이 노래는 처음부터 끝까지 너무 좋다.. 비트며 악기며 가사며 안무도.. 비원에이포 6년차 팬이지만, 이 노래가 너무 마음에 와닿는다. 특히 새벽에는 갬성때문에 미칠 것 같다. 목소리도 5명 다 최고다. 각각 파트에 딱 원하던 목소리 처음에 저노래 들었을때는 왜인지 모르겠지만 울었다. 멜로디가 심금을 울렸다. 대부분 가사때문에 울컥한 적은 있는데 멜로디때문에 울컥한 적은 난생 처음인 것 같다.. 정진영 최고.......
"Now I'll let you go into the bright sunlight, You belong there." B1A4 will forever be OT5 in our hearts but they all deserve a better future, even if they have to walk on different paths.
I say 다시 말하지만 우리의 인연은 여기까진 것 같아 you say 좋은 사람 꼭 만나 우리의 사랑은 생각보다 얕았나 보다 이렇게 우린 갈라져 틈이 갈라져 너를 등지고 돌아서는 내 모습은 초라하겠죠 내가 했던 말은 거짓말이야 떠나가란 말 다 거짓말이야 a lie a lie 내가 했던 말은 거짓말이야 제발 가지마 다 거짓말이야 a lie 모두 거짓말이기에 상처뿐인 말만 늘어놓고 뒤 돌아가 내일이면 다시 아무렇지 않게 살아가겠지만 너와 내 사이 운명 쉽게 끊을 수는 없다면 다시 돌아갈 수 있을까 예전의 모습처럼 환하게 웃던 미소가 눈물이 되어 흐르고 같이 부르던 이 노래가 내 맘을 적시고 점처럼 작아져 가는 그대 뒷모습 바라볼 때면 비가 내리며 나를 위로 해주네 슬픈 그대여 이렇게 우린 갈라져 틈이 갈라져 너를 등지고 돌아서는 내 모습은 초라하겠죠 내가 했던 말은 거짓말이야 떠나가란 말 다 거짓말이야 a lie a lie 내가 했던 말은 거짓말이야 제발 가지마 다 거짓말이야 a lie 모두 거짓말이기에 어둠 속에 묻혀있던 너의 미소 매일 암흑 속에 갇혀 있던 너란 햇빛 이젠 보내줄게 밝은 햇살 속에 네가 살고 있었다는 걸 언제나 힘없이 처져 있던 너의 그림자 항상 입술을 깨물며 고독하게 너는 혼자 고통을 참으며 눈물 삼키며 하루하루를 넌 괴롭게 보내잖아 내가 했던 말은 거짓말이야 제발 가지마 다 거짓말이야 a lie a lie 나를 떠나가 행복해 제발 더 행복해 나를 떠나가 행복해 제발 더 행복해 I say 다시 말하지만
I get the feeling of "lonely" at chorus part. Is it just me?? this song is so good. MV looks different from what they used to do. I think it is cool. Sandeul is so handsome.
I'm not even a Bana (even though ”My Love" and "Tried to Walk" give me life), but I've found myself watching this video at least 15 times a day. This is truly a beautiful song, and I hope they receive a lot of recognition! B1A4 is amazingly talented!! Bana fighting!
I can't even being to describe how much I love this song, it is truly a masterpiece, no matter how many times I listen to it I never stop feeling goosebumps, and the sorrow in it it's just beautiful, I absolutely love this, and I miss b1a4 so much, and the fact that Jinyoung is able to accomplish this Type of music without having studied music it's just out of this world. I Love B1A4
@@independent_owl706 are you talking about the classical musicians react vid? they did praise the song a lot! i always listen to this song when i feel down
B1A4 and Apink are much alike. They made comeback more than a year since the last album, with great MUSIC, but didn't get appreciated as it should be. This song, and Apink-Only One, are just so beautiful. This is music. NOT AHAHOHOHYIYAYIYA THING.
I will admit I haven't listened to B1A4 for sooooooooo long, and right now I am getting the shivers EVERYWHERE. It's one of the most beautiful songs I've heard
Glad you're back at "good timing", keep watching this M/V please ^^ If you have time, check other songs of the album Good Timing too, you will not regret.
Yurin Yoo I 100% relate with you.. they haven't made a comeback in so long so I haven't listen to their music for so long then I come to this and got shivers everywhere like this song is so good..
