Gravitas: Why Plane-maker Airbus must assemble in India | Gravitas WION

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 кві 2024
  • India has placed orders for 1220 planes in less than two years.
    Of these planes, 850 are being made by Airbus.
    The European plane-makers has assembly facilities in five countries.
    What's stopping it from assembling in India- the country that has given it its record single order?
    #Gravitas deep dives.
    #airbus #india #gravitas
    About Channel:
    WION The World is One News examines global issues with in-depth analysis. We provide much more than the news of the day. Our aim is to empower people to explore their world. With our Global headquarters in New Delhi, we bring you news on the hour, by the hour. We deliver information that is not biased. We are journalists who are neutral to the core and non-partisan when it comes to world politics. People are tired of biased reportage and we stand for a globalized united world. So for us, the World is truly One.
    Please keep discussions on this channel clean and respectful and refrain from using racist or sexist slurs and personal insults.
    Subscribe to our channel at goo.gl/JfY3NI
    Check out our website: www.wionews.com
    Join our WhatsApp Channel: bit.ly/455YOQ0
    Connect with us on our social media handles:
    Facebook: / wionews
    Twitter: / wionews
    Follow us on Google News for the latest updates
    Zee News:- bit.ly/2Ac5G60
    Zee Business:- bit.ly/36vI2xa
    DNA India:- bit.ly/2ZDuLRY
    WION: bit.ly/3gnDb5J
    Zee News Apps: bit.ly/ZeeNewsApps

КОМЕНТАРІ • 130

  • @JacobTJ1
    @JacobTJ1 20 днів тому +25

    Airbus probably does not want to train another competitor from India like they did for China C919

    • @badujabar9410
      @badujabar9410 20 днів тому +3

      Buy it & copy it.
      That's the 21st century substitute for innovation. Why spend time & money if u. csn get it for free.

    • @uTube00789
      @uTube00789 20 днів тому +4

      lol. Even if they give out entire blueprint, new gen Indian engineers won't be able to build it.

    • @Jackson34466
      @Jackson34466 20 днів тому +3

      @@uTube00789why not?

    • @trijalinamdar5396
      @trijalinamdar5396 20 днів тому +3

      @@uTube00789. India is literally building IPhones now, Why not Jets?

    • @badujabar9410
      @badujabar9410 20 днів тому +1

      @@trijalinamdar5396 They can. Thousands of Indian Americans work for Boeing & Lockheed Martin.. They have access to the technology. Rather than selling it to China for a quick buck, help India compete in military & civilian aviation.

  • @Aerrow62
    @Aerrow62 19 днів тому +12

    6:08 : "India has skilled labour" ; everyone who runs a business disagrees. Our definition of skill is screw driver approach with no real engineering skills. Our engineers are unemployable because they are only good at writing tests but not capable of building anything. Don't be overconfident. If you really had the ecosystem and trained labour, the world would be begging you to let them setup a production unit instead of the other way around. We have a long way to go when a field trained construction welder knows more about metallurgy and structural stress than top university mechanical engineers. Get your educational act together before throwing pipe dreams around.

    • @bkchaitany
      @bkchaitany 16 днів тому

      Idiot, please support India and Indians. Be positive and don't be a crying baby. Everything begins from nothing

    • @nomaanparvez384
      @nomaanparvez384 16 днів тому

      because indian engineering students are not concerned about making things , they are only concerned about packages 1cr ,2cr

    • @Aerrow62
      @Aerrow62 15 днів тому

      @nomaanparvez384 Never understood how their mind goes from certificate to 2cr packages without any maker skills. Some of the best engineers I worked with were diploma holders with exceptional skills both in India and abroad.

  • @Vivekanandakg
    @Vivekanandakg 21 день тому +9

    Assembly of flight is not like assembly of Lego.. it's a complicated world and most of problem accurs at Final assembly so airbus will not take risk.. they have a wonderful final assembly line in Toulouse.

    • @yashdesai0654
      @yashdesai0654 16 днів тому

      The most realistic and rational comment.

  • @bhavikshah5016
    @bhavikshah5016 20 днів тому +2

    I had the same thought when both Airbus and Air India were placing 400+ order with the 2 manufacturers. Ideally this deal should have been driven with Govt getting involved to push for local assembly. Airbus and Boeing would have than have to fight it out to come to India and set up a shop here to get the world's biggest orders.. Its a missed opportunity

    • @yashdesai0654
      @yashdesai0654 16 днів тому +1

      Well you see most of the parts for Airbus aircrafts are manufactured in Europe. For Instance, Wings and Engines are being manufactured in UK. Direct flight from UK to France takes no more than 1-2 hours. If the same engine is to be transported to India one way flight takes 9 hours and then back to UK or France. So, it would take almost a day to transport 2 engines for 1 aircraft. So, at conclusion it would take longer time to manufacture an Aircraft. And another reason is that Airbus has technologically advanced Final Assembly Line in Toulouse, France.

