Jerusalem In Islam: Mordechai Kedar
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 лис 2024
- In an address entitled “Jerusalem: Whose City Is It?” Prof. Mordechai Kedar (Bar Ilan University) analyses the early history of the Islamic religion and how it relates to Jerusalem and the Temple Mount. From the ZOA in New York City (2017).
Mordechai Kedar has lot of knowledge and he is real patriot.
TV Mystery Mordechai is full of shit...
@@malenedietl3369 why you say so????
@@tvmystery261 because he is biased, and speak against better knowledge.
@@malenedietl3369 For example?
@@samwek8053 if u cannot hear that, then who am I to try to make youhear it?
Wow what a lecture. Very informative. This should go viral.
Naa..Who wants to be bothered with truth?
They want to hear about big bad so called apartheid state where actually Muslims enjoy the best living conditions and human right in the middle east. They want to hear about the so called IDF genocide of muslims when they quadrippled in population since Israel was established -unlike the ethnic cleansing arab states
We Israelis will always be monsters and Jews are demons to most people.
The world hates us no matter what we do.. what else is new?
He is full of lies.
Thank You Mordechai Kedar for this video... so helpful in understanding the beliefs of Muslim's. You are Brilliant!!!
How amazing all of your answers, Prof. Mordechai.
A great history lesson with excellent conclusions and advice to the world. Well done Mordechai!
Muslim and i agree 100%
Not muslim and I agree
This is the worst lecture on Hadith science and al aquds in Islam
@@klaywharf3602 There is no science in hadiths.
This was mind blowing. Kedar dissects the history of Islam and their own intra-political conflicts that lead Muslims prohibited to do the Hajj to Mecca decide to bring it to Jerusalem that they had conquered and had power to do so. Etc. Eventually it didn’t stick, but the idea that Jerusalem is significant in Islam does not constitute a historic or legitimate reason to consider it a candidate to be the the capital of Arab/Palestine of today.
Not true the prophet mentioned the importance of jeruslem and al aqsa
Jami` at-Tirmidhi 326
Allah's Messenger said: "A mount is not saddled (for a journey) except to three Masajid: Al-Masjid Al-Haram, this Masjid of mine, and Masjid Al-Aqsa." [Abu `Eisa said:] This Hadith is Hasan Sahih.
@@klaywharf3602 Even Taif in Saudi Arabia has been considered as the Al Aqsa mosque location. In Jerusalem Muslims face Mecca, thus turning their backs on the Holy City and undivided capital of the Jewish people. Go and build a temple, synagogue and church in Mecca for all the world's faiths !
" Dangerous Enough", We Support Erets Yisrael , Am Israel Chai.
Jerusalem don't appear in Koran
Makes a lot of sense.
Ha'Shem is in control! Keep on blessing the Creator of the universe, and sing praises to Him. He moves in the prayers of Israel, and His works will continue to bless you.
“The Al Aqsa is mentioned several times in the Quran. For instance, verse 17:1 in the chapter Al Isra reads:“Glory be to Him who carried His servant by night from Al Masjid Al Haram to Al Masjid Al Aqsa; the environs of which We have blessed, that We might show him some of Our signs. Indeed He is the Hearing, the Seeing.”
The term “Holy Land” is mentioned several times in the Quran and refers to Jerusalem (al quds) and its surroundings.
The only point I raise here is if the prophet Muhammad was transported to al-Masjid al-Aqsa during Isra. how come the masjid was built only later between 658 CE and 715 CE, that is several decades after his death? M. Kedar gives an explanation (Saudi Arabia) of which I am not convinced, but I will be doing further research.
Brilliant. Well presented. Thank you for the fascinating insight into the historical interactions. Shaalu Shalom Yerushelayim.
And this was produced 4 Months before President Trump has *DONE THE RIGHT THING* to begin the *RESPECT* for the true, eternal Caiptal of *ISRAEL.* Jerusalem.
Are you sure about your irrelevant statement? he knows nothing about history.
@@sjmousavi8754what history?
Brilliant lecture by the professor Kedar
Fearless!
A true scholar
Peace for Israel
Your the man. God bless
Enlightening ....as usual.
Dr. Kedar you gave wonderful explanation about Islam its agenda..
According to me Jerusalem is important for Muslims to debunk Jews and Christians and want to make Islam Supreme..
