I don’t know how to begin to express the depth of respect for what you do in your classroom or have been teaching our kids! Thank you for this class and for your work.
His basic premis is all wrong this isn't a Palestinisn Jewish thing. It's about Zionists & Israelis. Muslims don't hate Jews. Move on from that. Now let's talk about the Israeli Zionist settlers which are way way different than my good Jewish neighbor
@@AnnMarieAisha Muslims don't hate Jews? Religious Muslims hate Jews. period. Just ask the Jewish population in the suburbs of Amsterdam & Paris where there's been a big immigrant Muslim population move in.
@@AnnMarieAishaThis guy with his thoughts and speech nothing more than gibberish, little to none of anything being factual or even reality. I feel sorry for these kids having to trust these education system that's force-feeding all this propaganda crap in their minds.
@Eliyahu673 the nature of your comment...no substance, just insults, violates every principle of good dialog and ratchets up the credibility and honesty of the whole conversation. Try the approach of this man's great Lebanese mentor
@@rosalindpaaswell9513 Is this one of those times, because you say so. Hum! Biblical History won't validate what this guy is is saying. World History, not even secular history will support his pseudo belief and his so called experience. For one it's built upon a lie and you can't make a lie be the truth. The Bible clearly make it known to those that seek truth that the whole world has been lied to. But I 'm sure he wouldn't know nothing about that since he made it know that he's so proudly stated that he was an atheist. That along is worth examining and questioning. In general just tired of sincere honest seeking truth about many things and are being lied to on so many levels and through all these systems designed to deceived. Wheater gullible, naive,or a lack of studying or knowledge.
First UA-cam comment in my life. Much love and respect to Dr. Sam Richards for a fair and accurate conversation led with compassion and humanity. So much more of what we need. I've studied the conflict for the better part of two decades. It would've been easy to spend the entire class answering just one or two of the questions thoroughly. But it was beautiful to lead with empathy and debunk fear, conspiracies, and cynicism. Bravo!
He's clearly biased and gaslighting others. If you want the whole truth. Try listening to other unbiased Jews such as Norman Finkelstein and Ilan Pappe
Thank you, Dr. Richard's I have a college education, but I've always enjoyed every history class, from yesterday to 2 million years ago. I'm a respiratory therapist, but I have 32 historical credits. I love to learn actual facts and not media propaganda. You're an incredible professor and teacher of both sides. Thank you for furthering my education, especially with the history, situation, the actions, and protesting happening in America and all over the world, especially since October 7th. Sincerely MLBW1966
I really like this professor. I really agree with his stance on honouring the suffering of other human beings. It's the absolute minimum moral action we can take as individuals, especially if we feel we have no other way to help.
Thank you Sam for continuing to provide a space that puts humans unequivocally first. I learned a lot, and I think a lot more than just your students could use this right now.
Dr. Richards, I have been on the Gaza and in Israel on several occasions and you are absolutely correct. The last question and your answer summarized the discussion perfectly. Your discussions are reminiscent of my days at St. Louis U.(Go Billikens) Critical thought is rare in this Millenium. If you reach 10% of your students you will be successful. I was also delighted to hear you cite some of the news sources we utilized in the intelligence community. My daughter is now a member of that community as well and he eyes and mind are wide open.
The poster didn't mean reaching 10% of students as someone watching the lectures. It means that 10% of those students actually listened and thought of the content and were able to think critically.
There were 3000 Christians in Gaza in 2005, and now there are less than 1000 and 0 Jews there. Hamas and the Gazans don't treat non-muslims well, and if you're Muslim, you have to follow their strict laws that are full of harsh punishments and penalties that we in America would never see here because of the 8th amendment in our Constitution.
These are the conversations we need to be having. People need to truly see things from both sides. Talk to everyone instead of staying in your own little bubble.
What I really appreciate is that he takes his time to think about the questions before answerimg them. I think everyone can use this for better conversations.
Seeing all the propaganda that boils over in the universes, this guy is a real gem with a good vocabulary and knowledge. This is what brings the world forward, not the woke hate speech from leftist professors. This guy may be a leftist for all I know, but he has the ability to put things into perspective.
As an Israeli (that currently lives In the south of the country ), I would love to have a follow up with actual Israelis and Palestinians. I think our perspectives are important here and a lot is missing. I’m more than willing to be in said conversation btw.
If one party wants the whole of Israel for itself and the other is willing to share with others there cannot ever be peace. One democratic state/nation/country with Jews, Arabs and a mixed and diverse multitude from the nations appears to be the only possible solution. Sadly, this seems very unlikely.
Gotta appreciate the good work you do trying to give the next generation perspective. Truly being able to voice and informed opinion on a matter requires the upmost dedication and research to give that subject its due diligence. Hopefully we can keep the young minds open and awake.
I think this is exactly what is lacking so direly in education - to show young people how to develop an individual perspective that's not an easy, borrowed, cult position such as are constantly thrust towards the individual in the media. To think not by deciding first the position you want to reach and then looking for arguments to support it, but from the desire to reach a solid position. And that a position that is not incendiary or dramatic is more useful in dialogue.
Thank you so much of this lecture. Hope has returned to my mind. Instead of a raging storm and thunder, there’s calm and rain. I’m so grateful. Thank you, thank you, thank you so much. 🙏
When he said human being just want to get on with there lives hit me hard... I was shot 6 times and flat lined a couple of times and my honest to God feeling after the initial trauma was to forgive that man that shot me. In my mind he will answer to God, my life has been absolutely great after moving past Revenge feeling, I have to live especially for my kids. Forgiveness was the best decision I made ....
These sorts of forums of discussion should be available to everyone, in the way the Greeks and the Romans could publicly meet at the forums to hear the thinkers speak and co verse with the masses in a real personal level. This changes minds and broadens peoples concepts of the world.
Gazans did in fact vote Hamas into power though you are correct that since then there have been no elections. Additionally, it is quite obvious that Hamas is very popular among Palestinians. Even in the West Bank where it is dangerous to be a Hamas supporter because their rival political party Fatah is in charge, it is still quite common to have Hamas supporters.
@@DearProfessorRF Long I bet you haven't lived here but yes it is very popular but it depends on region and clan/tribal/family affiliation. There are entire towns fully affiliated with Hamas lol.
@DearProfessorRF you have that backwards and he is correct. The Palestinians supported them fully untill the bombings started. That's why in the rocket attack u see basically every1 celebrating and now we're getting civilian videos condemning hamas.
@@GimPGrows How exactly can we be sure the elections were not rigged by Hamas themselves? How come you trust them as a source when it comes to this particular claim, but reject of all the other claims presented by their news media?
as a canadian. a right leaning for certain canadian, I consider myself fairly intellectual. And I constantly seek truths, and I constantly aseek resolutions. And I also am often catching myself asking wtf. I salute you, and your efforts, and your approach to putting the real matter into light in a way that you connect with your peers/students what have you. Thank you for this. I myself needed to see this. You have made a difference. Thanks man.
Taking control of our thoughts is essential. Proverbs 4:23 states, "Above all else, guard your heart, for it is the wellspring of life." The “heart” includes the mind and all that proceeds from it. Someone said that every sin we commit, we commit twice, once in our thoughts and again when we act upon those thoughts. It is easier to rid our lives of sin if we attack it at this fundamental thought level rather than waiting for it to become rooted in our lives by our actions and then try to pull it out.
Beautiful. Articulate. This is what we need more of. I’m personally a Zionist and this has really opened my mind to allow myself to try understand another perspective. I have always thought I am very open however this is showing I have more work to do. Thank you
Thank you for fostering an environment of intellectual curiosity WITH empathy. Talking about this in the framework of the average individual person on either side was (hopefully) very productive.
