The day he said the confessions are admissible is the day I saw the judgment he's talking about already those five accused are already given life sentences
Judge Ratha behaves as if he is being influenced elsewhere rather than applying law. His behavior is disgusting & shameful to say the least. He has said it several times that his judgement can be appealed if the defense is not happy.
Judge Ratha must step down for long he is having mouth diarrea on this case we can't let him go with it at one time I had him saying xhaaaaaa to Mshololo
The writing has always been on the wall. ratha gave hints a while back, and he would speak about appeal. " If this case goes somewhere, a clever lawyer would ask whatever." he would be talking on behalf of baloyi or the witness in the witness box. Now he couldn't hold himself. You are right advocate, he told advocate Mnisi that "you will read my judgment and you'll tell me if I'm right or wrong". That explains his impatients and hostility towards the defense and accused. He can't wait to read his judgment. My heart goes out to the Meyiwa's. This is so sad
The judgement is already written very true. For the judge to allow the brigadier to do as he pleases and sometimes become a judge himself without calling him to order is amazes me.
Good morning Advocate and family through his statement he should take a responsible why he said that may God Almighty intervene in this case I still trust God of miracles Ratha's mission will not be accomplished in Jesus name global family of Justice asikhulekeni and the universe say Amen evil will not prevail in South President Trump made a way for all the nations thank you Lord for raising the God fearing President for South Africa 🙌🙌🙌no devils will stop this move in Jesus name🎉🎉🎉🎉
What does the law say about this kind of behaviour from a judge this is a total disgrace and i believe he is behaving like this because he was given a mandate to convict no matter what the defence will say or do 😢😢😢
💯 Advocate. From the way he is even assisting state witnesses . He assisted Gininda on the question of a gold tooth when he realized that he was cornered. This trial is so unfair, but they won't succeed .
Morning Advocate...it's not the first time he says that...He previously told the defence and in particular the late Mr Mngo that he can take him for appeal....it shows that he has already has his judgement ready no matter the evidence...it's sad...#JUSTICEFORSENZO
We will need him to cum to parliament to tell the country hw n y dd he sentence those 5guys,wht were his findings n where is the mastermind y nt is she arrested y only the hitmen wil b sent to JAIL without the mastermind
Sifiso meiyiwa must tell the judge, i dnt just put the blame on the on what tumelo said.. the boyfriend of zandi which i dont know by name shot senzo... this my brothers live which he lost , im not just saying cos i want to say... thats what tumelo told my ibrither inlaw.... im not here to wana put longwe in prision ... sfiso must express himself on that way with emotions.
We all see the judge is winking, answering, for the state witness interfering, distract, defence lawyers can't u do sumthing adv this old man is annoying too much
Happy Sunday ntate Thulo, it has always been apparent and obvious that Ratha has already written the judgement. Going back to Zungu to fetching the notes from KZN before he came back Ratha had already written the ruling and he said himself, we saw it coming when he admitted the confessions as well that he has already convicted these guys. Question remains, what then happens with the mastermind? What laws will he base himself on when the state case seems to be so weak? Why waste time and tax payers money continuing with this sharade? Is it because he's to follow the protocol to the end? Appeal is loading we trust God to deal with all the wicked the way He wills.
The conviction was discussed somewhere, the bad part of it is these young men will be convicted I think as a judge he can not preside over a case where other witnesses are hindered to come to court even the master mind, the case is about mastermind and her hit men but really it's sad
@@thaddeusndebele6880They will never talk about that because it doesn’t fix their narrative. Now no one is talking about that recording. That judge has the accused on record talking and telling her everything.
You are lying and misleading to say Judge has already made judgement. You do this because you have certain narrative of your own judgement. Judge Ratha responded to Advocate Mnisi based on the argument he has made regarding the police form should be used when taking statement. Judge Ratha explained and also gave example of certain judgement. Don't mislead people because of your narrative.
It’s what he does on this channel all for views. A judge doesn’t always give reasons for his order but will write the reasons in his judgement. It’s simple law. This guy behaves like he is not an advocate
Ratha is one of the best judges in south africa and no appeal ever stood on cases presided by him. This is a judge who knows the law and you can tell the way he knows and reads the case laws is like a hobby to him.
The day he said the confessions are admissible is the day I saw the judgment he's talking about already those five accused are already given life sentences
Nje nami kwangikhanyela lapho ukuthi abasolwa bazogwetshwa Wu Tavern Judge nge more than 50yrs experience yenkohlakalo
That was painful to watch. My heart bleed when looking at Ntanzi. He looked the same as when his bail was dismissed 😢 💔
Judge Ratha behaves as if he is being influenced elsewhere rather than applying law. His behavior is disgusting & shameful to say the least. He has said it several times that his judgement can be appealed if the defense is not happy.
Judge Ratha must step down for long he is having mouth diarrea on this case we can't let him go with it at one time I had him saying xhaaaaaa to Mshololo
Good morning, Advocate. How can we file a motion requesting or forcing the judge to recuse himself? I believe this can be done. Please advise!!!!!
The writing has always been on the wall. ratha gave hints a while back, and he would speak about appeal. " If this case goes somewhere, a clever lawyer would ask whatever." he would be talking on behalf of baloyi or the witness in the witness box. Now he couldn't hold himself. You are right advocate, he told advocate Mnisi that "you will read my judgment and you'll tell me if I'm right or wrong". That explains his impatients and hostility towards the defense and accused. He can't wait to read his judgment. My heart goes out to the Meyiwa's. This is so sad
First day Judge Ratha said and I quot" I'm here to convict..."