omg i feel you. even the last time i listened to them was when they were promoting Lonely. i'm so glad that this mv played on my autoplay, this song is sooo beautiful I even cried without knowing the lyrics
it's good that B1A4 got recognition from idols; jessica, jin, eunji did recommend this song. as expected, B1A4 has risen up once again with the marvelous concept as their comeback. good job WM Ent and the members themselves to participate in the making of the album! c': - sincerely, multifandom fangirl that is a bana as well
they've grown up a lot 😍😍😍 I've been their fan since OK released. they become mature by the time. they look super handsome 😍😍 CNU tho.. he looks extra handsome nowadays. can't wait for the live performance
I'm here after the news and I don't really know what to say, I wish that they could continue with five members but I'm happy that Jinyoung and Baro left in good terms. I've became a Bana 2012 when I was eleven years old and discovered K-pop, theses boys really change my life. They made songs that made me dance, cry and laugh and I'm so happy that I got the chance to see them 2015. They were amazing live and I'm glad that 3/5 is going to keep singing. Remember Bana, we got to stay strong and support ALL of the boys
@@n.y5345 hello, i like "good love" sing by the leader Jung Jinyoung, "only one" par le groupe, "misty road" par Jinyoung ( chanson de love in the moon light) c'est lui qui l'a produite. Si vous aimez mon choix, dites le moi et je vous donnerez d autres titres Bonne ecoute
I'm still here, miss this song this group, this misterpiece and the old kpop songs, that were perfect and has something special not only a good beat. I wish I could turn back time and apreciate much more than I did some years ago. That time I didn't know how life could be hard they made my life easily and happy. I will always love them for this
I'm so glad so many people are recognizing B1A4's talents aaaa they've been in the industry for a long time and they deserve everything nice I'm so proud of them
I agree! As a fan in the U.S. who speaks no Korean, I love their music and voices. They gave an OUTSTANDING concert with live band for over 2 hours in San Francisco 2014. They have fans everywhere and can fill concert halls around the world. Please send B1A4 on tour again! ❤️ 🌱
Well I didn't Know this band before ... recently I became a fan of Sandeul's voice on duet song festival then watched 'Love in the moonlight"and fall in love with Jinyoung's acting so charming ... This song is great indeed ... I'm getting to know the other's members talents ...! fighting B1A4
Cassandra Lopes guess you are the new kpopper?? In kpop, the company usually want the one who is the mostly well known member to get most air time. And jinyoung popularity atm is huge
simply beautiful! i'm not a bana, but i always supported them and loved their music! tbh nowdays i find kpop dissapointing...i dont like the music that rookie groups are releasing and old kpop groups are either in long ass hiatus, either disbanding. I'm so happy that finally a big name in kpop is coming back with such an amazing song! totally worth the waiting from an emo old kpoper
I love new group I love monstax, i love seventeen, i love sf9. But if someone ask me what your fandom, I will say that I'm BANA I'm will not say that i monbebe, carat, or fantasy cause boy group who always in my heart is B1A4. my love for B1A4 is bigger then that new group it's like whatever I go I will back to B1A4 I really love B1A4
Echa Cha I like other group and I try to like any group But still B1A4 is the best for me💕💞💞 They are different from the other group They are positive thinking guys, cheerfull, kind, innocent yet mature, and all words that refers to happiness They are the definition of Happy #비원에이포 #행복하자
i just recently watched The Dude In Me, Jinyoung's movie, and it made me miss him and the group. I won't ever forget the VERY first kpop group that I stanned and it's them. I miss them. *so much.*
Just saw OneK peace concert in Manila and B1A4 a big hit as expected. "Long time no see!" The boys told the crowd who laughed because B1A4 just had a concert in Manila last January! They didn't sing "Lie" perhaps because it's a sad song and they sang instead their jauntier hit songs and everybody loved them. Jinyeong and Baro were as expected the most popular although I heard my female seatmates remarking howthey found Jinyeong really better looking in person. Sandeul was a big hit when he sang solo the OST of Jinyeong's KBS historical drama. Gongchan wellliked too. But the ladies were really swooning over CNU who seemed too shy to acknowledge that he was causing too much oohs and ahhs. Which further endeared him to the girls. B1A4 really rocked and charmed Manila and they performed their usual best! Thank you, B1A4!
Last year, at the fans meeting, Jinyoung cried as he looked at his fans. This year, at the Live Space concerts, Jinyoung thanked his fans for supporting them and he broke down cried again, worrying that some of his fan might not support the B1A4 in the future. I think that he was indeed sincerely thankful for his fans and that he was so touched that his die hard fans were there at the concert to support them. But obviously, there are less B1A4 fans today compared to 2012. Look at their old songs, they got so many million views but today, the song A Lie only got about 2 million views. Why? I think that A lie is a beautiful song but it did not get more views. Look around, some okay songs got many million views in a short time because these groups got lots of fans to view their songs. I just hope that many people will come to know B1A4 from now on and their old fans will come back to support them and to re-discover how talented B1A4 is.
Okey, I just discovered B1A4 because of Jinyoung apperaing on a Netflix show. And Jesus, what a beautiful song 👏 I know there are now only 3 members left, wish them a good future 💛
y'all everything is so good about this album but i want to talk about 1. cnu's awesome hair 2. baro's rapping is stellar?? he's so underrated. b1a4 is so underrated.
뵤네포 진짜 좋은 노래들 많은데 알 사람들만 안다는게 너무 맘 아픔 이런 노래들은 모두가 들어야하는건데 우리만 알고 있기 너무 아까움🥺🥺🥺🥺 다들 음색도 좋고 노래도 다 좋음 진짜로 심지어 바로 랩도 잘하고 노래랑 잘 어울리고 가사도 진짜 좋음 이런 노래 모두가 다 듣게 해즈ㅜ새요 제발요 🥹🥹
1. Produce 101 - In The Same Place 2. Oh My Girl - One Steps Two Steps 3. I.O.I - When The Cherry Blossom Fade 4. Ben - Misty Road (Moonlight Drawn By Clouds OST) 5. I.O.I - Hold Up 6. B1A4 - It's A Lie 7. Good Timing (B1A4 FULL ALBUM - 12 Track) okay Jung Jinyoung thanks for make this year wonderful !!!! and R.I.P MY REPLAY BUTTON
You forgot "lab me lab me lab me lab me lab me beybeh" and we all did anyway haha. I hope they don't disband. They were the first KPOP group I ever got interested in. It would really be heartbreaking if they don't renew. 💔
i think b1A4 deserve to be more famous than the new groups because all they are handsome and jinyoung oppa write the Lyrics by himself and sandeul oppa has the best sound and seriously did you ever see some more handsome than gongchan? Of course you cant find and our cnu oppa his voice is beautiful like him and he can sing rap amazing right? and our rapper baro he cute and hot in the seem time and his rap so gooooood , i'm arab bana and Proud b1A4 is my Favorite group and once i be bana its mean forever bana b1A4 Fighting
b1a4 songs is piece of an art and it is very different with other song because it has their own uniqueness to present in every song. i must say this video ia beautiful and meaningful. This song also reminds me of their previous song which is 'tried to walk' and 'lonely'. B1A4 is so talented in the combining pop and melody where sad story is represented but at the same they never fail to cheer us with delightful music
I don’t know what to say... I will miss all of you being together... I will continuing to support all of you, no matter if you’re no longer together. I respect your decision and I love all of you guys. Thanks for blessing me with your wonderful songs and voices❤️😭 I thought I wasn’t going to cry, but here I am...
