Army dont mind pointing out imperfections because we know the reasons for them - intensive choreo, singing live no matter the health status etc. As for solo careers - BTS is one of very few groups where every member is free to have their own music and no one tells them how their music should sound, they have free reign, which is amazing! but they all prioritize the group. Official contract is till 2027,but they can resign if they want to. These people genuinely like each other, so we're not too worried
@Biss am Bais their first contract expired in 2020, by that moment they'd already signed another 7yr one which came into power AFTER the first one expired. They resigned early, yes, but that doesnt change the duration of each contract
@Biss am Bais if you google "when does bts contract end" literally the first result is 2026, BigHit made that announcement through Forbes and Billboard had articles too
Yeah I really love the way they have so much more freedom then most other artists and they're allowed to do these things. Then again though looks like they will be diving more into solo careers🤐. Of course we know not for good though, but while they're taking a break from so much intense and exhausting group promotions that have worn them out. It's well needed though I feel bad that I didn't completely see this coming. Of course I thought about them needing a break but it was still a little shocking to see how much they REALLY needed one after hearing and seeing them say so themselves. And seeing how exhausted and worn out they really were😔. I'm glad it's not for good though and that it isn't because they're being forced to do anything, but because THEY personally, after much thought, made this decision to focus more on themselves while still wanting to be BTS in the end! Couldn't be happier this is the way it turned out.😊💜
One thing you have to remember; most of the live reactions you've done of them are them singing after a LOT of dancing and singing from the earlier songs from the concerts. Seriously, if you look at their live medleys, they dance so much that you get worried that their bodies will fall apart. And then they put in these calmer songs to help them ease off the tension.
they've all lived together 9-10 years, depending on when each member joined. they've discussed many times that they're so happy and lucky that they're together because they wouldn't be able to do it alone. because they have creative freedom, they get to express themeselves both through bts songs and solo mixtapes and songs. they're not one of those bands that was just put together and secretly hate each other or feel suffocated in the group. i don't think they could do it solo without each other haha. about the pitch thing, no we don't mind! i can hear them being slightly off key every now and then myself so obviously pointing that out is no problem, it's only natural that they aren't perfect. especially with the choreo! it becomes a problem when people will use some pitchy vocals to try to prove that they can't sing and are always lipsyncing or autotuned whenever they do sing on key. as if a note off key is somehow "exposing" them lmao. there's so much footage of them singing perfectly on key acapella :) thank you for the reaction, i'm always wanting more bts from you haha!
Yea that is true...though obviously things have changed just a little. It's interesting thinking about when we used to think that now since theyre going to be doing solo albums. We really should have saw it coming with all the immerse pressure mentally and physically from so many group activities for all these years. I'm glad and happy for them though, much more than i thought i would if they ever did mostly or all solo stuff. And I'm glad this didn't happen and this decision wasn't made because they hate each other and arent going solo for good and it's just a well needed break from so many group promotions
Yea that is true...though obviously things have changed just a little. It's interesting thinking about when we used to think that now since theyre going to be doing solo albums. We really should have saw it coming with all the immerse pressure mentally and physically from so many group activities for all these years. I'm glad and happy for them though, much more than i thought i would if they ever did mostly or all solo stuff. And I'm glad this didn't happen and this decision wasn't made because they hate each other and arent going solo for good and it's just a well needed break from so many group promotions
Dude no one should shred you for pointing out how they're off key. Anyone with ears can hear it. lol. Much love for continuing to be open to reacting to foreign artists like BTS.
I agree and true fans will not do that if there is a true mistake - What I really enjoy about your reactions is that you talk about the actual singing - I wondered how he got back on point - you explained it - no other reaction I have listed to did that - truth is the best!
Thank you for being fair to V. A lot of reactors seldom consider how good he really is as a singer and over-all performer. Many people think just because he is a baritone, his technique is easy to replicate.
They have lived together for so long that they really can't live without each other more than couple of days. I think they bought their own apertment to train for that.. Because we know there is probably coming to that inevitable separation for a while for them, starting Jin and Suga, who only have that 4 months age separation.. :/
since they all release solo projects (musical or otherwise) pretty often, i'm sure their careers will flourish even after bts. all 7 are such powerhouses! acting, singing, dancing, rapping, producing, writing; very talented group. one of the members, suga, even produces for other artists and has won awards for those songs. i feel like bts is one of the few acts that has shown that it's possible to be your own entitity within a group. i saw an interview with nick jonas where he said he went to see bts at rosebowl and he was fascinated by the fact that each member had their own solo stage within the concert. it shows how you can still be your own person and do your own thing without having to choose between self or team. and as always, love your bts reactions! your explanations are so thoughtful and imformative. i feel like bts get a lot of flack when they perform live and it isn't absolutely perfect. you always approach these situations with great care and professionalism.
They can go this high with being a group, at this point it would be so lonely to go solo with the fame, pressure and stuff, this way they can lean on each other, being solo must be really stressfull.
