Are Expensive Down Jackets a Waste of Money?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 47

  • @OscarHikes
    @OscarHikes  9 місяців тому +6

    Hey everyone! I wanted to let you know that together with my wife, we make these minimalistic hiking posters for various thru-hiking trails. You can check them out over here ➜ trailgoals.com/ (10% discount code: oscarhikes)

  • @marci8435
    @marci8435 9 місяців тому +21

    you have to compare the mt500 instead of the mt100.
    you can also treat your mtX00 with nik wax and it also gets a compared water repellant down.

    • @Dgb27
      @Dgb27 7 місяців тому +1

      Was actually thinking the same! It's just about 30/40 bucks more, but it's also rated for lower temps compared to the one he's reviewing. Been using both, the mt500 for winter and the 100 for spring/fall mainly. They're both quite nice, especially considering you'd spend 150 more for something with roughly the same lifespan😂

  • @pleok08
    @pleok08 9 місяців тому +12

    Sunday, February 11th: There are times when you pay for quality and times when you pay for the name. We don't always know. Happy Trails! Ross08

  • @alissa_thornton
    @alissa_thornton 9 місяців тому +6

    Just received my Decathlon puffy jacket for prepping my 2025 PCT thru hike!

    • @precambrian_rabbit
      @precambrian_rabbit 9 місяців тому +2

      it's an amazing jacket, unbeatable for the price + it goes on sale

    • @alissa_thornton
      @alissa_thornton 9 місяців тому

      ⁠@@precambrian_rabbitYes I did get it on sale which is even better!

  • @liv-oi6vg
    @liv-oi6vg 2 місяці тому +2

    the women's mt500 uses 850fp down ich makes it extremely competitive with the most expensive jackets out there. the main difference is the more robust fabric, which adds weight

  • @samthompson390
    @samthompson390 6 місяців тому +1

    Just found your channel toda., great advice, obviously experienced and actually testing gear normal people can afford. 10/10 keep it up :) 👍

  • @camping_guru_uk
    @camping_guru_uk 8 місяців тому

    Just bought it, £60 here in the UK, love it, packs up so small and weighs very little. Cheers

  • @wonderfullife9585
    @wonderfullife9585 2 місяці тому +4

    Bought too many cheap down jackets even some are not so cheap in Germany but doesn’t work at all 😩 at the end have to buy a good one

  • @ToudaHell
    @ToudaHell 9 місяців тому +3

    You kinda need a canvas outer protection layer to help maintain the feathers in the rain. I have a really good quality down jacket without a canvas outer layer and one that has the canvas outer layer. The one without canvas couldn't retain its warmth for more than 10 years. I'm on year 14 with the one with the canvas outer layer. In good quality down jackets, the thing that wears out most often is the zipper, which can be easily replaced. I still use my over 20yr old jacket, just in higher temperatures. Also, Sir Terry Pratchet have a great quote about the economics of buying good quality vs. Cheap things in his book Men at Arms.

    • @patrickbedruz6475
      @patrickbedruz6475 18 днів тому

      Will a quality shell outerlayer do the job?

    • @ToudaHell
      @ToudaHell 17 днів тому +1

      @patrickbedruz6475 absolutely. You just need something to protect the inner layer where the feathers are.

    • @patrickbedruz6475
      @patrickbedruz6475 17 днів тому +1

      @@ToudaHell Awesomee thank youu!

  • @petercourtney7125
    @petercourtney7125 9 місяців тому +41

    Bit unfair. The MT500 is a closer comparison.

    • @OscarHikes
      @OscarHikes  9 місяців тому +15

      I looked into it and yes, that indeed would be a more fair comparison. The specs are really similar to the OV down jacket. It's just that I didn't have it on hand and I haven't used the MT500 before.

  • @mrridikilis
    @mrridikilis 9 місяців тому +2

    what I've done in the past is to treat my puffy down jacket with Nikwax wash-in waterproofing, made especially for down. I think it's a pretty good hack, but, honestly haven't actually done a field test, as I've never soaked my down jacket before. but buying the nikwax double pack (cleaner and waterproofer) costs probably only at 20-25 USD, so it's a considerably cheaper than buying a more expensive jacket.

    • @OscarHikes
      @OscarHikes  9 місяців тому +2

      Yes, that's a very cheap and effective way to do it! :) I'll probably do a field test like that someday on my channel when I throw out my current Deccathlon Jacket and buy a new one. How long it's able to keep me warm when damp and not waterproofed vs waterproofed and damp. The difference should be huge I imagine!

    • @ToudaHell
      @ToudaHell 17 днів тому

      @mrridikilis it might be inexpensive now, but we'll pay a much bigger price later. Those chemicals are as dense as air. As it floats into the atmosphere, it will eventually accumulate in the arctic and antarctic, making those regions THE most polluted areas on the planet. I have a post grad in environmental sciences, and I avoid anything that can be sprayed.