Too the point. We'll stated. God bless Israel.
Fantastic lecture but his audience couldn’t care less about what he is saying. Living there with all their comforts while in Israel Jews are suffering daily attacks by Palestinian terrorists. While the world sits back ,Jews included, does nothing. It’s absolutely shameful.
Merci & Shalom 2X Prof DR Mordechai Kedar & your Family - thanks alot 4 a great nice discussion. Kindness regards from nice city of Yogyakarta of Indonesia. John'S.
Invincible Israel 🇮🇱
Nimrod was an African. The United Nation is a revised edition of Nimrod's Tower of Babel. At the top of the Tower of Babel there was a sanctuary [ a lobby ] where differences could be resolved.
Baruch Ha'Shem! Israel Chai ha'olam!!!!!
Kedar is the greatest and most authoritative scholar of Arab culture alive. The only one close to his knowledge is Meir Ben Shabbat.
Yeshar coach The naked true dutiful fsineted important Message to the Pupil in Israel Thank you so much.
Mordechai God bless you
Curse of the zionistic terorist and antisemite Mordechai ben zona
Curse of the zionistic terorist and antisemite Mordechai ben zona
Jesus didn't make himself GOD. __ GOD made himself Jesus. ___ Jesus is LORD and Jesus is a Jew.
Jerusalem belongs to the God of Abraham. And through Gods glory, may the children of Abraham, forever perpetuate rightousnes and love for God's Generosity and Mercy for the many blessings, for which we are so very thankful and greatfull.
Forgive our short comings of promise to show our love for you and each other. Grant us the persuit of impeccable integrity and truth of your will father. Amene
PS. Some Believe, not I. I know you are my Life 🌈
And now we have the US embassy in Yerushalayim !! 🇺🇸 🇮🇱
Mordechai is telling the truth or iran ?
He proved to be right. Look what happened now in 2024
Mordechai Keidar has a great knowledge of the arabic language, the quran and islam !!! He gives a hard time to the muslim arabs at any interviw!! they all are get angry at him, because he knows so much, and they have no way to win against him!!!
He doesn’t he is ignorant lying Zionist who doesn’t know anything about Islamic history
Her bijî mam Mordechai❤❤
Wow!
Although the sufee are said to originally follow the teachings of Abraham and worship IL, ILA, (YAHWEH, KANE Hawaiian God of all creation and heaven). Also did Ibrahim and Ishmael build an alter on the Temple mound.
Interesting lecture, but a bit too biased.
Joshua lost Jerusalem because he did not fully drive the Jebusites out of the city and he did not build the Temple. ___ King David had to reconquer Jerusalem and begin the process of building the Temple. If the Jews do not remove the Muslim threat from Jerusalem and locate them in a safe place like the Jezreel Valley where they can be watched and if the Jews do not build their Temple they will lose Jerusalem even though [ like Joshua ] they won every battle against the hostile tribes surrounding them.
גם ערבית גם אנגלית עברית כמובן כל הכבוד מתי יש זמן ?
ARAFAT'S STRATEGY WAS TO OUT - WIT THE JEWS. __ TODAY THE MUSLIM STRATEGY IS TO OUT - WAIT THE JEWS.
❤🇮🇱
✔
Terorista
Who is Yohanis?
John, Juan , Yohan, etc.
Thr president of Romania
Why bother?
This guy have so much hate . He is Spreading hate.
@1970amar He is speaking the truth. The truth will set you free.
I don’t sense any hate. He is educating you. Everything he says is true.
THE TURKS SAY; "When an Arab invites you over for dinner be careful because you may be on the menu."
Definitely wiz
Absolute BS
all facts, you cant handle ;p;
The land was given to them “conditionally”. As you know jews disobeyed god so many times.
Quran 5:21
O my people, enter the Holy Land which Allah has assigned to you and do not turn back [from fighting in Allah 's cause] and [thus] become losers."
I don't recall any mention in the Torah granting Israel to Arabs .
The queeran is a bad man made copy paste of the original.
What a bs if Mohamed was a strange so the Moses and the Torah
This guy is making up stories
So the muslims are coming
Salaam means cease-fire Not Peace.!?
Yes
This guy is trying to be funny be failed miserably
Covenant was conditionally , and it’s broken :
Deuteronomy 31:16
16 And the Lord said to Moses: “You are going to rest with your ancestors, and these people will soon prostitute themselves to the foreign gods of the land they are entering. They will forsake me and BREAK THE COVENNANT I made with them.