Before you go further you might want to review their solo work. I might suggest RM'S early Do You, Suga as AgustD ' s most recent Dechwita, JHOPE'S Ego. Big Hit was the first in So. Korea to encourage their artists to write, produce, and direct their own projects.
Well Taehyung has always said that individuality is important like always even if it's interview or anything and also if you have seen latest interview released by bighit for 8th anniversary of BTS they asked all members questions career... And all other members replied BTS but V replied " i will make it from now on" so now you can see how much individuality matters to Taehyung it means his solo career... They can make solo career while being in BTS also
No worries pointing out imperfections. Jimin is my bias. I find his voice the most moving. I think of it as piercing. Just has that ability to give you goosebumps. That said, I think he's struggled the most with stability and pitch. It's heartbreaking because he's hard on himself for those imperfections. And it's nerve wracking sometimes when I know there's a particular note coming up and I don't know if he's going to hit it or fall flat, so to speak. Confidence also plays a part. He can't get out of his own head it seems. He's definitely grown as a singer and is an inspiring example of someone who didn't set out in life to be a singer or even begin with an abundance of natural singing talent, but trained to become better. Jin and V are great examples of that too. JK has definitely improved as well, but seems to have better innate control over his voice from the very beginning, before learning any formal technique. There's a really bittersweet behind the scenes moment where JK is trying to coach Jimin on how to make a particular sound, how to place his tongue in his mouth, and it's just not working. They both realize that it's easy for JK, but Jimin can't produce that same sound even when following JK's guidance. There's either more to the technique than tongue placement or it just doesn't work for him in particular, whatever the case may be. But it's like this stark contrast between them that frustrates them both; Jimin wanting it to be easier, JK wishing he could just share his own ability since he hates seeing Jimin struggle.
It’s so sad :( but I know they always try their best and support eachother I just hope jimin will not be hard on himself it’s just breaks my heart :( 🥺💔
Jimin's voice is so beautiful when he is on key, that we don't mind the occasional off-key notes. I actually enjoy these moments, because it shows he is very human.
This minute 9:12 He said it doesn't matter, it means clearly he said JK's voice was offkey because JK didn't match Jimin's highnote At the time he said offkey
This song was performed right after a segment with choreo. Look at how much they're sweating and how hard they're breathing. You will always notice the most vocal imperfections from them right after they've danced or during a a segment with choreo. They have little bottles of compressed oxygen backstage that they all need when changing clothes because they are doing so much choreo and singing at the same time that they literally collapse when they're off stage. And don't think they're forced to this either. They choose to to it because this is what they love.
Going solo? Of course it's possible, they have spoke about how they thought about disbanding because of the pressure they felt in 2018, but I don't think that wanting solo careers would be a reason if that happens, because they already have their solo careers even while being in the group, It's not something common but they make it work RM has two successful mixtapes, had created songs for other artists, have done music and stage collabs with others and even performed on a festival after the release of his first mixtape Suga has won awards for his work as a producer for other artists and his own mixtapes are really successful JHope's mixtape and collabs made him the most listened and followed Korean soloist in Spotify The singers produce, compose and write songs and also make covers, all of them have released solo songs, V have acted on a Korean drama and with Jin they made the OST, JK works on video editing on his studio and directed BTS' MV for Life Goes On, they are always breaking each other's records Also they still keep the group's apartment even if all of them have their own place now and of course they're all shareholders of BigHit company I really hope they keep doing music together for a long time, even after de military service
Exactly how I feel! I hope they continue making music together for a very long time. Just like Jimin said, he wanted them to sing together even after they can't dance anymore. They can just sit and sing, and armys will continue love and support them. T_T
@@tigerlilyem-o9s Yeah If that what they want, I hope it can go as they wish. Sometimes I just think about all those songs that I haven't heard live, I'm from small country in South America so I just have in mind that maybe I will not have the opportunity to go to a concert (Brazil was my only chance but it's so difficult to get tickets lmao) Hope they can still go on world tours for as long as they want
We wouldn't get angry at you pointing out someone being off key. We know they're human, so we don't expect them to be perfect all the time! Of course it's normal to make mistakes. It's another story when people start to shit on them, and use this kind of thing to say they can't song or whatever. Your approach and comments are always constructive and informative, so I appreciate that a lot. Thanks!
They love each other so much to leave and go solo They do mixtapes and solo songs while bieng Bts at the same time so they don't need it but maybe if they disband one day they might continue as solo
nice reaction! i really dont mind imperfections bwing pointed out. makes bts more human haha 😅 By the way, this month BTS is celebrating their 8th anniversary according to their official debut date 💜
Wow, thanks for this, I've been an army for over a year and thought I'd watched and listened to nearly everything but not seen this performance! I think I've never personally heard anyone in the fandom talking about this song!
i honestly really can’t imagine one particular member of bts just leaving while the others stay together like what happened with one direction. they’ve known each other for practically a decade and have such a genuine connection that you really can’t fake. i think that they all have unique sound and writing style which they could all use to go solo if they wanted but they already put out a lot of solo work which allows them to express their individuality. i can definitely see some members choosing to continue a music career after their disbandment while others not doing so, but i don’t think one would just leave. one of the rappers suga had to leave due to a shoulder injury for a few months and it really changed the tone of the group and it was visible that they felt less complete without him. they even said it themselves that when suga was gone for only a few months the group was really struggling.
