aftab, please go back to your scholars of tabling and tell them to teach you some manners and some respect
@@Umme-45 Mushroom is not disrespectful, i mean they are not experienced in the field of jurisprudence, that's it,Otherwise i don't have any personal vengeance with him....okay just mind your own business it will be good
I'm confused. If the Hadiths are fabricated, what are they doing in books? Shouldn't Ulama remove them from the books? Or not convey them to anyone?
That is correct but some intimidating to use even though they shouldn’t. Hence why Shaykh Uthman made this video
This will make this more clear iA
ua-cam.com/video/-sjRDu4ck6w/v-deo.html
You have knowledge , you should publish a leaflet which can give guideline in terms of all the hadiths in this book which are fabrications.
Jazakallahul khairan...
Yeahhh,
it is better to know by every one
that book fazael a'mal
more fabricated hadith inside in...
Full context can be learned here iA
ua-cam.com/video/-sjRDu4ck6w/v-deo.html
Sallam brother what about slaatul tasbeeh
Sheikh the book is part and parcel of their da’wah. Ive engaged many of their elder workers and leaders with regards to changing it, doesn’t seem like it will ever happen. It’s part of the hizbiyyah of the jama’ah.
والله المستعان وعليه التكلان ولا حول ولا قوة الا بالله
What if I told you they used to tell me to read this book instead of saheeh buhari. They used to say it is authentic
@@civilservant4843 Unbelievable
what about Mutakaba Hadish Kitaab
Come to salafiyyah ya tablighi jamaat
Lol
Salàams...my brother
Do you have any better ideas?
Bis millah.
We should still respect the scholar that wrote this book, even though we might disagree with him, this author has a title, and we should not delete his title lest it be out of spite or poor character. You refer to yourself by a title, you refered to another scholar by a title, but you ignored this mans title... not only does that show bias because there are many books with weak and fabricated hadith but it shows poor akhlaaq.
May Allah bless me and all of us with guidance and good akhlaaq that will unite the Muslim ummah.
User user السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
Are you in agreement that books with fabricated Ahādīth should not be given out to the masses to read? I am amazed that you are worried about the honorary titles being used but not concerned that lies are being attributed to the Prophet صلى الله عليه وعلى آله وسلم a fabricated Hadīth is not a weak Hadīth it is Harām to attribute it to Rasūlullāh صلى الله عليه وعلى آله وسلم
@@MasjidRibat
I don't know the verdict on the use of the different grades of hadith. I am not a mufti so i will not endeavor to make such a verdict. I would be perfectly happy if muftis sit down and discuss this and come to a verdict.
And whatever the decision, it can be disseminated in a respectfull peaceful way, whilst at all times maintaining respect between all sides. Yes ideally there should be only one side, but the reality is that there are many sides/ preferences/ affiliations, some differences are trivial others not so, but all our words should be designed towards unity- focused, and strategic. biizniallah,
Alhamdulilah you have wonderful way with your dawat, may Allah grant you a greater reach and greater success, may Allah make you the means of the entire ummah being united and knowledgeable about our deen.
May Allah bring many people into the fold of Islam at your gentle hands.
And May Allah grant me all of your good qualities.
Maaf if i offended you Sheikh, i don't know Sheikh personally to have a private discussion.
May Allah forgive us and guide us.
User user السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
That’s a great idea! I am willing to sit with any Mufti or Mawlana and discuss inshaAllah. You are a good person with good intentions so I encourage you to seek knowledge: here is an introduction you can easy understand inshaAllah ua-cam.com/play/PLExCKwROz20HG3bMIYe9gCtKJjbG5J1Z3.html
@@MasjidRibat so get connected with mufti ilyaas ghumman sahab idiot..
@@syedadnanahmed2158 Are you calling me an idiot or the Mufti? Ether way whoever teaches you such bad manners i don't want to connect with .. May Allāh bless you with better manners
What is your opinion of another book which some tablighis use called منتخب احاديث muntakhab ahadith
Also in Middle East tablighis use رياض الصالحين riyadh ul-Saliheen
Amir in Delhi Markaz Maolana Saad has been telling these radical oldies to stop using this book for decades! Having said this, Maolana Saad is also not free from any errors, ask Darul Uloom Dewband!
a desai True
But it goes to show the book is an issue more just the ahadeeth mentioned. Not the work of tabligh which I believe people are looking for and will now justify with this issue which is just a shame
Understand the issue with context here iA
ua-cam.com/video/-sjRDu4ck6w/v-deo.html
@@malipat5809 With respect - the issue here i think is that common lay persons who make up the bulk of TJ brothers do not read Ibn Majah or Bukhari or Ibn Qayyim. They do not understand the sciences of ahadith however the FA is read daily and mostly without scholarly guidance. The brothers then use those fabricated and questionable ahadiths in their Dawah in order to strengthen their Imaan. The pitfalls of this institutionalized and irresponsible attitude towards material used in Dawah is evident from goofs that leading TJ scholar like MTJ keeps making e.g. Yusuf a.s. being humiliated and disgraced in public.
@@adesai5901 point taken bro, I did say I understand that shaykh was highlighting the problem that it’s encouraged to use by the masses, my point was if the broader context isn’t also highlighted regarding the compilation and the author then it would easily be misunderstood that the author is some kind of deviant and making compilations like this isn’t allowed, the link I shared shows this kind of work has been done by many and the author is far from a deviant (I know shaykh didn’t say this but it can easily be interpreted that way by people)
If we leave people to make this judgment then the same would have to apply to all those great scholars that we benefit from and where will that take us! Just saying the broader understanding is needed when making these kinds of content filled vids