Heard this on Radio 3 just now in the car. Had to find out what it was as it was just so bad. Sounds like the Kho San Road in Bangkok at rush hour. Composer should have her degree taken away.
I like that you've sought it out on You Tube and found my modest offering which presumably cemented your view. I didn't know the composer or the work but I have great respect for the musical taste of the conductor, and when I saw it was a 30 minute performance of a contemporary (new?) work I thought it would be worth seeing/hearing. I was very happy I went to the concert, although the noise of the audience in the first work threatened to turn it into a 'concerto for unmuffled coughers', and the applause between movements which felt obligatory rather than inspired in the Tchaikovsky, the third to fourth movement notwithstanding, tested my concentration. The recording engineers really do a splendid job in that great hall, despite the efforts of the great unwashed.
"This channel is dedicated to writing and analysing music based upon the method outlined in the book The Modal Method of Music. By using a simple mathematical process, even the most complex music can be understood at a level unsurpassed in music theory. From J. S. Bach to Jazz, the Modal Method of Music reveals both the thought processes of the composer and the hidden world within the music itself." You, Sir, are off your rocker. As Dan Reynolds used to say "... all methods lead to the eventual recognition of the failure of our methods." I suggest an afternoon with Helmholtz before wading into these waters again kind sir.
@@MrKurtank Naturally the channel run by the pos(t)er of the comment I am replying to. I, for one, am glad you posted this curious work for orchestra, which to my ears is a rather clean exploration of rational intonation - which is mathematics at the simplest level . Why I was quoting @TheModalMethodofMusic-fu1qr channel page description is that they seem to claim some authority on the mathematical analyses of music. Clearly, this isn't the case and I think Helmholtz is good place to start if one wishes to analyze work in the 21st Century that deals in pure number ratios. Also, I stopped analyzing compositions from my car stereo in the early 80s, so it is just hard to take comments like @TheModalMethodofMusic-fu1qr seriously. I do hope they improve their knowledge of contemporary music before taking the time to denigrate younger composers. To quote Dan Reynolds again - "Once your reputation is done, its time for a life of fun."
Saw this comment just now in the studio. Had to find out who the commenter is because the comment is just so pointless and deliberately deceitful. Reads like anonymous online hate speech. Commenter should have his/her channel taken away.
Another absolute banger.
Terrific
It’compelling
After listening to this Read the Book of Revelations
Heard this on Radio 3 just now in the car. Had to find out what it was as it was just so bad. Sounds like the Kho San Road in Bangkok at rush hour. Composer should have her degree taken away.
I like that you've sought it out on You Tube and found my modest offering which presumably cemented your view. I didn't know the composer or the work but I have great respect for the musical taste of the conductor, and when I saw it was a 30 minute performance of a contemporary (new?) work I thought it would be worth seeing/hearing. I was very happy I went to the concert, although the noise of the audience in the first work threatened to turn it into a 'concerto for unmuffled coughers', and the applause between movements which felt obligatory rather than inspired in the Tchaikovsky, the third to fourth movement notwithstanding, tested my concentration. The recording engineers really do a splendid job in that great hall, despite the efforts of the great unwashed.
"This channel is dedicated to writing and analysing music based upon the method outlined in the book The Modal Method of Music. By using a simple mathematical process, even the most complex music can be understood at a level unsurpassed in music theory. From J. S. Bach to Jazz, the Modal Method of Music reveals both the thought processes of the composer and the hidden world within the music itself."
You, Sir, are off your rocker. As Dan Reynolds used to say "... all methods lead to the eventual recognition of the failure of our methods." I suggest an afternoon with Helmholtz before wading into these waters again kind sir.
?! Which channel are we talking about? @@jacklunetti8850
@@MrKurtank Naturally the channel run by the pos(t)er of the comment I am replying to. I, for one, am glad you posted this curious work for orchestra, which to my ears is a rather clean exploration of rational intonation - which is mathematics at the simplest level . Why I was quoting @TheModalMethodofMusic-fu1qr channel page description is that they seem to claim some authority on the mathematical analyses of music. Clearly, this isn't the case and I think Helmholtz is good place to start if one wishes to analyze work in the 21st Century that deals in pure number ratios.
Also, I stopped analyzing compositions from my car stereo in the early 80s, so it is just hard to take comments like @TheModalMethodofMusic-fu1qr seriously. I do hope they improve their knowledge of contemporary music before taking the time to denigrate younger composers. To quote Dan Reynolds again - "Once your reputation is done, its time for a life of fun."
Saw this comment just now in the studio. Had to find out who the commenter is because the comment is just so pointless and deliberately deceitful. Reads like anonymous online hate speech. Commenter should have his/her channel taken away.