  • @bhavikshah5016
    @bhavikshah5016 20 днів тому +5

    This lady has to tone down.. its ok to raise questions but you need to tone down..

  • @ashishsehgal296
    @ashishsehgal296 20 днів тому +1

    Government should implement a simple policy to end airbus and Boeing's duopoly. The manufacturer who sources the most from India gets all the orders. Automatically both will compete. We continue the policy until about 80% of the components are sourced from India. Then we go the Chinese way.

  • @Aerrow62
    @Aerrow62 19 днів тому +2

    Because you don't have a choice. They need to setup a new plant and train resources taking 5 years. They can just scale up the existing operations to supply the 1000 aircraft over a 5 year period. Also high speed trains will directly compete with airlines over next decade. They won't setup a new operations and supply chain until multi-decade commitments are made.

  • @rahulp4017
    @rahulp4017 21 день тому +8

    Totally agree.

    • @yashdesai0654
      @yashdesai0654 16 днів тому

      Well look for practicality. It would huge economical and logistical affair to develop an assembly line for manufacturing or assembling civilian aircrafts.

  • @arunkrishnan5071
    @arunkrishnan5071 19 днів тому +2

    True but its not easy to setup that massive company

  • @KGopidas
    @KGopidas 17 днів тому +1

    Air india need not feel lonelybankruptcy with grounded aircrafts or

  • @phanivinayak5371
    @phanivinayak5371 16 днів тому

    Nice introspective and needed article, which GOI should take note of, of assembly line in india, in terms of employment to Indians.

  • @oadka
    @oadka 15 днів тому

    Airbus can start by setting up MRO shop in India! CFM Leap engine MRO is need of the hour with the rising number of deliveries of neo family aircraft to India.

  • @krishnadwivedi3880
    @krishnadwivedi3880 20 днів тому +1

    India needs to give similar incentives to these manufacturers as we are giving to chip manufacturers. They need to build whole city where they can spend their riches..

  • @DarkStorm7
    @DarkStorm7 18 днів тому

    this is best time to setup an factory for airbus

  • @user-almighty_is_here_now
    @user-almighty_is_here_now 20 днів тому

    IS GOI listening ?
    This is an EXCELLENT IMPORTANT IDEA
    GOI should implement this idea
    Please

    • @yashdesai0654
      @yashdesai0654 16 днів тому

      GOI has more brain than those who wrote the script for this video.

  • @sajukumarc11
    @sajukumarc11 16 днів тому

    Awesome news

  • @sidban
    @sidban 20 днів тому +12

    This is like reading bullet points from a tele-prompter with poor understanding of business and economics. Stay with click baits instead.

  • @sudirsankr3361
    @sudirsankr3361 18 днів тому

    India should build an aviation mfg. free zone which will attract AirBus and Boeing to set up shop here .

    • @kunti_putra
      @kunti_putra 17 днів тому +1

      they won't. Until India starts building it's own home grown aircraft and shows significant progress, they simply won't.

  • @guyogalgalo-ie3le
    @guyogalgalo-ie3le 21 день тому +1

    They should send them to every Russian embassy in Europe n display their strong machines 😂

  • @manoharkardile3289
    @manoharkardile3289 19 днів тому +2

    Make in India is open for investors, while Tesla is entering,why not Airbus, Boing and Bombardier. However these Giants are
    not willing, there will be many more choices in coming years.
    🚩🚩🚩🇮🇳🚩🚩🚩

    • @yashdesai0654
      @yashdesai0654 16 днів тому

      ऐसा मत सोचो कि एयरबस भारत में अपने नागरिक विमान बनाएगा। यह चिप्स बनाने जैसा कुछ नहीं है। चिप्स आकार में बहुत छोटे होते हैं जबकि, एक विमान के आकार को देखें। विमान के हिस्सों का निर्माण यूरोप में किया जा रहा है, इसलिए उन हिस्सों को यूरोप से भारत लाने में अधिक समय लगेगा और इससे विमान के संयोजन समय में वृद्धि होगी जो दुनिया में कोई भी निर्माता नहीं चाहता है।

    • @TomJerry-qv5eh
      @TomJerry-qv5eh 15 днів тому

      🍌 🍌 😂😂😂

  • @lobzangdorjay757
    @lobzangdorjay757 20 днів тому

    Air india keeps both Airbus & Boeing happy but Indigo, as a loyal customer keeps Airbus happy 🛫🤑✔️

    • @yashdesai0654
      @yashdesai0654 16 днів тому

      One reason is that Air India is Full-Service Carrier and Indigo is a Low-Cost Carrier. So, to reduce the cost of training pilots on new type of aircraft it takes long time and expenses as well. So, by ordering same aircraft type Indigo is saving the cost.