Quran 2:124
And [mention, O Muhammad], when Abraham was tried by his Lord with commands and he fulfilled them. [ Allah ] said, "Indeed, I will make you a leader for the people." [Abraham] said, "And of my descendants?" [ Allah ] said, "My COVENANT does not include the wrongdoers."
1 Samuel 15:28
28 Samuel said to him, “The Lord has torn the kingdom of Israel from you today and has given it to one of your neighbors-to one better than you.
Genesis 15:18
Genesis 17:21
Genesis 28:14-15😊
Zechariah 12:2-3😊
Jesus made the sabbath lawful:
Matthew 12:12
“...therefore it is LAWFUL to do good on Saturday”
Quran 3:50
And [I have come] confirming what was before me of the Torah and to make lawful👈 for you some 👈of what was forbidden to you. And I have come to you with a sign from your Lord, so fear Allah and obey me.
So pathetic. This was such a waste if time. None of the claims are true. Same logic that put Jesus on the cross was applied to Mohammed. If you in any way -as you pretend- believe in Jesus, why not convert? And if you won't, so what is Jesus to jews? "Jerusalem is jweish", so any jew who converted to Christianity or Islam should lose his right to live there??!! Is this the jewish democracy you brag about?
Arabs don't know what Democracy is .
@@thomasellner6331 thanks to the US/Isreali overthrow of democraticly chosen governments and installing puppet dictators, The Sjah, Saddam Hussein, Husni Mobarak, Sisi, Zinedin ben Ali, Saudi Arabia (was never a democracy but stays in power with the help of US/Isreali weaponry).
Fake researches he doo
Silly .Muslim 😂😂fake like your koran
@@jasmitsirah The 1924 Cairo version is the best version of the quran ever made. far better than the versions Uthman burned.
Full of hate and lies about islam
why are you full of hate and lies about islam?
Give proof. Don’t just make a statement with no basis.
He is talking the Truth
@@worfoz he is speaking the truth
@@simpsonisoe8994 Islam is a political ideology but they do not own Jerusalem
ask your caliph, she knows
The sad thing is about this is that he attempt to be despicably funny and is incorrect on many point and is very insulting, not suiting an academic. I would get very angry if someone tried to ridiculize or insult judaism in the manner that he insults islam. But he is already speaking to an audience who shares his hatebeliefs so he can continue. He is speaking politicaly and not academicly. He tries to convince the listeners with islamic words to make them belive that he is factual but he is not. Arab coutries were always treacherous when it comes to Palestine. He tries to justify the occupation and killing of innocent people by the Isreali army by theological explenation. The people living the are human beings who lived there centuries. It is despiccable that someone who has never been to the holy land but has more right than people who are already living there. That is pure racism my friends, nothing else. Get rid of your hate and exept your fellow human being as an equal, there is no such thing as a chosen people.
Your umbrage on Judaism's behalf is appreciated, but completely unnecessary. Attacks on the authenticity of Judaism can be refuted quite simply.
It was the Muft of Jerusalem who insisted that "just as it is impossible to put two swords into the same sheath, it is impossible to squeeze two peoples into one small country.” It is only Palestinian insistence on rendering the entire historic homeland of the Jewish people land "from the river to the sea" free of Jews, as they do in the Palestinian-controlled areas in Area A+B and Gaza, that makes it impossible for Israel to reach any sort of accommodation with them.
Sahih al-bukhari 2926!!!sahih muslim 1767a!!!!
This is hatred from the beginning!!!
looks like you are a religious extremist who lives by religious text. Goy is.created to serve you.and you.can kill anytime you.want?@@tempelhoferfeld7727
or both (drunk & tired; sucked of masculine energy)
This guy is full of hate and animosity towards islam but what doesn't now is he is insulting god
No, you're the hater here. Dr. Kedar is a distinguished scholar recognized as such even by Arabs and Al-Jazeera. To refute him you'll have to know more than he does - and I guarantee that you don't.