![[MV] B1A4 _ Sweet Girl](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5W7GSJ-4ZqQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![TAEMIN - GOODBYE Dance Cover (태민 - 댄스 커버) [WILDKARDZ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/bOWfb9krbzE/mqdefault.jpg)
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
The most underrated boyband i know, is really something.
Now I'm still here 2024
Not underrated during their prime years. They used to be famous though.
정진영이 진짜 천재긴 해... 갠적으로 비포가 진짜 저평가받은 아이돌중 하나라고 생각.. ㄹㅇ아티스트라고 불려도 손색없는데
맞아요...ㅠㅜ
비포는 회사가큐브여서그럼 포미닛도 좋은걸그룹인데 개네들도 큐브엿음 차라리 SM이나JYP엿으면 좋앗을텐데 대신에 하는일이 빡셋겟죠??
@@보라색수염 wm 아니에요?
고1 때 나온 노랜데 성인이 되서 지금까지 듣고 있는 노래👍🏻 멜로디가 너무 좋다... 내가 생각하는 best 띵곡... 비원에이포 다시 뭉쳐서 노래나왔으면 좋겠다 ㅠㅠ
ㅇㅈ :B1A4노래들 은근 좋은노래 개많음..다시 5명 완전체 보고싶다 진영 신우 산들 바로 공찬
뷰리풀타겟, 잘자요굿나잇 ,걸어본다, 이게 무슨 일이야, 론리, 솔로데이, 거짓말이야 등등 띵곡 많음 ㄹㅇ.. 5명이서 다시 이런 노래 내줬으면
이 노래는 처음부터 끝까지 너무 좋다.. 비트며 악기며 가사며 안무도.. 비원에이포 6년차 팬이지만, 이 노래가 너무 마음에 와닿는다. 특히 새벽에는 갬성때문에 미칠 것 같다. 목소리도 5명 다 최고다. 각각 파트에 딱 원하던 목소리 처음에 저노래 들었을때는 왜인지 모르겠지만 울었다. 멜로디가 심금을 울렸다. 대부분 가사때문에 울컥한 적은 있는데 멜로디때문에 울컥한 적은 난생 처음인 것 같다.. 정진영 최고.......
와 미감 미쳤다 오랜만에 다시 보러 왔는데도 전혀 옛날 뮤비 느낌이 안 나네요.. goat.. 재차 확인사살 박습니다.. feat. 이제 10년차 팬이네요..ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
다 좋은 비원에이포 노래들 중에 단연 1위,,
다른 곡들도 만만치않게 좋아서 아직도 듣지만 이 곡 도입부를 이기는 노래는 없는 듯
진영 작곡은 진짜 뭘까
비원에이포 타이틀곡부터 수록곡까지 명곡 진짜 많은데 제발 역주행했으면,,, 멤버들 능력치에 비해 빛을 많이 못 봤다고 생각하는 터라 더 아쉬움 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
ㅇㅈ요ㅠㅠㅠ
역주행 ㅈㅂㅈㅂ
역주행 제발
제발 역주행🙏
B1A4 is completely a different boyband. They sing, they compose, they write. they are just so awesome. Proud of them
So does BigBang
@@clubpenguinbeer Well atleast B1A4 is a clean group.
And BTS too
True. B1A4 is a talented and unique kpop boygroup.
Okay this is classic. Who's here in 2021.
B1A4 music never fails to amazed me.
yesss
here
2022. B1A4 forever, come back as 5, please.
J ecoute B1A4 tous les jours! J adore
why are they so underrated . ??? this song is amazing!!!
LORD TAEHYUNG Lord Taehyung i see you everywhere XDDDD.... And Yeah! i don't stan them but they sound awesome! 😍😍😍😍😍😍😢😢😢😢😢
LORD TAEHYUNG ohhhh ARMY!!!!
LORD TAEHYUNG they aren't underated?
LORD TAEHYUNG theyre not rlly underrated in korea. but still they need to get famous more like other group!!!
They are very well known in Korea
2019 , I miss B1A4 😭
Me too. hoping for a comeback.
😭😭😭😭
Me🤩
same TT TT so sad
I miss B1A4 too, lets support their 'A Day of love ' song it written by our Eomma Bear CNU before getting enlist and it's a song for us Fans (BANA)
이 노래가 나온지 4년이란 시간이 지나가버리네...
진영은 진짜 곡 잘만든다
이 댓글이 4년 전이네요 이제 ..
Who is here 2020? I really love this song...
we are here!!
I'm here again. 🥺
Pluemonade _Lovechild yes same
Let's support Sandeul on the release of his other songs.❤
Pluemonade _Lovechild yes definitely support B1a4 ❤️❤️❤️❤️
진짜 타팬이지만 믿고듣는 b1a4
갑자기 머릿속에 이 노래가 맴돌아서 들으러 왔다.