Thank you for honest reactions. One hears he is off key so your mentioning it is nothing short of honesty. Since some get annoyed, and rightly so, when they are called machines, here is proof that they are not.
It would be interesting if you reacted to some bts lyrics, some of my favorites are intro: persona, epiphany and blue & gray you could also react to the rap line, bts debuted as a hip hop group and their rap line is the one who mainly writes and composes the songs for BTS, Namjoon has more than 170 credits (not counting production credits), he is a genius with an IQ 148 and he is a great poet
Speaking of Jin and Jimin sounding like one, and speaking of multiple layers of vocal from one source, I would love to hear your analysis of Mongolian throat singing.
constructive criticism is always welcome! everyone makes mistakes, so do they and there's nothing wrong in pointing it out and it's a learning experience for all of us to know how to better manage such problems and etc!
Really really appreciate your reactions. It's just really obvious that you react fairly and embrace all sorts of music and performance as it is. Not just this but also with the Dionysus reaction. Personally, I really don't care if you point out any mistakes. They're not perfect. Especially like you did here where you explained what really happened. Many youtubers are just really scared and have to cover themselves and I'm tired of hearing it lol. Really enjoy your comments, so thank you!
They have solo works but to totally go solo and leave bts is not the idea of any of the members. Thats even make them more different than other , few members have even said some times that they can't even think about doing anything alone. They are eachother strength and weakness. So if they can't even imagine of doing work alone. They have very special bond together. Members have even wished to work together for 30,40 years. They literally said that out of 365 day they are together for 360 days. And they even are said to be like old married couples. Who gets adjusted and know every thing about eachother
That was really interesting, hearing the technical side of being off key. It never occurred to me that you can be off key and NOT compromise vocal technique. I thought being off key WAS compromising vocal technique, though I’m not really sure why I thought that. Just the impressions of someone outside the field of vocal performance I guess. I work the pre-show end of entertainment/performance in design & production, so it’s always interesting to learn about what’s happening onstage (or alternatively, the pre-show work done by vocal performers). I very much appreciate you sharing your insight, experience, and expertise with us! 💜BTS ARMY
The rappers already have solo albums! j-hope released "Hope World" in 2018, RM released "mono." also in 2018 and Suga is working solo under alias AgustD and released 2 albums already, one in 2016 and one in 2020. Some of the members also released singles and did some collabs, there's a lot, so I won't go into details ;)
Most of the live concert videos are in a Japan concert. They sing songs in Japanese concerts that they would not sing in a regular concert. The fact that they make and sing songs just for the Japanese ARMY is very impressive to me. How many singers sing in three different languages with such ease. Love them and I got tickets for their LA concert yay
This was very educational. I have to admit I came here cause I see those „off key“ moments with Jimin sometimes and I want to understand what happens. I observe this more at the end of shows or concerts. He than sometimes doesn’t sing a note or he seems a bit stressed when he sings one bit couldn’t get there ... but he is also someone who gives 200% on stage so no wonder 😅 I think you are entitled to say something about their voices techniques etc since it’s just facts. Army need to learn that BTS can be off key or make mistakes too. I mean the guys know how they sing .... it’s nothing we need to protect them over. Thank you for being honest. Also , go solo T.T. I don’t think one of them could ever leave them... maybe cause it’s too much but never to go solo. Nah Never. But they do their solo stuff so no need 😂 V and JK would never get It done anyway and they all need RM for lyrics 😂
Jimin was often offkey on these old clips. Now he is much better thanks to covid and quarantine. You should definitely check the newer ones out, they all improved so much. I think they had many vocal lesson during this time.