When the professor told the student to go learn about the history of the landmass that was gold. The student was so caught up in his own train of thought and ideals. Bro didn’t unfocus 😂
I have heard Palestinian and other Arabs interviewed that expressed greater denial than he did. I wonder how history is taught there, and what passes for archeology, S many think there was never an Israel, and Jews only passed through recently, but Palestine has been a thing for millenia.
Said a lot without saying much. He has been there and met these people and spoke to these people but all he told me is that he knows and we don’t. Tell us what we don’t know… Teach man!
I felt the same way. I don’t understand as to why he is getting so much praise. Very strange to me. He begins one sentence and then when finishing a thought he begins to shift the conversation. I feel he would be insightful but I didn’t get to gain that insight n
@@MahalTSJ he loves to liste to himself but eventhough he talked a lot without saying anything he tried to deliver the message that in general people there just try to live their lives and that we should try not to see this conflict as good vs evil. It is a simple message but it is missing in everybodys heads
I am so thankful you are able to conduct your classes the way you do. Too many professors have lost their livelihoods for touching far smaller and less controversial (and, therefore, less important) topics.
I wish everyone in the country could see this thoughtful presentation. It isn’t superficially “bothsides,” it’s a clear-eyed look at all sides. The saddest point was that most people in the region are not looking for a fight.
The leaders of both sides are looking for a fight. And those leaders on both sides are willing to sacrifice their people in order to stay in power indefinitely.
The Palestinians in the West Bank do not support Hamas. The Gaza Strip is a different story, but conflating the two is precisely the kind of naïve, unnuanced, one-sided, ignorant narrative the English-speaking world news-media is trying to sell you here.
I’m an Israeli citizen and I can say I love what this guy has to say. He actually went and tried to understand my country, although I don’t agree with everything he says (which is normal and ok), I respect him for actually learning about it himself and not relying on often politically charged sources. We need more people like Prof. Richards.
7:39 Criticism of you can boil down to “you had an hour long conversation and ended where you started”. Maybe you don’t want to come up with a solution. 1:11:08 hearing this… maybe having conversation with humility is right. Admitting we won’t find the solution today, but that we’re willing to keep coming back to talk. If we don’t have the conversation… someone with something to gain will
I appreciate and respect your attempt at having a open discussion and trying to help develop empathy and broad thinking in your students. At the same time you are stumbling into moral equivalency in small nuanced yet dangerous way that undermines your primary intention. And you have some inaccuracies that you need to be educated on.
Professor, I just want to say thank you very much it’s awesome to see somebody is caring issue trying to teach the younger generation what is right and not what CNN says is.
Two things 1. Prior to the current outbreak of fighting, to what degree was this statement true, “If the Arabs put down their weapons today, there would be no more violence. If the Jews put down their weapons today, there would be no more Israel.” 2. Can the IDF separate average Palestinians from Hamas when Hamas fires rockets from school grounds and housing complexes?
@fragment97 Hamas and other terrorist organizations happily use children as shields and pawns for their own gain. It's a bit more nuanced than that my man.
@@fragment97 He’s saying Hamas using children as human shields makes collateral damage certain. This damage is relatively likely in normal war but is exacerbated still through hostages, blending of civilian and terrorist presence, and using of infrastructure as militant springboards.
@fragment97 if you use children as human shields, you at the very least don't have the moral high ground. To them the children are martyrs. Hamas sees their sacrifice as a worthy dead. The love death as much as the jews love life. It's their motto
@@fragment97 IDF has weapon systems that are capable of tracking rockets back to their launch point. More times than not the IDF doesn’t shoot back because the launchers are next to a school, a hospital or apartment complex. Serious question; if your adversary is shooting at you from behind a hospital, what do you do?
Cool to see, but if everyone he met in Gaza didn’t support Hamas, then it also says a bit about his sample size. He met the people most interested in finding peace, so that is somewhat expected. But its hardly comprehensive of what Palestinians think.
It just looks like he hasn't really investigated abd just met wonderful people but that's picky not random people with random opinions he has the minimum idea of what's actually going on here I expected more honestly
I’ll be honest, I watched every minute of this, and I really didn’t learn anything. Sure he’s a nice guy and he’s a good perspective on world peace, and he’s proven to challenge his own perspective, but i literally didn’t learn anything about the conflict. I just learned about him.. and everyone in the comment section is giving this class praise just because he proved himself to be a “good” guy by not picking a side.
@@Souxie123 that’s the issue. I have no biases, therefore I did not learn anything. Perhaps if I was a narrow minded individual, this class could have benefitted the way I think and reflect, but as far as actual material in regards to the conflict, I didn’t learn a single thing.
@@MrKn0w17A11 when I think of sociology, I think of culture, and the history behind that culture. Like, your right, it kind of was missing the sociology. Don’t get me wrong, I’m sure a lot of students benefitted in this particular class, as far as being able to “zoom out” and simultaneously view a situation empathetically and objectively.. which can go on to be beneficial in future classes. But yeah you’re right, the actual sociology was missing imo.
Well done. The concept of "unfocus" and the nuance you've given these young adults is essential in not only this but every major social topic of debate.
Sam Richards and I would disagree on many things and yet we come together on more than anyone would think from either “side”. He keeps trying in many of his classes to drill down to the point of personal experience and how it conflicts with the understood narrative or accepted views. I would love to sit and talk with him for a few hours, I am a conservative with a similar mindset…I think most people miss the bigger picture he is trying to paint.
The answer to the question of why did Hamas launch this war is not found in a reported provocation that Israel committed in the recent past. The answer lies in Iran. If you are not seriously discussing the Iranian regime and their influence on this attack in Israel, you are not being honest with yourself.
@@OsiAleogena proximity in time matters when discussing cause and effect. I’ve heard people say, “Well, I don’t want to talk about 10/7. I want to talk about 1948.” And I’m thinking, “Well, why stop there? Let’s talk about 1936, 1929, 1920, 1914, 1834, 1660, 1517…” Things weren’t peaches and cream even before 1948, so it seems nonsensical to keep kicking the can backwards in time to things that are not direct causation. To me it seems like a deflection tactic, because people don’t want to tackle tough issues that are factually inconvenient.
After two weeks of diving into everything possible about this conflict, it is time to focus on my priorities. Great session. I would have liked to have heard a question of The Hamas Charter. Otherwise thanks tonall youbstudents to being there.
I watched many lectures and debates ....... and I have to be straight forward by saying that this lecture led me to nowhere. Absolute waste of time. 1. "Everybody wants peace" ....... 2. " People are just living their lives" 3. ....."theres misinformation""" ....blah .....blah ....blah NOTHING MENTIONED ABOUT ILLEGAL SETTLEMENTS AND EXPANSION OF ISSR@EEL AND THE EVER CHANGING MAP THERE
Hamas did not "took over" after Israel left Gaza in the early 200os. Hamas was ELECTED in democratic elections by the PEOPLE in Gaza. Polls today show that Hamas has 70% support. How can he say that he met with hundreds of Palestinians from Gaza and not a single one of them supported Hamas? The hundreds that he met must have been a very special subclass, not representative of the Gaza (and Palestinian) population at great. It's like saying that he met hundreds of Americans and not a single one of them supported the Republicans (or the Democrats).
My argument too. How did Hamas grow? What about the suicide bombers , the training of kids by Hamas. Hamas proudly posted these things so it's not propaganda
He was is the West Bank where at the probably early-mid 2000s the support for Hamad there was negligeble. Nowadays the support in WB to Farah is fading and the support to Hamas is increasing although I doubt to the degree that has been seen in Gaza. After the post 7-Oct conflict is difficult to assert the Gazan support for Hamad, and Gaza is becoming a shell of what it was.
