I came here because I heard the IV movement this morning. Liked it. Took a photo of what it was so I could look it up. It seems John Williams may have liked it too. It sounds like it could be the basis for some of his works. :)
I. Introduzione e Allegro: 0.55 II. Alla tedesco: Allegro moderato e semplice: 14:39 Iii. Andante elegiaco: 21:43 IV. Scherzo: Allegro vivo: 32:03 V. Finale: Allegro con Fulco.Tempo di Polacca: 38:02
I keep coming back to this amazing performance, I listen a lot to Rico Saccani's videos as a conductor of Philharmonic and Opera but also his piano recordings, he was a wonderful pianist before he started conducting. This recording is the best !.
This theme is the same that appears majestically before the coda. Only half of this theme actually appears. It seems that in the original version of this symphony this theme appeared in its entirety before the coda but the composer cut it in half as we now know it.
@@santiagorodriguez3330 Yes, the video of RS doing the D'Indy Symphonie on a french mountain air is great. I can't believe he conducts it from memory, just like this video.
@@waverly2468 H conducts everything from memory.. did you know he was the winner of Karajan competition and worked with some famous conductors who were his teachers? Among othes Abravanel, Ozawa, N. Boulanger, Bernstein and others.
In general, quite good, and sometimes even good. But there were unjustified slowdowns in the third movement, and the polyphony in the fugato of the finale was not distinct.
Quite good and welcome as this work is poorly represented on UA-cam. But the reading is very clinical, lacking any real sense of Russian passion. NOTE. The score calls for four piano accordions which have been omitted. To me, an improvement as I can't stand this instrument.
@@creativeoneuk Thank you David, you're quite correct. Haven't listened to either for some time and memory slipped a trifle. As for the accordions, you are not alone in liking them but for me they have always been a pet dislike in any context. And of course, Tchaikovsky was a master of orchestration so who am I to question his choices?
Origins of music unevidenced. Except it is gift to humanity from God the Creator. Music continues in heaven. Discontinues in hell. Jesus Christ died and resurrected for remissions of everybody's pre-existing sins to save from eternal hell. Penalty of sin already paid by Jesus Christ on The Cross. Accept HIM. Be saved from eternal hell. Enter heaven. Enjoy heavenly music. For free.
It came from Tchaikovsky's head. I guess you have a connection with someone who has visited heaven and hell and described them for you. I enjoy music for FREE from UA-cam.
I think the orchestra is talented, but the conductor is insufferable - he makes this masterpiece sound boring and torturous. The music does not sing with the sense of Russian melancholy that is so desperately present in much of Tchaikovsky’s work. One reason is that there is very little contrast in color and texture - everything is just the same dynamic. I wish the faster movements could have more brilliance; the slower movements lonelier and quieter. Moreover, it doesn’t help that the conductor makes a lot of distracting movements and facial contortions. Listen to Karajan if you want the real Tchaikovsky experience.
@@santiagorodriguez3330 You sound like a teenager who can’t take criticism. We both have an opinion, which happens to differ. If we had an intelligent discussion about it, maybe we both could’ve left with a new understanding. But all you did was throw out a name to satisfy your injured sense of pride. Grow up - let’s be adults here.
Braaavooo... A marvelous performance!
I came here because I heard the IV movement this morning. Liked it. Took a photo of what it was so I could look it up. It seems John Williams may have liked it too. It sounds like it could be the basis for some of his works. :)
First-class performance! Thanks for posting.
Clean, vital and vivid performance with a confident and ebullient Maestro in Rico Saccani.
Beautiful. Awesome performance.
thank you for your kind words
I. Introduzione e Allegro: 0.55
II. Alla tedesco: Allegro moderato e semplice: 14:39
Iii. Andante elegiaco: 21:43
IV. Scherzo: Allegro vivo: 32:03
V. Finale: Allegro con Fulco.Tempo di Polacca: 38:02
Beautifully done! Bravo Maestro Saccani and orchestra!
thank you Peter for your very kind words
I keep coming back to this amazing performance, I listen a lot to Rico Saccani's videos as a conductor of Philharmonic and Opera but also his piano recordings, he was a wonderful pianist before he started conducting. This recording is the best !.
VERY generous words. thankyou
@@santiagorodriguez3330 You are welcome
Perfect execution. I don’t understand the dislikes...
I stopped to try to understand some people, I just enjoy the beauty and Rico is an amazing conductor and pianist
Haters gonna hate...
Perfect !
Excelentes y mayormente jóvenes músicos.-Muy buena orquesta
Bravo grandioso!
thankyou Leonardo. la partitura é grandiosa.
gotta love this conductor!!!
Watch the you-tube vid where he conducts the D'Indy symphonie on a French mountain air.