  • @sebastianbjoernestad
    @sebastianbjoernestad Місяць тому +1

    Hey Oscar,
    I'm looking to buy a Novapro here in Europe. Where did you get yours?

  • @Fernando-qi3el
    @Fernando-qi3el 6 місяців тому +1

    Can you also talk about pants you use in your hiking in the mountains?
    Nice video though 🙏🏽
    Thanks

  • @daniel.konecny
    @daniel.konecny 9 місяців тому +3

    Sorry, but the OV jacket fit is just atrocious 😂 Looks very similar to Patagonia down sweater. MT100 is the winner for my hiking needs. Slimmer fit, higher neck collar, better shaped minimal hood and tbh I really don't think I need anything more warm than that.

  • @MarshallsLife
    @MarshallsLife 3 місяці тому

    If been using a $799NZD Macpac Phoenix Waterproof down jacket for a couple of months now, anddddd it’s one of my biggest regrets, at a certain point, your just paying extra for a tiny boost in quality. Would recommend paying anywhere from $200NZD TO $350NZD..

  • @ParaBellum282
    @ParaBellum282 Місяць тому

    I've used the decathlon for years, with a wool base layer and a fleece under and toggs rain jacket over, it can handle 10° F like a beast.

    • @OscarHikes
      @OscarHikes  Місяць тому

      Yeah, with enough layering I've been out in -10C and below temps with it as well!

  • @jaypandya9661
    @jaypandya9661 2 місяці тому

    How well and unbiased Explanation given superb

  • @rogerhoneycutt1697
    @rogerhoneycutt1697 9 місяців тому +3

    I’d wear two of the cheaper one and still be cheaper than the expensive one

  • @flaxin
    @flaxin 2 місяці тому +1

    where did you get the MT100 for only $50?

  • @Obi-Wan_Pierogi
    @Obi-Wan_Pierogi Місяць тому +1

    Couldn't you just treat your jacket with a product like Nikwax? That's whatI do with my Decathlon jacket.

  • @tonywillingham8109
    @tonywillingham8109 Місяць тому +6

    $48 my butt. Its $99

  • @disartster
    @disartster 7 місяців тому

    Have you tried any clothing items from 4F? I find many of them to be pretty nice quality. A bit more expensive than Decathlon, but much higher quality (haven't tried down jackets yet though)

  • @lbco5229
    @lbco5229 12 днів тому

    $$ usually means better quality down, and $$ means more warmth.

  • @sylvono
    @sylvono 7 днів тому

    Or use 2 cheap down jackets?

  • @patrickbedruz6475
    @patrickbedruz6475 18 днів тому

    Will these down jackets be ok in the pacific northwest where its wet a lot if you put a quality shell over it?

    • @ToudaHell
      @ToudaHell 17 днів тому +1

      @patrickbedruz6475 I've always had down jackets. My experience is that moisture is the worst thing for those jackets. The shell is absolutely necessary to keep it functional. I've had jackets with and without a shell. The one with the shell lasted much longer than the one without. Even though the one without was much better quality and more expensive. It was much lighter, but when new could withstand up to -25C. But the feathers lost their heat trapping capacity after only 10 years while I'm on year 15 with my lower quality shelled jacket.

    • @patrickbedruz6475
      @patrickbedruz6475 17 днів тому +1

      @ToudaHell wicked thats nice to know, I'd be happy with that performance.

  • @maxywaxymus
    @maxywaxymus 7 днів тому +1

    does anyone else get this effect where the decathlon keeps making a circular looking dent when it bends, looking like you have a gigantic belly button?

  • @Juanlu.
    @Juanlu. 9 місяців тому

    Buen vídeo! Muy instructivo!!! Los que vivimos en la España mediterránea y sólo nos acercamos al Pirineo en verano, lo tenemos claro: la de decathlon!

  •  9 місяців тому +1

    TNF Thermoball is on discount rn 🏷️

    • @Jordan__Sloan
      @Jordan__Sloan Місяць тому

      TNF makes trash products for people who don’t actually use them for outdoor sports, happened about 10 years ago

    •  Місяць тому

      @@Jordan__Sloan They make clothes. How and when one uses them is up to people who buy them. For me Thermoball has worked better that Micro Puff in DESERT MOUNTAINS. Very happy with Nuptse in the CITY. Planning to take it with me to Nepal. So there.

  • @moorejl57
    @moorejl57 9 місяців тому

    It looks like the MT100 is going for $99 US now.

  • @Tosadar_Outdoors
    @Tosadar_Outdoors 9 місяців тому

    👌🔥🤘❤️🍻💯

  • @lukeflynn7025
    @lukeflynn7025 9 місяців тому

    ❤from🇮🇪