I'm Sorry, WHAT? | Reading Reddit Stories
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 чер 2024
- These stories are...too much. Go to factormeals.com/pitreddit50 and use code pitreddit50 to get 50% off your first box plus 20% off your next box.
0:00-0:45 Intro
0:46-13:36 I told my friend her child’s name will ruin her life / aita_for_telling_my_fr...
13:37-29:19 My boyfriend gave away my Hamilton tickets, should we break up? / my_29f_bf32_m_gave_awa...
29:20-30:35 Sponsors!
30:36-42:17 I lied about knowing how to play the piano and now I have to play a show / advice_im_meeting_up_w...
42:18-51:39 I paid my wife for sex / i42m_paid_my_wife42f_f...
51:40-01:04:47 My boyfriend can’t stop eating garlic / aita_for_controlling_w...
SUBSCRIBE: smo.sh/Sub2SmoshPit
WEAR OUR JOKES: smosh.com
WHO YOU SEE
Shayne Topp // / shaynetopp
Amanda Lehan-Canto // / filmingamanda
Arasha Lalani // / arashalalani_
WHO YOU DON’T SEE (usually)
Director: Emily Rose Jacobson
Editor: Vida Robbins
Director of Programming, Smosh Pit: Emily Rose Jacobson
Associate Producer, Smosh Pit: Bailey Petracek
Assistant Director: Amanda Barnes
Art Director: Cassie Vance
Assistant Art Director: Erin Kuschner
Art Coordinator: Alex Aguilar, Josie Bellerby
Prop Assistant: Adam Mustafa
Audio Mixer: Scott Neff
Audio Utility: Dina Ramli
Camera Operator: Eric Wann
Director of Photography: Brennan Iketani
Director of Design: Brittany Hobbs
DIT/Lead AE: Matt Duran
CEO: Alé Catenese
EVP of Production: Zoe Moacanin
EVP of Programming: Kiana Parker
Executive Coordinator: Rachel Collis
IT: Tim Baker
Operations PA: Katie Fink
Post Production Manager: Luke Baker
Production Manager: Amanda Barnes
Production Coordinator: Marcus Munguia
Operations & Production Coordinator: Oliver Wehlander
Production Assistant: Ovsana Tsaturian
Senior Manager, Channel & Strategy: Lizzy Jones
Social Creative Producer: Peter Ditzler, Tommy Bowe
Social Strategist: Erica Noboa, Mallory Myers
Editorial Coordinator: Kim Wilborn
Talent Coordinator: Selina Garcia
OTHER SMOSHES:
Smosh: smo.sh/Sub2Smosh
Smosh Games: smo.sh/Sub2SmoshGames
El Smosh (Spanish Dub): smo.sh/Sub2ElSmosh
SmoshCast: smo.sh/Sub2SmoshCast
FOLLOW US:
TikTok: smo.sh/TikTok
Snapchat: smo.sh/OnSnapchat
Instagram: / smosh
Facebook: / smosh
my favorite shakespeare play, Rhomaeyoh and Ghiuliyette
I genuinely thought the problem was gonna be she's calling her daughter Juliette when she already has a son called Romeo
Murkoosheeyo is one of my favorite characters.
@@Sandi2105to this day I still feel bad for Rohzalyhne
The Khapphyoullattessss and the Maouwnntayghiuuuezzhs
Wileyam Sheikspeer
For the first story, there's a difference between cultural/"ethnic" names, stylistic choices in spelling, and whatever is going on with "Ghiuliyette." Arasha and Amanda are absolutely right about uncommon/cultural names. Those names have meanings and should absolutely be respected. Stylistic choices should also be respected, such as spelling variations (e.g. "Shane" vs "Shayne" or "Sarah" vs "Sara"). The difference between the examples I gave and "Ghiuliyette" vs "Juliet" is that Shayne and Sara are still very obviously Shane and Sarah. "Ghiuliyette" isn't even phenetic. It's just a pain in the ass.
Yeah, for real.
Yes exactly this should be the top comment!!!! If she named the kid Giuliana or something that would be no problem, it’s other ppl’s issue if they can’t learn how to spell a less common version of the name or if they’re ignorant enough to fuss over such a simple thing.
But the mom very obviously just wanted to be quirky and different and spell it as confusing as possible which definitely is an asshole move towards her daughter who will have no chance of anybody ever recognizing what sort of spelling she uses.
@@endeavor1664hell, "giuliette" is right there too 😭
@@sillylittlecourtjester yes sorry that’s what I meant lol that is a real variation of the same name lol thank u for adding that 😭
Phonetic
I think people forget when it comes to naming a child, you’re not just naming your child or a baby, you are naming a HUMAN BEING. A human who is gonna have to go through their life, live their own experiences, have their own personality separate for their parents. They are not just your child, they are HUMANS. And, yeah, maybe the kid’s life isn’t gonna be “ruined” by having a ridiculous spelt name, but it’s definitely an added annoyance to their life just so their parents can feel unique
i agree with you. also the teacher who gets top comment also speaking from his experience about kids with weird/unusual names will experience difficulties and might be going through bullying. he knows because he experienced it, of course he saw those kind of things several times at school. arasha and amanda discrediting the teacher's experience is a lil bit too much...
Exactly. They care about appearing unique as PARENTS. they sure as hell are not thinking about the kid
THIS ONE
Yeah their rants about the name were bullshit, that kids gonna have it rough
yeah, I completely agree with the Smosh crew here and I do think it's not the friend's business what the kid is named... but those parents do sound like awful, self-aggrandizing people, and of the reasons they could have to give THAT name to their kid, none of them are good. questioning that is entirely legitimate. in the end, they still get to name their kid. and that kid gets to change their name when they want to.
Dude. That Hamilton story. The relief I felt knowing she still has the tickets. My heart was RACING.
I had to pause and come back in 10 minutes. I was CRUSHED! so glad she was still able to go with her mom ❤
YES!!! Im like screw that because how the hell would the boyfriend see how happy she was and SEEN the text between girlfriend and moms excitement to then suddenly go call his sister and telling her "yo I got you tickets to Hamilton" LIKE EXCUSE ME!!
No fr I was about to be sick 😭
@@CozoMicroyeah that whole story gave me a visceral reaction it was so bad 😭😭
I thought he nabbed the tickets and gave BOTH of them away, I was SO STRESSED
All bullying and problems with other people aside, poor 5 year old kindergartner Ghiuliyette is gonna have to try to spell that on all of her papers for school.
😂😂😂
LOL, the best point.
That being said, she may end up getting ahead because of it.
Or like. Turns out the girl has dyslexia. Lol
It won't even fit onto the papers for the first couple of years
So I know this is a joke, but my sibling has a tough to spell name, and they just spelled it phonetically in school. They only started spelling it correctly later in life for Id and documents
"Do not tell them how to raise their children" assumes that parents always know how to best care for a child; as a teacher I've had to file enough abuse or negligence reports with CPS to know that's certainly not true.
Is it not a parents responsibility to treat their children correctly? Sure but obviously having a child doesn't magically turn them geniuses, they should work towards learning how to parent, and naming your child something non conventional is not abuse.
I believe that. As a mom, I don’t react well when people criticize my parenting; but as a victim of childhood abuse and neglect, I wish people would have stepped in more on my behalf. Many tried but it persisted all through my young life, and it’s the reason I no longer speak to my mother and keep my dad at a distance. It doesn’t take a rocket scientist to figure out if someone is making bad decisions as a parent, even if you don’t fully understand the context of their home situation. Thank you for standing up for children.
@@nuyynuyy In cases like the above, yes it is. Just like how it's abuse to make children do things like participate in youtube videos and pressuring them into scenarios they don't want to be a part of. That child will be bullied every year of school, will have employers ignore their applications, and will have their mental health suffer. All for the ego of the parents.
Children are people, not tools for a parent's amusement. Doing something intentionally or negligently that will negatively affect the life of a child is abuse.
@@Evelyn-qt3hi
Or she could just go by "Julie"
@@nuyynuyy yes it is
I feel like with the first name, there’s so many chances for her to be potentially refused license, passport, travel will be difficult, her card could get snapped when trying to go out for drinks because it looks so fake. It isn’t even spelled phonetically. It looks like a child trying to make themself look more adult by being more complicated than necessary.
They refuse making documents if the worker doenst like the spelling?
@@brendielahooha don't underestimate the laziness off bored office workers my friend.....