벌써 6년전 노래라니 놀랍네...
Revenez l ecouter souvent. C est un chef d oeuvre de la vraie kpop!
THIS SONG IS SOOOO BEAUTIFUL I'M HAPPY THAT I CLICKED ON IT
I'm glad you give it a try. I recommend Nightmare, I'll find you, Together... as side tracks from this album too ^^
GI NA thx
Kimberly Kranz same name e.e ❤💗
Kimberly Kranz Yeah same here hehe! I don't really listen to B1A4's songs, so it's the first time I'm clicking this. So beautiful😍😍😍 Hehe!!^^
Kimberly Kranz Yeah same here hehe! I don't really listen to B1A4's songs, so it's the first time I'm clicking this. So beautiful😍😍😍 Hehe!!^^
2023년에도 보고 있어요 B1A4 💚 💚 💚
2024🥺🫂
2024.02 😭
2024
"Now I'll let you go into the bright sunlight,
You belong there."
B1A4 will forever be OT5 in our hearts but they all deserve a better future, even if they have to walk on different paths.
They will have Perform as 5 in the future 💚💚💚💚💚 let's just wait
Yes. B1A4 5 forever until the end. Let us wait until they reunite as 5 again.
I say 다시 말하지만
우리의 인연은 여기까진 것 같아
you say 좋은 사람 꼭 만나
우리의 사랑은 생각보다 얕았나 보다
이렇게 우린 갈라져 틈이 갈라져
너를 등지고 돌아서는 내 모습은 초라하겠죠
내가 했던 말은 거짓말이야
떠나가란 말 다 거짓말이야 a lie a lie
내가 했던 말은 거짓말이야
제발 가지마 다 거짓말이야 a lie
모두 거짓말이기에
상처뿐인 말만 늘어놓고 뒤 돌아가
내일이면 다시 아무렇지 않게 살아가겠지만
너와 내 사이 운명 쉽게 끊을 수는 없다면
다시 돌아갈 수 있을까 예전의 모습처럼
환하게 웃던 미소가 눈물이 되어 흐르고
같이 부르던 이 노래가 내 맘을 적시고
점처럼 작아져 가는 그대 뒷모습 바라볼 때면
비가 내리며 나를 위로 해주네 슬픈 그대여
이렇게 우린 갈라져 틈이 갈라져
너를 등지고 돌아서는 내 모습은 초라하겠죠
내가 했던 말은 거짓말이야
떠나가란 말 다 거짓말이야 a lie a lie
내가 했던 말은 거짓말이야
제발 가지마 다 거짓말이야 a lie
모두 거짓말이기에
어둠 속에 묻혀있던 너의 미소
매일 암흑 속에 갇혀 있던 너란 햇빛
이젠 보내줄게 밝은 햇살 속에
네가 살고 있었다는 걸
언제나 힘없이 처져 있던 너의 그림자
항상 입술을 깨물며 고독하게 너는 혼자
고통을 참으며 눈물 삼키며
하루하루를 넌 괴롭게 보내잖아
내가 했던 말은 거짓말이야
제발 가지마 다 거짓말이야 a lie a lie
나를 떠나가 행복해 제발 더 행복해
나를 떠나가 행복해 제발 더 행복해
I say 다시 말하지만
Feel sorry for the people who don't know B1A4
👍👍👍
And I'm so so sorry cuz they are not together anymore
arn bn huhu i just came here! Huhu :( they reminded me so much of winner huhu im soo late :(
@@blinkshari4377 have you watched their 9th anniv online earlier?
Same😭
Who's watching this again? Suddenly remember this song when watching Police University. Why is this so underrated!!!
Meeeee
me, this is still my fav song tho
here
Me
same here beb
B1A4 I love you.
Who 's listening this music now?
Who 's reading comments now?
Me. This song brought me back ❤❤
@@CK_Drama. I love B1A4 :)
@@aysusalamova9681 same goes here.Since i watch B1A4 sweet girl few years ago when it release i fell in love with jinyoung. Who's your bias
I love b1a4 too 😊
@@janepaulenebode7819 Me too :)
진영 음색봐 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
신우 머리색봐ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
산들 귀여움봐ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
바로 랩봐ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
공찬 얼굴봐ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
비포 노래봐ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
다들 입덕하세요ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
사랑이죠비포옴걸 바나들에 오빠라서 넘나 좋아요♡
***** 6년 맞아유~♡
it's 2022, I still feel goosebumps and crying for this masterpiece .
me too
오빠들 영원히 비원에이포 하고 저희한테 좋은 음악 많이 들려줘요 5명이 모여서 부른 곡 다시 듣고 싶어요 정말.. 말로 표현 할 수 없을만큼 사랑해요 🤍
동감해요
이별노래지만 전 이 노랠 들을 때마다 오히려 사랑하고 싶어져요.
그 사람을 위해 뭐든 할 수 있을 것만 같아요.
내가 아이돌을 좋아하지 않는데 유일하게 인정했던 그룹 ㅜㅜ 보고 아이돌이 저렇게 세련되게 멋질수있구나를 처음 느낀 곡과 무대 ㅜㅜ
이곡을 들으면 다섯명의 B1A4에 대한 미련은 영원히 버릴 수 없다는 것을 깨닫게 된다
정진영은 정말 천재가 분명하다
I get the feeling of "lonely" at chorus part. Is it just me??
this song is so good. MV looks different from what they used to do. I think it is cool. Sandeul is so handsome.