What's missing from this conversation in the area of Civilian casualties is how Hamas intertwines its military infrastructure with the civilian. Also there's a false moral equivalency here between purposefully attacking and trying to kill civilians and accidentally killing them because you're trying to get at the people that want to kill you. Saying that Israel cannot strike back as it does in Gaza is basically saying that Hamas is allowed to hit them but Israel is no way allowed to strike back because the cat avoid civilian casualties because, back to point one, Hamas intertwines their military with the civilians. The other false equivalency here is just because more on the enemy side die then do your guys does not make you wrong. Ten times more German civilians died from the English bombing Germany then did English civilians. Was England wrong the prosecution of the war to get rid of the Nazis?
So if there is a person that you want to get at and he is in a hospital, do you think it’s morally right to obliterate the entire block? And by the evidence that we are seeing so far, Isnotreal hasn’t been able to prove that H amas fighters are in any civilian structures..
I think this could help young people understand equality and the fact that we as people we all want the same things: People I see people around the world We all have the same pictures in the phone Family love and friends Cats and dogs Smiles and sun Kids and schools And a picture on the wall I see people around the world We all have the same dreams in our phone A house a car A kid a home and a fire place to warm us all And a picture on the wall I see people around the world Why if we all want peace We keep fighting each other like a beast We all have the same dreams on the phone Of that picture on that wall
Did you watch the video ? Did he miss something 🤔 add it in to the comments. I'm not sure what complexity theory is but I do understand discussing topics or discussions in general and I thought it was a well made video opening my mind to new ideas.
@@bleekrides Complexity theory and game theory are hugely relevant to the political science aspects of this conflict. It was tediously frustrating to sit through all the fluff in this lecture, so I was asking to see if he ever got to anything substantive. This is supposed to be a university class, not a kindergarten.
@chrisheist652 No, he mostly covers his time in the areas now being fought over and how we here in the u.s. need to understand this is a very complex issue between Palestine and Isreal. Take a moment to focus on the many nuances of both sides. And not get swept up in fire and passion that may resemble anti Semitism. It a college class sure. But are all student logical analytical thinkers ? Some may be closer to kindergarten students. A professor teaching people to take a 10k foot view of the issues I think is certainly a place to get these kids started.
This was a great thing to do, so many school/college kids will be astounded by the silence from their teachers on this topic. I wonder how Dr Richards would feel about events now though, things have become worse than we could possibly have imagined on the 12th October regarding the vengance of Israel, when you see footage from Palestinian press, and from idf soldiers, it's not like anything we have ever seen before.
When you realize Muslims today honestly think Palestine existed 3,000 years ago, like this young man in class, you can begin to understand the depth of the false information that drives the conflict.
Wasn't able to watch live today like normal but I'm glad because I had to relisten and think more than usual. Started watching the livestreams at the beginning of the semester and this has been the most interesting/thought provoking/learning experience thus far. But I'm slowly going backwards rewatching old streams so I am sure there will be lots more great conversations. Great approach 👍
I’ve spent 30 years studying the region and it’s conflict. While I agree so many want peace there are many, especially in Gaza, that do not want peace. I’ve found the same info Israelis. The problem is the continued rejection of the 2 state solution by the PLO and others. I don’t have to repeat the put their guns down line do I?
It is a Hamas which doesn’t want a Two-State not the PLO, which is why Netanyahu has been supporting Hamas. Netanyahu doesn’t want a Two-State solution and now 11,000 dead people are paying the price.
@@DearProfessorRFThat’s 100% a conspiracy. You can dislike Bibi, but to claim he’s trying to propagate war shows your extreme bias. Especially as he actively tried to communicate peace and open deals with SA.
@@fedbia2003 this is how you say this is a joke without saying this is a joke. Not even Israelis like Netanyahu unless you’re a far-right right racist like the rest of his Likud party. Well, now he and thousands of dead are paying the price of his political calculations.
Netanyahu is on record as supporting H***s (No this isn't a crack pot theory. His comments to his party conference in 2019 were widely reported in mainstream media as saying explicitly that)
Was fun to catch a live one! Chat was nice and civil, thanks again guys.. love this class. I’d bet the channel grows pretty quickly, I’ve already seen folks doing reaction videos 👍
This guy is great. He should be flown round all the top Universities in America to have a word with some of the lunatics running round campuses "protesting" at the moment
This is why I think we don't know the half of it all here in our insulated US. I enjoy this man's lectures. I also agree that critical thinking is exorcised less and less these days.
Here in my final year at a university in California. With this kind of civility from you compared to most staff and students on campus, really wish I could have someone like you as my professor for a class like yours. Thank you for exceptional discussion in a difficult topic while being calm, cool, and collected
@@austinquick6285 First and foremost that humanitarian stand point is most crucial no matter what. Secondly to allow different viewpoints and keep ethical boundaries at the same time. Have a clear moral compass. What are yours?
In the class the professor mentioned resources to learn about that area of Israel. What are those resources that he mentioned sending to the one male student? 1:10:03
I’d like to know how he came to the conclusion that antisemitism came from Christianity. It’s my understanding that antisemitism has its origins a few thousand years ago.
I’m not sure how this topic can be adequately discussed or understood without touching on how religious beliefs are guiding the actions of Hamas and what impact regions beliefs have on both the Israelis and Palestinians people.
Anti semitism was not created by christianity...anti semitism is as old as ancient Egypt..its as old as Judaism itself because it's a highly spiritual and has to do with the fact that Satan hates God's people
Dr. Richards, I feel your point that US weapons are in Hamas' hands is false, according to the Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh, Hamas received $70 million in military help from Iran. "We have rockets that are locally manufactured but the long-range rockets came from abroad, from Iran, Syria, and others through Egypt," Every photo of a Palestinian fighter with a weapon appears to be an AK 47
On the point made at minute 24 that nobody in Gaza supports Hamas. •Hamas was actually elected in 2006. Polls in 2021 found that: •53% of Palestinians (both Gaza and West Bank) see Hamas as "most deserving of representing and leading the Palestinian people." And •50% of Gazans did not agree that "Hamas should stop calling for Israel's destruction and instead accept a 2-state solution". •You don't see any protests, civil uprising or mass demonstrations against Hamas and its savagery by the Gazans or other Palestinians.
@@SOC119 Some have judged the election to be legitimate and others illegitimate. But the international observers have judged the election to be peaceful, free and fair. The EU, the Bush Administration and the National Democratic Institute have all approved the election. Regardless. My other points still stand. The opinion polls suggest not only support for Hamas but also for their attacks on Israel. And there is a lack of any visible civil disagreement or protests by the Palestinians against Hamas and their actions.
when the Palestinians have been disenfranchised for this long, I almost can't completely blame them for going to extremes How do you feel about Israel's current ultra-conservative coalition government?
I've watched almost every video after stumbling upon this class. Mad respect to the teacher, he doesn't push left or right views but gives both sides. We need more teachers and classes like this to have these discussions without pushing an agenda
Some say that sociology is a waste of time because it doesn't lead to employment, or because it's possible to learn the same things by reading on your own. And it might be too much power in the hands of an authority figure like a teacher, depending on the teacher's views of course. What I find mind-blowing is that lots of people talk about how many Palestinians died but nobody talks about the Israeli hostages and the invasion that was the starting point of this current conflict?. "About Hamas, what are you going to do?" Well, depose them? If you "don't like them", why keep them? This is not about the people, it's about their governments, In both Palestine (as it seems that Hamas is the ruler) and the Israeli government.
“Violence, naked force, has settled more issues in history than has any other factor, and the contrary opinion is wishful thinking at its worst." This is a war of ideology not reason. It will not be settled with words. Its a shame but this is what you want and this is what you get.
"[Anti-semitism] doesn't emerge out of Islam." That's a doozy... Hard to take a sociologist seriously when he is unable to acknowledge Islam (or at least popular expressions of it) as fertile soil for antisemitism.
The only comment I have is that he needs to read up on his history of the land. Want it called Judea? It was named Palestine by the Romans but the people were still Jewish
interesting lecture but a bit nieve in many ways - notice at the end he says 'hamas gained power' - guess professor didn't want to mention that hamas was voted into power after the occupation ended
Great professor. He clearly laid out some obvious and true facts of the situation on the ground. Although he failed to mention that there's not way to achieve peace without taking power away from hamas first. You can't have peace when the "leaders" of one party are hell bent on the opposite.