@@brendielahoohait’s not that they don’t “like the spelling” it’s that the spelling is so out of left field that they might be confused and think there’s some mistake. phonetically, the spelling of the name doesn’t work to make the j sound, so someone might think it’s a completely different name for a completely different person. my name is caitlin, and the first paycheck i ever received spelled it as caitlyn. i had to ask my boss to make me a new one and she had to void the previous one. it was very clear it was still meant for me, but sometimes there’s policies or it is going through a system and not a real person.
Yah imagine pronouncing that name publicly at a event like a graduation ceremony or any other occasions.
Also, in an emergency, if people can't spell your name, it can lead to a lot of problems. It's an unnecessary "Rilki-Tikki-Tembo" situation.❤
Here's the thing about the first story. Ghiuliyette isn't gonna stay as a cute little baby forever. She's going to be an adult. The parent's obviously weren't thinking about that when they choose her name, whether they wanted to be quirky or not. That girl is going to get bullied for how her name is spelt, she's always going to have to correct people on how to pronounce her name and it might just make it harder for her to get a job with a name spelt like that.
Sometimes parents need to know that the name they choose is gonna have negative consequences. I saw a reddit post just the other day about the OP's little sister naming their new born daughter Harlot so she could have the nickname Lottie. The little sister didn't want to name her child Charlotte after their grandmother, but wanted her daughter to have the same nickname as a way to honour their grandmother. And she choose that. OP told little sister that it was a bad name, apparently Op's sister even searched up the meaning and basically just said "No one's gonna know." and then got mad at OP for not warning her about the name after OP's sister announced her new born's name on social media and got backlash.
All I'm saying is name's do have consequences and parents need to name their child with them growing into an adult in mind. Ghiuliyette is not a name for an adult. That's a garbage name and OP's friend needs to realise that and change her daughter's name before it affects her child.
"Noone's gonna know"
Man, English isn't even my first language and I know. 🤦♀️
I know someone who named their daughter ABCDEFGHIJKMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ and pronounced it “Noelle” because it was the alphabet without an L 💀
just curious, what makes ghiuliyette not an adult name in your opinion?
@@bubgerkirg This is my opinion and I do understand others having a different opinion. But this name will make it so much harder in many ways: pronunciation, more likely to get bullied and less likely to get jobs when applying for them. It’s also just going to be so hard for that kid to be able to learn how to write her name and she (I’ve found this when people in my life but she may not feel that way) may end up resenting her name.
Now imagine y'all's names were spelt AUGHRAUGHSHUGH, AUMENNDUH and CHXAIYGNE 💀
the first one sounds straight like Angela's laugh btw
B-but just because it's not normal doesn't mean it's bad 🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺
@@v_dollNot to say it's bad, but it'd def be a pain in the butt for all involved
@@AIBot929I think V was being sarcastic lol
EXACTLY!!! 🤣😂
I'd never forgive my parents if they spelled my name like a 90's chopped & screwed song lmao
Y’all, Lin’s final performance in Hamilton was ALSO Leslie and Pippa’s final performance…the energy in that room was electric. I’m glad that OP and her mom got to be there; they deserve it. Screw brunch boy
Real. If I had gotten to see that I just know it would’ve been the best experience of my life. So glad OP and her mom got to go
I don’t know what any of this means but it sounds like the ideal happy ending. I’m glad for them standing their ground.
@@jac0736 Lin, Leslie, and Pippa all are the original actors that play the three major leads in the show (Alexander Hamilton, Aaron Burr, and Elizabeth "Eliza" Schuyler-Hamilton respectively). It's a pretty big deal, so it's super ideal that they didn't give up the tickets. I very much envy them lol
Bro I almost skipped the whole story because I was so pissed off. Glad I saw this but now I'll have to listen to it for the happy ending😭
Really? Wow I’m so happy for them!
I'm so glad that everyone else can see how ridiculous they were being with the first story. How could they not even understand where that person is coming from, even remotely. It's almost like it's engagement bait.
I think they missed the mark by conflating it with ethnic names, they focused on the complex spelling part but without considering that it’s a normal name, just spelled weirdly
Raising the concern is fine. Pressing it is a bit much. I do think the comments got away from the question though about the two parties involved to get into potential future hypotheticals. Honestly, it's the commenters that are that kids future bullies.
I think Amanda and Arasha were the only ones focusing on the actual question. The question wasn't if the name was bad. It was if the friend was a jerk for what she said/how she said it. Which she absolutely was, even if the name is considered ridiculous by many
I think the most underrated part of this show is being able to hear the crew absolutely lose it sometimes. It truly brings me joy to hear them having fun.
"I'd watch that show" was perfection
I absolutely need to know who that laugh at 46:10 came out of 😆😭
@@magickaldust1213 That was definitely Kiana
Poor Ghiuliyette is gonna get bullied so hard with “yo mama cant spell” jokes
I love this comment. 😂
I do feel bad because she's going to have a LOT of kids asking how to her spell her name on repeat. That's annoying and awkward.
THE WAY...bahahahahah I cracked up so hard 🤣🤣🤣
I once asked a customer for her name for a form and it was Aunesty - pronounced honesty. Naturally I just go with it because I'm just doing my job thing, but she clearly had a face and air of someone who knows their name is confusing and annoyed by it. I can't even imagine how this poor kiddo is going to feel about that ridiculous spelling.
Even then, imagine having to write that out on every homework assignment, or anything that needs you to spell out your name
Don’t forget that she was already bullied by these three loser adults saying things like “studio ghibli-ette, Gillette, etc”
I think Arasha's closing argument in the first story is completely valid and I agree with in isolation, but it has nothing to do with parents making their child's name super difficult to spell for no reason, this isn't a cultural name, it's just a weirdly spelled name for the sake of being different.
My thoughts exactly if it’s from another culture absolutely you shouldn’t change the spelling. But if it’s just to be quirky no you should not change the spelling
@@poperman3208 You can even be quirky within reason, Juliette, Giuliette, Julieta... Those are all valid, non ridiculous variations of the name.
I think not seeing that abomination of a name written down might have made it sound less ridiculous for them.
@@nina9565 they saw the name.
@@nina9565Just one thing, Julieta isn't a quirky spelling. It's how it's spelled in Spanish speaking or Portuguese speaking countries. I guess it would be a quirky spelling if someone who wasn't from any of those cultures picked that one.
EXACTLYYYYY
I had a classmate called Princess Diana Elizabeth, those are three names and her parents chose that. She changed her name as soon as she legally could
theres no way this is real, omfg... whats wrong with her parents?! its not a contest to show up with the most unique name
I know someone who named their daughter ABCDEFGHIJKMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ and pronounced it Noelle, because it was the alphabet without L, “no L” 💀
@@borahbros1664 holy shit that’s bad but I gotta hand it to them that’s really creative 😂
the hamilton story is crazy. i cant believe they thought getting a 17 year old tickets to a show is going to fix her and make her happy. she's 17. every 17 year old hates themselves and their life and pretty much everything. she has her whole entire life to see her favorite shows on broadway, OP's mom doesn't.
I don't think Arasha understands the difference between a name being "difficult" because it's a cultural name and parents choosing to make the kids 'unique.' It doesnt carry the same validity there..parents cannot do whatever they want to just because it is their child.. that not correct 😂
Exactly!!
This was my thought... I was surprised that she identified with that story in that way, and that this was one of the few stories she couldn't see both sides of at all.
yep. naming your child something stupid is 100% child abuse, and definitely not the AH for pointing it out. I think the spelling they suggest is sufficiently stupid as to be harmful, just switch to Julyette with a Y or something. I was definitely confused by their reaction to this.
Completely disagree. There a literally laws set in place to keep names from being vulgar and realistically names are names. People are named differently all the time. Reasoning doesn’t have to be there and trust me if this kid is gonna get bullied for their name they’re gonna get bullied regardless. Let parents name their kids what they want if it’s not vulgar who are we to judge?
@@Kamakazehsaying that name is stupid is exactly why kids get bullied in the first place for names. It’s genuinely childish behaviour to think that your opinion matters when a name directly connects a child to their parents. There are laws set in place to protect children from vulgar names and that is not one of them. Stop judging people’s harmless decisions based on bully’s and people who behave like shit in the world.
As someone who's been a kid and been a teacher, that poor kid has a ALOT of bullying ahead of her, "but bullies would find other things" yeah and handing them more bullets doesn't help. Kids are RUTHLESS.
I was bullied for my name. My teachers would mispronounce it all the time and my bullies would purposely say my name wrong in my ear to annoy me. If I have a kid, I'm saving them the headache of "unique" names.
100% true, literally said the same thing you did in another reply. There’s a difference between simply throwing someone into shark-infested waters and throwing someone into shark-infested waters having dumped countless buckets of chum into the water beforehand.