This minute 9:12 He said it doesn't matter, it means clearly he said JK's voice was offkey because JK didn't match Jimin's highnote At the time he said offkey
No one gonna shred u, bcs we love honest n professional opinions like you.. we appreciate it .. also it’s prove that they are human 😅😅 cause we sometimes doubt they arent😅
It's totally ok to point things like them being off pitch cause we know too. Thanks for breaking the technique and reasoning behind all that though because I didn't know any of that! I thought it was just simply being out of tune. And we KNOW they can get really worn out from concerts. They're very professional though and try to hide it while on stage but they release a lot of behind the scenes footage and we can see them on the point of collapse as soon as they're out of sight of the audience. They even have little oxygen tanks to help them recover. And sometimes they'll be sore and in pain, but once the time is up, they'll drag themselves back on stage and push through the rest of the performances without any sign of pain or fatigue. They're truly devoted to their art and performances
There will always be some pitch issues during concerts because they perform for at least 3h non-stop every day while having very heavy choreography and constant practice performances. On another note, can you please check out MAMAMOO? They are insanely good live singers. Please check-out MAMAMOO killing voice performance
BTS are like the last group that would ever go solo lol. There's not one member who has said that they want to and plus they all release solo work whenever they feel like it while still being part of the band. Also something about the description of them as "machine like" and "technically perfect" really bothers me and gives off oriealentist vibes. These people are human and put a lot of hard work and passion into their music and performances, but people see this level of professionalism and tie it to "manufactured" yet people rarely say the same for western artists such as MJ who also dance and give amazing performances with amazing vocals.
If I'm recalling correctly... BangPD, their CEO, gave RM the option of going solo or staying with BTS... he chose BTS. They all have solo projects that they release FOR FREE on SoundCloud. And yes.... they go off key sometimes, which I kind of like since it shows they are human and also... that they are singing live. :) Also... Jimin is a perfectionist and will beat himself up after a show if he makes mistakes :( He's a lot better about it now, but he used to be SUPER hard on himself.
@@reneezemlock7880 yep your right he didnt know. One of those unnecessary pranks, as you can clearly see he is distressed at the end. You have probably seen the full version but if not, its is included in the Mnet 4 things show Ep3 Rap Monster ytube.
@@gerriberri.4412 I've seen it. It stresses me out even knowing it's a prank. Same thing when they prank JK before his birthday surprise by making him think he's in trouble for not hitting his mark. The fact that he's so relieved when he finds out everyone was faking that he cries. T_T
@@reneezemlock7880 oh god yes, the jk birthday one. It stresses me too, cause they were so young, fragile and I dont get why humiliating them is deemed as funny. Don't even get me started on the AH kidnapping one!! On a lighter note I was lucky enuf to watch the 2day muster concerts live and really enjoyed it. Did you see either? Have a great day 💜
About solo thing that you asked i think it will be V who will go solo first becz for him individuality is very very very important but also I don't think BTS will ever disband
Hello…thank you for “continuing to learn more about BTS”. I did subscribe and would like to see your reaction to Ugh by the three rappers of BTS..RM. Suga & JHope.💜💜💜💜💜💜🇺🇸
They're not perfect, they won't have perfect pitch, it's perfectly normal to point these flaws out. You're a vocal coach, it's literally your job, thank you for doing so.
Yes, someone in the feed said it was Jimin, but he was definitely referencing Jungkook as being off key - he replayed the clip at least three times to illustrate. Unfortunately, he used the name given to him in the stream (incorrectly).
This minute 9:12 He said it doesn't matter, it means clearly he said JK's voice was offkey because JK didn't match Jimin's highnote At the time he said offkey
I think it's good to point out the pitch problem. Otherwise you're filtering your reaction and aren't as interesting to me. Super cool to hear about how he adjusts!
BTS has already responded to these biased criticisms, " After you have done what I have, then throw that stone", Bulletproof Pt 2. . Or the entire lyric of "UGH" . All stay well
Your reaction is nice but why is everyone in your chat so shitty. Nobody will go solo, BTS love singing together and want to stay together forever. Also when you actually sing live every time you slip. Kpop dont know it bc idols all lipsynch
When it comes to giving criticism on BTS, there are a lot of presumably young fans who think they are perfect and should not be criticised. I think you should say it anyways! Jimin was definitely struggling here. Their tours are relentless so no wonder they struggle sometimes!
Army dont mind pointing out imperfections because we know the reasons for them - intensive choreo, singing live no matter the health status etc.
As for solo careers - BTS is one of very few groups where every member is free to have their own music and no one tells them how their music should sound, they have free reign, which is amazing! but they all prioritize the group. Official contract is till 2027,but they can resign if they want to. These people genuinely like each other, so we're not too worried
@Biss am Bais their first contract expired in 2020, by that moment they'd already signed another 7yr one which came into power AFTER the first one expired. They resigned early, yes, but that doesnt change the duration of each contract
@Biss am Bais if you google "when does bts contract end" literally the first result is 2026, BigHit made that announcement through Forbes and Billboard had articles too
@Biss am Bais links please
@Biss am Bais OK, thank you!