Here from Israel and wanted to say thank you for doing this topic... I wanted to write something long about my feelings that probably most Isrealies feel at this time, but I decided not to. If wanted I can elaborate to whoever wants. But again thank you for taking the time and not choosing a side. It's very important to look at the bigger picture.
Hello! My name is Maria, and I am from the USA, with a Syrian father and armenian mother. I would genuinely like to here your perspective and have a meaningful conversation.
@@DrDeen1828 If I remember correctly, civilians were given a warning to leave Faluja before the Marines went in. It accomplished two things in Faluja, the civilians left and more enemy combatants moved in. When the Marines went in, the whole city effectively became a free-fire zone and, largely, the only people in the city were Marines and enemy combatants.
Because that would be saying the truth. The reality is that there is such antisemitism the other side will not admit to the true purpose of Hamas or the PLO, or Iran,
Surely, all people around the world hope for peace? Standing up for our ideals, should be done in a peaceful way, respectful of others and accomodating to the rights of others to live and prosper in peace.
Great video! I remember when seeing all of the posts going around on social media, I didn’t know what to think. People asked me where I stand… and I said I just didn’t know enough about the history of the two countries to say. Posts online said not saying anything was bad too, but I just stayed quiet. I took my time, and found that the conflict between Isreal and Palestine is complicated, much more complicated than the people online seem to realize. Even upon beginning to try to scrape the crust on the history of the conflict, it was obvious right away that even if I knew all there was to know, how could I take a side? The biggest truth was that people were dying. Palestinians were dying, and Israeli were dying.. and so i just couldn’t side with either. It’s a fight that has had many attempts at seeking an end, many peace attempts, and it hasn’t worked. I think what’s most disturbing to me, is that when discussing this online a comment I’ve faced is that Palestine is more justified because Israeli is worse to them and has killed more people.. ever sickening! It’s that kind of mindset that keeps that fight going. An eye for an eye! I hope a solution can be found someday. I wish people could just sit down, ignore the media for a moment, and take their time to really look at what’s happening here and realize it’s not about picking sides. It’s about ending suffering.
He has a lot of great points but I’m not sure many people that had their home taken away from them by some settler would embrace the other side lol And yea you say you know more in the last 40+ years but this has been even longer than that, and yes what Hamas did was terrible on oct7, but what has happened the last 75 years… wouldn’t you think after being oppressed for so long that sooner or later it’s just gonna boil over? Like finklestein said, eventually it was gonna happen I’m on question 3 but felt like I needed to post Now that I’ve gotten further along the discussion, sounds like he was just trying to lower all the hate the Jews have gotten more than anything, and if he idols Netanyahu for the last 10 years, sounds like he’d probably talk a little different today than he did whenever this was done or I would hope so since he sounds like he cares for humanity lol I keep editing, I don’t like the fact that it’s always Hamas has been doing this atrocities but the Jews or zionists have been doing the same thing lol this will be my last edit, good luck to everyone in the world and hope for peace for everyone
Nobody would be being oppressed by anybody had the Surronding Muslim nations not try to take out Israel a year or 2 after its inception. At least to my knowledge, Isreal has never launched an offensive attack in the region unprovoked. Now unfortunately, cause humans are humans, religion is already a huge basis for rivalry (whether violent or not) and when you toss in wars trying to eliminate Isreal right after it's inception (right after the holocaust also) the unfortunate dislike and hatred is born generational on both sides. How you fix that I don't know, at this point there probably is no fixing it maybe except if both sides agree to put themselves in timeout with an international oversight committee of sorts if that makes sense
true, ... seems like, he's doing damage control for israel. ... he finds it hard to call occupation as occupation!! there was fair exchange in west-bank?! ridiculous!! AND, he forgot to mention the difference between Jews and Zionists
He was simply saying, that despite the autrocities in the past, from the opposing side, it still doesn’t justify hamas massacre. It’s not defendable. It just fuels the fire.
![[UA] NAVI vs MOUZ | BO5 | IEM Rio 2024](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/CMBYk0cbGoA/mqdefault.jpg)
I don’t know how to begin to express the depth of respect for what you do in your classroom or have been teaching our kids! Thank you for this class and for your work.
His basic premis is all wrong this isn't a Palestinisn Jewish thing. It's about Zionists & Israelis. Muslims don't hate Jews. Move on from that. Now let's talk about the Israeli Zionist settlers which are way way different than my good Jewish neighbor
@@AnnMarieAisha Muslims don't hate Jews? Religious Muslims hate Jews. period. Just ask the Jewish population in the suburbs of Amsterdam & Paris where there's been a big immigrant Muslim population move in.
@@AnnMarieAishaThis guy with his thoughts and speech nothing more than gibberish, little to none of anything being factual or even reality.
I feel sorry for these kids having to trust these education system that's force-feeding all this propaganda crap in their minds.
@Eliyahu673 the nature of your comment...no substance, just insults, violates every principle of good dialog and ratchets up the credibility and honesty of the whole conversation. Try the approach of this man's great Lebanese mentor
@@rosalindpaaswell9513 Is this one of those times, because you say so. Hum!
Biblical History won't validate what this guy is is saying. World History, not even secular history will support his pseudo belief and his so called experience. For one it's built upon a lie and you can't make a lie be the truth. The Bible clearly make it known to those that seek truth that the whole world has been lied to. But I 'm sure he wouldn't know nothing about that since he made it know that he's so proudly stated that he was an atheist. That along is worth examining and questioning.
In general just tired of sincere honest seeking truth about many things and are being lied to on so many levels and through all these systems designed to deceived. Wheater gullible, naive,or a lack of studying or knowledge.
First UA-cam comment in my life. Much love and respect to Dr. Sam Richards for a fair and accurate conversation led with compassion and humanity. So much more of what we need.
I've studied the conflict for the better part of two decades. It would've been easy to spend the entire class answering just one or two of the questions thoroughly. But it was beautiful to lead with empathy and debunk fear, conspiracies, and cynicism. Bravo!
After this lecture, I can barely watch any other commentary on this topic with good conscience. Thank you so much, this has been so valuable.
He's clearly biased and gaslighting others. If you want the whole truth. Try listening to other unbiased Jews such as Norman Finkelstein and Ilan Pappe
THEN SHARE IT
What's the name of the man speaking? Is he a professor? I'm new to his content.
@@AB-zq4fw Samuel Richards, a sociology professor from PennState in Pennsylvania
How? What did you learn?
Dr. RIchards is a gem. It is so rare to find teachers like there nowadays.
Thank you, Dr. Richard's
I have a college education, but I've always enjoyed every history class, from yesterday to 2 million years ago. I'm a respiratory therapist, but I have 32 historical credits.
I love to learn actual facts and not media propaganda. You're an incredible professor and teacher of both sides.
Thank you for furthering my education, especially with the history, situation, the actions, and protesting happening in America and all over the world, especially since October 7th.
Sincerely
MLBW1966
I like the way the professor is massaging the brains of the students. Bless this beautiful loving teacher
we learn by being critical not caressing people's feelings
I really like this professor. I really agree with his stance on honouring the suffering of other human beings. It's the absolute minimum moral action we can take as individuals, especially if we feel we have no other way to help.
Thank you Sam for continuing to provide a space that puts humans unequivocally first. I learned a lot, and I think a lot more than just your students could use this right now.
Can you please explain a bit more
Dr. Richards, I have been on the Gaza and in Israel on several occasions and you are absolutely correct. The last question and your answer summarized the discussion perfectly. Your discussions are reminiscent of my days at St. Louis U.(Go Billikens) Critical thought is rare in this Millenium. If you reach 10% of your students you will be successful. I was also delighted to hear you cite some of the news sources we utilized in the intelligence community. My daughter is now a member of that community as well and he eyes and mind are wide open.
let her know muslims and their narrow thinking! she will understand that there's no peace under sharia law.