@@waverly2468 I listened to it, it's great, I heard just about everything Rico recorded, especially with Budapest Orchestra
39:40 A moment in the symphony that moves me whenever I hear it. A beautifully epic melody that uplifts the soul.
This theme is the same that appears majestically before the coda. Only half of this theme actually appears. It seems that in the original version of this symphony this theme appeared in its entirety before the coda but the composer cut it in half as we now know it.
When this theme appears as the majestic chorale before the coda it is so magnificent, yet sublime. Maestro T at his best!
Love encore, the Yablochko from Red Poppy of Gliere with a short beginning resembling Baba Yaga from Pictures at The Exhibition.
undervalued Symphony by Thaikovsky
That 's a fate of the Symphony ...
I only recently heard of Rico Saccani from recordings I purchased on Google Play. Very good conductor.
waverly2468
thankyou! RS
videos on Facebook and UA-cam. CDs on iTunes and Spotify. Enjoy!
@@santiagorodriguez3330 Yes, the video of RS doing the D'Indy Symphonie on a french mountain air is great. I can't believe he conducts it from memory, just like this video.
@@waverly2468 H conducts everything from memory.. did you know he was the winner of Karajan competition and worked with some famous conductors who were his teachers? Among othes Abravanel, Ozawa, N. Boulanger, Bernstein and others.
Whats the part from 48:19-53:34 called?
Russian Sailors Dance by Gliere
@@santiagorodriguez3330 Thanks a lot and great video btw (:
The T 3rd always makes me hap e
that makes two of us
Eine glänzende Ausführung chinesischer Musiker! Die Aufnahme ist prunkvoll!
In general, quite good, and sometimes even good. But there were unjustified slowdowns in the third movement, and the polyphony in the fugato of the finale was not distinct.
then you’ll do it your way when you conduct it. buona fortuna
@@santiagorodriguez3330 I am not a conductor. :-) And what time of this concert?
若いオケのエネルギーと指揮者の情熱性がベストマッチングしてる。このフレッシュな交響曲の内容にも合ってて、すごく良い演奏ですね♥
とても親切な言葉をありがとうございました。それは傑作であり、オーケストラはその情熱と献身的な仕事で素晴らしかったです。いつもよろしくお願いします、RS
Thanks very MUCH for good relations TEMPO
thankyou for your kind words
Good....but no Muti.....BRAVO from Acapulco!
Funny you say that because Muti is Rico's favorite conductor
A much better work than the noisy and banal 4th!
why "Polish"?
because last movement is a Polonaise
Stirring!
many sincere thanks for your kindness
Quite good and welcome as this work is poorly represented on UA-cam. But the reading is very clinical, lacking any real sense of Russian passion. NOTE. The score calls for four piano accordions which have been omitted. To me, an improvement as I can't stand this instrument.
um... surely the piano accordions are in the 3rd suite, not the third symphony? (and I quite like them)
@@creativeoneuk Thank you David, you're quite correct. Haven't listened to either for some time and memory slipped a trifle. As for the accordions, you are not alone in liking them but for me they have always been a pet dislike in any context. And of course, Tchaikovsky was a master of orchestration so who am I to question his choices?
Clinical? LOL
you must be thinking of the Suite no 2 which has accordions in the middle movement
@@normstrong1 Thanks Norman, but someone else beat you to it in correcting my faulty memory. Your comment appreciated none the less.
Origins of music unevidenced. Except it is gift to humanity from God the Creator. Music continues in heaven. Discontinues in hell.
Jesus Christ died and resurrected for remissions of everybody's pre-existing sins to save from eternal hell. Penalty of sin already paid by Jesus Christ on The Cross. Accept HIM. Be saved from eternal hell. Enter heaven. Enjoy heavenly music. For free.
It came from Tchaikovsky's head. I guess you have a connection with someone who has visited heaven and hell and described them for you. I enjoy music for FREE from UA-cam.
@@jcui5007 When Tchaikovski giving a glass of water to someone, Tchaikovski is giving the water which is created and gifted by someone else ie God.
I think the orchestra is talented, but the conductor is insufferable - he makes this masterpiece sound boring and torturous. The music does not sing with the sense of Russian melancholy that is so desperately present in much of Tchaikovsky’s work. One reason is that there is very little contrast in color and texture - everything is just the same dynamic. I wish the faster movements could have more brilliance; the slower movements lonelier and quieter. Moreover, it doesn’t help that the conductor makes a lot of distracting movements and facial contortions. Listen to Karajan if you want the real Tchaikovsky experience.
then you conduct it moron.
@@santiagorodriguez3330 You sound like a teenager who can’t take criticism. We both have an opinion, which happens to differ. If we had an intelligent discussion about it, maybe we both could’ve left with a new understanding. But all you did was throw out a name to satisfy your injured sense of pride. Grow up - let’s be adults here.
Funny you mentioned Karajan, Rico won his competition, isn't that amazing