Yeah I really love the way they have so much more freedom then most other artists and they're allowed to do these things. Then again though looks like they will be diving more into solo careers🤐. Of course we know not for good though, but while they're taking a break from so much intense and exhausting group promotions that have worn them out. It's well needed though I feel bad that I didn't completely see this coming. Of course I thought about them needing a break but it was still a little shocking to see how much they REALLY needed one after hearing and seeing them say so themselves. And seeing how exhausted and worn out they really were😔. I'm glad it's not for good though and that it isn't because they're being forced to do anything, but because THEY personally, after much thought, made this decision to focus more on themselves while still wanting to be BTS in the end! Couldn't be happier this is the way it turned out.😊💜
One thing you have to remember; most of the live reactions you've done of them are them singing after a LOT of dancing and singing from the earlier songs from the concerts. Seriously, if you look at their live medleys, they dance so much that you get worried that their bodies will fall apart. And then they put in these calmer songs to help them ease off the tension.
they've all lived together 9-10 years, depending on when each member joined. they've discussed many times that they're so happy and lucky that they're together because they wouldn't be able to do it alone. because they have creative freedom, they get to express themeselves both through bts songs and solo mixtapes and songs. they're not one of those bands that was just put together and secretly hate each other or feel suffocated in the group. i don't think they could do it solo without each other haha.
about the pitch thing, no we don't mind! i can hear them being slightly off key every now and then myself so obviously pointing that out is no problem, it's only natural that they aren't perfect. especially with the choreo! it becomes a problem when people will use some pitchy vocals to try to prove that they can't sing and are always lipsyncing or autotuned whenever they do sing on key. as if a note off key is somehow "exposing" them lmao. there's so much footage of them singing perfectly on key acapella :)
thank you for the reaction, i'm always wanting more bts from you haha!
Exactly!💜👏
Yea that is true...though obviously things have changed just a little. It's interesting thinking about when we used to think that now since theyre going to be doing solo albums. We really should have saw it coming with all the immerse pressure mentally and physically from so many group activities for all these years. I'm glad and happy for them though, much more than i thought i would if they ever did mostly or all solo stuff. And I'm glad this didn't happen and this decision wasn't made because they hate each other and arent going solo for good and it's just a well needed break from so many group promotions
Yea that is true...though obviously things have changed just a little. It's interesting thinking about when we used to think that now since theyre going to be doing solo albums. We really should have saw it coming with all the immerse pressure mentally and physically from so many group activities for all these years. I'm glad and happy for them though, much more than i thought i would if they ever did mostly or all solo stuff. And I'm glad this didn't happen and this decision wasn't made because they hate each other and arent going solo for good and it's just a well needed break from so many group promotions
Dude no one should shred you for pointing out how they're off key. Anyone with ears can hear it. lol. Much love for continuing to be open to reacting to foreign artists like BTS.
They're off key it wasn't as soothing as it should be but they're damn tired😔
I agree and true fans will not do that if there is a true mistake - What I really enjoy about your reactions is that you talk about the actual singing - I wondered how he got back on point - you explained it - no other reaction I have listed to did that - truth is the best!
Thank you for being fair to V. A lot of reactors seldom consider how good he really is as a singer and over-all performer. Many people think just because he is a baritone, his technique is easy to replicate.
Agree💜
Who’d go solo? You’d have to pry them away from each other with a crowbar 😂
They have lived together for so long that they really can't live without each other more than couple of days. I think they bought their own apertment to train for that.. Because we know there is probably coming to that inevitable separation for a while for them, starting Jin and Suga, who only have that 4 months age separation.. :/
since they all release solo projects (musical or otherwise) pretty often, i'm sure their careers will flourish even after bts. all 7 are such powerhouses! acting, singing, dancing, rapping, producing, writing; very talented group. one of the members, suga, even produces for other artists and has won awards for those songs. i feel like bts is one of the few acts that has shown that it's possible to be your own entitity within a group. i saw an interview with nick jonas where he said he went to see bts at rosebowl and he was fascinated by the fact that each member had their own solo stage within the concert. it shows how you can still be your own person and do your own thing without having to choose between self or team.
and as always, love your bts reactions! your explanations are so thoughtful and imformative. i feel like bts get a lot of flack when they perform live and it isn't absolutely perfect. you always approach these situations with great care and professionalism.
😅I feel like they are too in love with each other to go solo😂
They can go this high with being a group, at this point it would be so lonely to go solo with the fame, pressure and stuff, this way they can lean on each other, being solo must be really stressfull.
They have said its very lonely when being solo.
Before you go further you might want to review their solo work. I might suggest RM'S early Do You, Suga as AgustD ' s most recent Dechwita, JHOPE'S Ego. Big Hit was the first in So. Korea to encourage their artists to write, produce, and direct their own projects.
Well Taehyung has always said that individuality is important like always even if it's interview or anything and also if you have seen latest interview released by bighit for 8th anniversary of BTS they asked all members questions career... And all other members replied BTS but V replied " i will make it from now on" so now you can see how much individuality matters to Taehyung it means his solo career... They can make solo career while being in BTS also
they do go solo, there are individual mixtapes outside of BTS.