He's reaching a lot more then 10 % of his students through platforms like this
The poster didn't mean reaching 10% of students as someone watching the lectures. It means that 10% of those students actually listened and thought of the content and were able to think critically.
There were 3000 Christians in Gaza in 2005, and now there are less than 1000 and 0 Jews there. Hamas and the Gazans don't treat non-muslims well, and if you're Muslim, you have to follow their strict laws that are full of harsh punishments and penalties that we in America would never see here because of the 8th amendment in our Constitution.
@@Bittzenonly if we allow them to gain control over our country, which is their goal, even if it takes a thousand years.
These are the conversations we need to be having. People need to truly see things from both sides. Talk to everyone instead of staying in your own little bubble.
What I really appreciate is that he takes his time to think about the questions before answerimg them. I think everyone can use this for better conversations.
Seeing all the propaganda that boils over in the universes, this guy is a real gem with a good vocabulary and knowledge. This is what brings the world forward, not the woke hate speech from leftist professors. This guy may be a leftist for all I know, but he has the ability to put things into perspective.
Thank you! I'm 62 years young & I learnt loads from this.
We never had these conversations when I was at school or at college.
What did you learn
As an Israeli (that currently lives In the south of the country ), I would love to have a follow up with actual Israelis and Palestinians. I think our perspectives are important here and a lot is missing.
I’m more than willing to be in said conversation btw.
I want to see that conversation
That is really the only conversation we need to hear as we have no idea but the narritive we are sold
Hey! Email Sam at staff@soc119.org. Let's get connected @Razbrosh12
That is, only if there is Israeli and Palestinian students at that college
@@randymarsh9488
I am sure it is not difficult to find some to talk to. I would be more than happy to come.
If both parties want peace there will be peace. If one party wants war there will be war.
very well said
If one party wants the whole of Israel for itself and the other is willing to share with others there cannot ever be peace. One democratic state/nation/country with Jews, Arabs and a mixed and diverse multitude from the nations appears to be the only possible solution. Sadly, this seems very unlikely.
If (say) 60% of both communities support war, the rest has no stand.
To bad
It’s easy for you to say peace for both parties. It’s difficult to have peace when one group steals the houses and the land from the others
@@Ali-xu4db Which group is that?
We need more professors like him, spitting facts and truth.
Gotta appreciate the good work you do trying to give the next generation perspective. Truly being able to voice and informed opinion on a matter requires the upmost dedication and research to give that subject its due diligence. Hopefully we can keep the young minds open and awake.
I think this is exactly what is lacking so direly in education - to show young people how to develop an individual perspective that's not an easy, borrowed, cult position such as are constantly thrust towards the individual in the media. To think not by deciding first the position you want to reach and then looking for arguments to support it, but from the desire to reach a solid position. And that a position that is not incendiary or dramatic is more useful in dialogue.
Thank you so much of this lecture. Hope has returned to my mind. Instead of a raging storm and thunder, there’s calm and rain. I’m so grateful. Thank you, thank you, thank you so much. 🙏
When he said human being just want to get on with there lives hit me hard... I was shot 6 times and flat lined a couple of times and my honest to God feeling after the initial trauma was to forgive that man that shot me. In my mind he will answer to God, my life has been absolutely great after moving past Revenge feeling, I have to live especially for my kids. Forgiveness was the best decision I made ....
These sorts of forums of discussion should be available to everyone, in the way the Greeks and the Romans could publicly meet at the forums to hear the thinkers speak and co verse with the masses in a real personal level. This changes minds and broadens peoples concepts of the world.
Gazans did in fact vote Hamas into power though you are correct that since then there have been no elections. Additionally, it is quite obvious that Hamas is very popular among Palestinians. Even in the West Bank where it is dangerous to be a Hamas supporter because their rival political party Fatah is in charge, it is still quite common to have Hamas supporters.
No, it isn’t very popular. Their popularity is increasing after the bombings.
@@DearProfessorRF Long I bet you haven't lived here but yes it is very popular but it depends on region and clan/tribal/family affiliation. There are entire towns fully affiliated with Hamas lol.
@@whydoIneedone846 don’t ever become a professional gambler, then, and keep your daytime job.
@DearProfessorRF you have that backwards and he is correct. The Palestinians supported them fully untill the bombings started. That's why in the rocket attack u see basically every1 celebrating and now we're getting civilian videos condemning hamas.
@@GimPGrows How exactly can we be sure the elections were not rigged by Hamas themselves? How come you trust them as a source when it comes to this particular claim, but reject of all the other claims presented by their news media?
as a canadian. a right leaning for certain canadian, I consider myself fairly intellectual. And I constantly seek truths, and I constantly aseek resolutions. And I also am often catching myself asking wtf. I salute you, and your efforts, and your approach to putting the real matter into light in a way that you connect with your peers/students what have you. Thank you for this. I myself needed to see this. You have made a difference. Thanks man.
Amazing work Sam. Your experiences, your perspectives are truly eye opening & I look forward to hear more. Thank you!!
Some people with angry expressions in the class.
So glad this is posted so those outside this class have the privilege to watch it. Thanks.
@1:15:00 hamas attacked because Israel was talking to the saudis and iran didn't like that
Not that simple
Totally agree
Can u elaborate a bit? This is the first I’ve heard this. I’m genuinely curious. I don’t know much about the conflict or it’s motives
Taking control of our thoughts is essential. Proverbs 4:23 states, "Above all else, guard your heart, for it is the wellspring of life." The “heart” includes the mind and all that proceeds from it. Someone said that every sin we commit, we commit twice, once in our thoughts and again when we act upon those thoughts. It is easier to rid our lives of sin if we attack it at this fundamental thought level rather than waiting for it to become rooted in our lives by our actions and then try to pull it out.
My favorite college professor, Gennadiy Barabtarlo, wasn't half as emotive as Sam here, but he radiated the same kindness and thoughtfulness. ❤
Beautiful. Articulate. This is what we need more of. I’m personally a Zionist and this has really opened my mind to allow myself to try understand another perspective. I have always thought I am very open however this is showing I have more work to do. Thank you
Thank you for fostering an environment of intellectual curiosity WITH empathy. Talking about this in the framework of the average individual person on either side was (hopefully) very productive.
When the professor told the student to go learn about the history of the landmass that was gold. The student was so caught up in his own train of thought and ideals. Bro didn’t unfocus 😂
I have heard Palestinian and other Arabs interviewed that expressed greater denial than he did. I wonder how history is taught there, and what passes for archeology, S many think there was never an Israel, and Jews only passed through recently, but Palestine has been a thing for millenia.
@elliri3012 It is unfortunate, but its ideology that drives their interpretation of history.
History like " ἀπὸ γὰρ Φοινίκης μέχρι οὔρων τῶν Καδύτιος πόλιος ἐστὶ Σύρων τῶν Παλαιστίνων καλεομένων"?
professor should learn the history, so many errors, and partial history
@@aleejones7508 What exactly did he say that was wrong?
Said a lot without saying much. He has been there and met these people and spoke to these people but all he told me is that he knows and we don’t. Tell us what we don’t know… Teach man!
I felt the same way. I don’t understand as to why he is getting so much praise. Very strange to me. He begins one sentence and then when finishing a thought he begins to shift the conversation. I feel he would be insightful but I didn’t get to gain that insight n
@@MahalTSJ he loves to liste to himself but eventhough he talked a lot without saying anything he tried to deliver the message that in general people there just try to live their lives and that we should try not to see this conflict as good vs evil. It is a simple message but it is missing in everybodys heads
Thanks Professor Sam, you are a very brave man!
As an atheist myself, I can tell you’re doing the work of god. Thank you.