Stefanie Queen I feel that this mv reminded me of Baby I'm Sorry
yeah right I got the same vibe as well
Stefanie Queen for me it reminded me of tried to walk
It's not just you; Lonely is my favourite song of theirs, and this is a close second now!
Stefanie Queen same
기다렸자나ㅠㅠ 비원에이포우ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
노래.미쳤따ㅠㅠ❤
만두 맞아요 ㅠㅠ 완전 아름다워요 이 노래... 😭❤
This is seriously underrated.
No. They are famous in korea. They have been more than 9 years in industry. Thu not have strong fanbase in international
@@independent_owl706 Well, the song is underrated it should get more views. (:
@@Tiffany-ov2jf Same.
I can't wait for these legends to get their World Domination.
우리나라 보이그룹 역대 노래중에 top5안에 드는 노래인듯
이렇게 완벽한 노랜데,, 물론 뜨긴했었지만 노래에 비하면 덜뜬거같아서 너무 아쉽다
재평가 역주행 시급하다 ㅠㅠ
2022년... B1A4 보고싶어요... 모든 노래가 주옥같은걸...
I'm not even a Bana (even though ”My Love" and "Tried to Walk" give me life), but I've found myself watching this video at least 15 times a day. This is truly a beautiful song, and I hope they receive a lot of recognition! B1A4 is amazingly talented!! Bana fighting!
Thank you, hope you become BANA soon ^^
I may become BANA before the year is over. I've listened to their album and I'm in love with it.
I can't even being to describe how much I love this song, it is truly a masterpiece, no matter how many times I listen to it I never stop feeling goosebumps, and the sorrow in it it's just beautiful, I absolutely love this, and I miss b1a4 so much, and the fact that Jinyoung is able to accomplish this Type of music without having studied music it's just out of this world. I Love B1A4
Even some classical players appreciated the transition of the notes. I forgot how they described it. But yeah hes lit.
@@independent_owl706 are you talking about the classical musicians react vid? they did praise the song a lot! i always listen to this song when i feel down
It is one of the best songs ever made in the kpop industry ....it has been years and i always comr back to this masterpiece
퀸덤 보고 오마이걸 노래 듣다가 b1a4도 생각나서 노래 정주행 중인데 wm은 참 좋은 음색 가진 가수들을 데리고 있었네요 산들은 노래 잘하는건 알고 있었는데 옴걸 뿐 아니라 b1a4도 음색과 화음 조화가 참 좋은 그룹이였네요 다른 곡도 들어 봐야겠어요 👍🏻
Jinyoung, Baro, Gongchan, Sandeul and CNU are so handsome and talented! Thumbs up guys!!!
OK I STAN B1A4 ITS FINAL
Kpop Trash MINGHAO
Kpop Trash your welcome to the BANA family
Kpop Trash Me too.
I am new to kpop and my new Stan here , can I get a brief account on them their fanclub
2020 and that song remains my favorite. I miss that time and even more B1A4
Certain songs still forever in memory....
Socorro. Tenho um comentário de 2 anos atrás aqui também. B1A4 volta plmds eu não aguento mais
Same. B1A4 songs will always be the best songs KPOP.
@@staybin1941 No doubts! ❤
@@millysaturnino Yes
B1A4 and Apink are much alike. They made comeback more than a year since the last album, with great MUSIC, but didn't get appreciated as it should be. This song, and Apink-Only One, are just so beautiful. This is music. NOT AHAHOHOHYIYAYIYA THING.
Alan Li B1a4 and Apink are one team!!!!
Alan Li of
Which song is the AHAHOHOHYIYAYIYA thing from?
B1A4 has an incredibly large fanbase though
Christine Duong i think Twice - ooh ahh 😂😂😂
I will admit I haven't listened to B1A4 for sooooooooo long, and right now I am getting the shivers EVERYWHERE. It's one of the most beautiful songs I've heard
Glad you're back at "good timing", keep watching this M/V please ^^ If you have time, check other songs of the album Good Timing too, you will not regret.
Yurin Yoo I 100% relate with you.. they haven't made a comeback in so long so I haven't listen to their music for so long then I come to this and got shivers everywhere like this song is so good..
SAME! now. i,m keep on repeat this song
omg i feel you. even the last time i listened to them was when they were promoting Lonely. i'm so glad that this mv played on my autoplay, this song is sooo beautiful I even cried without knowing the lyrics
Yurin Yoo same
it's good that B1A4 got recognition from idols; jessica, jin, eunji did recommend this song.
as expected, B1A4 has risen up once again with the marvelous concept as their comeback.
good job WM Ent and the members themselves to participate in the making of the album! c':
- sincerely, multifandom fangirl that is a bana as well
Bela Arthasari Jessica seems to be a B1A4 fangirl. She also promoted Sweet Girl last year. 😃
Bela Arthasari
bts also tweeted a pic of them listening to this song
Jimini Pabo omg I'm so happy rn I'm gonna cry. my boys are getting so much love! 😭
Yugyeom from GOT7 just already update about this song in IG
Ailee too just post on insta. Her friend baro and Sandeul. WM artist always gt idols support for them. That's mean they are really a good person.
