DOCTOR WHO REVIEWS Rogue Series 14 Episodes 6
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 жов 2024
- You never give me your money: paypal.me/paylock
My Amazon UK Storefront:
www.amazon.co.u...
My Amazon US Storefront:
www.amazon.com/...
What's on my eBay: bit.ly/ebaylock
I'm an Amazon & eBay Affiliate so if you order something from one of the links, I earn a shiny micro-penny!
#doctorwho #doctorwhoreview #whoinverse #rogue
![[UA] NAVI проти G2 Esports | Blast Premier Fall Final](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QWlIm4FGESQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Doctor who is not what it used to be. Thank GOD we have the classic series to fall back on. They have lost me completly. Every week I am less enthusiastic than i was the week before for the new episode.
My thoughts exactly. True fans will always have the classic series to rewatch.
I find bringing in human relationships to Doctor Who just makes it pedestrian and dull it's always been a problem since they brought the show back. The doctor is no longer other worldly.
That’s what hamstrung the Tennant period. It was interesting to see the effect of time travel on the home life of the companions, but beyond that it lessens the character.
The Doctor making eyes at or copping off with humans makes about as much sense as us humans doing that stuff with our pets. I guess that's the arc for the next season.
There wasn't enough bumming in the bushes 😂
At least a handy for goodness sakes. Where was that? Lmao
Doctor who is now a boring soap opera on par with Eastenders and Corrie, and with that i a m now out......veryvdisappointed with RTD, who i thought would fix the mess Chibnall left, but he has made it worse.
I do miss the days of the doctor not kissing anyone amor falling on love
good job captain jack didn't kiss the doctor then...oh wait!
@@thetalonsofwaynechiang so, what's your point?
@lennymccartney1 I daresay he was harkung back to the proper Dr Who which ended in the 1980s, before it was 're-booted' with Eccleston slumming it by taking part in the detritus that Davies spewed out.
After being a fan for over fifty years, today is the day I let the Doctor go and also everything attached with it. Goodbye guys, it's been great. 😢
You're not alone! Doctor, you were fantastic but it seems like me and basically everyone I know are no longer in your demographic. It's a sad farewell.
Yeah, same. Fan of 48 years here. Time to let childish things go, I suppose.
@@DaveLynchWriter nah do what i have done get the doctor who boxsets the collections series.sod modern who
@@DaveLynchWriter Agreed. But never saw Doctor Who as childish. It is now though. And that's the rub.
How true!! feel the same!!
I used to absolutely love this show grew up watching David Tennant era was top tier 10/10 and after Matt smith it started going downhill and now it’s not even close I can’t even watch the show anymore 😢 I just miss when doctor who was good
If you didn't watch the episode, then you really shouldn't be bothering to comment.
@@TheDarrenLock I did watch the episode
@@TheDarrenLockI just watched it
I didn't watch it and I won't be commentating.
Wait a minute, you just left a comment… 😲
The horrible irony is that RTD made the Doctor into a heterosexual quasi-immortal superbeing chasing 18yo Earth girls.
That should never have happened at all.
Yes. The only reason it wasn't worse was that Eccleston and Piper pushed back so hard.
I'm starting to think that was just a stepping stone to making him Gay.
Yup this is why RTD has to go so hard in the other direction to prove his allegiance. Moffat had similar accusations with his portrayal of Amy as she was often sexualised and with the whiteness of the main cast once the show hit America. This lead to Moffat portraying London 200 years ago as not only being more diverse but suggesting to his black lesbian companion that it's white people who are keeping this a secret from modern people. It's one thing to show the world how you want to see it but to blame the differences on some kind of faux-racism is frankly sickening.
@@nealgrimes4382 Yes of course it was
In retrospect, it becomes obvious that the ultimate goal of RTD was to make the Doctor gay.
1. The Doctor is no longer asexual, but now gets romantically involved with companions.
2. Imply that the Doctor has a wife in the future.
3. The Doctor can now regenerate (transition?) into a female.
4. The Doctor was originally a black girl.
This makes it so much easier to then make the Doctor a flamboyant gay black man because the fans have been subjected to everything else that has been destroying cannon. It's basically the frog in the pot on the stove analogy and the heat has been turned up to "flaming".
A lazy rehash of the Girl in the Fireplace but it has to push the Message.
"Rogue" could have been a half decent commentary on cultural appropriation/Blackface/Slumming it/Hipsterism. But that would require the makers to shine a light on themselves. Much easier to point judgemental fingers at everybody else and accuse everybody else of living in a bubble.
At this point they ought to simply change the Police Call Box sign to read Gents and have the TARDIS rock up to Hampstead Heath at night; then the Doctor can drop all pretence of being on a time travel adventure.
Russell T Davis ruined the Doctor when he humanised him with Tennant. I prefer the Doctor being an outsider who isn’t interested in copying human behaviour. It seems that Russell T Davis hates the Doctor’s characterisation and always wanted to change it. The writing this season has been atrocious and this certainly hasn’t helped.
All people want is good stories. That's all. Doesn't matter about the orientation, colour or any other demographic. a decent writer would not need to emphasise all that. A good writer tells stories. There are no good stories here. And where the writing peaks, it goes nowhere.
I didn't watch it now, just watched the reviews, and in years to come who on earth will even want to remember this era of crap. I can take a joke, love them, but this era of Who is beyond that... RTD did say he was going to offend the old school fans, and didn't want them, just the new generations like the Z... he has managed to make everyone want to walk away...