RM just dropped a solo song ‘Bicycle’ a couple of hours ago - free music as part of Festa.
i love their musters, Japanese Armys are very sweet and super respectful so they deserve everything they have
No worries pointing out imperfections. Jimin is my bias. I find his voice the most moving. I think of it as piercing. Just has that ability to give you goosebumps. That said, I think he's struggled the most with stability and pitch. It's heartbreaking because he's hard on himself for those imperfections. And it's nerve wracking sometimes when I know there's a particular note coming up and I don't know if he's going to hit it or fall flat, so to speak. Confidence also plays a part. He can't get out of his own head it seems. He's definitely grown as a singer and is an inspiring example of someone who didn't set out in life to be a singer or even begin with an abundance of natural singing talent, but trained to become better. Jin and V are great examples of that too. JK has definitely improved as well, but seems to have better innate control over his voice from the very beginning, before learning any formal technique. There's a really bittersweet behind the scenes moment where JK is trying to coach Jimin on how to make a particular sound, how to place his tongue in his mouth, and it's just not working. They both realize that it's easy for JK, but Jimin can't produce that same sound even when following JK's guidance. There's either more to the technique than tongue placement or it just doesn't work for him in particular, whatever the case may be. But it's like this stark contrast between them that frustrates them both; Jimin wanting it to be easier, JK wishing he could just share his own ability since he hates seeing Jimin struggle.
It’s so sad :( but I know they always try their best and support eachother I just hope jimin will not be hard on himself it’s just breaks my heart :( 🥺💔
Jimin's voice is so beautiful when he is on key, that we don't mind the occasional off-key notes. I actually enjoy these moments, because it shows he is very human.
This minute 9:12 He said it doesn't matter, it means clearly he said JK's voice was offkey because JK didn't match Jimin's highnote At the time he said offkey
This song was performed right after a segment with choreo. Look at how much they're sweating and how hard they're breathing. You will always notice the most vocal imperfections from them right after they've danced or during a a segment with choreo. They have little bottles of compressed oxygen backstage that they all need when changing clothes because they are doing so much choreo and singing at the same time that they literally collapse when they're off stage. And don't think they're forced to this either. They choose to to it because this is what they love.
“Go solo” lmao they can release solo music and still be in the group 😪
Going solo? Of course it's possible, they have spoke about how they thought about disbanding because of the pressure they felt in 2018, but I don't think that wanting solo careers would be a reason if that happens, because they already have their solo careers even while being in the group, It's not something common but they make it work
RM has two successful mixtapes, had created songs for other artists, have done music and stage collabs with others and even performed on a festival after the release of his first mixtape
Suga has won awards for his work as a producer for other artists and his own mixtapes are really successful
JHope's mixtape and collabs made him the most listened and followed Korean soloist in Spotify
The singers produce, compose and write songs and also make covers, all of them have released solo songs, V have acted on a Korean drama and with Jin they made the OST, JK works on video editing on his studio and directed BTS' MV for Life Goes On, they are always breaking each other's records
Also they still keep the group's apartment even if all of them have their own place now and of course they're all shareholders of BigHit company
I really hope they keep doing music together for a long time, even after de military service
Exactly how I feel! I hope they continue making music together for a very long time. Just like Jimin said, he wanted them to sing together even after they can't dance anymore. They can just sit and sing, and armys will continue love and support them. T_T
@@tigerlilyem-o9s Yeah If that what they want, I hope it can go as they wish. Sometimes I just think about all those songs that I haven't heard live, I'm from small country in South America so I just have in mind that maybe I will not have the opportunity to go to a concert (Brazil was my only chance but it's so difficult to get tickets lmao) Hope they can still go on world tours for as long as they want
They're focusing on their solo career for now but they're gonna come back as a group soon💜
We wouldn't get angry at you pointing out someone being off key. We know they're human, so we don't expect them to be perfect all the time! Of course it's normal to make mistakes. It's another story when people start to shit on them, and use this kind of thing to say they can't song or whatever. Your approach and comments are always constructive and informative, so I appreciate that a lot. Thanks!
broooo, these men love being together so much that they signed a contract for 7 more years (their previous contract ended last year)
They love each other so much to leave and go solo
They do mixtapes and solo songs while bieng Bts at the same time so they don't need it but maybe if they disband one day they might continue as solo
I love that you pointed out the professional way to correct your pitch when you land off on the first try
I recommed you to watch Your Eyes Tell, live for Japanese tv. This was written by JungKook and the song was chosen for a Japanese movie ost.
nice reaction! i really dont mind imperfections bwing pointed out. makes bts more human haha 😅 By the way, this month BTS is celebrating their 8th anniversary according to their official debut date 💜
Wow, thanks for this, I've been an army for over a year and thought I'd watched and listened to nearly everything but not seen this performance! I think I've never personally heard anyone in the fandom talking about this song!
i honestly really can’t imagine one particular member of bts just leaving while the others stay together like what happened with one direction. they’ve known each other for practically a decade and have such a genuine connection that you really can’t fake. i think that they all have unique sound and writing style which they could all use to go solo if they wanted but they already put out a lot of solo work which allows them to express their individuality. i can definitely see some members choosing to continue a music career after their disbandment while others not doing so, but i don’t think one would just leave. one of the rappers suga had to leave due to a shoulder injury for a few months and it really changed the tone of the group and it was visible that they felt less complete without him. they even said it themselves that when suga was gone for only a few months the group was really struggling.