지금도 듣고 있어요 너무 조아서..
they've grown up a lot 😍😍😍 I've been their fan since OK released. they become mature by the time. they look super handsome 😍😍
CNU tho.. he looks extra handsome nowadays. can't wait for the live performance
Yes, they have first stage on The show today
Haha same. It's seriously mindblowing how much they've changed since O.K lol.
agree!!!
eka putri saraswati me too!! i've been BANA since OK era!! *high five* and couldn't agree more with you!! B1A4 fighting 💪💞🙌🙌
True! Although I miss his bobcut hair he looks much hotter. 😍
I'm here after the news and I don't really know what to say, I wish that they could continue with five members but I'm happy that Jinyoung and Baro left in good terms. I've became a Bana 2012 when I was eleven years old and discovered K-pop, theses boys really change my life. They made songs that made me dance, cry and laugh and I'm so happy that I got the chance to see them 2015. They were amazing live and I'm glad that 3/5 is going to keep singing. Remember Bana, we got to stay strong and support ALL of the boys
Virtual Hug 💚 let's support them Forever.
I dont think so they left in good terms gongchan unfollow them on twitter and instagram and also he delete all b1a4 picture on his instagram
You make me cry....
@@briekim2927 gongchan did??!! Oh no my ot5 heart :( or maybe he had too because of company
Stay strong B1A4 and BANA
This deserves more views!
Madeline Nicole Macalintal 100% agree
PROUD ARMOMMY This song is really good but sadly i think it is underrated. 😞😞😞
Nicole M. IKR! !!💪💪
I think the song is more popular. I remember liking this song ever since last year, but this is my first time watching the mv.
지금 들어도 너무나 좋은 노래.. 멜로디 라인하며 가사가 잘 어울러지네. 진영은 천재 프로듀서다..
ㄹㅇ ㅜㅜㅜ
B1A4영원하자💞💗💘💟💝💕💖
I was still so mad at the snl incident i almost forgot that they're releasing songs tonight
AND THIS SONG IS SO GOOD ILY
snl incident?
이하루 the staff of snl touch the members dick. As a joke but netizen mad at the lame joke.
ikr ! how can the staff do something like that it is so gross
Shine it's basically sexual harassment so they have the right to be mad, i'm fucking pissed like who tf ! fucking disgusting
jinyoung is so talented and he is very special. I LOVE HIS EYES!
BIA4 fighting!
이 노래 내 최애곡.. 슬픈데 너무 쳐지지 않고 적당히 신나는 노래 뭔가 추억이 담긴노래 같다
갠적으로 이노래 유명해졌으면 좋겠는데 나만 듣고싶은 노래.. 너무 좋다
2023, still in my daily playlist. hope many more people can listen to this masterpiece
Dans ma playlist egalement. ❤
Well, I discovered it today! I'm missing B1A4 T_T.
glad I discovered this song this year ❤will be checking out all their songs since I loved this one. any recs?
@@n.y5345 my favs are good timing, solo day n crushing on you again
@@n.y5345 hello, i like "good love" sing by the leader Jung Jinyoung, "only one" par le groupe, "misty road" par Jinyoung ( chanson de love in the moon light) c'est lui qui l'a produite.
Si vous aimez mon choix, dites le moi et je vous donnerez d autres titres
Bonne ecoute
중 1때 진짜 질리도록 들었었는데ㅠ
이제 들어보니까 가사도 다 기억하네,,
개추억 ㅠㅠㅠ
2022 and “A Lie” remains a highlight in the outstanding discography of B1A4! Jinyoung is really one of the best idol songwriters & producers.
I'm still here, miss this song this group, this misterpiece and the old kpop songs, that were perfect and has something special not only a good beat. I wish I could turn back time and apreciate much more than I did some years ago. That time I didn't know how life could be hard they made my life easily and happy. I will always love them for this
I'm so glad so many people are recognizing B1A4's talents aaaa they've been in the industry for a long time and they deserve everything nice I'm so proud of them
Yes, I'm so proud to be a BANA ^^
I agree! As a fan in the U.S. who speaks no Korean, I love their music and voices. They gave an OUTSTANDING concert with live band for over 2 hours in San Francisco 2014. They have fans everywhere and can fill concert halls around the world. Please send B1A4 on tour again! ❤️ 🌱
Well I didn't Know this band before ... recently I became a fan of Sandeul's voice on duet song festival then watched 'Love in the moonlight"and fall in love with Jinyoung's acting so charming ... This song is great indeed ... I'm getting to know the other's members talents ...! fighting B1A4
again and again a mv biased ..... jinyoung is everywhere
ikr... i wish they give other members more screentime esp chan and cnu
Yes chan and cnu was the member with the less screen time .. it's always like this
Cassandra Lopes guess you are the new kpopper?? In kpop, the company usually want the one who is the mostly well known member to get most air time. And jinyoung popularity atm is huge
Shine in other b1a4 mvs he got most of the screentime all the time
For this mv, it is arranged to fit the plot. You can check other b1a4's mv, the on-screen time of all members are quite even.
이 노래가 벌써 7년이 됐네.. 언제 들어도 좋다..
Want to see them on weekly idol soooo bad😭😭 I really missed them
Once & Army Me too
Me too
holy cow so many modulations.... -Umu
ReacttotheK omg i found umu
ReacttotheK please react to this!! 💓
OMG Looking forward for the reaction on the 16th! 💕
Just watched the reaction XD!!! LOVE U UMU
ReacttotheK i came after ur reaction video 😄
simply beautiful! i'm not a bana, but i always supported them and loved their music! tbh nowdays i find kpop dissapointing...i dont like the music that rookie groups are releasing and old kpop groups are either in long ass hiatus, either disbanding. I'm so happy that finally a big name in kpop is coming back with such an amazing song! totally worth the waiting
from an emo old kpoper
100percent Romania omo I'm sure B1A4 will be happy to hear this especially Jinyoung! Thank you for your support to #B1A4 ! 😁
N. Aina i‘m not sure he understands english 😂😂
100percent Romania let's hope someone will translate it for him 😅
진짜 거짓말같긴해 5명이 아닌 비원에이포가
언젠가 다시 하나 되줄거라고 믿는다 비더원 올폴원
Exo-L, starlight, inspirit, b2uty, melody, army, aroha here to support!!!
stop it already. this is getting annoying
+yeppoheera what's wrong with this comment?