Yeah, that poor girl is gonna be "Ghouliette" all the way through school.
Like, what?? But bullies will find other thi gs to bully her? Like it gives of the energy as we all die someday, so lets just burn the clothes im wearing for shits and giggles. Just because it will happen doesn't mean you should or even be justified to enhance the process. Like bullying is no light matter and saying yeah its not going change anything bc pff children will bully you anyway is crazy. Like how about preventing it beforehand LIKE YOU HAVE THE POWER AND THE CHOICE, do not choose to make your childs life harder just bc you think you want to be kwuriey (quirky)... Omg
"Why are names spelled a certain way?"
Because that's how written language works?
That's the bug difference between an unconventional name with roots in a different language, and a name just intentionally going against the norms of the family's native language
You must not know linguistics or the history of language. Standard spelling is a relatively new thing with a letter based writing system. Language is also fluid and ever changing.
@@wombat4583 the letter based writing system that has existed in English (the language they're talking about and in here), for over a millennium?
Language does change over time, but that doesn't mean there aren't norms for pronunciation and spelling in a given time. I can't just write the above sentence as "Langwaj duz chanj ovor tym, bot that duesnot men ther ornot norrmms furr prununsiachown ant supelin en a givvon tym" and expect anyone to know what the hell any of those words are.
@@TheDonkeyJote Lol you clearly aren't used to old writing then. Check out spellings from 500 years ago and more. Honestly even a lot of places before centralization. Spellings can change from one piece from another. Modern spelling is inherently tied to centralization and while that has provided many benefits its not perfect and is largely inflexible to its detriment.
@@wombat4583 I actually have read a ton of old stuff. Studied history in college. And you are right in that spelling standards were inconsistently applied, but they were still there. And even among the inconsistencies, attempts were still being made for the spelling of the word to replicate its pronunciation
That's not what's happening here. They're intentionally eschewing the standards of the language just so everyone can see how unique they are.
@@wombat4583 This is true but it's completely irrelevant to the situation at hand.
The Hamilton ticket story is the perfect example of Narcissistic abuse I’ve heard in a while. These monsters prey on the kind empaths. I’m so glad she seems to have gotten out.
I’ve always hated the “Don’t tell parents how to treat their kids” mentality because it just allows parents’ shitty behavior. You shouldn’t be afraid to call parents out if their actions seem harmful. Someone should’ve told my parents how to act.
Exactly. Preventing bad parenting isnt "overstepping boundaries". Its a priviledged take from someone with good parents.
Yes, this is why child abuse is so incredibly common, because we view children as property and not people.
This. I don’t get how people act like the act of childbirth turns both parents into child development geniuses. There are maternal instincts but besides that they haven’t gained any new information just by the child coming into existence. There are SO many books on parenting for a reason. Your kid should not be a trial and error experiment
The person did.. And the thing is, it is enough
Yes, but it would be a stretch to call the parents’ actions in the first story “harmful”. It would be one thing if they were abusive to the child, but I think the child could make the decision for themselves if they want to be called something else in school and then perhaps change their name legally later on. I really think the OP of that story was overstepping their bounds. Maybe suggest to the parents once that they change the name, but to be so insistent is kinda weird
this felt like a sleepover with my cousins. it started out fairly serious and everyone is talking shit, and just devolves into uncontrollable 3am giggles. amazing.
With the first story, it's empirically proven that children with conventional American names, spelled unconventionally are bullied more, and have more mental health struggles. This is a classic case of "facts don't care about your feelings." Was it out-of- place to hound the friend about the name? Sure. However, bringing up that concern kindly and gently is being a good friend. "Hey, this wold is hard and unfair to live in. Are you sure you want to give your child such an unconventional name spelling?"
"Ghiuliyette Mahriya" belongs to r/tragedeigh
that’s exactly what i thought of lmao
that’s what i was thinking of the whole time
There's a difference between a name that's unique because it's not western or english and a common english name being spelt with purposely butchered spelling as a way to feel special. It's about context. It's a weird almost red flag to give your kid a name that's ridiculous on purpose with no care for the child's feelings. It's not the same as a traditional/foreign name.
Yeah chosing a more difficult life for your kid to feel quirky is bad parenting and literally illegal in most countries.
Yeah going have to go with AH for the smosh cast on this. I still love them just saying their examples of their names and such are not really valid and, sorry to put it this way, they are not young so they can't go by their experiences.
Yeah, they made it personal when it’s way worse than their experiences! (Except the 2nd woman’s husband’s with his name which should have been taken more seriously.)
The thing is I think the cast saw this name as a cultural/traditional/foreign name and that we should respect such names. Which I totally agree with! There are so many cultures, traditions, ethnic groups and they surely have their own customs, names, spellings.
HOWEVER, this is not the case. In the first story it's probably a white couple who wants their kid's nam to be quirky, funny, outstanding. Sorry but you're bringing trauma to this kid. And then the cast's reasoning is being that kids will always find something to bully you about? That's a tone-deaf thing to say tbh.
Sure, but it’s not about whether or not OP was correct for their opinion, it’s about whether or not they were the asshole. And OP was both probably correct and the asshole. She literally harassed the parents and went out of her way to make sure her opinion was heard multiple times even after it was made clear, the opinion was not wanted. OP could have handled this in so many better ways, and once the parents expressed their disagreement, OP needed to drop it, period.
The AUDACITY in the Hamilton story BY GOD.
We need the full uncut version of them cracking jokes and laughing about the “I paid my wife for sex” story. Watching anyone from this channel push a joke incessantly until they all break is the best thing ever
The first story was kind of weird for them to not be able to grasp. The OP is an AH for pushing it past a certain point but the parents are AH for naming their kids like that. Arasha is comparing having a culturally unique name to a very common name spelled entirely randomly.
My name is "Raul" people had problems with even just that, but it's a very common Hispanic name. Now if my parents had gone and named me "Rahuewl" that would be awful.
exactly. I have a baby that is named Gianina , we made it with one in instead of two so it would be easier to read.
Yeah, I wonder what Arasha's opinion would have been if her name was spelled Ahrawshua instead.
100% agreed. It's one thing to be different but normal within your own community (like with Arasha or Amanda's husband) and to be constantly "othered" for something you've come to identify as. Being like "yeah, it's Raul, it's Spanish" is worlds away from "yeah, it's Ghiuliyette, my parents are assholes"
You're right, I think it's an ESH too. OP had valid concerns but it's ultimately not her problem, especially not for her to keep pushing it. But the parents overreacted as well, like were they high when they came up with that name or something?? Cuz that name just looks pretentious af and over-the-top for no good reason.
I would get it, if it was a change to the phonetic spelling but that name was not phonetic
Regarding names, I want to say this: there’s a difference between naming your child with a name that’s common in your culture/language vs a name that’s already common but spelled differently bc you want to be “quirky and new”
I swear these parents forget they're not just naming babies but adults
Juliet is a beautiful name, spelling does not make your child special
When you name your child, you’re naming a baby, a child, an adult and an old person. People seem to forget that
Asian people coming in Europe who have weird names are obligated to choose a "normal" name
I agree thank you!
8:35 YES! They ARE gonna find one thing or other if they want to bully you, so let's give them more reasons to ease their efforts🥰
im dying the hamilton story may be the best reaction ive ever seen from arasha. i super super love her emotional maturity and evaluating both sides and everything but man there was something so beautiful and validating about "he's evil and needs to die" "lets bury him under the brunch place" go off guys lmfaoooo
when the intention is to “fuck up” the name just because, the parents are the asshole. they named the kids for themselves and not for the baby. plain and simple lol, that kid will for sure 100% get bullied
A bully will find something else to bully them about. I have a normal name and I was bullied by an "Ashliegh". Instead of Ashley. The kid will be fine, people are just being dramatic.
I totally agree with you there. My first thought was actually that the kid wouldn’t be bullied for having that name, but for the fact that likely won’t even be able to spell their own name when they are young. Could you imagine trying to spell that name in elementary school? I had friends that had trouble spelling their 5-letter, commonly spelled names when they were that young. The OP could’ve gone about explaining things in a better way than just telling them they’re wrong, but the parents are just trying to make themselves feel special. I think both sides are kind of in the wrong, though I don’t think the OP would be if they had just voiced their thoughts in a better way. I’d like to know what the parents names are. If they truly think that is a good name for their kid and their names are spelled conventionally, they should have to legally change their names to the most ridiculous spelling that a judge can think of. At least then they might see what the kid is dealing with
exactly! it is that it's not like it's a unique name and so of course it has a unique spelling, and it's not that it's a typical name with just one or two letters being slightly different in order to be differentiated.. it's a typical name that is actually very well known but has almost twice as many letters added, some of which are not even phonetic. that is purely so that the parents feel like the name is unique even though it's not and that's absurd! And they keep bringing up other names that have difficult spellings and how it's not life ruining even though it's difficult, and while I agree that it doesn't ruin any lives it does make things unnecessarily difficult for that child simply so that those parents can have a unique spelling.
when ppl get too woke or sensitive... this shit happens ig
@@slavaukraini1487 sounds to me like you didn't have the wits to respond with a simple "at leas me parents weren't so cracked out when they named me that they mixed up i and e - did they even graduate?"