  • @walidgheribi4047
    @walidgheribi4047 21 день тому +2

    China well done.

  • @mastvideos6298
    @mastvideos6298 20 днів тому +1

    We dont have infrastructure for airplane manufacturing !

    • @rajan5608
      @rajan5608 20 днів тому +3

      Dude Airbus is already assembling aircrafts and helicopters in India. You either have on knowledge or just a sour grape.

    • @eltonpereira875
      @eltonpereira875 19 днів тому

      Good luck​@@rajan5608

    • @yashdesai0654
      @yashdesai0654 16 днів тому

      @@rajan5608 india is proficient in manufacturing military aircrafts only. military and civilian aircrafts are two distant things.

  • @firetree2007
    @firetree2007 21 день тому +10

    assemble an foreign passenger plane? China's own make C919 passenger plane has already put into service. And now is making C 929

    • @shinchan.1998
      @shinchan.1998 21 день тому +2

      Haha bot

    • @hackerrank9173
      @hackerrank9173 21 день тому

      Yaa , that plane is a shit garbage.....only Airbus and boing makes good plane .....China make toys😂

    • @user-vk9kb2mz2c
      @user-vk9kb2mz2c 21 день тому

      yeah and we all will trust you

    • @firetree2007
      @firetree2007 21 день тому +6

      @@hackerrank9173 you cannot make anything but cow dung, haha :))

    • @hackerrank9173
      @hackerrank9173 21 день тому

      @@firetree2007 illetrate Chinese bot got frustrated with reality 😂....are you a boy or girl...I think their are no men in China ...it's hard to differentiate between genders their haha :))

  • @alex-fs5bl
    @alex-fs5bl 21 день тому

    Not if they know what is good for them...

  • @firetree2007
    @firetree2007 21 день тому +10

    airlines will refuse to buy and passengers will refuse to take air planes assembled in India

    • @deepakbhana8937
      @deepakbhana8937 21 день тому +2

      girl, India will become the largest market for aviation products for the next 25 years. It's only fitting that we manufacture our own products.

    • @firetree2007
      @firetree2007 21 день тому +7

      @@deepakbhana8937 Market and manufacture are two entirely different things. It seems you are confusing them.

    • @firetree2007
      @firetree2007 21 день тому +4

      @@deepakbhana8937 India, the total number of aircraft in the fleets of scheduled airline operators stood at 771 as on December 31, 2023.
      China, As of 2022, China had 7,351 civil aircraft,

    • @ramam1204
      @ramam1204 20 днів тому +2

      YES I agree... your mum and sistah will be there to distract the workers
      with the "yellow" river and its banks...

    • @bigtexan7562
      @bigtexan7562 20 днів тому

      Chinkapoo fart 💨

  • @cruzez1
    @cruzez1 21 день тому +1

    time to innovate India's own flight.

  • @swarnandrapradesh1
    @swarnandrapradesh1 17 днів тому +1

    Not in Gujarat at all...somewhere in South is must.

    • @yashdesai0654
      @yashdesai0654 16 днів тому

      it will not come to India at all. By the way, Vadodara the city of Gujarat already has Airbus C295 aircrafts assembling factory.

  • @Paris-coming
    @Paris-coming 15 днів тому

    You must be joking 😂

  • @firetree2007
    @firetree2007 21 день тому +1

    India, the total number of aircraft in the fleets of scheduled airline operators stood at 771 as on December 31, 2023.
    China, As of 2022, China had 7,351 civil aircraft, representing an increase of more than 550 airplanes from the previous year.

    • @sumitvashistha6865
      @sumitvashistha6865 20 днів тому

      In next 4 -5 years India will have larger Metro train network than USA.

  • @pchou061377
    @pchou061377 20 днів тому +3

    ...and if Airbus refuses, then what??? Will 6E and AI get together and design and build their own planes??? What stupid logic is this??? Customers might be king, but they still cannot bully their vendors and suppliers... who will simply walk away!!!

  • @dinoddewmila4690
    @dinoddewmila4690 19 днів тому +3

    Nice dream 😂😂😂😂

  • @firetree2007
    @firetree2007 21 день тому +4

    QatarEnergy has signed a $6 billion agreement with China State Shipbuilding Corp. to build 18 liquefied natural gas carriers as it prepares to boost its output of the super-chilled fuel.

  • @MuhammadNaeem-fs7mw
    @MuhammadNaeem-fs7mw 21 день тому

    Salaam m

  • @YouCantHandleTheTruth.
    @YouCantHandleTheTruth. 16 днів тому

    *Gravitas: Why Plane-maker Airbus must assemble in India*
    BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHA!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @sanjaypriyadarshi
    @sanjaypriyadarshi 21 день тому

    It will happen … wait for few more months

  • @badujabar9410
    @badujabar9410 21 день тому +4

    Intent to buy is not a commitment. Unless it's prepaid it's not an order.
    Build your own jets, why buy jets from your colonizers.
    Don't beg for investments, create your own jobs.