As an atheist, as well, I would second that.
Thirded
I am so thankful you are able to conduct your classes the way you do. Too many professors have lost their livelihoods for touching far smaller and less controversial (and, therefore, less important) topics.
I think today with all that is going on quite a few colleges need to have this lecture played to all students@
I wish everyone in the country could see this thoughtful presentation. It isn’t superficially “bothsides,” it’s a clear-eyed look at all sides. The saddest point was that most people in the region are not looking for a fight.
Well, outside of Gaza and West Bank, maybe, where over half of people have a positive view of Hamas.
The leaders of both sides are looking for a fight. And those leaders on both sides are willing to sacrifice their people in order to stay in power indefinitely.
The Palestinians in the West Bank do not support Hamas. The Gaza Strip is a different story, but conflating the two is precisely the kind of naïve, unnuanced, one-sided, ignorant narrative the English-speaking world news-media is trying to sell you here.
"I trust the bbc" "Aljazira".... XD omg this professor is insane
I’m an Israeli citizen and I can say I love what this guy has to say. He actually went and tried to understand my country, although I don’t agree with everything he says (which is normal and ok), I respect him for actually learning about it himself and not relying on often politically charged sources. We need more people like Prof. Richards.
7:39 Criticism of you can boil down to “you had an hour long conversation and ended where you started”. Maybe you don’t want to come up with a solution.
1:11:08 hearing this… maybe having conversation with humility is right. Admitting we won’t find the solution today, but that we’re willing to keep coming back to talk.
If we don’t have the conversation… someone with something to gain will
I appreciate and respect your attempt at having a open discussion and trying to help develop empathy and broad thinking in your students. At the same time you are stumbling into moral equivalency in small nuanced yet dangerous way that undermines your primary intention. And you have some inaccuracies that you need to be educated on.
He should debate Finkelstein
You are doing God's work
Professor, I just want to say thank you very much it’s awesome to see somebody is caring issue trying to teach the younger generation what is right and not what CNN says is.
Two things
1. Prior to the current outbreak of fighting, to what degree was this statement true, “If the Arabs put down their weapons today, there would be no more violence. If the Jews put down their weapons today, there would be no more Israel.”
2. Can the IDF separate average Palestinians from Hamas when Hamas fires rockets from school grounds and housing complexes?
Hmmm so ure saying children are hard to be identified cooooool.
@fragment97 Hamas and other terrorist organizations happily use children as shields and pawns for their own gain. It's a bit more nuanced than that my man.
@@fragment97 He’s saying Hamas using children as human shields makes collateral damage certain. This damage is relatively likely in normal war but is exacerbated still through hostages, blending of civilian and terrorist presence, and using of infrastructure as militant springboards.
@fragment97 if you use children as human shields, you at the very least don't have the moral high ground. To them the children are martyrs. Hamas sees their sacrifice as a worthy dead. The love death as much as the jews love life. It's their motto
@@fragment97 IDF has weapon systems that are capable of tracking rockets back to their launch point. More times than not the IDF doesn’t shoot back because the launchers are next to a school, a hospital or apartment complex.
Serious question; if your adversary is shooting at you from behind a hospital, what do you do?
A person may be an independent thinker, but people as a collective can be lead anyway you want, much like sheep.
im from israel, i think you made a great job and every proffesor should be like you❤
Cool to see, but if everyone he met in Gaza didn’t support Hamas, then it also says a bit about his sample size. He met the people most interested in finding peace, so that is somewhat expected. But its hardly comprehensive of what Palestinians think.
People want peace more, violence will always linger more and cause more conflicts
Do you have a better source?
It just looks like he hasn't really investigated abd just met wonderful people but that's picky not random people with random opinions he has the minimum idea of what's actually going on here I expected more honestly
The nuanced perspective that both sides are not interested in telling. Thank you for this lecture, you have brought me much clarity :)
I’ll be honest, I watched every minute of this, and I really didn’t learn anything. Sure he’s a nice guy and he’s a good perspective on world peace, and he’s proven to challenge his own perspective, but i literally didn’t learn anything about the conflict. I just learned about him.. and everyone in the comment section is giving this class praise just because he proved himself to be a “good” guy by not picking a side.
You won’t learn a thing if you’re still not able to consider what peace is about.
Try to examine your biases & watch this again ;-)
@@Souxie123 that’s the issue. I have no biases, therefore I did not learn anything. Perhaps if I was a narrow minded individual, this class could have benefitted the way I think and reflect, but as far as actual material in regards to the conflict, I didn’t learn a single thing.
@@austinquick6285I missed the sosiology in this lecture..
@@MrKn0w17A11 when I think of sociology, I think of culture, and the history behind that culture. Like, your right, it kind of was missing the sociology. Don’t get me wrong, I’m sure a lot of students benefitted in this particular class, as far as being able to “zoom out” and simultaneously view a situation empathetically and objectively.. which can go on to be beneficial in future classes. But yeah you’re right, the actual sociology was missing imo.
That means that you knew everything he said
I think this professor is an asset to humanity as a whole and I really hope all his wishes for peace come true.
Well done. The concept of "unfocus" and the nuance you've given these young adults is essential in not only this but every major social topic of debate.
Sam Richards and I would disagree on many things and yet we come together on more than anyone would think from either “side”. He keeps trying in many of his classes to drill down to the point of personal experience and how it conflicts with the understood narrative or accepted views. I would love to sit and talk with him for a few hours, I am a conservative with a similar mindset…I think most people miss the bigger picture he is trying to paint.
The answer to the question of why did Hamas launch this war is not found in a reported provocation that Israel committed in the recent past. The answer lies in Iran. If you are not seriously discussing the Iranian regime and their influence on this attack in Israel, you are not being honest with yourself.
Did Iran help, definitely yes, is it the reason, definitely not
It would be interesting to know what you mean by ‘recent past’.
@@malakashraf2801 don't so sure....I certainly am not
Recent past as in 2000 or as in 1948. You're trying to add context by eliminating context
@@OsiAleogena proximity in time matters when discussing cause and effect. I’ve heard people say, “Well, I don’t want to talk about 10/7. I want to talk about 1948.” And I’m thinking, “Well, why stop there? Let’s talk about 1936, 1929, 1920, 1914, 1834, 1660, 1517…” Things weren’t peaches and cream even before 1948, so it seems nonsensical to keep kicking the can backwards in time to things that are not direct causation. To me it seems like a deflection tactic, because people don’t want to tackle tough issues that are factually inconvenient.
After two weeks of diving into everything possible about this conflict, it is time to focus on my priorities. Great session. I would have liked to have heard a question of The Hamas Charter. Otherwise thanks tonall youbstudents to being there.
I watched many lectures and debates ....... and I have to be straight forward by saying that this lecture led me to nowhere. Absolute waste of time.
1. "Everybody wants peace" .......
2. " People are just living their lives"
3. ....."theres misinformation""" ....blah .....blah ....blah
NOTHING MENTIONED ABOUT ILLEGAL SETTLEMENTS AND EXPANSION OF ISSR@EEL AND THE EVER CHANGING MAP THERE
Hamas did not "took over" after Israel left Gaza in the early 200os. Hamas was ELECTED in democratic elections by the PEOPLE in Gaza. Polls today show that Hamas has 70% support. How can he say that he met with hundreds of Palestinians from Gaza and not a single one of them supported Hamas? The hundreds that he met must have been a very special subclass, not representative of the Gaza (and Palestinian) population at great. It's like saying that he met hundreds of Americans and not a single one of them supported the Republicans (or the Democrats).
My argument too. How did Hamas grow? What about the suicide bombers , the training of kids by Hamas. Hamas proudly posted these things so it's not propaganda
He was is the West Bank where at the probably early-mid 2000s the support for Hamad there was negligeble. Nowadays the support in WB to Farah is fading and the support to Hamas is increasing although I doubt to the degree that has been seen in Gaza. After the post 7-Oct conflict is difficult to assert the Gazan support for Hamad, and Gaza is becoming a shell of what it was.