Ghiuliyette makes me glad we have rules against weird ways of spelling names in my country.
That's neat
For example in Denmark you can only name your kid a name from a pre-approved list.
Yeah strict naming laws are literal anti child abuse laws, theyre great.
So interesting! Where are you from?
@@simonji2940 LOL it’s bad, but not *CHILD ABUSE* level. It has no bad meaning, and it’s weird but can be phonetically justified.
I salute the Hamilton Tickets lady for not committing murder. Breaking up is the kindest reaction I could think of.
Honestly the friend is not an asshole for trying to reason with the friend about her child's name. She tried, she failed and the rest is on the parents. She's right the kid will definitely be bullied A LOT her whole life not to mention how frustrating writing her name down will be not only to her but majority of people around her with paper work ect.
If your boyfriend calls you a c-u-next-tuesday for standing up to him because he tried to STEAL YOUR THEATER TICKETS, that’s more than a “dump him” situation. That’s a “nuke every last trace of your relationship because this is a psycho” situation. WTF.
No that’s a, “no officer, I was not at the dump, I was in my home watching friends” kind of response
What baffles me the most is the fact he DIDNT do the simplest part and ASK her. Instead, he went out of his way to promise someone something he doesnt have, then hide it up until the very end when he has the Audacity to tell his family in front of her. LOL wtf. He could have at any point asked her !!! How do you expect your gf to take away her present from her OWN mother and give away thousands of dollars for your sis unknowingly WHILE he’s the one filthy rich. & then the family backing him up like yep!!! Hes in the right! He stole your present from your family but its ok bc its now benefitting us!!!
@@jl7662 Because he knew exactly what he was doing. He knows that his girlfriend loves her mom, and that she wouldn't give those tickets up if he asked directly
So he decided to spring this on her as she was meeting his parents for the first time, so she wouldn't be able to say no (or atleast that's what he expected)
That's the misconception we have about rich assholes, they aren't oblivious to the wants and needs of people below their station. They're just entitled enough to think their convenience takes precedence
I'm really hoping she erased herself from the narrative, letting future redditors wonder how he reacted when she broke his heart.
Honestly, as a man, if your bf calls you that at all, no matter the circumstances, dump him. 100% no doubt.
First story: The expression on Arasha and Amanda’s face as Shane initially spelled out the name is exactly the reaction that poor girl has to endure for the rest of her life! 1:27
A close friend of 17 yrs should be able to voice their opinion in the best interest of a friend, regardless of how the friend takes it. Not the asshole.
yeah people keep saying "well she is the asshole because she expressed it poorly" but I just have to protest that those people are definitely more the asshole for giving their kid a potential disadvantage purely so that they can feel unique about giving her a traditional name. it's absurdly selfish, and no it's not at all the same as having a cultural name that is spelled differently in that culture or having a unique name that is spelled phonetically, or any combo of those two things.
no for real, it should be very telling that Amanda’s initial reaction was to LAUGH!! that child will be laughed at for years when people see the spelling of the name compared to how it’s pronounced. it’s very different to cultural names like amanda’s husbands or arasha which uses actual teaching of the english language both written and phonetically and would be easy for a child to read and pronounce properly. like the “GHI” sound at the start does not make a “J” sound when reading it normally.
It’s also very clear those parents are doing it just to be different, because the name juliette is very common but going out of your way to spell it that way was for the parents to be “fun” and “different”, they’re not thinking about the potential impact this could have on their child’s life. Not to mention if you’re BEST friends with someone for 17 YEARS you should be able to tell them when they’re doing something that they disagree with without being cut off completely.
Literally, I would hope my friends make fun of me if I gave my kid a dumb name. I'd do the same.
And then they have the audacity to try and defend the name. Like. Please be less aware of your own reactions 🙄.
It doesn't matter if the opinion is asked for. People need to stop thinking it does. Other people are always going to have opinions based on things like your name. Arasha, sorry girl, but the fact I can spell your name without trying proves you wrong.
@@dahor6655 Yeah so true. I love the Smosh cast, but sometimes they have the most horrid opinions.
Really wish he read the other comment on the 1st story about how it can really affect how kids with weird spelling of common/simple names end up having problems with spelling in general because of it and often take longer learning to write/spell because they’re uncertain how to spell something right.
I think the "it's their child, they can do whatever they want" card is invalid when the behavior in question is borderline abusive.
Why are they mixing unique and/or cultural names with names purposely spelt differently for the sake of being different? There’s no need to make it purposely different. That kid is going to go through their whole life facing ‘oh you’re Juliet? But your named this? ‘ and then have to laugh it off each and every time. It’s annoying
Because they needed that strawman fallacy to justify their side. The fact that they all laughed or pulled faces at the name originally shows that they're full of shit.
Agreed. Don't think I've ever disagreed with their take on a story so hard
exactly, like it might be just a short moment for someone new theyre meeting but to them its constantly happening.
I do think OP is an asshole for how she went about it, but the parents are even bigger assholes for giving their kid that name.
@@jakebarrett7013op could have better gone about it though. Take them aside and say, "hey, you sure about that?" in a kind and gentle way. It's the doubling down and aggressiveness of op. I agree with op, but I don't think they went about it right.
Im glad the comments section is against them on the first story.
Naming your child something unique is fine. Butchering a basic common name just to have a unique SPELLING, that doesn't even make any sense phonetically, isn't
Im not even against name your kid Apple or something
Like every name is made up
But that's nothing like name them ×¥₩÷× to be unique
Exactly, my first thought upon seeing the name “Ghiuliyette” without knowing it’s supposed to be Juliet would be to pronounce it like “Ghoul-ee-yet” because English phonetics have taught me that anytime a word has a “g” and “h” together it should be pronounced with the long G or “guh” sound
@@TheJunmengoyeah it's like "We named our kid Xchdgd pronounced Xavier" THEN JUST NAME YOUR FUCKING KID XAVIER
@@mysteryacount123they want to be different so bad not knowing its going to shit on the kid in the future💀
also they're going to have to write this silly ass name on every test they take lol that takes time
Re: 1st story ... Here is the thing, words that start with gh in the English language carry a hard /g/. In the middle or end the gh carries an F sound. Parents are not just trying to change the spelling, they are trying to change Phonics. Everyone is going to say Gool-iette. So yeah in 4th grade, when learning gh sounds in phonics class, kids are going to call her a ghoul or something. Few girls would like being called an evil spirit that feeds on dead people at age 8-9-10.
Can we just talk abt how Shayne just at random times looks like he got stuck by a bit of lightning 49:49
Sorry but what kind of psycho's first thought after reading cute texts between his gf and her mom being excited about a show is to GIVE THE TICKETS THEY HAVE TO THAT SHOW TO SOMEONE ELSE???? THEY AREN'T EVEN YOUR GODDAMN TICKETS!!!!
Truly! Wow!
And then for his family to take his side when they find out he attempted to steal her tickets without even broaching the topic with her, on top of their horrific way of speaking to her, is absolutely disgusting.
Yeah that is sociopathic unless we're missing a lot from the story. I don't even know what new info would justify his behaviour though
@@mettatonex7221 I mean, he had to have got it from somewhere right
As someone who's mom married into a very wealthy family when I was a teenager, I can say this is pretty common for people from wealthy families. When you've grown up in a system that is completely catered to you and your wants, of course that mentality is going to extend into every aspect of your life. In my experience, they tend to view people as property, and themselves as above the "peasantry" if you will. It's classism 101, everything is transactional and the world owes them all that it has for nothing in return. Shit, my family would get so bored from not having real problems to deal with that every week we had some new reality tv style drama happening bc they had to create it to keep themselves entertained. Oddly enough, the guy who made all that money for them, my granddad, is sick of all of it and he and I have a pretty good relationship lmao
Naming your kid in the most absurd way you could possibly spell it in order for it to be ‘unique’ instead of just picking a unique name is what makes those parents the assholes. It gives off the same energy as people who have a favourite shade of beige.