  • @Pepe46873
    @Pepe46873 21 день тому +6

    Who would want an airplane assembled in India??

    • @Booklovr1276
      @Booklovr1276 21 день тому +2

      Who would listen to Pepe taco 🌮🌮?

    • @xmkl38
      @xmkl38 20 днів тому +4

      Those who want to go to heaven quickly. 😂

    • @Qpalzm142
      @Qpalzm142 20 днів тому +1

      @@xmkl38 you mom is one of those coffin boxes

    • @xmkl38
      @xmkl38 20 днів тому

      @@Qpalzm142 TMKB

    • @priyanshu95.
      @priyanshu95. 14 днів тому

      ​@@xmkl38don't play with the bat , eat it😊

  • @jeetenboyjoo2494
    @jeetenboyjoo2494 19 днів тому

    India must created in OWN COMMERCIAL AIRPLANE like China did with the COMAC C919...
    not lived and worked as American&European domestics pets for life.... If India assembled AIRBUS.... there will no place for an INDIAN PLANE...

  • @xmkl38
    @xmkl38 20 днів тому +1

    If bridge with hundreds of components can collapse twice during construction in Endia. Wonder how safe planes with thousands of components put together by Endians will be? 😂

    • @adityamukherjee-mz9bz
      @adityamukherjee-mz9bz 20 днів тому +1

      so you don't come to India because coming to India will be the end of your life

  • @CENTRIX4
    @CENTRIX4 21 день тому +2

    Cultural Differences Around The World
    Western Aspirations --- Pension Fund
    Chinese Aspirations --- Own Their Own Home
    Indian Aspirations --- Blue Eyes
    Indian Airport -- Blue Eyed Passengers Arrive
    Indian passengers lift them onto their shoulders and carry them around the airport.
    Aryans arrive by chariot.
    Aryans arrive by plane.
    Blue eyed Aryans return to India.
    R1a1a Z93 Indian Cline Migration.
    Lithuanian and Sanskrit languages are almost identical.
    Vedas --- Lithuania is the frozen north.
    Blue eyed Gods?

    • @arcaakvira
      @arcaakvira 20 днів тому

      no blue eyed gods in indian mythology and you might not know but colored eyes are actually more common in india than you think

  • @mikeroo8736
    @mikeroo8736 17 днів тому

    Ridiculous idea and a complete non-starter

  • @AG-gv9cb
    @AG-gv9cb 15 днів тому

    If our India has best engineers, why not build jets ourselves?? why need french or american help? And whats up with oyour annoying tone? sound so angry and mad!

  • @TomJerry-qv5eh
    @TomJerry-qv5eh 15 днів тому

    After hearing her speech 😂😂

  • @bigtexan7562
    @bigtexan7562 20 днів тому +2

    No one buys chinese made CoMACS - their ad is “I believe I can fry…..”

    • @mastvideos6298
      @mastvideos6298 20 днів тому +2

      Other dont need to , China gonna replace other airplane to local .

  • @TomJerry-qv5eh
    @TomJerry-qv5eh 15 днів тому

    Suoer power country expert 😂😂

  • @IndiaVirus-OriginofC0vid
    @IndiaVirus-OriginofC0vid 20 днів тому +1

    Cheap labor 😅
    Billions of people.

  • @harishvbn6334
    @harishvbn6334 20 днів тому

    Absolutely.....Indian Govt should force airbus/Boeing to setup assembly line in India as a pre condition to deliver orders.....India should towards move towards atma-nirbharta in civilian aircrafts.

    • @yashdesai0654
      @yashdesai0654 16 днів тому

      bor that is completely illogical and utter nonsense. what if AIrbus refuses to deliver the aircrafts the indian airlines would be stranded. if government forces companies to do something they can leave the country. so come out of fairytale.

    • @harishvbn6334
      @harishvbn6334 16 днів тому

      @@yashdesai0654 airbus/Boeing cannot ignore India coz of huge orders and big Indian market.....airbus has assembly line in 5 countries incl China and us....india shld force airbus otherwise we have Boeing as OPTION.

    • @Sedna063
      @Sedna063 3 дні тому

      @@harishvbn6334what makes you think Boeing would do so?

    • @harishvbn6334
      @harishvbn6334 3 дні тому

      @@Sedna063 if Boeing does not setup assembly line in India.....Indian airlines will buy from Airbus....so simple.....Airbus is already building assembly line in Gujarat for Military planes

    • @Sedna063
      @Sedna063 3 дні тому

      @@harishvbn6334 But as the report says, Airbus is not building an assembly line for commercial jets…