You know how “voting” works in a totalitarian regime right?
That’s a long time to go without an election.
What's missing from this conversation in the area of Civilian casualties is how Hamas intertwines its military infrastructure with the civilian. Also there's a false moral equivalency here between purposefully attacking and trying to kill civilians and accidentally killing them because you're trying to get at the people that want to kill you. Saying that Israel cannot strike back as it does in Gaza is basically saying that Hamas is allowed to hit them but Israel is no way allowed to strike back because the cat avoid civilian casualties because, back to point one, Hamas intertwines their military with the civilians.
The other false equivalency here is just because more on the enemy side die then do your guys does not make you wrong. Ten times more German civilians died from the English bombing Germany then did English civilians. Was England wrong the prosecution of the war to get rid of the Nazis?
So if there is a person that you want to get at and he is in a hospital, do you think it’s morally right to obliterate the entire block? And by the evidence that we are seeing so far, Isnotreal hasn’t been able to prove that H amas fighters are in any civilian structures..
Well maybe israel shouldn't habe started this war
So you have learned absolutely nothing. @@xeibei4804
I think this could help young people understand equality and the fact that we as people we all want the same things:
People
I see people around the world
We all have the same pictures in the phone
Family love and friends
Cats and dogs
Smiles and sun
Kids and schools
And a picture on the wall
I see people around the world
We all have the same dreams in our phone
A house a car
A kid a home and a fire place to warm us all
And a picture on the wall
I see people around the world
Why if we all want peace
We keep fighting each other like a beast
We all have the same dreams on the phone
Of that picture on that wall
Sam does a very good job of explaining nuance and complexity a well shaped discussion brought from a place of experience.
Really? Does he discuss complexity theory at all during this discussion?
Did you watch the video ? Did he miss something 🤔 add it in to the comments. I'm not sure what complexity theory is but I do understand discussing topics or discussions in general and I thought it was a well made video opening my mind to new ideas.
@@bleekrides Complexity theory and game theory are hugely relevant to the political science aspects of this conflict. It was tediously frustrating to sit through all the fluff in this lecture, so I was asking to see if he ever got to anything substantive. This is supposed to be a university class, not a kindergarten.
@chrisheist652 No, he mostly covers his time in the areas now being fought over and how we here in the u.s. need to understand this is a very complex issue between Palestine and Isreal. Take a moment to focus on the many nuances of both sides. And not get swept up in fire and passion that may resemble anti Semitism. It a college class sure. But are all student logical analytical thinkers ? Some may be closer to kindergarten students. A professor teaching people to take a 10k foot view of the issues I think is certainly a place to get these kids started.
This was a great thing to do, so many school/college kids will be astounded by the silence from their teachers on this topic. I wonder how Dr Richards would feel about events now though, things have become worse than we could possibly have imagined on the 12th October regarding the vengance of Israel, when you see footage from Palestinian press, and from idf soldiers, it's not like anything we have ever seen before.
Thank you Sir! Much appreciated! Very insightful lecrure! We need more informatjon and platfeoms like this. 🙌🙌✌️🙏🏻🕊
Context and being educated on the facts of a subject and all the different complexities involved is a wonderful thing.
When you realize Muslims today honestly think Palestine existed 3,000 years ago, like this young man in class, you can begin to understand the depth of the false information that drives the conflict.
What did you learn thoufh
Wasn't able to watch live today like normal but I'm glad because I had to relisten and think more than usual. Started watching the livestreams at the beginning of the semester and this has been the most interesting/thought provoking/learning experience thus far. But I'm slowly going backwards rewatching old streams so I am sure there will be lots more great conversations. Great approach 👍
I’ve spent 30 years studying the region and it’s conflict. While I agree so many want peace there are many, especially in Gaza, that do not want peace. I’ve found the same info Israelis. The problem is the continued rejection of the 2 state solution by the PLO and others.
I don’t have to repeat the put their guns down line do I?
Send an email to staff@soc119.org
It is a Hamas which doesn’t want a Two-State not the PLO, which is why Netanyahu has been supporting Hamas. Netanyahu doesn’t want a Two-State solution and now 11,000 dead people are paying the price.
@@DearProfessorRFThat’s 100% a conspiracy.
You can dislike Bibi, but to claim he’s trying to propagate war shows your extreme bias.
Especially as he actively tried to communicate peace and open deals with SA.
@@fedbia2003 this is how you say this is a joke without saying this is a joke. Not even Israelis like Netanyahu unless you’re a far-right right racist like the rest of his Likud party. Well, now he and thousands of dead are paying the price of his political calculations.
Netanyahu is on record as supporting H***s (No this isn't a crack pot theory. His comments to his party conference in 2019 were widely reported in mainstream media as saying explicitly that)
Was fun to catch a live one!
Chat was nice and civil, thanks again guys.. love this class.
I’d bet the channel grows pretty quickly, I’ve already seen folks doing reaction videos 👍
Sir I really appreciate what you've said I will make a change in people's prospective
great Lecture ! i really wish that more people could learn this lesson!
This guy is great. He should be flown round all the top Universities in America to have a word with some of the lunatics running round campuses "protesting" at the moment
This is why I think we don't know the half of it all here in our insulated US. I enjoy this man's lectures. I also agree that critical thinking is exorcised less and less these days.
Here in my final year at a university in California. With this kind of civility from you compared to most staff and students on campus, really wish I could have someone like you as my professor for a class like yours. Thank you for exceptional discussion in a difficult topic while being calm, cool, and collected
This guy needs to be saved at all costs
Thank you, that was very insightful.
@31:00 it does matter when it comes to the 1 state 2 state... 1 state= no Israel and Muslim rule.
Not true. There is literally a possibility of it not being Muslim rule.
It’s just not probable.
Great classroom! All participants a great thank you. We can learn a lot from you interaction.
What did u learn?
@@austinquick6285 First and foremost that humanitarian stand point is most crucial no matter what. Secondly to allow different viewpoints and keep ethical boundaries at the same time. Have a clear moral compass.
What are yours?
In the class the professor mentioned resources to learn about that area of Israel. What are those resources that he mentioned sending to the one male student? 1:10:03
I’d like to know how he came to the conclusion that antisemitism came from Christianity. It’s my understanding that antisemitism has its origins a few thousand years ago.
I’m not sure how this topic can be adequately discussed or understood without touching on how religious beliefs are guiding the actions of Hamas and what impact regions beliefs have on both the Israelis and Palestinians people.
I want just to meet you to say thank you for this wonderful lesson ❤️
I'm curious about his statement, "Antisemitism emerged out of Christianity instead of Islam?" Can you please explain that to me? Genuine question.
Look at history, Muslims have a history of protecting Jews from Christians. Look at the glory days Jews had in Turkey.
Anti semitism was not created by christianity...anti semitism is as old as ancient Egypt..its as old as Judaism itself because it's a highly spiritual and has to do with the fact that Satan hates God's people
Dr. Richards, I feel your point that US weapons are in Hamas' hands is false, according to the Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh, Hamas received $70 million in military help from Iran. "We have rockets that are locally manufactured but the long-range rockets came from abroad, from Iran, Syria, and others through Egypt," Every photo of a Palestinian fighter with a weapon appears to be an AK 47
Agreed. That's from 25:43.
Excellent class. Thank you
On the point made at minute 24 that nobody in Gaza supports Hamas.
•Hamas was actually elected in 2006.
Polls in 2021 found that:
•53% of Palestinians (both Gaza and West Bank) see Hamas as "most deserving of representing and leading the Palestinian people."
And
•50% of Gazans did not agree that "Hamas should stop calling for Israel's destruction and instead accept a 2-state solution".
•You don't see any protests, civil uprising or mass demonstrations against Hamas and its savagery by the Gazans or other Palestinians.