😅 lol favorite shade of beige. I mean I kinda feel like Juliet or Juliette is a fairly unique name already. I named one of my pet snakes with the 2nd spelling because I have a vampire theme and the vampire I named Juliette after is spelled that way.
I mean maybe it's a fairly popular name somewhere but I've never met anyone named Juliette 🤷🏻♀️
@@Upper_echelon_exoticsRight?! You don’t hear Juliet often, and it’s so elegant.
Yeah. Granted, I think the parents were trying to base it off of a more Italian spelling ("Giu" and "Ghiu" being a more Italian way to spell "Ju"), but throwing in a "y" near the end just completely ruins it by grafting on a very English twist in the worst spot. I say either keep it spelled the local way (assuming "Juliet" or "Juliette" if English-speaking), or fully commit to an Italian or other spelling. Where they went wrong was in trying to mash together two entirely different languages.
@DefectiveDictionary777 but if you put an h there in an italian spelling, the g wouldn't make the j sound, but the g (as in garden) sound. Ghoul-iette
Yeah. They mentioned names from other cultures being similar but those names usually have rules to how they're spelled, following the language they come from, but these made up names don't even make any sense. I think that's mainly the issue. You can be called Giuliette, that's an already existing name, but idk what that name was lol. It's not just a unique name, it's just a unique spelling for no reason.
Dont ever feel like you guys need to keep it within a time limit. I love this series and can watch it for hrs on end (depends on the people on the couch, of course)
For the first story with the name being spelled like that, in various countries in the world you'd be banned for naming your kid like that, due to causing possible future trauma.
Yeah its literally chosing to make your kids live worse just so you can feel quirky and special
It’s for names like “AAAAAA” and “Wet Hole” not bad spellings lol
@@DrDinoNuggies There are plenty countries ar. world that dont accept "strange" names including weird spelling of "normal" name on birth certificate, or at least you need to ask for special approval first.
Yeah during this story I was really glad that I live in germany where you can't really do those weird spellings... like you can't name your child Frankenstein. Even with weird spellings you can have trouble with the burocrates that have to agree with the name which sometimes is overbearing but it's also very difficult to completly change your name when grown up only with good reasons
It looks like someone dropped their keyboard
The parents in the first story are the a-holes. Get a pet if you want something to have a "quirky" name. Don't do that to your child, who has to spell that shit out everytime they tell someone their name. It won’t ruin her life, but it's going to be insanely annoying. So why even do it?
Probably because they are jealous of people who have cultural names
Right its going to be very annoying to deal with i kinda relate too, my name is Kenna and i often get called makenna so having to constantly tell people my real name is annoying so no its not going ruin her life its just going to get old fast
These people think of babies as little accessoreighs and not actual human beings that have to live with the choices the parents make for them. There is no benefit to the child to having such a name, but there are numerous downsides to having a name like this. Why do that to your child? The only one that benefits from a child having a name like that is the parent who gets to take credit for being so "creative". Its a parent choosing themselves on day one of the child's life. Its such a selfish move.
Right? Amanda and Arasha are completely out to lunch on the first story.
@@snacker66 yeah, it was kind of infuriating how compassionate Arasha got about being so wrong. It’s clearly not a cultural issue. It’s clearly an issue of two asshole parents wanting their kid to be “different” and “unique”. Of course neither of them are thinking about how the kid will be affected by this. It’s pathetic, and I don’t see how arasha and Amanda are so blind to it.
as a deadhead, yall nailed it. phish is also a "jam band" in the same vein, I believe it came after the dead's success. It is like jazz in a lot of ways, with long improv portions where the musical parameters are set by whatever song they were playing.
The Hamilton tickets story made me literally sick to my stomach.
Dude, I don't think a reddit story has made my blood boil this much in a long time. 😑😡
They really missed the whole point with the first story. This isn’t having a name that’s common in one culture but you’re living in another. This isn’t being called Arasha in the Western world. This is being called Amanda spelled U-H-M-U-H-N-D-U-H. It’s not a cultural thing whatsoever. It’s an entitled quirky parenting thing.
Edit: So in the latest video, it was stated that this video was filmed as the last one of the recording week and everyone was exhausted. Maybe don't do that anymore. Good judgment skills and exhaustion aren't besties.
This is not shitty behavior though...
It is trivial.
Ghiuliyette is still pretty phonetic for people, it's a cool spelling, and people who would be a dick to the kid about it would likely find anything else to be a dick about (AS THEY SAID).
Pushing back on "Don’t tell parents how to treat their kids" is useful for actually important things but this isn't that & to act as if we understand these parents as pieces of shit or entitled or insufferable from ONE VERY SPECIFIC STORY is completely inappropriate.
@@austinthesan-antonian3932 Then you’ve never had parents who see their kids as trophies, and not as individual people with a future that will exceed their own. It’s not about the name. It’s the entitlement. Telling parents how to parent starts with exactly seemingly small things like this. Name your pet Sniffles for all I care, but don’t do this Grimes shit to children.
Also, they’re still missing the point because they’re making it cultural. It’s not cultural.
@@levischorpioen it's all a complicated situation, arasha very specifically backed off of the whole topic that I found mature if you watch the thing (whenever I have an opinion that goes against reddit.... I just get hateful of humanity, I legitimately rather try her way for a change.), we don't reach full context just from the reddit story as told and first comment, we are inferring what you said through extra sources they do not have here..... Which is why inferences are nuanced, and complicated. And not always right.
Moreover, the format is just shayne and the two guests. It's not fair to get on arasha's, or Amanda's, or even shayne's ass if none of the three of them came to the conclusion the comment section collectively reached. And it's REALLY unfair to single one of them out when they all disagreed with the take. You do realize the people that picked out the story are also in the room, and also know the online take, yeah? It's okay. Everything will be okay.
But also fuck humanity. Lol
@@austinthesan-antonian3932 I'm Finnish. A kid in my school got teased for having the name Nico. Niko with a k is one of the most common male names in Finland, but changing one letter made him stand out. The thing is, Nico isn't that rare of a name either but he still got teased for it. I can't even imagine what the kids with these much worse spellings of ordinary names are feeling. The kids who bully others for their names are pieces of shit, nobody is denying that, but "unique" names like that will draw those bullies like moths and before you know it the kid hates their name.
There's so many baby names that get rejected here in Finland for being too "out there" and I completely agree that it should be the norm everywhere
The only motive for the parents that was mentioned in the story was that the name was unique. Idk if this meant that they wanted a way to separate their child from other Juliets for practicality or to stand out and be part of the ✨ special ✨ name-trend. Don’t like the parents if they would make their daughter’s name more complicated just to stand out.
I would like to hear the parents’ reasoning. It feels unnecessary because it’s so much longer and harder to read. At first I thought the name looked kinda ugly, but the spelling kinda grew on me, but it’s still pretty inconvenient tho.
Full disagree on Amanda, my cousin got stuck with a dumbass name despite the entire family warning about it and I feel so bad she's not old enough to get it changed yet.
Also the whole "they can just change it later if they don't like it" irked me because changing your name isn't an easy or cheap process, I've heard it's easier if you're getting married, but that definitely isn't the case for kids with stupid names like that
does that kid wanna change their name?
@kaitlynmorgan4613 she does, she's made a lot of comments about it as she's never had a teacher spell it right
@@ecoonrad4753right?? like im trans and changing my name was a financial and practical nightmare, i wouldnt wish that process on my worst enemy
@@ecoonrad4753 It’ll also be harder on them if they’re listed on other official documents under their birth name, like a will. They can prove that they are them, but it requires more time and paperwork. And that’s AFTER the time and paperwork (and money!) the change takes up!
I love the energy Amanda brings to literally everything. Like everyone in her vicinity just wants to snuggle up to her and goof around she’s absolutely infectious 😭💖
Their take on the first story is wild
Ayrechhuh and Uhmanduhr are so right.
Ghuliette Mharya is never gonna be looked at like she has a fake passport, fake ID or fake Drivers License ever anywhere in the world. Its totally quirky and oh so necessary. /s
Dude, you COMPLETELY butchered Ohmhendah's name >:(
Don't forget about sjaiyne
not even a little bit the point of what they said but okay go off
@@SnoipaH999i think its spelled skejin
@@sevansnake369 did you also miss the point of the comment? lol regardless of what they say about whats normal or isnt or should you even give an opinion on the name etc... the fact is that the name is still spelled stupidly and it most likely will cause issues in the life of that person in one way or another. a weird spelling doesnt make a name unique if its pronounced the usual way. if you name your kid eahmeellie and say its pronounced emily... is it really unique or just stupid? lets be real
I’m so glad I’m not only one who thinks their take on the first story is wild. Like they can’t even see the other side of it.