Thank you for honest reactions. One hears he is off key so your mentioning it is nothing short of honesty.
Since some get annoyed, and rightly so, when they are called machines, here is proof that they are not.
It would be interesting if you reacted to some bts lyrics, some of my favorites are intro: persona, epiphany and blue & gray
you could also react to the rap line, bts debuted as a hip hop group and their rap line is the one who mainly writes and composes the songs for BTS, Namjoon has more than 170 credits (not counting production credits), he is a genius with an IQ 148 and he is a great poet
Jimin highnote is amazing
They do get tired. If you look closely, they are covered in sweat. This is a cool down song after a couple of fast dancing songs.
Speaking of Jin and Jimin sounding like one, and speaking of multiple layers of vocal from one source, I would love to hear your analysis of Mongolian throat singing.
constructive criticism is always welcome! everyone makes mistakes, so do they and there's nothing wrong in pointing it out and it's a learning experience for all of us to know how to better manage such problems and etc!
Really really appreciate your reactions. It's just really obvious that you react fairly and embrace all sorts of music and performance as it is. Not just this but also with the Dionysus reaction.
Personally, I really don't care if you point out any mistakes. They're not perfect. Especially like you did here where you explained what really happened. Many youtubers are just really scared and have to cover themselves and I'm tired of hearing it lol. Really enjoy your comments, so thank you!
I always enjoy your insights into the performances to which you react. 💜
They already do solo stuff while in BTS
They have solo works but to totally go solo and leave bts is not the idea of any of the members. Thats even make them more different than other , few members have even said some times that they can't even think about doing anything alone. They are eachother strength and weakness. So if they can't even imagine of doing work alone. They have very special bond together. Members have even wished to work together for 30,40 years.
They literally said that out of 365 day they are together for 360 days. And they even are said to be like old married couples. Who gets adjusted and know every thing about eachother
That was really interesting, hearing the technical side of being off key. It never occurred to me that you can be off key and NOT compromise vocal technique. I thought being off key WAS compromising vocal technique, though I’m not really sure why I thought that. Just the impressions of someone outside the field of vocal performance I guess. I work the pre-show end of entertainment/performance in design & production, so it’s always interesting to learn about what’s happening onstage (or alternatively, the pre-show work done by vocal performers).
I very much appreciate you sharing your insight, experience, and expertise with us!
💜BTS ARMY
The rappers already have solo albums! j-hope released "Hope World" in 2018, RM released "mono." also in 2018 and Suga is working solo under alias AgustD and released 2 albums already, one in 2016 and one in 2020. Some of the members also released singles and did some collabs, there's a lot, so I won't go into details ;)
Most of the live concert videos are in a Japan concert. They sing songs in Japanese concerts that they would not sing in a regular concert. The fact that they make and sing songs just for the Japanese ARMY is very impressive to me. How many singers sing in three different languages with such ease. Love them and I got tickets for their LA concert yay
This was very educational. I have to admit I came here cause I see those „off key“ moments with Jimin sometimes and I want to understand what happens. I observe this more at the end of shows or concerts. He than sometimes doesn’t sing a note or he seems a bit stressed when he sings one bit couldn’t get there ... but he is also someone who gives 200% on stage so no wonder 😅
I think you are entitled to say something about their voices techniques etc since it’s just facts. Army need to learn that BTS can be off key or make mistakes too. I mean the guys know how they sing .... it’s nothing we need to protect them over. Thank you for being honest.
Also , go solo T.T. I don’t think one of them could ever leave them... maybe cause it’s too much but never to go solo. Nah Never. But they do their solo stuff so no need 😂 V and JK would never get It done anyway and they all need RM for lyrics 😂
Jimin was often offkey on these old clips. Now he is much better thanks to covid and quarantine. You should definitely check the newer ones out, they all improved so much. I think they had many vocal lesson during this time.
This minute 9:12 He said it doesn't matter, it means clearly he said JK's voice was offkey because JK didn't match Jimin's highnote At the time he said offkey
One of my fav Japanese songs!
No one gonna shred u, bcs we love honest n professional opinions like you.. we appreciate it .. also it’s prove that they are human 😅😅 cause we sometimes doubt they arent😅
It's totally ok to point things like them being off pitch cause we know too. Thanks for breaking the technique and reasoning behind all that though because I didn't know any of that! I thought it was just simply being out of tune. And we KNOW they can get really worn out from concerts. They're very professional though and try to hide it while on stage but they release a lot of behind the scenes footage and we can see them on the point of collapse as soon as they're out of sight of the audience. They even have little oxygen tanks to help them recover. And sometimes they'll be sore and in pain, but once the time is up, they'll drag themselves back on stage and push through the rest of the performances without any sign of pain or fatigue. They're truly devoted to their art and performances
they would not go solo as much as i know ,but they will have solo mixtapes and songs that they would put out .