Read about how that election unfolded. That was not an election like one in a modern democratic state.
And you really believe 81 million people voted for Biden?.
And polls can be very biased.
@@SOC119
Some have judged the election to be legitimate and others illegitimate. But the international observers have judged the election to be peaceful, free and fair. The EU, the Bush Administration and the National Democratic Institute have all approved the election.
Regardless. My other points still stand. The opinion polls suggest not only support for Hamas but also for their attacks on Israel. And there is a lack of any visible civil disagreement or protests by the Palestinians against Hamas and their actions.
when the Palestinians have been disenfranchised for this long, I almost can't completely blame them for going to extremes
How do you feel about Israel's current ultra-conservative coalition government?
@Hadiye The Kingdom of Israel has been in Israel for close to 4000 yrs, & you focus on the term state? Desperate at all?
I've watched almost every video after stumbling upon this class. Mad respect to the teacher, he doesn't push left or right views but gives both sides. We need more teachers and classes like this to have these discussions without pushing an agenda
This calmed my thoughts. I felt ur sigh in the questions... but you reached many. Just hold that vision for just a second... humanity over virtue
2/3rds of the students could give a shit about what a gift this man is for them.
Question number 6 I agree with the statement, he was warned. We all know that Israel is the most protected country on earth, so how did it happen?
Some say that sociology is a waste of time because it doesn't lead to employment, or because it's possible to learn the same things by reading on your own.
And it might be too much power in the hands of an authority figure like a teacher, depending on the teacher's views of course.
What I find mind-blowing is that lots of people talk about how many Palestinians died but nobody talks about the Israeli hostages and the invasion that was the starting point of this current conflict?.
"About Hamas, what are you going to do?" Well, depose them? If you "don't like them", why keep them?
This is not about the people, it's about their governments, In both Palestine (as it seems that Hamas is the ruler) and the Israeli government.
Don't underestimate the power of War for conflict resolution. When your enemies are dead and broken, peace takes root.
“Violence, naked force, has settled more issues in history than has any other factor, and the contrary opinion is wishful thinking at its worst." This is a war of ideology not reason. It will not be settled with words. Its a shame but this is what you want and this is what you get.
"[Anti-semitism] doesn't emerge out of Islam." That's a doozy... Hard to take a sociologist seriously when he is unable to acknowledge Islam (or at least popular expressions of it) as fertile soil for antisemitism.
Antisemitism comes from the Christians dude.
@@Souxie123 who's saying it doesn't?
French woman here, I guess I didn’t understand your com.
Both religions have their own form of Antisemitism, neither one exist because of the other. Each side has its own relationship with Judaism.
@@Souxie123 how
Compare how Muslims are treated in the West and how Muslims treat others in their countries.
Omg you actually wanna see how Muslims treat others in Muslim countries look at the dhimmi system.
The only comment I have is that he needs to read up on his history of the land. Want it called Judea? It was named Palestine by the Romans but the people were still Jewish
The Romans used that name to antagonize the Jews.
I'd go to Penn State just to listen to him.
interesting lecture but a bit nieve in many ways - notice at the end he says 'hamas gained power' - guess professor didn't want to mention that hamas was voted into power after the occupation ended
Great professor. He clearly laid out some obvious and true facts of the situation on the ground. Although he failed to mention that there's not way to achieve peace without taking power away from hamas first. You can't have peace when the "leaders" of one party are hell bent on the opposite.
Here from Israel and wanted to say thank you for doing this topic... I wanted to write something long about my feelings that probably most Isrealies feel at this time, but I decided not to. If wanted I can elaborate to whoever wants. But again thank you for taking the time and not choosing a side. It's very important to look at the bigger picture.
Hello! My name is Maria, and I am from the USA, with a Syrian father and armenian mother. I would genuinely like to here your perspective and have a meaningful conversation.
+
+@@mariamanaa-cs6qr
I REALLY don’t think that the Palestinians want to be left alone. Unless it is only to give them time to sharpen their butcher knives.
Why doesn't anyone point out that GAZaNs was warned to evacuate and was given time hamas did not give no warning
Something practically unheard-of in the history of warfare. Only other instances I've heard of were Hiroshima and Nagasaki
It's pointed out quite a bit, but within this whole class, I don't think that's the point.
@@DrDeen1828that is a little known fact but is very important.
@@DrDeen1828 If I remember correctly, civilians were given a warning to leave Faluja before the Marines went in. It accomplished two things in Faluja, the civilians left and more enemy combatants moved in. When the Marines went in, the whole city effectively became a free-fire zone and, largely, the only people in the city were Marines and enemy combatants.
Because that would be saying the truth. The reality is that there is such antisemitism the other side will not admit to the true purpose of Hamas or the PLO, or Iran,
Surely, all people around the world hope for peace?
Standing up for our ideals, should be done in a peaceful way, respectful of others and accomodating to the rights of others to live and prosper in peace.
Best questions made so far start with "So I'm like really uneducated....."
accepting ignorance is the start of learning.
Great video! I remember when seeing all of the posts going around on social media, I didn’t know what to think.
People asked me where I stand… and I said I just didn’t know enough about the history of the two countries to say. Posts online said not saying anything was bad too, but I just stayed quiet.
I took my time, and found that the conflict between Isreal and Palestine is complicated, much more complicated than the people online seem to realize. Even upon beginning to try to scrape the crust on the history of the conflict, it was obvious right away that even if I knew all there was to know, how could I take a side?
The biggest truth was that people were dying. Palestinians were dying, and Israeli were dying.. and so i just couldn’t side with either. It’s a fight that has had many attempts at seeking an end, many peace attempts, and it hasn’t worked.
I think what’s most disturbing to me, is that when discussing this online a comment I’ve faced is that Palestine is more justified because Israeli is worse to them and has killed more people.. ever sickening! It’s that kind of mindset that keeps that fight going. An eye for an eye!
I hope a solution can be found someday. I wish people could just sit down, ignore the media for a moment, and take their time to really look at what’s happening here and realize it’s not about picking sides. It’s about ending suffering.
He has a lot of great points but I’m not sure many people that had their home taken away from them by some settler would embrace the other side lol
And yea you say you know more in the last 40+ years but this has been even longer than that, and yes what Hamas did was terrible on oct7, but what has happened the last 75 years… wouldn’t you think after being oppressed for so long that sooner or later it’s just gonna boil over? Like finklestein said, eventually it was gonna happen
I’m on question 3 but felt like I needed to post
Now that I’ve gotten further along the discussion, sounds like he was just trying to lower all the hate the Jews have gotten more than anything, and if he idols Netanyahu for the last 10 years, sounds like he’d probably talk a little different today than he did whenever this was done or I would hope so since he sounds like he cares for humanity
lol I keep editing, I don’t like the fact that it’s always Hamas has been doing this atrocities but the Jews or zionists have been doing the same thing lol this will be my last edit, good luck to everyone in the world and hope for peace for everyone
Nobody would be being oppressed by anybody had the Surronding Muslim nations not try to take out Israel a year or 2 after its inception. At least to my knowledge, Isreal has never launched an offensive attack in the region unprovoked. Now unfortunately, cause humans are humans, religion is already a huge basis for rivalry (whether violent or not) and when you toss in wars trying to eliminate Isreal right after it's inception (right after the holocaust also) the unfortunate dislike and hatred is born generational on both sides. How you fix that I don't know, at this point there probably is no fixing it maybe except if both sides agree to put themselves in timeout with an international oversight committee of sorts if that makes sense
true, ... seems like, he's doing damage control for israel. ... he finds it hard to call occupation as occupation!! there was fair exchange in west-bank?! ridiculous!! AND, he forgot to mention the difference between Jews and Zionists
He was simply saying, that despite the autrocities in the past, from the opposing side, it still doesn’t justify hamas massacre. It’s not defendable. It just fuels the fire.