Tbh a lot of their takes on these Reddit stories make no sense to me. Love them, but sometimes they seem like they just go along with whatever the first person says and follow it to an extreme without considering the alternative perspective.
I think this is the first time I have ever STRONGLY disagreed with Smosh’s opinion on a Reddit story
@@endeavor1664Exactly how I feel. I think Shayne thought the name was ridiculous, but didn’t wanna disagree with Arasha or Amanda.
@@ryder389the only time I disagreed with them to the point I was actually kind of upset about it was when they all agreed that reclining your airplane seat was perfectly acceptable. I may be in the minority on this completely, but I seriously view people that do that as the scum of the earth (I’m exaggerating but only kinda). One of the few nice things I can say about Spirit Airlines is that none of their seats recline, which is how it SHOULD BE on every plane.
They all make valid points, especially Amanda’s point that it’s not someone’s place to give unwanted parenting advice, but at the same time, that’s exactly what I’m gonna do lol. I just have a personal disdain for parents that are so selfish that they’d purposefully make their kids life harder, even if just a tiny bit, solely so they can be quirky with the spelling of the name. Like why not just *come up* with a unique name for your kid? I totally agree with the teacher about the outlandish names being red flags for the problematic parents- it’s such a small thing on paper (and yeah, not that big a deal in the grand scheme of things), but I think it’s a huge indicator of the type of people they are.
Minus the 1st story take (which i also didnt agree with) this has to be my favorite episode. Something about the 3 of these guys together with these ridiculous stories had me cracking up. Literally. 😂😂 Love this.
Lowkey ive been OBSESSED with these reddit videos like watching them religiously over n over again shayne ur a great host i love these videos thanks guys
You're absolutely right. There's literally nothing wrong with someone naming their child something like X Æ A-12.
I’m trying to understand lol
@@kandacenoireMusk named one of his child like that
It's none of your business what people name THEIR kids.
@@sidlarewiczBut the problem is that the names that the parents created so the parents could be seen as quirky and unique WILL become a problem for the child
@@sidlarewiczit will be people’s business when that poor girl is gonna apply to places/things and official paperwork and people are gonna struggle with it. Almost no one spells my name right and it is irritating at times because I shouldn’t have to be on the verge of showing my ID so that they can see the spelling. Not to mention that my name got butchered horribly sometimes when I had substitute teachers when I was in school. As someone who has dealt with this struggles, this is something that the child will very likely appreciate someone imputing a very valid opinion.
the main thing that theyre missing with the first story is that yes, there are unique spellings for unique names all the time especially for other cultures, this isnt one of those cases. its clearly another old white lady wanting to feel special by naming her child something like Cymbeerleigh
edit: thank you all for the support! im glad i wasnt the only one who felt this way about that story!
Yeah my brain melted when they took the spelling very lightly
I don't think it's unique to white people, just look at filipino names, sometimes we get really weird.
I met siblings named Queleigh and Quevin, pronounced Kay-leigh and Kevin. At least the spelling isn’t as ugly as whatever Ghouliette or however it was spelled.
Tbf, most of gen A have weird names, so amoung their peers of their own age it will be considered normal. We are still stuck in our old way of thinking about it.
Yeah, the parents of that kid are definitely bigger assholes there in my opinion
I’m so glad everyone else has already made every single top comment exactly what I was thinking about the name one 😂 the way they were talking about it I was worried I’d be the only one commenting about that teacher being right lol
46:07 I love how this absolutely killed the director in the background 😂
Yah, SMOSH got it wrong on the name situation. A cultural name is completely different than just screwing up a basic name to feel “special”. It’s been proven that potential employers will bypass a name spelled ridiculously for a job. If you want to be unique, choose a name based on your ethnicity/heritage.
yea this is my first time disagreeing with them 😭
Yeahhh this is a bad take from Smosh
They even made fun of it in the beginning and then flipflopped over to "well there's nothing wrong with unique, let them fuck up their child's life"
Yeah, there's a lot of leeway for creativity with names, but there's still a limit. _Giulet_ or _Giuletta_ would be fine, because they're not THAT different and are evoking the Italian spelling of the name. Likewise for something like _Juliyette_ . A bit cringy but still easy enough to read. _Ghiuliyette_ is about 2-3 steps too far, and is just making your child's life unnecessarily difficult. It's not going to outright RUIN their life (probably/hopefully) but even in the best case scenario it's going to be adding in little pitfalls to their daily existence for no good reason. You'll be forcing almost every new interaction where they introduce themselves to be about three times more complicated and awkward then it needs to be. What these parents chose was the equivalent of Shayne's name being spelt like _Xyainn_ or something.
They were making light of it and joking naturally about the name in the beginning but eventually switched on their LA woke "must accept everything or else were dicks" mentality honestly
For the first story- Sometimes new parents forget that they are naming a person that will one day be a full fledge adult. Get a pet if you wanna give something a unique name.
And the parents are in their early 20's, probably feeling the novelty of naming a child and wanted to make it unique and quirky
Exactly!!
Honestly I get where they were coming from trying to defend unique spellings especially because a lot of immigrant parents spell their kids name phonetically, but this is ridiculous and an intentional choice to make it “unique”
HARD agree also Arasha said that she had a problem with top comment's use of the word normal then went on to say normal just means recent. Okay but that is what is normal for today... you arent disagreeing with the usage of the word. You might not like something being called normal because you dont fall within it(speaking from experience) but that doesnt mean that it isnt the NORM which is where normal comes from
@@BlackDragon-uq1wyexactly! It was not stated if the parents were from a different ethnic background so I assume they're just white. Not that white people can't name their child "uniquely", that never stopped all the Keyleighs from existing. But come one they knew what they were doing to their child.
Love the fact that right before Aryasha gave her take on garlic, an ad for Sonics garlic butter bacon burger came on 💀😂
The Juliet one, my moms a teacher and I can tell you that little girl is gonna struggle with her own name so much when learning how to read and write, that's not cultural or anything it's just a pain😭
Shayne comparing an added Y to Ghiuliyette is insane. Not even in the same ballpark lol
Lol yup
Come back when you spell it Scheiyghne
@@shinigamijack4208 Sheighyne
While the spelling of “Shayne” is not as common as the “Shane” spelling, it still is an accepted spelling. Heck, even some people have “Shayne” as their surname.
I grew up with a Cheyne
The most frustating thing about the first story is that if you have unconventional or difficult to spell name, every time you deal with important document your anxiety spikes hoping people wouldn’t butcher it
also when the child starts learning to how spell and write. it's gonna be so difficult for a toddler to spell that correctly every single time
I have a very unconventional last name and this is exactly true. I constantly have to spell out my name, it took my college professor 75% of the semester to pronounce it correctly, I constantly felt embarrassed as a kid for having it.
Now, I've learnt to be very happy about my last name and uave accepted it as what makes me unique, but there's a VERY good reason people got infuriated at a family naming their child "Abcde."
40:13 best moment for me Amanda freaking out about bill Murray and Shane laughing while pointing at Amanda had me dying
Amanda at 46:35 and the next 10 or so seconds almost made me sit my drink out from laughter. I was not expecting this from the two of them but it was hilarious.
That poor kid having to spell out her name for the rest of her life. So cruel man
And I’m thinking about how hard it’s gonna be for them to write their name in kindergarten.
She is 100% going to change it as soon as she is 18. Fuck “quirky/unique” parents. I changed mine from Gerammie to Jeremy, as it should be spelled. My parents kicked me out and I live with my aunt and uncle who helped me change the name.
it’s different when it’s so much harder to connect to the original with the spelling and that it is such a known name. i think they’re not the full asshole. i see what they’re saying but i don’t fully agree
She'll have the same experience every immigrant has in a foreign country. It's not that bad
Yeah everyone in the story were assholes
Ghiuliyette seems like a Monster High name. Just replace the first I with an O.
Ghouliyette. Perfect name for your zombie-yeti hybrid daughter.
i was thinking the same thing 😭
Thats what i was thinking lmao
Glad I’m not the only one lmfao that’s immediately what I thought
That's my problem with it. It's basically ghoul.
As a monster high fan, I now kinda wanna make a zombie yeti hybrid named this
The first story has an update where OP apologizes and is reinstated as godparent because the friend agrees the spelling might be crazy, but her husband still wants OP out. Wild that they didn’t include it because I’m pretty sure the update was available early on, but I could be wrong.
Thank you for this comment, I went to go read the update as a result of this.
lmao that makes the OP seem like even less of an asshole. Also as someone who had shit parents, 100% you are allowed to judge other parents
Might be the time frame in which they filmed it.