Cheryl Tyt y'all keep saying this fandom here to support b1a4 and bla bla bla. just enjoy their music.
+yeppoheera there's nothing wrong with her comment..As a BANA like most are happy to see other people from different fandoms support our boys.
yeppoheera instead of being so negative; just be happy that other fandoms are supporting us.
Fans leaving B1A4 for newer groups? Can't understand why. Well, here's a new fan for your fandom 😘
I love the newer groups but I would NEVER leave B1A4~~~
me too! Always with B1A4!
I love new group I love monstax, i love seventeen, i love sf9. But if someone ask me what your fandom, I will say that I'm BANA I'm will not say that i monbebe, carat, or fantasy cause boy group who always in my heart is B1A4. my love for B1A4 is bigger then that new group it's like whatever I go I will back to B1A4 I really love B1A4
Echa Cha I like other group and I try to like any group
But still B1A4 is the best for me💕💞💞
They are different from the other group
They are positive thinking guys, cheerfull, kind, innocent yet mature, and all words that refers to happiness
They are the definition of Happy
#비원에이포 #행복하자
Once a real BANA always a BANA 💚
Having a B1A4 MV marathon... 'cause I miss them ☹
Same
i just recently watched The Dude In Me, Jinyoung's movie, and it made me miss him and the group. I won't ever forget the VERY first kpop group that I stanned and it's them. I miss them. *so much.*
Just saw OneK peace concert in Manila and B1A4 a big hit as expected. "Long time no see!" The boys told the crowd who laughed because B1A4 just had a concert in Manila last January! They didn't sing "Lie" perhaps because it's a sad song and they sang instead their jauntier hit songs and everybody loved them. Jinyeong and Baro were as expected the most popular although I heard my female seatmates remarking howthey found Jinyeong really better looking in person. Sandeul was a big hit when he sang solo the OST of Jinyeong's KBS historical drama. Gongchan wellliked too. But the ladies were really swooning over CNU who seemed too shy to acknowledge that he was causing too much oohs and ahhs. Which further endeared him to the girls. B1A4 really rocked and charmed Manila and they performed their usual best! Thank you, B1A4!
Last year, at the fans meeting, Jinyoung cried as he looked at his fans. This year, at the Live Space concerts, Jinyoung thanked his fans for supporting them and he broke down cried again, worrying that some of his fan might not support the B1A4 in the future. I think that he was indeed sincerely thankful for his fans and that he was so touched that his die hard fans were there at the concert to support them. But obviously, there are less B1A4 fans today compared to 2012. Look at their old songs, they got so many million views but today, the song A Lie only got about 2 million views. Why? I think that A lie is a beautiful song but it did not get more views. Look around, some okay songs got many million views in a short time because these groups got lots of fans to view their songs. I just hope that many people will come to know B1A4 from now on and their old fans will come back to support them and to re-discover how talented B1A4 is.
Omg....I missed them so much....one of my first Kpop bands...always be my favorites...
Keep watching this M/V to help them BANA ^^
음악적 지식이 없는 편이지만 곡 중간에 분위기가 확 바뀌는게 상당히 대담한 시도로 느껴진다. 한번 들으면 귀에 확 박힐 수 밖에 없는 곡 구성인듯.
Okey, I just discovered B1A4 because of Jinyoung apperaing on a Netflix show. And Jesus, what a beautiful song 👏
I know there are now only 3 members left, wish them a good future 💛
ONE OF THE BEST COMEBACKS
Dieu Nguyen So True!!!!
y'all everything is so good about this album but i want to talk about
1. cnu's awesome hair
2. baro's rapping is stellar?? he's so underrated. b1a4 is so underrated.
뵤네포 진짜 좋은 노래들 많은데 알 사람들만 안다는게 너무 맘 아픔 이런 노래들은 모두가 들어야하는건데 우리만 알고 있기 너무 아까움🥺🥺🥺🥺 다들 음색도 좋고 노래도 다 좋음 진짜로 심지어 바로 랩도 잘하고 노래랑 잘 어울리고 가사도 진짜 좋음 이런 노래 모두가 다 듣게 해즈ㅜ새요 제발요 🥹🥹
Today is the anniversary of "A Lie "
We are so close to reaching 6M views keep streaming BANA !
SUPER JUNIOR ELF HERE TO SUPPORT B1A4 AND I CAN'T WAIT TO SEE THIS SONG LIVE
thank you for the support, ever since I was at their concert in Madrid I am their fan (BANA) forever!
I am BANA too and my bias is Jinyoung and baro
Sacha Girl
mine is Jinyoung and second is Sandeul :)
I'm an ELF too and i came here to support them
Jinyoung is my bias too LOL
hhhhhhhh wooooooow great my ELF chingo 😉😉
1. Produce 101 - In The Same Place
2. Oh My Girl - One Steps Two Steps
3. I.O.I - When The Cherry Blossom Fade
4. Ben - Misty Road (Moonlight Drawn By Clouds OST)
5. I.O.I - Hold Up
6. B1A4 - It's A Lie
7. Good Timing (B1A4 FULL ALBUM - 12 Track)
okay Jung Jinyoung thanks for make this year wonderful !!!!
and R.I.P MY REPLAY BUTTON
Bayu Boxer oh he produced all those songs?