Wow, did he say that? His behavior says it all
The judgement is already written very true. For the judge to allow the brigadier to do as he pleases and sometimes become a judge himself without calling him to order is amazes me.
However, he is very quick to shout at the defense team
The judgement in this case is hidden in plain sight
Good morning Advocate and family through his statement he should take a responsible why he said that may God Almighty intervene in this case I still trust God of miracles Ratha's mission will not be accomplished in Jesus name global family of Justice asikhulekeni and the universe say Amen evil will not prevail in South President Trump made a way for all the nations thank you Lord for raising the God fearing President for South Africa 🙌🙌🙌no devils will stop this move in Jesus name🎉🎉🎉🎉
We thank you for always giving such information. Thank you ADV❤
Always welcome
Yes. We all heard it during the court case.
Thank you Advocate for your analysis. As one of the people who know the "LAW" my question is - What are you gonna do about this?
Ratha helps the witnesses and always disrespect the Defence 😡😡😡😡😡
Judge Ratha washelela lulwimi mani🇸🇿🇸🇿
This trial have prove globally data SA it's a lawless country...
What does the law say about this kind of behaviour from a judge this is a total disgrace and i believe he is behaving like this because he was given a mandate to convict no matter what the defence will say or do 😢😢😢
This matter will have to appealed.
True Xolile
Who gave Ratha that mandate to convict?
Walter u gave him that mandate
Morning my judge , thanks once again for information, it is indeed this so called judge already pre judge the matter
💯 Advocate. From the way he is even assisting state witnesses . He assisted Gininda on the question of a gold tooth when he realized that he was cornered. This trial is so unfair, but they won't succeed .
Exactly
It means the judgement is ready ,so we are just waist our time and tax payers money .
Morning Advocate...it's not the first time he says that...He previously told the defence and in particular the late Mr Mngo that he can take him for appeal....it shows that he has already has his judgement ready no matter the evidence...it's sad...#JUSTICEFORSENZO
I heard that too...Sad
Sesalawulwa livangeli ngabe lolokwenteka kuMeyiwa bekuyowenteka kukakhe phela kute buhlungu lobuya esitsendzeni
Rata is a super crock of a judge,he will convict then we as the accused we will go on appeal till we go constitutional court
We will need him to cum to parliament to tell the country hw n y dd he sentence those 5guys,wht were his findings n where is the mastermind y nt is she arrested y only the hitmen wil b sent to JAIL without the mastermind
Convict them based on 2percent ey this judge is a poes
It seems to me that you are right
Judge Ratha once said to Adv Mngomezulu he can appeal and see if he is going to win
He says that to all the defense when the challenge him
Sifiso meiyiwa must tell the judge, i dnt just put the blame on the on what tumelo said.. the boyfriend of zandi which i dont know by name shot senzo... this my brothers live which he lost , im not just saying cos i want to say... thats what tumelo told my ibrither inlaw.... im not here to wana put longwe in prision ... sfiso must express himself on that way with emotions.
We all see the judge is winking, answering, for the state witness interfering, distract, defence lawyers can't u do sumthing adv this old man is annoying too much
Happy Sunday ntate Thulo, it has always been apparent and obvious that Ratha has already written the judgement.
Going back to Zungu to fetching the notes from KZN before he came back Ratha had already written the ruling and he said himself, we saw it coming when he admitted the confessions as well that he has already convicted these guys.
Question remains, what then happens with the mastermind? What laws will he base himself on when the state case seems to be so weak? Why waste time and tax payers money continuing with this sharade? Is it because he's to follow the protocol to the end?
Appeal is loading we trust God to deal with all the wicked the way He wills.
Adv dont be an alarmist, the judge will make a fair judgement i can assure you. The hudgement can go either way.
Remember the ruling he made concerning magistrate Cronje's recording in the confession statement. What do you say about?
The conviction was discussed somewhere, the bad part of it is these young men will be convicted I think as a judge he can not preside over a case where other witnesses are hindered to come to court even the master mind, the case is about mastermind and her hit men but really it's sad
@@thaddeusndebele6880They will never talk about that because it doesn’t fix their narrative. Now no one is talking about that recording. That judge has the accused on record talking and telling her everything.
Let us hope so.
Judge Ratha knows what is said on these UA-cam channels and all the ,"experts" I can just imagine what his remarks are to an "advocate" like you.😅
Thank you.
U walter gave ratha that mandate
You are lying and misleading to say Judge has already made judgement. You do this because you have certain narrative of your own judgement. Judge Ratha responded to Advocate Mnisi based on the argument he has made regarding the police form should be used when taking statement. Judge Ratha explained and also gave example of certain judgement. Don't mislead people because of your narrative.
It’s what he does on this channel all for views. A judge doesn’t always give reasons for his order but will write the reasons in his judgement. It’s simple law. This guy behaves like he is not an advocate
@@ncutshe01 well said.!! I wonder if this advocate would like to hear his clients talk bad about him behind his back.
Ratha is one of the best judges in south africa and no appeal ever stood on cases presided by him.
This is a judge who knows the law and you can tell the way he knows and reads the case laws is like a hobby to him.