HATED IT. It wasn't The Worst episode yet- that was "Dot & Bubble"- but I've got the same deja vu miasma I got during the torturing of the brilliant actor Peter Capaldi's turn of the Doctor. It's like RTD writes to make the worst experience for the actors & the audience. "BOOM" was the single show this season that gave the actors a chance to do a good show. I'm still a believer in Doctor Who. I don't believe in Russell T Davies.
The 15th Doctor is selfish and reckless. That might have been an interesting way to go with the character but he's also a self-righteous blubberer. All through this run, he's been careless, put Ruby in extreme peril and/or abandoned her. What a nobber. But the actor portraying this selfish brat can cry on cue so that's deep and meaningful, right? According to the marvel hacks RTD hired to pen this episode, Regency Bath is far less racist and homophobic than the present day and so much less racist and homophobic than the Funtime future. The sad truth is, men were still being hanged for homosexuality in England well into the 1850s - and that's even without the racial dimension in the mix. This episode was self-indulgent garbage. It's all fan-service references and culturewar jibes at the expense of telling a coherent story. Oh look he can sing (badly) and dance (badly) and be all #BraveandStunning so who needs anything resembling a plot? Who n eeds to appeal to an audience beyond RTD's own bubble?
Doctor Who is a fantasy adventure children's TV show. As we know, children love Strictly and Bridgerton and passive-agressive salvos in the culture war. All kiddies want from their fantasy adventure shows is twee revisionist period drama and the screechy insincerity of Queer culture. RTD knows what the children like.
Find me! That was a convincing gay voice 😂
That was my normal voice…
They’ve just lost 50% of their fans now
The Doctor: *snogs Madame de Pompadour*
"This is fine"
The Doctor: *kisses a man*
"This is not fine" 🤔
If they've lost any fans, those fans have a very backwards double standard they need to have a serious think about...
@@TheCagedCorvidmorals.
Can’t stand that episode either! 😂😂😂
They have been rapidly losing fans since Capaldi. It's over.
RTD hasn’t just shat the Doctor Who bed, he’s given a once mysterious character a catastrophic prolapse. That Kylie scene was gut-churning to behold. And if the Doctor is newly-gay, why is he suddenly so behaving like he’s been cruising down Old Compton St all his lives?
Yeah, good point. At least with Whittaker's relationship with Yaz with was explored with a tentative naïveté you'd expect from someone who is alien and not used to that sort of thing. Whereas this new Doctor is a stereotypical Earth homosexual who seems to be gagging for cock...all...the...time... (Which makes his relationship in this episode ridiculous as really they'd be shtumping in the bushes rather than trying to save the day - because cock comes first!)
Irony is, after destroying WHO the bbc still churn out classic series blurays, licensed products etc to bring in funds. How much stuff related to the last two terrible Doctors sells? Doctor Gay and Doctor Her
Who is doctor whos target audience now? No wonder they only get 2 million viewers.
When you try to shoehorn minority interests into mainstream culture, you end up with a minority audience… You can be inclusive without alienating your audience, which RTD completely mishandles.
Really good review. Same here. Doctor Who has gone off the edge. For awhile now, to be honest.
Heh, the thing you said about deliberately trying to destroy the franchise. Sad we can't figure out if that is the case or that they're actually genuine in thinking it's "good." It's a mad world.
It’s because we’ve moved from telling a good, engaging story into shoe-horning whatever personal agenda the showrunner has into the narrative. This half-arsed attempt at story telling just breaks franchises - we’ve seen that with Disney & Marvel. They won’t stop until everything is broken and unwanted by the mass market - so they are deliberately aiming to create niche programmes with very limited appeal, which is counter intuitive to what making mainstream entertainment was all about! 🙄
@@TheDarrenLock Agreed. It'd be a fascinating study, if it weren't our beloved franchises. lol
It is baffling, though I have suspicions that it's intentional, but where it all pans out eventually, dunno for sure. Definitely proving to be a non-winning strategy.
At least we have the old, good, quality stuff to hold on to.
My biggest problem was a flashback to a conversation with Ruby's mother about "Can you keep her safe?". Yeah... What episode was that from again? Was it the Xmas special*? Because flashbacks to conversations the audience never even saw the first time around is pretty shoddy writing. I'll accept anything this show does except flashbacks to stuff we didn't even see the first time around.
*=Urgh... I'm going to have to watch that Xmas special again to find out.
I bet that was an episode that Disney axed well after "Rogue" was in the can.
Russell T Davies didn't write this episode, in fact this is one of only two episodes this season NOT written by him which is quite refreshing especially since these are new writers to Doctor Who.
My mistake. Still pedestrian gibberish…
@@TheDarrenLock sez u...
Indeed, sez me…don’t see anyone else here… 🙄
@@TheDarrenLock not surprised with the bollocks that you spout!
In your opinion… 👍
Ever since Eccleston took over, with the brief respite of Matt Smith not being quite as bad, this series has been an egregious and irredeemable pile of shit. I am hoping that AI makes it possible to bring back Tom Baker instead of this ludicrous over sexualised drivel.
me too... i really miss the wobbly sets, rubber monsters and wooden acting...and don't forget the robot dog!
Tom Baker will be brought back via AI, but he will be bumming K9 in the TARDIS to give representation to those under the + banner…
@@TheDarrenLock and that's the sort of homophobic comment to be expected from this channel!
What I don't understand is why some people are only now saying "I'm out". What were you watching for the last decade? I bailed after 5 episodes of JW, not just on DW but on the BBC in general.
No, that’s not homophobic. It’s Robophobic but aimed at those who like animal shaped robots so it’s technically RoboBeastialophobia…