Godparents are there as a guide for the child. Yes, OP can comment on what they think is beneficial to the child.
It depends on the filming date
First story - absolutely relatable for me. For most of Vietnam, we have two “first names”, usually the first part is from a parent. Mine is Minh-Triet and the hyphenated portion ALWAYS gets confused for my middle name. When I started elementary school, my parents actually were the ones to suggest me use a nickname while at school so since then, I go by Michael
But now imagine your first name was actually spelled Meighn-treaieght
That is what the parents are doing in the first story
Naming a child in a "unique way" is a form of abuse.
Edit: Obviously, weird spellings in them and such.
Honestly I cannot fathom how Amanda and Arasha defended the parents naming their kid so ridiculously and brushing off the idea she could get bullied because of it...mere MOMENTS after they themselves make fun of the name?!
Right?! So weird
Kinda made it hard to watch the rest of the video because of how bad their take was.. I just cringed when Arasha got mad about a high school teacher that literally shares their experience with students having “uNiQUeLy spelled” names. First time that redditors seem sane, and not these 2 with the first story.
when arasha said “i haven’t been so angered by a reddit story before” i was just like. hm thats how i feel about this take.
They were mostly dicussing the etiquitte of OP hounding the parents abt the bad name tho, to the point the husband have to send an email privately to tell her to stop.
@@micahcheck she obviously had a very different viewpoint than most of us. She was noticeably pissed at the teacher using the phrase normal spelling and saw it more as different spelling from different cultures like Jean and John technically being the same name. We saw the parents were being annoying for no reason than to be “unique”
The first story and verdict is exactly what I was thinking.
Cultural names are one thing but butchering your kids name without thinking of the impact on their lives is insane.(Arasha’s and Amanda’s husband’s name are cultural.)
I’ve never disagreed with the cast more than on this story. (Although I completely agree with the fact the opinion wasn’t asked for.)
Exactly my thoughts!! Cultural/foreign names and purposefully butchering a common name as a way to be unique and special to the point it is unrecognisable from the intended name are not the same. One is a real name that has history and culture and precedent and the other looks like a game of scrabble
agreed. they keep equivocating by giving names that are spelled how they sound or names that are literal cultural names - Juliet is also a cultural name but it's not like they're spelling it the Italian or French way! it's just an absurd spelling just for the sake of being absurd which will make spelling her name for the rest of her life unnecessarily difficult... Even Amanda's like "oh people always react this way to my husband's name," right so some people don't want that! why give your kid a minor inconvenience for the rest of their life over a name that's literally typical?
All that said, fine, yes, the friend is definitely a jerk for continuing to go on and on about it, but also I do not fault her at all for trying to say something to save that kid from having that shitty spelling. it's my opinion that they are an asshole for how they went about it but they're not THE asshole in the situation.
Agree, imagine applying for a job with a name like that. It’s not just kids making fun of them in elementary school, the impact will follow them in life. Mostly cause that name in the story is just spelled ugly, should run it through the random name generator a few more times.
@@Debbiefromcomplianceyeah, i've had to come to terms with the fact that i'm going to disagree with the cast in these videos at least half of the time.
I have a cultural name of McCullough, which is irish people rarely ever pronounce it correctly or spell it right, same for my last name which is Scottish. It feels weird to compare to botching a name to make your kid special.
as someone's whose birthname is utterly RIDICULOUS, got bullied for it in elementary school and even middleschool (kids would press me for my middlename to try and use it instead of my nickname i've gone by since i could speak) yall completely missed. My name is a correct spelling too and I still suffered, I can't imagine kids who have normal names absolutely butchered for their parents entertainment going through what i did. That highschool teacher in the comments was right on the money
As someone who bonds with my mom over musicals together the Hamilton thing- breaking up is the least selfish response humanly possible
I highly disagree with the cast on the first story. There’s a HUGE difference between naming your kid a name from your country than taking a normal name and spelling it wrong on purpose. Because in that country, it’s a normal name for that country and culture. Changing the spelling is just for the parents to show off how “unique and quirky” they are, and will cause multiple issues for the child. I feel bad for that little girl because holy shit.
Or even creating a completely original name
That was not it
And also they're not and probably were never teachers or educators for that matter. From my experience, the kid who had the "Anglicanized" name spelled in a weird or awful way didn't like their name and usually had a nickname or was called by a shorter/easier name and that was it.
Exactly. Maybe they've spent too many years in LA and are used to hollywood people giving their kids awful names.
It's definitely one thing if it's from another county. Like if it's Giulia because they're Italian. But randomly choosing an awful spelling to be unique is just child abuse
the cast never argued about that tho. they even clearly said it's a different thing. what they're saying op is wrong for is that they doubled down for something that really doesn't affect them at all
@@lankyalpaca They did seem offended that the opinion, and that of the Redditors was unsolicited by the parents. I'm on the fence about that - while I agree that people should, for the most part, keep their unsolicited opinions to themselves, these parents are idiots and are intentionally opening their child to years of bullying, as well as a lifetime of of administrative/paperwork related woes, and a never-ending cycling eyerolling at their very nonsensical given name.
The thing about "trendy" names is that trends die.
That person has to either live with that spelling forever or resent their parents for needing to change it just so they can get a job and be taken seriously.
I agree that there is a line, but the cop out of "no one should ever tell a parent what to do" is why the world is full of so many traumatized adults...
Its not a really bad one but the amount of Emma's I grew up with is insane (mid 20s) and later i realized exactly why. In Friends the show one of the main characters has a baby named Emma. Its not bad but always found it very weird
@BigPekka69 That happens a lot, too. Emma is a nice name and understandable why it became popular, but I know what you mean. I think the biggest issue lately is we have people naming their kids ABCDE and X Æ A-XII trying to be "edgy" and "cool" without caring how it will impact the person forced to live with the name. There's a negative connotation with trendy name spellings like the one in the video, similar to "Karen", where it's become a complete joke. It's not the kids' fault, but they have to live with the consequences.
@@SurprisePotato91 IKR? My cousin thought she was the only one creative enough to come up with the name "Nevaeh," but when her kid started school there were two other Nevaehs in her Kindergarten class.
@ttintagel Definitely. I've met several Traeh's and Nevaeh's, it's somehow both common and unique lol. I can appreciate a lot of fun naming ideas, but there's a fine line between unique and cumbersome. Like adding silent or unnecessary letters to common names that make it hard to read, spell, or pronounce for literally no reason. Fred spelled Phreihde or Kyle spelled Pcaeile (silent P, of course). I made those up, but still. It's a trend people are already mocking, just don't do it.
I needed this video, honestly it's been a HELL of a week and I feel SO much better now! Thanks
The ending with so much laughing was really wholesome, hope to see you 3 again!!
On the first story: It appears that Arasha, Amanda, and Shayne were all very fortunate to have avoided heavy bullying growing up. They don’t seem to be aware of how hard it can be. Names are one of the earliest ways bullying can begin. The kid will have no cultural reference to explain any sort of history or meaning behind their name. Indeed, it’s the opposite. It’s a complete bastardization of a well established name.
Though, the name itself isn’t what bothers me. It’s the parent’s lack of awareness of the sorts of decisions that can impact their child socially. If they are this clueless about something as simple as a name, then this is likely only the first of many needless obstacles they are creating for their child. I agree with the teacher: it’s a red flag on the parents.
Yeah they're talking about how kids don't need a reason to bully other kids. Yeah but don't give them even more of a reason the second they're born. And then they need to carry that joke of a name with them until adulthood when they can finally change it and go no contact with these borderline abusive parents
I think some parents forget that they are naming a future adult.
Bullying will comes in all shapes and forms and having this type of name, it will just add more fuel.
I'm childfree and have no interest in kids, but these parents are selfish af. They treat their kids as a toy, not a real human being that will grow up and have feelings.
Their whole atitude was upsetting.
@@nathanellis622 I don’t think that’s the issue. Adults are better equipped to deal with this as children. They can choose to change their name, or they can choose to crusade against society’s prejudices on uniquely spelled names, as Arasha seems prepared to do. However, it’s unfair to put that burden on young children who are a long way from being able to grasp the social context and complexities that would prepare them to fight these battles. For so many things, children don’t have a choice and rely on having aware parents that can make good choices for them.
What the parents need to understand is that children are not pets. A dog doesn’t care what its name is; it’s irrelevant to dog socialization. Human children have to learn to navigate very complex human social interactions, and a name is a big part of that. Parents shouldn’t needlessly be making it harder to integrate socially, especially at such a young age.