They do both, solo and group. They already release a lot of songs as a solo artist or unit
There will always be some pitch issues during concerts because they perform for at least 3h non-stop every day while having very heavy choreography and constant practice performances.
On another note, can you please check out MAMAMOO? They are insanely good live singers. Please check-out MAMAMOO killing voice performance
BTS are like the last group that would ever go solo lol. There's not one member who has said that they want to and plus they all release solo work whenever they feel like it while still being part of the band. Also something about the description of them as "machine like" and "technically perfect" really bothers me and gives off oriealentist vibes. These people are human and put a lot of hard work and passion into their music and performances, but people see this level of professionalism and tie it to "manufactured" yet people rarely say the same for western artists such as MJ who also dance and give amazing performances with amazing vocals.
If I'm recalling correctly... BangPD, their CEO, gave RM the option of going solo or staying with BTS... he chose BTS. They all have solo projects that they release FOR FREE on SoundCloud. And yes.... they go off key sometimes, which I kind of like since it shows they are human and also... that they are singing live. :) Also... Jimin is a perfectionist and will beat himself up after a show if he makes mistakes :( He's a lot better about it now, but he used to be SUPER hard on himself.
That clip of Bang PD making RM choose between going solo or BTS was a prank. Still, RM chose BTS without any hesitation.
@@rappyluvspuppy I know, but RM didn't know that in the moment :)
@@reneezemlock7880 yep your right he didnt know. One of those unnecessary pranks, as you can clearly see he is distressed at the end. You have probably seen the full version but if not, its is included in the Mnet 4 things show Ep3 Rap Monster ytube.
@@gerriberri.4412 I've seen it. It stresses me out even knowing it's a prank. Same thing when they prank JK before his birthday surprise by making him think he's in trouble for not hitting his mark. The fact that he's so relieved when he finds out everyone was faking that he cries. T_T
@@reneezemlock7880 oh god yes, the jk birthday one. It stresses me too, cause they were so young, fragile and I dont get why humiliating them is deemed as funny. Don't even get me started on the AH kidnapping one!!
On a lighter note I was lucky enuf to watch the 2day muster concerts live and really enjoyed it. Did you see either? Have a great day 💜
About solo thing that you asked i think it will be V who will go solo first becz for him individuality is very very very important but also I don't think BTS will ever disband
Hello…thank you for “continuing to learn more about BTS”. I did subscribe and would like to see your reaction to Ugh by the three rappers of BTS..RM. Suga & JHope.💜💜💜💜💜💜🇺🇸
They're not perfect, they won't have perfect pitch, it's perfectly normal to point these flaws out. You're a vocal coach, it's literally your job, thank you for doing so.
That was JK not Jimin. He does the most singing during a concert.
Yes, someone in the feed said it was Jimin, but he was definitely referencing Jungkook as being off key - he replayed the clip at least three times to illustrate. Unfortunately, he used the name given to him in the stream (incorrectly).
This minute 9:12 He said it doesn't matter, it means clearly he said JK's voice was offkey because JK didn't match Jimin's highnote At the time he said offkey
I didn't heard it before
BTS💜💜💜💜
actually most of their live songs such as this are done after like several dances and performances and that's why they look so tired.
next time please reaction bts medley performance this was legendary
Jimin's voice is realy high and unique
Yes there shows are all them there ,no other act,s
Pls.watch also LET GO japanese song also of bts.... its one of my favorite bts song ever also the choreograhy... amazing..
I think it's good to point out the pitch problem. Otherwise you're filtering your reaction and aren't as interesting to me. Super cool to hear about how he adjusts!
You were talking about Jimin singing off, but it was actually Jin you pointed out.
BTS has already responded to these biased criticisms, " After you have done what I have, then throw that stone", Bulletproof Pt 2. . Or the entire lyric of "UGH" . All stay well
Please react to BTS your eyes tell live eng sub
They do NOT perform every day. I wish people would stop passing on the misinformation. They mainly performed on the weekends on their stadium tour.
Please react Jungkook-My Time Live
Your reaction is nice but why is everyone in your chat so shitty. Nobody will go solo, BTS love singing together and want to stay together forever. Also when you actually sing live every time you slip. Kpop dont know it bc idols all lipsynch
I like how Charlie always just ignores the few passive aggressive BTS dislikers in his chat.
Plz react to jungkook singing in English
Plz react to
Jungkook If you cover by ( Mel Galarza)
Jungkook breath cover by Noona channel
When it comes to giving criticism on BTS, there are a lot of presumably young fans who think they are perfect and should not be criticised. I think you should say it anyways! Jimin was definitely struggling here. Their tours are relentless so no wonder they struggle sometimes!