Galena - that's very nice of you; and I like your first name. So are you related to the poet Thomas Gray? I actually don't like my surname that much - it's German for "shining stone". You need to remember that such surnames became mandatory in Europe only in the 17th. century or so, and did not exist prior to that. My first name, which is Hebrew for "lion", is the one you need to focus on. That appellation was handed down to me from my Jewish ancestors in Israel millenia ago. So that the surname you purport to admire so much was an historically very recent addendum demanded by State law - the first name is the ancient and authentic one which confirms identity.
Galena...too shy to answer? Don't be...really, nothing to be afraid of. We're just having a civilized conversation about names.
Not at all. He is simply a realist when it comes to Islamic Cultures and Societies. And no, insulting god? Not so, and frankly, G-d will let him know if G-d is angry. Humans don't need to attempt to make declarations of insult.
Not actually..he is full of facts.
Problem is that the Palestinians and most of the Muslims believers don't know much about their faith.
A talented clown !
This Mordechai is very respectless and condecending, horrific to listen to. How he describes the prophet of a world religion as a ridiculous streetpreacher. Which professor who expects civilized people to take him serious will speak of a world religion in this manner? I'm just wondering.. A socalled man of mature age and some, I suppose, education. Incredible....Shamefull.
If that's how you feel, by all means, to get the inside story, read Hamed Abdel-Samad's "Islamic Fascism."
@@wescolumbus621 look, you find fascists everywhere, but there is no fascism in Islam. Dont lecture me on my own religion. In the Taurah there is no fascism or in the teachings of Jesus. Moses, Jesus and Muhammad, peace and blessings be upon them all, only conveyed what God revealed to them. It is people who put in the fascism. I don't need to read any book, that claims Islam to be fascistic.
@@malenedietl3369 Yes, you're totally free to believe in your way and ignore my friendly suggestions. I still wish you the best!
@@malenedietl3369 you wanna believe in fairy tales go ahead, this man speaks from scriptures , historic texts and findings, not feelings. im sure its a bummer to hear what a bluff your religion is but frankly every rligion is- only islam shouts and sheds blood as if we are in the middle ages, all in the name of religion- hence its important to debunk islam and the absurdity of their claims to places and prophets which they just copied and recycled over the years. the arab is the man behind of the world so we must put a mirror in his face before he tries to drag us down to the desert culture which he wants so much for the world to sink in to again. i say a gain=every religion is essentialy bullshit but the most ridiculous one is yours, no offence, and islam has butchered millions in order to make itself legitimate, and still does today, so we must debunk the shit outta it
@@wescolumbus621
Abel samad is a antisemite!
Fake scholar... a liar...
you cant handle the truth lol
Are you sure Islam started in Saudi Arabia? Doesn't matter who cares. What's important you claim to be a Semite, but you have German accent amazing, isn't it?.
Sj Mousavi
How would you know what his accent sounds like???? This even more amazing
those who occupied Palestine are Ashkenazim Germans originally from Khazar land. They all have a German accent when speaking English. this man is ignorant about whatever he says. Jerusalem is the holy land and not a homeland.
Sj Mousavi
NOT true. The majority of Jews in the late 19th and early 20th century came from Russia....The German Jews came much later after the end of WW2. So... as one might say.... shove it. This is the babble of an imbecile.
Jerusalem is a holy city.... how would you know? Jerusalem was proclaimed holy by the Jews during King David's rule. Jerusalem is holy because it was proclaimed as so in the Jewish bible. Then came all the others.....
I suppose you have never heard of repatriation. Dr. Kedar's Family was repatriated to Israel. Now my Grandma's family was butchered by Arabs in 1929, and they were there when Caliph Umar rolled up the Perfume Road and invaded.
Doesn't matter where the ethnoreligious People known as Jews are repatriating from. Israel is their ancestral homeland. And being Indigenous to the South Levant, it is no one else's choice to determine who is and who is not them. That is settled by halacha. Sorry Sj, colonizer Arabs don't get to make those decisions. In Israel, Arab and Islamist Supremacism is not a factor, that is simply as sickening as white supremacism in North America. Arab Palestinians can make up any weird history about themselves they want. They are still Arabs. Doesn't matter if they have Bosnian Ancestry, Somali Ancestry, et. al. They are still all Arabs.That is their culture. That is who they are.
Is not a lack of fact what is missing here ,but hatred towards us ,but the best part is we r not going to let go of uor beloved land
Sahih muslim 1767a
Sahih al-bukhari 2926!!!!!!!!!
John 3:16😊