There are so many better ways to enable your child to be a unique and memorable person than butchering the spelling of common names. Give your child access to experiences and opportunities that make them a more interesting person. I feel like there’s a lot of overlap between people that name their children this way and people that hang “Live, Laugh, Love” signs in their house.
so true this is the exact rant i went on outloud when they were reading this so true!!!!
She's a GRAPHIC DESIGNER! PROFESSIONALLY! OF COURSE she knows! The flyer, the menus, it's all fake, and she's a legend.
I checked the OP's Reddit page, and I'm 99% sure this is a shitpost, if it isn't it's definitely a ruse on OP.
@@MMorangatang yeah, story is definitely made up, that dude is a 24/7 redditor
@@MMorangatangok but its also extremely funny so we can pretend
Yup, I totally agree!! I immediately thought shes A LOT smarter than he thinks and TOTALLY knows he's lying so she's creating this "shit your pants" situation for him and laughing the entire time!!! 😂😂😂Legend, truly
I bet their daughter is upset because her family constantly promises her things to make her happy, but they never keep up their end of the bargain, that's why they wanted to get someone else to take her to Hamilton.
that rendition of "Juliet" is absolutely cursed. It cant be explained why her name is spelled that way outside of the parents wanting to be "different". That child is going to be bullied to hell and back.
The thing with the first name is that they are choosing to make their daughter’s life infinitely harder for their own satisfaction. It’s not like Arasha and Hardzei where it’s cultural or that’s the only way to spell it. From how they describe the mother in the story she’s just doing because she thinks it’s cute. Just because the mom has the right to name her baby whatever she wants doesn’t make it morally good.
The kid will be fine.
@@slavaukraini1487 people have difficulty spelling meghan and Megan. that spelling is downright evil
@@slavaukraini1487 just because someone comes out of getting bullied and moves on doesn’t mean they’re won’t be lasting emotions due to it
Its a child, a human being not a pet they are talking like its a fucking pet
exactly what i was thinking
that man child giving away her tickets, saying it's just a show and she should give it to his mother, it's crazy how entitled he is. without even asking! tf?
it’s actually crazy man
thats rich people for ya, majority of time
he is literaly tryin to steal from her
That story made me so mad. I have no words.
Notice how it’s just a show when he takes it from her but not when she refuses to give them 🙄
I think for me there is a difference between having an "unusual" name with an "unusual" spelling (my name is Rhiannon) and having a traditionally common name with a "unique" spelling and also how off the rails it is. Like replacing a letter or two cool (like adding a Y in Shayne and Sophie spelt Sofie), but rearranging the name completely to the point its not easily readable/recognisable gets a bit out of hand. There is also a difference between a different spelling due to your culture/heritage and just for the sake of it.
This was so chaotic. I loved every second.
I think another thing with the whole 'spelling a normal name in a weird way' is its an inherently selfish move. Its not for the child, its for the parent. The parent wants to show the world how cool and quirky and unique they are. IF they really cared about calling their kid Juliet they would just spell it that way so that everyone will also be able to call them by the name they have chosen. Also, its a lot easier for a kid to decide to spell their name differently, as their own choice later in life as an actual expression of their individuality, than to try and normalise a spelling. I know people who have gone from Charlotte to Charlie to Charleigh and it was all their choice, and that's how it should be.
States with stupid anti abortion laws aside, having kids is selfish. Parents do it for no other reason than because that's what they want. Parents all name their kids things that *they* want. I think the spelling is stupid, but stupid spellings are increasingly common (which is why thus obvious rage bait story exists 😂), so the idea that one kid with a weird spelling will have their life "ruined" is just bullshit.
There's always at least one blatantly out-of-touch take on these episodes.
@@EvieCorwell i dont think that the take is that crazy letting your friend know that the spelling is a bad idea but you never mess with parents she had also just given birth of course shes emotional
@@flip.2 What? Of course you "mess with parents". The fact that they're the parents doesn't give them the right to make their child's life more difficult for _no_ reason. They're choosing a "cute and unique" spelling of the name because _they_ like it, with no regard for how it'll affect the child growing up. The _only one_ thinking about the well-being of the child is OP, the parents aren't and neither are Shayne, Amanda and Arasha.
not saying i entirely disagree with you, because there are definitely people who treat their kids like this, as extensions of themselves rather than their own people. but i do think that some of these cases could be just "i thought it was such a pretty name". which is seemingly harmless, but the absurdity of certain names can affect the child's life, unfortunately
'Juliette Maria' is already such a beautiful french/latin name... there's NO need to spell it like the parents did
Mariah and Mireya are also real and pretty names so they have no excuse
Even choosing ONE of the alternative spellings would be great. Like Giuliette follows real orthography (compare to Giulia). Juliyette is a little quirky but not to the degree that you're just adding every single letter you can.
I mean the entire progress of (Juliet -) Juliette - Juliyette - Giuliyette - Ghiuliyette is A LOT
@@EmmaWargh I think that the Y and the H are a little extra
@@EmmaWarghSuggesting the Italian spelling (Giuliette) is exactly what i came here to do!
I think they kind of misrepresented the topic in their discussion as they seemed to be fighting the idea of kids having to always have their name spelt a “standardised” way despite cultural backgrounds but I think the issue is more when names are changed for the sake of being different or unique. It’s just unnecessarily confusing and seems like you are worried your child won’t be special so feel the need to try and pack in as much uniqueness as possible.
I agree with them however on cultural names where the “standardised” way is the anglicised way of spelling it like the italian spelling vs english spelling.
Amanda slipping in a Wedding Singer reference. 🙌🏼 her references to 80s-90s movies that no one else gets is my favorite.
Shayne doing the "HONK" noise for the paying your wife video will live forever in my mind 🤣
Can I just say...I really hope Jen is okay. She was 16 at the time and it's been 8 years. I hope she got away from that insane family
she would be 24/ 25 which would mean she doesnt have to remember her age just the year mfs all good imo
What makes u think shes any different probably as crazy as they are
@@tiffmitch702 hopeless optimism
@@DepressedGoose Isn't optimism defined by hope? I suppose hopeless hopefulness still tracks, paradoxical as it is.
@@Todesnuss I'm a hopeful nihilist.
For the first story: I have a very common name for women born in the 90's. Theres about 8 normal spellings, 20 uncommon spellings, and 150+ registered ways its been spelled.
Its *obnoxious*
I was in a class once in high school with 8 other Katelyns, and we ALL had a different spelling. 2 of the girls had standardized testing messed up because of it. I had a friend who it took forever to get her passport because somehow her social security card and birth certificate had her name spelled different ways! I've had my taxes missfiled!
That woman is absolutely not the asshole.
exactly exactly that name will one hundred percent be misspelled most of the time. its gonna create so many unnecessary administrative problems for her in her adult life
Oh hey, my name is Caitlyn!
Not a single person gets it right the first time. Always tries to put down a K. Than either an e or a y for the I. Or puts an I than tries to put down another I where the y is supposed to be. Than once we get to the end some people add the extra n
Oh ya and not a si gle person in my FAMILY knows how to spell my name properly
So I agree, the name thing is dumb, it's far easier to go with most common spelling for names or you have to try and correct every single person you meet
My dead name was Ashley…….I easily had many other Ashleys with various spelling in classes growing up
👋 One of 6 Madison's in my grade alone in my rural ass town. 4 in the grade above, 7 below.
I have always wanted to go by my middle name and wasn't allowed to until college. I only wish I could've done it sooner.
I have a very unique last name at least here in the states where I’m from it’s pretty common, but whenever anyone has tried to pronounce it, they have gone so far off that I’d get headaches, the more they tried
Obsessed with how this started off as a critical Socratic discussion and turned into ChRisTMaS cAmE EArLY
Sorry but one of my biggest pet peeves is people intentionally butchering the spelling of a name to be "unique". I don't agree with the approach this woman took to tell her friend but I agree she isn't the asshole. Some people don't like hearing the truth
Two things can be true at once. The first story person can be right in their judgement of how the kid is gonna suffer bc of their name but also be wrong in how insistent and rude they were in telling the parents to change the kids name
Yeah. I probably would have voted ESH on Reddit.
Yeah, the OP there had a point and wasn't intrinsically wrong for bringing it up, but they went about it the wrong way, from the wrong angle, and were too dogged about it to ever have gotten the response they were after
This! Especially with how they keep pushing. Sure, as a friend you can give your opinion unasked for sometimes out of genuine care. But you have to do it in the right way. This person clearly didn't. It's not even about if they're right or wrong, it's about how they did it.
THIS. YES.
Yeah I feel like Reddit ignored how rude OP was and Smosh ignored how stupid and annoying this choice by the parents is. Definitely ESH lol