+fusiongemini if I'm not mistaken, he wrote these songs
yes, he produced all those song :))
He wrote "One Steps Two Steps"?!?!?! I love that song!!! It's my daily jam!!! Ughhh, keep stealing my heart Jinyoung!!!
he's very talented
아 미치겠다.. 노래 너무 좋고 뮤비 분위기도 너무 좋다..ㅠ 진영 음색 너무 좋고 바로 특유의 굵직한 랩도 너무 좋고 나머지 멤버들도 말 할것도 없이 너무 잘 어울린다,, 진짜 좋다 ㅠ 사랑해
It's almost a year ever since they released this and I still have feels every single time I play this dammit.
Agatha Kristie yessssss 😭
from 'u zoom zoom my heart like a rocket' to this art.
Azzimah PSB never forget bad Engrish
"YOU JOOM JOOM MY HEART LIKE A LOCKET"
what are you talking about 'u zoom zoom my heart like a rocket' is a poetic masterpiece
laughed when reading this. im rooting them since their debut and watching them grow up is really amazing
You forgot "lab me lab me lab me lab me lab me beybeh" and we all did anyway haha. I hope they don't disband. They were the first KPOP group I ever got interested in. It would really be heartbreaking if they don't renew. 💔
we must wait the news on june. i hope its a good one
i think b1A4 deserve to be more famous than the new groups because all they are handsome and jinyoung oppa write the Lyrics by himself
and sandeul oppa has the best sound and seriously did you ever see some more handsome than gongchan? Of course you cant find and our cnu oppa his voice is beautiful like him and he can sing rap amazing right? and our rapper baro he cute and hot in the seem time and his rap so gooooood , i'm arab bana and Proud b1A4 is my Favorite group and once i be bana its mean forever bana b1A4 Fighting
Jinyoung is really so good. Composing, singing, acting. Why did I Know him so late.
WHY ARE PEOPLE STILL SLEEPING ON THIS SONG???? IT IS A MASTERPIECE!!!
Min Yoonji true
Trueee
Bana fightingㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ let's give a trophy to B1A4 they deserve it!!!!!
Gladys Cheung yes they diffently need to win
Tatjana T absolutely keep on streaming♡
Gladys Cheung they won i think right?
Raz 7 yaya♡
Jessica Jung promoted this song. ❤
Emanuelle Fernandes yes! she said it was good, so i took her up on that and came here!
a hyung I'm so glad the queen promoted them, they really deserve it 😍
KT Diva on her instagram! jessica.syj
KT Diva I don't have certain. But she tagged one of them (jinyoung) so maybe she knows them?
i think she also promoted sweet girl on her ig too❤
내가 아직도 좋아한다 진영아 사랑해ㅠ
seriously guys ... this is thr best kpop song i have ever heard ...
*the
Taufik Hidayat I agree😀
Taufik Hidayat ..I agree with you😊 this song it's like a beautiful dream😘.Army here to support this amazing group ..B1A4 fighting!!😘
I'm EXO-L but I love Jinyoung more than I love EXO :)) he's so talented,he can sing,dance,compose,acting..he is handsome too!I LOVE HIM SO MUCH ❤️❤️❤️
Ngọc Anh Nguyễn Aww hello and welcome ❤
I can't agree with you more. Jin Young is a talented composer and actor!! Besides, I like EXO, too.
^_^
SAME! I've been an EXO-L for around 2-3 years but I love Jinyoung WAY more :') I'm glad to have discovered such a talented person
he can sing,compose,act well but dance ...ㅎ Exactly, I love jinyoung❤
I think I'm in love with them. 😍😍😍 I've known them since Lonely but never really paid attention but after hearing this song, damn, can I be a BANA?
Bri Yauder Welcome to the BANA family then 😊💖
you're always welcome!
You're welcome with our open arms
I'm new to them. How do you pronounce b1a4? Or is it BANA? I'm confused
한번이라도 좋으니까 제발 모여줘ㅠㅠ 제발..
When you FINALLY give B1A4 a chance
Yes! No regrets! 😍🌱
Rachel Smith thank you :D
KNK's My VITAMIN JACKSON haha
B1A4 Jinyoung- Another name in the music genius Category! He produces such catchy songs!
b1a4 songs is piece of an art and it is very different with other song because it has their own uniqueness to present in every song. i must say this video ia beautiful and meaningful. This song also reminds me of their previous song which is 'tried to walk' and 'lonely'. B1A4 is so talented in the combining pop and melody where sad story is represented but at the same they never fail to cheer us with delightful music
2021 anyone with me?
⬇️⬇️⬇️
HAIIIII
I saw them in concert last night in NYC. I loved every minute of it. They are amazing live.
I don’t know what to say... I will miss all of you being together... I will continuing to support all of you, no matter if you’re no longer together. I respect your decision and I love all of you guys. Thanks for blessing me with your wonderful songs and voices❤️😭 I thought I wasn’t going to cry, but here I am...
Virtual Hug 💚
ㅠㅠ 앨범 사서 cd로 이 노래랑 수록곡까지 다 들으면서 시험 공부하던 예전의 순간이 떠오르네요
진짜 모든 곡 들으면서 가사랑 코러스까지 다 외우고 그랬는데 ㅋㅋㅋ
진짜 좋은 추억 남겨줘서 고마워요 오빠들 꼭 다시 뭉쳐주세요 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
a lie and lonely are b1a4's greatest songs imo
yes!! like the sad boy-type songs